Anakin has blue eyes not brown eyes* my bad!

I 100% agree that Ahsoka would be able to calm him down along with Padme they would be able to bring him back

what if the sith conquered the galaxy and the jedi created the rule of two

I agree 100% I think that Ahsoka would have been able to talk Anakin down. Honestly I think that had Ahsoka never left the order and stayed Anakins apprentice. I don't think he would have even been swain by the visions. I think Ahsoka would have seen them as a tool of the Dark side even if she didn't know who was behind them.

I don't know if in the duel if Anakin and Obi-Wan would fight separately though. They were brothers in spirit, and when combined, they were a perfect set, one defending and the other striking and overwhelming. My thought is that the 2 of them could've defended each other, overwhelmed Palpatine, and ended the empire.

I believe if Asokha went to Mustafar instead of Obi-Wan with Padme then things would have turned out differently

If Ahsoka had talked Anakin down, I very much doubt that he would be up to facing Yoda and Obi-Wan. More likely is that he flees on his own ship to face Palpatine himself, a battle which I can see him both winning and losing, depending on how he plays it. If he wins, he takes Padme and goes into hiding. If he loses, he dies and the Empire survives.

When Obi Wan went to mustafar he stood at the top of the ramp of the spaceship and only angered Anakin even more and made him choke padme out of paranoia and anger. Then Obi Wan only made things worse by blaming Anakin for everything. I think that if Ahsoka went with Padme to confront Anakin then they would have a much better chance at bringing him back from the dark side. When Anakin was talking to Padme on Mustafar he believed that she had turned against him then when he seen Obi Wan standing there it only confirmed his suspicions and this made him choke Padme out

I like the semi-realism of this one. It's not too far-fetched, and could actually have happened in canon (although with some differences I imagine). Very nice fan-fic, well done and thank you. This was a great listen!

Well done. Like many alternate realities, this speaks volumes about how if one little thing had happened differently in Anakin's favor, he'd be more likely to realize his mistakes and own up to them. 5:09 and 6:26. I never cease to be amazed at how many ways and scenarios there are to look at things. In most cases like this one, they seem to show Anakin either never becoming evil or him realizing soon after that it was a mistake. Also in most cases Anakin learns to use his light and dark side powers, which is what truly brings balance to the Force. There are so many ways things could've worked out so much better for Anakin than the canon way we all know.

I think this story makes a lot of sense... except for Anakin taking over as chancellor part. Between having no political power to do so and the guilt of his treason and murders, he would have a lot of atonement to deal with.

One small change would be that Yoda would NOT agree with trying to bring Darth Vader back to the light. Yoda never believed Sith could be turned. He tried with Dooku and failed. This would cause Ahsoka to be dispatched with the order to kill Darth Vader; a surefire death sentence for her. In reality, I believe Yoda would send Obi-Wan with her, but for the sake of the story, lets say that doesn't happen. Ahsoka would go to Mustafar, but disobey Yoda's orders, leading to the scene as you described. There's just no way possible that Yoda agrees that Anakin can be redeemed.

What if Anakin said "I'll try spinning, that's a good trick!" and became a Beyblade on Mustafar

I like these stories so much for how silly they often are. Completely forgetting all the horrors Annakin has committed, I doubt Padme would do that.

Let me know your thoughts! Next video is “What If Darth Plagueis Killed Darth Sidious?”

what if the jedi didnt know that anakin was the chosen one

What if anakin wasn’t actually the chosen one? Darth Plaguis would use the midi chlorians, as he was as powerful to do so, to convince them to produce life. But, when anakin was born, his midichorian levels were very high, as in the phantom menace, palpatine would do as he did in the films, gain his trust and twist his mind, but, darth plaguis, before he got killed by palpatine in his sleep, he was planning it before, like a few days before. He didn’t know he was going to die, but he was going to be killed as he killed his master soon. So he used the midichlorians to make 2 people, one fake, which had midichlorians levels of a high amount in his young age , in which was anakin, and then, when he aged to 15, the midichlorian levels began to drop. Darth plauguis had done it. Even though he died. And someone else, who was born at the same time as anakin. I don’t know who the actual chosen one would be , you can choose that, make your own decisions. And then, who the chosen one was 15, he or she was a Padawan who saw how powerful anakin once was, but then as he or she felt way more different. I’ll end my theory there, you can alter it and make it better. . Really accurate vid. I enjoyed it.

I love when ahsoka disengaged her lightsabers and aged a whole 3 years😂 the battle with palpatine was taxing

In Rebels, Ahsoka also met Vader, and he even gave her a chance to run. I don't doubt for a moment that he wouldn't be able to kill her, but i'm sure that he didn't want to. I'm glad she escaped in another way

What if anakin liked sand?

I do agree that Ashoka and Padme could have gotten through to Anakin. But Yoda didnt lose, technically it was a draw. And we know the force visions Anakin had were his own. In your writing of the battle, I think Anakin and Ashoka would try to teach Luke and Leia the Jedi ways and then take on on other students

What if Canon Vader sent his conscious back in time to the legends timeline and took over Legends Anakin's Body ?

What If Satine survived

This has promise…also, HAPPY NEW YEARS!!!

One difference: I think Yoda would have instructed at least Ahsoka, and possibly Kenobi to stay with Padme and the children seeing that was the only hope if they were to fail.

Thank you for making these fanfictions 🙌. I wish you a wonderful NEW YEAR and May the Force be with you ALWAYS 🥳🙏🙂!

What if Rex went to the temple with Yoda and Kenobi and saw the security recording of Anakin? What if during Anakin’s nightmares he was contacted by both Ajunta Pall and Ulic Qel-Droma with them trying to tell him it was trap?

Well done and an interesting line of thought. I feel this completely disregards the lessons learned on Mortis after meeting the Force Weilders. Ahsoka was warned if she stayed Anikin's apprentice she would fall to a dark fate, same as Anakin was warned of his fall to the dark site should he choose to not remain on Mortis to balance the Son and the Daughter, leaving him to be corrupted by his love for Padme. By the time Anakin swore himself to Palpatine he had already been twisted, poisoned against the Jedi. Ahsoka may have inserted herself but would have quickly met Anakin at his darkest and possibly been killed. Anakin became paranoid and despotic as the delved deeper into the dark side. He would have felt they both turned on him. In his rage not only did he put Padme's life, and the lives of his children, at risk he would have absolutely blamed Ahsoka. From the beginning, through all canon was said this was the path that was set for him, twisted by Palpatine and falling to the dark side.

It was a good story but I don't think Ahsoka would've made it off of Mustafar. Even George stated that the only ones who could bring Anakin back would be Padme or his children. That and Mustafar's environment along with Anakin's growing connection to the Dark Side would have left him in a state of high delirium.

Great job! Yes Obi wan just incited rage in Anakin.

I really enjoy these "what if" scenarios, especially as I'm finally getting around to watching The Clone Wars and really seeing how incredible Ahsoka Tano is.

Well done having Ahsoka talking to Anakin and getting him calm. Never liked that old bastard Palpatine glad Anakin killed him. Sad Yoda and Obi-Wan died.

The story is pretty good. Keep it up!

What if Barriss Offee didn't bomb the Jedi Temple, but instead quit and left the Jedi to go on a journey of self discovery? (and hopefully get a good therapist to help her with the trauma of being Jedi Master Luminara Unduli's Padawan. There is a reason in some what if's on other channels Luminara hold the record for the quickest in turning Anakin to the dark side with him running away from the Jedi within a week or two of dealing with her and all but throwing himself at the first Sith he can find.)

Bro I can see you passing every sw channel like sw theory and stupendous wave I can't wait to see what your next video will be

Good video!, keep the awesome content going!

Is this just me or is he on the way to surpass literally all big what if SW channels which have more or less given up on this series?

According to new canon, Anakins Potential was NOT restricted by the loss of his limbs.

Best alternative I have viewed. 💯

your videos are so creative i litterally love your channel

Some speculate that Plo Koon was a another Jedi who could've calmed him down.

“I don’t want to hurt them”- Ashoka 💀

I truly believe this would work because 1. anakin love padme And 2. Having ashoka their since he also loves her as a sister figure he would've been redeemed or atleast I hope. This is just my thoughts and opinions. I truly feel like anakin loved having his two close loved ones company in a way

Great video!

Ahsoka, the fun aunt 😂 She totally would be

Hi can you do a video on what Anakin reached his full potential

Hey man you are the best I ever seen in the world!

You are my new favorite youtuber

Something else is that ashoka knows how it feels to be betrayed by the order so she can see and know what he's going through.

Bro you really do kill Kenobi a lot 😂

Yo can't wait for another banger

This is a good story ! I think it would be a little bit more difficult for ahsoka to cause anakin to return back to the light since he was in such an absolutely blind rage, but I think it would work out nonetheless. Ps it doesn’t relate to the video but I still think that it’s a misconception that anakin burning on mustafar caused his potential to become less, I think he still has all of his full potential imo and afterall things changed after Disney took over, but that he could never access that potential because of his immense mental torment. Everyday was a nightmare in the suit as Vader. Not only was he in extreme pain, but he wouldn’t have reason to even attempt to reach his potential in power anyways because he already lost everything and everyone that he ever loved so when I look at it that way it makes sense to me. But what do you think ? I also have some ideas for videos if you’re interested

If i'm not wrong, I heard that in the ahsoka series, she will travel through another world like in rebels a world where it is her who confronts anakin, but don't know if it's true

Recently discovered your channel and am already a huge fan!!! Amazing work! How long does it take you to come up with these stories?? Disney should talk to this guy about a Star Wars What If?

I feel like it's more of a fan thing to want to think Ashoka would bring Anakin back to the light on Mustafar. At the point of Mustafar, he's stormed the Jedi temple killing all in his path, executed unarmed non combatants, even slaughtered kids unjustified (Unlike the Tuskens, where his anger at the death of his mother by the Tuskens is somewhat justified. At the point of Mustafar, everything he's done is out of "fear" that Padame will die, not that she actually died). To me it didn't matter who was sent as Vader still would have been there. I feel like Anakin would have still been upset with Ashoka because from his perspective she "abandoned him", he might see it that if he didn't give up Ashoka would convince Padame to abandon him as well thus ending the same with a duel but Anakin would have won (imo). I don't think it was Obi Wan being there that caused him to flip, I think it was Padames reaction to what he has done, it would have built up some anxiety and taken "Anakin" out of control which would have put "Vader" in control. You see it in how he's reacting to her, a brief moment of confusion that turns to anger when he looks up and sees Obi Wan. I don't think Padame would have stayed with Anakin after what he did, even if he turned back to the light. I think in the moment Anakin realized that as well, fell further into the Darkness only to look up and see Obi Wan Kenobi, the literal embodiment of the light Anakin just turned on. In the lines "You turned her against me!" and "You will not take her from me!" Anakin is refusing to acknowledge the effect his actions has had and is blaming Obi Wan for losing Padame when in truth, it was Anakins actions that "lost" her. Actions that he was manipulated into taking, a manipulation that started long before the Clone Wars. Sadly, as much as Anakin loved Ashoka, he loved Obi Wan all the same. If he turned on Obi Wan, he'd turn on anyone. By the time of O66 everything was perfect for Palpatine, from the state of the Galaxy to the personal opinions his enemies had of their own allies.

The fight i would think would turn out differently because whenever Anikan gets angry, he usually uses the force choke and try to force push them before using lightsaber combat as seen a lot in the clone wars.

I like this very much. Thank you.

He still would have murdered all the children and Jedi in the temple. There was no going back from that…

"She would've been killed too.. and the droids would now be in the hands of the Empire.."

editing is 10/10💀

In the book, Anikan was content with Padme there alone. He was already ready to go with her, it was seeing Obi Won that brought all of his darkness back. Ahsoka would act as another light in his heart.

Has anyone requested 'what if ahsoka was the sith lord' ?

Damn if only George would’ve put Ahsoka in the movies

I love lissinging to this when showering

Anikan would tell Ahsoka "We need not be adversaries. My Emporer will show you mercy if you tell me where the remaining Jedi went". Ahsoka would call Anikan a monster! Anakin would say "Not yet. I'm not."

7:30 tie fighter noises intensify

I think she'd have most likely be dead, if she went there. Anakin at this point was too addicted to playing with his Youngling Slayer 3000.

Fantastic what if!

Actually it wasn't said that someone would bring light... That someone would bring balance.

“Lava planet”

I agree that Ahsoka and Padme are the best two to speak with Anakin. I don't think Obi-Wan dies against Palpatine though. Yoda, more than likely sacrifices himself for Anakin and Obi-Wan to get an opening. Anakin would also have to answer for his crimes against the Jedi and his war crimes against the separatists. He would not be Supreme Chancellor either. That would most definitely go to either Padme or Bail Organa (more than likely Bail Organa). If they don't sentence him to death, then they definitely sentence Anakin to life in prison. Maybe if they convince the jury he was being controlled/manipulated by the Dark Lord of the Sith, they might get him at best exile but there is no way to tell. With the head of the separatists being slaughtered, their allies and supporters would more than likely martyr them but probably slink into the shadows to gather their power. Darth Maul may head them but ultimately I think they would fall. Their army is only good with numbers, and the Republic has strength the separatists no longer have. After that, Obi-Wan would rebuild the Jedi Order. Hopefully learning from the mistakes of the previous iteration and helping younglings understand their emotions instead of repressing them. I would hope Qui-Gon Jinn would help Obi-Wan understand the way of the living force and separate the Jedi from politics entirely.

What if Anakin didn't execute order 69 on Padme?

This is a really good theory I've never thought about this but I gotta say this video is really interesting

Before seeing, reflecting Ashoka did go in Rebels, might have been different. Good side thought though

I love this

More Is Needed

Well there’s one thing that heavily complicates the possibility that this could have happened which is that ahsoka would either still be on mandalore or in hyperspace.

All is well...right until the the Yuuzhan Vong arrive and conquer the galaxy.

I searched "Why was ahsokas outfit so revealing" and found this masterpeice, This is probaly the best thing ive seen all day

apparently this will be a episode in the ahsoka series (like a veiw in the world between worlds) so cant wait to see how accurate you are

Good History..... I Want More

I like how it ended.

That changes the chosen one prophecy completely making Ashoka the one that brings balance LoL good what if story thought

What if Anakins lighrsaber also changed purple? Would be pretty cool!

What if Anakin had reacted to the Tuskins , the way Sarah Conner did toward the man destined to unleash Skynet, in Terminator Two? In a very special scene in the movie Sarah saw this man and his family for whom they were:terrified humans. Perhaps a sand child could bring Anakin to his senses .

Yoda is strong enough to counter the lightsaber's energy to not get stabbed by Palpy's lightsaber strike. Overall this would drain Yoda of his strength and distract Palpy long enough for Anakin to strike him down. As for Ahsoka, that empathy is actually a force power as a telempath. Leiah actually has that power too but only noticed it in Legends later in her career as a diplomat&politician.

As much as I loved this video, I don’t like the idea of Obi-Wan Kenobi, and master Yoda being killed off those two could’ve easily rebuilt the Jedi order!

Thank You Ahsoka😄

Misa thinks, Honestly anybody elsaa would have been better thana obi

love how they tried to rez obi but didnt give a flyin fuck bout yoda lmao

What really would’ve happened: “Ashoka, I remember when you were a youngling… and I don’t like younglings”

I think that if anakin chose not to rebuild the jedi order then I think that asoka might seek to do so by finding the surviving jedi. As not all jedi fell when order 66 was initiated. Even if she chose not to there would be a number of jedi that would attempt to including VOS and Shak TI.

I doubt that Ashoka could change something. Anakin was so lost in Mustafar. He killed even children before he went there. I agree that see Obi wan was only worse but Anakin Skywalker was deeply touched that Ashoka abandoned him. At that point it was too late to change something.

Anakin, not Vader as Chancellor. LOL Would like to see that vid.

Mall, however, is still alive. How would he play a part of the Star Wars universe now?

It’s crazy that Asokha was there though out The event but in the movie version she was never ever mention mentioned at all why is that?? That’s crazy

I think you or someone should make this stop motion I think it would be great to see all the remaining Jedi storm palpatine and Ashoka calm anakin down

Wouldn't Anakin have had to face some kind of war crime for all the murders he committed. I mean he killed a hunch of younglings. That would be a pretty big deal.

I love when it’s a happy ending for Anakin

Anger < passion 🤌🏻👌🏻