This ONLY covers TDI & TDRI, I will not be expanding on this timeline as this is a separate what-if video
Пікірлер: 105
@WakelessLon4 ай бұрын
honestly, i think they’d bring heather back over eva in this tdi. that’s probably the only thing i’d change, i love these
@sirkillalot98924 ай бұрын
Agreed. Because they would be more aware about who is a drama hog here. It is just this would be a challenge for Leshawna to stomp, so there is a debate if Heather would be a minor nuisance now.
@havikrogers18013 ай бұрын
I kinda agree, but I don’t think it even matters, since Leshawna just crushes the challenge and since nobody likes Heather, she would just be eliminated again, so honestly, I would have Eva still return, because nobody likes Eva.
@bottlescc4 ай бұрын
11:53 WE DONT TALK ABOUT THIS ONE😡
@TYLERTDBIGGESTFAN3 ай бұрын
Fan of Axel????
@bottlescc3 ай бұрын
@@TYLERTDBIGGESTFAN YESS
@termitesc.aardwolf36444 ай бұрын
Damn, Staci almost made the merge.
@moonrain61844 ай бұрын
13:28 From what I heard in the ending where Gwen won she denied it but Chris is like “It’s in your contract” so it wouldn’t end because of Chris
@jessyhovington15875 ай бұрын
Since there isn't a lot of what if on the reboots, i'd like to see one next! I've got two idea for it What if Bowie didn't managed to convince his team to vote Caleb out, leading to Emma being the first boot in season 1 episode 1 Or What if Julia got eliminated instead of MK in season 1 episode 6.
@1NS1GN1USPH5 ай бұрын
Also, a great what if idea {if you want to proceed with this route} is a what if where Blainely didn't compete in WT.
@jaydent13205 ай бұрын
And what if Beth did
@rafaelban94934 ай бұрын
Noah can get back to game! She deserv
@1NS1GN1USPH4 ай бұрын
That's a great idea!@@jaydent1320
@1NS1GN1USPH4 ай бұрын
I'm glad you actually can read my mind. Both him and Beth are the possibly replacements that I can have when I make it.@@rafaelban9493
@Sirrano4 ай бұрын
Beth joins
@user-gy1rn8jd8c4 ай бұрын
Are you going to do one with Beardo and scary girl switch seasons ?
@bossome777774 ай бұрын
Scott definitely would know about Mike’s MPD As before the elimination in The Treasure Island of Dr Mclean, thats when Cameron originally told him
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
True but in this version Cameron would never talk to Scott since he wouldn't know about him having the immunity idol and think he's being voted out, so he wouldn't be worried enough to accidentally tell him
@ashp46134 ай бұрын
9:29 in the og series, Owen and Duncan wiped out, but Chris eliminated Lindsay because the rules said "last to cross the finish line loses" so here even though she was the only one to complete the challenge, she would go home due to being the last one to finish the race
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
True, but she's also the first, so it'd kinda defeat the whole purpose of a sudden death elimination is he kicked the person who won.
@carlosgamingtv71814 ай бұрын
My ideas: What if Sierra and Topher swapped seasons? What if Katie and Sadie AND Amy and Sammie swapped seasons? What if Trent didn't obsess over Gwen in Action? What if Duncan didn't come back World Tour? What if Scarlett wasn't cartoonishly evil? What if Sky and Zoey swapped seasons? What if Scott and Rodney swapped seasons? What if Bridgette was the ratings freak instead of Geoff? What if Sierra didn't blow up the plane in World Tour? What if Dakota wasn't mutated? What if Ezekiel didn't become feral? What if Alejandro and Justin switched seasons?
@1NS1GN1USPH4 ай бұрын
Dude, your gen swap might as well be an entire generation. {I.e combined gen 2 and gen 3 swap with gen 1 cast. 😭}
@carlosgamingtv71814 ай бұрын
@@1NS1GN1USPH Don't worry, i edited the comment.
@PuppySparkАй бұрын
Bro you are such an underrated TD KZfaqr this is a really good vid in my opinion you understand perfectly how all the characters would interact keep up the good work.
@1NS1GN1USPH5 ай бұрын
An amazing video right here. ALso, like I said in the community post, it would be amazing to glorify this series into A massive GENERATION SWAP, but aside from it, it's amazing.
@Razzberry_dollz5 ай бұрын
Well they’d have the contact twist happen like what happened in Gwen’s ending
@Carrie_Devin5 ай бұрын
I would like to see Eva and Jo swap seasons or Eva and Axel
@carlyskolnik2964 ай бұрын
This video was fantastic. I hope to see more season swaps!!! They are fun 🤩 plz do more
@entymash4 ай бұрын
here's an what if idea i thought of and even made my own version: what if tdroti featured the same cast as the first 3 seasons? here are the contestants i handpicked: cody, courtney, duncan, eva, gwen, heather, justin, katie, noah, owen, sadie, sierra, trent and tyler. alejandro wouldnt be able to compete due to his condintion, as for others who didnt make it, i imagined it as a race and the first 14 contestants to escape the volcano and get back on the island are back in the game. i also considered those who didnt get a change to shine in their seasons (eva, katie and sadie) along with some that needed redemption (courtney, gwen, trent). you can pick your own cast if you have something better in mind!
@termitesc.aardwolf3644Ай бұрын
Idea: What if the finalists swapped (Owen and Gwen in ROTI, Lightning and Cameron in the original TDI).
@joaquinbarboza32234 ай бұрын
8:14 Makes sense that Trent tells Gwen about the GU as Scott McFord also voices him. So any McFord character can rat out alliances. XD
@raymondthefiregod55984 ай бұрын
This was a good video. Also, I'm actually making my own Total Drama Alternate Universe series. But instead with just the players from the merge, I put all the characters from Total Drama (Ridiculous Race not include) and Disventure Camp into a wheel, and I chose 22 people to compete.
@tdtheorys5 ай бұрын
btw theres a french dub in canada with gwen winning and her refusing the million bucks, but they take it from her any way
I enjoyed the video and your other ones hope you keep it up also unsure if you do suggestions but a similar idea would be what if Amy and Sammy and Katie and Sadie swapped Seasons.
@Catathyst4 ай бұрын
Awesome video 🎉🎉🎉 signed a Zeke and Staci fan lol
@rajori1115 ай бұрын
spoiler: omg dj is the perfect replacement for owennwkxk he still keeps the chemistry while being, better!
@ilovenoahsomuch25 күн бұрын
it doesnt matter if the finalists refuse the million, in gwens ending of tdi gwen originally refused the million, but chris forced the fight for the million regardless
@rEdbrICkmArOOnAUbUrn49755 ай бұрын
I’d love to see a video about what if Izzy and Katie never swapped teams
@worstspytf28245 ай бұрын
Nice to see another upload, don't worry about it not being the random AU, I love 'what ifs' (as well as 'what id' as the tittle says at the moment ;D)
@SummerSideStories26 күн бұрын
Love this what if I think it could be fun if did the same thing but instead do the two duo charcters (Katie & Sadie + Amy & Sammy ) As I feel like it would change a lot as Amy & Sammy would be different teams which they would be happy with leaving Izzy on the bass. As for patikethw Idk what would change but, knowing you it would be super fun to see!
@ItsMoco4 ай бұрын
Scott wouldn't have had a bad go-kart in Grand Chef Auto since the only reason he had one in the actual show, was because Mike found a gold key and Scott forced him to trade it with his regular key.
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
Ah good point that is true. He still loses to Brick without the blackmail tho
@pixelrakurai4 ай бұрын
One thing to note is that in the fine print contracts Chris made, it does essentially make the winner forfeit the 100k for 1 million, but i wouldn't blame you for stopping the Island timeline there. From a writing perspective in the show, it makes sense to do so to keep the seasons going.
@mallow44604 ай бұрын
Staci is a Goddess
@slashEdance34 ай бұрын
Short what if idea: What if sierra didn’t blow up the plane in world tour?
@Woodenfan3 ай бұрын
You know, by this season's logic, Zeke's in All-Stars since he took Sam's original spot. I don't know what to make of that.
@lestatcanada4 ай бұрын
Some season swaps I thought of What if Leonard and Izzy swapped season? What if Justin and Alejandro swapped seasons What if Dave and Mike swapped season What if the revenge of the island cast and the pahkitew island cast swapped seasons? What if Duncan and Scott swapped seasons?
@Charles-xe4ow2 ай бұрын
One question... WHICH. SEASON.
@Duncannomg_hola5 ай бұрын
Great! Can you Please pass the link to the Tier List?
For world tour I feel it would go like this Eps 1 and two r no eliminations so from ep 3 Xx) Duncan (quits) 18) Harold 17) Bridgette 16) Leshawna 15) DJ 14/13) Izzy (injured)/ Lindsay Duncan returns 12) Staci 11) Noah Same order as Canon
@Charles-xe4ow2 ай бұрын
A swap I'd like to see is if Wayne and Raj and Katie and Sadie swapped seasons
@chaeltrgg56584 ай бұрын
Brick did deserve to win Revenge of the Island so this is a good ending
@LeninistLink4 ай бұрын
katie/Sadie, Amy/Sammy, Wayne/Raj swap seasons. the 7 eliminated premerge revenge cast swap with the 7 post merge pahkitew cast. some no swap dumb ideas, dragon Ella now exist as a form for her in the main canon during pahkitew island, comes from dramarama episode were her and Max are cousins to Gwen and Owen, prob just another twist villain episode like with scarlet though. What if Zeke killed Chris in allstars, realistically the season ends early but the shows universe is mean spirited enough to keep it going like that one fanfic that had the premise of if Gwen had kill killed in the psycho killer episode.
@supermontythomas21593 ай бұрын
Idea: What if Trent didnt throw challenges in Action? Idea: What if Sierra and Topher swapped seasons?
@tyler_totaldrama4 ай бұрын
10:33 nah, Lindsay would do amazing on this challenge as we can see on total drama action
@Mudkip_lieker134 ай бұрын
13:28 in an audio recording for this episode Chris comes up with some bullcrap that says that they have to accept the offer
@Razzberry_dollz5 ай бұрын
Kinda love villain Duncan
@DEKSONNNNNNN4 ай бұрын
The we dont talk about This one 💀💀💀 #justiceForLeshauna
@thesplendidredengine054 ай бұрын
what tier list do you use for these?
@jacobmeebling8224 ай бұрын
It would be cool if you did the inverse of this aka what if Beardo and Caleb (season one) swapped seasons
@ryanvlamnl38553 ай бұрын
Actually I think Noah wouldn’t be out bc Courtney wasn’t there to wake Duncan up so Duncan would be gone instead of him
@TDMrFairy4 ай бұрын
If you Want do what if: Caleb and Raj swapped sexualities
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
Hmm interesting
@virzavion4 ай бұрын
What would happen if Leshawna didn’t have…”the elimination” and if Ezekiel win the challenge for ummm (I forgot the team name) in season 1
@TotaldramaEzekiel129Ай бұрын
Action but it's all 22 1st generation characters
@bossome777774 ай бұрын
tier list plz
@mertbilge14123 күн бұрын
No feral obuisly wait................
@ThatEzekielGuy4 ай бұрын
is it weird that Ezekiel looks more like a S4 char
@dariusbrawl37594 ай бұрын
Hear me out: swap *Scott* with Ezikiel I think TDAS scott would be a better fit for gen 1. Staci could go into *any* season given how little screentime she has, but she feels more like a TDPI character than anything
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
I actually considered doing that, not sure if I’m gonna use Ezekiel but I am planning another season swap with Scott for sure
@dariusbrawl37594 ай бұрын
@@amusicalindividual1772 It really just depends on which version of scott is used - he's the only character who has an argument for improving in TDAS, mainly because rather than being derailed, he was just put onto another track entirely. If you use TDROTI scott, I'd say sugar's the best person to swap; If it's TDAS scott, then Ezikiel's the best option In both instances, the person replacing scott would debut in season 4, affecting the TDAS cast. (NOTE: i feel as though sugar would act similarly to TDROTI scott in s4; take this was you will)
@mertbilge14123 күн бұрын
What if aleJandro was GONE
@Marioandsonicplushbros3 ай бұрын
11:54 What Would Geoff Do With Mr. Coconut
@user-rr5um1nh3q4 ай бұрын
I would like to see you do season 3 since Stacy would be there instead and a lot of the relationships would be different
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
I honestly think it’d still play out relatively the same. Staci would be the first boot since she’d still be on team victory and be overconfident and annoying, and after that everything would still be more or less the same (Heather vs Alejandro, love triangle, animal curse, team victory sucking, etc.)
@taroknight84645 ай бұрын
What if SIERRA was the main villain of world tour and not Alejandro?
@PBLightning1455 ай бұрын
That doesn't make sense.
@kelmoment5 ай бұрын
@@PBLightning145 it could lol Alejandro could've just been a smaller threat
@Catathyst4 ай бұрын
Omg like she uses her knowledge of the game to take out her least favorites and to maximize her chances of winning! Probably tries to get Cody to the finals with her so even if she doesn't win Cody does
@taroknight84644 ай бұрын
@@Catathyst yup and if she’s ever in danger of getting eliminated she like uses her knowledge of the players to start rumors & drama and create targets on big threats to slip by and maybe uses her obsession with Cody as a cover until he starts rejecting her then it gets realer and she gets crazier
@OldiesJan19th4 ай бұрын
What’s the name for the teirlist
@TheRennes19974 ай бұрын
So no TDA or World Tour?
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
Sadly no not for this one, I’m gonna continue my randomized cast series
@TheRennes19974 ай бұрын
@@amusicalindividual1772 Here's a random one; for TDWT, what if that one fan obsessed with Trent, Kelsey switches with Sierra and becomes a contestant, or if that one nerdy fan that asked Leshawna a question about her relationships, Harvey switches with DJ?
@awm84144 ай бұрын
I kinda think Zeke and Dawn would interact more
@ZoPoj3 ай бұрын
Staci would be first boot anyway
@jackburgess19876 күн бұрын
Also, but I say Hey chatty, stay stay Stacy. She is not the best one chatty Stacy.I found her too➡️🤡
@that_dude_over_there4 ай бұрын
When it comes to the revenge ending, I disagree and think that Brick has the edge. They’re both equal in strength, but Brick has more wit than Lightning and actual combat experience. I think that unlike the actual finale, this finale would play more like a gladiatorial duel.
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
Brick is smarter and has better combat training/smarts but he is nowhere close to Lightning in strength. Lightning can practically fly through the air, can bend and strike through metal, and also has much more endurance then Brick does. Though you could argue Brick could find another way to fight him without the iron man suit
@that_dude_over_there4 ай бұрын
@@amusicalindividual1772 really? Maybe I need to revisit Revenge of The Island.
@GamingHero...4 ай бұрын
IMO, it doesn't make sense when you say the timeline ends if neither contestant risks the 100k for the million, since in Gwen's ending (which is equally as canon, disregarding the reboot timeline) Chris uses the contract to force them to give up the money
@amusicalindividual17724 ай бұрын
Yeah I didn't know that Gwen's ending extended past ep26 in its own version until after I made the video. Although I will say that version makes the stakes of S1 feel really hollow and is in general just COMPLETE BS, even for TD standards
@Walterskidsaccount2 ай бұрын
Why vote Mike out he been through much😭
@MadChristoph16 күн бұрын
I think Staci with Katie and Sadie work well, even since Staci was just the first boot for ROTI and was so annoying and unlikeable
@tdtheorys5 ай бұрын
first, also awesome
@afterlifeMonicaIruma-9021Ай бұрын
Don't be down on your What ifs I love them alot i just wish for a animation but hearing it is better then nothing keep up the amazing work like always AMusicallndividual here's my Spiecal Love and Happiness Hearts you deserve them alot~ 🤍>w