The multi-part stories are the absolute best What Ifs. I'm still holding out for the rest of What If Neville Was The Chosen One. Also, I'm dying laughing at the idea of some random Quidditch World Cup attendee accidentally becoming a Horcrux instead of Harry. Maybe it's Agatha Timms and Voldemort's soul knows a lot about eel farming.

- Baby Harry hiding under the invisibility cloak - Voldemort: "Wormtail, bring me the Petrol..." - Credits roll over a burning house -

Umbridge as "good" teacher I imagine is like a college professor who shows the material but refuses to explain or take questions but instead demeans anyone who doesn't instantly get it or asks questions

Personal theory: The reason Harry is able to return to life isn't because of his sacrifice. Dumbledore just needs the world to believe it so they don't know the true power of the Deathly Hallows. In truth Harry is the true owner of all three, both being that he is the rightful heir to them and they have all been passed down to his possession. He is able to return because he is actually the Master of Death.

LOL Voldy’s face on Lucius’s body is the most majestic image I’ve yet to see.

3 what if ideas 1.what if dumbledore told harry about the prophecy in philosophers stone 2. What if the troll killed hermione 3.what if Krum won the triwizard tournament (Also massive respect for uploading 2 videos in 1 minute) And I hope you continue what if Neville was the chosen one

Day 1 of asking: what if Grindelwald and Dumbledore actually went through with their plans?

I'm only 40 minutes into the video right now, but I wanted to pause it to let you know that this is awesome.

What if Snape never called Lilly a Mudblood? Would that change the plot at all?

I’ve watched all the “what-if’s” multiple times. These combined videos are great for throwing on when I’m doing house work. Thanks for all the great videos. We all want the rest of “what if Nevle was the chosen one” but I’m also curious what would change if Snape stayed and heard the whole prophecy. Would Snape have told Voldemort? Would Voldemort have done anything different? Y’all are awesome. Keep up the great work!

"The teen who lived"

Voldemort’s face on Lucius is so weird and funny

so both snape and sirius survived in this version. dang that is a really big change

theres one big issue with this, if hermione gets petrified on halloween harry wont know to not look the basilisk in the eyes when he gets down to the chamber and will likely die in the chamber of secrets in his first year. i know this is hard to swallow but shes the one that found out that the monster is a basilisk and she only does that toward the end of the year, the piece of parchment harry and ron find on hermione and moaning myrtle is how they find out about the basilisk's instant kill eyes, and this way round they wont have a relationship with myrtle AND they wont have this info, so its very unlikely harry still defeats the basilisk

Your multi parts are awesome! Yoy always make My day ! Flower pot ruled😊😊😊

Absolutely love you vids! I've been watching since... forever! I would love a theory about what if Barty Crouch Jr actually controlled himself as mad-eye moody after the maze.

LOVED this one! Happy easter brothers! 🔥🔥🔥🐇🐇🐇🐇🐇

There's a major problem. Kakarot was only durmstrang head master after leaving the country. So the events would have been different since durmstrang would have had a different headmaster

That Voldemort laughing clip gets me everytime 😂

these videos are very well-made! Love it

I am left with only one question: Isn’t it impossible to make Gryffindor’s sword a Horcrux due to it’s properties? It is said that the sword only takes in what makes it stronger. A soul of Voldemort would make it a vulnerable object or am I wrong?

Questions: 1 What would happen if the trace was triggered in a fidelius charmed house would it work? 2 What would happen if you polyjuiced into a viela are they the same species? It works when Fleur does it and she’s 1/4 Viela???

After 3 I was like, “ Voldy is da master of the elder wand! Gasp”😱

The only thing that I can’t quite see is Voldemort getting the philosopher’s stone in year 4. I thought nicolas flamel was actually planning on dying anyways and just let Dumbledore borrow the stone. Would it still be in the SCHOOL vault at Gringotts? In my mind, Flamel deposited the stone to the Hogwart’s vault. Then, Dumbledore had Hagrid pick it up. With such an important item, why would it not be on Flamel or under his own protection? He’s had it for hundreds of years right?

I love it continue the videos

Love your videos

Am I the only one that gets teary-eyed when James urges Lilly to take Harry and run.😢😢😢

could a coat be an invisibility coat if its a normal one under the fidelius charm? Because it should be invisible to anyone but the owner so anything beneath it as well. Yes it would work differently than the "normal" one but still. I wonder if this would be possible🤔

Hi SCB i have two suggestions for what ifs: What if Hermione confronted Lupin about him being a werewolf in POA, or if she even just told Ron and Harry? What if Lupin didnt forget about his wolfbane potion that night and didnt transform, Pettigrew probably wouldnt have escaped, etc Needless to say I'm a Lupin stan

Really good work!

That was an amazing What If. It had me riveted to my tablet.

i love the part where snape shouts "alive!" because its such a contradiction to most stories/theorys where they proclaim hes dead

You guys should make a Percy Jackson video

yo your doing great keep on uploading

Why does Sirius always need to die in your theories? Also: Why didnt Hagrid give baby Harry to Sirius to raise when Voldemort struck on Harrys parents? The story would have been different, but better.

“Wormtail, I’m doing the Wordle. What’s a five letter word that starts with ‘S’ and ends with ‘KE’?”

polyjuice is actually used 5 times in the deathly hallows. 1. ministry break in 2. gringotts break in 3. 7 potters 4. godrics hollow 5. bill and fleurs wedding

Amazing!!!!!

Much better Elder Wand solution here than the main story.

If Moody's eye can see through walls, and the room of requirement is being used as a "somewhere that can't be found" room, can Moody see through the wall into the room?

We gotta get this guy Ben a thesaurus. Heard “as ever” 5 times and I’m half way through

Hey there! I was wondering if I could make a suggestion. It would be amazing if you could create a video of Harry accepting Lupin's offer in the Deathly Hallows. I'm sure many fans, including myself, would love to see that iconic moment come to life. Thank you so much for considering it!

James wouldve gave it to Lily and she would've escaped with Harry. James would've been matyred but Voldemorts power would've continued to grow. Until they couldn't escape him.

Does the “rightful owner of the cloak” means it is also make it sound proof? But in the movie - when Harry used it and gasped - Snape heard him… right? If not, baby Harry would probably be crying. So V could just pull off the cloak and kill him, no?

I’ve had a theory that I’ve been sitting on for a while. If the Elder Wand’s got a thestral hair core, what if the invisibility cloak is made of thestral hair? I mean, thestrals are invisible, and so is the invisibility cloak.

I was re-reading Goblet of Fire the other day and a solid What If scenario occurred to me: What If Frank Bryce got out of the Riddle House before Nagini spotted him and reported what he heard to the police? I imagine the Ministry has ears in Scotland Yard and might hear about it also. What then?

1:02:13 I was actually thinking about the dragon just outside the vault.

I love what ifs videos 💚 Now only need there take on what is siruis was proven innocent, both during back in the trial and at the end of POA. unless it exists already?

56:40 bro is cooked heh... get it? y'know, cooked. Because of the fire... heheh...

I love this theory and I do think even in the movies they kind of hint to the cloak being more powerful for hardy. When snape hears Harry’s footsteps while questioning quirrl and reaches out I always saw the scene in my minds like the movie portrayed. Snape reaching out and hitting a void where harry holding up the cloak should have been. Since the cloak would not truely protect one from death if the magic in the cloak were not more than just makes you see through.

I love how snape character was shown

They should have put a silencing charm on the cloak

What if Moody's eye was a fourth hollow, think about it he has bested death multiple times, losing pieces of himself each time. I think it would be cool if he request an eye to see death coming so he can prepare for it. Constant vigilance.

That shirt Ben is wearing is absolute 🔥🔥🔥 and I want one!!!!!

Quick question. What happened to the stone in the snitch? I don’t think you guys ever used it.

When Voldemort created an 8 horcrux with the Sword when the goblet, ring, and the diary are destroyed. What stops him from just always having 7 horcruxs. Whenever one is destroyed, he can just create another one, right?

c. 55:00 -- I'm not sure Scrimgeour would be the new Minister. Isn't it possible that, this time around, it would be Amelia Bones, assuming Voldemort hadn't killed her? Unless, of course, she was one of the casualties in the Battle of the Prophecy in which Crouch died.

Video idea what if harry remember the 2 way mirror Ifk if it would be a popular video if it was made but I'd like to think the battle of the department of mistery still happened some way

Fun storyline, but in Prisoner of Azkaban, Lupin did see cloaked Harry on the Marauder’s map. Semi plot hole given the later significance placed on the cloak.

Love this version of Goblet of Fire. Much better villain plan than the convoluted one we got in canon lol😅

that ending was lit

i love how they pronounce accio "ah-see-oh" loll

I just realized that his voice is very close to penn Gillette.

This is going to be a twoferone I know you done the Harry Potter in Slytherin but what if Sirius Raised Harry and he is still going to Slytherin? How can that work? It's a big challenge but it's worth something.

Just heard about this from the podcast

Ooo can we get a deep dive on Moody's eye?? Pleeeease??

I came back to you this account after months and what is that beard . WHAT IS THAT BEARD

question... how does this spell work? (in one of the other videos, it's made clear that gold cannot be duplicated... the "why are the weasleys poor" video )1:01:53

But in Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 17, Lupin explains hat he can still see Harry on the Marauders Map, even under the Invisibility Cloak!

Hey man, you look like Joseph seed from far cry 5😂

What if Albums Dumbledore take Harry Potter as his apprentice early

Did Snape die? There should have been an epilogue for the aftermath great story though

CLICKED SO FAST

59:05 Harry might not have the phoenix core wand at all.

Here's an idea: What if ... A _naturally _*_POWERFUL_* Muggleborn student (either Lily Evans or Hermione Granger) was a blood descendant of Martha Steward (the squib daughter of Isolt Sayre. Who is a descendant of Salazar Slytherin and Morgan le fay) and therefore born as a parselmouth with the ability to transform into an animal (crow or snake)... somehow. The born as an Animagus bit was optional

You need to do a what if of what if they accidentally summoned Saruman into The wizarding world.

the only thing i would doubt is, that volcemort wouldt make a horkrux with an object that harry could call through a hat...if it was once in his possesion and then harry called it thorugh the hat it wouldnt make any sense fpor him to do trust the object again... also in the normal series he doesnt really care to make a gryffindor item after his "death" so i dont really see it beeing such a big deal to him to make it this time....but it was a great scene how you described it

Back to the norbert question, would norbery explode, like once Scabbers died and returned to human form would Norbert be okay?

Wow. Like. Thanks yall

How about. WHAT IF HERMIONE WAS THE CHOSEN ONE ?. Respect and keep up the epic work.

Not sure how I feel about the sword getting turned then “killed” but other than that this was better than the original 😂

It's an amazing interpretation, but sadly not much of this can happen, since Fleur chooses Roger Davis cause he is pretty, not because of anything else. Harry at that time is still 10x more famous than him so that bit of extra fame would do nothing. And it's still Fleur's sister that gets to be her target so it makes very little sense that even if she invited harry to the yule ball that he would be in the lake for her. The only way that could happen is if they had developed a full blown relationship at hogwards in the few months between her arrival and task 2!

Does anyone else wonder why the trio didn't use the cloak to kill nagini?

What if Draco was in gryfindour

36:15 Loool if you think for a second Dumbledore would have been fooled by Harry you’re delusional. Dude has xray eyes « that miss nothing ». He seems to always know what’s bothering Harry. The only reason he doesn’t figure it out in book 5 is because he’s ACTIVELY avoiding Harry.

What if Sirius stays the Potters' secret keeper?

Why can only Harry retrieve his prophecy? What happens if someone else tries to retrieve it?

hambuger are also a deadly hollow i guess

Man based on this, when you think about it you really don’t need the whole slugghorn mission since dumbledore already knows about one and he found the ring before handand he already suspects harry’s a horcruxe so why need him?

43:50 wait, isn’t the cloak impervious to spells ? Shouldn’t it protect Harry from crucio while he’s under it ? Yk as he is its true owner

What if Draco Malfoy Had Attended Durmstrang instead of Hogwarts? I believe that Draco brings up in The Goblet Of Fire that his father, Lucius, was initially intent upon his son gaining his education at a school which actively taught the Dark Arts, not to mention the fact that I got Karkaroff, a supposedly ex-Death Eater, was serving as its headmaster since sometime after his capture and Ministry trial/hearing? It was only Narcissa Malfoy's reservations about her boy/beloved son being so far away from her on the European Continent, since I think Durmstrang is in a centuries-old Norwegian castle or something like that, which prompted Lucius to send his son to the same institution him, and, at least so far as we are aware and know, all previous generations of Malfoys that came, lived, and went before them? Would Draco still meet Harry in Madame Malkin's Robes For All Occasions at all? If not, then perhaps we get another "Harry Potter Sorted Into Slytherin House" scenario? How would the complete absence of one Draco Malfoy as Harry's primary rival and enemy at Hogwarts affect the series, especially when we consider his planned role to kill Dumbledore in The Half-Blood Prince? Also, will Harry still end up on the Quidditch team in his first year, without Draco to steal the Rememberall from Neville as a direct catalyst? And how would Harry, Ron, and Hermione discover Fluffy and the trap-door without the ruse/ploy of the Midnight Duel Challenge from Malfoy? Could Malfoy end up at Hogwarts in fourth year as part of the Triwizard Tournament's Durmstrang delegation, perhaps somehow replacing Victor Krum as the Durmstrang Champion? And what about the Chamber Of Secrets if Harry is a Slytherin in such a universe, without Draco around to steal the Diary of Tom Riddle, and Ginny obviously having no access whatsoever to the Slytherin Common Room and Dormitories as a Gryffindor?

40:34 why is there a static X on the screen tho

Which is the best? What If Harry Was In Slytherin, What if Neville Was the Chosen One, or What If James Kept the Invisibility Cloak.

What if Draco was sorted into Gryffindor or at least not into Slytherin?? I feel like almost nobody ever asks this...

Id like to see a What If Regulus lived

Does this also mean that harry is a direct descendant from the third brother and he is also related to the master or used to be the master of the wand?

What if Lilly just aparated out when she got Harry from upstairs? Maybe to dumbledore or something? If James could hold him long enough for her to go to the nursery why not aparate?

Spoiler warning: I love the idea of Harry disarming Dumbledore as foreshadowing that he's the master of the Elder Wand. Not only is it neater than Harry just getting lucky, it fits with both the official and theorised mechanics of the wand. Did Harry become the master because he disarmed Dumbledore, thus defeating the current master? Did Dumbledore allow Harry to disarm him for this reason? Or did the wand choose the stronger wizard in Harry, believing itself to be betraying Dumbledore and taking a new master?

You should do: what if Harry’s parents doesn’t die

What if James and Lilly had their wands when Voldemort came for them? I propose this because it would have done no good for James to have the cloak if he didn't have it handy and ready to use when Voldemort came bursting in. If james employed his wand and the cloak, he could have ambushed Voldemort and put him out of action for years.