Nice one😂

Same with Vivaldi

Holst: you're a Star Wars fan who loves the orchestration style of The Planets because of it's influence on John Williams score (at least that's me).

Maybe you'd rather be thrown into the red eye of Jupiter than hear it again? Some players feel that way. 😂

@@jesustovar2549 Would you like to see a video about which pieces had an influence on Soundtracks like Star Wars or John Williams in general?🙌🏻

I have to say that Tchaikovsky was my favorite composer for a very long time, maybe that's the reason.😂

I could tell it was your favourite with a description like that

It's SO ACCURATE! Except you should have added that if your fav composer is Tchaikovsky you're either that or a ballet dancer or both like me😂😂😂

I feel attacked lol

@@emanuelebabici oh, but Eugene Onegin! (Soprano 😂)

With troons and joggers. And of course Them.

As one as well, I agree. Admittedly it's a quip, but I'm not arguing with it.

It hit too close to home with that one..

Totally agree! I laughed and laughed.

Tchaikovsky and Bach are the best composers of all time, Bach's music restructures your mind to be more intelligent and wise, idk who the crap these other folk are but their music don't match. Not all classical musicians are good, even if you like classical music. I've heard of and listened to most of this obviously, they put it on for a lot of babies an shit, school, movies, who knows how we find it all, but I'm not interested in most of these bloaks. Idk what you would call my interest, but both Bach and Tchaikovsky pique my interest, so there's a for sure synergy between the two, even though they are different, something is exactly the same and idk what it is lol. It's like, idk I think all the differences between all the notes in both their work is very naturally achieved, like some people are natural at something, because they learned it right. But they created music that makes YOU feel like a natural at whatever your doing while listening to it. And it lifts up your mind to the best and divine things in the universe. They both do that, even though they are not close in the measure of time, they were close in a lot of other ways. Heck, when Bach was alive they didn't even have timing in music, just slow to fast, no metronomes, it's really fun to see how people translate that because some peoples will be better if the player is better, plus you get to learn about how they translate Bach. Definitely the greatest. No doubt. They literally don't make music like that anymore.

Gustav, I thought you are dead?😂

@@Carl-FriedrichWelker Mahler is immortal ;)

@@EminAnimE1 you're damn right😂

I love your symphones and song cycles Gustav, there are like epic movie scores and I'm always imagining my own movies while lsitening to your works (which maybe explains the lenght of his symphonies).

@@Carl-FriedrichWelker Which piece is being played for the Mahler section

Thank you🙌🏻Did you know all the pieces?

You wrote Verdi as "Berdi".

What about Debussy? Anyway, thank you very much!

@@jesustovar2549 They most likely speak Korean, and Korean doesn’t have a “v” grapheme in the Hangeul alphabet.

@@chopinistarr7438 the Debussy one is a very famous symphony piece called "La Mer"

sadly, i edited the comment and lost your heart :') 💔 @Carl-FriedrichWelker edit: thx for giving the heart back

3:31 Apparently I don't exist...

4:10 🖤🤭

yep the tchaik violin concerto is brilliant. it’s the textbook definition of an ideal, or perfect violin concerto.

Violinist spotted edit: Returning to this comment thread has made me realize something funny. as a Music major, In every musicians life, we go from liking Vivaldi, to despising how easy/boring/simple Vivaldi is in high school, and then hopefully, return to appreciating baroque composers and the timeline of music history. A lot of people here seem to scoff at Vivaldi but remember that without Vivaldi, there are no Tchaik, SS, Bruch concertos, and theres certainly no Paganini.

i agree

@@jacksonhover9654 100% a violinist

Smells like a violinist in here

Saint Saens: You just found a book about music's history and want to show off your knowledge Vivaldi: You are either a beginner violinist or you are not serious about classical music and just know about 4 seasons Paganini: You watch 2 Asian violinists screaming at some weird shit online and hating on Lizst Idk I can't stereotype others

What do you mean by hip

1:what does schizo mean 2:what about classical English

@@peanut9560 Quantum balls

also proto-romantic/late classical Storm und Drang in Germany

@@peanut9560 Classical English according to this video: it's a thing only when you're desperately proud to be English.

You love invest? Bro I wouldn’t admit that 😂

​@@rxw5520it's not that bad

@KentuckyIndependence Of course you're from Kentucky lol.

@@rxw5520 Investing is a good thing.

hope you agree - Bach and Handel are the greatest!!!

Yes, apparently I don't exist...

Yes😉

And he hates Mahler because his own life is shit

@@Carl-FriedrichWelker From another Bruckner fan, I salute you! You forgot Vivaldi! 🤬I think Handel was Beethoven's favorite composer.

@@aachoocrony5754 vivaldi is my favorite.

@@BendOfMind 😁 Vivaldi...is also one of my favourites. There's no other composer who keeps you more firmly in the Western tradition, even more so than Bruckner who 'converted me into a Catholic'. There is an uncanny similarity with Vivaldi and Shostakovich. Their music speaks very naturally from the instrument. Yet should you choose to, you could go to incredible depths and dive as much as you'd like to still find more, turning out different from what others discover.

Thanks and I'm sorry😂

lol yeah I was expecting something surface like "romantic and possibly closeted gay" not a dissection of my whole being

I love Tchaikovsky because a) I'm queer and b) That Onegin Production With The Autumn Leaves.

⁠same I liked his music from the barbie movies (the old ones) but I see myself as a burden to others because the amount of time they spend on me vs what I get out of it is less rewarding then if they just used their own time, and I used mine

Guess I’m the only one who got it 😂

@@evr551Because you are a Brahms lover.

That's a cool family you got I love shostakovich 💖

that and you judge a composer by just one damned piece, without ever bothering to look around. congrats!

You are also extremely overplayed because of a film that came out which led to a sudden surge in popularity for an obscure mediocre piece.

oh the rage, the savagery, the brute violence! what have I done? uhahuauh

You also either hate cellists or are hated by cellists. Or both.

And your name is actually Philip Glass.

Same

Yup

Just that it is complete nonsense. Beethoven was at his time a harsh critic of anti-democratic societies like in Germany and Austria, which wasn't a widespread sentiment to have. If he was alive today he would've been a radical leftist.

Dvorak ftw

Don’t be misled, this is all baloney.

Thanks🙌🏻

Same. I was shocked lol

He truly feels like that considering his life.

I’m absolutely astonished here, yes the 100% accuracy. My life has revolved around his music since my earliest memories. In the Ken Russell film, the wealthy heiress is telling Anton Rubinstein she thinks Tchaikovsky is a genius and that she wants to die experiencing his music. Well l have to agree on both counts and to this day l have never ever sat on a plane without at least one device and a pair of headphones with my two favourite pieces of music to takeoff by/survive turbulence/crash with. 🌹

I can't get over how accurate it was 😅

lol my favorite is chopin and I play 2 instruments ofc one of them is piano and i totally favour it over the other one

@@theluciadd bruhhhh

@@theluciadd cool! I’m a beginner violinist. What is the other instrument that you play?

​@@cheddarcheesewoah ooo string gang i also play cello :D

Same 😅

Same. Except I'm dumb and I know it.

Ahead of his time? He was of his time; we have inspired nothing like him.

It’s something awesome

What was the first piece you listened to from Shosta?🙌🏻

@@Carl-FriedrichWelker string quartet No. 8 2nd movement

I thought Schostakowitsch would grant you the quote: "you really, really, REALLY don't like Stalin" 😂

Dvorak, Liszt, Shostakovich, and Chopin got me in, but my favorite is Ravel

I hope you just like the music of Rachmaninoff and your are not depressive😂

Tchaikovsky is 100% the opo music of classical music - the 'accuracy' you perceive is that it's just an emo soundbyte any basic bitch would see and say 'omggg it's literarly me'

I just feel so you... Not only because I fit into the description, but also because I have been thinking in listening something from Rachmaninoff after listening the one from this video

@@helvete_ingres4717 Congrats you totally pwned that loser. Btw you are now the other type of “basic bitch” that gets unreasonably angry at any sign “basic bitch-ness”. I’m now the other kind of “basic bitch” that points out the “basic bitch-ness” in “basic bitch” haters. Actually I think I just got promoted to the self aware “basic bitch” “basic bitch” hater hater though.

yess my fav is tchaikovsky and i felt pretty attacked

Omg I love those two as well 💖

Yeah, he deserves to be there, I just forgot him😂

The thing is, Grieg is a lot more than Morning Mood and In the Hall of the Mountain King. I would be upset if he would appear in the list with any of those pieces.

Grieg is so fcking cool. If after searching your name I find both In the hall of the mountain king (which is one of the songs that scare me in a very good and pleasant way) AND Morning mood (which is the most calming piece of music I know) then yeah ypu are metal asf

You beat me to it. Grieg deserves to be in here.

Guess I forgot a few famous ones😂

they don’t exist

@@inserttapehere276 :(

Saint-Saëns: Your spirit animal is French? 🤷‍♂️

@@jacktrainer4387 let's be more specific, a french cat😂

Thanks😂

Me too!!!!! 😊😊

Same loll!!!

Same 😂

Me too🤣🤣

Also a pianist and yes it checks out lol

Everyone you listed is a top 5 for me I fully agree tho I’d probably go Tchaikovsky, Chopin and Debussy are 2 then Rachmaninov and then Liszt

tchaikovsky>>>

@@malcolmmillar7702 Tbh I didn't list them in any specific order. The actual order for me would probably be something similar: Rachmaninov, Tchaikovsky, Chopin/Debussy and Liszt. I love Tchaikovsky, but Rachmaninov is my absolute favourite. I also agree on Chopin and Debussy being on the same level, I like listening to them both a lot.

Rachmaninoff arguably has the best melodies

Sorry but, Rachmaninoff mixes many feelings together both Minor and Major.

why is that? i really like his operas, so i‘m asking

@@vickyengler21 Tacking on to what Yenny said, Wagner was a serial anti-semite. He was so jealous of fellow (Jewish) composers Giacomo Meyerbeer and Felix Mendelssohn that he published an entire paper about how Jewish composers were inferior and couldn't create great music after Mendelssohn died. So yeah, great composer but massive dick.

@@yennyburgos82 Angela Merkel as well. 🤫

Just listen to a couple lieder ohne worte from Mendelsson and you’ll be fine

@@yennyburgos82 Hitler also drank water

Same bro

Sorry🙌🏻😂

Maladaptive daydreamer gang

same

Having constant fantasy relationships is called limerence, I used to do it too. It's a way of avoiding real life and can be a sign of past trauma.

Yeah, I got lucky there, I think it is even the same key😂definitely not on purpose😂

I'm a Shosta superfan and I've neither ever studied music nor am I nearly as old...sad.

I grew up in a musical household and i will say, Shosta has some real bangers. (Walz Nr.2 ist just perfection)

I was a late developer he was my fav from 16 to ...30 lol

You should become a pianist! There's nothing like the feeling of playing Chopin after a long day...

Who's asking you

​@@edieremia9464Me!

​@@edieremia9464This is a comment section. The point of its existence is for people to write comments in it, little cretin

You don't need to be a pianist to enjoy it , I am not a movie star and I enjoy cinema.

Haha, greetings fellow Dvořák fan

@@BimbelyGimbly lol greetings

I claped!

Dvorak 8 and piano quintet in the house

Stará vystrč prdel hosti dou...

I can't deny that🙌🏻

THE MOZART ONE WAS ACCURATE?? I'M NOT A CONSTRUCTION WORKER

I am quite fond of Handel, due to his recorder sonatas and the Messiah. Being a recorder player and a love of good Christian sacred music in english plays a big role here. I have a hard time picking a favorite composer though.

Trovatore is a combination of "the writer was on crack" and "this music slaps". Also, Leonora needs glasses.

It was infuriatingly inaccurate!

If I remember correctly, he started writing a song dedicated to Napoleon, whom he viewed as a hero. However, when Napoleon crowned himself Emperor, Beethoven changed the dedication to “to the death of a great man” or something along those lines.

@@highgrounder it was his 3rd symphony, Eroica, that he dedicated to Napoleon. But when Napoleon crowned himself emperor, Beethoven was so furious he scratched out Napoleons name so hard it tore through the page. He then rededicated the piece to the memory of a hero.

I think the joke is that Beethoven is a household name and his compositions tend to be favorable to modern popular tastes. It's a round-about way of saying people who have Beethoven as their favorite composer are basic bitches.

@@LoneWolf343 ridiculous

Vaughan Williams: You are a Hobbit.

Lfmao

I can't belive Vaughan Williams wasn't here. Him, Copland, and Duke Ellington.

The Reich one is good

No German, no Austrian, poor boy!

I have my own particular tastes. Eastern European sounds speak to me, as do French. Liszt is from a section of Hungary that is now a part of Austria.

It's ok, I made only a joke.

Yesss more banjo. I wish Wagner had written more instrumental music and not wasted so much of his time, energy, and effort composing operas. No I do not like opera and I am not going to apologize for not liking opera.

😂

Why does it say "doesn't exist"

@@DubravkaKaraula My thoughts exactly!

This

@@DubravkaKaraulaeven worse, this says “doens’t exist”

Mozart called Handel the greatest composer who ever lived. And who are we to argue with him?

A good example of Beethoven is the dedication of Eroica, or I suppose the hole where the dedication used to be

Fans act differently than composers. This wasn’t about composers

Beethoven was very much Liberal.

I think he's having fun with it. Certainly Verdi isn't just for grandmothers! And what if you have several favorites? Like Beethoven and...

Its about the fans not the composers themselves

Prokofiev is not even that progressive if you compare him to other composers st the time

Great analysis, though I'd personally associate Dali's paintings with the music of Messiaen 👍

I'd recommend looking into prokofiev's work on ivan the terrible, it's what got me into him and it shows a bit of a different side of him

Trash talking Cage like that on the internet is bold. The pseudo-intellectuals will come for you.

@@rob011 was that actually trash -talk about Cage?

Did John Cage dirty

@@miketackabery7521 I'm a huge fan but the fanclub can be a bit much sometimes haha

@@rob011 i will openly admit my hatred for cage

Thanks👍🏻

Hey Felix, the video you requested is out if you haven't seen it.🙌🏻 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/f76UfKiUvqnNXas.html

@@Carl-FriedrichWelker Thx, actually, I watched it the day you uploaded it (I am subscribed to your channel since I saw the first video). It is wonderful, as always.

@@felixmelendezvelasco4325 Thanks man, I appreciate it🙌🏻

Papa Franz would love the characterization of an overexcited puppy

No joke, I actually can't listen to Rachmaninoff when I feel bad, it's too damn depressing😂

Jesus Christ, the good lord who miraculously healed me of my years long nightly chronic breathing issue in prayer instantly, cares deeply for you my friends 😊

Rach can be depressing but also very romantic and beautiful.

@Musikbibliothek I'm not that strong😂

I don’t understand why people find his music depressing, i cant see it.

I love Verdi too! Don't have grandkids yet. I'm not too pretentious. But I don't know much about classical music, that's true 😅

Eri tu

Eri tu@@verak66

Or you just ARE a baritone. Verdi really did so much justice for the (mostly dramatic) baritone repertoire. Of course, I’m a young lyric so I don’t get to even glance at those roles unless my voice grows as I age. I still have Rossini’s figaro I guess…

There's always hope you hit late 30s or so and then suddenly, Verdi @@daltyd4820

Scriabin and Schulhoff too

How can you miss Debussy.

⁠@@jxmai7687 Ravel kinda doubles as debussy lol

​@@jxmai7687ravel is debussy but better 😂

@@le4chehenry324I kind of agree. I like a lot of his songs more. Though I am just a guy who enjoys classical music and don’t know much about how music works or whatever. I know some stuff from being in a middleschool band class but not much

Apparently you don't exist, how do you feel about that?

Someone told me Händel is for music beginners. That was by the salesman, and I bought that CD after that. 😂 ( I am listening Dvořák ATM).

@@jxmai7687 I don’t know, I Just enjoyed playing his pieces. A lot of technique, very ellegant and corresponding with his era, yet much more airy than Bach (in my opinion), it lighter, decent elegance, less curls. Maybe because of Händel was in England, where was no music and not much of decorations and curls and stuff… but thats history, not music :)

What is then difference between "my favorite" and "my absolute favorite"? I am asking just to learn. Thank you

@@namenlos2578 It's just an intensification of the statement:)

@@elifdurmus8243 No kidding? I thought it was a useless, meaningless and stupid intensification

@@namenlos2578 wow

So favorite is when you realize you love a piece even if you haven't listened to it for awhile. You may find yourself humming the tune at wrk. An absolute favorite piece of music is when you have to listen to it at least 3 times a week. If you don't you'll stick a sharpened pencil in your eye for suffering your own foolishness

Never heard of him, what is he known for?

@@Carl-FriedrichWelker For creating the Nokia ringtone, the piece is called “Gran Vals” there’s one part of it where you can hear something similar to the Nokia ringtone

@@PaganiniDaDemon Thanks for teaching me new stuff👍🏻

My favorites it's Liszt, Chopin, Rach and Bach, these three have create so much insane piece and that push the piano to his limit, i just start learn bach piece and it's such a joy to play them.

​@@filoue2583eh they don't really push the piano to its limits. you have guys like sorabji and cecil taylor for that.

You think you're smart, don't you?

@@le4chehenry324 huh?

It's called OCD, I think.

At least you enjoyed this one😂

When I listen to Handel I feel like a an english King who loves baroque.

@@jesustovar2549 And likes to put people on a guillotine😂

@@Carl-FriedrichWelker Nope, but I feel like in an english or a royalty scenario, I call it "BAROCK TIME" or "WIG TIME". Sometimes I have my "BAROCK AFTERNOONS" LOL.

He "handeled you" (You can hit me if you want, that was a not incredible jokeTwT)

So ur turned on by incest and violence...?

So cousin or sister?

@@renevillarreall.r.3503 Why choose, when she can be both?

@@renevillarreall.r.3503 both (yours)

@@renevillarreall.r.3503 I dunno, what about you: the neighbourhood watch, or the special police? You have an hour, or I'm calling both.

Thanks😂

Yeah, if you're on crack...

living as a French aristocrat in the Rococo period That's hilarious😂

Vivaldi was Italian