Why is criticism of a weak character automatically sexist and racist?

Of course we couldn't have Luke mourning Han. We needed time for him to milk alien creatures.

Let's be honest, those sequels were already a "stupid move."

the only problem with Rose is they forgot to cut all her scenes.

In all seriousness episodes 7, 8, and 9 could have been deleted.

Rose isn't the first Asian-American woman in Star Wars. *Dalyn Chew,* who portrayed *Lyn Me* all the way back in 1983, is.

I’ve never had a problem with the actress who played Rose or the actress in Kenobi that got hate. They are just actors who got screwed into playing poorly written characters. I blame the writers for killing Star Wars.

The biggest mistake was not chucking "The Last Jedi" in the trash.

I never understood why shooting someone who has a gun pointed at you and clearly wants to kill you before they shoot you would be considered cold blooded. Instead IMO its the only thing anyone with a working brain who lacked a death wish would do under the circumstances. And its been a while since I watched any John Wayne movies but I'm pretty sure his characters sometimes shot people who were about to shoot them but hadn't pulled the trigger yet.

Sorry but Rose Tico’s character was just horrible. Stop blaming race & trolls

Star Wars jumped the shark after the first trilogy. And hell, even those first three films were screwed over by Luca's film re-edits later on.

we could have cut the porgs for a Luke scene

I thought The Last Jedi was a bad movie, then I saw The Rise of Skywalker.

The scene at Tosche Station REALLY should have stayed.

3PO probably would've short circuited when he proclaimed "Thank the Maker" IF he actually knew who his 'maker' became......

Deleting the scene showing Luke morning Han is just another example of how these people do not know what FANS want or they just don't care

Films 7,8,9 where just one giant pacing issue, those never should have been made without a outline for all three films already being set in stone,and scripts being written around that outline, instead of what they did.

I know I'm going to anger a bunch of "Han shot first" people in the comments here, but let me just say that to those who actually read Greedo's dialogue in the original version, Han shooting Greedo was always done in self-defense: Greedo literally stated his intent to kill Han moments before Han shot. The original version simply showcased Han firing a preemptive shot, where the later versions simply show that "stormtrooper syndrome" applies to more than just stormtroopers.

For Greedo to miss that shot point-blank means he must have fired reflexively in defense.

The Disney star wars stuff sux. Got nothing to do with the actors. They do the best they can with the turd sandwich of a script. Luke's scenes were dropped when someone else recut and saved the plot of episode err.. 1 or 4... biggs "yeah.. stories" was originally on the cutting room floor, and it was awkward.. at least it made his death make sense. Originally, with people dying all around him, Luke was particularly shaken by biggs which was quite confusing. Creating continuity there was always going to be a problem as I believe the 1977 cut was the right call

Abrams, Tario and even Lucas sure were snorting SOMETHING.

How to fix the sequel trilogy: get rid of it all.

“Sorry Kelly….the dog ate all your scenes”

I find it impossible to believe that Kathleen Kennedy would allow any scenes that contribute to DEI to be cut due to any perception of "fan backlash" or online trolling - no matter how bad. If there's one thing I've learned since Disney took over, it's that they have their ideals that they wish to push forward, and they have zero intention of listening to the fans, or anybody else who might not agree with them, even if it dooms the project from inception. Case in point, Star Wars Acolyte.

Tiresome narration-ah.

Too much like American graffiti? The first time you saw the cockpit of the millennium falcon Chewbacca walked right into a pair of dice. There were furry dice hanging from the car Harrison Ford drove in American graffiti. In attack of the clones Obi Wan goes to see his friend Dex who owns a diner with a droid waitress on wheels. In the DVD commentary Lucas said that was his tribute to American graffiti

ANH had other deleted scenes removed while it was in theaters. When the stormtroopers call to close the blast doors, and our heroes jump thru at the last moment, troopers ran up to them calling to open the blast doors. The last part was removed because audiences chuckled at the empires frustration. And Lucas didn't want something light hearted during the fight in the death Star.

Rose’s dislike had nothing to do with race. Bad writing is what brought that on.

5:24 What on Tatooine is that unForcely abomination on the shelf, to Anakin's left? 😱

Id rather deal with Han shooting first than "MACKUNKY!!"

Pacing is actually key in movies. It's called narrative and is far better than the current tendency towards stringing 2hrs worth of Tik Tok moments together in the hope of a few memes.

I also heard that the Rose and Leia scenes were cut because they couldn't finish the FX effects to allow Leia to blend into the scenes in time.

Considering that the entire gameplay style of smuggler in star wars the old republic went along the line that smugglers hated fair battles so they preferred to shoot first, George Lucas was dumb to change the cantina scene to allow Greedo a lucky potshot at killing Han solo. In fact, he was foolish on a number of other occasions, mostly on the seaquels, where he allowed JAR-JAR Abrams to mess the episodes up royally, as well as that woman "dictator" that had the entire feminist power concept behind Ray and all the new female cast ruin the OG characters by killing them off and the so called fan service they did in the very last one of the episodes with that Karen ramming the rebel flagship into the imperial fleet after having the fleet decimated by the imperial plot armor of rebel fleet being out of fuel.

While deleting the "American Graffiti" because someone teased Lucas about it would be a stupid reason, another reason might be, the scene would have messed up the pacing of the film, and would have left the audience confused. Instead, we are following the two droids, and in that context, meeting Luke when the droids meet him makes a lot more sense. In the dinner scene we establish that Luke is a farm boy (who ever once says "As you wish") who longs for adventure outside the farm of his guardians. The scene would not have added anything to the movie.

Deleting all of those scenes with Luke made him look like a bitter asshole.

No problem with Tran other than the scene with the casino, and you can't blame her for that, that's on the director and scribblers ("writers")

The "Han shot first" could have easily justified by changing Greedo's dialog to something like "You are going to die now. Any last words?". That or something where Greedo assures Han that he is going to be killed. It is pretty simple really, and makes more sense that dodging a beam from a blaster

Rose was just an annoying character. It was the way she was written. She almost got everyone killed because she wanted to give Finn a little kiss. There is no need to be racist. Just be honest. Her character was foolish. And downright annoying. 2:53

There were other reasons these scenes probably got cut if you think about it, other than those stupid reasons. 7. Disney were terrified people would think ep 9 horrible right off the bat if they saw Rose in it too much. 6. This is already the slowest star wars movie to begin, so having more talking would just slow it down more. 3. People can't lose limbs in a Disney movie. Also having Phasma die, then get back up again, only to die again does feel clunky. 1. In the final release of the film, Luke says "Where's Han". And they cut straight to Kylo Ren for the first time in the movie. When I first saw this scene, it sent a shiver down my spine. The mourning, like a lot of these scenes, is a good scene, but they didn't have room for it (That's why Ren is my favourite sequel character, even with the bad lightsaber duels and wishy-washy villainy. I also liked the whole dyad concept with him too.😊)

Don't know about underwear, but paper and spectacles are extremely crude technologies. Given the prosthetic hand, why wouldn't you expect medical science to preserve everyone's eyesight?

My favourite sequel trilogy character was 'Endo Credits'.

Rose's star wars figurine was the most represented at the bargain bin. Just goes to show the character was not that likeable-it had nothing to do with ethnicity or gender.

Oh God Gareth Again

I personally didn't care for Rose's character or storyline. Nothing to do with race or sex...just didn't find the character interesting. Donnie Yen's character and brother in Rogue One were very good. Hate how if you don't support some characters, it's automatically racism or sexism. Don't like the new Charlie's Angels, well clearly you're sexist. Doesn't matter that everyone loved the originally movies with an all female cast, has to be sexism!

This video felt ai generated from the script to the voiceover lol

Favorite sequel character? BB-8. He was rhe only one who filled his role perfectly. The rest of the characters can be chalked up as "wasted potential".

Disney killed Star Wars. That is all.

@4:36 That scene! I had a Star Wars book when i was a kid that had scenes from the movie. That scene was in the book, but it always confused me since it wasn't in the movie!

Favorite sequel trilogy character: Yoda

Sad that the coolest thing 3PO did ended up getting cut.

Best sequel character is Poe

It would be really cool if they would make shorts or somehow integrate deleted scenes into new story content, not just for Star Wars either.

So I have a client with an annoying verbal tick, and now I have found where it comes from. Please please please can you ensure that when you are finishing a phrase or line, please don’t finish it it an -uh, like “then amidala found a room-uh, or , timing reasons-uh”. Jarring and doesn’t assist the narrative. Thanks in advance

I thought Rose Tico's role was cut in Episode IX because the Chinese audience and censors didn't like her kissing Finn in Episode VIII?

If they added these scenes back in. The movie could be changed for the better.

I hate that, dont mention Rose Tico without also mentioning she was a trash CHARACTER, thats equally important to the actor hate

6:35 At those ranges, he who fires first survives. If you fire and miss, you should not be carrying that sort of weapon.

Rose's character simply lacked verisimilitude. Not the actress's fault. I blame the writers.

No paper in space seems odd, they have to had paper before data pads or such, that and where did painters did their paintings? If Star Trek could have papers in the future, why couldn’t Star Wars have paper in space?

3:48 So Luke was The Toad. Charles Martin Smith, aka Toad, in More American Graffiti had the hot girlfriend and was a Huey Pilot. My favorite character.

Okay, but come on! C3PO tricking Storm Troopers THREE times in 3 MOVIES is totally worth it!

Now i want to see darth vader vs a wampa

Quit blaming everything on racism. Rose's scenes were cut because there was nothing appealing about the character.

No one liked rose that’s why those scenes were cut

People did not hate Tran, they hated the character and the whole story arc she anchored. It was not personal, it was just we wanted a good story.

Rogue One is the *only* decent Disney made Star Wars movie. The rest? They should have had a more cohesive storyline that was outlined before they started filming Episode VII. Instead, we got a ton of garbage that did not really make any sense after TFA.

Personally... and I'll admit, this is probably an unpopular opinion... I always thought that Greedo shooting first made Han look more like a total badass. Please allow me to explain... Despite the fact that Greedo initially got the drop on Solo, he still stayed calm and in control throughout the entire scene. And the fact that Greedo didn't just shoot Han's heart out through his back at the moment he had the chance showed Han that Greedo wanted him alive. Worse for Greedo, Han just sits back down with his left hand raised and his right hand in the very last place Greedo should want it to be; right next to his blaster. This shows that either Greedo is a rookie at bounty hunting... or that he's clearly a moron for not making sure that both of Han's hands are where he could see them. So, let's put ourselves in Greedo's shoes for a moment. You have your target right where you want him and are feeling incredibly pleased with yourself. But he's stealing your thunder by just looking at you like you're just another annoyance that the Force, or whatever powers-that-be put in his way. You want to wipe that nonchalant look off of his face. But you can't just kill him, because if you do, there goes your big bounty. So what do you do? What can you do to try to get him to show you some respect? Warning shot. I figured that Greedo's shot was a last ditch attempt to intimidate Han. However, unfortunately for Greedo, in his inexperienced and moronic stupidity, Han knew that Greedo wouldn't kill him and had already prepared his response.

Sexist trolls? They didnt like it because it was a Trash Character with to much emphasis

I just tend to watch those Biggs scenes between Rogue One and New Hope

Please don't try to link Han Solo and John Wayne. John Wayne refused to fight the Nazis. But said people who refused to fight in Vietnam should be sent to prison. There is a word for that, and I already used it in this statement.

My favorite sequel character is Bo Bo Frick 😊

The minute you start arguing for more Rose Tico, is where you lost me. Try not to be so obvious next time.

My most favorite sequel trilogy character was the end credits, really made me happy those trash movies were over

Seriously? You couldn't have left Disney's Star Wars out of this? I was so looking forward to watching this until you had to add Disney's into it

Kylo, baeba baebaa

WHYUH!

Some of those are just as well. A few would have been nice.

Sexist Racist Trolls my foot. The Character of Rose was aweful. People were only reacting fairly.

Rose isn't hated cause she's Asian. It's because she's a horrible character that added nothing to Ep 8. She was cut from Ep 9 cause Disney finally realized this and was trying to save face with its fanbase.

Greedo did not fire first, Han did not fire first. Han just fired only. And John Wayne's overrated, anyhow, George.

Either han solo bb-8 r2-d2 chewbacca force ghost yoda 3-- po maz kanata or porgs

Should star wars be rebooted?

For the "favorite sequel character" question, none of the above

“Who is your favourite sequel trilogy character?” NONE OF THEM!!!! THE DISNEY ERA OF STAR WARS SHOULD NEVER HAVE HAPPENED!!!!!! This may be just my opinion but I think that OG fans are getting angrier and angrier with every project now being released. Star Wars has become one of those franchises that were awesome back in the day but now should just stop and that makes me sad.

Rose sucked! Move on!!!!!

Poe Dameron

Dude Rose was a pointless character. Move on lol

My favorite star Wars character in star wars episode x must be poe

can you please tone down your requests for likes/subscribes between every list spot if you annoy the viewer they are likely to do the opposite, or stop watching your channel altogether.

This video made me despise Rian Johnson even more. I have a sith like hatred toward everything he does. His fancy boy detective films can go straight to hell.

Rose’s character sucked. That’s why she was cut, period.

Talk about dumb scenes that SHOULD have been deleted ... how about the battle with the Bouncing Yoda? Boing, boing, boing ... follow the bouncing Yoda. Is he made of Flubber?

What is most annoying is the over the top, all the way to the moon over-acting in this guy's voice. Can you imagine him ordering in a McDonald's drive through?? Just speak somewhat close to normal, it saves about half your audience from hitting mute.

Rose sucked anyway she didn't add to the film

1:04 online abuse from sexist and racist trolls? We can see this channel is sponsored by Disney. Why else are you spreading that lie. Her character was bad, period.

The only good character in the sequels is pow damron. The rest of the characters had shit writing

Please stop acknowledging the existence of the Disney sequels. They suck and should be disregarded completely. There are only 6 Star Wars movies, period

Rose is an annoying character. Whether it’s the writing or the actress. She is not good. That is not about race. That’s just her being a bad character. Same for Finn and even Rey and Kylo Ren.

Well to be frank there is no good characters in the sequel movies. Sure JJ abrams did start good, Rey, Poe, Finn and Kylo sermed interesting, but Ryan kinda broke them all. The only character that got fixed was kinda Rose Tico in the last Movie.

Episodes 7-9 are trash and they dont exist to me, that said, Rose Tico was an horrible character, completely unlikeable.