LOTR is a complex fantasy at the highest order. In contrast, HP is for kids. Cannot be compared.

Harry Potter: Great fantasy series with a positive message The Lord of The Rings: THE Supreme priceless Gem that reigns over all. Without it, HP wouldn’t even exist.

This is like comparing Dr. Suess to Huckleberry Finn. One is made for only children and the other it a master work in literature and adventure. There really is no comparing LOTR to HP with any credibility. Even the box office number are skewed. At least 1/3 of the people who went to watch HP were parents taking their kids.

LOTR is the best story ever told

Me writing an essay on why Lotr is better than Harry Potter: 👀

Cultural Impact- Also Star Wars 🌌 wouldn’t exist without the LOTRs since it does take inspiration as George Lucas said: “It’s a film about space wizards.”🧙🏻‍♂️🧙🏽‍♂️

The Lord of the Rings, not a debate

LOTR all the time ❤

One influenced Led Zeppelin while the other influenced "wizard rock". Should I even continue?

The Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter are two of the most popular fantasy book series in the world, and both have been adapted into successful movie franchises. While they share some similarities, such as their epic storylines and rich world-building, there are also significant differences between the two series. One of the key differences between the two series is their tone. The Lord of the Rings is a much darker and more serious story, with themes of war, loss, and sacrifice. The characters are complex and flawed, and the story is often bleak and grim. In contrast, Harry Potter is a more light-hearted and whimsical story, with themes of friendship, loyalty, and bravery. The characters are often more straightforward and simpler, and the story is generally more optimistic and upbeat. Another difference between the two series is their world-building. The Lord of the Rings is set in a vast and complex world, with multiple races, cultures, and languages. The story is heavily influenced by Norse and Celtic mythology, and the world is filled with rich history and lore. Harry Potter, on the other hand, is set in a more familiar and recognizable world, albeit one with magic and fantastical creatures. While there is certainly world-building in Harry Potter, it is generally less complex and more focused on the characters and their relationships. The themes of the two series also differ significantly. The Lord of the Rings is a story about the struggle between good and evil, and the lengths that people will go to protect what they love. It is a story about sacrifice and heroism, and the power of friendship and loyalty. Harry Potter, on the other hand, is a story about the importance of love and family, and the struggle against prejudice and intolerance. It is a story about the power of education and knowledge, and the importance of standing up for what is right. Finally, the two series also differ in terms of their cultural impact. The Lord of the Rings is widely considered to be one of the greatest works of literature of the 20th century, and has had a profound impact on the fantasy genre. It has inspired countless imitators and has been adapted into movies, video games, and other media. Harry Potter, on the other hand, is a more recent phenomenon, but has had a similar impact on popular culture. It has spawned a massive fandom, and has been adapted into movies, theme parks, and other merchandise. In conclusion, while both The Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter are beloved fantasy series with massive fandoms, they are quite different in terms of their tone, world-building, themes, and cultural impact. The Lord of the Rings is a darker and more complex story with a rich mythology and themes of sacrifice and heroism, while Harry Potter is a more light-hearted and character-focused story with themes of love and friendship. Both are great stories in their own right, and have had a significant impact on popular culture

LOTR!

I’m a huge fan of both lord of the rings and Harry Potter. Bot are incredible and amazingly well told stories. But lord of the rings just does everything better. !

I never realized that Professor Tolkien spoke THAT many languages! Then add the 3 or 4 languages he made up, complete with alphabets and pronunciation rules, that he wrote poetry and inscriptions for? 😮❤

xD I love how lotr always wins, no matter what. And I do agree, the amazingness of LOTR is impossible to surpass. I'm a very big lotr fan. (I like HP too, but LOTR is just next level.)

As a young man I thought HP was better as I have matured lotr has taken its place as the best. Both are amazing though

LOTR movies 10 out of 10, the books 10 out of 10, the HP movies 4 out of 10, the HP books 9 out of 10. The battle of Hogwarts is a 'pathetic excuse for a battle' it is nothing compared to the Battle of Helm's Deep. Voldemort lived for 71 years, Sauron lived for more than 60,000 years.

the slytherin thing is facts

I feel like it’s extremely hard to compare these two movies you can’t go off box tickets basically for every kid there was a parent going off Soli off which ones better lord of rings can’t beat the dialogue

Quick note here, has Tolkien been alive in this modern age, he likely wouldn't be super progressive, the man grew up in the early 1900s.

3:28 Uh, how is questioning the idiocy of a ridiculous movement bigotry?? And I am pretty sure that Tolkien would have had a much bigger say in this ridiculous movement since he was a Christian.

RUN YOU FOLS

They are not the same legue. Harry Potter is a mid-written book series with some cool characters and ideas, but LotR is different. It tells messages, creates worlds and species. LotR will probably be always the best of the best, whilst Harry Potter is the top of the middle...

Harry Potter is an excellent movie, but The LOTR WILL ALWAYS BE THE BEST..❤❤❤❤❤

There is only one lord of the ring, and he does not share power.

We also wouldn’t have Game of Thrones

L O T R 🌋

I agree completely on every factor.

Most definitely Lord of the Ring is the winner🏆 I mean, I did enjoyed reading Harry Potter series at first, but let's face it, was Hermione who did most of the heavy lifting. Without her, Harry Potter would have been the loser!

YESSSSS LOTR IS THE GOAT. THE GOAT

No contest. Currently working through the HP movies with friends, and it's just... bad. I can't understand the love, but i understand loving snape. He's the best part of those movies (so far, anyway)

Harry is way more entertaining on the 1st read. LOTR is deeper and will always win on the long run upon reflection. But anyone saying Harry Potter wasnt more entertaining upon first is fucking lying lol

Harry Potter is win

Vecna: I have supernatural powers and I want to take over a town. Davy Jones: I'm the most feared sea monster in a very big sea and I have a very amazing ghost ship. Lord Voldemort: I'm the most feared and powerful dark wizard in the entire wizarding community, I'm a cult leader and I also became immortal for a little while. The Night King: I have an endless army of the dead and I almost froze all the kingdoms. Sauron: I'm an angelic entity, I'm the most trusted and powerful servant of Morgoth, I was born immortal, I have a bigger army, my name is more feared and I took over the world twice. Emperor Palpatine: I'm a space dark lord who took over a galaxy and I have Darth Vader as my puppet. Thanos: I'm a gigantic alien titan from deep space and I'm the only one in the entire universe who can properly wield, control and survive the cosmic powers of all six infinity stones, I crushed all of the avengers including some gods with just my bare hands and I erased half of the universe with just a snap of my fingers.

LOTR is far more iconic, especially when were talking about the movies. Once again, if we're only talking about the movies and leave the books aside, they had a far bigger impact on culture and especially the film industry. LOTR changed the way many blockbusters would be made from then on in terms of VFX, cinematography, score, iconography, etc. I can't even count all the times a movie had to end with a big epic fantasy battle since ROTK left theatres. Harry Potter changed jack shit when it comes to that.

Lord of the Rings is the only other franchise that rivals Peak Star Wars. Harry Potter is barely a pebble in comparison. But Harry Potter should be thanked for helping current geek culture to be normalized who I can be a nerd without being bullied.. now I’m being bullied by fellow nerds!

This is obviously a biased review, these two films are always compared to each other when they were obviously meant for different audiences Age wise

Honestly I have much respect to j.r.r Tolkien he’s a great man could speak insane amount of languages made super great books just a smart man Rowling I have less respect kinda racist stuff and worldbuiding isn’t even that great as lotr and just in general trash opinions and the ideas are just weird in a bad way sometimes

I’m the end they are both literary and cinematic masterpieces Lotr has already had a decade to grow and I bet when Harry Potter is as old as lotr it will be just as much of an Impact that lotr has at this time

My personal favorite is Harry Potter, and second one is LOTR

yeah lotr is just better but wtf is this video xD, it makes no sense

Bro half of the information you given are false. Let's remake the video: 1. Movies: Harry Potter with $5M diff The Lord of the Rings Trilogy: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001): $871 million The Two Towers (2002): $926 million The Return of the King (2003): $1.119 billion Average earnings per movie in The Lord of the Rings trilogy: (871 + 926 + 1,119) / 3 = $972 million Harry Potter Film Series: Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone (2001): $974 million Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (2002): $878 million Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004): $796 million Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2005): $896 million Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (2007): $942 million Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (2009): $934 million Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 1 (2010): $960 million Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 (2011): $1.342 billion Average earnings per movie in the Harry Potter series: (974 + 878 + 796 + 896 + 942 + 934 + 960 + 1,342) / 8 = $977 million 2. Creators: Lord of The Rings (I can't disagree) 3. Merch: Lord of The Rings (I have no quantiative proofs so I gonna believe what you gonna say. But my mind keeps saying this should goes to Harry Potter as it has a huge Wizarding World.) 4. Books: Draw (Please note that comprehensive sales figures for The Lord of the Rings books are not available, so the numbers provided are approximate estimates.) Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone: 150M copies The Fellowship of the Ring: 150M copies 5. Cultural Impacts: Harry Potter Harry Potter: i) Global Fanbase: The series has amassed an enormous and dedicated fanbase worldwide, transcending age groups and cultures. Fans organize conventions, fan clubs, and online communities, fostering a sense of community and shared enthusiasm. ii) Literary Influence: Harry Potter sparked a renewed interest in reading among children and young adults. The series encouraged a new generation of readers, revitalizing the publishing industry and inspiring subsequent fantasy authors. iii) Popularity of Fantasy Genre: The success of Harry Potter played a crucial role in the resurgence of the fantasy genre, leading to the publication of numerous fantasy novels and the emergence of fantasy-themed films and TV shows. iv) Film Adaptations: The Harry Potter film series, consisting of eight movies, brought the magical world to life on the big screen. The films not only introduced the story to a wider audience but also set new standards for visual effects and cinematic storytelling. v) Theme Park Attractions: The Wizarding World of Harry Potter theme park areas, located in Universal Studios parks in Orlando, Hollywood, and Japan, provide fans with immersive experiences in recreations of famous locations from the series, such as Hogwarts Castle and Diagon Alley. vi) Language and Vocabulary: The Harry Potter series introduced numerous new terms, spells, and phrases that have become part of popular culture. Words like "Muggle," "Quidditch," and "Hogwarts" have entered the lexicon and are widely recognized even by those who haven't read the books. vii) Philanthropic Impact: Author J.K. Rowling's philanthropic endeavors, such as the creation of the charity organization Lumos, have had a positive impact on various causes, including children's rights and welfare. viii) Social and Political Commentary: The series addresses themes of prejudice, discrimination, friendship, bravery, and the fight against evil. It has sparked discussions and encouraged readers to reflect on these issues, promoting empathy and inclusivity. ix) Educational Influence: Many educators have incorporated Harry Potter into their teaching, using the books to engage students and explore topics like literature, morality, ethics, and critical thinking. x) Merchandising and Merchandise: The franchise's immense popularity has led to a wide range of merchandise, including toys, clothing, collectibles, and more, creating a significant economic impact and giving fans opportunities to express their love for the series. xi) Snapism Religion xI) Quidditch Game xii) 9 3/4 Station These are just a few examples of the cultural impacts the Harry Potter series has had. Its influence can be seen across various aspects of popular culture, literature, entertainment, and beyond. Lord of The Rings: i) Epic Fantasy Revival: The Lord of the Rings played a pivotal role in reviving and popularizing the epic fantasy genre. It inspired subsequent fantasy authors, such as Terry Brooks and George R.R. Martin, and influenced the development of fantasy literature as a whole. ii) Film Adaptations: The film trilogy directed by Peter Jackson brought The Lord of the Rings to the big screen with stunning visuals and a faithful adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien's world. The movies not only gained critical acclaim but also introduced a wider audience to the series and set new standards for epic filmmaking. iii) Landscape and Location Tourism: The beautiful landscapes depicted in The Lord of the Rings films, primarily filmed in New Zealand, have become tourist attractions. Fans visit various filming locations, such as the Hobbiton movie set, to experience the real-world settings of Middle-earth. iv) Language and Naming: Tolkien's intricate language creation, including Elvish languages like Sindarin and Quenya, has inspired language enthusiasts and influenced the naming conventions in fantasy literature and role-playing games. v) Iconic Characters: Characters like Frodo Baggins, Gandalf, and Aragorn have become iconic figures in popular culture. Their traits, quotes, and heroism have permeated various forms of media, inspiring countless references, parodies, and tributes. vi) Mythology and Worldbuilding: Tolkien's extensive worldbuilding, detailed mythology, and rich history of Middle-earth have influenced subsequent fantasy works. The depth and complexity of his universe continue to inspire authors and storytellers to create their own immersive worlds. vii) Literary Legacy: The Lord of the Rings trilogy is regarded as one of the greatest literary achievements of the 20th century. It has been studied in academic settings and has influenced the field of literary criticism, particularly in the realm of fantasy literature. viii) Music and Soundtracks: The iconic musical score composed by Howard Shore for The Lord of the Rings films contributed to the immersive experience and has become instantly recognizable. The soundtrack's popularity and impact on the film industry are widely acknowledged. ix) Gaming and Role-playing: The Lord of the Rings has served as a foundation for various role-playing games, video games, and tabletop games. Games like The Lord of the Rings Online and Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor have allowed fans to explore and interact with the world of Tolkien's creation. x) Environmental Themes: The Lord of the Rings reflects Tolkien's concerns about the destruction of nature and the impact of industrialization. The series has resonated with environmentalists and advocates for ecological preservation, inspiring discussions on the importance of protecting the natural world. These are just a few examples of the cultural impacts The Lord of the Rings has had. Its influence can be seen in literature, film, music, tourism, gaming, and beyond, making it a seminal work in the realm of fantasy and storytelling. Better Book: Your Choice Biggest Fandom: Harry Potter Winner: Harry Potter

Harry Potter will always be better in my opinion. Just remembering all the hype and excitement in 2011 for Deathly Hallows part 2 in the movies was something that no other franchise has ever achieved. Not even the avengers in the late 2010s

I love LOTR way more than Harry Potter but I think you were unfair to J.K. Rowling she was telling the truth sex is real and to say it isn't is only harmful to their own cause and it's delusional trying to change definitions and invalidate language to fit your own narrative is fascist and honestly you basing a loss off that is dishonest and biased and takes away from anything you said

Harry potter is the goat fantasy series.

"Bigotry will result in a loss 100% of the time" 🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓

If you compared the harry potter books to the lord of the rings books and then to the Bible the Bible definitely made the most money. Holy shit it’s crazy how much that book makes and what’s crazier is people actually believe it. It’s like believing in Harry Potter or lord of the ribgs

I think the Harry Potter Books are way better than the Lord of the Rings Books. With the films, however, I can't decide which one I think is better. I love both movie series

Thumbs down, JK supporting women's rights and accomplishments isn't being anti-trans or a bigot. I thought this was going to be a fun video, but I had to turn it off after that woke nonsense.

you are just bias towards LOTR

The Harry Potter Movies are much better than Lord of the Rings and Hobbit Trilogies. The Deathly Hallows Part 2 is way better than all three Lord of the Rings Films. Also the Harry Potter films did a lot better job adapting the source material than LOTR. The Harry Potter films are also a lot more rewatchable and entertaining than Lord of the Rings. Plus the merchandise of Harry Potter is better than the LOTR merchandise, I don't care about those statues.

Lord of the rings is too slow. Drawn out, boring. Theres action, but the pace of the movies are painfully slow. Harry potter doesnt have a single dull moment.