Hope you enjoy this special edition of TWIST WATCH folks! Let us know your own Susan Twist theories below - excited to see what you've got!

WhoCulture literally predicting the entire plot of the episode in reverse order is kinda hilarious

4:32 " Do i think he's likely to have brought back such a niche villain to the classic audience? I don't think so. "

I can't believe this _just_ occured to me. In the extended Who universe, the doctor's wife / Susan's grandmother is named Patience. _Patience._ "The one who waits"...?

regardless of who she is, it's safe to say that Susan Twist really understood the assignment. She's been sinister, funny and very versatile in pretty much every role on the show. The thought that she may be a villain makes me even more interested to see what's to come

One interesting thing with the Sutekh Theory ... In the Devil's Chord, The Doctor showed Ruby her time as it would be if they didn't intervene; this is almost exactly like what the Doctor did with Sarah Jane in Pyramids of Mars.

I am not sure who Susan twist will end up being but I actially think Mrs. Flood will be revealed to be Susan Foreman and an ALLY to the doctor.

Anyone else watching this after the episode?

My theory is that the Tardis broke when 15 split it in half / duplicated it. Always seemed like a weird thing for them to do in the first place, but in retrospect, downright dangerous.

When it comes to The Trickster. The Trickster’s theme music from Sarah Jane Adventures is the same music that is played in The Devils Cord when Ruby is suspended in the air right before Carol The Bells starts to play. My theory is that The Trickster is using either Susan Triad, Ruby Sunday, or both to bring forth “the one who waits” which I predict will be Sutekh

Gave me a heart attack with that thumbnail. I thought I missed it & it was Friday already!

Triad probably calls back to the notes that banished the Maestro, so she may be the one who waits.

I'm here after the episode... you got it. I feel SO dumb I didn't catch it, I was so invested in this idea that Susan Triad was actually the Doctor's granddaughter that I didn't realize who the actual mastermind could actually be!

Keeping this spoiler free, but post episode this video is Witchcraft.

Bbc released a preview that shows more susan twists in different places

I don't know if anyone has spotted yet but, so many of Susan Twist's outfits/surroundings have blue in it - the crew messanger lady in Space Babies had a blue outfit, the Ambulence in Boom has a blue backbround/interface, the hiker in 73 Yards has a blue jacket, Lindy's mother in Dot and Bubble has a blue background, and (I think) she had a blue outfit, or I think the outfit was cut off, so we couldn't quite see it. But either way, I wonder if that means anything? The TARDIS also happens to be blue, so maybe her being connected to the TARDIS in some way makes even more sense.

Its worth noting that the first time we hear the tardis groan in that weird way and see susan twist was in wild blue yonder.. which makes me think its not just because of duplicating the tardis or invoking the superstition at the end of the universe that would cause the tardis to groan, since the groan happened before.

Sutekh. 5 Malcolms out of 10. Probability of a trap... 100%

Carole Ann Ford was also at the Starbeast premiere and all the other past companions that attended have had some link with RTD's era whether in Tales Of the Tardis or in the case of Mel, The Giggle. Yet, Carole Anne Ford has not done anything within this era yet but Susan's literally been namedropped.

Susan Twist is the Monk messing with Time to meet Omega like he did with King Harold in "The Time Meddler"

I really think Susan Twist is an original character. I think Mrs Flood is Susan.

The Tardis made that noise 3 times actually, it was first heard in wild blue yonder where tenants dr was like “strange”

I've told everyone The one who waits is the Absorbaloff he will be waiting for ever 😂😂😂😂 Antp

Im calling it now, i think the hooded figure is grown up ruby leaving baby ruby as a time loop thing ! Maybe she needs to be left there to be found to save the universe and so on

@WhoCulture Ellie.. You might have missed that in Wild Blue Yonder, Donna mentioned that her Head of Choir was a "Mrs Bean" who had a funny vegetable name & that her favourite song was Wild Blue Yonder, which in the novels, Wilf told her that it was not a happy song as it was about people going to war. It could be that Susan Triad in her "Pepper-Bean" phase was around to monitor Donna as a child. In her latest guise in Legend of Ruby Sunday, Susans belt also has a what appears to suspiciously like a Gold P & B on the buckle. Also have a look at Verse 2 of the lyrics of WBY, which refers a lot to what could potentially be happening. Interestingly the lines of the verse that can be associated with a lot of the aspects of the show also have "Devils chord" of 3 notes in the physical musical score.

I think Clara is Ruby's mother, because Clara is an anagram of Carla.

Came back here after watching the episode and I'm going to try and avoid spoilers here, but I love how almost all of these got addressed somehow... RTD knows the fans and knows what he is doing ❤

14:29 perhaps she’s Tecteun, taking the Timeless Child arc in a different direction

There absolutely HAS to be some link to Ruby in this. All the theory videos talk about her being Sutekh or the Tardis or whatever, but we're forgetting the episode is called The Legend of Ruby Sunday - if its a Ruby plot, how would Sutekh, Susan Foreman etc link in?

My prediction: Susan Twist is the latest regeneration of The Master Ms. Flood is River Song Ruby is her own mother.

Mrs flood is another water-related name. (Pond/River) I’ve always thought that Susan may not have been blood-related to The Doctor. The age gap may have just inclined her to call him that. Also, the name Foreman was borrowed from the junkyard. We don’t know if Susan had a last name. I wouldn’t be surprised if Susan Triad is related to Susan and have two hearts. 😉

Oh Ellie, Doctor Who does love to prove you wrong don't they?

The Tardis groaning sound was also heard in Wild Blue Yonder

bang on with the first one

7:47 It was just shown in a new KZfaq short on the official Dr.who KZfaq channel that the groaning sound came from the tardis in the wild blue yonder as well. Meaning that Susan twist started showing up around the same time as the groaning, which is both pre-ruby and pre-split tardis.

My theory. Ruby Sunday is the Daughter of The Doctor from River Song after their night on Darillium and she had to give her up because of her fate in The Library. So Susan is the daughter of Ruby Sunday since Time Lords it's all out of order as The Doctor mentioned.

Carole Ann Ford is still around at 83... it'd be a slap in the face to use someone else for Susan Foreman, since she would age after being stranded by the Doctor...

Watching this was rather fun... after just watching the finale. That was bonkers!

Another thing is that the appearance of this character is very similar to that of Clara during the 11th Doctor's era

S Triad is also an annagram for Astrid, Kylie Minogue's character

I think the reason she wasnt in the star beast and the giggle is because they are both set in modern day england (or at least in an area near UNIT tower due to the fact she was in the pub in TCORR) therefore Susan Twist would be Susan Triad during those episodes around that area.

It’s actually kinda crazy that all of these things were actually touched on on the episode

I can’t help but think of Sky Smith As she was planned to be the child of the trickster. Then “ the curse of Clyde Langer “ has a few similarities to 73 yards Something sacred is touch and a person is ostracised through the story.

Hmm watching after the reveal

It's funny how the episode itself played up all the speculation.

watching this after the legend of ruby sunday, was great haha, well done.

OMG Ellie you were so close with some of your predictions, I bet you have been screaming all day. Loved this episode, but I want MORE!!

Anyone else just waiting for the ups and downs after that last ep?

The Sutech theory was right on target! Well done!

Regarding the TARDIS -- let's not forget that 15 is using a duplicate Tardis he created using the residue of the Toymaker's domain. The original Tardis remained with 14. And the way it was shot in the Giggle, it was very clear which is the original and which is the duplicate: 14's Tardis stayed in place and 15's Tardis emerged from it. They *could* have shown it as a single Tardis splitting in two -- one Tardis appearing to the right, the other to the left, of a vacant spot which the original Tardis had occupied. But no: 15 is clearly using the duplicate. Whether that point will be revisited remains to be seen; but I'd be disappointed if 15's Tardis would develop a problem without this issue being even mentioned (even if it's just to rule out that explanation)

You did it Ellie, spot on prediction 😅

Wouldn't it be cool if the Ruby's Mother was River Song? It could fit between the night on Darillium and the library episode and would explain why Ruby had to be abandoned and being river she would know that her baby would end up in a good home, and it would also explain why the Doctor says he cant step in because he recognised her and knows he cant cross the time line? My guess is that the mysterious woman portrayed by Susan Twist is the Doctors Granddaughter and that Ruby is the Doctors Daughter.

Sutekh is BACK

I cannot wait for Ellie to react to the episode. Dang. That was a great starter to a two part season finale.

I don't need to know definitely where The Doctor came from, but I'm definitely in the camp of those who want it definitively said that they're NOT the Timeless Child. Move The Division to season 6B, have Doctor Ruth come between Troughton and Pertwee, and make everybody happy. The big thing that we've been told (via the synopsis of the adventure) is that SOMEhow, the events of this episode will tie back to a Pertwee adventure. There's rumors that Sean Pertwee will (finally) be playing his dad's characters in some fashion, and we know there's a new Tales of the TARDIS episode that will be dropping next week, featuring Ncuti and Millie, (and possibly Sean). Russell has said in a recent interview that re-watching Spearhead from Space would be a good idea - I don't know if there's anything in specific there that it'll spin from, or if it's just a good episode to get you introduced to Three. But that's the detail that almost all of these Clever Theories to not incorporate.

We have been acting on the assumption that Ruby's mum dropped her off at the church... But Maistro said "the oldest one how could he be there" but already knows "the one who waits" is almost here... So they are 2 different beings... He was there... the oldest one. So unless the Doctor is the oldest one... Perhaps the hooded figure is the oldest one, and either has changed gender (not unheard of especially for a Gallifreyan) or there was someone else there in the shadows!

It might not be that Susan Twist herself is the Trickster, but the Trickster is almost certainly involved somewhere as the Tricksters theme from Sarah Jane Adventures was heard in the Devils Chord

What fascinates me is that we have all these previews, teasers and theories about Susan Twist’s character front, right and center, and yet it’s called “the legend of Ruby Sunday”, implying that it’s Ruby who will somehow play the central role in the episode or at least in it’s resolution. Had Ruby even appeared in any promo for this one? Certainly not in any noticeable fashion

It’s also the thing that the pantheon of discord isn’t the same as the toy make’s pantheon. The pantheon of discord is specifically the trickster’s and his brigade (think the time beetle from turn left). The toy make’s pantheon seems to be made up of his kids, with maestro being one of them. It’s also the thing that the doctor knew of the pantheon of discord before meeting the trickster, but he didn’t know of the toy maker’s pantheon until the toy maker told him. Furthermore the toy maker’s pantheon was lock away until the toy maker was released into the world and defeated, maestro even says so.

Maybe more than one theory is correct. For example i get the feeling Susan Twist is Susan Foreman who is also Rubys mother

pfft no... Susan Foreman married someone with the last name flood and now lives next to Ruby :) edit: the trickster however, as of a plot leaked from the finaly of the sarah jane adventures that never happened is a part of Ruby, as he was supposed to be a part of Sky in the sarah jane adventures, he's like a parasite, sapping out the paradox surrounding Ruby until he emerges from her, Ruby's mother bargained her life to the trickster in exchange for her daughter to be a time bomb delivered to the doctor

My theory based on the 5 episodes RTD mentioned to watch. This helped put in a lot of context and lore. “Spearhead from Space Features the Nestene Consciousness” and “The Bells of Saint John” features the Great Intelligence. These are gods knows as the Great Old Ones, A Pantheon of Gods who originate from “Ancestral Universes” created before the current one. The Pantheon of Discord is a lesser known subgroup derived from the Great Old Ones. The toymaker mentions to the Doctor “A Pantheon within a Pantheon” during “the Giggle”. So far the Story is that during “Wild Blue Yonder” the doctor interfered with the unknown which he regrets instantly. Opening up the Possibilities of the Impossible which released the Pantheon of Discord into the Year 1925. Giving them Plenty of time to plan shown during the Giggle from the Toymaster and Maestro Destroying Earth in the Alternate timeline. The Toymaster also has a Sister, Hecuba. Queen of Time, has the ability to manipulate time and control the tardis. She also loves to play games with toys. During the season we hear the tardis “groaning”. The doctor unsure what this is. During “Parting of the Ways” we see rose absorb time and space and briefly control it to her wants. I believe that she tries to control the tardis as we see the tardis getting scanned in the trailer. Also could be the reason they’re using a bike to get across London. A Time window is also known to be in the next episode. During this Season we see Ruby manipulating time around her, making slight or major changes, creating Time Mirages when she’s emotional and it always connects to the Day she was abandoned on “The Church of Ruby Road”. Furthermore, During Space babies we see the memory again, but the Mother has changed time during that memory to warn off the doctor. Reassuring that she is Hecuba. I also believe that Hecuba is the One Who Waits, During “The Devils Chord” we hear Maestro mention that this power can only belong to the old ones, then becomes terrified to meddle in their affairs. Susan Twist I feel has played and lost to Hecuba, become her toy and been cast through time to watch Ruby. As during “The Giggle” the Toymaster Mentions the one who waits and ran as that’s someone else’s game. And finally onto “A Good Man Goes To War”. 1 phrase. “Demons Run when a good man goes to war” this episode shows how far the Doctor will go to protect his friends.

One theory not mentioned in the text is that Susan Twist is a reincarnation of Romana, a Time Lady and former companion of the Doctor. Romana is a character from the classic 'Doctor Who' episodes and has a close connection to the Doctor. She has the ability to regenerate, just like the Doctor, which means she could have taken on a new form and identity as Susan Twist. This would explain her numerous appearances throughout time and space, as well as her apparent deep connection to the central events of the series. Several elements support this theory: Reincarnation Motif: Romana has already undergone regenerations before, so it would be consistent with her character to reappear in a new form. Time Lady's Knowledge: Susan Twist's character demonstrates a deep understanding of time and technology, which would align well with Romana's background as a Time Lady. Relation to the Doctor: If Susan Twist is Romana, it could explain her repeated appearances and indirect influence on the Doctor's missions and decisions. This theory could add an exciting layer of complexity and nostalgia to the series by reintroducing a beloved character from the classic episodes, while also tying new and old stories together.

Now we know, i think, why the Tardis was "hitting" the walls of the time vortex in every episodes opening titles screen. It was because it wanted to get rid of Sutekh, the god of death. Sutekh grabbed on to Tardis and the Tardis was trying to get rid of him, but the Doctor didn't notice any of this because of many reasons of which i believe it was the chameleon camouflage or whatever. Remember that we saw something similar in one of the David Tennant's era Doctor Who episodes where Captain Jack Harkness (who was made a "god" by Rose Tyler) grabbed onto the Tardis and flew to the end of time. What i am trying to say is that the Tardis tried to get rid of Jack too, but couldn't. Of course this time we have to do with the god of death, unlike Jack who was and still is a good hearted man. :) And by the way, why isn't this man here helping? o.O He IS supposed to have been an unkillable man for god knows how many eons. We know he turns from human form to that head creature called " The face of Bo ". :) Someone please tell BBC or whoever to bring this man back, earth needs him...WE need him. :) I would LOOOOOOVE to see Sutekh trying to kill Jack. XD Remember that it was Jack that was locked in a room full of radiation and didn't feel a god damn thing. Got shot and just wiped it out like it was nothing.

Here straight after the episode. Ending was crazy

I think she's both Susan Foreman and Ruby's mother, making Ruby the Doctor's great-granddaughter.

I prefer the combination of Susan twist being the doctors child / susans mom, and that shes Ruby's mom. So making ruby the first incarnation of susan. They keep teasing Ruby dying what if it actually happens and she regenerates. Maybe not after the first regeneration but later on she could regenerate into a young child again and be left with the 1st doctor to raise as his granddaughter

While watching the image of Susan Twist under the Triad logo it occurred to me that she looks very like Kate O Mara did as The Rani. If she is The Rani it would explain her appearing at different time periods since she is a Timelord. 73 yards left unanswered questions. One was how old Ruby travelled in time. Could the finale two parter answer some of these questions?

Calling it now... Trickster, with Susan Triad enabling the Trickster through commercialising time travel, something that would sow untold chaos and thus grant the Trickster immeasurable power. Due to the unfortunate passing of Elisabeth Sladen, the Trickster's final plotline was never brought to fruition, and that's likely something RTD has wanted to correct in some way for a long time. The Big Bad NOT being a returning Doctor Who villain as stated by RTD rules out Sutekh, however, the Trickster has never appeared in the mainline series, and would be more than powerful enough to warrant being a series-ending villain. Logically speaking, having the first series tie up loose SJA plot threads, and bring another member of the Pantheon of Discord into the main show would make the most sense, especially if your previous episodes have already featured previous members.

Susan Twist character is Jenny the doctors daughter she is trying to impress her dad but messing up.The Triad is not the enemy but the 14th ,15th doctor and his clone daughter Jenny. Jenny could be being used by the true villain. As a bonus if you use the same logic for the creation of the name River Song to Ruby Sunday you get Rosy Resurection a possible Connection to Rose Tyler.

Not saying I buy into any of these, but I've also heard: 1. Susan Twist is the Meddling Monk. 2. Susan Twist worked for UNIT in 3's era, got access to the TARDIS while 3 was trying to recover it's secrets, and worked out enough of the tech herself to found her own tech company. 3. Susan Twist is Clara, scattered across the Doctor's timeline.

I won’t say who it is, because it’s a brilliant reveal, but one of your predictions was right. This episode is a blast.

You forgot to mention the song Ruby sang when Maestro had her, is the same/similar theme that Trickster had in TSJA.

Susan Forman doesn’t have to be Susan Triad, but what If she is a Susan Twist variant, Maybe the doctor will meet with his Grand Daughter after a long time apart and it turns out that she is A Susan twist variant in a similar way to Clara’s echos, not only would it be a connection to classic who, it would show how long this ancient evil has been trying to enter the universe (since the 1st doctor settled on Earth)

Your theory about Sue tech was spot on, but only 50/50? The 'tardis' anagram was so obvious, that it was discounted right at the beginning of the episode, although the Tardis was sickly due to Sutekh wrapping himself around it. Can't wait for the finale!

I'm kind of surprised you didn't mention Missy/The Master. That would make the most sense at least to me.

There is a small clip on KZfaq where the Doctor display all Susan Twists Faces from earlier episodes including this cyborg and horn version of Susan with the pyramids at the background, so that won't likely be her "final villain form" or Sutekh

The first appearance of Susan Twist is right after Donna throws coffee at the console, so it might be linked to the TARIDS thorugh that event. And the "indigestion" remark not as much of a joke.

Sutekh the Destroyer; Last of the Osirians Home world: Phaester Osiris Met the 4th Doctor

I think the Susan Twist character is some entity from beyond the edge of the universe, invited into our universe the same way that the Celestial Toymaker was when the Doctor did whatever he did in Wild Blue Yonder. I'm guessing this entity looks like she does because the Doctor and Donna had just caused some kind of paradox by starting that whole "mavity" thing, and whatever entity that crossed over has somehow been strengthening itself by feeding on that paradox, and Mrs. Merridew's face keeps reappearing for that reason. I'm hoping that part of defeating this enemy will include fixing this paradox so that we start using "gravity" again.

Not sure how this fits into anything, but we keep hearing about the BOSS in the new season. A while back RTD mentioned that the plot had something to do with the 3rd doctors era. The 3rd doctor had a story arc in the classic series that involved a super computer called BOSS. coincidence?!?! Probably, but something to think about. 😊

Not sure about the Sutekh theory. He was aged to death in the pyramid of Mars and he's a powerful alien posing as a god, not actually a deity. But if I'm wrong then shows what I know. Edit: Seems like I don't know what I was talking about after all. Oh well.

Ellie.... I'm scared of your powers of prediction

Just watched the new episode, that cliffhanger knocked me out.

Wait... could Ruby Sunday be (a future incarnation of) The Doctor? And the hooded figure who dropped The Doctor off was The Doctor? Or could the hooded figure be Ruby's mother... Melody Pond! (aka) River Song? Think about it, she became pregnant with her husband, but never told him. Personally I'm hoping for "None of the Above", I like to be (reasonably) surprised. As always, thank you all so very much for the videos. Could Ruby be The Doctor's sister?

Not sure who Susan Twist will end up being, but The Doctor will end up being a child of the pantheon. The pantheon alter reality and cause chaos. Sometime in the past they decided to give chaos a physical form, so they created a child, imbued it with their power a dropped it into the universe. But the child forgot why it was their. Tecteun found her, experimented on her and gained a portion of the patheon's power. Specifically the portion that makes them virtually immortal/timeless. Eventhough the child had forgotten its purpose to cause chaos it is still drawn to it. That's why The Doctor always pops up when crazy stuff is going on. He is drawn to disaster/conflict/chaos, but instead of causing it he fights against it. When he reaches his penultimate form (again) as the Valiyard, he will embrace his chaotic nature and start causing true chaos throughout the galaxy. At that time we'll get a spin off with a group of companions working along side The Master/Missy and River Song chasing the Valiyard through time and space to stop him from destroying everthing and get their friend back by forcing his "last"regeneration.

I can’t believe it just watched the episode after seeing this video and umm wasn’t expecting that

My brain has turned to mush from all the theories I've gone through these past few months. Susan, Rani, Mrs.Flood's identity, Ruby possibly dropping herself off at the church.. now to the idea of the Doctor being the father/creator or just unknowingly being a part of the Whoniverse's pantheon of Gods (somehow tying in the timeless child arc), "the beast" from Satan's pit, Ruby becoming a god, Ibrahim coincidence, etc. At this point, Jenny or River could be Ruby's biological mother, making her the Doctor's daughter or granddaughter, and I wouldn't be surprised 😩 I give up. Honestly, all I want to know is whose red painted nails picked up that tooth.

I have a different theory but linking to the trickster. I believe Susan twists characters are pawns of the trickster and he's using her to cause chaos throughout time by placing her at different points where the doctor shows up

Who is mrs flood and who is the person mistro said may have put a song inside ruby? Who is the one who waits ?

Looking back after part 1, I LOVE how on the right track you were!

I think Susan twist will be a deamon (from the 3rd doctor story the deamons) Russell said that something is buried under unit tower and it connects to something to do with the 3rd doctor, maybe ruby is a god.

I hope you guys watched Doctor Who's scene they released.

The Doctor mentioned the Rani early on in this series so perhaps Susan Twist is a new regeneration of the that character?!

I feel like Susan isn’t a big bad, simply someone who saw an opportunity to make money from time-travelling technology that was left from the 3rd doctor. From this, she didn’t know how to properly use it, which led to her being split so many ways accros time. There feels like there needs to be loads more to the stories though, so I’m guessing that another consequence of Susan’s actions is that a big bad took advantage of the situation. Just a guess though.

I can't wait to find out how everything ties together. I've been having Sutekh, Susan Twist, Susan Foreman theory dreams for days. 😂 Love to see my favourite rating system bac. I give this video 10/10 Malcolms. 💜

Am i tyhe first one here after HE RETURNED????? SUCH AN AMAZING EPISODE I CANNOT WAIT FOR NEXT WEEK!!!!!

She is the Moxx of Balhoon . No reason just sounds good.

Having just watched the episode, wow. Can't wait to see your reaction.

I think Mrs Flood could be linked to River Song. Melanie Pond > River Song > Mrs Flood. All water-themed!