Why Manor Lords Beat All Odds and Defied the AAA Studios

  Рет қаралды 28,248

Andy's Take

Andy's Take

Ай бұрын

Manor Lords has beaten all expectations and become the highest concurrently played city-builder on Steam of all time, and it did so pretty much within its first 24 hours of release. Manor Lords received 3 million wishlists on Steam and must have sold in the hundreds of thousands, all despite being mostly developed by one person, and being this person's first game. In other words, Manor Lords has surpassed the initial sales and player numbers of most if not largely all major AAA strategy game studios out there, which is an insanely impressive accomplishment.
But what lead to this triumph, and how was it made possible? How did Manor Lords come out of seemingly nowhere and rival or even surpass the AAA games with established and loyal audiences and fanbases?
I think it's because of Manor Lords' dedication to authenticity, freedom, player choice and last but not least, to history itself, aspects which many studios seem to forget about or prioritize less. Manor Lords follows in many ways in the footsteps of other accomplished and celebrated indie history or history-like titles, like Kingdom Come Deliverance or Mount and Blade Bannerlord, all games developed by indie studios, and all games doing incredibly well, especially relatively speaking. I think AAA studios need to be more open with their audiences, open their lines of communication, and understand what the players want, because so many of them seem to have no idea, despite players everywhere screaming at the top of their lungs for change, and being very specific about it.
But what do you think? Why did Manor Lords succeed, and can its success continue? And what of the AAA studios? Let me know in the comments, and don't forget to leave a like and subscribe to the channel!
#manorlords #manorlordsvsaaa #manorlordsvstotalwar

Пікірлер: 241
@dmitriyvasilyev6408
@dmitriyvasilyev6408 Ай бұрын
Devs used to make games that they would want to play themselves. That's the most important thing in gaming craftsmanship.
@disgoyknows88
@disgoyknows88 Ай бұрын
It's something I've noticed as well. 90% of studios are in it for the cashgrab, while a one man dev team is just in it for the passion.
@jzerf5329
@jzerf5329 Ай бұрын
To be somewhat fair to the cashgrab folks, they gotta eat too. When I was learning basic coding I made a 2D game where a turtle moved around eating balls that would appear on screen. Call it "Son of snake: reptiles together", and you get the idea. It was fun to make, and was a decent time waster better than some mobile games out there (though that's probably my own bias) Wouldn't have made me a dime. I'm just saying there is a balance, and I don't blame them for trying to find the formula of fun games to steady income.
@macobuzi
@macobuzi Ай бұрын
@UngaBungaBrain I agree. In AAA studios it is 100% of the CEO's decision of how the game looks like to maximize their profit, even rushing the devs to release unfinished products or forcing them to implement the ugly way to finish it, which led to many beautiful graphic but soulless games we have nowadays.
@backuptokeshav
@backuptokeshav 23 күн бұрын
@@disgoyknows88 easy to talk all this passion and cashgrab stuff , those devs gotta make money too
@disgoyknows88
@disgoyknows88 23 күн бұрын
@backuptokeshav 🥾 😋 If you're doing it for the sake of making money then your game will more likely be trash
@sanvean4601
@sanvean4601 Ай бұрын
The truth about gaming industry or all industry is that each company is started by enthusiasts, then it is being taken over by businessmen and it ends its lifetime with lawyers behind the wheel. The creators of titles like Manor Lords or Songs of Syx see the player base as people whereas for example CA or Blizzard take us for an excel table. Great vid and comment Andy, thx!
@FuckoffgoogleGetDoxxed
@FuckoffgoogleGetDoxxed Ай бұрын
Its not exactly always the case, you have to realise that only a company with a monopoly can enforce its consumer unfriendly practices wich is deff the case for blizzard and CA. There is also a big void in the market regarding RTS games wich is why the hype for this game was what made it skyrocket. The same story goes for Baldurs gate where people want a new rpg game that caters to the old formula and enjoyment. One could even argue that it is inevitable for a company to turn into blizzard or ca because of their size considering investors and market shares. Then comes along a bobby and takes all the money and enforce anti consumer practices.
@AndysTake
@AndysTake Ай бұрын
Thank you, my friend! Blizzard is especially egregious here, I don’t think CA can be categorized in the same ballpark, and even then, it’s definitely the managers and as you say, “businessmen” who are at fault, not the devs who work hard to bring out the games they make and can be proud of with harsh deadlines and ancient tech they’re not allowed to spend time and money on to update and fix. It’s tough, man.
@sanher20
@sanher20 28 күн бұрын
Exactly, making a video game is a creative process and as such it's an art, it's like writing a book or making a movie. Since video games are such a new development, businessmen don't understand this concept and what ends up happening is that they destroy the whole creative process. When businessmen get involved in a video game they only see video games as an opportunity to make easy money without having any clue of why people would pay to play video games in the first place.
@pittsburghpirateshat8950
@pittsburghpirateshat8950 Ай бұрын
You know why it beat the odds? Even though it wasn’t what a lot of total war players like myself would’ve wanted out of a medieval 3, it’s still a very fun game. The graphics for the type of game it is are great. You can tell that the dev put a lot of love into it. It doesn’t feel like a corporate soulless yearly release, it feels like a game the devs would play themselves. It feels like a game made before the video game industry got consumed by greed. Hopefully CA learns from this game’s success and actually tries to do what works in their next game.
@AndysTake
@AndysTake Ай бұрын
Agreed!
@josephpe90
@josephpe90 Ай бұрын
“Corporate soulless yearly release” THATS the problem with AAA studios. It’s all about quantity but not quality. I’m so sick of it. Reason why this game it’s so refreshing because there’s no much love and attention to detail poured into it
@po-cf1ut
@po-cf1ut Ай бұрын
I don't have a powerful laptop and this game runs, in EA, so flawlessly and bug free. The performance alone helps with the immersion. I've been really impressed.
@AndysTake
@AndysTake Ай бұрын
Indeed performance is so crucial
@Crosis89
@Crosis89 Ай бұрын
I wish I had the same experience man :) I crash very often ( almost refunded it that's how bad it was on ultra, still not great on high (. No idea why, laptop has a 3070 and the drivers are upto date. )
@_RandomPea
@_RandomPea Ай бұрын
What's your laptop, must be at least min specs. Mine isn't and it really shows lol 😂
@Scrim71
@Scrim71 Ай бұрын
@@Crosis89 My laptop struggled so i stream it on Geforce now. runs superb
@po-cf1ut
@po-cf1ut Ай бұрын
@@_RandomPea I bought it in 2016 - i7-6700HQ, 16 GB RAM, 1 TB Plus 256 GB Storage, 4 GB NVIDIA GTX980
@Spot-0n
@Spot-0n Ай бұрын
I really hope Greg (the single dev) will use some of the 40+ Millions of dollars he made to bring this title to the next level. The only thing missing, tbh is the scale. If this game gives us a huge map, with castles and level 4 or 5 buildings and siege weapons with several factions, this game will be everything.
@ErnestIsGaming
@ErnestIsGaming Ай бұрын
Time for him to make a new game called empire lords
@elijahbill9148
@elijahbill9148 Ай бұрын
Scale (walls, defences, forts etc) diplomacy with other lords on the map (also having the lords actively building their town on the map), mods and online. Then we set 🫡
@takecarestudios
@takecarestudios Ай бұрын
This :D
@ThinkPositiveDude
@ThinkPositiveDude Ай бұрын
I wouldn’t doubt it if he decides to sell the ip to Tencent in the near future
@elijahbill9148
@elijahbill9148 Ай бұрын
@@ThinkPositiveDudeplease god no
@BadgerMushroom2
@BadgerMushroom2 Ай бұрын
It’s also great seeing the entire community backing the fact that this ONE developer created something that’s making BANK. MAYBE THEY WILL SEE HOW WELL THIS GAME DOES AND FINALLY STOP GIVING US 1/4 GAMES.
@luttren
@luttren Ай бұрын
It really isn’t just one developer. Several things have been outsourced to other groups of developers
@whatx11
@whatx11 Ай бұрын
havnt been this inmersed in a game for atleast 10 years
@AndysTake
@AndysTake Ай бұрын
The hours literally fly by
@ShooterMcGurk
@ShooterMcGurk 23 күн бұрын
The other day I found myself watching KZfaq videos about medieval crop rotation 😂
@DrGrotesk
@DrGrotesk Ай бұрын
Totally agree, games like Manor Lords only can be done with passion, not with the intend to please the stakeholders.
@slothsarecool
@slothsarecool Ай бұрын
This seems like a reasonable outcome for 7 years of solo dev IMO, he certainly did a good job, but the fact massive studios put out even less just seems dysfunctional
@thegreatdodo5092
@thegreatdodo5092 Ай бұрын
I mean just take this: Every soldier you have, is literally the most important resource you can have, not ONLY because hes a soldier, but he's also your hunter, your woodcutter, your cobbler, your smithy, your forager, etc. This game is a new evolution of both city building, because of the free semi-procedual placement of buildings, and a new evolution of strategy games as well, as population IS the key ressource for battles. Thats why so many mods for Medieval 2 implement a population based recruiting system. When such high stakes are in place, you'll care for what you do, and if everything is so tightly and nicely intermixing, it is just mindblowingly fun and engaging.
@TiGGowich
@TiGGowich Ай бұрын
It's crazy to think that a company like CA cannot even make a game where the armor of units represents the types of materials you actually have access to... I know this was a thing in ME2 but my god am I missing the old Total War games.
@asneakychicken322
@asneakychicken322 Ай бұрын
I really miss the visual representation of the upgraded armour you give your men, from padded armour to chainmail to plate, and can see it in battles on whatever units have it, even if it’s just your basic spearmen units. Seeing that again in Manor Lords, where you can see your men kitted out with metal helmets, chainmail etc. in battle and knowing the effort it took to make the stuff from scratch, really satisfying
@nunosilvacycling6769
@nunosilvacycling6769 Ай бұрын
As i got older i spent time playing videl games less and less but now with this one, it ignated again the passion in me
@ArishVanNikon
@ArishVanNikon Ай бұрын
The music in this game.... 👌👌
@selecks6462
@selecks6462 Ай бұрын
I have never worry as much as I do in manor Lords about the little guy, my foot soldiers. I hire mercenaries to be the frontline because my little guy have actual value
@filipsalamon
@filipsalamon Ай бұрын
Perfectly said, there is just not enought historical games. Every second citybuilder is a viking one or another grid shittygraphic looking version of banished... there are so many more interesting periods and not enought games. Manor Lords gave us something new and unique and for EA it's incredible value. Final release with mods will be absolutely amazing.
@mickeymouse-xr9gy
@mickeymouse-xr9gy Ай бұрын
MN is essentially a slower version of Age of Empires rather than Total War
@globo5743
@globo5743 Ай бұрын
Finally, someone rational
@theburden9920
@theburden9920 Күн бұрын
Whats MN?
@user-om2wm4hi5r
@user-om2wm4hi5r Ай бұрын
CA - we must create game for casual player and by this way we will sold more copies some dude - hmm, i just wanna create game about medieval city
@user-yn5td4kn9c
@user-yn5td4kn9c Ай бұрын
0ad kept me alive the past few years
@sanher20
@sanher20 28 күн бұрын
The reason is actually very simple, creating a video games is a creative process, it's an art. The problem is that AAA companies are run by businessmen that don't understand this concept who only see videogames as an opportunity to make more money, so what ends up happening is that when a greedy businessman funds a video game, from the beginning the intention of the development is to make money and in summary they end up destroying the creative process and creating a bad game. People can notice very easily when a game is created with the intention of making money rather than actually making a good beautiful game.
@HypaxBE
@HypaxBE Ай бұрын
Don't forget, we recently also have a party ... Ubisoft .... that claims to build AAAA games. They are serious about it at Ubisoft. I find it seriously hilarious, that they are so out of touch with what they are competing with.
@Falcon-dq4ye
@Falcon-dq4ye Ай бұрын
Yeah they should shovel their 'AAAA' games in their fifth A.. 🤣
@FutaCatto2
@FutaCatto2 Ай бұрын
Skull and Bones was both developed by Ubisoft Singapore and funded by the government. As someone who is staying in Singapore as a local, let me clarify to everyone that most people here see video games as a hobby for children. There is zero passion for gaming. The culture here revolves around study, work, money, happy.
@anthonyhampton2991
@anthonyhampton2991 Ай бұрын
Gonna finally play this tonight can’t wait
@bradjarman8721
@bradjarman8721 Ай бұрын
Though I've only managed to sit down and play Manor Lords for a couple hours. I've been loving it. I loved games like Anno, Banished, Timberland and the like along with being a massive CK3 player and a former lover of Total War games. Manor Lords has been a massive breath of fresh air despite being an incomplete game. I'm excited for what else is to come!
@starzgarden5553
@starzgarden5553 Ай бұрын
I think this game is riding on the wave of anti AAA sentiment. It’s symbolic of what gamers really want, rather than being the actual game they want. It is a message to the gaming industry that gamers are fed up and they want to see change. Outside of this context, I don’t think it would be as hyped as it is, nor do I think the game is as good as the hype suggests.
@ashamahee
@ashamahee Ай бұрын
the game is great though, especially as a simulator. The games that had this kind of simulation were the likes of Settlers 3 and perhaps some of the older Anno titles. The combat is good and impactful. The game is not only popular because of anti AAA sentiment, it is more than capable of standing on its own feet.
@FuckoffgoogleGetDoxxed
@FuckoffgoogleGetDoxxed Ай бұрын
Totally agree, if you want the best city builder you should play songs of syx. Also made by one guy btw. Its more like its a tech demo of what can be achieved thats how i view it. One person can make a beatifull game like this then that sends a message to the industry wich people subconsciously know but cant tell you. In terms of gameplay it is very simple in scope wich you can see from the upper bracket limit of having around 1-2k villagers. There is no world map just a single map with about 8 grids. The supply chains are simple and ultimately dont support a large empire wich is tied to its engine. Also half the fun of many city builders was the exponential growth you can achieve and the limit of one's empire being dedication and expansion. There are no walls to speak of with just now having collision added. I think it is deff overhyped and once you realise the limit of your empire you will feel disappointed and leave the game because you know what the end really is. Map generation is also almost void it is the same itteration of the map placing slightly different grid sectors sometimes not even that. It will be a fun game after a year perhaps when there are more functions and lategame options.
@Pilps
@Pilps Ай бұрын
i totally agree
@binbows2258
@binbows2258 Ай бұрын
@@ashamahee the combat is not as good as total war, and i'm mostly into the game for the citybuilding. I like the combat for how it's actually levy based, how losses have a direct effect on the population and thus the city you are building. It is an auxiliary to the town management, a means to the end of building more.
@ashamahee
@ashamahee Ай бұрын
@@binbows2258 yeah but then again as you mention its a city builder with combat added to it so for that and how it directly affects the economy is really nice. Besides total war has gone badly down hill real fast the last decade.
@argo7353
@argo7353 Ай бұрын
This is a wonderful game; Especially considering its production journey. Very immersive, I’m losing multiple hours of my day in what feels like the blink of an eye watching the world go by in my growing settlements. Crazy to think it’s still early access, and there’s a bunch more content and updates to come. Huge congrats to the developer; deserves all the praise for ( inadvertently I’m sure ) “ sticking it “ to the AAA companies of more recent times. Now I’m off to play some more! It’s harvest time!
@backfischritter
@backfischritter Ай бұрын
You nailed it with this video! Totally agreed!
@notificare.
@notificare. 24 күн бұрын
I just think everyone who s playing this game finds Something nostalgic here regarding old games played in the past: AOE , knights and merchants , pharaoh , CIV or banished or bannerlords. And the rethoric with one single Dev doing this is also helping in the ecuation of sales. IT s in the early and i am sure that the moders will bring in this game all the flavours of the titles mentioned above.
@ThaoDo-hb3wl
@ThaoDo-hb3wl Ай бұрын
I can't get enough sleep after playing this game
@huantruonginh2946
@huantruonginh2946 Ай бұрын
At this point all AAA studios should fire all of their staffs but one person and use all that salary to develop the actual game instead..fair enough huh.
@byronbuonamici3160
@byronbuonamici3160 Ай бұрын
I think it's mostly because people really want a city builder with a purpose. It's a complex city builder, but you actually have a nice customizable and immersive battle aspect. No other game makes both aspects this complex. It's one facet or the other (battle focus or city focus). If someone came up with a civ 4x that had total war battles, that game would crush. The last game that did it this well was stronghold and that wasn't nearly as good looking or complex. AAA studios can do multifaceted games but choose not to.
@Hjorth87
@Hjorth87 Ай бұрын
Love it so far. But there is definitely a bit of a learning curve. My main town is doing well apart from a firewood shortage I can't seem to shake, and I have no idea whether my food supply chain is sustainable. They have survived so far, though. I'm a bit more fearful for my new region where I forgot it was November when I sent my settlers in....
@markkrejic8736
@markkrejic8736 Ай бұрын
This is incredible 😎 one dev kick ass
@SizzleCorndog
@SizzleCorndog Ай бұрын
The reason this game did so well is almost explicitly because it was developed by one person for 3+ years. When you start getting larger studios it gets harder to effectively coordinate what everyone is doing which is one of the reasons older games felt so much more cohesive and like they had an actual message. This has nothing to do with "respecting their players" (which isn't to say that to don't, the dev and the publisher have been very active in the community) it just comes down to simply having a cohesive design philosophy and direction to the point where the developer will shoot down ideas and clap back at the community for either ideas that he thinks are contrary to the idea of the game or for cheese builds like the current trade "meta" that a lot of people are using to side step the core mechanics of the game
@danieldpa8484
@danieldpa8484 Ай бұрын
Congratulations to my fellow Polish countryman who did this! Top job! Now let’s make a mode which allows the player to beat Teutonic order and later march on to Moscow! 🇵🇱💪💪💪
@HermanBogaers
@HermanBogaers Ай бұрын
Love plaiyng this game. Already 30 hrs playtime. Not I have seen one battle. But I think genaraly people like the battles ocured in history, aftter that architecture and then the way people lived in those days. This game covers it all. Hope it stays like this. Though the buildings aren't that impressive yet I hope. They are impressivly detailed though.
@1norselad
@1norselad Ай бұрын
Ive enjoyed what ive played so far haven’t spent hours on it yet as have a newborn and it isnt the kind of game you can play half heartedly but its fun looks cool and is reasonably polished for early access. Lots to expand on and if and when the modders get there hands on it then it will be next level
@iamkyle8680
@iamkyle8680 Ай бұрын
🎉 Congrats on your noob, fellow gamer Dad 🎉
@danschmidt6206
@danschmidt6206 Ай бұрын
It works really well managing my 1 month old. Not only can I play one-handed (baby in the other hand bundled and falling asleep), but there's the all-important pause button.
@1norselad
@1norselad Ай бұрын
@@danschmidt6206 oh yeah it isnt impossible but ive waited for this game for so long i want a real session to concentrate and actually learn the game. Like i said its great so far!
@fizzlepop5318
@fizzlepop5318 Ай бұрын
Before Manor Lords, I played a lot of Farthest Frontier. Manor Lords adds more advanced combat, but honestly, Farthest Frontier does most everything else better.
@christopherjohnferrer3771
@christopherjohnferrer3771 Ай бұрын
I just want a feudal Japan manor lord. I like customizing samurais like in For Honor. Kenseis are so badass including Shinobis.
@MuhammedWaleed-qb6fq
@MuhammedWaleed-qb6fq 28 күн бұрын
Hi andy i am your big fan bz of you i start playing total war my first one wS total war rome 2 thank you so much
@caddycheon
@caddycheon Ай бұрын
Medieval 2 Remaster will be sooner than I expected
@randomasian1830
@randomasian1830 Ай бұрын
The developer himself has said multiple times that he doesn't want the game to be a competitor to 'Total War.' But as is often the case, there are still people who hold this opinion, even though he never said it and has denied it multiple times...
@53strat55
@53strat55 Ай бұрын
@Mm-du2lt Lmao, this is anything but an age of empire competitor. Those are totally different types of RTS, the combat is close to total war due its mechanics and the city building aspect is the bread and butter. You can compare that with other city sims.
@FuckoffgoogleGetDoxxed
@FuckoffgoogleGetDoxxed Ай бұрын
Its more like Anno with a better fleshed out combat system. Total war is on a different scale entirely wich one could say is city state management minus the actual improvement of one's city planning.
@53strat55
@53strat55 Ай бұрын
@Mm-du2lt I said the combat, I did not say the city building is similar :)
@erisahmetaj6233
@erisahmetaj6233 Ай бұрын
We've been playing with bugs around for so long that it became part of our gaming habit. 😅 Playing this feels so different.
@mememachine6022
@mememachine6022 Ай бұрын
Massive L showing Victoria 3
@moto3463
@moto3463 Ай бұрын
I really hope Greg updates the game and make it the best game ever made.
@JustAnotherAlex3D
@JustAnotherAlex3D Ай бұрын
Its like the game banished but improved by a multitude of ways , I hope they add fishing like banished has
@CoachJure
@CoachJure Ай бұрын
On discord it was said fishing and more will be added.
@BAD7667
@BAD7667 Ай бұрын
Ah yes, the Civilization games, known for their ultra realistic visuals until Civ 6 decided to go for a more cartoon look. The games before it never had a stylized visual look to them.
@jaspermooren5883
@jaspermooren5883 Ай бұрын
I think the real reason is that its promise is actually quite small, and therefore the expectation is. And it has a relatively small price tag that comes with that. And with a project that is mostly run by 1 person you don't need to make a lot of money to actually make a lot of money. If this games make a million dollars, that's a ton of money. If a tripple AAA game makes a million dollars, that would be a massive loss and a total flop. You can't pay 1000 people for 6 months with a million dollars, you can pay 1 person for 7 years with a million dollars, and it's quite a high pay at that. It's a cheap game that delivers a small experience, but it delivers that experience really well. And people are really into anti-corperate passion projects right now, since corporate products at least seem to become more corporate by the day. That doesn't mean it is from an objective standpoint a great game, what makes it great is it's price tag and story behind it. And the fact that it doesn't have to find alternative ways to make money. Since there is absolutely no way to make your money back (let alone a healthy profit) when you make a AAA game with just a $60 pricetag and no other ways to make money. You'd have to find half the world to buy your game, and the market is far to saturated for that to happen.
@jollygreen4662
@jollygreen4662 Ай бұрын
Refreshing as a paid demo. Can't. Wait for the updates
@davidareeves
@davidareeves Ай бұрын
Game development industry now is just like Disney and movie making. A giant spreadsheet with what sells the most for each group. So tell me Disney hows that working for ya. All the older games creation teams became big development over time by making games that they wanted to play and what people wanted, say Blizzard and Diablo. Then they became a big shareholder group and no essence of their former selves. Good to see there are people out there like Greg that don't listen to all the "key" BS that marketing teams spin at big publishers, and just get down to making a game we wanna play. Guess who won and so he should. As the team grows as Slavoci Magic, I hope they keep making great games and expand on what was done in the first place, and also Hooded Horse backing their vision without demanding change of direction because X game is the IN THING
@starzgarden5553
@starzgarden5553 Ай бұрын
Monetisation kills gameplay
@Ohanrahan
@Ohanrahan Ай бұрын
AAA+ devs have this weird idea that what worked 10+ years ago.. still works today, its like they believe its an infinite pool they can keep milking. However it doesnt work like that, people want to be suprised, and want a challenge. I think its a shame and a bit sad that nowadays they dont dare to challenge themself, let alone their playerbase by adding things... and i get it from their point of view : if it costs millions to make a game and adding a new fresh idea could potentially cost you millions then yes it wouldnt be easy, but sometimes right now i believe some devs arent even trying and thats a shame.
@jivkodjamiarov8508
@jivkodjamiarov8508 29 күн бұрын
Let's not forget about Knights Of Honor 2 :).
@AndysTake
@AndysTake 29 күн бұрын
Sadly didn’t sell well, to my great disappointment, so yeah we can forget about it in this case :(
@SimpleKowalski
@SimpleKowalski 19 күн бұрын
Another Polish Masterpiece.
@robskinnershow
@robskinnershow Ай бұрын
The bigger companies aren't interested in making good games, they are interested in monetizing the customer. Those two things aren't compatible with each other most of the time.
@tomaT_om
@tomaT_om Ай бұрын
Balls
@JboJackson
@JboJackson Ай бұрын
The game is good and what the dev did was amazing but its also far from complete and will probably take years to finish. You get about 1 or 2 campaigns out of it atm.
@Huntanor
@Huntanor Ай бұрын
This game is about zibes. Zibe games are about feeling what's trying to make you feel, not doing any specific thing. I wouldn't play a second campaign at all until my whole map felt like it was lived in.
@nihil-baxter
@nihil-baxter Ай бұрын
If it wouldn't crash like every 10 minutes, it would be the best game ever created.
@XquizitRush
@XquizitRush Ай бұрын
It does not crash. The problem is your pc. Upgrade your graphics drivers for a start.
@LizZard1988
@LizZard1988 Ай бұрын
what machine are you running the game on? Not many people are reporting game crashes. Had no crash in ~20 hours of gameplay
@DarthWeeder69
@DarthWeeder69 Ай бұрын
didn't crash once
@animuslite8809
@animuslite8809 Ай бұрын
Hasnt crashed once for me
@SpicyCreamy
@SpicyCreamy Ай бұрын
lol best game ever created, ok buddy
@bisse23
@bisse23 Ай бұрын
i love manorlords already and one thing i would say about total war i stopped playing somewhere after the napoleon and shogun 2 total wars its a sad development and bad decisions... but i do have a question anyone who knows what to do with a dead ox i dont know how to remove it it died cause town battle XD
@globo5743
@globo5743 Ай бұрын
This game shouldn't be compared to total war games or tw-like games. It should've always been seen as something older gamer dreamed of which was a next level or better Age of empire( which has it own fanbase greater or equal to tw so it not niche).
@carlfrederickbowers
@carlfrederickbowers Ай бұрын
totally agree
@user-yn5td4kn9c
@user-yn5td4kn9c 23 күн бұрын
manorlords to rule them all
@CoachJure
@CoachJure Ай бұрын
I just want crusader kings rog/dynasty/intrique + manor lords building and total war scale/battles. 🎉😂
@miorahmadsyukranbinrozaman7452
@miorahmadsyukranbinrozaman7452 Ай бұрын
Manor lord also destroyed fifefly studio, Manor lord shine like a star
@BYZANTINE_GR
@BYZANTINE_GR 26 күн бұрын
If only they add Europe’s map and some factions
@morgomi
@morgomi Ай бұрын
Are you kidding? Manor Lords is nothing but a hobby project. It's a “product” that took 7 years to develop and it's ridiculous to expect us gamers to like it. Why should we “customers” care that it was developed by one person? I don't get the hype. The game is completely empty after 8 hours, not to mention the bugs! And the guy is working alone! He needs at least 1 year to fix the bugs, let alone add new features! And he said that (in reddit) he had no roadmap and was not keen on making new hires for the developing process. In that case, I'm afraid that this game will need at least 4 more years to be truly “playable”, a deep strategy game worth spending time on. To be logical, I think it will stay forever in early access in this case. The game doesn't “kick” any AAA studios. Stronghold 3, which is very similar to this game, was sent to 7 levels of hell with criticism when it came out and still hasn't come out. Even though it is a much richer game in terms of content. Stronghold 3 was also developed by a very small team, but as a customer, no one cared how a “product” they paid for came out: and rightly so. We live in very strange times! This behavior will only encourage new developers to make even more “early acess” empty games.
@BiPolar417
@BiPolar417 Ай бұрын
Atlast a city builder to knock the great Banished game off of the top.
@mowtow90
@mowtow90 29 күн бұрын
Manor Lords works because its a passion project of 1 man. The guy is making the game he wants to play. This is how games used to be made when they ware owned by the studios , not the publishers. The big AAA games are made by the financial and marketing deparment of the publisher , not the dev studios. The devs have 0 say in those games. The marketing department gives a list of features that they want and the financial tells you where to cut. This is why AAA games are sold in pieces , released first and fixed later , deprived of any emersion ext. This is why CA failed miserably with Pharaoh. Because it was not a new game "Bronze age TW" but a half baked reused stuff from Troy made cheap. That is what it is. This is why the market is flooded with "Battle royals, co-ups and RGPs" , because those are easly monitized and why RTS is pretty much abandoned by the big AAAs.
@mariogaeta8911
@mariogaeta8911 Ай бұрын
This is why I’m back to Shogun 2
@Georgy_47
@Georgy_47 Ай бұрын
best game ever...
@YzzSC
@YzzSC Ай бұрын
One big reason is because that no AAA games are being made in this genre? Not for real though? Would love it if someone named one that could be for real considered AAA and not just made by some minor studio owned by a giant.
@Huntanor
@Huntanor Ай бұрын
AAA companies make high market pressure games with maximum consumer access. These games are too niche. This game might convince someone to try, but the result will be a similar game that also tried to appeal to every gamer ever all at once
@JakeSoulFreeTravels
@JakeSoulFreeTravels Ай бұрын
I love it! I think it’s exactly what it should have been with features added later, the heart and passion shows and someone who doesn’t see that, then of course, they can go play some cold corporate game.
@reeeanonymous8399
@reeeanonymous8399 Ай бұрын
You can say whatever you want about why you bought this game, I just bought it out of pure spite for how the modern day big boy companies make their games and monetize it and treat their players simple as
@Cool_Night_King
@Cool_Night_King 28 күн бұрын
Manor Lords is not even close to a AAA game , even it's maker said it's nothing like them , it's its own thing.
@bajanbru
@bajanbru Ай бұрын
I feel like in the actual state of the game its more enjoyable playing it more like a city builder than a rts because its lacking a lot of political mechanics, like if the other king invade your territory and you dont have enough troops you just have to accept your fate
@MijnAfspeellijst1234
@MijnAfspeellijst1234 Ай бұрын
Oke real talk, manor lords has a lot of potential but in the current state the game has not a lot of replayability. Is it just me or is manor lords a bit over hyped
@Orendiz
@Orendiz Ай бұрын
Did you even read a least 1 negative review on steam for this game before making this video? Its unreal, at this point it feels like an AI generated channel lol.
@filipzietek5146
@filipzietek5146 Ай бұрын
Company of heroes 1 felt innovative and still looks good but the games stopped progressing including total war.
@liszarezo3658
@liszarezo3658 Ай бұрын
If only ont this unreal engine bug...
@boon6848
@boon6848 Ай бұрын
my only take is... fkin archers seems to be using plastic arrows lol. arent archers supposed to be deadly in medieval wars? 🤣
@riccardocappelletti9652
@riccardocappelletti9652 Ай бұрын
does this have a workshop ? Is it moddable ?
@cameroncrider6970
@cameroncrider6970 Ай бұрын
Not yet. It will come in the future. Probably 2 years until the workshop is released. It won’t stop people from making mods though.
@MasterK-hv4ws
@MasterK-hv4ws Ай бұрын
Most overhyped release since cyberpunk.
@frackinfamous6126
@frackinfamous6126 14 күн бұрын
I think it’s great
@stevemuzak8526
@stevemuzak8526 19 күн бұрын
This happens when game developer focus on making brilliant game and not on "diversity and inclusion" and BlackRock leaches. Great success! Legendary Polish Power is real.
@jorndebello7317
@jorndebello7317 Ай бұрын
I feel Oriental Empires is a way better replacement for the game civilization. It stays in between the years 1500 BCE and 1500CE, so no modern or future stuff
@raspvidy
@raspvidy Ай бұрын
Meanwhile city skyline 2 is releasing apologies
@BloodyMathios
@BloodyMathios Ай бұрын
People have to stop comparing Manor Lords to Total War and Age Of Empires... The game is completely irrelevant at this point with the two above mentioned. The best comparison is Anno and Cities Skylines on different era. The battle mechanics are really vanilla at this point and people should not buy this if they want grand battles and conquering. This is a city builder only at this moment, but the future could be different since it's in early access. (I have beat 2 different campaigns already with different difficulties and the game is 100% a city builder).
@caiqueviola3359
@caiqueviola3359 Ай бұрын
i dont think manor lords is fun because historical accuracy.... i think the game is fun because the game transforms much of the time period as aportunities of gameplay and interation not jus brush them away, i think a fantasy game culd be fun with the same concept, but we do realy need indie developers tring these simple yet fun new ideias.
@JM-nw2pb
@JM-nw2pb Ай бұрын
it wasn;t that difficult to listen to that huge community begging for a great medieval total war since 20 years ago....
@mvega82890
@mvega82890 Ай бұрын
one thing i really hope this game does is wake up all these big studios and shows them what needs to be done. im so tired of bigger studios being driven by profit and not giving a damn about the actual player base.
@ejb6822
@ejb6822 26 күн бұрын
it's absolutely unclear what "child friendly" even means. i've never met a child that'd choose that cheesy comic bullshit over realism. children playing medieval games want gritty, realistic stuff, not this disney nonsense. the entire concept of "child friendly" is a huge cognitive dissonance that's nothing to do with what children actually want. and it's certainly not what anyone playing a niche-game would want. i'm an egyptologist, and i'd love a pharao total war. but not a phantasy-comic-pharao, exactly because i am invested in ancient egypt. companies are doing this simply out of lazyness... it's impossible that the messages of the customers weren't heard.
@user-ei9st8sq4g
@user-ei9st8sq4g Ай бұрын
It still not are total war
@GuthrumsClips
@GuthrumsClips Ай бұрын
The game is nowhere near finished and won’t ever be because the one and only dev wants to be stubborn and continue flying solo
@fearan9406
@fearan9406 Ай бұрын
Take a seat Andy, it's about 3 years minimum from being total war killer, but a good start for sure
@tigertankerer
@tigertankerer Ай бұрын
Witcher, Cyberpunk, Dying Light, Frostpunk, now this... I am starting to think Polish games are superior.
@Hypoksi
@Hypoksi Ай бұрын
The English is very good. But the Norwenglish will always be there
@AndysTake
@AndysTake Ай бұрын
Praise be inshallah there will always be remnants of God’s own language in my English 🙏
@ruben9618
@ruben9618 Ай бұрын
Its good really good, but needs more work and stuff added in.
@Huntanor
@Huntanor Ай бұрын
This statement is weird. Like I always want more options and posibilites in my games, but I try to be satisfied with what I'm given if it seem a real reflection of the developer's pitch. This game is better then a lot of games at full release right now. If it never updates again it's worth the door price already. When it does update that will be it's own thing.
@Pilps
@Pilps Ай бұрын
I feel like I'm the odd one out here, I ain't really enjoying it to be honest, it feels like the publisher knew they had a monopoly on the hype so it wouldn't fail in sales so they rushed it out half baked. I'm sure in a year or so it will be what we all hoped for but personally it just feels around 95% of it is just a work in progress, bare bones or just a chore.
@austinhan6998
@austinhan6998 Ай бұрын
Absolutely, it's a very unfinished game. Call me a sucker for supply chains, I'm already enjoying this more than Total War (and I'm not even touching the combat).
@MrHyonD
@MrHyonD Ай бұрын
I think you didn't follow the development to say such a thing. On the contrary it has been delayed several times because Slavic increased his ambitions multiple times.
@Nlwalker487
@Nlwalker487 Ай бұрын
It's early access. They released it in a playable state with the core gameplay concepts. Kind of how early access works lol Now they can get feedback from players to help make the game the devs and players want to play. Far from being finished and isn't advertised as finished
@popo9959
@popo9959 Ай бұрын
Finally a youtuber that isn't afraid to say how they truly feel. It's ok to feel like this, yes im in the same boat. Yes i know its early access but this still feels more than demo than more to enjoy here, which sadly i feel is going to leave a lot of people disappointed. Around 20 hours in and i feel ive done everything, which isn't great.
@PjAw27
@PjAw27 Ай бұрын
Yeah they shouldn't of released it in its current state, its going to leave a lot of bad tastes in everyone's mouths. The game is great and fun, but it got boring and repetitive real quick for me. They need to look into making armies and crafting etc, its such a slug fest. Yes i know thats not the games main focal point, then tell me, why was a majority of the trailers showing combat? Because they followed like pilps said here, the hype train. Ill probs not be playing again until a couple of updates/close to a year, shame.
@bhran07
@bhran07 Ай бұрын
The biggest prank it's just about food and many broken things
@re-birth8865
@re-birth8865 Ай бұрын
Simple. Just make a good game
@Gradashy
@Gradashy Ай бұрын
I really want to like Manor Lords, but historical is too boring to me.
@simonsalgueiro6217
@simonsalgueiro6217 Ай бұрын
It's a pretty barebones game that gets repetitive fast as many systems just don't work well. Not hating the author, it's obvious he put a lot of effort, but not even for an EA game this level of dephness is acceptable...and I mean like very very shallow dephness.
@GreatBigBagOfDouche
@GreatBigBagOfDouche Ай бұрын
Im 25hrs in and on my 2nd save. I love that i dont feel stressed or rushed. I actually enjoyed restarting after my first failed. My problem now is I have grown attached to my towns and armies after the hardships and victories. I dont think I could ever raise another flag in another playthrough.
@GreatBigBagOfDouche
@GreatBigBagOfDouche Ай бұрын
I'd actually love a system where you could turn town levies into recruitable mercs for other playthroughs.
ULTIMATE Guide to Manor Lords - COMPLETE Tutorial with Timestamps
29:29
Manor Lords Released A Major New Beta Patch AND IT IS HUGE
15:10
TheTerminator
Рет қаралды 28 М.
Can you beat this impossible game?
00:13
LOL
Рет қаралды 42 МЛН
格斗裁判暴力执法!#fighting #shorts
00:15
武林之巅
Рет қаралды 88 МЛН
КАКОЙ ВАШ ЛЮБИМЫЙ ЦВЕТ?😍 #game #shorts
00:17
How To Get Sheep In Manor Lords
3:01
Gamers Heroes
Рет қаралды 28 М.
A Total War Veteran Analyses Manor Lords' INSANE Warfare
9:50
Andy's Take
Рет қаралды 236 М.
It's brutal to be a gamedev right now...
14:33
BiteMe Games
Рет қаралды 43 М.
10 Games You Can NEVER Play Again
15:46
gameranx
Рет қаралды 664 М.
Avoid these mistakes in Manor Lords...or else
8:37
Welly
Рет қаралды 1,9 М.
Why didn't Rome conquer Persia?
10:59
Knowledgia
Рет қаралды 585 М.
No Other Publisher Does This
18:39
Bellular News
Рет қаралды 123 М.
I AM AMAZED: Manor Lords Players Are Building MASSIVE CITIES!
9:47
TheTerminator
Рет қаралды 51 М.
Total War Is Dying And This Is Why
16:21
Resonant
Рет қаралды 174 М.
My "kingdom" full of peasants voiced by chat
33:35
CHRBRG
Рет қаралды 479 М.
HEROBRINE vs NIKOCADO AVOCADO Rank Up Challenge
0:20
Mazizien
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
дед пранканул маму киллера #роблокс #мем #анимация
0:43
Пьяный дед продал внука в Roblox! 😱 @titwow
0:28
ОСУЖДАЮ 💀 #shorts
0:26
апален🗿бравел🥵
Рет қаралды 2,4 МЛН