All of Lily's songs feel somewhat bittersweet and nostalgic. Like you'd never know exactly what memory is being brought out but you know it's close to your heart.

I'm listening to this while drinking water out of a milk carton, nothing can get sadder than this

This song shows that comfi beats does indeed produce comfi beats. Even though the mood of the song is obviously very sad and moody, it still is vv comfi and a good song to listen to while studying. Thank you Lily for another amazing song! I can't wait for the 1-hour playlist when u compose enough😊

everyone's talking about the violin but what i first noticed was the title and the falling petal. your music's been a great help for me, lily. i hope u're doing well.

i've noticed that ever since i found out about lilypichu i've just wanted to watch all her stuff because she's genuinely interesting. I can say without a doubt that i've never paid attention to a KZfaqr or twitch streamer more than Lily, and i admire how diverse her talents are.... Anyway... Beautiful piece 10/10

You’re the reason I started trying hard to play piano and I’ve gotten a lot better because of it thank you!

beautiful ❤️

Lily your arrangement are actually really good! Props for you! Hope you see all the positive comments and I hope it can ease your heart that a lot of us here are appreciating what you're doing (because tbh it's really good). I hope to hear more music you create Lily! Cheers!

This is so gorgeous it reminds me of being dumped in Paris. Not that I ever have been, it just does.

People: violin = sad My monkey brain: hehe comfi

Why does it kinda sound like that theme song from Howls moving castle?.. But ofc I still love the melody ;Dd

"Living without you isn't living at all" -That person

lily i don't know if you know this but all your songs do strike a chord within the souls of those who listen to it. whether it may be happy, sad, nostalgic, genuine sincerity or just plain comfi beats.

Around the time of Lily's breakup, I had a similar, sort of more messy one which has affected me to this day and for the rest of my life probably. I don't think there's any correlation of this to her previous relationship, but to me it feels that way and it brought me back to that time all over again. I'll probably never listen to this ever again, even though it's great music; I jsut don't want to remember a breakup that transcended our relationship, affecting even my "friends" and family. Also the time I survived a suicide attempt. I don't intend for anyone to read this, just wanted to get that off my chest after listening because if I don't I'll probably feel bad for the rest of the week.

lilys content is really amazing, and she puts out so much of it! she is really on her A+ game right now, i hope she isn't too stressed. i love all of this lofi and have a whole playlist for it

This is such a vibe and gets me in the feels during quarantine (also Lily it's gonna be alr because I saw your livestream yesterday and you started crying idk if it was because you were drunk or it was actual genuine feelings but please you'll get over it just like all of us when quarantine ends we'll think of it in the future as a distant memory)-From a Fan............................. PS:im also a normal person in a normal household and we're still holding up and making ends meet and we somehow have enough money to spend on extra things so we can make quarantine bearable

Very sad feeling song. Would advise anyone not to get too tinfoily about how Lily is feeling and all that, she got people around her

look i know that everyone thought about the person that we know bu if we think ......its sad that we the fans of lily cannot hear a violin in one of her videos without thinking in him i think that we as the same as lily in some point we have to let that things that happend in the past stay in the past and let her grow in the music without thinking in the past and now she has her little crackhead

Still awake and its 7 am here and listening to this has finally told me to go to bed. Thx Lily for making Content and music as always. Keep going 👍

it's interesting how quickly stops at the end..

i wanna hear mykul saying ' hey buddy' in one of these

The end, as the echo of the Violin fades into emptiness... Just like a memory

This is actually how i feel if music could be feelings. I just went home from the school area I've went to for at least 13 years. I've literaly gone there since 3 years old in kindergarten. It really is super bittersweet, I moved to a new school for grades 7-9 but still having some lessons there. Now though there's nothing left but memories and feelings there. It really is just fantastic how perfectly timed this was, now I feel that I atleast can cope somewhat and be functioning. Thank you Lily

Yay, finally some peace

some serious studio ghibli vibes from this one, I love it

Heavily inspired by the Howls moving castle theme, likely pretty intentional as it was one of the Songs that Albert had played with Lily a few times. Given the tone and subject matter it's not a stretch to surmise that the inspiration for this music came from a cherished memory with Albert as they played this song together, slowly losing its value as the breakup moves further behind her.

Hi Lily I recently broke up with my girlfriend and everyday for the past week I’ve been very depressed and doing basis stuff like sleeping or eating is almost impossible for me. But your comfy music helped me bare myself to sleep and helped clearing my mind out at the loneliness darkness at night. Thank you.

dang this hits me right in the feels like your taking a long walk through a garden filled with flowers for the first couple walks you took a rose it's beautiful, gentle, comforting, and fragile you took it with you walking upon miles and miles of nothing but the blue sky, overgrown grass, and many more flowers it's nice just feels like you could do this forever till you noticed petals from the rose start to fall off one by one and exposing painful thorns , it hurts, you really never felt this pain in a long time , , the rose you once picked many miles ago has wilted leaving nothing but wounds but you continue to walk anyway the only path to that place is forward. (working on a story i've been cooking up for awhile the song reminded me to work on it hahaha thx Lily!)

This song reminds me of my own breakup. At 14, I broke up with my ex. It was really toxic to begin with. Ever since, he has tried contacting me and calling me at random times. I stupidly accepted his apology two times. Around the first time, I had started drinking for 'cooping'. I had sent him a picture, started drinking, and became very suicidal. From that moment, I knew that he was never going to leave me along and that he'll always be in the back of my mind. I'm in high school now. I have really bad anxiety, since someone had my picture I sent him. So I feel like eyes all over me now. But I try my best. And hearing this song makes me cry, not only because of sadness, but because I'm grateful that I found you Lily. Your music makes me feel happy. It really does. And if your reading this, I want you to know that I envy your relationship with Michael. I wish I had someone that cared for me as much as he cares for you. But I still love you guys, and everyone in the house. ^^ Also, this feels like a type a song that would be in Beastars.

Mannn..this kinda reminds me of the good ol' days, where piano and violin were just rooms apart from each other. I miss music streams with friends 💛❤.

Lily's songs touch you in a way that you'll never know what memory it's triggering but its a bittersweet one and makes you cry and you don't know why.

I'm actually super happy your focusing so much on your music lately. It's reason I started following you then the rest of offlinetv. Because of a chill mix that started with your version of song of storm. I listened to it a gazillion times and had to find who made it. then found a video of you following people with a melodica at a con then running away hahaha

This slaps harder than my parents

Love the illustration, the fading red hair and rose, the violin, B R UH, big feelies 😰🙏

Speaking as a fellow piano player, I just feel so soft when I hear the faint sound of the pedal coming from the piano in the beginning. To me, this made the song very nice. I really liked it. Good job~

Each new song really does live up to the name "comfi beats" I love each and every one, this one and Dreamy Nightmares I find myself coming back to a lot. I think sometimes I like to remember how things were, sometimes I do feel sad about it, but I'm glad because there are also a lot of good things that have happened along the way after those times in the past too.

Walking down the street, she noticed a bright red rose just laying on the ground. In this concrete jungle , a gentle rose like this does not belong on the solid pavement. As she walk closer to the rose , her steps slows down as it starts to feel as if walking against the flow of river and final stopping in from of the rose. Unconsciously bending down and reaching for the rose the start to remember the times when rose means a start of a date or a wonderful evening accompanying with joy. She raises her body while rose in her hand , while lettings go of the handle of the case. The rose seems to be wilting and seems to not be as beautiful as from a far. She hold up and stares at the wilting rose ,eyes stings,heart aching and fingers prick by the thorns. Her gaze is fixated with the beauty of the rose while all this feel doesn't seem to matter anymore. As a sudden gust blew, a single petal broke off and gently returning to the hard concrete pavement. She realised ,like the happy moment that has passed, the petal will never be a part of the rose and here on out more petal will fall and fade into the hustle and bustle of this street. "I am not happy ", she pauses, "there is no point anymore", she whisper to herself. The rose fell to the ground as she loosen her grip. She started walking away from this even living the violin that use to meant everything to her. Her heart heals as memories wilts.

This gives me "Ib" vibes. Especially when she's holding that rose! Haha.

I love this art style of her's, its so different and comfy.

This really made my heart sunk. I feel so nostalgic for something I've never experienced before, it's so weird to put into words, but it's one of those feeling that you just appretiate that you can feel, idk. Thank you so much for this Lily, your work is amazing

damn why does this sound like this is the season finale of OTV. I don't wanna make assumptions but sheesh first thing I noticed was the piano and the title made sense to me. Hearing this song is kinda breaking my heart a little. Great melody tho

Lily, i hate how you create such good music and how great all of your composition are i could listen to all of your pieces on loop for an eternity i just want to say keep up the good work and i don't understand why people are analyzing your life just because you used the violin its such a great sounding instrument keep up the good work and don't let others discourage you Love you

this is what living in a ghibli movie feels like. jokes aside, keep doing what you're doing lily. you inspire us in ways you could never know and your music is absolutely beautiful. we love you so much, even if we don't know you. ~

as soon as i saw the title i thought there would be a violin in this one :’)

I’d love to find someone to write memories with... even a good friend :’3

I love how you can hear the pedal squeak underneath the music and the way the violin slightly scratches, not because it sounds good but because it makes this piece feel so much more relatable and down to earth and like there is a person actually playing the instruments, unlike other songs you hear. that feeling gives it so much more emotional power, like it's really coming from the heart.

5 songs in 1 month what the diddly heck THANK YOU LILY YOU HAVE BLESSED US

this legit sounds great! jun sounds great in this too. also people overthinking this I did not notice anything until i saw the comments lmao

Damn yall gotta start being here for her music than for her life

I have been listening to this song over and over and it just gets better.

Your songs always make me feel like I'm remembering something, even if it doesn't actually remind me of anything. It's like bottled nostalgia

No one: Me: ah yes, vibe time

Song: has violin Me: Oh no.

This honesty made me cry, so beautifull and emotional. Beacause of that, it makes it very comforting. Unbelievable that music can make you feel this way!

This gave me goosebumps. Thank you so much for making this lily!

I was thinking what if she's forgetting him. Which is good i know. Like all their memories are fading so much so that she feels nothing or thinking of nothing when she heard the violin. Awesome beats btw

Why do I have the feeling that Lily is going to become as influential as Nujabes?

The drawing is really cute and the song itself is calming. Thank you Lily for releasing these nice songs. Stay comfy 😄

im really stressed currently and ur music is really helping. thank u so much lily ur amazing

Always love depressing music it kind of makes me happy to know I m not the only one

love the art and music ^.^

listening to your songs while working or chilling and what you have done is really great. I love your videos, streams, art, and music. I just want to say thank you for all you have done and hope for the best. You are the reason why i got into music and want to draw more

I'm not exactly sure why but just listening to this song lily made and watching the petal fall made me cry...

So early that Michael hasn't even tazed anyone yet

Melancholic kind of comfy But i love it very much, id like to hear it without the accompaniment of the violin because i like the intro so much, with just the piano But nonetheless, still a masterpiece~

After having a panic attack in the middle of online class a comfy beats upload is just what I need. Thanks lily.

I cry from this. Happy tears, sad tears, my life has been great and horrible, all at once. I feel so happy yet empty, but now these memories leave me, and happy ones replace them. I feel comfy now :)

This music suits to be in Hollow Knight as one of the ending ones.

I don’t see enough “wake up lily” comments

Legit got a rush of old childhood dreams (like sleeping dreams not aspiration dreams) and got a rushing sense of nostalgia for thoughts I thought I had completely forgotten, I’m sad but in the best of ways

i feel like i can hear you get better and better with every song. this is beautiful! wish you the best in making some great new memories :*

I don't wanna make any assumptions, but I think I know what this song is for. ;-; Edit: Guys, I'm saying this ahead of time, but please be respectful about things you say. Let's just wallow in feels music together

Hey lily you should combin all ur Lofi songs on after the other and make it into a podcast on Spotify so that people without premium can skip around and we can set a sleep timer for it to turn off after a certain time so we can fall asleep while playing your songs (idk if that makes sense and you probably won’t see this is just popped into my head)

Another brilliant piece

The words "beautiful" and "stirring" come to mind.

this belongs to the Promised Neverland soundtrack

i think it's odd how in the last charity livestream michael walked in he room and said "ohhh.. you're day drinking.. again." and then she drops this? i hope everythings gonna b ok and that lily just stays positive.

Lily, thank you for being my reason for trying to get back into playing the piano. Thank you for always being compassionate. And thank you for always being you. 💕

Every song is so good. Thanks Lily!

last time i was this early, this type of comment was original

If you're reading this comment, I'm always here for you.

Kinda funny how a few weeks ago my notifications suddenly showed a song from this channel when I'm not subscribed Finally youtube did something good for once and plus I'm now subbed to this channel :)

im amazed how there's 7.2k likes and only 7 dislikes; a true testament to how great this piece is. this is my favourite song by lily so far, i just wish it went on for longer

How many times did Micheal taze you while making this?

i guess we can only hear tazers and saxophone noises now :( they really had a gud relationship but i guess lily has her crackhead now

thank you lily, i started watching you a few years ago back in 2016 I believe. i had seen your art and thought it was beautiful so i kept watching all of your content. you are the biggest inspiration to me. all of your streams, emotional, funny, or not help me cope with emotions i feel inside. you are so talented. i aspire to be like you one day. your music, videos, etc helped me overcome incidents that had hurt me for years upto weeks upto months upto days. i hope you know that your audience is so happy to see you thrive. i want to give you a big hug :)

The first few tunes of the melody already gave me the chills, so beautiful

These beats always help keep me calm.

This feels really fantasy themed like some music that came from spirited away, howl's moving castle, totoro, etc.

Has a super melancholic feel to it. Very nice.

I know everybody talking about the violin and how this is comfy and sad but goddamn this song just makes me wish for my own high school days back, everyday I took for granted, every friend I've lost etc. Very nostalgic and self reflective music.

Love it lily i want you to keep making this for all of my hardtimes thank you.

i'm just here, crying... this is absolutely beautiful

I feel like I can relate to this songs and always lily your an big inspiration to me you helped me through Suicide and depression I still have depression but it helps me watching you makes me feel better I feel like I can relate to someone else and I always listen to your music and your music from 2015 because it makes me feel relax and not worried about the other things even though I having a hard time through life right now I’m glad to know there is also somethings to be happy about. Thank you so much you mean a lot to me Lily

Love how your music is always filled with emotions, im always lookin forward to listen to your new releases, keep up the good work and keep doing what you love and enjoy. Much love♥️’

man can I just say 2020 has been one fucked up year Kobe,covid and now fed cmon man just get better... but I will always watch fed no matter what but things will never be the same after this you will never see them hang out again it really pains me to think that we won't have fed in offlinetv anymore just stay safe everyone and ill see you at the top...

i pushed shuffle and this song played, i swear i thought it was a studio ghibli track. this is fantastic.

The song sounds sorta sat but it’s honestly very comforting. Ack I love it too much!

Your music is so calming, you're very talented and you're such an inspiration for me, thank you Lily for sharing your music with us ^^