@@kanizfatima1377 I have to ask something. Do you know, according to traditional scholars can women be leaders in social things like maybe in a school, can she be the head teacher and lead other male teachers? Or maybe in an hospital, can she be the head of doctors? I know, classical scholars think women can not lead a country or a mosque but what about other things?? Dou you have any knowledge about this?

@@kanizfatima1377 Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) heard that the Persians had appointed the daughter of Chosroes as their queen, he said, “No people who appoint a woman as their leader will ever prosper.” (Reported by al-Bukhaari, 13/53).

@@naqsh7735 Beware about you say Naqsh, these are not my words. Rather it is from the Prophet Muhammad SAW

@@naqsh7735 if you call yourself a muslim, fear ALLAH, and delete your comment

Know that the thing you want is not higher than Islam. You are so delusional. Equal is not justice! Stop feminizing Islam!

Nt like church women should silent n saying anything is sin... bt in islam like aisha n salama lead as a imam.. they scholar also... u maybe amazed they joined in politician n leadership as commandor aisha.. khadiza was busineswomen n economist

No it is not. We are enot smarter than the prophet or companions in religion

@@Lutestick What about Quran praising Queen of Sheba?

@@shafiqsha9875 what does that have to do with the comment above saying we can change islam or our understanding of it to fit the times?

But he said one thing and that is there is nothing and no authentic Hadith that prohibits women from leading prayers like dr. Sabbir said

Can you mention the reference in the hadees?

This is good. He is open for improvement

Well said. These weak and ignorant so called Muslims need to wake up and ask the folowing questions: Why did God never send a female prophet? Why did Allah SBW said the translation of: If you need 2 witnesses you can have 2 men or one man and 2 women, and He explained why - in case one of them goes astray the other one would remind her. Why shibba did not continue as the leader of her people rather she ended under the authority of Solomon. Why did the prophet SAW said what translates: No people elect a woman as their leader they will not have success. Etc....can state many many reasons why it is not appropriate for women to lead in the mosque. If you put a women as mosque leader what would you do when she become impure.

Where is proof that Allah has denied her to rule ? When Suleiman actually moved her to Yemen where she ruled over 3 other nations! Yes she was no longer ruling the nation of Sheba. Smh the internet is dangerous and ppl will say anything.

So they can still lead a prayer from behind?

what ?? imam has to stand in the front @@crazyshorts4278

I would be entranced by a woman's voice. And I mean that in a great way. Our local imam has a terrible horse voice. But his wife has a beautiful soft call. It's very sad she is not allowed in or to speak to us. Islam was supposed to empower women, but ended up being the greatest tool for sexism to date. Bless you sister. May Allah reward you greatly

@@bigelowtech السلام وعليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته سبحان الله. The sexist stuff is all human made; not what Allah intended.

@@bigelowtech You're supposed to listen to the message, not the voice. What you said literally proves why women shouldn't be leading prayer... You're not supposed to be there to enjoy the voice of a woman... You literally admitted that would distract you.

@@darkninja1693 if you're animalistic and can't control yourself when a woman speaks you have deeper issues than a simple prayer. You probably want a woman to wear a niqab and stay submissive so you don't have to learn self-control? Imagine where the middle east would be today with more female leaders. It wouldn't be the desert sh*t stain it is today

@@bigelowtech thank you for sharing this

I have to ask something. Do you know, according to traditional scholars can women be leaders in social things like maybe in a school, can she be the head teacher and lead other male teachers? Or maybe in an hospital, can she be the head of doctors? I know, classical scholars think women can not lead a country or a mosque but what about other things?? Dou you have any knowledge about this?

He used queen of sheeba and matched that hadith with the quran

I pray for the women in your life

No. You will not find in Quran that it is sin to take picture or selfie

Halal Latina, a related Sin(w this topic) is to pray to a image, idol or icon! "Memories" in picture or in mind are not harram as long you are not going away from God by thinking of it! Its all about the intention sister!

A person shouldn't be obsessed with selfies,and post those in social media for mass attraction and create a chaos.

Halal Latina not really but some people use it to show their cleavage which is definitely not allowed. again it's your intention

Halal Latina sounds like a yummy name rofl

No dear the scholars will not allow you to do so😂😂😂😂

Why??

If you haven't realized, that wasn't a hypothetical question OR answer... If you're hinting that women can never be leaders or imams then I have no words

To say to you

It's not about old or new times. Point is why would a woman want extra responsibility. If I could I would always stay a child (not reached puberty) because children don't sin

@@shayaandanish5831 Why would a man want extra responsibility by marrying and having a family? Obviously some men do not marry and they can live without responsibility, but others do. Similarly some women may want the responsibility and they should be able to have it as there is no bar!

Prophet Muhd pbuh had taught us on how to pray, dont be among those who are astray. It is frightening how you are so easy to be deluded by western standard that you decide to forsake the sunnah of the prophet.

Doesnt exclude women to take power to their hands .

I have to ask something. Do you know, according to scholars can women be leaders in social things like maybe in a school, can she be the head teacher and lead other male teachers? Or maybe in an hospital, can she be the head of doctors? Cause we know our prophets wife was the head of her bussiness and Aisha was the head of an army so are these acceptable? I know, classical scholars think women can not lead a country or a mosque but what about other things?? Do you have any knowledge about this?

He has referred to the Quran which does not prohibit women from holding leadership. Your complaint is that he should mention scholars and or hadith to prove his opinion. I will refer you to two Quranic verses, the first one is addressed to the Prophet, "Why hast thou forbidden that which Allah has made lawful" (The Quran 66:1). Clearly, not even the Prophet can forbid that which Allah has made lawful! So any Hadith forbidding female leadership would be in contradiction to the Quranic verse praising the Queen of Sheba as an able ruler. The second verse says, "Rabbis and monks determined what was lawful and what was not instead of God" (The Quran, 9:31). The scholars are the "rabbis and monks" referred to in the verse. We can respect the medeival scholars for their learning but they lived in different times in completely different societies with a mindset reflecting those times. Learning and knowledge moves forward and does not remain stagnant. We have to understand Islam in light of the Quran and with the conditions existing in our societies today.

@@ahmedakhan1 thank you!! I don’t know why these people don’t understand that the Quran > hadees 10000000…x why do they give preference to the hadith (which is susceptible to flaw) over the Quran is something I can never understand!

@@nooriarizvi3279 You are welcome! Here I would like to quote one more verse from the Quran which may explain why the Quran is held in such low regard today. Allah says, "Then the Mesenger will say:'O my Lord! Truly my people took this Quran for just foolish nonsense.'" (The Quran, 25:30).

Keep Strongly disagreeing

@@ertugrulcigci seems like you are from Turkey. No wonder your answer matches with your knowledge of your religion.

Ibn Hazm argued Mary was a prophet

They may be ......that have a video in this...

@@Mscursed2 Mary was not a prophet

Who said they arent When God said that he sents prophets and Rasuls He didn't say that He ONLY sent men He sent prophets and Rasuls Is there anywhere in the Quran where Allah said Women can't and won't ever be prophets NO as far as ik He unlike u isnt obsessed with Gender

@@shahjadatalukder2706 وَمَا أَرْسَلْنَا مِنْ قَبْلِكَ إِلَّا رِجَالًا نُوحِي إِلَيْهِمْ مِنْ أَهْلِ الْقُرَى “And We sent not before you [as messengers] except men to whom We revealed from among the people of cities.” (Yusuf: 109) Fear Allah and be careful on sayings things which you do not know.

الله يخلصك. كل الناس أحرار ولكن يحتجزهم رجال شريرون

What has Shabir Ally said that is contrary to the Quran? He has said what Allah has said in the Quran. If you believe the scholars over the Quran then you are committing the error that the Quran warned us, "Rabbis and monks determined what was lawful and what was not instead of God" (The Quran, 9:31). Fear Allah!

​@@ahmedakhan1well said

She's not allowed to pray during her period.

And knowing she's on her monthly cycle means what exactly? Why should women be made to feel ashamed of something that is natural and from Allah?

Being shy and ashamed of are different things. Shyness is part of Imaan. Satr of a man is from navel to knee. Men can show the rest of the body. But do you accept an Imam just covering the satr. Let alone Imam men won't be able to go out of home covering just 'satr'. It is shyness. It's not like he is ashamed of something. Same thing applies to women. When a man is shy to buy undergarments from a place where even men are watching. It's not even about undergarments it's about periods. So she shouldn't be ashamed of but shyness is perfect.

Zayd Abbas also there aren't many stories support the claim which women can lead a prayer otherwise we would see the majority of the companions follow it throughout the history, as well the prophet PBUH would encourage such an act if it would benefit the Umma. So lets not create an innovation in the Deen, we all know how sensitive the issue of equality between men & women so the Dajjal plan to fill the mind of people with "why this and why is that", just to create more division, if you ask me I've noticed the amazon tribes are successful than us in terms of the community structure and family concept, as they follow the same traditions throughout the history and thats the plan, imagine what would happen to them if Dajjal entered their life? Lol, I believe the modern Islam scholars are too philosophical than rational, and Only Allah knows,

I think why you would be distracted is because it would be so unexpected because it's so unusual.

And women are distracted by men. So no imam?

you're only distracted bc society convinced you that you will be distracted by the slightest thing a woman does. westerners or people who aren't muslim or don't know abt such beliefs like men get distracted by anything a women does, it won't even cross their mind to be distracted. it's all about beliefs

If they KNOW what they're doing, then i couldn't care less if it's a Man or a Women.

Ayesha, the wife of prophet was an army general

@@amalmohamed8357 women bodies are stronger in a sense that they can bear more internal pain While men can external

Why not??? If Hazrat Aisha can lead men in war and Umm Waraqa lead men in prayer why not other women???

Forgetful??? Ummul Mumineen Aisha RAA transmitted the most ahadith. Of all the narrator's of ahadith there were hundreds found to be liars - not one single female narrator was among the liars. The teacher of Imam Shaf'i? A woman. The teacher of Imam Malik? A woman. Who taught the companions men and women from the Mosque in Madina while the Prophet SAAW was alive? Aisha Bibi RAA. Truly the evidence is abundant!

It is the people who want to show the superiority of men and their absolute dominance over women, who are following in the jahaliyah traditions. The people who follow the Quranic message of equality between men and women are following true Islam!

@@ahmedakhan1 Are you trying to teach Allah his religion while Allah knows whatever in the skies and the earth, Just as Allah has created day and night differently, He has created men tough and female soft and thier function will be different.

@@nafizmustafiz466 I am not teaching "Allah his religion," I am trying to get you to stop following the example of misogynist scholars and refer you to Allah's Book, the Quran! There is no mention in the Quran of men being "tough and female soft." What the Quran says is this: "Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, because Allah has given the one more (strength) than the other, and because they support them from their means" (The Quran, 4:34). So clearly men and women are equal except the two areas mentioned. The Arab society in 7th century CE (at the time of the Prophet) was such that the state provided no police forces to maintain law and order and so it fell on individuals to provide for their own defence. Hence men, being stronger then women, were able to do so to some extent. Also societies were agrarian, and the lack of machinery made farming a job that required strength. There were few opportunities for women to have gainful employment, so husbands or fathers provided support. As the Quran says neither male or female are superior to the other, except in so far as males provide protection and sustenance to the females. In the same way that in some societies rich people provide sustenance to the poor through charitable contributions or trained soldiers provide protection to the weak, but that does not mean that either of these groups are superior to the poor and the weak! In today's societies, in most countries, the state provides protection to its citizens, while at the same time firearms make physical strength irrelevant. Also most jobs today do not require physical strength but are more cerebral in nature. Hence women can perform such jobs as well as men can, depending on education and training. With large numbers of women in the work force they make a contribution to family incomes, and in some cases may make more of a contribution then the husbands. So in today's societies there really is no difference between men and women in terms of protections that they can provide or earnings that they make. Why should either male or female have superiority over another, since the Quran clearly states the two reasons why men have a degree of superiority over women! Now if a woman is contributing more to the family income then clearly she would have more of a say then the husband, and that is but fair! Understand the Quran with intelligence and do not follow mindlessly the scholars of yesterday! As Allah says,"The words of your Lord are complete in its truth and justice. Nothing can change His words - He is the All-Hearing, the All-Knowing. If you obeyed most of those on earth, they would lead you away from the path of Allah. They follow nothing but speculation - they are merely guessing" (The Quran, 6:115). Finally, Allah says, "Rabbis and monks determined what was lawful and what was not instead of God," (The Quran, 9:31).

What about Queen of Sheba?

There is only one jahil and thats a man who thinks he have the Power over women

I love how uneducated people always wants to blame the "Western thought" or "feminism" to point out what is wrong within their society. Today's Muslim has nothing to do with prophets' time. They took many people's rights because that is what "Islam teaches" in order to use it to oppress as a mean to take advantage of people, without the people even realising it because they use propaganda (through their scholars and sheikh to spread theinformation they wanna spread). Western is not a perfect society, but Muslim countries became worse because of their misuse of the quoran. I truly believe that the fact that they're countries with extreme poverty and oppression because they lost the true meaning of Islam. Stop blaming the other for your sins... Acknowledge your wrongs and change them for the better. As long as Muslim countries rely on corruption, sexism, discrimination (because that is what "the quoran and hadiths" says) you cannot blame other countries!! That is called hypocrisy, a true Muslim would know that it is a sin. So it is our duty to get out of that vicious circle, and not be afraid to get out of our boundaries and see the world as it really is. Use your own brain not what most people/muslims think!!!

@@ridori5358 Well, lucky for us that we have such "educated" people like you who are so different from us "uneducated" people... You really know how to go off the point. Don't you?

@@ridori5358 Well said.

@@razakza why are you so angry?? Did you read what they said??

@@razakza they call us sexist so be it brotha, call us misoginy so be it brotha, call us oppressor so be it brotha. We live in time of fitna. Their morality base on their own desire. Ours morality base on what God say on us

In the Quran you will find that Allah says that she says that she accepts that solomon is a messenger from Allah.

And when the word muslim is used it doesn't necessarily refer to the followers of Mohammed pbuh, but it could also refer to people who are followers of the messengers of Allah, the god of the Torah, Bible, and Quran.

You obviously don't know much about Islam! If Queen Sheba became a muslim she would 1. Not have to relinquish her kingdom and title as there is no bar for a female ruler. In Islamic history there have been female rulers and today a number of muslim countries have female heads of state (the US has not ever had a female head of state in its history), 2. Not have to wear a "full burka" as nowhere in the Quran is there a requirement to do so, 3. Not have to become anyone's "fourth wife" (I don't know where you are getting this from), 5. There is only a requirement for males to be circumcised, but no requirement for female circumcision, 6. No requirement either for arranged marriages. The Prophet's first wife Khadija (who was 15 years older then him) proposed to him, and it certainly was not an arranged marriage!

The only ignorant one is you! Shame on you!

Many nations destroyed in past led by man and many nations flourished led by women.

Strange that some of the greatest nations are then led by women 😉

This Hadith is weak in the bukhari

@@abdelrahmanahmed424 Sahih Bukhari has all it hadith classed as sahih. Unless u referring to Bukhari's other book. Also the same/similar hadith appear in An Nasai with a sahih rating again.

First of all there are hadiths classifed as "sahih" but are very doubtful! Secondly it is unlikely that the Prophet would have said this as it is in direct contradiction to the Quran which praised the rule of Queen of Sheba. Finally even if the Prophet said that, we know from the Quran that the Prophet could not know the future, so his statement may be true for his time but certainly not for other times.

has not UK, Pakistan, India, Bangledesh, etc prospered ? These nations have or use to have women as their leaders. May be that hadith is fabricated

Did not aisha RA lead an army after the prophet left us?

That Hadith is weak

@Umair nawaz the army aisha (ra) lead was defeated by Ali (ra)

So even if the Hadith is clear then what the Prophet is saying is that no nation will prosper as its head. But we know from the Quran that the Prophet did not have knowledge of the future, so his statement could be true during his time but not necessarily true in the future!

Tbh he provides reliable arguement and evidence than blind and extreme interpretation