Katrina Coglitore this is the nicest way of suggesting things to a youtuber. ❤️

Katrina Coglitore im agree with your comment but we can apreciatte more if people stop smoke

@@dsmun1203 YES!! ❤❤

such a nice comment

You suggested that to beautifully😍

Aileen No she is so ignorant on this whole ingredient topic🤦🏻‍♀️ but spewing comments like she is really informed on it all.

I was actually thinking that as well, it only contains coconut water...I was thinking she didn't actually research these ingredients, I think she just assumed

So.Much.This.

I'm also a chemistry student. I completely agree with you. I'm cool with her talking about cutting things out of her products to an extent... But at some point it's too much. I know from working in product testing labs that fragrance tends to have formaldehyde in it, so that's certainly something one should consider cutting out of their beauty routine. But many of these other ingredients she keeps talking about - and I've read many, MANY labels looking for toxic chemicals known to the states of CA and WA - are not toxic at all. These products include coconut, which she went on about for a few minutes, and has reiterated in multiple other videos. She's gone so far as to categorize a completely safe ingredients as toxic based on her own allergies to them.

@@claire-yn2zi I agree with you about coconut and toxicity. Let's not forget the fact though, that parabens although haven't been proven yet that are related directly to breast cancer, are chemicals used as preservatives, that penetrate easily the skin and have been found in high doses in the breast. So it is another factor to be avoided. Good to know all these but as you said not everthying is toxic. I hope we could have a brand that is all natural and good at the same time, but is rather difficult, or then it might be extremenly expensive, becuase products will just exprire really fast. (i am a mol biologist and work in drug developement and research)

Hannah people also used to use arsenic and lead on their faces even though they knew it was bad because they wanted to look beautiful so that isn’t really an argument. That being said, its the trend right now and will hopefully die out soon. Its just the way things go, generations go from synthetic to natural and back to synthetic again without knowing why they do what they do.

Agreed!!!!! 👍🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👍🏼👍🏼

Right!!!!! I just heard her say that and read your comment lol

Riley Marie me too 😂

Same then I was looking for that one other person who also pointed that out 😂

Same same same

I was actually a bit sad because the packaging was so cute

Just subscribed to your channel! You seem to have pretty cool videos! ❤️

Julia Nell James and Jeffre burned it

The crayon case cosmetics is the way to go 🥰🥳

Zaara Nausheen aw thank you so much honestly !!!

Mary Gatewood And then I love when something doesn’t smell nice because it’s not fragranced and then she’ll say something like “ew! This smells so bad! I can’t!” Like... okay so you’re gonna complain because it has fragrance... and then complain when it doesn’t smell fragranced...?

Ella Park I wish more people would combat this crap being spewed in the internet (not just Tati but everyone who is enamored with natural and organic products)

It was my understanding that ethyl and methyl parabens are ok, but propyl parabens are not so much. Do you know? And you're right about the refrigeration part. I'm glad a big influencer cares, but yes, she needs to tone it down and address the subject properly.

Thankssssss

Stephanie Gaughan: I was getting rashes for a couple of years. Found out that methylisothiazolinone (sp?) was inserted into multiple products as a substitute for the more expensive parabens. Japan has outlawed the product and Canada is working on outlawing it. Ten percent of the population is extremely allergic, ninety percent are ok with it. So, there's that, too.

@@grayskies6192 almost anything can have it's positives and negative effects. This more of a complicated subject than can be addressed in 20min videos anyway.

If you see a james Charles making make up he shows how easy it is to make darker shades.

She is coming from such a privileged place by being able to say "sure, they made a mistake, but whatever" when her skintone is ALWAYS represented. It was purposeful that they left out dark skintones, and that's not anywhere near okay.

Some companies can afford to do that, and depending on where they launch, it might not make much sense. One wouldn't expect, for example, a company in Korea to have a shade range suitable for non-Asian skin tones. But I agree that for a company like Tarte, with vast amounts of money and a vast audience spanning the color spectrum, should've had a full shade range. But I prefer not to attribute to malice what I can just as easily attribute to stupidity. People are too self absorbed to be as interested in offending random strangers as many random strangers seem to think.

I wouldn't say privileged at all. It's her opinion, she didn't mean it in a malicious way at all.@@austynhl9484

@@austynhl9484 but it was definitely purposeful on Tarte's end.

People keep saying this video after video after video and she's not listening

Unless YOU have a degree in biochemistry, please refrain from making stupid comments.

@@mistressmars3200 I am studying pharmacy. 7th sem. I bet I am X times more qualified to give advice on any kind chemical, drug or excipient, than her. Thank you very much :)

Its her channel let her be. If you want your opion to be heard then make your own. Tati love you!

All this people saying to stop it...well if youdont like it dont come back to her videos!

JayCeeTee Agreed. Look at Fenty, they’re dropping 50 concealers at once, and adding 10 more foundation shades to their already huge range. If they can do it why can’t other huge companies? Especially brands that have been around for quite some time?

@@aimeeduff8000 Fenty put a lot of these companies on notice. Its about time!!

Absolutely!! For a big brand at this point it’s wilful and indicative of a non-diverse company culture - smaller brands maybe. Not tarte

Yeah. I’m (personally) not willing to “forgive” a huge multimillion company who launched a foundation thinking that 20 light shades and 2 dark is even acceptable. “Cancelling” in this case is just voting with our money, otherwise they won’t learn.

Yes!!!! Exactly! Well said!

She is obviously trying to be more conscious and not just about the pretty and expensive makeup and I appreciate that. I myself also recently started to make research on skincare ingredients and watch skincare dedicated channels, and I do not know what sources she has, but I feel the whole picture is not very clear to her. She only tosses random pieces of information she read somewhere just to try and make her content more educational, but it is not happening.

Agreed. I haven't really been watching and I feel like she might lose subs for this

Agree!!

Same girl

Brittany G same :(

Hope Murray Lmaoooo 😂

Looking for this 🤣🤣

Well it wasn’t just one thing...

Hanna yassssssssss

Exactly!!!!!

THANK YOU 🙌🏻

Hanna that is a different point of view I like it you must be a good person

THANK YOU

Cody Ref I shout that’s a conspiracy. That’s probably a fact.

Cody Ref factss

Definitely😂😂😂🤦🏻‍♀️

She's about to bust out a Halo Clean Makeup line.. at least that's what I think.

Braedyn Rix. GREAT IDEA!!!

I’ve stopped watching a lot of her videos because I’m so sick of hearing about things that are “good” or “bad” when she’s spreading misinformation.

TATI NEEDS TO DO THAT

YES 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻👏👏👏

Yes I'm not interested in ingredients that much and it's tough to have to skip every few seconds. She should make a dedicated video and if she reviews products she could review other factors and link everyone to that video regarding the ingredients

Bethany Mullins It’s not going to happen any faster if you just “cancel” the company completely- it’s a learning experience. Letting them fall and giving them the chance to get back up will bring you even quicker results, instead of shutting them down before they even realize their mistake.

I completely agree

@@ata9419 what I'm saying is, it should have already happened. The learning experience phase should have ended years ago. What do they need to learn? People of color exist and deserve good makeup as much as everyone else? If a company is still "learning" that, I don't want to support them. They don't support me. It's not a malicious thing. It's a statement. A silent protest to be recognized

Fr how she says one false move it takes months to develop a product. Girl bye

Bethany Mullins thank you! Cancel culture can be a wake up sign for these brands.

I was thinking the same thing... YIKES

Kieli Sunshine THANK YOU

Science is your friend not an enemy ❤️

You’re taking like a good point and taking it waaaaay to far. Yes don’t wig out about an ELEMENT or something, but you should fully pay attention to ingredients, particularly if a product doesn’t work for you. And the idea that companies care so much about your wellbeing is insane. Check out the talc lawsuits Johnson & Johnson is facing.

Don’t you know? She’s learning, sometimes she can be wrong and so can you! /s per her other video Composition of substances takes a long time to learn and is often done with a scientific background, I find it ridiculous that she has no basis in chemistry or biology and is talking about ingredient interactions. Are you serious? Please come back with me to my organic chemistry days! That stuff is so hard to understand, you can’t learn it from just clicking about and reading an internet article. 🤦‍♀️ practical examinations are also part of learning drug interactions and compounds - who remembers calculating moles and trying to balance out chemical reactions 🙋🏽‍♀️. The basis of all of this is not easy. I think Tati is sweet but her this clean ingredients nonsense is just plain ignorant.

She has her own skin care line, I'm pretty positive she already knows that. Besides it's her own choice to take her time and look into the ingredients that go onto her skin. She's not forcing you to do it with her, just let her do her thing...

Yes! I just commented the same thing....I support the concept, but it's gotten preachy as of late.

yes

Yes

I agree. I like what she’s saying and all, but it gets redundant.

It’s something she’s passion about. Stop trying to tell people to stifle how they feel. She’s a human before a youtuber

Jill Billy I was slowly dying inside I was about to skip the video her rants just kept going and going

I legit had to skip through at least 50% of this video cause of all the talk about ingredients

Jill Billy honestly I’m up to the 10 minute mark and I’ve had to switch off. I used to love her videos so much but these days I just find her patronising and stuck up..

I’m paying more attention to the comments while the video plays in the background.

SAME HERE!!

Go to Sephora or ULTA and get a sample. Just cuz things work for her doesn't mean they will work for you or just cuz things work for you doesn't mean they will work for her and everyone else.

Caring about ingredients isn’t a fad. She’s also said she’s still reviewing products. Learn how to listen .

Nyssa SanMiguel I don’t think you get my comment lol. I just said I wish she would stop mentioning her opinion on ingredients since she’s been talking about it a lot lately for the past few videos (other commenters are saying the same thing)

L P it’s great she’s taking a closer look at ingredients, but her being so vocal about it is very new and I’m not sure she will continue to do so since a lot of subs like me are getting a little annoyed. She’s been doing it a lot lately and yes she is still reviewing products, but if you’ve been watching her for a long time it’s been a little odd and different from her usual reviews. Still love her tho pls don’t feel the need to “defend” her I’m just giving constructive criticism sis 😊

@@greeneyesyesterday oh we are listening. Pls go back, watch the video again and assess for yourself how much of the video is actual review of the products and how much is the "ingredient" talk, which isn't backed by science either.

Mee too! I do the ocm method with it.

I was gonna say the same. I make my own scrubs and most of them I use coconut oil and aloe and other stuff and it’s saved my skin. I use to spend 100’s of $ for nothing.

I love the idea of coconut oil for everything, but it clogs my pores and its something that took me awhile to discover because i was in the camp of 'surely something that works for "everyone" cant be the cuprit right?' well it was. So i appreciate that Tati is open about how she avoids it now and how it affects her skin.

That's great, really, it's awesome you've found it works fine for you. But the fact is that the majority of people with acne prone skin will have the same issues with coconut oil that Tati is having because it has a high comedogenic rating, meaning it's more likely to clog your pores and give you acne.

MyLifeInWonderland yeah well I have acne prone skin to. But to write of all oils as a culprit is kind of stupid. Grape seed oil I also great for skin. I use to have awful skin and only thing that helped was natural oils, aloe Vera and witch hazel. Making your own skin care is honestly best way, because then you can tweak things to your needs without breaking bank and loading chemicals onto your skin that gets absorbed. But guess majority perfer to be lazy and waste money :)

100% she setting the stage for her "clean" products

I agree!!

Agree

I really hope so, I'd be all for that!

Damn you clocked it the house. That’s really smart pr, can’t be mad at that!

I totally agree. That's what I thought too!!

No, I think she’s learning and growing and not putting crappy ingredients on her skin anymore.

From what I see, I thought that something had happened in her personal life, which is why she’s going in this route!

She had a lump in her breast, which was non cancerous. This is why she's removing all of the crappy chemicals from her makeup.

You word it perfectly. i bet it's the reason.

Maybe with enough research she can find affordable natural clean beauty. Let her make what videos she wants..dang.

That HAS to be the STUPIDIST, most uneducated comment I have read in a decade.

Her eye makeup is ALWAYS the best.

Alyssa G 110% agree! And I love how respectfully this was worded!

I completely agree! I think she is preparing the way to launch smth in her own company which will be probably toxic free or "clean" and that is why she is saying all these now. I have no information about any product launching, this is just my opinion, based on all of her latest video and redundancy on teh topic.

Caitlin Sammut buhhhhhh Jesus wept do we need to read the SAME comment 200 times

I love when all the scientists & doctors come out to play and inform. Truly. I don't see nearly enough of this on the social media sites. Of course, you also wrote this comment before our nation's attitudes on and belief in science were really put to the test. As it would turn out, well, you know how it turned out lol.

She said she's fine with coconut, just not on the face

The sol de janeiro cream is for the body which she said in this video, she’s keeping fragrance and coconut away from her face not body

It’s James favourite, not hers

Interesting! Thank you for commenting something that actually helps people understand the difference :)

Beck Wynta i know it’s so hard to buy products without synthetic fragrances because it dries my skin so much

i don't understand a word of what this says but thank you for the information

Go off sis :)

hehe no worries guys I am a chemistry lover and talk about chemistry and skincare on my channel if anyone wishes to check it out :) Happy new year to everyone! xo

Alissa Palmer I disagree. I’m here for the clean products. I’d rather not have cancer if I can help it. “Fragrance” is a cop out half of those ingredients aren’t even disclosed to the FDA.

Alissa Palmer very well said! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

It's her channel.

if i hear her say toxic one more time i'm gonna have to unfollow, she honestly has no idea what she is talking about and needs to go listen to people who do. nothing in products is "toxic" its just a buzz word used by "clean" brands to scare you in to buying from their brand.

@@krisnolan2037 yep. And if she continues to produce content not conducive to what people want, as I'm not the only person to voice this opinion, then she will lose subscribers. It's her channel. She does what she wants. It's also a business. A certain amount of maintaining a healthy business is providing something others want. If said business does not provide, people go elsewhere. I highlighted what I liked about her content on her channel, as well as commenting on what I didn't enjoy. It's constructive criticism. She encourages comments at the conclusion of her videos, and therefore accepts that people will not always share a positive view on her channel, videos, product - however you want to label it. 🤷

Wiiiiiiiiig hahaha

Christina Marie she reminded me of Jennifer Aniston in We’re the Millers when she’s in the strip club 😅

It’s a wig?!🧐🧐🧐🧐

VS M 🙌🏻 Thank you for mentioning this! If fragrance irritates your skin, it irritates your skin regardless of whether it’s synthetic or natural. I’ve had products fragranced with “all natural” essential oil (like Origins, for example) that are more heavily scented and irritating than many synthetically fragranced products I’ve tried. In general, I stay away from all fragrances, natural or synthetic, because that’s what MY skin needs. I just hate the preachiness of natural v synthetic scent. Fragrance in products is so personal, and not a direct result of some “scary synthetic chemicals.” For example: Rose fragrances, synthetic or natural, always break me out. It’s a very individual thing.

Thank you. I never realised that but im luck I only use 2 products on my face.

Yesssss

Most marketing is like that. You need to really look at what you are being told and what isn't being said. Hypoallergenic, allergy tested, non-irritating, safe for you are all actually baseless terms. The companies dont come out and test eveything you are allergic to so how would the company know that those terms apply to you...they dont but marketing teams know that comsumers dont generally know/think like that. It is the same reason i see boneless skinless chicken breast market as gluten free.... there is no freaking gluten in plain chicken breast! But it says gluten free so people will pay more for it...because people in general dont stop to look up what gluten is and where it comes from (grains) to know it was never there to begin with. They just know because they heard it from somewhere or saw it marked on a food package... gluten is bad. Do the research educate yourself. Sorry that was long had a very long day at work and caffeine still has me wired for sound.

hoi491 well it is really important. I think it’s very good she’s starting to try and get more healthy with her beauty products. Specially when she uses so many. She’s always talked about how she’s always been into health.

It's very boring to me

Debra Barycki i find it nice but that because I’m also trying to get into fresher more non toxic products but to each their own 💕

misscuitepie 833 I wish she would make dedicated videos on these topics instead of going on tangents in videos dedicated to different topics though. It’s important but starting to become overkill

It makes me LOL when she rants then justifies some product she loves that contains the Very Bad Ingredients.

Feeling the same way!

I love shape tape and I own a lot of tarte products like blush and bronzer and even a foundation, but they don't wow me like shape tape does. Going forward concealer is the only thing I'll get from them.

I love Tarte blushers, highlighters and some of their eye shadows x

Marissa Fralick she actually talked about this in a video. She said that she’s going little by little and that it’s not about all or nothing.

I agree. So much conflicting information between the two videos. And this video barely had any make up items I would not guess where bad on my own. Oh your amazon make up wasn’t top notch? Thank heavens you included it, I never would have known.

She literally was one of the few influencers who hasn't talked about the tarte foundation till now. Did you even watch the video or listened to what she had to say? She said she's not into canceling a brand over one mistake if they are taking the steps to correct it and learn from their mistakes. She didn't like the formula, that's why it's in this video...

I think she’s in the middle of a process. Yeah, there’s a lot of conflicting stuff, but I think she is in the process of finding what’s good for her, good for health, good for her channel. Plus I think for the best and worst videos, because she just recently started the deep dive into ingredients, the items she featured in these videos reflected what she has tested over the year - not necessarily her transition in products.

she's in the middle of a process. If you ever decide to make the movement to "clean" you'll know the feeling. You fall in love with makeup, smelling good, nice voluptuous hair, you trust that something that is approved by the FDA and the general masses wouldn't harm you and then you stumble across something one day that peaks your interest ... you do some research and find that ALL of your favourites have at least 1, if not all "dirty" ingredients. Meaning, potentially cancer causing, or lung irritant or what have you. Once you've researched that to death (which there is no end) now you need to start finding clean alternatives. But you still LOVE the way you look & feel with your "dirty" products... so slow and steady you start the change and try to inform others the best you can... be there done that & you don't know, until you know.

It bores me!

this this this !!!

Yeah I agree too preechy

Agreed! and these products were hardly 'the worst stuff', most of it was just stuff she was saying that she is boycotting or doesn't like the ingredients for. I want to know what the bad makeup actually is for the year! :/

It’s too much 😩

Isabella Ramey Yessssssssssss☕️

Shut up 🙄

You can just Google it as well..... Just a thought.

@@cknight2316 well yeah, but Im curious to see what shes reading

You can do your own research, girl!

@@Mar2376353 Yes I am but I also want to see hers to see if I'm missing something 😊 asking someone to back up their claims isn't hate so don't take it the wrong way please

I agree! Just commented this

I 100% agree and i do the same. First wait for some days, then read comments and if its not about ingredients I will watch it. If it is, then I 'll skip it. I have a phd in mol. biology and work as a researcher in drugs and neuroproteins for more than 10 years now, so i think I know which ingredients are good and which aren't. And to be honest if i want more info I will read some publications or consult some good doctors and not someone who is an expert in make -up. I have no idea about make up and I consider Tati an expert. I hope I am not offending anyone; what i mean is that as long as we know our field of study/work then it's safe to talk about the specific subject. Otherwise we jeopardize saying thinks that do not exist.

She just seems a bit self obsessed lately. She used to be more humble and her attitude lately has been a bit annoying

Same !

I feel the exact same way !

Hahaahaa

Bratty By Nature my bet is she’s planning on launching a skin care line and the main schtick will be “clean ingredients”.

Yeah i hate people stop using something just because of some ingredients. I am sure the scientists that formulate those products knows better than you do. Everything is there for a reason. EVERY ingredient work TOGETHER to give u the best results. If u break out from using some products, it just mean it is not suitable for you. Not because of the "bad ingredient" inside. Why would brands EVER make something that will break people out with those "bad ingredients "?????

Dear Chrissy, thank you for expressing that you are frustrated. Nobody cares. Well, I guess I do, since I replied.

croguy and like 99% of the comment section

go to Dr. Dray's You tube channel. She is a dermatologist in Texas and very informative You tuber. She has loads of information on skin care ingredients that has medical research to back it up.

I didn’t see it from this perspective but I totally agree. I enjoy and appreciate that she mentions these things because I think it’s good to be aware of things that you wouldn’t put on or in your body if you knew it was in a product. However, I’m bored of it. I get it you don’t like bad ingredients, no one actively wants bad ingredients. I feel like her videos could be half the length (or include more beauty talk) if she cut back on the rants. I love her but I just started skipping because I don’t care.

@@LoloTheModel me too! I second everything you said! Lately I am not hearing about good and bad make up, and that is why I come here. We know we love Tati, but I so agree with everything you said!!! :)

I agree ,a lot of it is her personal choice, not fact.

I agree, I can't use any Sisley or Bobbi Brown because the often use essential oils. The make me break out more than artificial fragrance .

Brenda Frederick natural or botanical products break me out!!

Ugh and people claiming "essential" oils are actually essential are the worst.

That's why she says do what works for you... This is what works for her.

Yup. I can’t do fragrances. I go natural for a lot of stuff but sometimes I need like the super sterile basic boring barebones stuff.

Laura ! Omg yes am I the only one it gets annoying

I did not find it patronizing...she said you can find “Good/bad/conflicting” information on ANY ingredient and to find what works for you. I think she is just really into skincare and therefore talks about it alot. Plenty of beauty gurus do it. Plus she already released skincare products.She states it is her personal opinion and doesn’t come off condescending in any way.

I disagree. I don’t think she sounds patronizing at all, but everyone interprets differently

I really do hope she releases her own clean beauty line.

Laura ! 👍🏼

Taylor Butler same!!! I have very dry skin but coconut oil makes my skin break out super bad, clogs my pores, and makes my skin insanely oily. I hate it so much lol

Same! I can't even use coconut oil in my hair cause then I'll break out if my hair touches my face too much, I hate that a lot of natural makeup companies fill everything with coconut oil. 😭

Coconut oil is the worst on my skin it broke me out so bad I hate it.

I enjoy coconut oil but it breaks me out as well. So frustrating!

Cori Nicole SAME! It gave me horrible back acne after using it on my hair, it took months to get under control again!

I'm just confused what she would try now, it's been no secret what is in makeup and skincare for a long long time??

Right like kinda annoying

​@@dividedconquered3784 I'm 99% sure she's doing it to set the ground for her own product release, whether it be skincare or makeup, that's gonna be "FREE OF ALL THE TOXIC MINERALS THAT I'VE BEEN TELLING YOU GUYS ABOUT FOR THE PAST 5 MONTHS, WHAT A COINCIDENCE!".

Fragrance free 😤😤

Vordie oh true!

Jazzmin Garmendia it’s like a flash back to when she discovered her gluten allergy and it was addressed in every single video 😂

Miriamegu i feel the same way. She claims to care about inclusivity but doesn’t care at the end of the day because she gets to have a shade. So hypocritical

If it works for her, i don't see the big deal. Plenty of brands don't make a foundation light enough for my skin tone. I don't insist that everybody boycott them. That is ridiculous. Every brand is not required to offer every shade in the human skin tone range.

Most of the time, I agree not to boycott a whole brand, but like why would you put a product with a bad shade range in the “top products” video? I get she likes it for a lot of reasons, but it just sends the wrong message.

@@mygirldarby Obviously it's ridiculous to expect brands to have EVERY shade that humans have but every brand should make a real effort to be as inclusive as possible. Clearly it can be done so these brands just appear to just be lazy or just don't care to be inclusive imo.

Exactly. I not a makeup person but I enjoy listen her.