This video is fake, your graphic comparison is not even on the same stage I guess, but surely not on the same spot. Sound comparison is also fake, fact that generations sounds better. And you cannot compare gameplay Codemasters was always above WRC series. Don't make fake videos, bro, unless u payed for it😂

Finally a video that aknowledges WRC Generations' existance

Thank you for doing this comparison. The other content creators have continually compared EA wrc with dirt 2.0 and avoided mentioning KT's WRC. Seeing this makes me wonder if they were told not to compare by EA

EA WRC looks like it was made for mobile, but it runs like it was made for super computer.

I'll always love generations. I dropped dr2 after 200 hrs to play generations. In my opinion it's the best complete rally game which Richard Burns Rally being the best for the actual physics. Generations was a close second to RBR in terms of handling.

I have both games and dirt rally 1 and 2 too. I find WRC generations as the best of them.

The sense of speed in WRC Generations is better.

Ever since my first stage I loved KT WRC games and always hated people hating on them for no reason. This new WRC just showed people how good the KT games were.

My biggest gripe with EA WRC is that the stages are just so freakin boring. Look at the Croatia stages from @8:00 on. WRC Gen has imperfect roadways. Debris on the road, cracks, patches, obstacles, varying widths. The stage and road surface have character like it's actually an area that's been lived in and weathered. EA WRC is like all the country's tax dollars went to making every road meticulously perfect. No potholes, no debris, all the lines are perfect, and the road is a perfect 10ft across EVERYWHERE. And every stage in the game is like that. EA WRC sounds better and can look better in certain scenarios but Codemasters just don't have the attention to detail that KT put into their stages. I won't even get into physics because that's all subjective.

Why is it that codemasters can't make trees that are full of leaves? Every tree is scant and it makes the scene look less realistic. There is no real density to the forests

Is it me or the EA WRC rain looks kinda weird ? Its so slow that the rain almost look like snow?

Just been refunded for wrc 23 and I don’t know why they released it in the state it’s in a lot lag and other issues. Now your comparison was very interesting and my vote goes to wrc generation I have played a lot of dirt rally 2.0 but I quite like the generations as a different challenge for me and thank you for the comparison very helpful.

For me the biggest downgrade from DR2 to EA WRC is the sparse scenery....

It looks the maker(kt racing?) of WRC gen has skills for good game graphics with less hardware demanding overall.

Thx for the video mate, I was tired of game journalists comparing the new game with dr2, while completely ignoring the rough diamond that is generations, probably due to incompetence. Cant believe it that a lots of wrc fans completely trashed generations for a Jimmy video☠️

In WRC GENERATIONS the gameplay seems to be better. The cars move way more smoother which adds realism to the physics.

I have tried EA WRC at a friend's house and I prefer Generations, WRC 10 and even WRC 9, the speed at which you can drive in both Dirt and EA WRC is absolutely unreal, there is no real weight transfer, the car rotates on a CENTRAL axis, not on the front steering, with a small adjustment in EA WRC as much as in Dirt you stay with the car, something that is absolutely unreal and false, then graphically it is boring, the Kylotonn stages are more fantastic and the sound in EA is laughable.

Dirt 2.0 was better in graphics, sound and in photo realistic landscapes than the new WRC, even the rain stages with all the mud in between was awesome... For the next video i recommend you to put an inside view of the rain and droplets from a cockpit perspective. The details are a great factor to the experience. In addition to gameplay, the feeling is great in WRC. It's better in some aspects than WRCG, but the snow in WRCG is better in my opinion. Cheers!

I can't believe I am saying it but in Generations the car looks like it actually has weight and looses grip. In EA WRC the car behaves like it has F1 levels of downforce and grip. Let alone the fact that it looks much better too :(

Kt Small? Ive told everybody GENERATIONS IS THE BEST STILL ❤❤❤

Generations is a simulation, EA is a simcade .

Generations look better.

WRC Generations all day, every day. Saw a clip of EA Sports WRC where someone was driving a Hyundai more or less flatout 90% of this tarmac stage. That dont happen in reality, ever. Not even a bump! And people call it a rally simulator.

WRC 9 120 fps mode is still my favourite rally game, Turkey at nigit in stormy westher is really fun. Dirt 1&2 is Also gr8 games of course. EA WRC has potential to be great. But i think it need a few patches to fix a few graphical issues and fps/stuttering issues. I play on Xbox

Amazing comparison

В странах СНГ больше любят Dirt Rally, чем WRC от KT… Я наоборот очень люблю WRC 8, WRC Generations и Loeb Rally Evo! Я очень рад, что здесь в комментариях люди ценят и любят WRC Generations, возможно это не популярно, но оно заслуживает уважения! Для меня Dirt Rally это аркада с неаркадной и нереалистичной физикой, получается «и не рыба и не мясо», играть в это неудобно, потому что управление остаётся аркадным. В таких играх очень важно сочетание контроля (рулевого управления) автомобиля с физикой, я считаю, что разработчики из КТ с этим справились значительно лучше, чем Codemasters.

In the End KT Racing won over EA. But they probably should have used their old engine instead of Unreal Engine which is not really a engine for racing games

In chase camera Gen car transitioned around bends smoothly, in EA the back end appears to step around a bend

Well my only question here is : how do you get such bright headlights on EA WRC @3:01 ? Mine do not have such lighting effect and just seem dimmed. The middle ramp just look like the ones on the side.

I played dirt rally and dirt rally 2.0 which i enjoyed at the time i then played wrc 9 wrc 10 and kylotons last instalment wrc generations , now after playing Ea wrc 23 game i have been very very disappointed i was expecting it to be as good as wrc generations or even better !! this was supposed to a next gen 4k 60fps on console but its not !! what on earth were codemasters thinking of ?? wrc generations is far more realistic has better graphics and has really good physics you feel the weight transfer of the cars etc where as ea wrc game has poor graphics stuttering issues and is just too arcadey !! i think they have made it to appeal mostly to gamers who use controllers rather than sim racers with wheels pedals and cockpit ?? content creators know that this new ea game isnt as good as wrc generations so i too am pleased that someone has done a comparison people complained about the throttle in wrc gen that it wasnt progressive but all you had to do was go to throttle sensitivity and set it to 4 and it worked perfectley also in wrc gen the car felt connected to the ground and you could almost drive it with the seat of your pants so in my opinion WRC GENERATIONS IS A BETTER GAME !!

There was really some fatigue on the KT WRC games, but after the EA WRC was released I really appreciate those games again. I only tried the 5 HR trial since I also liked Dirt 2.0 ... I ended up playing WRC 10 again and might give generations a shot for a few bucks.

May be EA only win the car sound and the length of the stage

I was like WRC is a nice step up until I realized generations was on the left lol. What a downgrade.

Wrc generations is for me the best rally game to this day (excluding RBR NGP). Dirt Rally 2.0 and 1 handling on tarmac is just ridiculously bad.

Ea sports wrc has the mini cooper looks amazing and that sound is unbeatable im gonna buy it tomorrow

Check out my EA WRC Gameplay clips! www.youtube.com/@BelowAmbient/videos

Seems like in terms of damage, EA SPORTS WRC & WRC GENERATIONS are still miles behind even WRC 5 RALLY EVOLVED. Even so, EA SPORTS WRC is still well worth the purchase despite also there are minor lags.

I actually find the cockpit view shockingly bad on the new WRC.. Constantly getting dirt and snow effects that clip through the cockpit from the outside aswell as trees and bushes. Rain straight up looks like oil snow doesn't even hit your window shield meaning when the wipers are pointless in snowy conditions as u see just fine. Literally all WRC needed was rain effects from dirt and it somewhat got that but nowhere near as good but it just dropped everything else wrc did right with it's cockpit view Stuffs important the little details add up.

KT is redeemed. The codies fanboys got fed slop with this one. I always said the tarmac was better in that game too, never played Spain or Germany in DR2.0 because of the busted physics but those were my fav rallies in WRCG. Might get it if they drop a Phill Mills DLC

La cámara interior de los autos, con lluvia, en los 2 juegos, no cae las gotas de agua en el parabrisas ( de nada sirve que funcionen los limpiaparabrisas)...en el dirt rally 2.0 no tienen ese detalle, la lluvia o las gotas de agua si caen en el parabrisas en su cámara interior...

that ea rain was fucking atrocious

the fact that the cars are this unresponsive with inputs using controller in WRC generations should speak volumes. Rally cars are extremely responsive in real life, it doesn't take seconds for the car to turn when turning the wheel, how people can still say the physics are realistic despite this is mind boggling, BUT WRC generations does have better stage designs and graphics

night in ea wrc is like dusk, at best. or just an overcast day. it sure aint night though.

KT really suffered from lack of polish in the yearly release cycle of death. The physics are a top notch "accessible but close to sim" take and will be missed in upcoming releases.

I actually tried the 5 hour trial of wrc, something about it i didnt like, cant put my finger on it. Just felt off somehow. Staying with generations.

There is something off with tree shadows reflections on EA WRC, and overall there are missing reflections on cockpit when passing trough tree shadows. The details in tracks are better in Generations. Anyways why dont they just take the RBR and Dirt Rally leave physics alone and just make better graphics? This is all we need

i miss the livery dowloads it would be nice to dowload liveries from other people what wrc generations did 😌

The biggest issue with the Codemasters rally games is that your car aren't steering with the front wheels... It's like steering in the centre on the car floor. Generations feel miles better.

I try both. And it's hard to tell . I think wrc ea 2023 looks a bit better but wrc 10 is now for xbox in store for only 6 euro ..

codemaster improved graphics of dirt 2.0 later of its launch. i know the game should come much better in qualitty at its launch. but at least they will improve thatbom time. for now lets sumerge in the fun of driving

I just bought WRC Generations for my PS5. I love the physics, it’s very hard to be fast, which I find realistic. I will skip EA WRC.

lighting in EA WRC is appalling... especially considering its "next gen" only and using Unreal Engine. It looks worse than WRC Generations, which is sad because you'd assume a new game will look better than an older one, right?

Damn Generations looks miles better and people said it had ps3/xbox 360 graphics? Hahaha how the tables have turned??? Also wtf is that rain in EA Wrc? It's basically slow motion oil trown on your screen.

I actually re-installed WRC10 and Generations again last night. I did a one on one comparison on PS5 and WRC looks significantly better. BUT…..not better than DIRT Rally 2.0!!!!! ​​⁠WRC is apperently next gen only. It looks worse than a previous incarnation on lesser hardware on a previous generation though. Dirt Rally 2.0 to Dirt Rally was even a large graphical step forward in the same generation. This is a five year development cycle and new, much improved hardware and it looks inferior in many ways. What bothers me even more is that I find the track layouts uninspiring, barren, boring and generic. For instance Monte Carlo is almost a.i. generated like it is done with the trackbuilder in Dirt5. The uphill righthand corners keep repeating themselves in exactly the same way. It is like driving the same road for 17 km’s. Trackside details, elevation (like the Turkey track in Kileton’s efforts) etc. are all substantially lesser implemented than in Generations and even Codemasters’ own Dirt Rally 2.0.

Seen some with high-end wheel rigs say WRC Generations is difficult, isn't fun enough and doesn't feel right enough for them when it's at least a 80% Sim game. (personally it's very good, would lighten the cars buy about 15% and it would be even better) Then they have played EA Sports WRC and say they love it when its a much more Arcady and looks worse. EA have gone for the middle ground, but it's not technical enough to carry on playing for my tastes.

Cómo todo lo que toca EA....el juego deja mucho que esperar. Para mí gusto conducción y realismo WRCG es muchísimo mejor en todo carreteras y autos.

Generations was just WRC10 remastered, plus EA WRC just came out so time for more updates to come. It could have come out more broken on console than it did, it's very fun. Not a masterpiece to be sure but there's time for that if we are patient and EA doesn't screw it up.

Need to say I will stick to generations. I´m not super happy with ea version, the driving is just... not funny while generations is a blast.

Generations seems to look better imo. Doesn't sound or play as good though.

It would be great if we could have the option to do time trials in any weather/season and time of day… dynamic time and weather would also be sick. Kind of like Ride 4 (and probably 5 I only have 4). Start a stage at sunset and end in the early hours of morning. With weather changing throughout. EA WRC is just lacking in some ways that made its release really kinda meh. I’m only now finding stages I’m enjoying playing and give that visual satisfaction as well that DR2.0 did. Still, DR2 is far better in a lot of ways. I would’ve taken an update for that game, adding in the WRC cars, and the stages from WRC rather than this game as a whole.

thats fascinating. generations does look better. so does dirt rally 1 and 2. and they all perform way better too. this new game is rather disappointing.

I played in the generation immediately after the full complete WRC 7 company. In general, the same car in the generations gives worse acceleration and turns much worse. I liked the team development system and various events in addition to completing special stages. but the fact that I barely passed the test run the 10th time, although I showed good results in wrc 7 on the same car, discouraged me from any desire to somehow develop in this game. I just feel deceived.

Ea wrc looks great love the dust physics

but what if EA WRC support VR?

I just bought WRC Generations on CDKeys for $13. From your video, I like Generations more. The graphics, weather effects, and sounds are much better than WRC 2023. God the sound on WRC 2023 was horrid! I ended up lowering the volume during it's demo because it was so loud and obnoxious. I'm glad I went with Generations instead. I don't care about chase cam as I do cockpit only. I hope my G29 wheel works as well as FFB.

EA WRC would be winner if it wasn't tearing, freezing, and dropping frame rate randomly, but on every stage somewhere. Not sure it's going to really work on console. I played WRC Generations endlessly and loved everything except the throttle, I'm playing WRC 10 tonight without any graphics issues and a perfectly working throttle. So far the best thing I can say about WRC 23, is it lowered the price of WRC 10 to $6 in the xbox store. Really hope they patch the issues, otherwise it's a great game.

porque se ve borroso en la version EA Sport WRC23

Офигеть. В EA WRC даже щелканье форсунок слышно❤

EA sports WRC looks faster but the other WRC looks more realistic

Dogshit vs Perfection. I'm still glad that you did the comparision tho.

please learn and listen to the pace notes man and also dont flick the joystick just move it smoothley but effectively trust me you will be faster and smoother

👌👍👏

I think codemasters did a good job with wrc. I just cant believe we cant adjust camera settings. While in the F1 games also by codies thats a standard option. P.S. i know there is a FOV slider. I just want an option to lift de cockpit/Helmet camera a bit higher.

Ainda nao joguei o WRC Generations somente o WRC da EA....Gostei do WRC da EA

WRC-G look much better. EA WRC looks terrible bad!

At moment KT WRC is better, but EA WRC has potential.

Zamn car damage model on EA WRC look worse. Is that because the brand car doesnt want their car looks broken? 14:15

EA WRC is clear in my opinion

Overall which one has more sell? I'm getting the EA WRC. 1 for EA 😁

O novo wrc da Codemasters tinha tudo para ser o melhor mas tinha de vir a EA para estragar tudo a meu ver o que tem de bom é os sons dos carros e jogabilidade porque de resto a kt foi melhor em tudo, desde designs para partilhar com o pessoal, as condições reais do tempo, troços mais detalhados e reais carros avariados e batidos na via tudo isso a kt ficou a frente da maior desenvolvedores de jogps de rally do Mundo

Mucho mejor el WRC generations por mucho!!! Gráficos, tramos, conducción y detalles en carreteras.

They're both decent

Who knew it'd be close between a last gen, small studio game, Vs a next gen huge studio game??? Kyloton must be happy how much EA didn't blow them out of the water. Really not a Next Gen showcase. Dirt 2.0 got close / looked better in places than this EA WRC.

I think EA WRC is a grower, not a show’er. Lol Meaning the graphics is growing on me. It looks better every time I play the game. It’s not necessarily as good as WRC generations, but it’s not nearly as bad as some cryers are claiming. Like: “Tears tears kick scream it looks like a ps2 game blaaeee buuhuu blleeaa so many tears”

slomo rain LOL

Thanks! Sorry but i can't watch full length this video because Kylotonn's WRC is so trash from every aspect that hurts What's wrong (only audio + visual) in KT's WRC: - Night: doesn't matter how many lightbars attached, always 2 light cones available in ahead of the car - rain: looks like total the same as sunny day, but with falling dots - sound: all sound is crap. (05:00 i guess a french guy was recorded as he played with his mouth on a comb which was covered by toilet paper) - revving the car: shaking the whole 1500+ Kg body???. total insane bullshit - 45 degre only for both side steering wheel animation - incorrect gauges The only Pro is the color of the asphalt in KT's WRC Also you can't see in this video: the car in EA WRC can fully fall apart (rear wings, lightbars, doors, wings can be splitted)

Tbh I like both games a lot. I have wrc 4,5,6,7,8,9,10 and generations, I have dirt 3,4, dirt rally I rally 2.0. I love all these games. But if you ask me which one is my favourite I must say wrc generations is the best for me. Ea wrc would take a 2nd place. I know many people say dirt rally 2.0 is better than ea wrc, but honestly the driving model on ea is just a bit better. I would say it's on pair with generations. I just like generations a bit more.

EA WRC is ugly. Blurry and soft. Other games are clean and sharp. I don't understand why, seriously. 😔

Generation - better in all ..... Codemasters ???

EA SPORTS WRC: DAMAGE: X Car List : ✓ Content: ✓ Graphics even with 1.3 Patch: X.

Ea wrc is a bad rallygame and everyone who says its good is payed for saying it.

WRC9 looks far better than generations on ps5

WRC GENERATIONS: Game made by small studio with less than 120 people EA WRC: Game made by big AAA studio with 300+ people Lol and generations still look better.

Generations seems so much better across the board

Dirt rally 1 is best rally hame on console

The sound in WRC generations is really bad

I am not sure but, these are my conclusions: - Graphics: WRC Generations done well the car and track details in the 3 weather conditions but somethings like burnt rubber and color were unnecessary as well as unrealistic; EA WRC has realistic graphics, I just think they could have done better the rain stage; despite that, nailed the stages design according to real life. - Sounds: EA Sports WRC (obviously) - Car Chase Cam: EA Sports WRC - Cockpit Cam: EA Sports WRC - Car Damage: Tie (except for some details of the moment on the impact of WRC Generations) - EXTRA: Gameplay: EA Sports WRC My opinions is that, WRC Generations is very good game, but EA Sports WRC with things such as great handling, graphics, modes plus the whole cars of the WRC History will bring many more people to the world of rally...

It looks like it was played on Nintendo Switch

EA WRC Championship has better sound and jump physics, I think that's really it... The Yaris feels way less capable in the new WRC; slow steering, overweight, bad grip in high speed gravel corners and bad grip on low speed tarmac corners. In Generations or even WRC 10 the Yaris has incredible oversteer, the ability to hoon dirt corners at like 120 MPH and still point the car exactly where you need it. Trying to drive Finland's or Estonia's fast gravel roads feels like absolute garbage to me in WRC 1 class in the EA Sports WRC Championship. I can barely twist my car into a dirt corner doing 80 MPH...

WRC generations is almost impossible to play with a controller