He does limp but ive often see that he walks just fine like it's just an error for the actor lol

I doubt cutting off 1 toe will make you very instable. Probably in the beginning but you body might get used to it and find a way to walk

@@Fr_g You cut off your toe and try to walk properly

2 toes actually (on the same foot/left foot)

@@Fr_g yeah, in Friends, Monica cut off Chandler’s toe by accidentally dropping a knife and he made the joke “that’s why for the next year everyone called me Sir Limps-A-Lot lol

The second half has a bunch in the final 3 episodes

Literally. The second half made season 4 my favorite season of You.

The plot twist is insane (literally) 🤣

He needs to watch volume 2

It also kind of explains why everything Nadia said was the same fashion the murders ended up occurring in

I know right 😂😂

already spoiled by saying that mate

@@zee2213 Nah, part 1 was so off-beat that everyone unconsciously would've picked up that there was something funky going on. The writers were cooking up a storm.

@@dainluke Idk kept me guessing atleast. My mind went there just once but definitely didn't guess who the actual murderer was

honestly i think Rhys is the best character of this show, by far... his acting was so incredible, i was speecheless by his talent

he has a podcast

That vocal fry makes me want to rip my ears out.

@@Boobeinstein yup, its too much

His voice is so sexy man i really want an audiobook with his voice

@@Boobeinstein now after watching i thibk the change of the tone of his voice is intentional

no fr🤨 like I don't remember his voice ever sounding that annoying

Literally, bro has that "throat cancer" voice

it’s called getting older

and i love him for that.

i like it 🫢

A glimpse into a serial killers mind, absence of self awareness is what allows them to do what they do 😂

You guessed the guy was rhys right? Like he was the most obvious guess next to Kate.

@@breecoward2289 Saw it coming from a mile away.

@@breecoward2289 Very obvious, like Alex said it was a standard whodunnit that thinks it’s something special. Though, Kate was a little _too_ obvious, so I knew it’d never be her. It was the fact the (on top of Rys being the black sheep of the friend group) he had almost no attention placed on him at all. Joe only suspects him for a minute and only because he’s doing that to everyone else. Rys wasn’t even at the mansion until the very end. Whodunnit killers are always the person the writer tries to make you forget about until the “twist” at the end. And You wasn’t even subtle about it. He wasn’t even in the last two episodes until the end.

@@unofficialbeautyqueen6624 Not everybody bro. A lot of serial killers are perfectly aware of what they do. But they have no conscience and isn't affected by their actions, they even get off on it. Joe here is delusional and has some sort of saviour complex, its different

That’s actually a really good twist! You could be onto something there

I could see that, but that’s almost as dumb as it being Rhys.

ahhhhh u were right (just finished p2)

@@darealtriplegee LMAO u had a goof 11 hours to watch it since you replied to me u sound stupid

@@ed3427 u are an idiot. U said i had 11 hours to watch it like everyone doesnt have a life. You watched all 5 hours as soon at it dropped and decided to spoil it for everyone. You’re a waste of sperm

So were all the characters in season 3, except for Marienne. Suburbian hell vs. posh British hell.

They're supposed to be like that

Like in every season tbh

thing is the show is meant to show you things through Joe's eyes until around Season 3 when perspective shifted to Love but only briefly, so you're annoyance to the characters is also meant to be Joe's annoyance to them. granted we as the audience are able to say that he's a creep bcs we all know he's bein one but it's also kind of like how as a normal person you tend to focus on others more than yourself

What about Kate ? She is obviously unlikeable but she is an interesting character and I like her relationship to Joe so far

it's a friggin university, that ain't no high school lol you don't just go there like hey yey I wanna be a professor lmao there's a ladder you gotta climb ans that shit takes yyyyeeears and years

Isn't it like fucking Oxford?

but he got a resumé saying he graduated from some prestigious university

If only it was that easy to be a HS teacher 🙄

This guy is talking about high schoo not university guys so stop correcting them lol I'm sure they know what they meant

FR. chills lmao they knew what they were doing by making two parts

@@helloworld7944 For Real For Real

I didn't think it was a twist at all. I already knew that was happening since the beginning of the season

@@LenaCourtney cause u read the theories well done u arent special

​@@LenaCourtney can you please spoil me ? I dont want to watch the hole season

‼️Yeah I totally agree! And no one has mentioned that because the series is heavily based on literature that each season follows a lot of the tropes of a certain genre of fiction and then subverts them. The first season is subversion of the romantic comedy novel, the second season idr a lot about honestly, but I think it was more psychological with Joe dealing with himself and his past, a psychological thriller subversion. The third season was a take on the stepford housewives suburbia where everything looks perfect on the outside but everyone has secrets. And this fourth season is about you know the Agatha Christie who dun it detective novel. So far. I have a feeling since the mystery is solved now the second part of the season is going to become a play on the cat-and-mouse genre. I personally love this season so far! I like how Joe realistically jumps through mental hoops and the true to life portrayal of cognitive dissonance. He really believes he's NOTHING like Rhys. When in reality Rhys is a better person than him. Joe harms women who he is obsessed with and manipulates their lives. Controls and hurts them and those who they care about. While Rhys is harming terrible people who use their wealth to hurt those less fortunate. So Rhys is morally a better person than Joe. But as in real life bad people never believe they are bad people. They justify their horrifying actions in their own minds and really believe they are the good guys. EDIT: I HATED the end of the season. But I wonder if next season is going to be like a play on The Wolf of Wall Street genre. Rich guy uses wealth to get away with crimes. Who knows but I really didn't like how Rhys was all in his head the whole time 😭

He’s a master manipulator

Lol u should Wstch the new episode.. they came out like 3 days ago😅

@@omarcalvo977 I watched them all the first day they came and I’ll need therapy for at least 3 business months🤚🏼

@@milk5028 literally Ik joe was fucked but god damn😅

Yk what, I too like to think Dan and Joe are the same people. They might as well be considering the way GG ended 🤷🏾‍♀️.

@@oseremhen9075 Penn Badgley actually talked about this in an interview, same character, different eras.

LMAO

Love this comment hahaha

Serena is supposed to be representative of me

Remember he used to restore old books and even faked a label on a bottle of wine so it seemed expensive… he easily could have forged all of that

Apparently he can also forge references at other universities, who the hiring department would absolutely call to vet him

maybe his fake identity has previous experience? i havent watched the show yet so idk

Joe moved up the ranks higher than Beck ever did and ever could have if she lived

@@jacquelinemiller7422 Forging a label is a bit easier than faking real life connections lmao

Yeah the story is really interesting but somehow the other characters are boring af

​​@@arahqurany5199 I think it was intentional. To show how vain/hollow people are

Me too

@@arahqurany5199 yea they were flat and boring in the first part and I felt like I couldn't even relate to them, hate them or even like them, because they were just flat, but in the second part, I saw a lot of character development, especially with pheobe, kate, roalhd, and phoebe's husband

I just finished it and I literally couldn't close my jaw throughout the last 2 episodes😭😭😭

Part two was a whole roller coaster. My jaw dropped

its great ngl, but honestly the twist made me feel like its a Fight Club knockoff

@@lenavis split personality doesnt belong to fight club

@@lenavis or Mr robot...

Not the ending yet, it was only part 1. part 2 comes out march 9.. then we'll see the true ending

@@literallywhatdoiputhere408 you got confused they’re talking about season 3 the season we’re watching right now is season 4

Yeah, his kid is free from monster parents and his psycho wife was gone along with his life in the states. It could have easily ended there with just the implication "Joe will never change" Its either gonna be a repeating cycle until he dies or ends up in jail since the point isnt about finding someone who loves him since he subconsciously enjoys the hunt

@Andrea Gamez to bw fair they said London instead of Paris which is what we were left with in season 3

put a sock in it!

Im glad i have someone else who enjoys it. I really enjoyed the plot and was gripped all the way through!!😊

I enjoyed it too! I thought it was kinda refreshing l, but still had elements from the past few seasons that made Joe still feel like the first guy from season 1

I think every season was pretty unique. First season was more stalking a new girl, 2nd season was falling for a new girl but new girl also turns out to be murder, 3rd season Joe wants to be a happy family but is angry with his wife fucking things up for him, 4th season Joe wants to start over but someone wants to frame him for murder and it's a who dunnit. Every season is pretty unique imo. Maybe 5th season is going to be more about the police having found out about Joe's murders and he now has to appear in court.

I’m enjoying it too it feels like his character have evolved in my opinion

I also loved it

1- urine doesn’t actually contain any DNA so it’s not real a concern 2- Joe makes some fake antique books to sell for Ellie so it’s implied he keeps sending her money 3- No clue

I completely agree. It would get boring very fast if it was just him obsessing over a girl over and over again. Instead, they made him the prey and seeing Joe have to be the one being stalked instead is genius

Yeah, same. I really enjoyed it.

I also did! I thought it was a great season, I wouldn't have watched it if it was just about another girl

@@kaneywaney173 Its also simple. They didn't overdo anything it was a simple plot line that was easy enough to follow but also had enough twists to keep us from knowing the ending in episode one.

I am so glad they decided to rework the show for this season because Season 3 just felt like the most ridiculous direction you could take the concept and while it was entertaining, it was also really hard to take seriously and it made a lot of people hate even Love by the end of it

Oh interesting

They have a book out?

@@antbanks415there are three books in the you series. Book # 4 comes out this spring

@@antbanks415 Yeah, it's written it's based on the book at start of every episode

@@jessierocket8227 where can you find the books the show is based off of

HAHAH YOU WOT

I woulda been down for him and Rhys to actually have some real rivalry that was a cool aspect to me bc he has met his match but the twist is amazing

Omg

Totally agree

As long as he doesn't get "caught" for a crime he didn't commit. If he tracks down the blackmailer and he dies or gets caught trying to take him/her down, it would make no sense that he's smart enough to get away with those murders but not this one, and would just mean the story ends with the blackmailer just being a better version of him.

I've been wanting to see him suffer

Me too! Ugh. I hate Joe so much. Book Joe is EVEN worse.

Me too!! I just want to see Joe rotting in prison for his crimes, and for all of his victims to finally get their resolution. If this show ends with him getting away again- I would throw my remote at the wall. I do hope they bring the PI investigating Peach‘s death as well as the cop who loved the reporter lady from season 2 back into the deal, and anyone who is able to testify against him.

Nah love was a psycho

@@yourwrongimright101_69 yeah but like, so is Joe, and she didn’t go all psycho until Joe gave her reasons to. 😂 it wasn’t that hard to just be loyal and live a happy life, but because Joe is so psychotic and dissatisfied he couldn’t do that. He literally kills Love and still justified his every action afterwards, showing he is kinda worse.

@@unofficialbeautyqueen6624 she was crazy way before he came in, Joe mostly kills people that somewhat deserves it, while love kills mostly undeserved people for her own selfish needs. He was being loyal at first, yes he did almost full-on cheat but he contained himself and didn't. Whereas Love full-on cheats on him and after he finds out, he didn't wanna be with her anymore and with someone else. He wanted a divorce first but love had other plans, he mostly just countered her tactics and killed her. Both of them don't deserve good things but love definitely deserved what she got.

@@yourwrongimright101_69 Joe rarely killed anyone who deserved it. His story is from his perspective that gives the readers the impression that they deserved it. Joe killed Beck, Elijah, whom of which didn’t really deserve to die. Even Peach, you could argue didn’t deserve to die despite her obsession with Beck. That was not Joe’s call to make. And he was not being loyal if he had intent to cheat. He literally fantasized about the cheating first 😭 Love only ever killed for Joe’s sake is what you’re not realizing. And yes, even though Joe refrained from going through with the full sexual act, they still kissed, he still cheated emotionally and physically. Love didn’t cheat until she discovered Joe did, and that Joe didn’t love her anymore. Yes, they’re both terrible people, but Joe is most definitely top tier bad. Had he been faithful and accepted her as his better twisted half, things would have went different.

@@unofficialbeautyqueen6624 Joe mostly killed people that deserved it like Beck's bf, his neighbour's bf, that gangster guy etc. Obviously there are people that didn't deserve it. Emotional cheating is not worse then literally cheating, he pulled himself back while she didn't. She didn't even give a single thought of talking with him before what she did, while he was willing to talk it through when she did it and not go full on killing. If your sole reason on why Joe is worse is because of emotional cheating, then Candace is the real villain.

I hope You is a fluffy purry cat next season :)

this comment made me love this new season!

I think the Rhys isn’t a killer, and Joe is starting to go crazy. In the end us and or him will realize Joe did the killings and framed Rhys while he was going full schizo. Maybe then he’ll realize he was the danger the whole time

With all my respect, this is the best comment ive seen so far. Everyone is missing the point of this season which brings a new perspective, such as Joe being mirrored by a person exactly like him, forcing him to feel as the victims he hurt. He plays the hero role because he wants to be better, denying his true nature at the same time. He cant accept he s a monster because he s scared of monsters himself. If u pay attention, Joe likes innocent, pure people. As soon as he discovers damage in people he idolized, he would feel repulsed and become cold, avoidant, sceptic, the way he became with Love once he knew she s like him, a predator.

sorry, can you remind me about the stalker's redemption arc?

Right? Same thing every time. See girl, want her, get her, kill for her, she escapes or he kills her. Yawn.

I wish Love had killed him lmao I would’ve LOVED that ending 🙈🫣

@@ash_tray did we watch the same show

I’m just watching bc I’m invested in the story. I don’t mind the nonsense. Pen Badgley could play a fork and I’ll be sit

The season 3 finale was literally one of the best episodes. It would have been a perfect hill for the show to die on, but nooooo. We need to turn it into the next Vampire Diaries

Even spoiled rich people in real life arent as 1 dimensional as the characters in this show.

Lmao the rich guy who literally rationalises executing joe in cold blood and how his rich influential family will protect him and then hunts him like an animal for his own sadistic pleasure. I know they were trying to make these characters unlikable so we sorta rooted for the killer or kept guessing who it was but they seriously couldn't have made them any more 1 dimensional if they tried. It's like their only physical attribute is a fat bank account and a lifetime of never dealing with consequences. The sheer disconnect was just jarring to me.

@@blank2707 that’s the whole point though. It’s explained throughout the season that these are mindless brats, and honestly this is the reality for a lot of rich people, albeit maybe not AS exaggerated but that wouldn’t make for good TV. It actually reminded me a lot of The White Lotus season 2’s commentary on the rich and their lack of moral compass.

@@SolidSnake240 true

@@blank2707 oh interesting

I bet he will walk into the sunset scott free, although i agree he should be arrested

@@heavenlyarianator6335 see don't say that, I'll be so pissed if I watched this entire damn show just for them to give the gross, murdering narcissistic asshat a happy ending! We deserve better than that darn it lol

@@sigal42 i dont want it to end, i love when joe thinks stuff like "why does this keep happening to me?" So i can shout at him "because you wont call the police you psycho!" Lol great times

Why do you watch a show where you dislike the main character and what he does?

@@mikaelb.2070 ......so you...LIKE stalking...and controlling behavior...and gaslighting...aaaaaand murder? Cause that's what Joe does 😂 we're not supposed to like him!

Exactly! It’s baffling.. get some blinds or something, I feel like it’s definitely a British thing

@@whosthatchick5150 nah, I think it’s just a white people thing in general, cause that’s been the only common factor I’ve seen here in the US

that aspect always baffles me as well, just get some blinds or curtains ESPECIALLY if you have windows so close to another building. I live in Europe and everyone has curtains and blinds, there might be some exceptions if the window is facing a field/forest/place with no houses and roads around, but in general if it's possible for people to look inside, be it from other buildings or roads/paths and such we simply put up curtains and once the sun sets blinds. it's such a common sense thing that I don't understand how all those folks never thought of it.

​@@abena736 fr. White ppl just leave their back door unlocked too...they feel so safe in this world its insane.

Tbh blinds if they’re not included with your house/apartment are so expensive 😭 I get why some nsu not have them, especially college students or those who move frequently. But at least get curtains!

and creep Emily so badly they replace here with Sophie who's kind, and opposite of Emily

Lol would’ve been great for him to take her out right away I can’t stand that show or the character

HOW R U HERE FOR EVERY VIDEO LOL

Or the N**** in Paris crossover!

I legitimately just laughed aloud

I feel some repressed feelings In that teacher bit hehe

@@Svol09 Someone makes a compliment and you go: "behind the compliment you have some real big life issues" 🤨 Like what the heck are you doing mate? Come back on earth

@@quirogatnonerrat3214 what the hell you talking about man?I was just joking about the teachers getting hired because they hate kids and have anger issues bit that he made in the beginning. Are you high on something?

@@Svol09 "Alex can NEVER disappoint" - that's literally the comment and then you came and replied with "well I think you hide repressed stuff behind your nice compliment, harumpf!" How on earth do you think anyone would react to your reply? 🤨🤣

@@quirogatnonerrat3214 bro, read my first reply to this comment please, and then think about it

@@NoName12344o yeah, i had to edit my comment too. Didn't realize the word "gruff" was changed to "good". Dude sounds like he gargles marbles as he speaks

@@KitsuneFyoradamn, that’s just his regular voice though 😭

@@unofficialbeautyqueen6624 hey, i ain't saying it's bad. I'm just saying he would make a perfect werewolf

That would have been a pretty predictable storyline. It dosent sound like a bad idea but I don’t think people would like itn

@@AmonsRealm But then it’d just feel repetitive. Sure it’s a stronger storyline than what we got, but it wouldn’t be interesting because the show’s already done that kind of thing many times before.

Sounds very similar to dexter new blood

also if they did this they would have to make sure its planned ahead of time, as well as actually plant hints. Otherwise it'll just feel like an asspull after people bitched about it being the same thing. but in theory its a good idea

If you like this then listen to the books on audible. They don’t follow the same storyline but they have the same Joel obsessing over women. The first season is based off of the first book and it follows it pretty similarly

it's actually a very solid theory, i'm not sure about Marienne, but everything else fits too well imo. Joe was on a crime scene when Simon was killed (which says to me he was the one who initially killed him), the first murder was basically the guy laying on his table, the last murder was to the girl who was irritating to Kate (the girl he's obsessed with although he says he isn't), and other many hints point at him

@@EntrEsprit I mean we have never seen Joe leave a girl alone, he's obsessed with. Therefore I came to the conclusion of Marienne being dead.

@@fidabaloch7601 i thought maybe Joe being in delusion this season, and thinking he isn't the one behind the murders, is caused by the fact that Marienne was the only girl to get away from him, she rejected him for who he is, and therefore he created his Rhys personality who is still killing them all, while Joe sees himself as the guy who is changing for the good

They literally showed Joe committing the murders, when he was publicly being accused of being the Eat the Rich killer. I think your theory is correct

@@fidabaloch7601 but how does that explain when Joe and the other rich guy who loves Kate (forgot his name) are chained up and almost left to die in the cellar? Joe couldn’t have created the fire and chained himself up with another victim.

That honestly sad

you didnt get the 9999999 clues from the first sec on? like stalking her?

i think Joe killed all 3 people this season, and is still obsessed sociopath, he's just in denial, let's see what part 2 gives us

In a way, it's refreshing to see how even when he tries hard to stop his behaviour as he is conscious of how bad it always ends, he still has something like fate/karma getting after him, and how someone like him will deal with it all. Yes he has a (kind of) stalker, but he's Joe, not a random good guy.

I fail to see how. The show constantly repeats itself. Second season was just the first in that Joe gets a new obsession, Delilah is the non-white woman he has a short-lived relationship with, just like Kate/Karen, whatever her name was, and Jenna Ortega’s character just being a different take on Paco in that they’re both meant to humanize Joe and be the troubled kid for him to look out for. Heck, the guy abusing Paco’s mom and the guy that was targeting Delilah’s sister were the exact same character, role-wise. The white guy that's abusing or planning to abuse a non-white female character. The show then repeats itself again by doing the “who killed Delilah” story all over again. Only this time, it’s some guy in his apartment. Add on top the third season getting extremely liberal (tell me a story, don’t preach to me) and I found it pretty damn lame, to be honest. They use the same story in the first season and add little changes to it for the second and third. That’s not intelligent writing. That demonstrates a lack of creativity and a fear of taking risks. It's the same thing over and over, how is that a sign of great writing? And Beck was an idiot. She made herself way too easy to stalk. No curtains, not even when she has men over, didn’t lock her electronics, very easily manipulated by her friends. It was hard to believe. In my opinion, the show’s extremely stupid. I’ll never watch it again.

@@equestrianmidnight5619 how was the third season "getting too liberal" lmfao

⁠@@diorsse “Liberal” because season 3 delved into idiot anti vaxxers and that commenter felt personally attacked.

it aged just fine you's however is weak.

Yay

Yeah, instead of being worried for their lifes every time they were in deadly danger I thought "okay great"

Every new character is absolutely horrible. At least in past seasons, there was at least ONE aspect of the recurring cast that made you sympathize with them where you didn't want them to die. But these British "friends"?? God no!

Yes. YES! It's like watching knives out or glass onion. They made the characters so damn unlikable and unsympathetic.

@@gut853 You know, like sometimes I think this show is intentionally trying to make me hate all rich and famous people. Like, literally not *one single good* rich/famous person in this whole show? I mean, I know that Netflix likes to have political bias in its shows, but does it really need to be that blunt? The only way for the show to fix that is to turn 100% self-aware and tearing down the whole narrative of the show, since it's from Joe's delusional perspective.

Totally agree! Binged it today and really enjoyed it.

can you explain how it’s predictable? I feel like I’m missing something lol

Haha ! Me too

His ex took the dog so that has to suck.

I was wondering the same thing and was looking in the comments to see if I was alone. lol

He divorced his ex about 3 years ago(i dont remember well)

I've been under a rock. I had no idea also 💀

@@CaptainCaterpillars I miss Charlie :(

Lol same🤣🤣

Same

He's not wrong

At what time?

5r6

Yeah I didn’t even get a minute into the video without having to stop and come down into the comments to say that Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 100% needs to be removed from the shit list at the beginning because it’s an incorrect assessment. I’ve never seen mental health so beautifully dealt with in a television medium before. I truly encourage you to watch more of it and reevaluate lol

Thank you for pointing this out Sabrina ❤

CEG is easily one of the best shows to come out of network television in the last decade. It's also not difficult to see even in the first episode that it's deconstructing stereotypes and not leaning into them. I think Alex saw the title of the show and thought it would be good content to make fun of. Because of that, he wasn't actually able to take in the premise the show actually laid out for him.

@@GeekyNerdTheatre I haven't watched the show, but I think it makes sense that he might not be understanding. From what I gather, The comment "I have BPD and I relate to her" is very common whenever this show is mentioned. We live in a time where BPD is still stigmatised and where it is more popular to be judgmental towards people having it. People will say they would want to beat up Amber Heard for punching Johnny Depp. People are understanding of depression nowadays, but they are not so open for the conversation about BPD. I see more youtubers talking about it, but this might take some more time for people to deal with the stigma.

I have BPD, watched 2 eps of this show and hated it

"What kind of sick mind thinks forcing a teenager into the system is doing her a favor?" - Joe talking to Love. -s2/ep10 And look what happened at the end of this season with Nadia... I love the writing in this show.

I actually really enjoyed getting something different. I love that the writers do different each season and this one is the most different. But I get why people didn’t like it

Tbh I think Season 3 should’ve been a Bonnie and Clyde season, but maybe keep the first part so we can explain Joes mommy issues but then tap into Loves issues. But nooooo Love is worse than Joe somehow and needs to be killed and Joe gets away.🙄🙄🙄

Fr i loved love he should have settled down

@@____.__9625 nahhh she was into that neighbour kid and stuff, stuff went a bit crazy. I really doubt love would've stayed faithful had they settled down for life.

the work of great writing does that

I couldn't tell who was the killer until it was revealed who it was. I thought it was the photographer guy obsessed over his uni colleague

@@quirogatnonerrat3214I really was focused on my theory that Nadia was the killer and was so disappointed to just see it was Rhys.

@@quirogatnonerrat3214 rrly??? It was so obvious 😭

True, I was thinking it was the student that he kept getting ideas from. Was her name Nadia? I just felt like it wasn’t a coincidence for her to be as involved but “out of the radar” enough

@@matthewblake8485 Yeah I agree. My initial reasoning was Joe liked her as they kinda had like similar likes and interests. She allegedly dated the Mal guy (can’t really remember his name), and said he let her down (a motive for killing). The stalker at the time also called Kate a bitch, which in my head thought of course she wouldn’t like her because of the cheating. Also times like when she bent her head down in class to reach something, or left Joe’s room right after getting her letter were when she got the texts. Not to mention all the knowledge she knows about murder mysteries. I feel like she’s gonna have some bigger role because of Rhys book she recommend.