Windlass Musketeer Rapier Review
18:57
Пікірлер
@jon2067
@jon2067 4 күн бұрын
Does it have any distal taper ?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 4 күн бұрын
@@jon2067 yes, why would you think it doesn't? All handmade swords have distal taper of varying degrees. The only swords I've actually seen that do not are usually stamped and or pre-cut stainless steel display swords. Regardless the whole distal taper propaganda is overplayed to promote a handful of high-end manufacturers, designers and smiths who have proposed this marketing ploy that "distal tapering" makes enough difference in handling that somehow that equates to function and durability to promote their high asking prices and superiority to lower end swords. Then unfortunately they aquire a handful of die hard supporters who push this propaganda. Why they push it? Because it's easier ride coattails and buy into patreons and sword clubs than putting effort into learning actual sword skill or sword knowledge and feel credited and enlightened when they plagiarize these high-end sword makers. Anyway point is you're only asking because of what I just said and the influence by this sad hive mind mentality towards distal taper. Point is if any sword I ever reviewed or review in the future didn't have actually any distal taper whatsoever it would be noted in the reviews. This is also why I do not measure distal taper because again it is irrelevant and won't tell you how a sword handles. Weight and Point of Balance will tell you how a sword will handle much more than a distal taper increment because the distal tapering factors into those two just as much as profile taper, blade type and hilt configuration. I do very details statistical analysis and measurements in my reviews, if somethings missing then it's either an irrelevant increment or one not worth the time. For example why I don't stat scabbards, seriously who gives a shit how long or wide the scabbard is, it either fits the sword or doesn't right? Anyway sorry if this comes off as a personal rant to you. It's not it's just a final nail in the "distal taper" question coffin that gets asked way too much in my various comments sections. Honestly feel free to share it around.
@valentinvanruiz
@valentinvanruiz 5 күн бұрын
16th century Italy was part of the Kingdom of Spain. So it is technically a spanish sword, not Italuan.😅
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 5 күн бұрын
@@valentinvanruiz That's like saying a Claymore is an English sword. Occupation or territorial domain doesn't erase culture or regional design. The three ring hilt is of Italian design. Just like the Bilbao and Cup Hilt are of Spanish design.
@phoenixprism
@phoenixprism 6 күн бұрын
another youtuber testing his out said the wires on the handle started coming loose, if you've tested it yourselves have you noticed anything else coming loose? also is the pommel peened?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 6 күн бұрын
@@phoenixprism pommel is peened, yes the wire has movement, which they're going to anyway with how they're applied.
@pablofernandez57
@pablofernandez57 7 күн бұрын
Actually the rapier was developed by Spain and we have to keep in mind that by that time most of Italy was part of Spain
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 5 күн бұрын
@@pablofernandez57 Regardless of domain, the three ring hilt was designed by Italians and is known as an Italian hilt. No different than the cup hilt being of Spanish origin. Doesn't mean people's of other regions didn't use these hilt configurations, just that they were prominently used by peoples of and designed in those specific regions.
@billrich9722
@billrich9722 7 күн бұрын
Huh. It looks a lot smaller in the movie.
@sgregg5257
@sgregg5257 8 күн бұрын
That tang looks terrible. Looks like a rat tail to me with the screw end welded onto the tang.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 8 күн бұрын
@@sgregg5257 nah, tang is 3/4" wide and 1/4" thick. No welds, the tang end is roded then threaded at the end. Never had a threaded Windlass fail on me and I have quite a few. Watch the video and you'll see, I give a full view of the tang from all angles.
@Ryan-ob6gp
@Ryan-ob6gp 13 күн бұрын
Great content. I'll check through your library, but whats the method to remove a peened tang?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 13 күн бұрын
@@Ryan-ob6gp much more difficult, you basically have to re-heat the peen and get it soft enough to remove the pommel. It's easier to just re-wrap the grip with the pommel still peened, unless you really want to remove the grip and replace it. Even then on keyed tangs it's more simple to remove the grip with the peen intact and sandwich method the new grip as the Peened Pommel will stay in place.
@user-zd2uf4bg9i
@user-zd2uf4bg9i 15 күн бұрын
Класс
@erichusayn
@erichusayn 18 күн бұрын
Looks like good cutter.
@occupymybrain869
@occupymybrain869 19 күн бұрын
Have one, love it.
@marvindavid1276
@marvindavid1276 19 күн бұрын
Is it rigid enough? The other rapier with the same hilt is supposedly very floppy. I bought a hanwei replacement blade for a custom rapier and was very disappointed: blade is 6mm at the base has perfect distal taper and is still very floppy, point was bend and the secondary bevels are done at a 45° angle and the blade does not spring back to true entirety
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 19 күн бұрын
It is, it has flex but not whippy at all compared to others I've handled, completely different blade than the 17th Century Italian Rapier, just the same hilt.
@jimmydesouza4375
@jimmydesouza4375 20 күн бұрын
Hah. I saw bearing swords when I went to the Leeds Armory Museum years ago. I thought they looked cool as all hell but forgot what they were called and could never find more information on them. I find more info on them a couple of hours ago after it popping in to my memory and remembering that I have chatgpt now and then you mention them too. What an odd coincidence. If I were to buy a decorative sword to hang on a wall it would be one of those. They just look so impressive.
@garettallen4963
@garettallen4963 22 күн бұрын
I am wondering if you happen to know if the battle cry messer has the same blade as the cold steel messer? If so what are your thoughts on that? Thank you!
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 22 күн бұрын
Sorry not familiar with either messer. Probably very similar though as anything made in India and sold by Cold Steel is made by a subsidiary of Windlass.
@k9m42
@k9m42 24 күн бұрын
Looks like a gladius on steroids
@danzielinski5036
@danzielinski5036 24 күн бұрын
cool
@greganderson1519
@greganderson1519 27 күн бұрын
The skeleton was a giant who came back to life in the original stories. God i love that sword! Conan rulz
@bjornh4664
@bjornh4664 29 күн бұрын
Nice review! It answered some questions I had about the Windlass version. As for the threaded tang/steel tube grip, I would avoid using the sword for cutting anything more solid than plastic water bottles or tatami mats. Hitting a pell will most likely cause vibrations that might result in the pommel falling off, the threads being a potential failure point.
@AFStudiosMedia
@AFStudiosMedia 29 күн бұрын
I own this sword
@kamaeq
@kamaeq Ай бұрын
IIRC, the Albion version is more historical in function and the actual prop was an aluminum alloy made thick which was why it is too heavy.
@xXxCatsnakexXx
@xXxCatsnakexXx Ай бұрын
Aluminium castings AND hollow, with an aggressively distal-tapered blade & much deeper fuller is the way to go. Having the bevels look the same as this version, AFTER distal tapering would be the only challenging part.
@georgec5769
@georgec5769 Ай бұрын
So is this one battle ready unlike the marto variants?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Correct. Marto use Stainless Steel, this one is Carbon Steel.
@raycavazos8927
@raycavazos8927 Ай бұрын
Sword in thumbnail is almost a carbon copy Master Sword
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Which show just how much inspiration this sword had on all the film and video game swords before it. The Atlantean has about 10 years on the Master Sword being designed in 81-82. If you're a fan of Zelda or the Master Sword you should check out my review of the functional Master Sword I reviewed as well.
@Bradimus1981
@Bradimus1981 Ай бұрын
I would love for you to do a video of the sword that the late Jody Samson supervised making at Albion Armory. I wish I had ordered one when they were first released, because they are even more expensive now. My issue with the sword you are reviewing right now is that the size is not correct. The Atlantean sword from the first Conan film had a pretty small handle. Arnold was not able to grip it with both hands. That is why the sword had some changes to it in the second film.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
It's the same size, yes they extended the handle of the Destroyer Film Sword, but that also shows in the Albion version as well. Arnold griped the Barbarian Film Sword two handed, it shows especially when he grips it in the Witch's Hut and during his training after being resurrected by Akiro. It would be nice to have one of those but like you their price is out of my reach.
@spock_elvis
@spock_elvis Ай бұрын
What's the significance of the point of balance?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
It's the balance point of the sword and where it centers to the overall weight of the sword. A more forward (closer to the tip) P.O.B is going to make the sword more tip heavy and I general feel heavier in hand. A more back (closer to the guard) P.O.B is going to feel less heavy and more light in hand.
@spock_elvis
@spock_elvis Ай бұрын
@@DynamoSwordChannel Ok. Thanks. I wonder if it's difficult for the swordsmith to figure out were the point of balance will be while in the process of making a sword.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
It could be depending on their experience, there's a lot of factors that can change point of balance, overall weight, distal and profile taper, as well as the weight of the guard and pommel. Fullering can also effect point of balance.
@edwardromanada8650
@edwardromanada8650 Ай бұрын
Conan had 0 to do with Atlantis.....
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
True, but the Howard always stated that Cimmerians were descendent of Atlanteans and that Kull was an ancestor of Conan which was further emphasized in the Marvel books when they started their Kull series.
@raymcdonald4603
@raymcdonald4603 Ай бұрын
Dont need to cut weight,grow your arms...it was meant for Conan
@MegaCecko111
@MegaCecko111 Ай бұрын
Hi, complete amateur here. What did you use to do the polishing please?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Flitz brand polish. It pretty easy to find in most hardware stores in the US if your located in the USA. You can also buy it online at Home Depot or Amazon. Sword vendors KultofAthena and Museum Replicas also sell it.
@MegaCecko111
@MegaCecko111 Ай бұрын
@DynamoSwordChannel thanks a lot, Iam not in the US, but Europe, can see though that it is available here as well, overall, was split whether to get the Marto or Windlass edition, but seeing that the pommel can be polished on the Windlass, then its decided. To follow up if I may, considering its carbon steel, do I have to oil it regularly if placed on a wall naked?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Yea a monthly oiling will do or use the flitz on the blade too at least once a month pending handling or humidity.
@MegaCecko111
@MegaCecko111 Ай бұрын
@@DynamoSwordChannel much appreciated
@leemastro9904
@leemastro9904 Ай бұрын
In the book, Conan had to fight the undead king, who attacked him, when he took the sword.
@MIKE_THE_BRUMMIE
@MIKE_THE_BRUMMIE Ай бұрын
I love the black price one a bit better just because I feel the pommel on this one is way to beefy its a chungus of a pommel
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
True but it's size is what makes it so effective. Gives both good counter balance to the thicker heavier blade plus keep your back hand tight and in place for thrusting.
@MIKE_THE_BRUMMIE
@MIKE_THE_BRUMMIE Ай бұрын
@@DynamoSwordChannel Oh for sure I bet it makes the tip like a laser pointer hahaha I'd imagine it is lovely to handle, I'm just aesthetically not drawn to the look but the blade profile I love ❤️
@TheTransam4350
@TheTransam4350 Ай бұрын
Did you ever do cut test with this? I bought 2 of them 2 years ago. I love this sword, favorite fantasy sword of any game/movie/comic etc.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
No, haven't really had the time to get around to sharpening it and do the test video.
@TANKTREAD
@TANKTREAD Ай бұрын
Come on, no AWESOME power of Basil Poledouris during the review?
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Would've loved to but wanted to be safe and keep the video around lol.
@charlesolinger9735
@charlesolinger9735 Ай бұрын
I think the joke is. You need to be a grown ass man to swing this to be effective. "weight" hah. This meant to shatter shields of smaller lesser men.
@michaelhughes7718
@michaelhughes7718 Ай бұрын
When Conan took the sword, it wasn't rusty or corroded. It was encased in an old rotted scabbard, which he removed showing an immaculate blade.
@victorriceroni8455
@victorriceroni8455 27 күн бұрын
Really? That is interesting. I love the sound it made when he was knocking the scunge off the sword.
@johnbrasseaux5724
@johnbrasseaux5724 25 күн бұрын
The Dead king also comes to life and tries to kill Conan when he takes the sword, in the books and original comics.
@michaelhughes7718
@michaelhughes7718 25 күн бұрын
Lord that's such an overused trope, when I was a kid playing D&D my favourite paranoid rogue used to carry nets around because if you were in a room full of skellies along with a lever/button or treasure you'd throw them on the skellies before you touch anything.
@ourkeving
@ourkeving 23 күн бұрын
​@@michaelhughes7718 metagaming! lol
@michaelhughes7718
@michaelhughes7718 22 күн бұрын
@ourkeving True dat, he also magically carried several thick treetrunks to stop doors slamming shut and block descending cielings and crushing walls, hosepipes, and air bladders in case of flooding rooms as well as other odds and ends including a garden roller, barrels full of water and a ten foot barge pole to poke suspicious things. It was his quirk. He was paranoid about everything, a conspiracy theorist and a rabid flat Toril-er "if Toril isn't flat explain maps" he was also convinced his family was kidnapped by tiny goblins flying dinner plates, like magic carpets, after his family vanished after telling him to wait in the town square until they get back. "The little bleeders also stole the furniture and sold the house." Man, I miss those days.
@user-ck5ys3eb6x
@user-ck5ys3eb6x Ай бұрын
Nice video! Keep up the good work you are doing! Cheers from Greece!
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Thanks!
@TheGoldenBear79
@TheGoldenBear79 Ай бұрын
Thanks so much David, I have been wanting to hear someone that’s familiar with the Oakeshott typology explain it enough to have a better understanding of it! You have perfect timing Sir! 😂 Thanks again, I’m looking forward to the next one! Best wishes to you and your family. ✌️🇺🇸
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Thanks! Glad you're enjoying the series! I'll be posting a new part every Tuesday.
@nickbonavita1379
@nickbonavita1379 Ай бұрын
Good review but with one mistake. The guard and pommel are not " solid brass " they're plated. But you're not paying the $3,000 plus price of the Albion either.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Albions are bronze this one is brass. I polished it down enough that if it was plated it would've shown alloy underneath if not brass.
@user-ck5ys3eb6x
@user-ck5ys3eb6x Ай бұрын
Looking forward to that very interesting series of videos! Cheers from Greece!
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Thanks! I'll be posting a new part of the series every week!
@BLADESKNIVESBROTHERHOOD-vn3bn
@BLADESKNIVESBROTHERHOOD-vn3bn Ай бұрын
Thanks for this video Sir❤❤❤
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
You're welcome!
@user-ub9xw8ro3y
@user-ub9xw8ro3y Ай бұрын
Nice review! I bought the Albion version back around 2005, before the Windlass version was made. Though the Albion is a very nice piece, for the price, I think I would have been just as happy with this version, not to mention $2000+ richer! I did, however, consider getting the WIndlass scabbard for my Abion, but after looking into it, there seemed to be some minor size differences that would prohibit it from fitting the Albion. As a humorous side note, and absolutely no offense intended, the way you use your hands to gesture at the sword immediatley made me think of you as the Vanna White of sword reviews lol!
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Lol thanks! Yea I get told that a lot that I talk too much with my hands, keeps people from standing too close lol!!
@westtlink
@westtlink Ай бұрын
I know Chrono when I hear it 😊
@candyshop84106
@candyshop84106 Ай бұрын
Great review. I like this guy. Subscribed...
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Thanks!
@candyshop84106
@candyshop84106 Ай бұрын
I own the 90's Stainless Version. Is a Two. Handed Sword. The Half sword technique is Unique..Is like a short spear. If a guy had Super Strength, then the sword would be very formidable. I think feeling the weight as a mere human. I was weight lifter and still could feel the weight... Made for a Giant shows the Super Human Stregth Of Conan...😎...
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
The Marto one from the TV series? Or the Marto 90s movie model?
@christopherlanger3159
@christopherlanger3159 Ай бұрын
I found a sword in the trash and it was thrashed, but the blade is straight and no nicks
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Interesting, display type sword or is it a functional model?
@christopherlanger3159
@christopherlanger3159 Ай бұрын
@@DynamoSwordChannel display for sure. Claims to be 440 but there's no way
@christopherlanger3159
@christopherlanger3159 Ай бұрын
Also it's only half tang
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
@@christopherlanger3159 well that's sucks, but hey who finds a sword in the trash right? Kinda a cool find beats dirty diapers lol.
@codycarter7638
@codycarter7638 Ай бұрын
My son got one of those….his first sword he bought from Windlass came from their “Battlecry”:collection-(I have the Battlecry Buckler shield, actually)-along with their Oakshot Type XIV Arming sword-(my personal favorite)-along with their Bastard sword, amd the Damascus Viking sword, which was my first Windlass purchase…I just got their pole axe, which is “meh”, but generally speaking, for the money that you spend, Windlass offers a very good selection of swords…I’m most DEFINITELY a fan, although I really wish they would do a Langes Messer….I mean, technically, they DO make one: the Cold Steel version of one, at least. I own one of those too-(I’m a HEMA enthusiast)-as well as their “grosse messer” I also have Windlass’s “Crusaders axe”, amd absolutely LOVE it. Outstanding presentation, sir! You’ve earned yourself a subscriber!
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel Ай бұрын
Thanks! Yea sounds like you got some solid Windlass items in your collection. Ironically I too just purchased the PoleAxe and Crusader. Like them both, if I had a critique it would be the Pole Axe is just a little too short, be a lot better if it was around 6'. Also check out their site they just released a new Messer under their Battlecry Line you might like! Appreciate the support and subscription!
@ahhamartin
@ahhamartin 2 ай бұрын
Always loved how to the huge skeleton it was merely a one hand sword.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 2 ай бұрын
Definitely, one of the best parts of the movie was the tomb scene.
@Or_else_it_gets_the_hose_again
@Or_else_it_gets_the_hose_again 2 ай бұрын
Love this content! BTW, Thames is pronounced "tems" to rhyme with "tens". ;-)
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 2 ай бұрын
Thanks! Yea not the most linguistic but I try lol.
@preparedsurvivalist2245
@preparedsurvivalist2245 2 ай бұрын
The empty college bar scene as a background is an interesting choice, but yea, that's a grail ninja sword for sure.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 2 ай бұрын
Not college, we're a local sports bistro, owner is into surfing, but we're in Idaho so it throws some people off lol. Definitely it is a real awesome sword!
@invenio1978
@invenio1978 2 ай бұрын
Although this was 2 years ago, after watching the video today I went ahead and bought it. Thank your for the thorough review.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 2 ай бұрын
You're welcome, glad it helped with your decision!
@vapormissile
@vapormissile 2 ай бұрын
How about the sword his dad made at the start of the film...
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 2 ай бұрын
I was going to buy it a few months ago but it got pushed back for the Rapier and Master Sword I reviewed. Also I bought two of the Windlass Royal Armouries swords the 14th Century Long Sword and the 15th Century Two-Handed Sword so should have both of those reviews out in the upcoming weeks. From what I've heard it's a good sword, heavy like the Atlantean but not as heavy and we'll built. I'll let you know when I end up buying one and when a review it!
@vapormissile
@vapormissile 2 ай бұрын
@@DynamoSwordChannel how about his dad's sword after the Atlantean sword snapped it in half. I'd hang that on my wall. Maybe a replica head of Thulsa Doom alongside. ❤️
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 2 ай бұрын
@@vapormissile Yea that'd be cool. I think there were a few broken replicas made out of resin for sale on various sites. Idk about the head though... character or not I'd just see James Earl Jones lol!
@vapormissile
@vapormissile 2 ай бұрын
@@DynamoSwordChannel Right on. The giant headless anaconda would be too big.
@JiyuKishiParn
@JiyuKishiParn 2 ай бұрын
I myself started with an old Highlander stainless steel display sword that I was given as a birthday present about 25 years ago. Thankfully, I didn't try cutting anything more than cardboard boxes with it. It wasn't until much later that I acquired my first real sword from a mall shop that was going out of business, an Onikiri katana that may have been a step up from their usual baseline models, though still 1045 steel, but with a better heat treatment and better fittings. I've had it for nine years and handled it a lot, ito is still tight, habaki and tsuba still tight, and even the saya still holds the sword in when turned up. Most of my collection are budget ranged price. The only one that isn't is The Vindaaris from DSA.
@DynamoSwordChannel
@DynamoSwordChannel 2 ай бұрын
Nice, yea I think most of us have started in that phase regarding being sword collectors. My first sword too was a cheap Flea Market Katana with red nylon ito and a silkly embroidered saya that looked like one of the presentation boxes most mid tier functional katana come with. My first real sword was a birthday gift when I was 14 and is the Deepeeka 1860 Saber. You can see it in my collection video as I still own it. First Functional sword I ever bought was a Hanwei Practical Katana in 2003.