Tilly the Kid really needs to think about what she wants to do BEFORE her turn starts. She completely obliterates the flow of the game on every single turn. Come on girl, love ya and everything but the content really suffers from the Analysis Paralysis. Rosey broke a serious game table etiquette rule by Messing with another player's board. To most people, it's not that serious but a lot of people I know would consider that as unacceptable rude behavior and would be offended by that. I would personally have to talk with her about it privately and calmly in a friendly manner but repeat offenses would eventually warrant her not being invited to the gaming table.

Wow I know this is a year old but why is Manila in the wrong county lmao

Balanced play by both teams as I felt they both made some poor decisions at key points leads to quite and entertaining game. Spoilers below Dom killing Ken feels like such a throw but town was so lost I feel they go for the mayor win no matter what and I don’t see evil working well enough with sully to claim the win.

How did I know Tilly was also a Cancer before she said it? Love it and I'm interested 🤣

When jon's Lycanthrope kill didn't work they should have executed him that day (I'm still watching so this could happen, but it doesn't seem likely). - If he's drunk, then he's expendable. - If he picked Dom and it failed because Dom couldn't die then you would presume the demon would kill the lycanthrope. The fact this didn't happen would suggest that Jon is either not the lycanthrope and lying or is the marionette.

it's a shame Laurie didn't use the established price for the shoes, after all Dom already established the value of a sole😄

Faramir and Eowyn are definitely briefly shown together in the movies, but it's only obvious that they're together at Aragorn's crowning ceremony right at the end of the last movie.

like 24 mins in, Sully goes back 1

Spoilers **** Wow, minions fumbled the finish there, if they tie the final vote for john evil would have won

All I can think of for drawing “very” is trying to draw “vary” instead (assuming that doesn’t break any rules), which sounds exactly the same but seems like it would be just a little bit easier. Maybe drawing a bunch of different versions of the same thing a few times? And a graph or something? There’s the expression “your mileage may vary” so maybe try to draw two cars and try to draw one of them old and beat-up? …Yeah, I don’t really know to be honest.

“I was told to stay here” “who told you to stay here olie??😅” “Laurie told me to stay here😢”

I was really looking forward to tthis vido but this was pretty rough, a lot of rules weren't followed properly and the gameplay was pretty sloppy. I love this game and would love this to be played again properly.

"Arbitrarily chosen to be the most sus player and role-to-claim..."

The conversation between Tegan, Dan, and Sully taking about one minute to devolve into “We did the Bay of Pigs” was incredible

Blair is such a bad evil player and still won because Ken carried so hard. I hate this game LOL (this conviced me not to buy it, though, I dont think I´d enjoy it). Ken is probably my favorite player right now, followed by Dom and Sully.

jon’s room looks like the prison in andor

Either "No new characters were created last night" or "Last night, at least one person was poisoned." Both of these are correct Day One savant info. Can someone help me?

1:02:00 I haven't watched the rest of the game yet, so this may have worked out well for him, but I feel Ken protecting himself after that day was a waste. Considering they assume Ken is Devil's Advocate and Sully doesn't die, they will probably assume Ken to be protected anyways and to hang Sully. This would allow him to protect himself the night after Sully gets hanged and get an extra day of living. Just my two cents. Obviously I have outsider knowledge, so it is hard to know what everyone is thinking in the moment.

Based on this... I think I need to change my name.

So much invoking! It never Ra-ns but it pours...

re-watching, wish I could give it a second like.

didnt dom throw the game by nominating at the end? i thought there was enough votes on laurie. He gave town an extra chance to vote for no reason

Could John have a word with PJP please - all their South Wales outlets shut 6 months ago, and I have SO MANY Papa Points to spend lol

Totally puzzled why so many people in the comments are calling Dom the DM. This isn't DnD and they're not all playing murder hobos, there are no dungeons or dragons and bizarre monsters aren't popping out of tiny alcoves they couldn't possibly fit in. They're playing CoC and Dom is the Keeper of Arcane Lore.

I think the game seems like a lot of fun, though i do think being able to invoke Ra unlimitlessly, on a player's turn, does have an affect on the flow of game play. For a future addition of the game i would like to see a limit on the amount of times a player can invoke Ra on their turn. Maybe something like 1-2 players have 4 tokens to invoke Ra, 3-4 players have 3 tokens, 5-6 players have 2 tokens, and then 7-8 players have 1 token. As always though another great video.

why is this shit so blurry bro

they nrrd to rewrite the rules to where if you go off board you should get put behind last place.

****Spoiler**** "Wait, D-Dom, you Gambled me, you know I'm good!" Oof that realisation kicking in! What an ending!

This is frustrating if the DA would have just voted forthe amnesiac (at which he could) there wouldn't be a mayor win and his demon will be safe from execution. Logically speaking the DA should have voted

I don't get why the DA voted against his demon then decided to tie the amnesiac vote? What gives there was a very high possiblity of a mayor win and you tied the vote? You were the last to vote so why support the mayor? It feels like the DA was secretly on the good side on this play. 2:01:16

Sullivan’s bachelor actually sounds like a catch 😂

Got this game for my birthday, never played it as friends/family never wanted to learn the rules. It’s still on my shelf collecting dust. 😢

11th November 1984 11th November 1984 11th November 1984

Dom is such an incredible GM. I'm a new fan so this may already exist, but I would love to see GMing classes from him

Dan isn't getting enough credit for his plays in this episode, he was so damn close to unraveling the entire script.

This game is AMAZING!!!!

Watching pre game, So leech picks Vizier...game over? Bc what evil character would poison the Vizier? And they can't execute leech, OR Vizier right?

For someone who claims they're a spent roll, they spend a lot of time trying to convince the town to not kill them and that's definitely something an evil player, namely a demon would do.