Empire POV: Cape = Stylish Rebel scum ✍🏼

Make a version with this scene instead of making stupid series no one asked for.

What was the woman's problem with Luke?

Some please tell me what academy they are referring to?

"Nationalise commerce in the central systems..." Yep, George Lucas wrote this

Nice cut. The deleted scene didn't fit tonally, but gives so much good exposition, and helps fit in the prequels better.

Always felt the woman In the scene Was reys grandmother or something

"Nationalize commerce"? Sounds like communism to me.

The talk of nationalizing commerce and in context here of farming (albeit for water in this case) is another example of how much has changed. Story like this exists because it is based upon the history that should teach us. Someone wouldn't use that unless it was to clearly build up the backdrop and the motivations of characters in a relatable way. Now it is more common to delude oneself simply out of spite. Sure, I'll support tyranny, because <insert icon you don't like here> bad... very bad.

See the empire was evil because it nationalized industry (communism/socialism) But most people don’t understand that.

It would be really cool if Disney+ had like 3 different versions of the movie. One version would be the original 1977 theatre version without any edits except upgraded quality. One version would be the current version of the movie they have now. The third version would include all of the deleted scenes as part of the movie.

I know this is an old post but I agree with most here. They should have left this scene in the movie. Gives Luke a better backstory. Loved the ships coming out of hyperspace at the end.

I still dislike the ending of Rogue One. A New Hope heavily implies a cleaner getaway for the stolen plans. Why would they pretend to be a diplomatic mission if they were pursued from the moment they left the Death Star until they were finally caught? There's no sane reason to attempt such a deception in the Rogue One scenario, so the movies fit together poorly. It should have been a clean getaway, but the Empire starts putting together a few clues to track them. Then, after a few weeks, they finally locate them. Then, it makes sense to try and lie to the Empire when they get boarded.

So stupid , they were just talking openly about the rebellion on the roof top looking into the sky .....Then all of a sudden lets get quite about it ! 1:19 and then 1:50

That dialogue….wow….just wow.

Biggs reminds me of Lalo Salamanca

I think it flows really well and I didn't even notice the new scenes you added on first watch. Well done! It took me a second to catch on to the "boy called wolf" narrative but I think it's because I've already seen the footage. Also, keep in mind that the theatrical release of the lightsaber scene in Obi-Wan's home was also presented dramatically out of order for better pacing and a more sympathetic narrative. It's not unheard of in any given film, and VERY common in ANH.

gandalf

Buying weed from Biggs and playing foosball at Tache Station…

I like the part where the plans are literally handed over to the ship with Vader looking on and then suddenly he is on that very ship days later saying "I know you intercepted those transmissions"...oh wait, I am supposed to pretend that shit makes sense like everyone else here. It was a SHIT ENDING to Rogue One, it was written quickly as a last minute ending not long before its release and was not even done by anyone doing the rest of the movie and was CLEARLY written by someone that did not fucking pay attention to EP 4s opening and no, I am not going to pretend it fits. The plans were supposed to been intercepted while being transmitted from one place to another AND there is supposed to be a DOUBT that they were even on the ship. Does not help at all that the scene contains a video game boss Vader doing shit that makes his fighting in the originals all wrong.

Lucas was dabbling in the political stuff even then. Whomever was Editor did a good job on him.

I prefer nothing to be connected to the original from Effing D.

seeing the Tantive IV and the Star Destroyer show up in the sky was a great touch, it's a bummer that they took it out

this is legit.

Holy crap, there was another woman in A New Hope?

I know that this scene was shot before Lucas and his fellow writers came up with the concept of "Hutt space" but since in-lore Hutt space exists, this scene makes no sense. The Empire had a non-aggression treaty with the Hutt cartel.

there so much great stuff about this scene, i think one really good shot is seeing the corvette and star destroyer from ground level, it really puts into perspective what an average person would see if you weren’t involved with the conflict

missis ghalla ou fruit , zakariass lloll or assa say in ancient moutain? no... long long.. alone with an ... owwww (x) be the hope of alah

I absolutely love this. I wish Disney would do something like this. Great work on editing.

about a minute in when Luke says "But there was a lot of firing earlier!" Makes sense if its the Destruction of Scarif. You really did make a seamless transition, Bravo!

Who was the girl that took the binoculars away from Skywalker. She was taken off one of the biggest movies in history

Wow! That is pure unadulterated evidence of how bad George Lucas' dialog writing was. In the words of Harrison Ford "Nobody can say that shit".

And i thought the dialogue in the actual film was terrible

Luke: you’ll always be the best friend I ever had. Han: hold my beer

Funny how that led straight into the beginning of a new hopes intro...js

Its insane these scenes get deleted. They add so much context. Just like LOTR’s.

They can delete Rogue One and problem solved.

This would have aged like fine wine. Knowing Luke is on a random, insignificant planet seeing the battle for the Death Star plans really sets a huge scale for the movies. Hindsight is 20/20 I suppose

1970's close-talk acting is too homoerotic for my taste

Watching Rogue One then A New Hope is unintentionally hilarious. Just grade A gaslighting. Vader: where are the Death Star plans?! Leia: how dare you?! I’ve never heard of such a thing! Vader: we literally watched you take off with the plans on board like 15 minutes ago! Leia: nope, no clue what you’re talking about, I’m on a diplomatic mission. Vader: …is she serious? You guys are hearing this too, right?

Star Bores, is that the incestuous show with the brother who lays its princess sister and father os dark and its cousins brother haves a Baka that likes to chewee at the end of the brother and sisters love shack?

Out at Tache station, got my foosball fix in AND a bag of Mary Jane from Biggs.

You’ll always be the best friend I ever had… until Han comes around. 🤷🏻‍♂️

I like this. Idk y

I love the talks, deleted scenes give so much to the published movie, especially seeing them years after

Uh rouge one sucked just like every thing Star Wars released after Revenge of the Sith.

Boring.

Man I wish they had kept this scene with Luke and his friends in the film! I love how you chose to put these clips together. It adds some cool nuance to the storytelling 👍🏻

I love it so much

Wtff biggs Is casian andor Is biggs Is casian lol