Oops!

Yeah midnight motorist was always simple but people were looking too far into (and the spring Bonnie hed on the car could be a red herring)

We?

oh no, my theory its breaking apart, its fine, i mean already create another route to explain it, but this one is even more crazy than before it, at least we know hide and seek from fazbear frigths is about mike and crying child

The animatronic footprints in midnight motorists could possibly be a mysterious animatronic like golden freddy or shadow freddy or shadow bonnie I just giving you ideas to make your thoughts on what took place in midnight motorists more easier for you to think of 👍

I don't believe in anything until Scott or Stellwool confirmed it (but I believe JR's is Fazbear location

Welp it's crazy how aftonmm basically got confirmed by flaf

Ozone made a video about Nightmarionne and he explained why there's so much Nightmarionne plushies and also about the staff bots in the sewers representing it

7:59 building off of this thought, if William did have a history of stalking this family and learning their habits/routines he might have even gotten his hands on Mustard Man’s car and used it so that to frame him since he was already a suspect.

The Scooper is an interesting device, and I wonder where this will go next? 🤔😀🤔

There’s no doubt the Staff Bots are a strange yet interesting set of characters. 🤔😀 I am excited to see where Steel Wool will go with these guys. Especially with Mask Bot most likely co raining the body of Cassie’s dad. I do hope we’ll see him more, and Cassie will get closure to what happened to her dad. Edit: The Staff Meeting is no doubt a mystery, and your claims are pretty convincing. 🤔😀👍

Imo people think it's William because Matpat said it, even tho the evidence is shaky I think Mr. Mustard is a missing kid's dad, it's obvious from the footprints and the Toy Chica cutscenes, and for the fact the 2 other minigames in Fnaf 6 are about Freddy's victims Also, "Later That Night" is a LOT more likely to mean "the night after the main Midnight Motorist minigame", there's no connection between Security Puppet and this minigame

I actually love the idea that this mustard man was technically framed for William’s killings, even more so than the other theory I see of it being Henry getting blamed.

Watch Five Laps at Freddy’s come out and have a secret that makes Midnight Motorist even more complicated, throwing all our theories out the door

what if the answer to midnight motorist is into the pit... hear me out

I have a theory as to why the tear streaks don't show up for the newer bots. It's the same reason the newer bots don't kill you, the tear streaks are a representation of their free will and ability to act independently. My guess is once fazbear entertainment found a way to lock down and strip a soul's free will and independence, those tear streaks stopped showing up. And as a result, they'd do virtually anything that was asked of them. This would also make the "mask bot is Cassie's dad" theory a LOT darker, considering this would imply that there was hardly anything left of his soul by the time ruin rolls around.

i came from ozones video, very interesting video!

I have a theory that the Midnight Moterist house is the house we see in the FNAF 4 menu screen and also the FNAF 4 house has been shown in Fall Fest in Curse Of Dreadbear and Help Wanted 2! So what if the run away kid ran to Fall Fest, the yellow man said "Ran Off To That Place Again." He didn't say pizzeria or any restaurant, just said 'place' so the yellow man could be preferring to Fall Fest. And I also have a theory that the foot prints could potentially be Glitchtrap's since he has 3 toes and Glitchtrap is potentially connected to Fall Fest. This might be a setup to Fall Fest and the Mimic potentially.

Congrats on 300 subscribers!

nice vid man. cool to hear a Scottish fnaf fan lol Im Scottish myself

Came from Ozone's channel, love the theory! Especially the idea of the car being used as evidence to convict someone who isn't William! Who knows, maybe it's even the same purple car, but one person stole it from the other! (Either Mustard Man stole William's car, or vise versa)

I was gearing up to write a comment about how it makes sense, but doesn't seem to have enough narrative significance to bother putting into a minigame. The false conviction, though… that's clever.

there is a dead kid in that one fnaf 4 minigame where crying child gets locked in the employees only room by mike what if the dead kid is possibly the son from this theory

I think I have a solution : I think the minigame happened before cc was even afraid of the animatronics, and, because He was running to the restaurant everyday to see fredbear and sprongbonnie, and that was really annoying for William, so he decided to scare his son from the animatronics, because he doesn't want his son to get too close to the springlock animatronics and get injured (This aged well)

Scary! With the scattered knowledge I have of SB I assumed the human staff was just gone for the night- that didn't explain the lack of human touch for employees (break rooms etc.) where there should have been though. Cool stuff!

I'm still leaning towards Mustard Man being Henry. I don't know if it makes sense in terms of other theories, but just the fact that another monochrome guy is introduced for the first time, in the same game where Henry first appears... I dunno, it seems like it would be almost bad writing for that not to be him.

What I don't get about people that believe Jr's is another Freddy's location is that how many family restaurants have _bouncers_ , let alone ones standing out in the pouring rain at night when the place would be closed? Scott just needed a generic name for a bar and "Jr's" was one he picked. It could've been "Steve's", "Tim's", "Moe's" etc. A bar owner naming the place after themselves isn't that uncommon.

The staff bots that look like nightmare puppet are apparently called the alpha staff bots which could be the reason they were scrapped maybe the spirit had to much control because that the spirit’s in fnaf have to abide by the programming of whatever robot they possess

I love this theory omg, it’s nice to hear different takes and theories rather than the same ones retold over and over again. You executed it together really well :)

I just CAN'T get over how they drive on the left side of the road. I know it's likely a mistake and this minigame does take place in America but it infuriates me

I think i've watched up to 30 different videos about this minigame now lmao

Its definitely william lol I feel like ppl are just saying its not to be contrarian. It doesnt make any damn sense for it to be anyone else

Good job with the video! I never really understood the belief of Yellow Man being William. From a story standpoint, it doesn't really tell us anything if it is William, and contradicts the few facts we already do know about him.

On the scooper blueprint it says that it is a remnant injector so the one on security breach could do the same thing potentially

My theory is: Mustard Man is the abusive alcoholic father of an undetermined male MCI kid, and William came to the house in the evening in a gutted/non-springlock suit (doesn’t make sense why Afton would risk the rain, he was a lunatic but he wasn’t an idiot) the child wanted to come along with him to the location, but the child could not break the window. William broke the window for him (glass is not visible outside, so the child could not have broken out himself, possibly the father took away any objects he could break the glass with after the previous time?) and he led the child back to the main location and to the “secret party” with everyone else, and then he killed them (in order for the kid to be considered “killed at Freddy’s” as the poster notice says) It was likely that William knew where he lived because of the distance and because it seems this kid was the most fanatic about Freddy’s of all the MCI kids, so William would have a higher chance to get to know him (the kid probably overshared a bunch) The mound is probably the Mustard Man’s wife/family member or someone he killed in a DUI accident I don’t think the Mustard Man could be connected to and framed for the MCI murders, sure he has a purple car and history of child abuse but his connection to Freddy’s is slim and he was only known to abuse his own son, so it doesn’t make sense why he would kill the other 4 at a location he doesn’t like

The biggest issue is that Afton has never been depicted as orange. Which is why I've stopped believing AftonMM

This is without a doubt the most satisfying take on the minigame I've seen. Not only does it clear up the og newspaper clippings, which I always thought were retconned, but it just feels right. The evidence was there, the abusive dad, the kid who went to Freddy's often, the suit footprints, even the broken window, the lump of dirt near his own home (most likely the grave site), and no liable alibi for where he was with that same purple shade car. The fact most of the fnaf fanbase even mistook him for Afton makes it feel less of a coincidence, including the color of the man himself, the yellow color could even mean how the police thought he was the suspect, the man in the yellow mascot 👀 I love this theory, and it honestly fills more gaps than any other theory I've seen, there's no new questions or anything, like a puzzle piece. Even Scott saying how the game was meant to clear up things in the past, it fits just right

people often forget some of the first suits, like of spring bonnie, were *cloth* and not springlocks! i always assumed that he'd at least keep one around if they weren't still being used at the time of midnight moterist

I would like to believe the kidnapping theory, the problem being, like in basically all Midnight Motorist theories, the footprints. The child has made multiple footprints in the ground, but there is only one pair of animatronic footprints, as if it teleported. Also, I know it is not meant to be taken seriously, but the mustard man convicted theory has a lot of problems, like how fnaf vr tells us nothing was ever proven in a court of law, how tales of the pizzaplex suggests WIlliam's arrest was common knowledge, how mustard man could literally not be a suspect unless he worked at Freddy's, etc. If the Orange Guy is not William, which nowadays I am starting to believe he is not, I think the car color is just a red herring. Not only that, but William's car is actually blue, like in the movie and like in the fnaf 4 minigame, and it only looks purple because of the darkness, like how William becomes purple in the darkness.

I agree fazbear entertainment would be the type to bailed a scupper

Holy crap I love your voice. The way you talk and your accent is so lovely, great theory!

i actually like this theory, if im not trying to overly make sense fricken FNAF then this theory works better than midnight moderist being about the afton's

Tip for thumbnails! Since the Scuper hid the P in “SCOOPER” in your thumbnail, it made it hard to see and i couldn’t tell what the video was gonna be about for a second

I love this theory. It’s so much more terrifying to think of Afton not just doing the MCI but also actively seeking out kids.

The animatronic footprints in front of the broken window can’t have been Spring Bonnie, Springtrap has 5 toes while the footprints only have 3 (like Golden Freddy)

Omg I just realised something. If the „mustard man” is officially referred to as yellow, then it makes more sense than it seems. According to the colour theory what is the opposite colour of yellow? You guessed it - purple. I think the choice of colour there could be to signify the complete opposite of William Afton, which most likely suggests Henry?

Pizzeria Simulator already shows the lead-up to two of Afton's victims. It's always made sense to me for MM to be another victim.

i like your story telling, it makes quite a lot of sense: william was always in the game, but he was the footprints. who else would have been responsible for animatronic footprints near a missing childs bedroom? theres a story from chicas highschool adventures in fnaf 6 that sounds quite similar to story of midnight motorist. the newspapers never directly state that all 5 kids were at freddys before being lured into the backroom, so its possible that midnight motorist belongs to the mci. otherwise it could be connected to the dci as phone guy says: "whatever happens out there [...] has nothing to do with our establishment" it could be possible that some people witnessed charlies murder and just saw the purple car, further linking mustard man with the unnamed suspect from fnaf 1. the newspapers call out that he was caught on camera (perhaps since his son goes there often). however, they also claim that the police theorize the man wore a mascot suit. how would an unrelated person get hold of a mascot suit? perhaps mustard man worked at freddys. there is a theory that jeremy fitzgerald from the fnaf 2 location is mustard man. his son could be jeremy the mci victim. therefore naming the bar "jrs" is a reference to that. the midnight motorist family has a junior and he "can't be here" anymore. furthermore, jeremy junior could be abbreviated as j.j., naming balloon boys twin lol the mount of dirt could be the start of the fnaf 4 gameplay house, since its location looks similar to the one shown in fnaf 4s main menu. but its really unspecific and can have multiple answers. could be the fnaf 4 box, the grave of someone (my bet is on elizabeth because the circumstances of her death are hard to explain to officials), mby a lake, old man consequences, perhaps it will be cleared up sometime down the line. once again, thank you very much for your video!

I was always a MMAndrew believer. Yeah I think Frights is canon to the games. Also it just makes sense to me that MM would be another victim minigame like the other minigames.

thinking back now, i don't see much sense mustard man being purple guy, because there are some things in fnaf that are pretty straight forward. In the minigame we can see that mustard man is looking for the child, so, with him being the spring bonnie, that also lured the kid wouldn't make sense, as well as the kid going to the restaurant where he saw a dead kid, suposing he is CC, also wouldn't make sense (but it could depending on the timeline of events). i think the mustard man's kid could be one of the MCI victims, as we already have one or two minigames in pizzaria simulator that show/tell us how the murders happened. (sorry for bad english)