Пікірлер
@pelmen1294
@pelmen1294 2 күн бұрын
What a great channel!!!
@WolfHreda
@WolfHreda 3 күн бұрын
I'm running a full DCMS C3 company soon. 8k BV per lance, 4 lances total, although only two will be deployed per mission. It's gonna be interesting.
@Nitscherk
@Nitscherk 4 күн бұрын
May i ask where you got this beautiful hills from? Thanks for the Video! Now i finally understood what iNarc is for :)
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 4 күн бұрын
Those hills belong to the game store that I play at. I think everything is 3d printed from Thunderhead Studio STLs.
@FireflyMyLife
@FireflyMyLife 9 күн бұрын
What a game! I also really like how you've put together these battle reports. Not sure if you have house rules against it, but 3:56 might have been a good opportunity for a cheeky push/charge to win for Lisbeth (and might have saved her that lost arm and a painful head hit besides!). I'm sure the arena fans appreciated the more intense and sporting resolution. Please keep these wonderful reports coming!
@1nONLY_DRock
@1nONLY_DRock 9 күн бұрын
Uh oh. I don't have a battle cobra. What would you suggest I use to substitute?
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 9 күн бұрын
The Com Guards don’t have much else that fits the niche I had the Battle Cobra in. If you have an Ostscout, that can be a fast C3 spotter at a similar BV cost to the Battle Cobra. Taking that though, you’d be able to also look at replacing the Spartan with something that can fight better at range with the Ost getting close for it. Alternatively, you’d be looking to replace the Battle Cobra’s firepower with something heavier that comes in at more BV.
@monostripeexplosiveexplora2374
@monostripeexplosiveexplora2374 10 күн бұрын
nice unit composition
@user-xsn5ozskwg
@user-xsn5ozskwg 10 күн бұрын
Great overview! I also really appreciate the great captions, thank you for those.
@thehobbyhabit
@thehobbyhabit 10 күн бұрын
Huge Nova Cat and DCMS fan. This is my most favorite and heart breaking part of the lore. Was rooting for the Trukina the whole time knowing what the likely outcome would be. Great job. Subbed. 👍
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 10 күн бұрын
I’ve been a fan of the Nova Cats since they joined the Second Star League. This bit of their history is indeed heartbreaking.
@thehobbyhabit
@thehobbyhabit 10 күн бұрын
@@scottsgameroom1 … Excited for Randal to bring us the next book. They will obviously be a more minor player at this point, but this sort of noble pirate true keepers of the way feel should be good stuff.
@verysilentmouse
@verysilentmouse 13 күн бұрын
Yeah my conclusion are pretty much the same using davion c3
@tuckersaglio9823
@tuckersaglio9823 16 күн бұрын
I am doing the exact same thing -- building a 3050-70 era Comstar force. I've only played a few games with the Improved C3, but I've had good results pairing a Mercury, Flashman, Lancelot, and King Crab. The Mercury runs up to spot, the Flashman and King Crab attack, and the Lancelot loiters in the back. This is especially helpful for the King Crab, lowering the range penalties for its AC20s. I've also tried the Crab CRB-30, but it (and to a lesser extent the Lancelot) have major heat problems
@brockpaine
@brockpaine 17 күн бұрын
I love seeing that Lancelot. It's a favorite mech of mine.
@zoewhyumadbro3090
@zoewhyumadbro3090 17 күн бұрын
as someone looking into comguard, this has been pretty helpful. i finally understand how c3i works and that you dont HAVE to have 6 units. also, as someone with a growing clans collection, i love the clan list you played against. Guy pulled up, shouting: " FUCK IT, WE BALL" XD
@Jok395
@Jok395 17 күн бұрын
The risk/reward on C3 seems like a tricky thing to balance. Very cool lists, and a very cool experiment!
@jochenwenzel8878
@jochenwenzel8878 17 күн бұрын
Some further thoughts: - The Battle Cobra C* is kinda lame due to technological and design constraints. I get why you picked it but you'd been better off without it. - FASA designed C3i for C*/WoB base six units and not four machine lances, so you're also wasting tonnage and capabilities here. - C3 kind of shines in the Invasion era, because in the later eras - as you realized - there will be a lot of ECM on the field. CGL tried to counter that a bit with ECCM options and boosted C3 but given the low weight of an ECM vs. the various C3 variants I'm skeptical how much that really changes things.
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 17 күн бұрын
ComStar's Battle Cobra is definitely a flawed design (too slow for a 40 ton unit), but I think it performed pretty well in the games I played. The only game where it struggled was the 4th when my opponent got a few lucky LRM 20 hits on it and essentially knocked it down to just one MRM 10 by the end of turn 2. Personally, I'd say the Lancelot/Crab is the weakest entry in the lists I played. If I had more miniatures available to pick from, that's what I'd prioritize replacing first. The tonnage of C3i definitely pays off better with a full 6 units, but in a BV balanced game that doesn't really matter. Bigger networks have more of a BV cost too. We tend to play later eras locally, and ECM really is more something that ends up in lists just because a unit someone otherwise wants to take has one than something people are specifically bringing. I'm sure more people trying C3 would cause that to start to shift, but even then, countering one ECM unit in an enemy force wasn't too bad. The biggest obstacle to dealing with that is canon unit selections that combine ECM or iNarc along with C3 computers, but your opponent would also be restricting their options a bit by making sure they bring ECM in the first place.
@jochenwenzel8878
@jochenwenzel8878 17 күн бұрын
@@scottsgameroom1 'The tonnage of C3i definitely pays off better with a full 6 units, but in a BV balanced game that doesn't really matter. Bigger networks have more of a BV cost too.' - It does matter, since BV is based on the units stats. I can easily take your lance, switch out the Battle Cobra for an Sentinel or a Crab, go for variants without C3i for the rest and then swamp you with 1-2 additional units from your available mini pool @ 4/4 or keep your slighty modified lance @ mostly 3/4. 'We tend to play later eras locally, and ECM really is more something that ends up in lists just because a unit someone otherwise wants to take has one than something people are specifically bringing.' - Well, WoB had a boner for C3i so the rest of the IS started packing a lot more ECM as a cheap/light counter. So you will see more ECM automatically, either on new design or era-appropriate variants of older units.
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 17 күн бұрын
@@jochenwenzel8878 my point there was that C3i's tonnage being balanced for 6 units doesn't matter to the BV system. In a BV balanced game, you're looking at what you get for the BV cost not what you get for the tonnage of the unit. Running a network of 6 units is more expensive BV-wise than running a smaller network.
@thecommuterzombie
@thecommuterzombie 17 күн бұрын
A nice concise run through and it's always valuable to hear about experiments that didn't quite work as well as ones that do.
@derekburge5294
@derekburge5294 18 күн бұрын
I've always wanted to noodle around with C3i, but with as prevalent as ECM is in later eras, it just feels like too much of an investment.
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 17 күн бұрын
I think it's key to play with the ECCM optional rule so that a list using C3 has the opportunity to still work in the face of an opponent with ECM. Otherwise, any ECM at all is going to almost completely neutralize the BV spent on the network for a tiny fraction of its cost. In pick-up games locally, ECM is something that tends to just show up on accident rather than being a big consideration despite us tending to play later era lists. I'm sure if more folks were using C3 though then that could shift over time.
@MagnusMoerkoereJohannesen
@MagnusMoerkoereJohannesen 18 күн бұрын
So, kinda unrelated, but do you have a gallery of your Comstar painted mechs? I'm new to the game, and I often have a hard time parsing what's supposed to be what on a mech. Yours are really clear and crisp, and make it really easy to distinguish the various features.
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 17 күн бұрын
Closest thing I have right now is my instagram account: instagram.com/scottsgameroom/
@MagnusMoerkoereJohannesen
@MagnusMoerkoereJohannesen 17 күн бұрын
@@scottsgameroom1 That's really cool, thank you :)
@thorshammer8033
@thorshammer8033 18 күн бұрын
That was interesting. My group never really go past 3060 in games. The ECM and C3I battle adds a whole new dimension. Is there and fast hovers you could sub in that have a C3I ?
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 17 күн бұрын
ComStar's options are limited there. They have a Beagle Hover Scout and a Sprint Scout Helicopter that could serve as fast C3i spotters. Given how fragile those are, I think you'd want to at least double up on them if you were using them as your spotters.
@HouseMasterPoDing
@HouseMasterPoDing 18 күн бұрын
Classic with Gunnery 4.....that is a choice...nice video though!
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 17 күн бұрын
Locally, we tend to run a lot of 4 gunnery with occasional upgrades to 3. The BV cost of going 3/4 means that you tend to find yourself up against opponents that can outlast you with their armor & structure advantage. For a C3 force like this, I'm already paying a good amount of extra BV on improvements to my accuracy, so spending even more of my budget on it felt like it would leave me without enough durability in the list.
@HouseMasterPoDing
@HouseMasterPoDing 17 күн бұрын
@@scottsgameroom1 I just hate the TN's at Gunnery 4. I'm playing a roboto shooter, I want to be able to actually shoot things. The TN's at gunnery 4 are just insanely high, at least to my way of thinking. How people play at that level is beyond me. But I guess each person has their own experience
@Anjin-qg3ie
@Anjin-qg3ie 19 күн бұрын
This was really cool man.
@patrickhartigan2068
@patrickhartigan2068 22 күн бұрын
What brand is ur case
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 21 күн бұрын
That display case was from Crate & Barrel. I don’t remember what it was called. I’ve had it for more than a decade now.
@Fritzadood
@Fritzadood 22 күн бұрын
ive gotta compliment the paintjob on that turkina, looks so pretty! love seeing more detailed/less industrial designs on mechs
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 22 күн бұрын
Thanks! The Nova Cat Alpha Galaxy scheme is one of my favorites, and the Turkina’s big, flat torso made it a great design to really have fun with the stars.
@claytonsadventures7607
@claytonsadventures7607 24 күн бұрын
This was awesome to watch! Well done!
@katmandomo
@katmandomo Ай бұрын
It was getting comical how many PSRs those guys were flubbing. That poor Battle Cobra just couldn't catch a break. I do have to commend ComStar for the masterful use of that Long Tom strike. It would have taken forever to kill those elementals otherwise with the horrible gunnery on display.
@Phoney72
@Phoney72 Ай бұрын
Great battle report. The Spider only just managing to hit the gigantic mech lying on the ground ten feet away from it at the end there made me chuckle
@Papatim85
@Papatim85 Ай бұрын
this was fun! more please!
@ogrehaslayers605
@ogrehaslayers605 Ай бұрын
Fantastic video! Glad i found you!
@andrewsmith4281
@andrewsmith4281 Ай бұрын
Love this style of classic BattleTech report. Great work and I look forward to seeing more.
@thecommuterzombie
@thecommuterzombie Ай бұрын
That's a really well put together battle report, loved the slick editing and the fast pace. That looked like a brutal canyon brawl. You have a new sub! 🙂
@Miniaturegeek
@Miniaturegeek Ай бұрын
What map is that?
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 Ай бұрын
It’s the Devil’s Bath map from Map Pack: Tukayyid. I have the paper map, but there is a neoprene version too.
@AlexMon
@AlexMon Ай бұрын
Absolutely love the format, keep up the great work!!
@masonmcelroy8125
@masonmcelroy8125 Ай бұрын
I really can't stress enough how much I like your battle reports. The intro "back story" at the beginning and the "short" format recapping each phase is great. Keep it up!
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 Ай бұрын
Thanks! It's good to hear people are enjoying them.
@brennonsmith5006
@brennonsmith5006 Ай бұрын
Want to second this, its fantastically edited and shot. Entertaining and concise, good work!
@adamjones1281
@adamjones1281 Ай бұрын
Will you do anymore battles from Tukayyid?
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 Ай бұрын
No immediate plans for more Tukayyid battles right now, but I could see doing one focused on a different Clan for May next year.
@derekburge5294
@derekburge5294 Ай бұрын
Overheating: a bad day. Overheating, falling, and blacking out: a *real* bad day. Overheating, falling, blacking out, and dropping into mud: buddy, it's time to retire.
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 Ай бұрын
Aff, that Battle Cobra had a horrible day.
@MrKazyFreak
@MrKazyFreak Ай бұрын
Happy tukayyid! Hoping comstar kicks more clan butt at my local game store this weekend.
@dredge5960
@dredge5960 Ай бұрын
Well done, great report. Battle audio SFX at much better levels this time ;)
@crapshot321
@crapshot321 Ай бұрын
Ouch! Sick burn at 1:17.
@masonmcelroy8125
@masonmcelroy8125 Ай бұрын
That is cannon to the Battletech universe. 🙂
@crusignatioutremer791
@crusignatioutremer791 Ай бұрын
I sense from the poor gunnery displayed from the COMGUARD, that the mechanics must be guilty of some degree of espionage (boresighting/calibration). Great battle review!
@TheManyVoicesVA
@TheManyVoicesVA Ай бұрын
Happy Tukayyid day!
@JohnDoe-hc7jf
@JohnDoe-hc7jf Ай бұрын
That looked brutal man.
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 Ай бұрын
It was brutal. The narrow passages and mud pools on that map are hard to deal with.
@digitaldynamic3476
@digitaldynamic3476 Ай бұрын
Never Forget! 💥
@HellsGate9999
@HellsGate9999 Ай бұрын
I am pretty new to BT. I have been playing it with family but after watching this i feel like i am playing wrong? It seems multiple times one player would get into the rear arc of another but the one facing away still got to shoot back? I thought Torso twisting only moved you one hex side to the right or left. that wouldn't be enough to return fire at someone directly behind you. Right?
@scottsgameroom1
@scottsgameroom1 Ай бұрын
That is an advantage of arm-mounted weapons. They enjoy a firing arc that is a hex face wider on their side than the arc for torso and head mounted weapons. That means that after a torso twist, one arm’s weapons can fire directly behind a mech. Some mechs (those without any lower arms) can also flip their arms to fire both arms’ weapons behind them.
@HellsGate9999
@HellsGate9999 Ай бұрын
@scottsgameroom1 o wow! I double-checked, and you are obviously right!! I have been playing/teaching wrong. Thank you so much for taking the time to explain it. 😀
@rafale1981
@rafale1981 Ай бұрын
That was one thrilling match with a last second turn around. Those pulse lasers are brutal
@SWIFTO_SCYTHE
@SWIFTO_SCYTHE 2 ай бұрын
This is cool. I just picked up a starter box and this is a great battle report
@verrezen
@verrezen 2 ай бұрын
Well, the Draconis combine still breeds them stupid and full of testosteron, I see.
@HalIOfFamer
@HalIOfFamer 2 ай бұрын
You might want to try and shoot from sides where an enemy is already weaker. You peppered the knight from all sides but armor is there to be shot. In a one off game like this where you don't care for salvage you should really try to crit out your opponent.
@youtmeme
@youtmeme 2 ай бұрын
Excellent battle!!!😊