🙏🙏🙏

27/6/2024 11:11 am सर, परंपरागत चलती आयी चुनाव प्रक्रिया और गंदी राजकीय खेली सामान्य नागरिकों के लिए कुछ भी काम कि नहीं बल्की एक दिन कि छुट्टी का भी सम्मान नहीं ठहरता ! चुनाव तो सदीयोंसे चलते आ रहे है मगर सामान्य नागरिकों को हर समस्याओं में मजबूर रखते बस्स एक गुलामों कि तरह मिसयुज करते रहते है इससे चुनाव का कोई महत्त्व ही नही बचता ! लोग हर परेशानी में जीते जी मृतक कि तरह जिंदगी जीने के लिए मजबूर अवस्था में है क्या यही राजकीय नेतागिरी है ? चुनाव आयोग इन सभीपर जबरदस्त पारदर्शी नियंत्रण कब ला सकेंगे ? जो इमानदार निरपराध व्यक्तीत्व होते है उनकी ऍलर्जी बहुत पदस्थों को है क्या यह सत्यमेव जयते ब्रीद के देश के लिए जबरदस्त गंभीर चिंताओं का विषय नहीं है ??? धन्यवाद

Defectors did not stop defecting just because Rajiv Gandhi government inserted Schedule X. It is just that defection became more complicated. It is best that this Schedule X is removed. Monetary cost should be imposed if an elected representative changes his party. Recover the cost of election from him. Pecuniary liability is a great leveller.

I had read about Nani Palkhiwala giving a brief of the Budget immediately after the finance minister gave an official budget to the nation. I had read that how people were more eager to hear it from 'Nani'. I am happy to witness this recorded video of the same. Thank you Datar Sir for sharing this with us.

Good job

Leave and licence agreement which is unstamped, unregistered is admissible in arbitration, can I take a plea that no law in karnataka or in easement act no such requirement of registration hence just because it is not registered doesn't render it inadmissible.

Sir, undoubtedly ur understanding of tax law in the constitution is outstanding.

Sir has a capacity to present complex issue in such a manner that any laymen can understand .He is a true legend.

Dear when u write books how u determine the structure of books. Until 1998 there could have been lots of books on constitution how did u made sure u book is different from all other that came before

Great arguement sir 🙏

Sir.. is living Legend..

Sir, you are amazing story teller with content.

Mr.Datar’s point needs to be considered by the Competition Commission .

whatever we study, learn, and present or beg before the Hon'ble courts, it's not easy to get the results/appreciation from present judges, judges are not ready to accept young advocates specifically in lower courts.

Thank you forth this video

Datar Sir, your insightful conversations are truly enlightening. Kindly consider uploading more videos in the near future. The reason for such a request is that your talks go beyond mere legal realm, offering valuable insights into how a lawyer should operate to attain success. Of course, books are one way to understand, but in today's e- world such videos are highly appreciated, thanks sir.

as of Year 2024: Is there any chance (From the indian constitution saying that...) that Princely states and their crownlands to be rstore one day? Waiting for ur answer.

SIR, Can HC decide constitutional validity, requested to make a video on this topic . Thank you

Humble, very well grounded as a person as an orator aslo, sir Your are such a pleasing personality, gained so much knowledge

30:57 - Role of Speakers 47:29 - Constitutional Morality

Thank you for this scintillating discussion on critical aspects of our constitutional democracy 🙏🏼

Sir i watched your video yesterday itself it was more clear. Whenever you deliver ask the cameramen or organisers to give original copy of the lecture. It becomes more interesting.

Excellent Lecture Sir , Thank you 🙏

Nani Palkhivala could easily get a crowd of 50k to 100k by speaking facts and figures and explaining logic at Brabourne Stadium❤. While todays media is screaming their lungs out as they rapidly shift camera angles just to get trp😅

26:37

Sir, knowledgeable video. Sir, ek doubt tha. If old law is superceded with new law and any important provision is Missing in new. Whether that provision present in older law is applicable? Thank you

You are my inspiration for doing Ph.D in GST sir.

You are absolutely correct.

Both india and both are the same.....sense in constitution. Mind less people see both terms as different

20:00

INDIA IS LIKE SOME ONE CALLING GALI KA BAGAL WALA CHOTU BHARAT IS LIKE NAME GIVEN BY MOTHER

No but political parties love to spice things up to use the emotional fools in our country especially with elections are around in less fhan a year's time

Can our own name be in English

Na! We want people across the world use Bharat to address in future.

Ranting with out examples

Great one sir

I’m a law student how can I intern under Arvind Datar sir , please somebody clarify.

Great sir.

Good

Sir I would always see ur name board in the MHC addl law chambers with elation..accidentally happened to see this channel while reading your book Courtroom Genius..what a great coincidence!!!

Because of I am doing ph.d in GST sir

A true Legend. A fighter for common man. Middle Class would have suffered a lot due to our evergreedy politicians if we would not have had crusaders like Nani Palkhivala. Very sad to know that our politicians tried to upsurp even the Rights of Royal Princes and they would have succeeded if it were not for a crusader like Palkhivala. The video is long but every single moment is worth seeing.

Very inspiring and powerful jurist that Palkhivala is/was will never have any jurist of equal stature...Palkhivala will always remain unparalleled!!! The video is very educative in many respects!!

Judiciary has gone to nuts.better not to have it! status of implementation of datar's r Gandhi jud dt 11/5/10?hc, sc are contempting same hundred times to please state.our four clients in civil case won in trial court then in sessions appeal sr lawyer of opp side managed courts, they lost their life time supports, cji knowing such things unable to do anything.

Arvind, in yr 11/5/10 r gandhi judgements, non independent tribunals were declared violation of art 14. Now that funda right is violated by hc,sc , yr say?!

Also - Department simply objects ITC on most of the items of business promotion / employee related expenses (which are nothing but necessary for running business) alleging "PERSON CONSUMPTION"..

Lease - GST and INCOME TAX does not go hand in hand😅 Was it not decided in Foxconn to be deemed as sale.. for IT purpose! Now in GST - ALTOGETHER DIFFERENT TREATMENT

धातार सर Please take the CASE OF RESERVATION IN CG DAIRY NO 30748

Sir i have read your argument in centre of policy research vs income tax 1. I have one question, can income escaping assessment upto ay 2018-2019, non repsented in the form of asset after 1 april 2022? As these already expired on 31 march 2022 Amedment can not make dead period live. Is this right? Please reply if u can?

Amendment of 149 in finance act 2022 As per finance act 2022, the income escaping assessment should be represented in the form of--- an asset, an entry or entries or expenditure in a single transaction or transactions and expenditure.... For AY-2018-2019, the limit of 3 year get expired on 31 march 2022....now the amendment of finance bill 2022 be effective from april 1, 2022. so non asset based representation will also expire on 31 march 2022 for ay 2018-2019, if income escaping assessment is-more-than-50-lakh...is it right...............................................my questions is the following.... Questions : Can Income escaping assessment more than 50 lakh amended by finance act 2022 represented in the form of asset, expenditure or entries in the books of account will be applicable for AY-2018-2019, if assessing officer wants to open the case on 5 A pril 2022. As per my understanding its no Reasoning--- Asset based- Fine, Assessing officer can open Income escaping assessment more than 50 lakh amended by finance act 2022 represented in the form of asset Expenditure based- Time barred, Assessing officer can not open Income escaping assessment more than 50 lakh amended by finance act 2022 represented in the form of expenditure (as for ay 2018-2019, normal 3 years got expired on 31 march 2022 so it can not be amended by finance act 2022) single transaction or transactions- Again Time barred (as for ay 2018-2019, normal 3 years got expired on 31 march 2022 and new finance act comes into affect on 1 April 2022 , so it can not be amended as its already expired)