Tinto Maps #6 - The Butthurt Isles
1:12:57
Ireland after the Norman Invasion
47:54
Пікірлер
@adamwright9150
@adamwright9150 16 күн бұрын
This website work for other languages? I love CK3 but not being able to pronounce the names properly throws my off. This website would be great.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 16 күн бұрын
Yah, native speakers from all around the world put up pronunciations in lots of different languages. It's worth a look though you won't always find a pronunciation your searching for.
@facelessmonk6640
@facelessmonk6640 21 күн бұрын
Hey, the discord invites you keep putting in ur video bios keep expiring!
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 21 күн бұрын
Thanks for letting me know, this one should work: discord.gg/XHQRnHFBE8
@QuisUtDeus828
@QuisUtDeus828 28 күн бұрын
So its not prinounced mer-chad and dunn-chad its a k sound? Dang my guys got infinitely less cool this olay through
@Mandy87Marie
@Mandy87Marie 2 күн бұрын
That actually makes more sense and sounds better to the ear
@fergus41
@fergus41 Ай бұрын
Actually quite a few of the devs seem to be kaiserreich devs as well with the New England Dev being the Kaiserreich India dev
@arthurfisher582
@arthurfisher582 Ай бұрын
Even in an alternate history Dublin goes looking for Deutsche Bank.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc Ай бұрын
Great men for a few bob are the Germans
@bishopbrennan3558
@bishopbrennan3558 Ай бұрын
Have you ever looked at Ireland in TNO?
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc Ай бұрын
Not yet but it's on the list, I'm planning to look at the Ireland lore in the big HOI4 mods
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes Ай бұрын
Where is this mod exactly? I'm having trouble finding it.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc Ай бұрын
Looks like this is a common thing for HOI4 mods, it's been hit with a DMCA takedown notice on Steam! There's no grounds for it but Steam has to take the mod down for about 10 days. It's still available on through "Paradox mods" and should be back up on Steam again soon, I was lucky to download it before the strike.
@hamperfranklin9994
@hamperfranklin9994 Ай бұрын
Please keep Sinn Fein and Michael Collins in power
@dannywaite10
@dannywaite10 Ай бұрын
Labour will be a great playthrough. As for Weltkrieg plans - Ireland must not rest until Berlin GAA are given a bye straight into the quarter-finals of the Ulster SFC and could end up meeting Vienna (Leinster SFC champions 1942?) in the All-Ireland final.
@arthurfisher582
@arthurfisher582 Ай бұрын
Cairo is clearly fielding a few GAA teams. Because where are you going to get the wood for a camogie all the way in the desert?
@eldaddy144
@eldaddy144 Ай бұрын
Hey I think you looked at the national focus requirements a bit incorrectly - you don't need the NDP in your government to be able to do that focus, and you could do the eternal vigiliance focus after. There are one or two things and nice events you've missed out on for Michael Collins - like the removing restrictions focus that's around where the constitution focus is. Nice work on the playthrough all the same.
@Cian-O
@Cian-O Ай бұрын
Love the mod. Great playthrough. Looking forward to the ICA playthrough
@pomernguy1835
@pomernguy1835 Ай бұрын
You can actually take the focus "International Investment Hub", because it requires EITHER Sinn Fein or NDP being in charge.
@team_ribs
@team_ribs Ай бұрын
comhghleacaí poist brillianr
@brookb5890
@brookb5890 Ай бұрын
Missed this series, but I'm glad it showed up in my feed eventually.
@Daniel-en1on
@Daniel-en1on Ай бұрын
It’s nice seeing that the devs actually respect Ireland’s history rather than brushing it aside or it getting culturally appropriated. If this level of care and detail goes into all other areas of the map it will be by far the most detailed map in any Paradox game. And if this is Stellaris 2 then this is only Earth, what about all the other planets? 😅
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc Ай бұрын
This is just my theory, but the game will start in 2200 and you have about 20 years to build up your economy and fleet before a time distortion opens up and transports all the alien races back to the earth of 1337 to fight and ally with the people of that time. That or it's EU5.
@herkles5416
@herkles5416 2 ай бұрын
A wonderful video and I like these detailed videos. I am loving the detail in Project Caeser and I am hoping to see how it actually plays out when it is released. I don't like the term Tribe and I do wonder why the Irish can't just have monarchy while having their unique mechanics.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc Ай бұрын
I can see why Paradox would want to differentiate between "monarchy" and "whatever the Irish are" but I also can't think of a good reason why the Irish shouldn't be monarchy, that's a great point!
@TidusDowthelas
@TidusDowthelas 2 ай бұрын
Seeing as the British nearly cause the Celtic, Irish, Welsh, and Scottish Cultures, languages and traditions to near extinction from the 10th century to the 17th century... I'm sure our distant for being lumped in with the people who tried to out right wipe us out, is valid, but ironically it's modern times, and people need to come to a consensus. Why not call it "Albion" or "Isle of Celtica-Saxon"? Some creative names can be used, for different regions of the islands too.
@dcmccann11
@dcmccann11 2 ай бұрын
How would you prefer people refer to the islands in the North Sea near France?
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
The Channel Islands?
@dcmccann11
@dcmccann11 2 ай бұрын
@@ManiacalInc Thanks. I deserve that. But I see comments like Atlantic Archipelago, but the British Isles are not an archipelago. I see people use Great Britain and Ireland, but that excludes Mann, Jersey, Wite and Shetlands and Hebernies
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc Ай бұрын
In Ireland we don't really see the need of a collective term, the only place it pops up is in weird r/mapporn threads. If a term is absolutely needed for some reason we tend to go with "British and Irish Isles" but there is so little need that we don't really have a consensus.
@dcmccann11
@dcmccann11 Ай бұрын
@@ManiacalInc thx
@garnerireland
@garnerireland 2 ай бұрын
Hiberno islands seems to work quite well, but North Atlantic archipelago is tried and true.
@garnerireland
@garnerireland 2 ай бұрын
Ludi didn't dismiss it, I was pleased to hear, and enjoyed the Irish dynasties' whilst making that cough joke.
@bishopbrennan3558
@bishopbrennan3558 2 ай бұрын
First time seeing the facecam; has anyone ever said you look a bit like Brendan Behan? (I mean that in a good way!)
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
A picture of me and a picture of Brendan Behan looking worse for wear side by side - "Before EU5 releases/After EU5 releases" Can't say I've ever gotten that comparison before, it's probably bad lighting and my poor diet of recent. I use the camera for Twitch and the handful of livestreams I used to have here
@bishopbrennan3558
@bishopbrennan3558 2 ай бұрын
@@ManiacalInc I know you said you haven't been keeping up to date fully with other Project Caesar dev diaries, but have you seen the stuff on Situations and International Organisations? I wonder if you could have a Situation that brings the Irish under an International Organisation in a war with England where, if they lose, it leads to the Flight of the Earls, or something like that. (If that's at all accurate-my own knowledge of our history isn't great, that's why I come to you!) Apologies if you mention this somewhere in the video, I haven't watched all of it.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
I've seen that the High Kingship is going to be treated as an International Organisation (I think) so I'm looking forward to seeing how that works. Maybe something like the Flight of the Earls could be achieved as part of a push to "Anglicize" Ireland, so that other Catholic powers in Europe could gain the ability to recruit "Irish Brigades" if Ireland falls under English control. I'm not really sure what that would look like but the fact that the Pale is a Dominion of England means the devs are thinking about how to make Ireland interesting with England just blobing out and conquering it rapidly
@br2485
@br2485 2 ай бұрын
I've never heard of apostolic succession described as being like a blockchain, that's brilliant lmao
@MrJamBluejam
@MrJamBluejam 2 ай бұрын
'Britain and Ireland' is best for general use. If you need Atlantic Archipelago for those flora books you mentioned, knock yourself out. People insisting Saoirse is British because 'British Isles' are willfully ignorant, and I honestly don't know what is to be gained from being pricks to the Irish. On behalf of Britain, I can only apologise. I remember on a podcast once, Siobhan McSweeny said something about British ignorance of their history with Ireland is upsetting. I agree, it's the root of that kind of nonsense, to my mind. Good video as usual, btw.
@mandead
@mandead 2 ай бұрын
I'm impressed that even you managed to milk an hour out of this!
@colm9419
@colm9419 2 ай бұрын
Big fan of the content
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Thanks very much!
@gamertrojan4038
@gamertrojan4038 2 ай бұрын
Wonderfully knowledgeable and entertaining as usual. I agree this is 99% there and very respectful of Ireland, it's people and history as we know it. And added bonus ruffles the feathers of the West Germans living to the East of us in Greater Brittany ;-)
@IrishMedievalHistory
@IrishMedievalHistory 2 ай бұрын
By far not the last time in the next few years, that will be having deep chats on the topics covered in this video.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Looking forward to it. I was wondering if you had heard about "project Caesar", 1337's an exciting start date for Ireland
@IrishMedievalHistory
@IrishMedievalHistory 2 ай бұрын
@@ManiacalInc no! I didn't, first time seeing it. 1337 is the year I like to watch the rise of Desmond Fitzgerald. Going from 100 years war commander to rebel, to pushing to be Irish king to take control of Ireland with Kildare and the Parliament. Him and his sons are funny characters.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
The High Kingship is going to be represented in some way so I'm looking forward to seeing how that will be interpreted in this time period and how the Pale being a Dominion of England will impact gameplay. I don't think there is a planned release date as yet (technically we don't even know the name of the game, but it's EU5) but the 1178 start date will be added to CK3 in a few months time.
@IrishMedievalHistory
@IrishMedievalHistory 2 ай бұрын
@@ManiacalInc I will have to keep an eye on it for sure.
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes 2 ай бұрын
Regarding your hypothesis that Paradox actually did look for the original source for the king list of Munster and simply made the same mistake as the wikipedia page to settle on Murchad, Cambrian Chronicles recently did a video that points out a mistake that Paradox and almost no one else makes w/r/t to an old Welsh history hoax that most likely had to have been copied from Wikipedia without checking the source at all. imo, it at least seems plausible that for some things they just scraped the surface level of wikipedia without any further investigation.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
I just checked out that video, it was very good. I think Wikipedia was definitely used for CK2 but in a few places it is more accurate than the game, like the list of the Kings of Meath which is copied from "Irish Kings and High Kings" which is copied incorrectly into CK2 and 3. The game also has Gormflaith as the mother of the sons of Máelsechnaill mac Domnaill which has long been disproven and doesn't feature on either IKHK or Wikipedia so that comes from some other "source". I'm glad to see that it's not just Ireland that's the victim of bad historical sourcing!
@fergalkearney1603
@fergalkearney1603 2 ай бұрын
I saw the original, as irish man, and as a history teacher. I laughed at the guys annoyance doing the video. Why was he so determined to use british isles? Maybe he has a bad experience in the past. Either way he has no concept of Irish history. Great video reaction. It is not a "geographic term" any more as ireland is not in britain. Nowadays it is great britain and Ireland. Would that not do the job as we use that ourselves?
@herkles5416
@herkles5416 2 ай бұрын
Whom are you refering to btw?
@brianduddy349
@brianduddy349 2 ай бұрын
See no issues with saying britan and Ireland. I'm American, but am Irish by heritage, if you will, that wonderful American phenomenon of splitting our nationality and ancestry. The history, especially relatively recent history, is intertwined obviously, but I feel the culture and history is also quite different and rich enough to stand on their own. My father and his side of the family would also be spinning in their graves if I called any of them British. I prefer and encourage not lumping in Ireland with the "British Isles"
@misterinadequate3518
@misterinadequate3518 2 ай бұрын
erin go braugh
@brianduddy349
@brianduddy349 2 ай бұрын
Wanted to say, have been quietly watching your videos for about 2 years now, it's all in rotation with my regular historical vids. Your work is quite appreciated from me here in the US, always look forward to your vids and your knowledge of Irish history
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Thanks very much, I'm always glad when people watch these videos
@aidancusack4483
@aidancusack4483 2 ай бұрын
unironically learned more irish history from this channel than anywhere else
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Come for the games, stay for the history rants
@woohoo3786
@woohoo3786 2 ай бұрын
What is the DUP and the UDP? (as in what do they want.)
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
IRL the Democratic Unionist Party are a hardline Unionist party strongly opposed to any but the most limited concessions to the Nationalist community and they refused to endorse the Good Friday Agreement. IRL the Ulster Democratic Party was a small party linked to the loyalist paramilitary UDA, in Kaiserreich they replace and include many members of the Ulster Unionist Party which IRL governed Northern Ireland from the 1920's until the Direct Rule from Westminster was introduced in '72. In Kaiserreich they have joined with the rest of Ireland as the lesser of two evils after the fall of Britain to syndicalism and mainly want to preserve an independent Unionist identity and Unionist control of the former Northern Ireland. Collin's Sinn Féin and Lemass's NDP can work with them while generally the parties of De Valera, O'Duffy and Ó Cuinneagáin oppose them.
@richardalex4516
@richardalex4516 2 ай бұрын
The good timeline
@gingerwulf4503
@gingerwulf4503 2 ай бұрын
I've stopped buying the DLCs for Paradox games on release now, I'll wait for a sale. Not many of them are worth the full price IMO
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Yah, I'm thinking that's the best policy. Depending on what is included in them I might just totally be finished with ck3 DLC
@davidwarner3152
@davidwarner3152 2 ай бұрын
Yeeooooo he's back. Up the gaelsh
@SackOfCheeseyBalls
@SackOfCheeseyBalls 2 ай бұрын
Love your vids bro
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Thanks very much!
@LeonWilias
@LeonWilias 2 ай бұрын
Not exactly Bohemia, but the marriage proposal reminds me of Frederick the Great of Prussia regiment of Potsdam giants, were at least two Irishman in it
@eldaddy144
@eldaddy144 2 ай бұрын
Well. Good to see the series still goin. Getting the Emmet's Epitaph focus adds on the extra effects, and you keep the volunteers bonus until you join a faction. One thing though, you should add Field Marshals to the generals you are sending with your volunteers, as they will give more bonuses.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Thanks, I didn't realise you could appoint Field Marshals to Volunteers, that's my lack of HOI4 experience showing. I haven't checked the subreddit in a while, is there still an unknown/undiscovered outcome if you can satisfy both Nationalist and Unionists when Black Monday occurs or has everything been discovered?
@eldaddy144
@eldaddy144 2 ай бұрын
​@@ManiacalInc ah sure its been out two months now so I'll tell ye. If you deal with the opening Black Monday situation perfectly by satisfying both groups, manage to re-elect Collins in the 37 elections, milk the best bonuses out of Germany and Britain in the Gateway to the Atlantic while also remaining independent, there is a secret outcome. If you manage all of the previous stuff, and Ireland joins the Weltkrieg directly, then Collins gets the option to form a wartime coalition with de Valera's party and the UDP. Dev is made second-in-command, Basil Brooke is made an unremovable advisor, and Mulcahy is made Chief of Army if he isn't already. Oh and Collins' leader picture turns into one of him in uniform which is fairly class. You should check out the updated foreign policy focuses at some stage if you get the chance, it was updated in the hotfix and there are a few more things in it.
@eldaddy144
@eldaddy144 2 ай бұрын
Ah yeah, if you manage to perfectly resolve Black Monday at the beginning minigame, and if Collins wins the election, and Ireland stays independent in the Gateway to the Atlantic while also milking the best bonuses from the Brits and Germans, there is a hidden outcome. If you directly join the world war after all this happened, and Collins is the leader, then he can form a Wartime Coalition with de Valera and the UDP directly. Dev becomes a second in command, Brooke becomes an unremovable advisor, and Mulcahy is made head of army if he isn't already. And most importantly, Collins gets a sick new leader portrait in uniform!
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
That sounds like the definition of "nightmare blunt rotation"
@eldaddy144
@eldaddy144 2 ай бұрын
@@ManiacalInc it's all worth it for the uniform. The Big Fellow with the Big... democratic mandate
@portumnadaz
@portumnadaz 2 ай бұрын
snelll!!!! will that help
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 2 ай бұрын
Perfect, you're hired
@malekmohamed7458
@malekmohamed7458 3 ай бұрын
nice series and video but after this series is finished you should play as usa in kaiserreich and try to limit the civil war by electing john nance garner in the election and shutting the garner bill act and focusing in weaking the spa power the kill huey long then win the civil war against the socialists but you should max buff the usa and canada and the entente because the entente would be your friends in the war
@padraighegarty7114
@padraighegarty7114 3 ай бұрын
Love it. I loathe the shitty attempts done for "laughs"
@nervosadustbolt9642
@nervosadustbolt9642 3 ай бұрын
I love that accent, dawg. It's so rare to hear, where I am from.. So it is especially cool, when I actually hear it! Thanks for the upload.
@nervosadustbolt9642
@nervosadustbolt9642 3 ай бұрын
This is a stupid, but legitimate question. Are Irish people able to hear their own Accents? Or, do people tell you have them.. And, what it sounds like when they hear it? I'm from Canada.. Personally, I have heard people say that Canadians have accents, but I've never heard anyone from Canada with an Accent.. Even, while people are trying to point it out to me.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 3 ай бұрын
I wouldn't detect an accent in the people who live near me but there would be some Irish accents I'd have trouble with. There is a famous video of an Irish sheep farmer with a very strong accent, it went viral because no one could understand what he was saying... I could understand him perfectly! Google "Irish sheep farmer accent" and you'll find it
@nervosadustbolt9642
@nervosadustbolt9642 3 ай бұрын
I love those Unit Cards. Some people likely find them tacky. However, I really do enjoy them.
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 3 ай бұрын
I've seen people complain about them online but I really like them, they fit well with the setting
@battlements7649
@battlements7649 3 ай бұрын
Great video, and helpful to me. I made 1.1K likes!
@ManiacalInc
@ManiacalInc 3 ай бұрын
Nice! Glad you found it helpful, have you just gotten into CK3?
@arthurfisher582
@arthurfisher582 3 ай бұрын
17:22 *Craggy Island voice* "Are you fighting the King now, Father?"
@gingerwulf4503
@gingerwulf4503 3 ай бұрын
Gaelsh is such a cursed word. Well we've no choice now but to be the... Gaelsh