@gambler0101 Even for germans outside of Bavaria that was not easy to understand lol. This dub is incredibly funny.The text and the fact that you can expect these guys talking jive, but then bavarian? Allways great to watch

Hat ja fast sein ganzes Leben in München Ramersdorf gelebt

Wieso Homer is doch white trash. Passt scho!

This has several levels of being funny: In the original the two guys are speaking jive, which sounds like gobbledegook even for many native English speakers. So the sync chose to have them talk the Bavarian dialect sounding like gobbledegook as well for most German native speakers north of Bavaria. Neither are they talking about exactly the same as in the original version. Further, Bavarians usually have a hard time speaking "standard German" for everybody to understand. Partially out of not being able to but also out of being unwilling to. It starts with the menu: One ordering a fillet of fish calling it an "auszuzzl't'n haring" (sucked out herring) and the other one ordering a steak calling it "pflanzerl" (which is something like a Salisbury Steak). So far, so good. But in addition Bavarians have a repute of being rather conservative. Some even say they are a bit xenophobic, which I think is not actually true. But yes, it does contribute to the joke that two black guys certainly not fitting into the conservative scheme talk Bavarian. Then, their language is pretty straight, which is per se funny for many Germans. E.g.: "Die soll si beeil'n! Mir haut's glei die ganz Soßn naus!" roughly translates into "She'd better hurry up! I am going to throw up any moment!" This is also a strange mix: On the one hand, the man should be thankful that someone is taking care of his problem. But on the other hand, he is complaining about help not coming fast enough. This is also a trait you may find in Germany very often. The subtitles, either voluntarily or not, do not really say what people are talking. However, who would be able to check? Bavarians don't (really) speak standard German. Other Germans don't speak Bavarian. In this respect, it could also have worked with Swiss German but that would have failed in terms of straight language due to cultural reasons. All in all, it is a wonderful example of "free translation" that has done so many benefits to the entertainment of people. To see more of that, maybe you might try "The Persuaders", a contemporary TV series, as the pinnacle of this technique in Germany. With the dialogues sometimes only losely related to the English original, this show achieved cult status among German fans. I hope that helps.

Die ganze Szene erinnert mich irgendwie an die guten alten Schnoddersynchros. Das war bloß die Umkehr, Sprüche die im Englischen absolut nicht funktionieren würden. Das sind so kleine Eigenheiten von alten Synchronisierungen, die heute wirklich sehr fehlen.

Mir fallen da vor allem die alten Cheech and Chong Filme ein. Da waren so gute Gags im Original, die im Deutschen einfach nur albern waren. In einer Szene wurde versehentlich statt Koks Seife gesnifft, worauf es schäumte. In der deutschen Übersetzung nahm man dafür "Salz". Oder komplette Songs wurden umgeschrieben. Aber da ich mit dem Verständnis vom Englischen keine größeren Probleme habe, ist der Film eine absolute Granate. Wäre auf jeden Fall unter meinen Top 10 Komödien.

Volle Zustimmung, ähnliches auch bei Monty Python wo die Synchro fast besser ist als das Original.

Man hätte auch die Untertitel weglassen können, ich versteh jedes Wort.

Kommt daher dass die die Untertitel stumpf aus dem Original übersetzt haben und nicht auf das Bayrisch Gesprochene geachtet haben. Es ist schlich und einfach ein Fehler und nicht wie hier alle behaupten eine bewusste Entscheidung.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/iNiKn7qonarNYWQ.html Da bitte :)

Wo und wie wird hier auf "woke" geschissen?

Der Übersetzer hat einfach die Untertitel aus dem Original übersetzt, wahrscheinlich weil er fälschlich angenommen hat dass die beiden in Jive und im Bayrischen über dasselbe reden.

Was in dieser Szene hat auch nur irgendwas mit "political correctness" oder "kultureller Aneignung" zu tun?

The wrong subtitles weren't a conscious choice, it's simply a mistake. They're directly translated from the original subtitles, because the translators didn't know that the two speaking jive are talking about something completely different than in the German/Bavarian dub, probably because they couldn't understand Bavarian. That is funny on a meta level, but it's certainly not a deliberate choice.

@@szeddezs Nonsense, it's intentionally wrong - like in the original.

Just brilliant! Or like they say in Bavaria: "Sacklzementhallelujiadeswargrindig"

@@newYorkStories Das sagt ganz sicher niemand so auf Bayerisch, denn "grindig" ist etwas Negatives. Vielleicht "griabig".

@@LarsTragel-zh7ei des basst a

Do you know Günter Oettinger? Maybe you should listen to him speaking english...

​@@minimal_Sonntag"In Dschörmeni wi trai efaunds soliuschns in se inischiäjtif of se Deutsche Bank"

Heisst es nicht "Jagaschoas" (Kaffee)?

Yes. Bavarian is the most heavy accent in all of germany...ask any german

the more you come to the province the harder it is to understand. And of course every region in Bavaria has its own dialect. "Die spinnen, die Bayern".

@@minimal_Sonntag Bavarians are spiders?

@@undeadknight01 lol, might be right, but it meant that they are a little special (crazy), different from the rest of germany.

@@minimal_Sonntag lol