It would be cool if the pets could roam around the house without being forced to be sitting down forever... idk how I would implement that, but I always feel sad when the animals just have to stay in place
@GreenJab10 сағат бұрын
fair
@miasweatman734013 сағат бұрын
this is a really great video! unlike other balance videos, it sticks to Minecraft's core design principles by aiming to expand choice, rather than just adding vertical progression and balancing things like other balance videos do. however, I do disagree with some points. personally I think horses SHOULD be difficult to take through forests and hills. it balances them by them being easy to use in open terrain and harder in rough terrain. also, it feels more adventurous to explore rough terrain slower and on foot. the problem arrises when there is open terrain on the other side of rough terrain or ocean with no way to reach it. the fix I would suggest is making it easier to put horses in boats and minecarts. you could then navigate rivers to get through rough terrain or build rails over/through mountains. this would encourage players to build infrastructure such as canals, railways, or treeless roads through forests, and in my opinion encouraging building is good in Minecraft. also, it would make it easier to get THROUGH rough terrain while still being hard to EXPLORE thoroughly. I also don't think your entire inventory should be accessible from your hotbar. maybe in the late game it could be expanded a litttle, but not to effectively 36 slots. choosing what to put in your hotbar is a somewhat strategic choice that requires planning ahead whether you think you'll need to mine, eat, build, fight enemies, or travel. you might fill your hotbar with blocks to make building easier, but then be caught off guard by monsters and take a split second to equip a weapon. alternatively, you might equip a sword and axe in your hotbar but encounter a skeleton. or you might fight a boss and have to decide which potions and items you want instantly available. it's not the most engaging system in the world but I think it's at least somewhat interesting. I do like the changes suggested in this video, but don't think they're entirely necessary
@sp0opy31723 сағат бұрын
To me minecraft is a kingdom building game(with the kingdom being made up of villagers) but like others I do have certain villagers I use for trading even give them there own little stalls at the centre of my town
@KyusujiКүн бұрын
The Truman reference is truly what made me leave after giving a like and subscribe!🎉
@Rutious4Күн бұрын
Elytra didn't kill rail. Rail was dead way before, it's just so underpowered (you realise that at least). Why would you build a nice, satisfying overworld ride if you can just warp to another dimension and get a 8x speed multiplier? Or build an absurd ice boat tunnel there?
@Barakon2 күн бұрын
I want someone to make a furniture mod that has to have the furniture be constructed out of building blocks first, then combined using things like, screws, screwdrivers, nails, nuts, bolts, sandpaper, brushes, chisels, hammers, etc, etc. That way it can be done block by block & keep the player immersed! That way the player earns it like they do the ability to slay monsters in a flash at night.
@GreenJab2 күн бұрын
although sounds interesting, it still feels way to far removed from vanilla and no where near the scope of what I’m trying to achieve
@7gamesaday8672 күн бұрын
Please add a way to change or repair your mic haha for further videos
@GreenJab2 күн бұрын
I've gotten better at using my mic in part 3
@julianbaxter24032 күн бұрын
10:28 Not all of us cage them up. My villagers are free and happy.
@GreenJab2 күн бұрын
As they should be
@TheLunatrick3 күн бұрын
They need to add loot crates
@GreenJab3 күн бұрын
well the technically already did years ago (for April fools)
@Whitewing893 күн бұрын
Trivial to obtain? netherite? Isn't that shit like really rare? Like, I'm just getting back after years, but in all my playing, i have never had an abundance of dimands. I had my one set of gear and maybe a dozen or so spare dimand, i can't imagine mineing for turbo dimand fragments takes less than a few hours of mindless digging. Even if you only need one per item. You're brushing over hours of work and know how to set up mob farms for gun power and redstone contraptions for sugarcane as if it's placing a single block in your epilogue.
@GreenJab3 күн бұрын
I honestly don’t understand your arguments
@Whitewing893 күн бұрын
In my exspence some changes aren't worth the effort. I find the elder dragons in Monster Hunter are too much of a pain to fight for me to want to play the late part of the game where EVERY FIGHT is another elder dragon. I need to ENJOY the task as the payoff for besting the challenge won't carry me.
@GreenJab3 күн бұрын
elder.. dragon?
@Whitewing893 күн бұрын
You could also buff fish.
@Whitewing893 күн бұрын
As someone planning to build an item sorter, your golem changes sound painful. I already can't build the farm because i need a way to get villagers.
@GreenJab3 күн бұрын
how does the golem change affect villagers? and you can mine for iron?
@Nada-nonexistent3 күн бұрын
28:04 sick jumps you say? i wonder what mojang added this time
@GreenJab3 күн бұрын
what am I supposed to do? take down my video, edit it and reupload? I’m happy some of what I said is out of date if it means mojang is starting to implement the stuff
@Nada-nonexistent3 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab i was kinda making a joke, but i actually think mojang took some inspiration from this video for more recent update because it has been popping off (this got in my recommended like 17 times) 👍
@GreenJab3 күн бұрын
@@Nada-nonexistent It's okay, I was making a joke too.
@salmeleons4 күн бұрын
i think the best option is to lock firework boosting behind a non-rrnewable enchantment that you can find in a rare end structure. sure, people will immediately seek it out, but it wotn ruin the fun of others but still balance the elytra
@GreenJab4 күн бұрын
I'm trying to avoid stuff like adding a new enchant but rather reuse what the game already has
@weelebaseknowles44104 күн бұрын
Console edition had Minecraft at its best
@RyanHunter-zi7qe4 күн бұрын
Creeper with swiftness is awful 😂
@GreenJab4 күн бұрын
Awful but beautiful
@RyanHunter-zi7qe3 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab Absolutley, or like if some rarer mobs spawned with those supercharged enchanted items? Oh God the implications! Love your work man!
@terrencemoore87394 күн бұрын
Minecraft isnt just a survival game. That would answer a lot of why it isnt the way you'd like it to be. Players like making farms. They like making renewable respurces for things, i feel like redstone wasnt touched on much at all. There are plenty of survival games, there are even survival focused mods for Minecraft, i think Minecraft should continue being the everything game
@GreenJab4 күн бұрын
I agree, and I am apart of tmc, all I do now is farms and redstone. I'm not saying minecraft is a purely survival game, but there are elements of the survival experience that have become problems that I can no longer ignore
@Smug_K3 күн бұрын
Palworld has a bunch of renewable resources does that make it a survival sandbox game?
@xiNerdLordix4 күн бұрын
Frostwalker enchants for horses is a great idea
@tanayshahane52394 күн бұрын
honestly i dont think this really fits for the main game as it is a casual game and in general you wont need full defense from fire, explosions or projectiles in solo minecraft especially, id say this would be VERY WELL suited as a modpack
@Smug_K4 күн бұрын
I think you should Nerf end crystals to be only placed on bedrock
@timer1925 күн бұрын
The main problem is that the players can literally access the 2nd best gear in the game on day two
@GreenJab5 күн бұрын
I say something small in part 3 about this, but overall there isn’t much you can do about this without making vanilla no longer vanilla
@TheSpencermacdougall5 күн бұрын
As someone who recently decided to use a map in their world, I want that map book.
@GreenJab5 күн бұрын
I’m glad you like
@christophercollett56655 күн бұрын
Different materials of equipment should probably change the max enchant level. Wood and stone can't hold much, iron and diamond hold more, and gold holds the most.
@GreenJab5 күн бұрын
While I have thought about this, I have decided to go against this for the sake of simplicity, they only material which acts differently would be good to make it stand out
@TheSpencermacdougall5 күн бұрын
For your Inventory Section, I think Inventorio is a good mod to represent your idea, though I could be wrong. I'm mostly referring to the tool belt, since it adds something like that, along with some other things.
@GreenJab5 күн бұрын
The tool belt is one of the idea I have being debating on if it does fit vanilla. an alternative now that you can take your item of choice out of it, if you add either being able to hold multiple stacks, or perhaps 64 item, 32 “16s” (like eggs) or 4 unstackables could be an effective enough change to hold the extra tools that you wouldn’t have otherwise brought
@TheSpencermacdougall5 күн бұрын
28:00 Seems Mojang saw this video and decided to make you retroactively incorrect, given recent snapshots.
@GreenJab5 күн бұрын
Me being incorrect because mojang fixed it is not a bad thing, however there are a few things that are now broken in the new snapshots so it’s not all good
@mrskyler445 күн бұрын
I will stop playing minecraft if they remove mending. Sorry not sorry.
@GreenJab5 күн бұрын
but.. I'm not removing mending, just balancing it a little
@mrskyler445 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab yeah tbh your idea isn't too bad. I liked back when we had to kind of choose which enchants we wanted on each item because we couldn't have too many
@lexiu60366 күн бұрын
the bit about beacons reminds me of my idea i had a long time ago; adding a fire resistance effect (as it's quite often used) as a new effect for a beacon, but it would require netherite in some way
@dr_big_yoshi6 күн бұрын
I think rotten flesh would be another good bait for fishing. Very abundant in the early game, also gives it a use
@masun06 күн бұрын
They added your crafting idea!
@GreenJab6 күн бұрын
They have added a few things at this point
@brandond.7347 күн бұрын
I like your ideas. it seems like these would balance the game again. One thing I'd like to see in minecraft is a food update. There is no incentive to ever eat anything besides golden carrots or baked potatoes. Every other food item is basically useless, and adding some type of diet counter would i think be a good difficult adjustment. Not sure exactly how it would work, but something just as simple as every day you need a variety of "nutrients" so would have to eat some meet, vegetable, sugar food, and maybe even drink water. If you eat nothing but the same food, either your hunger bar doesn't fill up or it does fill up but then drains faster and faster the more of the same food you eat. There would actually be a point of getting all different types of food in the game if something like this was added
@GreenJab6 күн бұрын
You should have watched part 2 before commenting :)
@Smug_K7 күн бұрын
I think it would be cool if over enchanted gear has a higher chance to be cursed
@danilokleinerbutmobile27027 күн бұрын
Hotbar scrolling is in BTA. Try it out!
@hughmongus69597 күн бұрын
Every time I try to think of ideas to improve Minecraft, I start reinventing Terraria 😂
@GreenJab7 күн бұрын
There are a few things terraria does which minecraft could take a hint from, but overall they are different games from different genres so I’m not trying to turn minecraft into terraria
@TRMrStone7 күн бұрын
The way up there is so satisfying that I forgot that I wanted to steal smth.
@GreenJab7 күн бұрын
I hadn't even thought of that
@TRMrStone7 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab That spiral tunnel door was my favorite :D
@stickmann73638 күн бұрын
How in the hell do you build these 😭
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
by ya know, building them :)
@SomethingBak8 күн бұрын
If I saw a suspiscious trail of sticky pistons, I'd follow them for sure
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
even if it’s a trap?
@SomethingBak8 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab im prepared to make that sacrifice, plus it'd still be hella intresting kinda reminds me of the forest staircases creepypasta
@odilazulixl53518 күн бұрын
Comsidering how (I think) afk fishing farms work, you could just fix it by giving fishing a delay on when something can bite after right clicking the rod, so the player has to wait a couple of seconds after casting the fishing rod before a fish can appear instead of holding right click in front of a machine and getting the rewards while afk.
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
the machine detects when the bite happens so that wouldn’t really do much
@odilazulixl53518 күн бұрын
Very nice changes. The only thing I'd say is bad is draining tons of stamina to heal when sneaking since you wouldn't be able to run or regain stamina while sneaking and it would punish the player for sneaking after being damaged, which you would want to do even if you didn't want to heal right then and there. Plus it's counter intuitive to get tired and not being able to run after standing still. Instead I would make it so that when sneaking, you heal by using hunger directly instead like the old days.
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
although yes you are “standing still” but I would argue trying to heal yourself would take more energy than sprinting so it still make sense. It becomes another game mechanic to actually engage and manage with rather abuse after 10 minutes of gameplay
@Zephyr7138 күн бұрын
*coolest vault
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
very true
@amonidark8 күн бұрын
Image such :]
@raskzak33138 күн бұрын
Probably the most satisfying one fore sure
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
facts
@zeusosecmaat71658 күн бұрын
YOUR ENCHANTING MECHANICS ARE SOO GOOD 😮😮
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
and it gets better in part 2 and beyond
@zeusosecmaat71658 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab Its funny that your bundle changes got added in the new snapshot
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
@@zeusosecmaat7165 There is a slight problem with not being able to see everything in it now but otherwise it looks very promising
@zeusosecmaat71658 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab I think thats just a bug that will get fixed later on
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
@@zeusosecmaat7165 I think it will be addressed yeah, we will just have to wait and see
@fakestory17538 күн бұрын
the moving platform in the dark reminds me of Laputa
@TheNukeCell8 күн бұрын
ah yes, fixing minecraft.
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
I fixed vaults, what are you talking about
@Smug_K8 күн бұрын
Is part 3 coming this week?
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
my goal is end of this month, but will see how I go
@polishscribe6748 күн бұрын
This is just a fancy transportation system...
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
to an extent yeah
@S2plkmix15208 күн бұрын
Ye im building it (actually no)
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
but why not :(
@notallthatskilled7 күн бұрын
@@GreenJab because hadgls3is rkrnwoszbr
@SuperDZ5558 күн бұрын
the safest vault is an ender chest because the inventory is per-player
@GreenJab8 күн бұрын
fair, that is very true
@RngGm6 күн бұрын
It isnt. Accounts can still be hacked, but its harder to someones memories of the location of a vault You could make a vault that is harder to find than stealing someones password, but at that point why are you even playing with someone willing to steal your account for some minecraft items