WELL STUPID RECORD COMPANY. IF THIS SONG WAS MADE INTO A SINGLE. THIS WOULD HAVE BEEN THE NEXT NUMBER 1.

The "drifting..." part wasn't perfect, but it makes so happy she was confident and strong enough to go for it!

She always writes her songs in the highest key!!!!

Actually the first minute has no struggle! Don't compare this performance to the one in Tokyo Dome... it was 16 years before... and she was the same person not another artist so don't discredit her, she gave us some of the greatest timeless masterpiece like this song and also the greatest voice to ever grace the Earth!!

still sounds beautiful.

i'm just so glad she decided to perform this song that era. her voice was in a really good place and her tone was magical. of course she didn't do it as good as in her prime but the fact that she didn't dodge any whisper and falsettos is AWESOME given the fact that that is the hard part of the song. i just love her, people are just rude and don't understand her impact.

Why she look so flawless here.

People need to stop criticizing MC stop being hateful. Beforee we judge we must be a true singer first singing for so many years so we know how she feels, whats happening to her voice, state of voice, weather, hormones, age etc we all must be "empathic". She is the Best for me....!

She sounds like an angel here. Not perfectly delivered but the voice came from heaven.

without the beltings she sounds so amazing..! she sings like an angel, withOut beltings..! ok, Mariah was known for being hitting high notes, but c'mon, she's not in her 20's to 30's anymore.. just appreciate her new genre.,,!

you can clearly tell that her voice is lower but she still sounds good tho

At least she didn't lipped on this one. I prefer this

I truly believe this can be and should be a #1 song. I believe Mariah Carey should have more the 19 #1 songs. Her Discography is impeccable. Mariah's voice really is so wonderful feeds the soul angelic voice #MC30 #SaveTheDay #TheRarities #TheMeaningOfMariahCarey #OutHereOnMyOwn #UnderneathTheStars #MariahCarey

You all should thank her. She's being careful hitting all the notes cause we'll know its a complicated song.

I'm so happy she did it live ! Even her not being in her 100%, i really loved it!!

Although she can't sing as smoothly as before but I still love her vocals loads! She is one of the best! I can't wait for her #Beautiful single collaborating with Miguel out tomorrow, 060513!

I don't know if anyone's tried singing this song but it's pretty hard to sing and sound good. She did great.

I can tell she feels more confident. She sang Underneathe the Stars, Can't Take That Away, and Without You. Keep up the good work Mariah. Can't wait to hear more.

Ugh her voice is still great, and she's already proven herself to be the best so whatever, but compared to her vocal prime, this performance doesn't compare.

Crazy “and the feeling was so heady and sublime” gives me chills. Her voice transcends through space and time I thought my heart flew a few years ago when every artist doesn’t know auto tune Fabolous Mariah two thumbs up

Just for being confident and going for that "Drifting part " I give her credit 😍

I adore this song, its so enchanting and elegant and takes you away to a far away dream world. LOVE YOU MARIAH, THE QUEEN.

4:23 - 4:30 . Still got it! :D

Mariah literally needs to just release and album called "Mariah's Singles" with all the overlooked amazing tracks so that they can go #1😭🦄🔥🌈⚡🧡❤💋✨

4:39 idk why but that vocal break made me tear up!! watching her sing this in Morocco feels like fever dream... if you're reading this comment please listen to Underneath The Stars, Fourth of July, and Bliss by Mariah Carey in that order. your welcome

I love this song. And I love her voice :-)

I love this! So much! It was such a big deal that it was televised. People loved her so much ♥️♥️

one of my favorites....love love love

soooo amazing ,,mariah ,,you did it again after all these years . !!!I love you MC you're a true legend .33

WORD! Saw this beautiful DIVA twice in 2019. She was FLAWLESS!! Just like when I saw Whitney in 1999. 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥰🥰

Sounds soooo good! Very close to the recording! Loveee it!

one of my fave mariah songs ever.

Once again, I love that she slowed it down all the way. This is really a true groove song. And she looks stunning.

i love this 😍

Música mais doce que ja ouvi. Te Amoo Mariah ❤

I love it.. I wasn't expecting the Tokyo Dome version but you can feel she likes this song.

This is one of my favorite songs

One of my fav! Definitely would have been a #1 had it been a single!!!

AMAZING!

She sounded so good. I think she's making this song as a part of the regular setlist.

This was just magic. 😪

03/01/2016 - 14/05/2020 But the time went sailing by Reluctantly we said goodbye (Maar de tijd ging voorbij met tegenzin namen we afscheid) *Underneath the stars* Mariah Carey

Hahaha she's gorgeous, extremely funny, an amazing singer and has an amazing heart!! Thank you for uploading this, I am going through a hard time and only Mariah makes me feel a little bit alive! :)

Her voice has changed, but she did Underneath the stars better that I can expect. Although she removes her nodules, she will never sing like she did in '95s. It's a fact, but she's still one of the best

Lovely darling❤️that ending tho🙌🏻

Justice for Underneath the stars!

Your the best Maria carey,,, i love you

4:24 was heaven

She’s was right this would of been a bigger hit if they listened to her

Mariah did great loved it

One summer night, we ran away for a while Laughing we hurried beneath the sky To an obscure place to hide That no one could find And we drifted to another state of mind And imagined I was yours and you were mine As we lay upon the grass there in the dark Underneath the stars (young love) Underneath the stars (young love) Weak in the knees wrapped in the warm, gentle breeze I, so shy, a bundle of butterflies Flushed with the heat of desire On a natural high As we drifted to another place and time And the feeling was so heady and sublime As I lost my heart to you there in the dark Underneath the stars, (oh, woah) Young love Beautiful and bittersweetly You were fading into me and I was gently fading into you But the time went sailing by Reluctantly we said goodbye And we left our secret place so far behind And I lay in bed all night and I was Drifting, drifting, drifting, Drifting (and we drifted to another state of mind) (And imagined I was yours and you were mine) (As we lay upon the grass there in the dark) Underneath the stars (young love) Young love Underneath the stars (young love) Underneath the stars (young love) Underneath the stars (young love) Underneath the stars (young love) Underneath the stars (young love) Underneath the stars (young love)

Those beautiful airy voice of mariah carey is totally the best 👏👏👏 Thats why i really love her queen 👑👑👑 And i think most of those singer now inspired by her music techniques

That's another resin why I love her... she manages to join us (lambs) together like a family! Don't worry.. I bet that if we don't give up we'll get through the hard moments!! #Lambily

The way she sings hwr breathy notes changed so drasgically

ya..agree! i do appreciate what she did, putting her effort to produce such voice live. we understand she isn't like she was in 95, 96, but even with this performance i still give her 5 stars for trying hard and give her best. that's precious, and she did it for us. plus, now only i can listen to the runs clearly since he use less whisper in this song. :)

Diva overload dahhling 👏😂 i really love her

Her upper belt range is virtually non-existent in this song, but she clearly had it for Joy to the World 2013. She must've been fatigued or had too much alcohol before this performance.

Another Great song i love by her and no one can say this one is lipped either this is a very hard song to sing

Just not the same without the legendary D5...

looooove

Great

The show must go on. :)

go girl!

oh my GOD!!! I love UTS........MARIAH IS MARIAH!!!

Oh man I'm so sad and so happy for her at the same time :'( :')

I love the dress

love this :)

so good that she didn't let the back up voices sing at the beginning :))))

OMG the vocal moment at 0:47 is just DIVINE! that voice is just unique! a trademark itself.

DRINKING GAME! each time MC mentions MORROCAN its time to have a SPLASH wow im FESTIVE 4REAL!!! XOXOXOXOXO

I think about 16 years! Its crazy!

her voice was on fire that night ;)

Baby baby please let me be the one to have that space in your heart ❤ drifting under neat the stars 🌟 don't ever give your love away

she's 42 and she's still rockin me underneath her stars :')

Her nodules are at the top of her chest voice. U can tell thats where they rest.

Talented

at the end u can see her shaking her head.meaning she din quite satisfied.there goes major perfection of her.

WOW

i how she handled this freaking hard song

Underneath The Stars did not become a single because of Tommy Mottola! Mariah is a true genius about this song. Fans love it so much. So do I.

love when she saids Ray-C---tadadada! lol love her...hilarious xo God bless.

right on! she's one of the best singers in the world! you're lamb right?! :)

Ok but can we talk about how high her speaking voice in the beginning!!!

💗💗💗

00:53 love it,resonant

This shows how tired her voice was

2020 💓😆

please do a 2020 version ❤️❤️❤️

I agree with you. I was so pleasantly surprised to hear her sing a song without lip-syncin... I so prefer this Mariah

5:11 that was funny tho

I think this sounds beautiful I like rasp I know why she sounds like that, she earned it

Period,but she's still the greatest

i compare thiis to when she was in tokyo 1996 ahhh guys nooo

PEOPLE, she sang it just like the original track. The climax is the same on the original version. Did you all forget?

I often find myself really critical of her 2010+ performances but shit, I'm surprised by these comments. I thought it was quite beautiful

Oh dear 😳

Refer to WBT from this concert. It was live. The thing is. Her voice is still there. But it's hard to get it out.

I love how she sang a little line from "Who Do I Run To?" by Xscape. Now I gotta go listen to their remix of "Always Be My Baby" lol

Wow she did great! I mean it was not the same as the Tokyo one in 96 but still beautiful

Justice for #UTS ♥️♥️♥️💯♥️