you don't know it, but you are my upright teacher

"cats in 1881weren't really taking solos" I lol'd thank you for the lesson

Hey there this was super informative. I went to Lawrence University and studied under a great bass player but still struggle with thumb position agility. This builds off everything I learned and gets me excited to practice some thumb position and solo more up there! Thank you!

Hi Cole! Ok, First of all...This was a GREAT video and you single handedly just WON ME OVER! I am going to your website and getting your method book. Secondly...I am 59 years young and I just finished my MM in Jazz Studies from The University of North Texas last May 2023 of which I am proud of (which is why I mention it), BUT in my 45 years of playing the bass and 30+ years of play jazz and double bass, I have NEVER been adequately trained with a teacher to play in thumb position! I am not blaming anyone, but in ALL my academia (and there has been a lot), I was never taken into thumb position. Story for another time. So, I will begin here with the tunes (of which I know very well...but not in thumb position, LOL...) you outlined and do and practice the fingering as you have prescribed! Yes, once upon a time, I too, worked from the Simandle method and used it with my students. I also have the Rabbath book (Blue one) covering thumb position, but...embarrassingly, have never really cracked it open...because of the level of difficulty it appears to be and nobody to help me through it. Having said all that, (sorry this is so long) this is why I said you WON me over! Thank you for making this video...I will head to your website and start taking care of business in thumb position...FINALLY! LOL! Your new friend and bass brother, Kurt

I'm self taught I don't know the Simandl merhod, I never use the harmonics in normal playing (for timbral consistency), but I'm seeing progress by finding multiple fingerings for scales/modes in all keys, and spending time working out efficient fingerings for specific melodies. Shifting in and out of thumb position is the biggest speedbump for me. I'm just going to keep plugging away and I know I'm going to keep improving. I think that determination is the most important thing. Well, determination and awareness are two wings.

Good lesson. Thumb position opens up when it becomes movable, and anchors wherever it’s placed.

Great video! Your playing is fantastic, also I like the way you explain!

Man, just the first 5 minutes of this video already changed everything for me! Thank you for this fantastic information Cole

Great Video and great concept. Congrats

Tremendo Davis, vengo aplicando tus conceptos. Te felicito. Saludos desde Argentina

Thanks Cole!

Really appreciate these insights. Thank you, Cole.

Thank you. Great video, keep them coming The book is really good

Excelente abordagem. Bravo.

Really great !!!!! Thank you !!

Great playing and I agree with the premise until you present Simandl as a fingering system - it is an ear training and fingerboard mapping system. The fingerings are as often by Fred Zimmerman or Lucas Drew as Simandl. Sticking to the fingering in Simandl is misuse of the method.

Thank you!

8:26 sent me 😆

To go with the Left arm up on the E string it’s not natural at all , not good for many things and there are many reasons why not to do it. Otherwise , you have achieve a quite high level with your way of playing. Congrats!

Good stuff

This is a good revisioning of the classic method! The ideas of dividing scale notes in other ways than one or two isn’t that new of a concept on the guitar or even electric bass, but on the double bass it’s been another story 😅 Good to see that there are people that dare to think in and develop new ways to teach the instrument. I’m interested in the new simandl- book but would like to have a preview of it before making a purchase. Are there any youtube- videos of the book or pdf preview pages anywhere?😊

I started out on Cello using the classic BS (before Suzuki) methods. This means using a lot of open strings and focusing often on 1st position regardless of what key you're in. Later, when I started playing electric bass, I learned by ear and mostly put my first finger on the tonic. This way I actually learned the fingering patterns. So this seems to relate to your video here. Using the Simandl method is like trying to stay in 1st position regardless of key, even if it's awkward and inefficient. What you're advocating is put your thumb where it's most logical based on the scale and melody. If I were to teach anyone to play cello or bass, I would teach to play without open strings first, then add them in later after the student understood the scale patterns.

Thanks for the video, Cole. I am relearning thumb position and have your "Freedom of Movement" book. I started this last fall with the George Vance, but found you soon thereafter. This video helps so much by watching your body and shoulder position, too. I used to always sit. Now, I am trying to stand. When you move back to third position, do you move your left foot back in tandem or are just shifting your weight? Where do you find it more comfortable? I have had rotator cuff tendonitis in my left shoulder, from my day job as a dog groomer. So, I am looking for that path of least resistance. 😉

Not like Giovanni Bottesini would be using ‘Simandl’ method but he was soloing his ass off on the bass till he died in the 1890s He was already playing salon concerts improvising on operatic themes in the 1840s. Domenico Dragonetti was crushing improvised bass solo’s in the late 1700s… Simandl was late in the game… the Italian ‘Caimmi’ method was preferred to Simandl till 20th century when the string lengths on bass got a few inches shorter.

Great vid! Thank you. Is there a book that you'd recommend for thumb position?

Hey Cole, thank you for another wonderful video! I have a question: do you rather have your index finger bending when you play on thumb position, or you prefer to keep it straight? Bending backwards, I mean.

Hey man, great video. The link to the store doesnt work, and the patreon page doesn't seem to have the etudes book, can you send it ? thanks

Lots of truth here. I also find your fingering makes for an easy application of practicing the melodic minor in thumb which I have struggled with.

Maybe the first secret would be showing a thumbnail in actual thumb position. Crazy idea….i know! 😂

So should I learn the Simandl method then apply everything in the video to what I would learn from it or can/should I use this video as an introduction to thumb position?

My problem is my hand are so big that it is hard for me to play smaller intervals in thumb position without my hand being cramped up in a way that makes it difficult to play. By the time my thumb is lined up with my other fingered, my hand is scrunched up and I don’t know what I’m doing wrong or what I might need to change to accommodate my size hands

🙏

Good video, but in your printed examples that appear on the screen, you use a "0" for the thumb instead of a "+". This tends to be confusing and is the first time I've ever seen this kind of notation. Personally, in my 50 years of playing, I have been hindered by my double jointed left hand thumb. It really prevents me from playing in the high registers, especially on the low strings. If I bend and push it into my hand, it looks like a "comma". There are probably many of us out there that have the same problem, so your explanations on thumb positions obviously work well for you. Luckily, I have practiced enough to get around this "defect" and can ultimately play anything I work on, as is the solution for many of us.

Yo this video is hype as eff but I don’t think the telephone was invented in 1881, I think it was more of an 1876 kind of vibe. The metal detector has more of that “invented in 1881” kind of sound though

it was Marconi not Bell !!!

Simandl is kinda old lol

Real double bass players use a bow.