Calvin Johnson and Dez Bryant both caught those passes. You know which ones I'm talking about.

The Calvin Johnson catch was a travesty of justice That was a catch He only lost possession after his knee hit which means he was down Lion would of won the game Instead they lost😠

1:42 honestly, even though it didn't count, it was still an awesome and actually smart play by that lineman. The play was on 3rd down, so after the desperation throw by Tua, that was really the best outcome, considering it gave the Dolphins an extra down. If the ball just falls or is caught with no score, it's 4th down. Hunt making that catch AND getting a TD forced the Ravens to accept that penalty and give them another chance. Of course, Dolphins didn't capitalize on it, but still.

Aaron’s first throw was absolutely insane. One of the best plays I have ever seen

What’s crazy about 12:30 is if dez’s fingers didn’t touch out of bounds, Cowboys would’ve eventually made the playoffs instead of the (at the time) Redskins, Cowboys could’ve rest their starters on the final week meaning Romo wouldn’t have gotten injured that game (weather if they did anything in the playoffs is debatable) The Redskins would have missed the playoffs instead which means RGIII would’ve never injured his knee again too Edit: Romo actually didn’t get hurt that game, my mistake😅 Dez did end up injuring his foot in that game tho

No compilation of plays that get called back or not count is complete without a big play called back because of the human holding penalty, Bolles. Bravo.

Those freakin’ holding calls just suck the life right out of a game sometimes.

The Calvin Johnson and Dez Bryant no-catches are travesties to football. Beautiful plays that deserved to stand as catches.

I'll never forget, that Brandon Lyod catch. Bummer it didn't count.

Potential future game request ideas for Throwback: 2005 Week 10 Washington at Tampa Bay (36-35) 2002 Week 12 Colts at Broncos (SNF in the snow) 2004 Week 1 Colts at Patriots (Thursday night Kickoff)

Brandon Lloyd low key made some of the greatest catches I’ve ever seen in my life and I’ve been watching football for 47 years

That Steelers Jesse James one still kills me to this day!

I love how the Steelers and Lions catches touching the ground are here. Even the NFL couldn't get their rules right. It was explained to be early on that the rules are different if in contact with a defender. Both of these wouldn't be catches if a defender was taking the player to the ground at the time. But this seemed to get applied to all catches and not just in contact. Without that contact from a defender, the offensive player has to do less to establish a full catch. Maintaining control and making a move that then causes the ground to jar the ball loose is always a catch.

25:00......how is it a blindside block when he squared the guy up running straight at him?

The Calvin Johnson debackle is when I stopped taking football seriously

1:40 the greatest touch down never made. He saved a possible interception because him and the intended receiver/ the RB ran into each other and Tua threw the ball where the RB was supposed to be so good save but he was supposed down the ball. The play isn't dead until he's down so a fumble can be recovered by the defense who can decline the penalty. That run and stretch for the touch down was because he originally was a tight end so he was running on pure reflex after he caught the ball

*Somewhere in the NFL Throwback Studios* Boss: "Who's got an idea for the next video?" Some intern: "How about we upset every NFL fan for 32 minutes?" Boss: "You're getting a raise."

That Tarik Cohen TD at 15:45 should’ve counted cuz he didn’t step out of bounds. That would’ve have been one of the coldest walk off TD’s in NFL History if it would have counted

That moss to Favre throw was so legendary, it was like their first play together too lmao. My family was going crazy 😄

31:57 Going into this video I had a certain Dez Bryant catch in mind....and they made me wait until the very end, haha nicely done. True football diehards will always say that the Calvin and that last Dez catch were legitimate catches, and I personally feel the Dez catch is one of the greatest of all time. (I'm a Steelers fan btw) why you ask? If you really look at it, he completes the catch AS HE SURVIVES THE GROUND...in other words, he gained control of it the more it played out, that's why it's bogus to say he didn't maintain control. He gradually got control of it throughout the whole crazy process, he didn't grab it and then start losing control of it. You have to really look at it closely. It's at least one of the coolest looking catches. A lot of Antonio Brown, Dez and DeAndre Hopkins throughout this video

I'm not even a Detroit Lions fan but that Calvin Johnson reversal makes me so mad to this day

As a Chiefs fan 4:03 will always make so mad. I cried so much that night

Outstanding compilation. Great to see these either again or for the first time. Hope you can find enough for a part 2

I'm surprised they didn't include the Tuck Rule. That changed the outcome of a playoff game and, arguably, some careers and franchises.

NFL Instant Replay From 1986 To 1993 Thanks For Uploading

Leading off with the greatest catch that didn't count. Watched that game live. Absolutely unbelievable that they didn't realize he caught that thing. And then Jon Baldwin too. I think he was a combo of poor: coaching, atmosphere, and drive. Kid could've been great.

Still will never forget the Steelers pats game in 2017 I knew there would be an instant rule change after the game

That Jesse James call is one of the worst I’ve seen. As an Eagles fan I was hoping they didn’t make the same mistake on Ertz’s GW TD in the SB

Great set of plays, though you are missing the Bears/Packers fake fair catch on a punt return. It went for a touchdown (the Packers all chased down the guy signaling fair catch, while someone on the other end of the field actually caught it), but was called back for a holding penalty.

Thanks for the video NFL Throwback! I know this may be a hard question, does anyone happen to know any games that had a fight or brawl occur which resulted in more than 2 disqualifications? Here are some that I do know: 1. Browns-Steelers 2019 (3 ejected) 2. Dolphins-Bengals 2020 (3 ejected) 3. Bengals-Raiders 2012 (3 ejected) 4. Bears-49ers 2018 (3 ejected) 5. Giants-Rams 2014 (4 ejected) 6. Cardinals-Bears 1986 Preseason (4 ejected) 7. Bills-Oilers 1987 (4 ejected) 8. Oilers-Steelers 1987 (3 ejected) 9. Cardinals-49ers 2017 (3 ejected) 10. Raiders-Broncos 2017 (3 ejected) (I’m mainly looking for games from the 1980’s, 1990’s, and 2000’s)

I know there were a lot of scoring plays in this list, but I'm kind of surprised to not see THE Derrick Henry stiff arm. The internet loved that one, but it was another play called back due to penalty.

I have suggested this many times. I am glad to see that it has finally been made. Next suggestion I am waiting for, plays that were more than just their stat line. For example, Marion Barber's 2 yard run vs the Patriots where he broke several tackles and avoided a safety.

Can't believe they did not include the Zach Miller catch where he broke his knee on play where he scored a touchdown against the Saints!

Boy as a Steelers fan I’ll tell you that Miami game where browns foot just barely caught out of bonds kills me every time I watch it lol I swear it was like 2 toes out lmao. Oh well it happens 🤷🏻‍♀️

Man so many of these are real heartbreakers.

That Rodgers play was beautiful

Dez is a god at this

Calvin Johnson caught it :(

That one play I would remember that was wiped out by a penalty is that 100 some yard interception return TD during the Lions Falcons 2014 game. If the penalty wouldn't of happened, that would of been amazing.

the Brandon Lloyd one hander not counting absolutely hurt my soul 😮‍💨😮‍💨💯

Believe it or not, that 2nd play was something I could do ever since I started throwing the ball with my dad in the front yard, I did so well for so long and then I was told I couldn't play anymore because of my health (epilepsy) etc. Still breaks my heart I never got to make it up there.

I will say this till the day I die, JESSE JAMES HAD A TD!

1:55 Even Troy Aikman enjoyed that play!

I'll never forget being at Bucs-Steelers on MNF (Fitzmagic szn) and DJax had an epic, super-clutch punt return TD called back for holding. Haven't had a mood swing like that in my life 🙃

Thanks for another great video! If you guys are taking game requests, I'd recommend Week 17 Giants vs Eagles.

Quite often, those holding penalties that negated a touchdown were the only reason the QB had time to make the throw - it's pretty hard to throw a TD pass when you have just ben flattened by a pass rusher that just beat one of your O-linemen, who grabbed the rusher in order to save his QB's life!

The great Game of Inches! So many amazing moments

I see you saved the most painful one as the last one 😭💀😤

I can’t believe this left out Emmanuel Sanders catch against the Browns in 2015. that play was insane

What a GREAT idea for a list!

I will never not be bitter about that Dez "non-catch" against the packers. Breaks my heart every time I think about it.

You could do a follow up with plays from the past that counted but wouldn’t count under current rules

I still remember the Jimmy Smith pick six had me jumping up and down and screaming to the point where I almost lost my voice. That pissed me off so much. Still ended up being fine though because we won that game with a whole bunch of backups starting 👍

I dont care who your team is, if you're a football fan these are heartbreaking. Good video

Jesse James TD being over ruled was another Patriot blessing that they always seem to get by the officials. The Steelers would have won the Super bowl with the team they had.

The cover pic of dez breaks my heart. Such an amazing play, dez Bryant’s finger going out of bounds was the start of the giants Super Bowl run.

that browns play with hoyer to manziel is so neat

I love the Devin Hester one, they rescinded the return because of the flag and made them punt it again just for him to run back AGAIN 💯🤣🤣😭😭😭

I just burst out laughing out how they ended on the famous dez caught it 😂😂😂

That lineman screen for the Dolphins tho🔥

The hill catch was unbelievable that when I saw the replay I couldn't believe it

Dez caught it! Should’ve been nfc champ game that year against Seattle (which we would’ve probably won, maybe even the super bowl?) Jesse James caught it. Pittsburgh should be #1 seed that year and win it all had it stood. Calvin Johnson caught that ball, unfortunately, no miracles happen for the lions that year in 2010

This is incredible. And hard to watch! It's gut wrenching!

I remember the Brees record breaker being called back, what I'm a little fuzzy on is didn't they end up having to kick a field goal and he didn't get the record until the next drive right?

😩So much pain & joy in this video!

That Horseshoe doing wonders for Colts defenses, unfortunately not once the Colts have the ball in their hands

This is a great video thank you for uploading it NFL Throwback and some of these plays I think they should have counted

Way to dig deep and find the plays peeps, a lot of these would be on top ten lists everywhere if they would have stood!

I tuned in for the Moss to Farve pass. It was AMAZING to see in the moment, then the flag lands.

Best Video 📷 Ever NFL Throwback 🏈👍 Great Job ✅

As a younger cowboys fan i cant tell you how shity the ruling of the Dez Bryant catch was. 3 years of 8-8 and we finally put together a good enough group to take it up to green bay and we lose on that. Something later ruled as a catch years after, smfh. The football gods are crewel.

Naz Jones pick 6 of Aaron Rodgers on 9-10-17 called back. It was the first play of Naz's career. He was a DT for the Seahawks.

the antonio brown catch vs the saints at 20:10 should count lol... his heel touched in bounds before the rest of his foot touched out of bounds

The very last clip, thats a catch. I am not a cowboys fan but he had control of the ball.

Calvin caught it, never forget it

I love how the last video is of Dez and the "no catch" 😂

15:30 Makes me wonder how many total KR/ PR touchdowns regardless of flags Devin Hester has had

25:13 A blindside block call for blocking someone that’s running directly behind you is crazy

Dez CAUGHT IT!!!

1:29 This is arguably the greatest catch ever made, that didn't go into the books. What a travesty. No wonder I had never scene it! That catch would have been at the top of every "Greatest Catch" list.

2:04 even as a ravens fans, dolphins got robbed a big man touchdown. That’s cruel NFL

Funny how most of these plays involve the Packers, Steelers, Patriots, Cowboys, and Chiefs...

I can't believe my Jaguars were only on here once, and the call was in their favor. 😂

Correction: "32 Minutes of heart break if you were a fan of any of these teams."

14:08 That Chargers player stops thinking the play is over and gets decked 😂

Alternative title: Refball compilation

Dez caught it. That’s absolutely egregious.

James Harrison's interception and run back should be on here. There were so many blocks in the back.

The fact that Dez Bryant and Romo got three of these…

That one by Calvin Johnson was a touchdown

Wow I can’t believe they Call holding On the Packers!!!

Just to think we can put a man on the moon but at the same time cannot explain what a football catch is.

It's discouraging to see how many times the Cowboys show up in this video on the wrong side of the call. I think they may appear here more than any other single team. Oh--and Dez caught that ball.

Hopkins is 20% of this video and we’re the most amazing catches i have ever seen. Poor guy

This hard 🔥🔥🔥

They actually called a holding against the Fudge?!? What a very rare sight!

That ravens punt return that got overturned made me depressed for a solid three months

Alternately known as "The Least Satisfying NFL Compilation"

That Jessie James was nonsense lol

That first one was definitely a catch. I don't know why Andy Reid didn't challenge it