The tape over the bucket is the most ridiculous one to me. You know how to make a drum out of a bucket? TURN IT UPSIDE DOWN

The bucket one got me. Like why do the tape thing when you could just flip the bucket over and play the bottom! 🤣😂🤣😂

You don’t even need to be a musician to tell that the crafts aren’t legit 😭

5:40 "How's she changing the pitch?" Uhh... how's she even generating the sound. If you just blow into a pipe all you get is a whooshing sound. She's making the sound of a brass instrument, which requires blowing a "raspberry" angasint a mouthpiece - no reed.

The fact that 5 minute crafts has more subs than Two Set is sacrilegious itself.

Just a small detail - Overblowing allows you to access the whole harmonic series on woodwind, so it's not just octaves! (Although the higher you get, the harder it gets, of course!) This is how the altissimo register on saxophone works, for example

The audio not even being synced to the movements of her hand in the bowl-drum… SACRILEGIOUS!!!

Actually, I just switched piano teachers. And this new piano teacher says my playing is "unacceptable". Every video I watch by you said "practise". YOU are the motivation for me to do piano and your channel helped me pass my piano exam with High Merit :)))

you guys should make a video where you rebuild some "instruments" from 5 minute crafts! reminds me of Ann from How To Cook That who tried to make things 5 minute crafts and nothing worked out, she even pointed out that many things they show in their videos are really dangerous, esp. for children!

The carrot thing actually works. But not like these 5 minute dafts did it. You can't just drill 3 holes in a carrot and expect it to work. The holes need to be of different sizes. That's the actual key to making a flute. The positioning, order, none of it matters. The size of individual holes and their ratio to each other are what determines the notes. Sarah Jeffrey has a great video of making a recorder at a real recorder manufacturer with a carrot

@ 9:05 Every Scottish gene in my tiny ginger body cringed.

As a person that plays kalimba, the first thing is EXTREMELY SACRILIGEOS

Are we gonna talk about the fact that the carrot flute audio at 7:13 is literally from the video Twoset used when they made their carrot flutes? Like Five minute crafts couldn’t even be bothered to record their own audio😂

Finally Brett and Eddy has paid attention to the sacrilegious five minutes trash

Realistically speaking, when I did accordion competition, I practiced about 8-10 hours per day on two or three pieces for that many categories and it paid off. My accordion teacher said that "only perfect practice makes perfect"👍

One time I got one of my old car projects for my physics class and it had a balloon attached to a straw and I started playing with it and it started sounding like a tenor sax playing A. so naturally I lost it and I tried to recreate it but I never did. RIP tenor sax balloon straw thing 🪦💔🥀

Took me a whole minute to identify whether Brett really dyed his hair or it's just the light lol And he really did dye his hair!! LOVE IT!!

I particularly like how they printed a paper keyboard to put over their phone so you couldn't see what the app was actually doing

My favorite part is when you demonstrated buzzing 6:08. I'm a trombonist, had me cracking up

3:22 They played more notes than the phone screen even projected...

I have some experience in audio engineering. If you listen to the drum bowl clip starting around 8:04, at around 8:10 you'll notice a sudden blip of silence between drum beats. This happens because they didn't even bother adding any fades between different clips of the fake audio. Essentially, they spliced together two different clips of the same drum beat and didn't even bother to edit them together. That is something that can take as little as like one or two seconds, especially with how much empty space there is between these drum beats. Just an interesting tidbit for the curious and one more of many strikes against five minute crafts!

"Chopsticks is for eating, not for making instruments" All hobby desk drummers would disagree

3:05 WAIT WAIT WAIT plastic is insulator. hot glue is hot plastic. somehow it conducted. what

The copper wire piano is so cap. For it to actually work, you would need to somehow circulate the wires where the electricity to travel from the battery to the destination. You can't just hook up some wires loosely and expect to have made a robot, you need the wires to actually connect to something so that they can actually function properly.

if it was THIS easy to make instruments, no one would be buying them

3:15 This piano sound is actually a free sample library called Labs - Soft Piano. Notice that C on 3:18 is in a lower octave than this one 3:20. Same note, Different Octave. 5-Minute Crafts didn't even bother about making it look realistic lol.

TwoSet : 5 MINUTES CRAFT ONLY PRACTICES FOR 5 MINUTES!!!! Ling Lings who practice 5 minutes every 3 minutes : 👁👄👁 (Math : 40/24 hours =1.666… mins =1 + (6/9) mins Ling Lings practicing for 5 minutes = 5 minutes divide (1+6/9) =3 minutes Therefore, if Ling Lings practice 40 hours everyday, then they practice 5 minutes every 3 minutes. 4:02 Wow that’s so interesting! _This is definitely not fake and everyone who watches this knows that when you blow on straws there will definitely be sounds coming out of it and definitely won’t make a boring normal wind blowing sound!_

0:48 They're trying to imitate my instrument, the kalimba but terribly fails 😭

5-Minute Craft is not an enigma, it's a content farm.

Internet detectives are back to the game!! Though I do hope they could do another video crafting instrument (like the one with carrots)! It's interesting and sorta educational in a way lol

8:08 there are sounds of the person hiting the drum thing but the person didn’t hit it on time......

9:16 It's meant to be bagpipes. And it is so fake. LIke there is only 2 drones WITHOUT A DRONE SOUND! Bagpipes sound nothing like that.

Bravo Editor San, for that epic sound replacement, i bet you smiled a lot making that part.

When TwoSet says the words "internet violin detectives," you know someone's about to be roasted.

3:51 i remember making it in science extracurricular and it's work, with skilled cutting and stuff of course

8:49 acutally there is an italian youtuber that made that strument and it acutally works I'll link the video

I never noticed that the both of them dyed their hair! Eddy's is more obvious but I just noticed Brett's! Looks really good

The tape on the bucket thing is legit, this is just a very sloppy version. Taiko students who want to practice at home but don't have a mute pad or even their own taiko will take one of those big plastic trash bins, cut the bottom off then firmly tape the bottom, not the top. You're going to need the whole roll of packing tape, then duct tape around the circumference. By doing this, the trash bin helps to simulate the height of a taiko so a student can practice both their posture and movements without too much noise.

4:42 I literally made that in primary school not that world braking (also it's really difficult to get any kind of sound out of it)

the tape and bucket one is by far the most sensible one. i can picture tha happening, and since tape has tha crinkly sound, i see the logic in that, and it would prolly work if made, but the sensible thing to do would be to tilt the bucket over or bang a table

That cardboard piano was actually impressive just as an art project.

8:29 editor-san clearly had a trip with Eddy's request.

8:58 Please tell me scottish people watch twoset, cause i wanna know if they're offended by this. if they are, i apologize so much that 5 minute crafts did you that dirty.

HOLD UP TWOSET WHAT HAPPEND TO UR CHANNEL?!

The glove one is actually how bagpipes work. I call bs that she knows how to make that sound, but if they took the time to do more on that idea of the bagpipes it has potential

Eddy never misses the chance of flexing his perfect pitch.

For a pan flute you need the ends of the straws covered if u want it to work lmao

"She's just shoving that mouthpiece in her mouth" -Eddy Chen ( 2022 )

I used to play the panflute (southamerican, dont tease me :C) and they are literally just long tubes closed on one end. they work the same way an empty bottle works when you blow into it. THESE PEOPLE JUST CUT THE STRAW ON ONE END AND CALLED IT A DAY like how do they thing a straw will make a sound when you just blow in it! this is sacrilegious to the max. I mean, with classical music there are some things that us laymen can't understand and it's ok I guess... but they made the easiest thing to emulate in the world sacrilegious! that's some special skills right there!

as a percussionist, i can affirm that the tape "snare" won't make any sound, and there's already so much music made with non-classical instrument like punching your body so why do you need a diy percussion? and the little bowl... the drumhead isn't streched enough to make any derbouka's sound

7:23 where’s the back hole for the recorder?!

5-Minute Crafts ❌ 5-Minute Sacrilege ✅

The homemade "kalimba" might actually be interesting if the wooden part were hollow so it resonates, and if it had an audio out. they apparently dubbed a real kalimba sound over that thing which I can only imagine making buzzy clicky noises in the form shown. One would probably have better luck with extended paper clips, I've seen homemade kalimbas that make sense before. Those silly crafts seem most appropriate for eccentric audio engineers who like to stick piezoelectric pickup discs on random objects and sample them for granular or other audio processing.

"Chopstick is for eating, not to make instruments" I was in my room and... My mom: can you tell ur siblings to stop playing with the chopstick's, we need it to eat!

Great video. So ridiculous, it's like 5-Minute crafts want you to think their creations don't work. Just flat out embarrassing and your reaction to the carrot, with Eddy making the Tss sound was so funny lmao

3:24 this is technically possible but why the heck go through all the pain, it would fall apart after 5-10 seconds. Better get a 5$ keyboard, even if it takes six months to arrive, it'll definitely be more worth it than this... whatever that thing is

I feel like the only way these would ever be used is if someone’s kid was told to make a musical instrument as a school project. Which did happen to me back in the day. It was slightly annoying seeing some kids bring in stuff obviously made by their parents lol

7:50 subtitles: "I love 5 minute crap" LMAO

5:14 or turn the bucket upside down

Eddie's Chinese-mother-voice is phenomenal. I laugh every time

Two things. First, I can guarantee the pipe contraption sounded like blowing air, I've played with too much pvc pipe to think otherwise. Second, if you really want to have a cute, fun, thrown together drum use a balloon instead of tape. In fact, balloons and rubber bands are both fun to use, and you can tune the rubber bands by varying the length. That is all, goodbye.

As someone just getting into classical music, i really appreciate that Brett and Eddy actually explain how different instruments work. They've educated me so much on classical music just by watching a few videos. Keep it up guys!

3:25 This thing actually worked, after really hard work worked

ya'll are talking about how the weird pipe thing is changing pitch but how is it even making any sort of sound in the first place it's just a really long pipe!

5:56 At least on flute, that's only true for the low octave. You can get the first four or five notes of the harmonic series pretty easily using one fingering if you start low enough

Me, a woodwind player: "How is she changing the pitch?" Eddy not even 2 seconds later: "How is she changing the pitch?" Me: "My exact point!"

“More like they only practice for 5 minutes” I got CALLED OUTTTTT

5:26 the music is having seizures ?

In school we wrapped elastic bands around an empty ice cream tub and played it like a guitar. Still more sophisticated than anything in this video!

I love how they're picking out brass and woodwind faking now too, truly the music detectives

I will say the glovepipe does work but of course 5 minute crafts play some song with multiple pitches when the glovepipe plays one very wobbly note with the possibility to make it slightly sharp by pinching the straws.(If you want a cheap bagpipe look up DIY membrane pipes, it works I’ve made it)

never thought a classical music channel would review this kind of videos but im here for it

8:29 thank you editor san for making my day so much better :D !! no brett and eddy are harmed in this video !!

I will be using the bowl and plastic thing to cover food and put into the fridge

For the Irish whistle, the first overblow is for the octave up. The subsequent levels of overblow go up in like a natural pentatonic scale. This should be same for most fipple flutes or embrasure flutes.

0:36 I loved the "Uncle Roger" accent! I've seen the disposable glove "bagpipes" before. I would expect them to be ridiculously high pitched if any one were able to get a sound out of it.

0:56 looks like they were trying to do a sad attempt at making a Kalimba

i love you guys, your videos lift me up always when i am down, help me relax and get through difficult days. you are wonderful persons and passionate about classical music and skilled in your instruments, yet so modest and down to earth. like a ray of sunshine! keep up the good work, i wish you only the best :)

I don't think anyone noticed this yet, but for the carrot flute one she is literally BLOWING THROUGH THE PLUGGED UP END

The iPhone piano one in theory might work except for the copper isn't touching the actual screen where the keys are, just attached to the paper. Also the fact that the bare copper wires are touching along the top of the cardboard keyboard would confuse the iPhone, they should be insulated except where the person touches and where the wires touch the screen.

I've only done this on saxophone so I don't know about other woodwinds, but you can change which overtone is heard by changing the shape of your throat and mouth. This allows you to use the same fingering to make any frequency that is an integer multiple of the base pitch. The first overtone is double the frequency, or an octave above. The next is triple the frequency, a fifth above the octave. Next is 4 times or two octaves. Et cetera.

4:23, The air is escaping from the bottom of the straw and it would sound more like air.

8:10 there us no hole for the sound to come out...

Eddy flexing his perfect pitch🤣 4:26

Twoset why don’t you have a musical “battle” with 5 Minute crafts with you using your instruments and 5 minute crafts use their “instruments”.

Might be the first time that I heard to set violin talk about embouchure and brass besides when they were roasting baritones

the glove bagpipe mouthpiece made of straw actually works, I have tried it. It works like an oboe reed.

I like how when one of you dyes their hair, the other one had to as well.

It's such a great joy to see you guys at Friday night when quarantining at home for over 1 week. Thanks for bring us so many happiness!

I'd overlay the carrot one with dubstep for the heck of it

I'm no physics expert, but I think that one moving bobby pin didn't change pitch because it was vibrating from the joint in the pin and more or less just slapping against that dowel. Slap. Epic. Omg.

Eddy: * Pushes up glasses and roles up sleeves * "Okay... Listen." * Musician mode activated *

As a latina, wish TwoSet would learn spanish and review Les Luthiers to see the sacrilegious instruments featured and get a laugh with their legendary antics at least Grosso Concerto a la Rustica (RIP Neneco and Marquito). Although, It's been three years and I'm still asking them to watch Nodame in its entirety so.... no hope there.

The copper wires are covered in an insulator plating so they would have to scrape the insulation off of the wire - or the wires could all short each other. Not that that would do much since capacitive touch screens don't actually work that way - you can't just extend a point on the screen with some conductors. The tube thingy would just sound like you're blowing through a really long courogated pipe - it's just some noise with some peaks at some frequencies - basically just sounds like a fan. And in case people didn't notice, the tube is just left into the open end of the PVC, so the air will just leave through there instead of travelling down the whole length of the pipe. The bagpipe probably sounds like air going through a straw. Oh yes and of course like they pointed out nothing is synced correctly.

“If you can make it slowly, you can make it quickly”

The phone piano one and the carrot one actually seem probable, although the carrot's sound probably wouldn't be as good as shown, and the piano one would probably be a little unreliable and difficult to use. The other ones though, especially the weird tuba/french horn wannabe, are truly sacrilegious. Also I believe the carrot's holes need to be different sizes to properly work.

This is one of the best videos on this channel 5 minute craft is the most sacrilegious thing in the world Brett's hair 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️✨✨✨✨

The burn at the end was magical!

If you want to see NOT SACRILEGIOUS content of people making instruments out of vegetables and things like that you should react to Pietro Morello, he s an italian young and very talented musician.

aside from them using obviously fake sounds, the bobbypin one and the straw pan flute are actually good crafts for kids. they're cheap, quick, and easy to do and have semi-decent results