How does NOBODY have ANY documents for court? I'd show up with a briefcase full of relevant AND irrelevant (just in case) paperwork lol

I wonder if he could've asked the neighbor to share the ring camera recording of the tow, that would've cleared up any possibilities that they loaded his truck inappropriately.

The judge yelling at litigants for not bringing evidence is my ASMR.

I'm truly surprised JM was so easy on the defendant for not having documentation of the tow. They have a responsibility to document everything(damages noted before tow, etc) to cover themselves in these events. It's awfully suspicious this defendant didn't keep any paperwork, especially considering the plaintiff contacted him regarding the damage the very same day. He had to know this could end up in court. Very suspicious.

I’d be ridiculously over prepared 🤣

He was rushing out to get that fresh shave but left all of the paperwork at the office. You can still see that white chalk outline by his beard.

There’s no way the plaintiff would not have noticed two flat tires on the SAME side of his vehicle. As soon as he sat in the driver’s seat, he would have realized that the vehicle was more-or-less “leaning” to one side. Also, who picks a vehicle up from a tow yard, and doesn’t even bother to walk around it once? Ridiculous

DON'T CANCEL THE PEOPLE'S COURT!

Great judgment JMM, the Plaintiff HAD to notice 2 flat tires immediately or he's a dork.

My guy walked out of there with a Blessed Verdict.

I’m gonna miss hearing the stories from JM and JJ probably more than the cases. 😢

"And yet, you're "blessed" towing""😂😂😂😂

If I get in my car and it doesn't feel like it's sitting right, I get out and look at my tires. As soon as I start driving I can feel a flat tire.

I am convinced plaintiff showed up for his 15 minutes of fame, hopefully some agent watched the show and we will see plaintiff in some Netflix show in the near future.

The plaintiff has a superman jawline.

I do appreciate that the judge lets them tell the whole story. Judge Judy tends to cut them off from giving important details

As an auto tech with over a decade of experience I’m 100% sure the tow popped his tires. The heat shields underneath rot out all the time or the shop that used a “forklift” to move his truck damaged them. If he just had a little more proof.

I have a buddy that works at my local Mavis tire and brakes , he's heaven sent🙏🏾 I hope everyone gets a mechanic on their team. it's so important to either know the cars or know someone who does 😂

Look at us 🏃🏾‍♀️ over here for the People’s Jeffery Dahmer 😅

The plaintiff reminds me of Napoleon Dynamite. 😂😅

I know exactly how this happened. If the black top is gone from the street, there is a drop in the driveway. That's how the under plates got damaged. He went straight, instead of on an angle. It also means there's about a 4 inch drop on the sides of the road. If he got too close, to that, it will rub the tires. And if there's a bar sticking out of the concrete...pop goes the tires on the passenger side.

Should have seen if the neighbor had a Ring video of the tow 🤷🏻‍♀️

The side wall punctures are usually caused by hitting a curb especially if the curb is jagged. Or of course by vandalism. I doubt by towing. The plates underneath being described are heat shields. Way back in the day when I purchased and drove old used cars. The heat shields sometimes would rattle or fall off. If they couldn’t be tightened any longer. I would just have the shield removed. Making sure not to park on grass or leaves

I don't doubt for one minute that the tires went flat while in the "care" of the tow company. I used to work for a tow company and the drivers including the owner would mess up cars all the time while they were improperly loading them onto a flatbed, towing dollies or anyting else. We have flat tires, body damage and anything else you can think of simply because it was not properly loaded or unloaded correctly. Then the drivers would always lie saying they picked it up that way or they don't know how it happened it must be the customers fault.

Well, that neighbor is a piece of work.

The Plaintiff could improperly hook me up anytime.

First of all when you release a vehicle from a tow yard, you ALWAYS sign a release form to protect the company from liability such as being sued etc. Second, using a flatbed tow truck you can use the method of strapping all 4 wheels down or using chain hooks on the frame to secure the vehicle. Initially you hook the vehicle with chain hooks to the front control arms or subframe to pull the vehicle on the bed. This is information coming from a current tow truck operator. Sincerely, Synergy Towing & Transport Philadelphia-PA

Idk how he expected to get a refund from a tow where he was parked illegally

Jeffery Dahmer is that you👀

i need the plaintiff’s number… for research purposes

I truly think this was the tow company.

Plaintiff from Long Beach: West Siiiiiiiide. 😁

The plaintiff said that the tires were 6 months old, but the picture he provided looked like tires were almost done. If you hit a pothole hard enough, that will cause the side wall to pop. If he drove it flat, there was a good chance he could have damaged the heat plate under the truck.

You can see the front tire that had the bubble in effect on. You could see that he ran over the tire with the rim, cut a hole in the tire, the tires were damaged because the idiot after he picked it up, chose to drive a block you never do that unless you have a run flat, which being, it’s a Tacoma, it’s a truck, so it’s too heavy to have a run flat so the driver is at fault because he ruined his tires and probably his rims too

Plaintiff looks like Dahmer

the plantiff got that Jefferey Dahmer Drip coming in to the court........yikes

Yip as soon as he says he doesnt have evidence i immediately start smiling and jm goes off with wisdom. Love her so much. Theres no excuse. 😂

Wait- how is it an accident to have your truck blocking a driveway but also you're told you don't have to move it because the neighbor is gone? That means you knew. That means it was intentional, not an accident.

I'm so embarrassed for the defendant. As a business owner, he should have been over-prepared.

LOL....Plaintiff kept serving his profile to the camera. Okay, we see you, sir 😂😂

Judge Milian, I'm really surprised at you running out of gas several times that's unacceptable smh.. A lady with your wisdom and class i can't grasp the concept of how you would do this..

I’ve been a tow truck driver for the last 15 years and I know the tow company didn’t damage his tires. Whether it was on a flatbed or a wheel lift and dollies there’s no touching of the outer sidewalls of the tires. It’s even more of a bogus lawsuit because it was on the same side. The guy bumped a curb or something when he drove out of the lot or down the street. The heat shield he’s talking about wouldn’t be damaged on a tow truck either. Those rust out or bolts come loose and they sometimes rattle. If tow trucks damage tires and other parts of a car they would all be out of business quick. Even if the wrecker driver was negligent the sidewalks of the tires wouldn’t have been touched putting it on or off the truck. Negligence usually causes damage to bumpers or bending a control arm or tie rod when they hook it up wrong. The judge made the right decision on this one at least. I’ve watched a couple others that involved tow companies and I didn’t agree with her verdict against the tow company. It’s hard to understand how something may or may not happen if you don’t know how to operate a tow truck.

The story about the gas took me out 😂

the airport story 😂😂 that’s me, i need to do better

Judge Milan...these litigators make me mad too. Like bring your receipts! SMH!!

The judge & her hubby are so cute!

Honestly, there was no way the Plaintiff was going to win. That's probably why the Defendent didn't bring anything. Plaintiffs rarely win against tow companies. I can only recall once.

There should be some sort of punishment besides losing for showing up to court with no proof.

The towing companies are ALWAYS damaging peoples cars. They steal too! They did my relative the same way and caused so much stress.

I don’t agree with this verdict. They are supposedly supposed to rule with the evidence being more likely than not. And anyone who know how tow companies work, they know how rough they are with cars. What a weird coincidence that they towed his car and then the guy has two messed up tires and the plates under the car are busted . Like really ? That’s how they pick up the car by the tires and by hooking underneath by those plates. Bad ruling on this one

The plaintiff is giving me Zoolander Vibes on how he talks, lol!

Me. Smith isn’t lucky….he’s Blessed! 😃👍🏻

It's a pick up truck and it's very possible to drive a block, wondering what the issue is, and only stop after a block. A block isn't far. He said he knew something was wrong. He just didn't know it was a flat tire until he actually got out his car and looked. Silly of him yes to pick up his car and not check for visible damage, but it's possible for someone not to know a tire is flat immediately upon moving an inch. Happens every day.

Lol, that tow driver has had his ass kicked many times

If you got in your truck and the two passenger tires are flat the truck and going to be leaning to the right. You 100% would notice that as soon as you got in it.

The defendant wore a regular t-shirt under a v-neck sweater 😂

I wonder, since the tires were on the passenger side (aka the sidewalk side when parked) if the home owner, that was sick of people blocking their driveway, slashed the tires by puncturing them but the tires didn't go flat right away and leaked out slowly... It would make sense why it's that side of the car and why the damage is on the side of the tires.

The plantiff looks like Jeffery Dahlmer!

I had a similar incident when my car was getting serviced. I didn't noticed the 2 tires being flat til I started my car. My flat tired alarm was going off. I got out immediately. You could see a distant line in the cement from the car bay to my parking spot. Where the rims had left a line in the pavent. Similar to this guy's picture. The car dealership had to buy me 2 new rims & tires. How they didn't hear the alarm or the display saying the tires were flat is beyond me!

I knew a Frog that never parked in the correct places. He was always getting TOAD!! 🐸🤣😎

Sam speaks with an unusual accent

He does have the jawline

I’m curios, I’ve been towed a couple of times. Long ago, tow companies used a form to mark any damage. Even if he wasn’t present,I’m thinking there should be a form, to cover their butts. Heck these days, I’m thinking they’d have the form, AND pics. That’ll show damage, no damage. Suspicious no proof for court, especially on the tow co. smh

Dig that dress JM has on at the end of the show 🤗

The plaintiff probably needs to remember to breathe..

I too am uneasy with JM’a verdict. They kept saying “bockS” away but the guy said a 0.5-1 block away. Why wasn’t the tow company asked about any damage to the car upon them taking possession of the vehicle? Since the guy didn’t think to mention, “Hey, it had two flat tires when we got there.” I’m going to assume they got the vehicle intact. And yet when the owner picked it up, it was no longer intact. Doesn’t that seem more likely than not that they did something? Accidentally I’m sure. And is it possible they weren’t completely flat like that when he started to drive off but the pressure or the movement quickly push the air out? I don’t know much about cars or tires but this really seems like it should be on the tow company. Sure.. don’t award him the full amount he’s asking. But tires and labor seems reasonable. Even at a depreciated value since he couldn’t prove his tires were only six months old. Heck, he even made a good argument that he shouldn’t have to pay for the tow because they botched the service by returning his truck in a devalued state. He proved that they picked up the car in good working order. Now burden is on tow. Prove you gave it back in good working order. Am I completely wrong? I did just wake up HaHa. But the main thing they would have brought to court was the guy’s signature stating truck is good. That didn’t happen. Hmmmm.

JM: Open on Sunday and you call yourself Blessed Towing?..... maybe he's blessed in ways that have nothing to do with church???

Over there looking like Jeffery Dahmer 😂

Whether it’s a dial or range computer, the gas light comes on when there’s about a gallon left.

Judge Milian looks super fly in her tiger dress afterwords. I thought they would both be the type to never let the gas tank get low, it gets crap in your fuel

I’ve been to a tow yard where I witnessed the employee backing up a car into the lot and hit the gate. They acted like this happened before. it’s sad because there are tow places that mess up these cars.

9:49 It's a snatch and grab hitch! What direction was the truck parked? How did they get the truck away from the curb? In order to get it onto the flatbed?

I didn't know Jeffrey Dahmer had a son😂😂😂

As a California girl, I can definitely say, plaintiff is def from cali😂

How the hell you drive a car and not noticed you have flat tires. The plaintiff is slow.

Jeffrey Dahmer, I mean the plaintiff, is straight-up lying. As a claim adjuster I know the first thing you do when you have your vehicle released is walk around the vehicle to make sure that it's not damaged. Let's go with his logic and say that the entire passenger side was flat when he left the lot oh, do you really think you're going to drive for an entire block and not notice it? The minute you leave that lot, your shit out of luck because anything that is damaged at that point is on you.😂

Plaintiff looks like a serial... nah never mind 🤫🤐🤦🏾‍♂️

Looks like a cereal killer

Why would you have a vehicle towed when you’re not even home. Thats a petty thing to do 🤨

Uncle Rukkus for the WIN.

As a Mechanic to get myself through college, there is noway something on the road can cut through the sidewall. Unless he hopped a curb or someone physically punctured it. And the rattling is a heat shield. Absolutely harmless. They come loose on there own sometimes. I feel JM was wrong in this case.

Plaintiff: Dude someone could have flattened your tires while parked in front of the neighbors. Tow Truck Owner: Really dude…. No paperwork.., no nothing and you have a business!

i've had so many heat shields become loose its not even funny. highly doubt it was them. Also a flat tire is really obvious.

I got towed and received no paperwork or anything to sign. All they wanted was my money 🤷🏾‍♀️

Poor plaintiff a little slow. Good he's cute

Clark Kent ain't fooling nobody 🤨😏🤣🤣🤣

Side note, the defendant is really attractive. Just all bronzed and whatnot.

Wow, judge... that dress at the end!! You look Beautiful 😍

Best after verdict story. So funny.

Both of them are Ill prepared and judge Judy would’ve tossed them both out. I say lock them both up!

I can't even watch this case, the plaintiff is actually so hot I can't deal lmao

You have no flat tires, in your car gets towed and you have flat tires…

Another stupid verdict from this ridiculous judge, tow companies damage cars all the time, I've seen this firsthand on many occasions, the tow rep brought nothing to back up anything on his side, the plaintiff had video and paperwork and yet he gets nothing, the truck was in the tow services care and upon leaving there were immediate issues, ridiculous!

What a nasty thing to do, she wasn't even there so who cares that he was on her driveway, if anything she should be grateful to him, that way any potential burglar would think she was home, not on vacation...

What accent does the plaintiff have? He's 🥵

They have NO PAPERWORK. THAT ALONE should be enough to pay for these tires. Those tires didn’t hole themselves on side

sorry but you would know if you have 2 flat tires. esp on the same side the vehicle would be leaning to one side.

It’s sad because I believe the tow yard was at fault and unfortunately this young man didn’t bring enough evidence but who teaches these things nobody not the schools it’s like a person turns 18 and just has to know everything

Guess he really was blessed lol

The gas story is epic 😂😂😂