That lady is enemy number one calling a tow company so fast

That woman that claims to be the property manager is a spotter for the tow truck company. I'm sure she gets money on the sly

The defendant and his witness are a team. He probably gives her a percentage of the commission he makes from towing vehicles from that lot So, with that said, I would take everything the defendant’s witness said with a grain of salt.

I'm sorry but saying that witness is credible and remembers how the car was towed is complete B.S. The judge asked her how it was towed right after she asked the tow guy and she tried to copy what he said. She didn't even sound confident in what she was saying. Also, she obviously has a motive and bias in this case because 1. She was the one who reported the tow and 2. She was threatened to be beat up. Not saying I believe the plaintiffs either, just saying if the Judge is basing her verdict on solely believing the witness, I wouldn't say that's good enough. But, that's just me. 🤷‍♀️

If the defendant falsely claims to have taken it on a flatbed, what else is he lying about?

I'm the best tow truck driver there is! That's why I requested that you not mention the tow truck company's name.

“Did you threaten to beat her up?” “Yes I did, your honor.” 😂😅🤣

love when the court goes to recess and she tries to make sure justice is served

i don't get it, the tow truck driver told different stories and still didn't have to pay! and on top of that he didn't even fill out the paperwork correctly. Best tow truck driver my butt

The picture of the judge looking under the car had me cracking up 😂

The witness spotter got % from the two truck company.

“Do you hear me talking or is it just in my head” I be thinking this all the time 😩🤣

If they didn't do anything wrong why did they give the tow money back!

The defendant’s body language screams dishonest.

Judge should have asked the defendant’s witness if she was there and how he towed it BEFORE she asked the tow truck driver!

she could've waited 30 min to call the tow truck company its not unusual for people to go to the bank then post office afterwards

Did you threaten to beat her up? Yes I did, Your Honor. 😫😂😂😂

I dont believe the defendants. They seem like they are working together.

Douglas's reaction to "I'm a Beast" right at the end. Lol

Defendant's witness may be saving his hide. She sounds lots more credible than he does.

Harvey is so happy someone outside didn't give him a slow and stupid answer for once. Lmao. 😂

I don't agree with the judge on this one. The tow truck guy basically perjured himself and then the judge just believes the property manager that he brought along? She just copied what he said. Why should she be trustworthy?

What's the point in putting on a dress shirt(with a tie)and not tuck it in? Sneakers with a suit drives me nuts too!

I just wanted to say hi and have a beautiful day. Oh great judge

“…Very high-rated”. That’s me every Friday night 😂

Not me thinking that lady was a whole nun while she was sitting down 🤣🤣

I witnessed a tow truck driver rip the front end off a car, while backing it off the flat bed. I immediately told the owner when she came out of the passenger side of the tow truck. And the tow truck driver denied it!! I wrote her a witness statement and gave her my info. I hope she wins her case. The guy was clearly at fault.

IMO> The professional car thief, and like too many, they pay someone to be their spotter. He places a person to help run a scam tow company where as soon as the spotter calls, the predator is not far away and can quickly pounce. He's the definition of why tow companies have a bad raps. As he says with a smile "To be honest", is the point someone has been caught in their lies! Flat bedded, sure it was!

Douglas in the back at the end when the defendant said “I’m a beast” 😂😂😂

If they say "to be honest"...expect a lie.

I always wonder when a litigant says, "To be totally honest," what they had been up to that moment.

There was no reason to have them towed in the first place tbh

Sketchy! The spotter turned the tide. She says they went to the bank and the damage was not likely done by the tow.

Defendant's witness said she called the tow company at 10:20, and the receipts the plaintiffs provided showed they completed their transaction in the bank 4 minutes later. That witness was lying in wait for someone to park and not instantly beeline to the post office. Her credibility should have been suspect from the moment the times were compared. I smell a dastardly duo. 💩

if its illegal tow, charge the company double for punitive damage

10:09 is taking me OUT 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Judge: Did you threaten to beat her a*s? Plaintiff: Yes, I did your honor. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 I love her honesty…

That guy was right! Tow trucks are crazy in Philly!!!

She screamed across the parking lot "The car is being towed" andcthen ran after the parking lot, and then described herself as "enraged". Sounds about right lol. WHAT is "high-rated" and how does someone that dumb function in life?

Lol, what a judge. She actually got down on her back on the ground.

Second tow truck case in a row. 👍🏽

Dear tower men/women, make sure to make a video of every car you are towing, both before the tow and after you have placed it in the tow yard. That's easy and worth the effort.

The people that want to “beat your ass” over an everyday, adult, event….are the same people that will fabricate a story to get revenge and make a few bucks.

"He's a slackjaw" nail on the head. I wouldn't trust his recollection at all. The only reason there's any credibility is his witness.

Don’t tow truck drivers get dispatched? Are they required to check to see if the towing is legit before towing? I know they take pictures as evidence sometimes, but I guess that’s not protocol with all companies 🤷🏽‍♂️?

You cannot move the gear shift from park to neutral without the keys, so he did not hand push the car anywhere.

it must be SO annoying to park a good car and then get it back from the towing company all banged up....and you lose anyways because the Judge scratches her car all the time. You can look under MY car, Judge Milian, and you won't find any scratches!! That tow driver didn't inow what he did.....

I’m a tow truck driver and have been doing this since 2008. Early on it was hard to take photos since camera phones weren’t really a thing and this is an older episode so it was around that time I’m sure. For the last 12 years I have photos saved to my iCloud account of every car I’ve towed. I take 10-15 photos of every car I tow before, during, and after. I haven’t had a valid damage claim or lost a case where the company has been sued for anything I’ve towed since I’ve had a camera phone (iPhone 4). I personally wheel lift and dolly every single car and I tow 1200 a year minimum in a college town for parking where they’re parked illegally. The owner of the tow company here is lying about half the stuff he’s saying but I think the defendant didn’t do the damage. 99% of the cars are beat to hell under the bumpers from parking blocks and the damage by the wheel well is from is not caused by a tow truck. I know what the company owner is saying about Go Jacks and his testimony there is valid. Personally I don’t use them due to possibility of throwing my back out pushing cars around. Wheel lift and dollies are personally quicker and safer. I know most people here in the comments will just say all tow truck drivers are scam artists and these plaintiff’s were in the right for suing. Unless you actually know how to tow cars it’s hard to actually understand the process. I’d recommend people look into private property rights and respect them when it comes to parking. If you leave your car and walk off the property and it gets towed that’s nothing but your own fault. People can have their opinions but there’s consequences to your actions. It’s no different than someone parking in your driveway and walking away. I don’t completely agree with the tow companies that use spotters but there’s nothing illegal about it either in most states. If you didn’t do anything wrong then your car wouldn’t have been towed. Personally I only tow when cars have no parking permits or property managers call me directly but there’s different ways it can all be done.

Who is the announcer??? Thanks for always making me 😆 🤣

We should’ve known the tow truck drivers statement was gonna be inconsistent from the get get go. When your going to COURT and you wear a TIE you should tuck in your shirt. 😂

Tow truck drivers are usually just doing their job. It's not the driver's fault that you are already having a bad day. Towtrucker is a great KZfaq channel. Check him out

What about parking in a no parking zone? Tow truck driver marked wrong box . What about the lies the people that have the car told? Damage in rear wheel well and leaving together. He said wife went to the post office then decided later to go to the bank. Judge made the right call.

Witness or driver should have looked for surveillance footage of them walking off together

What do I need to do to be arrested by Douglas? 😉😉😉

So far, about the only thing the plaintiffs and the defendants agree upon is that the vehicle was towed.

Douglas in the back ground at the end when he said he was a beast 😂

I’ve had both positive and negative times having to call a towing truck. The negative time was really bad and the insurance company made a claim when they came out to look at my vehicle. I didn’t get all Irritate or threaten to whip anybodys butt LOL I was just like man that sucks fix it thanks

Who the hell goes to court with their shirt untucked?

I’m happy they won the plaintiff wife was annoying

Lol I thought she had on a habit

Who saw the guy waving in the audience outside?? 🤣🤣🤣

At the end he said he's a beast. Please

That awkward moment when you find out you are only "entitled" in your head.......

The Defendant's gestures reminds me of the type of person who's used to intimidating people. He acts like he's just DYING to jump on the Plaintiff. (...And I'll bet that Plaintiff would KICK his behind for him)! lol!

damaged because he DRAGGED the c ar out of the spot. happened to me. they WILL do this if they can't get into the car to put it in gear. that's how it got scratched up.

That's not true - if you're broke down on the side of a deserted road in the middle of the night you ARE happy to see the tow truck driver. You may not be happy about the situation of the broke down car, but you're happy someone is there to get you off the deserted road in the middle of the night.

Poor tow guy. People are outraged when they are towed. It's best to have cameras. This is not the first time I've seen tow guys get blamed for prior damages.

Anyone else here “Thomas the Tow Man” to the Bob the Builder theme song tune 😂😂😂 no, just me

The witness is Fr in on it. She called the tow truck immediately after they left the car and walked towards the bank.

Where on earth did they park the car? The PPC court studio is in Midtown Manhattan.

I thought the plaintiff was a nun walking in

I'm watching this on my phone and divorce court on my tv at the same time. What is my life. 😂

Always be careful where u parked at

I'm here...keep the uploads coming

you take pictures before towing!

If JM trust the witness, then she should believe that the plaintiff did *not* go directly into the post office, as stated by the witness. 🤷🏽‍♀️

The guy has lied multiple times already. He has already lost

13:00 I believe him.

The judge trusts the defendant's witness, I'm sorry but I don't... they seem like they know each other and went over their stories with each other. Having said that, I also think that the plaintiffs did not prove their case.

JM you are getting very impatient!! you interrupt the people, and then yell at them 'DO YOU HEAR ME TALKING? STOP INTERRUPTING ME" well, YOU STARTED IT!!

That tow truck company seems shady they just sitting back watching and waiting to tow someone's car. They won't be in business long you can tell.

I have yet to see a case in which the towing company loses.

Two company called at 1020 THEY were waited on in the bank at 1024 She ran into the pist office at 1038

I'm all for the working man but that tow company is scamming.

That tow truck guy seems like such a jerk. Ion know.

That’s weird as hell to call a tow truck it’s not that serious

I have seen people cheat all the time and park where they are not supposed to park and when they get towed they complained. Parasites. Opportunist.

Oh yea lol I’m from Philly the PPA don’t play

People need to mind their own business and stop looking for ways to make folks' lives miserable. Why the hell did she run out and call a tow truck which ended up being an illegal tow? I bet she has a relationship with the tow truck company and may even get a fee when she calls to report cars parked illegally. I don't trust that! There's so many other things she could've been doing as the property manager besides looking for folks who shouldn't be parked in a spot, I'm so sure.

Car cannot be moved into neutral from park unless the key is in the ignition or the proximity key is in or near the car...smh

The lady is definitely a spotter and probably gets a percentage of the tow company I think they walked off and then went to the post office so the so the toll is technically legal but the tow truck driver did do the little bit of the cosmetic damage but definitely didn't wreck the front-wheel drive

The plaintiffs already got their money back for the tow, this case was just about damage to the vehicle.

Another example of a guy that is horrible at his job, but really thinks he's one of the best.... No Pictures taken before the tow? Also his witness is the property manager and they are at the post office and the bank, but apparently there are No camera where they could have presented video evidence?...... tells me they are hiding the truth. Scammers!

Good thing, the tow truck driver had a Latina on his side or apparently he would have lost the case according to the judge over and over again.😅

The 1st and Only gunfight I've witnessed was between a tow truck driver and the person that's car was being towed...

what is a "honday"? i've never heard of it. is it a cross between a HONDA and a HYUNDAI???

Thomas the driver not to be confused with Thomas the train

Entowtlement.....

It was a bad verdict. It was so the tow drivers fault. Bad tow with spotters

I wonder if I've just gotten really lucky. I've had my car towed 3 times because the dealership installed a recalled part wrong (multiple times). Nothing bad ever happened to my car (knock on wood).