ADVChina still asking for handouts I see SMH

DonD512 it's not a necessity. If you don't want to donate then don't.

I don't see C-Milk's new video?

DonD512 Handouts? it's called supporting something you like. They work hard on these videos and it's their income to survive. You sound completely ridiculous.

Please check up your PAYPAL account, I've tried to make a donation, and it denied it and replied "Cannot complete transaction - stolen credit card." So please fix the problem soon.

Chris Simpson thank you! As a Cantonese American, I appreciate what you said.

Absolutely agree as a mando who learns canto

Actually kids in Guangzhou growing up these days pick up mandarin first in school

Thanks, I was still on the fence on whether or not to buy it

It's a must watch!

So is Conquering Southern China 🙂

You know 4 languages, awesome!

The jump is not massive. You can get used to it quite easily comparing to learning a completely new language~

Ken Yam it's not that bad learning Spanish was much easier for me because I did French as a child~

True, I am Cantonese, but I dont teach my son cantonese. Mandarin is more useful.

Google Soler, the Macau Twins who speaks various of languages as well...I really think this sort of people are extremely clever

What’s your country?

@@hansonkewl2377 Panamá🇵🇦 however lately the is a small group that is studying Mandarin

Pedro Lobo that’s very interesting....I wonder if those are the descendants of the Cantonese immigrants who emigrated to South America back in the late 1800s. Yea...not surprising, Mandarin becomes more influential by day, this will continue to be the trend in the next 10, 20, 50 years

Hell yea~

And I think Guangzhou is far more modern than Shenzhen and they didn't go to the right place. Guangzhou or Shanghai is the two best cities to live in globally arguably with world class living standards.

@@htht7831 GZ is much better than Shenzhen agreed...SZ has no history, bland soul less...Shanghai sounds like heaven but more rain than SZ and GZ..I lived in Ningbo and the rain killed my soul) Like fuckin Seattle

I agree. I don't think Cantonese should be a negative. That's like Spain asking Portugal to change their official language from Portuguese to Spanish. Yes, even though their 2 different countries, and Guangzhou is in China, you shouldn't force the locals to give up their language just because their the minority in the outside forces. And honestly, Cantonese is going down in Guangzhou, so if anything the people of Guangzhou should preserve their Cantonese language and culture!

Guangzhou also has nice modern buildings just like Shenzhen while preserving its culture and historical architecture.

Thomas T 😹

That gave me a good laugh lol

Thomas T lol

+splinkster1 C-Milk and family "bailed to the USA"?

thank you!

What happened when they tried it before? Riots?

They tried that a few years back and it was met with crazy push back from the Canton states. After they haven't try anything that stupid since.

The Government also moves families around China. From north to south, south to north and city to city to stamp out all the dialects. People moving in can't speak the dialect so they are forced to speak the "National" dialect or learn the local one. Also, the older people from the cultural revolution and while Mao was in power, didn't get to go to school, so many can't read or write and were never schooled in Mandarin. My Mother-in-law can't read or write, she is in her mid to late sixties (as an example).

People really shouldn't judge other's mother tongue and culture or worse try to change or influence them. We all hv different backgrounds and it's unfair to say this language/culture is better than that language/culture and blah blah blah. I am Cantonese speaking born in HK and grew up in South Africa and I am proud of it. Nice videos by the way AdvChina!

everyone, first off don't be a hater, you won't make anyone change their mind by loathing. And secondly, I think eazon already said it. Every Chinese person should learn Mandarin, however, it should not replace their own mother tougue. It's not one or the other, they can co-exist. Why can't people see that? In Europe people speak multiple languages and have media in multiple languages. One DOES NOT have to cancel the other. Personally I find cantonese very useful abroad as well. Such as in England, US, Australia, Malaysia, etc. It has about 80 million speakers around the world so there's no doubt in its usefulness. On the other hand, Mandarin is very useful to communicate with all non cantonese background Chinese. I would say if you speak both languages, you will do Ok in most Chinese communities across the globe.

actually， it was called Canton

the security check does not only exist in SZ, also in ALL major cities' Metro Stations i.e. Nanning, Guangzhou and that's ridiculous becoz it lowers the efficiency and increase the waiting time for trains....

This is ridiculous, name me one famous ancient poet who was a Cantonese. Name me one king who was Cantonese. Cantonese is in no way representative of ancient Chinese culture.

It's complicated and you can't say that Cantonese is not representative. It's difficult to compare between the concept of "Cantonese" and "Chinese" in cultural and racial stuffs. So it's meaningless to say that.

btw I love Cantonese

@diga Melo Mandarin is heavily influenced by the Manchurian language. So, its not hard to fathom that linguistically, mandarin is more distance to ancient Chinese than its Cantonese counterpart.

oh yeah, then you should go inflate Real Estate prices with your Wenzhou fellows, Boaster

Cantonese especially Hong Kong version is very funky, fun and zippy. It is able to convey different nuances of humor and incorporate foreign words in quirky and clever ways that the more formal and dare I say more uptight mandarin can. Hong Kong people have a type of humor that is special to them and their language is the best part of it. Stephen Chow's movies sound much funnier in their native Cantonese than in Mandarin it's entire due to the language different. There is an ease and warmth to Cantonese that Mandarin cannot quite capture, there are also many awesome idiomatic saying etc. Overall Mandarin is much easier for most Westerners to learn because there are less tones.

It’s true! Many if not most mandarin speaking Chinese immigrants ended up learning Cantonese after moving to Chinatown.

Very true. The Cantonese were the first Chinese to ever immigrate so the language came with them and it was passed down to their children and through the generations.

King Ming are u chinese udont know any Chinese history shut up u mouth I am from Shenzhen before 40years ago we are just a village. After the government help Shenzhen . Nowadays we look like a city . So shut up u mouth cause u know nothing about my country

thank you for letting me know, am trying to learn about China!

Comedian GJ and it's not cheaper to fly Hong Kong than Shanghai... But don't try to convince him with facts, cmilk Is the fake China expert. Notice how he roll his eyes when they talk about Poppy, I guess is because despite she has been a lot shorter In China she actually does her research before talking and has an actual positive approach, while Cmilk just talks according to his perception that is plenty times just plain wrong... Not that long ago he had a video saying that to come China you had to fly to Guangzhou, Shanghai or Beijing first, and that's absolutely not true. There is plenty Chinese cities connected with Seoul, Tokyo, Bangkok, so at least you really want direct flight is quite common you can get to almost any Chinese city with just 1 stepover and the number of Chinese cities with direct flights to Europe and America keeps growing every year... and leave alone his ridiculous claim that Visa to China costs 500$...

ReasonableRadio i love that

says joe BLOW

Joe Blow never sucked anyone off. you can’t relate.

Who is Poppy?

A YT star created by show business

correction, a very smart selfmade yt star that claims to be a business created star and showing this in the form of very eerie sketches with the message of how much of the stars are fabricated to be loved by people and to sell ther merch

cosmic mutant or maybe theyvare talking about yt channel called "wheres Poppy" whose host is living in Shenzhen.

AAAAAHH yeah that would make more scence thanks for a real explenation

That's just not true.

agree, this 2 foreigners are underestimating Chinese healthcare

Where do you find good medical, pharmaceutical, dental and pyschological care in China ? I thought it was lacking in all 4 areas compared to Hong Kong or Thailand or more importantly the West..In China everyone smokes and eats shitty food...

Seán O'Nilbud but remember China is not a developed country. It still has low infant mortality rate and high life expectancy for a developing country

I kind of agree with you on this one. The upside to "crappy public hospitals" is that they're...there. Nothing like that back in the states. I think they know though. It probably gets exhausting qualifying it with appreciation every time you criticize it.

I told them in a old video. They over estimate how good western hospitals are. The doctors in the U.S. knows very little, i'm not saying all. For example, there was a test for these doctors in the U.S.. They were given an MRI scan of a brain and they had to determine what the issue was. Only 50% were about to identify there was a problem, the other 50% thought the person was fine. Of the 50% who could've identify the problem only less than 15% could tell it was cancer. Of those only a few percent knew it was a late stage in cancer. I am mentioning this because my mom was diagnosed was lung cancer. She had surgery when the cancer was at stage 1B; the doctor said there were no problems after the surgery. 3 month later my moms leg was hurting for an unknown reason. We go to our doctor at University of Michigan Hospital (Top 5 in the world) and they said it's no big deal it's just from exercising. 6 month later, my mom was taken to the E.R. cause the pain on her leg was out of control. It was later determined that her cancer from her lungs had metastasized to her legs. A few weeks later, a friend who also has lung cancer (different mutation) told my mom that if her cancer has metastasized to her leg then it probably has to the brain. Went to the hospital and we told the doctors to get an MRI to check, doctors said there shouldn't be... My parents forced them. What do you know, 5 tumors on the brain. Wait but that's not all, asked for doctors advice on what steps to take. They highly recommended chemo, but everyone knows chemo is deadly and has a very low chance of working. We figured that we can try a clinical trial. U of M doctor strongly disagreed. However, at this point, my parent were sick of the U of M doctors because they were very incompetent and ignorant. They decided to go to Oregon and test out a clinical trial drug there. As a result my Mom's cancer had shrunk significantly and has stabilized. She told me if she had kept listening to the U of M doctors sh probably would've died. BUT WAIT THERE IS MORE... The Oregon radiologist can't understand the MRI's that they take so my mom has to fly to U of Pitt hospital to get it check. Long story shot, American hospitals are way overrated. Our family has countered way too many people who suffered the same as my mother. The lack of knowledge, ignorance, and incompetence from the U of M hospital ruined my mother (gone through many surgery from bone replacement from the leg to gamma knife on the brain). If they were more skilled they would've prevented a lot. The only reason why american hospitals rank highly is because they have more money and equipment/medicine, but all those are useless if the doctors can't utilize them correctly. As a person who has witness American Hospitals and have entire mom's side of the family working for Chinese hospitals, when it comes to knowledge, Chinese doctors better off. I feel like what's happening to Winston and C-Milk (Especially C-Milk) is that they have overestimate shit here because they experienced it. Too much media and the facade of the well designed hospitals makes them bias. I know this is a long comment but it's coming from the from deep inside.

One last thing, Chinese hospitals are nothing compared to U.S. Hospitals. My mom's surgery expenses was 200k, this is with good insurance. Total excluding insurance was nearly 1 million dollars. If we include all the medicine that shes been on... 1 month bottle of cancer drug is 10k. Enough said.

ink800ify I went to China last year. Lin yi, Shandong in my opinion is low key a beautiful city. In my opinion, foreign people tends to only go to beijing, tianjin, shanghai, Xian, Shenzhen, and Guangzhou.

I went to a Beijing hospital emergency room and was told if I had money I could be jumped to the head of the line for 20 $ US. So I I paid it, since there was no place sit in anyways.

John Smith I never find Winston awkward at all. He's very confident and professional in the way he expresses himself in all these videos. I think he's just more of a stoic type.

Cyiero, well disregard the adjectives for a sec, these are very subjective and not really the main point anyway. Do you not think that it would look a it more natural if he was looking at the other one and listening to him as though it was a genuine conversation? This is how the other guy looks at him. I have certainly seen him looking confident in many of his videos, but that is not how I would describe him in this video. When he is talking yes, but not while the other guy is talking. Surely you can see that where he looks and the placement of his hands appears fairly awkward; or uncoordinated if you prefer? If you rewatch the video and compare Winston's body language when the other guy is talking to the body language of the other guy when Winston is talking, you can clearly see that the other guy is more relaxed and more confident in his mannerisms.

I find winston super awkward, even when he's talking with his wife. I think it's just an introverted mannerism and not because he doesn't care

I don't see it. In his first sentence, he looks at Matt 3 times. In his second sentence, he looks at Matt 5 times, all the while looking at the camera, to keep the viewer feeling somehow involved in the conversation. They are both addressing the viewer, with the topic at hand. Over all I find him cordial towards who ever he is speaking to, and shows concern for the feelings as others, like when Poppy showed up, he was keen on making sure Poppy didn't feel neglected, even though they were still wrapping up their conversation.

LEAVE WINSTON ALONE!!!

i wonder what the capital of milk dogs is?😆

armancz you must be new here

I saw a toddler urinating in public in Urumqi, Xinjiang. Along with seeing a grown man urinating on a public street. Certainly different.

Los Angeles?

From my experience, Beijing. It makes sense since it's also the actual capital of China and it's the most old school of the first tier cities in China.

Channel Wheres Poppy

hi i'm poppy i'm poppy i'm poppy i'm poppy

Oh so "Where's Poppy" and they found her haha

You didn't even answer my question. Please refrain from chatting shit in future.

she's also a western youtuber in china, case closed

But can you read English? I did write ' NON- RICH foreigners.' If you own a company there, which is what helped you get a green card I'd bet then you would be considered rich, and that green card can be revoked at the government's leisure. I have never doubted there are many special exceptions for those running or bringing large businesses in China. And if you own it... why did you mention 99 years... that sounds like a lease ?

Also thought you guys might be interested but in London we have BYD busses now.

YIshis Lassie where are you now

The thing that annoys pretty soon in Guangzhou is the behaviour of the people. Spitting, unhygienic behaviour even urinating or defecating in public, jumping Q's, shouting at each other, all this is everywhere, but more around in Guangzhou. I could live in Guangzhou, it has a certain flair, but not anymore in a purely local area.

Is that not the southern Chinese culture in general? It seems like Shenzhen is this exception-a place (better) for foreigners, for an international crowd, for migrants from other parts of China. One can certainly advise "outsiders" to go to the more accessible place, but it seems disrespectful or something to expect (by comparison) a place of local culture to conform to the standards in an exceptional place. I've lived in India and have an ongoing relationship with the place; specifically, I go to the Punjabi region. Punjabis have a special culture within their region, and they are also many of the Indians you will find abroad. I speak Punjabi so I can communicate with the people there in THEIR language, even if they can understand the "national" language, Hindi. They want to communicate in their language and to see their own language thrive. And it does-when I'm in other countries (I'm American), I find Punjabis and talk to them when I can't speak the language of that country, for example in Paris and Hong Kong... It's just rude speaking to them, when their language is Punjabi and my language is English, in the Hindi language-to address them in the language of the central power of their nation-state. (And if I do that, it reminds them of the government stooges or the past colonizers.) Now obviously, people do whatever they need, and any gesture of communication that works is good! I just thought it was strange to write off Cantonese as a useless language, especially coming from people that have chosen to make their lives in a part of the world where Cantonese is the native language... and who are MARRIED to Cantonese speakers! What Cantonese wants to hear that curled-tongue shrr-shrr-xhh language?

Because HK is one of the most expensive places to live (relative to income), if you want to live in a box HK, if you want a place with less foreigner competition for jobs and much bigger living space, SZ.

Winston doesn't seem to care about Hong Kong that much. His previous married ended partly because he didn't want to move to HK, when he could have done so as his wife was from there. Unless you're moving from one branch of an international firm to one based in Hong Kong, it's also a lot easier to find work as a foreigner in Shenzhen. Rent is also about a fifth of what you'd expect to pay for a similar place in Hong Kong.

OK, I hear you guys. I guess if one HAD to move to China, one might be looking for such a "convenient" place to "bear" it. But who really has to? I have mad respect for Winston and Matt, but sometimes I am puzzled by their (seeming) lack of interest in Cantonese culture. And certainly a visitor (not someone moving to China to live) would not be interested in Shenzhen just because of tech and cute young girls on the street. (I mean, I'm interested in the cute girls, but you could seek them out in the more "vibey" cities... or, again, just go to HK.

This.

G Art Same in Canada.

China is a controlled materialistic country where the population is mostly robots doing what they are told and people judge everyone by their wealth not human qualities. USA has different problems with corrupt corps running the govt ; serious Health problems from garbage supermarket processed food and a medical industry taking advantage of all the diseases. Both countries are becoming Godless and if you look thru History all the great civilizations that stop worshiping God fell into ruin shortly thereafter.

Robert Gross If you seriously think that then you're as ignorant as a brick on China and its billion+ people.

Robert Gross Some of the most corrupt, violent and poorest countries today are also the most religious in the world. (Look at Africa, Middle East, Southeast Asia). The richest, most successful nations tend to be the least religious. Scandinavian countries, Western Europe, Canada, US, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, China (including Hong Kong, Taiwan and Macau), South Korea, etc. Spirituality can be achieved without a God or religion.

i myself was annoyed how much they complain, but that seems to be the way westerners are. they love to analyze everything. they're almost obsessed with knowledge. i'm wondering if part of it is putting on a face to satisfy critics who'll dislike them if they are too shallow. but if you notice things like them marrying chinese women and watching their "conquering northern/southern china" series, you'll see how much they really enjoy it :)

Don't you feel like on KZfaq everything about China is negative? I got that feeling everyday! It;s like I am living in a very modern 2nd tier city and we have great hospitals and somehow people like these two want to make them looks like crap and I AM SAD! I am really sad because even though i am prepared for negative non-facts but these are still - overly negative.i feel like we don't live in the same world. PLS treat Chinese people like PEOPLE. that's all i can say. If their neighbors see them doing this on KZfaq they will be so sad.

Taipei is as Chinese as London is Roman.

While Taipei is the best city that Chinese culture has to offer, it is not in China.

Aaron .Nunez, isn't it the other way round? China was destroyed by the cultural revolution and the only place you find genuine traditional Chinese culture is outside of mainland China?

Relax my guys it's a joke.

Jim Chen I have been there. Don’t have to worry about scammers, cheating taxi drivers, access to the full Internet. Plus you get to see all the treasures the nationalists stole from the mainland in the Palace Museum. What a shithole.

So, do beautiful women make you cringe? Props to him for speaking out loud what we all think.

Nick in Vietnam Yawn, are we there yet.

Uh oh it's a SJW!

Reported for spam

Jesus. You’re honestly everywhere. Even on ADVchina.

This is not the first channel to be on every video. There is a bot out there that can do this

can you explain to me what is wumbo? i am not woke yet and ill informed. google search brings back spongebob...

moutazmizo87 I think it's supposed to be wumao -50 cent army.

I am sure you are saying this tongue-in-cheek. I for one will continue to "perve" on beautiful women until the day I die. There is nothing wrong with appreciating beauty. 😋

Peak testosterone in men is 35-45, so Winston is at peak desire for tight asian pootie tang. His waifu should keep a close eye on him.

+Michael Bradley: Well, I'm not a pervert, but I kind of know what you're saying. And here is the answer. Most men pretty much stay the same, but they are expected to change when they get older. The recognition that they haven't significantly changed from when they were in their 20s earns them the moniker of "pervert".

+David Brown: Dude, I don't know what you're on, but you completely missed the point of my comment. The "perversion" talking about is simply a man continuing to be attracted to attractive women. "Perversion" only comes into the picture based on that culture (that varies by individual, place, and time) that judges that man. I will tell you now that I will never be physically unattracted to fit women in their 20s. Now, if I'm in my 20s, society has no problem with that. However, as people age, even if they keep their same preferences, society expects (wrongly) for us to change, so that 60-year-olds are expected to be most attracted to other 60-year olds. I'll tell people right now, that's not going to happen, even if 60-year-olds are married and in love and find each other attractive. Still, it won't be the case that 20-year-olds will ever become unattractive. One other thing to point out is that Winston isn't even an old dude. As someone probably somewhere around his age, I think he's still pretty young!

Rationalific - whatever David Brown is on it's pretty strong stuff....

I agree with you. The vast majority is definitely not attractive. There is literally just 1 out of 1000 women that can be considered attractive (I counted that, so it is a serious/legitimate statistic). I guess you must have some kind of asian fetish (which I don't have). Yeah, and chinese men probably will like me as well because I do not steal their wifes.... hahaha. However, as a foreigner girls are extremely easy. But I personally have no desire to make use of this situation. So when I go to china for me it is more like going to a monastery. Unfortunately ;) However, beside this big negative, China is just awesome - i love it!

It's the same thing for me with black women the past few years. I had nothing agains black people but just not attracted. I think now i appreciate them more. Maybe you just need a few years to adjust your aesthetics like me.(I'm chinese.)

Tao Yanbao same. A woman is a woman, and a beautiful woman, how can you resist?

Jam Connell well same with me, I'm attracted to white girls but specially red heads or pale blondes. I tried to like Chinese girls and sometimes I feel something specially with pale skin but.....i don't know how to put in words😦

Black women vary. A lot to do with life style habits. If they are candidates for early onset diabetes type 2 then no, that 's very unattractive. But there isn't just one black woman type. There is more DNA diversity in Africa than the rest of the world put together which makes sense as all modern humans outside Africa are descended from a few groups which moved out of Africa. I have seen African women who are walking goddesses and others who are trash.

Rad no need