AlternateHistoryHub still furst

AlternateHistoryHub Take your time mate!

fuck south dakota north dakota is best Dakota what a very aggressive username

Hey dude can you make a video on "What if Serbian Empire didn't collapse"? Please,pleaseeee!PLEASE!

*YAAAAYYYY* I’m excited 😆

And the French*

And the Yankees

Don't trust a colonist with a fancy English accent

iosif Muhammad // dont trust a dark, short british indian that has better english accent than english people themselves. ☠️

Insert poland

What is your opinion on the Saudi Government?

@@Rokaize I think we all know he can't say his opinion LOL

As a someone from the middle east, I say that his information were a little botched and his scenarios very vague. I too still appreciate him talking about the middle east. Doesn't change that it just sounded like a dumb liberal reflecting his beliefs on a land with rich and ancient history whilst intermixing different concepts like "wahabism" which isn't a real concept and Salafism, which is a real mathhab, etc.

@@griefwizard I struggle to take anyone seriously when they use ad hominem attacks like "dumb liberal" that are completely irrelevant to the discussion at hand. Sorry.

@@CoralCopperHead Cool, dumb liberal. 👍

@RAPH OOO yeah....

@RAPHZ OOO and china

@RAPHZ OOO Afghanistan, Iran, Irak, Yemen, Saudi Arabia , Emirate, Oman, Qatar, Kuwait Also

Best fact I've seen in 2 months

That is the most accurate statement I've seen in a while. Good show old man.

@Derin Selanik that meme is unfunny and dead

@@picardas1638 your mom gay

@@MedicMain9 even worse

@@picardas1638 ok boomer

Espiriquidiberto Senti you are that type person to say a dead meme even when it died years ago

JUST MONIKA natsuki is best waifu

there wont be any wars

A Not really. We'd still have the religious tensions.

JUST MONIKA Then the USA would get outta there :P

JUST MONIKA It would have peace and the West would either mind its buisness or find someone else to bully

It would have also included Chechens, Circassians and Armenians(all these are minorities in Jordan).

Since when the kurds and not muslims..? And just to be clear assyrians make less than 3 precent of Iraq population so nothing will change

bruh this "state" is supposed to be secular. so it doesnt matter

Kurds are majority muslim

@@BigChungus-ly8ym fun fact Iraq under Saddam rule was a secular country

today it's hard but it war the highest propablity in 1920

It was actually very probable after ww1

Better alternate scenario: What if Great Britain actually *honoured* every treaty it signed?

@Ivan Ivanovich Ivanovosky One Ummah , ideology , empire etc.

@Fat Earther huh?

Justin Y. You are bloody everywhere m8

Dennisz125 true

What if the middle east was a giant tropical forest?

Anikan Skywalker would move in

Justin Y. Anakin would conquer it with no resistance

Riku006 I believe so. It'll be through Amazon and other book stores. It'll be on E-Book Kindle so you can get it even if it doesn't ship international. I'll find out in a month

do you know roughly how much it will cost too?

I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. I will not download it from pirate bay. Oh look, its here :-P

I interpreted as it in the shipping alternative history; where the fictional Arab country you set the shipping price of book. I'm thinking "how detailed" and somewhat too detailed.

Oho Suomi mainittu

It’s been two years so...

NAZBOL

Socialist Nationalism.

nazism aimed to "cleanse" the "aryian germany" from anything that would have undermined its greatness (quoting hitler) , Baathism isn't even close to that "objective" , it's about reviving a colonized,divided and exploited nation and putting it back where it belongs on world stage for the values it holds especially on social level (which was kind of what everyone is fighting for , forever probably) , to quote baathist lore:" Immortal is the message of the arabs" (litteral) which loosely translates to "we still have cultural and social values that can help solve humanity's problems and we must act as humanity as a whole depended on our ability to immortalize these values and protecting them from imminent loss either by the commies or the capis , or the racially dogmatized foodchain theorists".. Zionism on the other hand , is the ideology of the natural supremacy of the jewish people (race and not religion) over all other humans (gentiles) ,and aims to make it a reality by directly engaging anyone who opposes it ( it's kind of the physical manifestation of all the money recolted from financing the bad deeds and businesses around the world) Zionism , as nazism , claims to be the salvation of a race by reattributing the "original" historical lands to a government /power that is racially and ideologically aligned with their own. While nazism at first wasn't really set up to be "all about race" , it's through the struggle against their direct opponent (the communists that were majoritarely led by jews) that they emphased the racial notions and the lebensraum ideal (which is exactly what zionism relies upon). Hitler's nazism is a germanized version of zionism, baathism is how nazism should have been - as baathists never engaged in racial cleansing or anything near and actually baathist beliefs just excludes other races from government but not social life or somewhat citizenship if they abide.

Unlike Nazism, Bathism does not resort to real racism, at least not the original Baathist ideology, nor did it look at one party system. It would have been something like Turkey during the past century.

Le commentaire Random disgusting

Le commentaire Random They'd probably have turned out like Russia. Or Cuba. Or China. Or Zimbabwe. Or North Korea. Or Venezuela. (Cue the muh durr never been tried comments)

Jim How was Zimbabwe communist

Joe Bowden Let's see: Land repossession (a key tenet of Stalin's Russia), state ownership of farms repossessed from the whites, and Mugabe is a self described Marxist.

Jim k

:(

Nobody Cares

Anschluss your ex.

Demand a referendum!

feels bad bro. *gives internet hug*

*laughs in Nazi*

Devin Mays hans get ze panzer

Odim Nazis aren’t socialist bud. They killed anyone who were socialist

@@nassimb7151 No, they specifically targeted radical revolutionaries acting on behalf of an international conspiracy to overthrow global powers in a violent revolution, National Socialism was meant to be a continuation of the old powers that was more conscious of the proletariat breeding an era of class unity, rather than the class struggles of both Communism and Capitalism

@@nassimb7151 Programs were even set up to integrate upper class children and lower class children, instilling them with values of racial solidarity that would instill a sense of comradery amongst all in Germany, and amongst nations the germans wanted to integrate, which was primarily central, northern, and eastern Europe. Italy and Spain already had Southern and Western Europe respectively, Germany would take the rest and end the struggles of the old kingdoms and lordships in its own way by integrating these Central Eastern and Northern Europeans into a common racial identity.

The Meiji Restoration overthrew a military dictatorship to install a constitutional monarchy with universal male suffrage. Baathist ideology's hold on the Arab world was part of what led to the Arab Spring, it was so repressive by nature. Japanese Nationalism was not kind to the Ainu. Arab Nationalism? That alienates Kurds, Turkics, and potentially even other Bedouin and Mashriqi cultures if the Heshimites are elevated. Mosul, Aleppo, Lebanon, Oman, might all see separatists develop in response to state discrimination or atrocities.

I am from iraq and baathism was ruling us by saddam hussein and I am happy to say that it might be the closest thing to happen

@@renaissanceweeb bedouins are Arabs though lol, they were the original arabs

Just have the american timeline with this Arabia's politics sightly influenced by the ideology No take over, just a slow integration into the West while nationalists push for modernization and a common arabian identity

baath is equals nazism bro

Hey I live in the UAE as well i can agree with what your saying but hey at least we didnt become Atheist and at least our most important and fundamental beliefs are still there

@@hishamalaker491 it's worse tho? UAE is normalizing relationships with Zionists who oppress their brothers in faith. Can't say they have an ounce of faith left if they support oppresors.

Japan is just as traditional as most western nations, they just have an Unfamiliar culture that seems traditional since its so different. A lot of people dont realize just how traditional the west is compared to the Far East and Russia.

jac of harts *coarse

But I get the point

deep

Tbh, neither of you are wrong Arabia was key in the development of Mathematics and Science, But now it's just holding the world back "You either die a hero, or live long enough to become a villain" - in a literal sense

uh oh someone is getting emotional. just be careful not to blow up there bud.

You do ir

Arabs in Africa would still be under British/French/Italian rule, so no, not all Arabs would be unified.

@@Threezi04 Then decolonization would happen after WW2 and the Arab nation would likely get in on bringing them into their sphere of influence. That said, baathism really wouldn't really work when there's no forced major divides lasting last the 40s or 50s.

@- EVIL Shut the fuck up, we don't give a fuck about aMAzIgH bLoOd, we are Arabs, plain and simple.

If the British actually gave Palestine to the Arabs like in the video, Zionism wouldn't really be much of a threat. Maybe Jews could even escape to the Arab state during the Holocaust (depends on German Arab relationships).

There likely would be very few alternate history YT channels.

Tony Koslowski True he is very the first one that became big. Plus he very is thr only one I am subbed to that the main content is alt history.

Several boring days and several historical facts wouldn't be brought to my/our attention.

You wouldn’t have made that comment and I wouldn’t be replying to it.

Goat-Emperor Bigs 😮

The Nazi ideology you are referring to is National Socialism not Social Nationalism. They are completely different. FYI Socialism + Nationalism =/= Nazism. Get your facts right please.

*Laughs in historical hindsight*

@@odranc1844 WHOOSH

Bright spark

He meant Nazbol

yeah , but the zionists militias back then were also week and can not match regular armies ...

While I do agree with you, I do feel that Nasser would be sympathetic to a Ba'athist Arabia, which he did say was the most likely ideology to take hold, so don't consider it too forgotten. King Fouruk probably would've fallen eventually as well, at least without Arabian assistance.

I can picture the Arabians having the same problems with Zionists in Palestine as the British did. I think Egypt go through a revolution as in our timeline and would either join the Arabian country or become a very close ally. Another issue not covered in the video is what would happen with the oil companies, which by the 40s were basically acting with impunity in the region, even in independent Iran

the Arab kingdom would be much much much influencial than eygypt

Ali Alahmad not really

While skunk drunk, high on weed and LSD, and of course, wearing swim trunks, and playing loud ass music, only to eventually realize the Ostrich was actually a terribly confused Camel named Alfred.

Florida let's people know about wacky yet totally rad things you can do, while other states are a bunch of squares.

Florida men actually exist in Egypt , I once saw one of then in its natural habitat once .

Probably has already happened

Grey, is that you?

WWIII & IV would have happened by now.

Reverend Lovejoy communist Japan. WWIII.

He's done this one already

Breaking News: World War XVII (17) started Nukes are not necessairly bad things. Their effects are indeed terrifying but the deterrent they create has been succesful in preventing a major international military conflict for the past 70+ years. Also: if nukes never came into play we would likely not have Nuclear Power, which, no matter what you think about it, not having it would lead to increased exploitment of non-renewable resources, like oil. In the end, if nukes weren't invented: World War 2 will have ended much later, likely between 1947 (at best) or even 1950, because the United States would have needed to invade mainland Japan in order to force its capitulation. And invading a mountainous region inhabited by nationalistic fanatics is not easy. The Cold War would have gone hot veeeeeery quickly, maybe even with the Berlin Blockade, which would have triggered war between west and east very likely before the United States captured Tokyo. At that point the Battle of Europe would be mostly between the USSR and the Western Allies, as the newly liberated european countries (like Italy) didn't have the Economic and Military power to engage in another conflict. Timeline: 1945 - WW2 Ends in Europe 1948 - The Russo-American war starts 1949 - The Communists win in china, Japan surrenders 1950 - Warsaw Pact formed between the USSR, the PRC (Communist China) and the DPRK (North Korea), PATO (Pacific and Atlantic Treaty Organization) formed between the USA, the UK, France, Canada, Australia, New Zeland, Japan and the ROC (Republic of China)

Yessssssss no noooooo Japan never surrenders

Fuckin hell I see you in every video

QYiHL lmao

Middle east peace, nigga please

thank you my good sir

I don't think the goal should be to be progressive. Progressive implies there is no end. Change is not inherently good, and progressiveness means to forever change.

@@algorithmgeneratedanimegir1286 You make no sense, do you even know what fucking entropy is? everything changes and you people cant change that. They make the world a better place, you sit there in your piss and shit crying about ye olde times.

Then we wouldn't be in this comment section.

But would someone else have tried to fill the channel vacuum?

Thomas Saldana good point

What if everytime we ask us a question like this we create an alternate universe?

Dont we create alternate universes, just by doing something? Like what if you didnt eat breakfast today? Would there be a civilwar in the US indirectly caused by that?

Razzy1312 interesting

We'd all identify as Greek, food would be blander.

Razzy1312 Certainly,He would have Pushed his Empire expansion into Arabia as he had proclaimed shortly before his death.

Well, if he didn't die, he would actually get to rule his large empire, he was already returning back to Macedonia by 323BC, because food supplies,etc were over, soldiers were tired.

the empire was too big for that time it's bound to fail

Brown Nazis?!

NAtionalische soZIaliache arbeits partei

@@matthewnunya8483 aka, Amin Al Hussaini.

Its not Nazi and not anti jew it would be anti zionist which is not the same thing

Not the Arab version. Nazism was strongly influenced by Hitler's personal pagan fantasies. And it's part had much more influence in the ideology than actual nationalism and socialism.

Real Nazism (Strasserism) was nuch more socialistic.Cody already did a video on that.

You tried Nazism? I feel sorry for your grandchildren.

Hmmmmmmm well since there is no Israel in this timeline maybe the National socialists were successful ☹️

They weren't. :) National Socialism and Arab Socialist Nationalism are different things.

I think they already did one on what if the war on terror never began.

8 Month late but yea it do be like that, just rivalry ship being overlooked :/

But as a Ba'athist you would know that most Ba'athist today would be more of a neo-baathist rather than the one Michel Aflaq had in mind. This is coming from a fellow Arab Ba'athist.

Neo-Ba'athism is long story short just Ba'athism implemented with an iron fist due to harsh times, whereas Aflaq was less brutish and didn't yet recognize the fight the Ba'athists were about to enter.

Neo-Baathism is the only way forward. Michel Aflaq being the corner stone of baathism doesn't mean we should agree with everything he said because honestly some of his ideas are pretty wonky. Btw which branch do you support.

Ankh Its very stupid to think entire countries should unite based on them sharing an arabic language.... All it would do is cause more conflicts.

Mahmoud Alissa we don't share the same culture. Can you honestly tell me a Lebanese guy will have the same mentality as a Yemeni or a Saudi? With regards to language the closest example I can think of that resembles the Arab world is Latin America, and you dont see them wanting to be one country. I'm still a new Ba'athist because I still hope for an Arab union similar to the EU.

same

This kind of video will definitely be very interesting for the numerous Arab perspectives. But the script would have to be slightly adapted. Such as when he brought up christians conservatism versus Islamic conservatism.

a primitive force and their balls conquer the scared white man lmfao

Kevin Picton Google weather in Mongolia, Siberia, and Russia and compare that to Western European weather.

Then the mongol empire conquors Europe

Chrice Chiu :Omg yes

yung t :calm down it. He said it as a joke lol

I like the kurds

Good question, Brendan, Cody totally skipped over the Kurds.

Louis Duarte My theory is that the Kurds would be a continuous problem for the state with them either politically or by rebellion achieve independence. Rebellion if scenario 3 occurs. I don’t know much about the several ethnic groups in the Middle East but I think there would be problems in Lebanon as Christians there identify themselves as Phoenician not Arab. I also wonder how Jewish immigration would factor in as without the Balfour declaration Jews would still try to migrate to Palestine/Israel.

and jews... that's a major fly in the ointment today

TheHunter701 *very

TheHunter701 no u baby

It's really amazing just how many of the issues we have with today previous generations already grappled with in some form, yet how different the world was just a handful of decades ago. The more things change, the more things stay the same.

I'm 50/50 on it, it interests me and it doesn't at the same time.

Uriah Siner ay lmao

No one would’ve watched the prequels

He would blow up instead of use the force

*"I don't like dirt. It's mushy, soft, and it sticks everywhere."*

Luke and Leia would have one hell of a tan.

Damn I wish Abdul Karim Qasim had stayed in power...

@@odim7960 fuck off bitch he destroyed iraq he destroyed the iraqi dream monarchy was better fuck abd al karim

That's a lot of Abduls...

@@officerchoclet2nd798 Iraq wasn't only bagdad under the monarchy, the other provinces in Iraq were quite poor, listen at the story of saddam's youth that's why Abdul Karim Qasim staged the coup but that doesn't excuse what they did to the royal family

It wasn't a revolution it was a coup

S3rp3nte that would be interesting they would definitely have more influence in South America but I do think that they would allie with the USA

Kameron Jones Unless it get involved in the conflict of Panama Canal, since Colombia could have become at that point either an allie or a protectorate of Brazil. And it sound unlikely that two supepowers would become allied, especially during the beginning of the 20th century, there would be too much conflict of interest.

S3rp3nte oh I thought you were talking about current day but it would be interesting to see how the two countries would handle the Panama canal situation.

Posible a war in south america betwee Brazil vs all there neigbords

Actually, it was once.. until they overthrew the monarchy, and implanted the shitty republic. Poor Brazil. It had such a great potential.. and it threw it in the trash..

why not in unreal?

@@terner1234 lmao, that got me off guard

@@terner1234 nah better make my own engine

So why the hell do we kill echother so much

@@ussrunion4049 human nature. Everyone wants to be the one in charge, preferably without any responsibility

Intergalactic Thought Criminal yes, I would love to read that!

Do you mean the fantasy version where it actually works as planned or the more realistic version where it goes horribly wrong and basically destroys Western Europe?

Be N S O N, ware it all falls apart.

Be N S O N both would be interesting

I think that's the direction Cody is going with his novel. I can see the blurb on the back cover now: "Drain the Mediterranean Sea to have more farmland to settle on. What can possibly go wrong?"

Alfred Thayer Mahan yes please

America's military strength was not very high back then. Sort of like having Vietnam or Chile on your side.

They did, they lost, Canada burned the White House in our timeline.

黑龍 - Hắc Long there was no Canada during 1812 it was the British who burned the White House.

What if France helped fight the US in their revolution?

Just as a heads up, I am well aware of why we didn't help. I just thought Cody would be the man for the job to go over in detail just how bad America would be screwed by Britain, and if it would ever recover, or even continue to exist.

**Vader turns on his lightsaber**

Hello there!

I FOUND SAND!

SpartanGerm 212 General Kenobi

Prussian Eagle Star Wars reference

The power of a True United States of America would be overwhelming but, would end up collapsing quickly do to all the political and cultural differences. A better option would be if the United States allied with the Central powers and obtained Canada by an annex maybe add Cuba and Panama as states. Then if the Dust Bowl was less extreme but, the agriculture lessons learned still happened. For Mexico I got nothing besides them annexing smaller states down south but, they couldn't be much of a power do to all the corruption in their history. South America would be the same except if the USA gave more influence. Which wouldn't happen unless a second war world broke out between major powers. The Caribbean would be influence be sole Superpower in the west. Unless the former Spanish Colonies of South America made a Union but, it could only rival Brazil. Unless South America Industrialized earlier.

Jacob Tuell no just wipe out the natives or large portions of them and force mass migration of citizens of the conquering country to the conquered regions and incentivize child bearing. Then the cultural differences and issues associated with that disappear

Defender nope

Our geography is too shitty for that.

Haha, funny, cute and not remotely realistic by any means, especially considering it seems that is the US' FAVORITE place to fuck with and completely run into chaos. Chile, Venezuela, Colombia... even Bolivia & Paraguay at one point. They completely intentionally enjoy thoroughly ruining and sending countries into utter chaos, then pretend they picked great leaders, intentionally fund rebel terrorist groups while giving them guns in order to have them run a coup, while they too infiltrate and screw with various political people in order to implant their pick for leader, only for it without failure ending up in a military junta, and other dictatorships, which then plummet the countries back into further chaos. Being so ridiculously unrealistic, I find it highly unlikely anyone would find it valuable or fun to try and pretend as if it had even a remote chance of ever happening without military force. That is unless the person happens to somehow be a willfully blind and ignorant US citizen and patriot who of course would then sincerely believe the US "would never be so cruel".

They have great fhlafel

Imposible, Its city of heaven, everyone wants it.

If Jerusalem was a state it'll be a another (miniature) Israel - due to the fact that Jews have a clear majority in the city.

Benjamin Edelman Not really if you include Jordanians and giving both the Palestinians and Israelis the right to return. I think it would be even with Arabs having a slight advantage. If you remove Jordanians (not Palestinian Jordanians) then the Jews will be the slight majority. Feel free to correct me if I’m wrong tho

@negro bsr Jordan was once United with Palestine in the name of “TransJordan” hence my inclusion of them. Jordanians would easily be able to move in Jerusalem given the opportunity. Either way, it’ll be marginal

What is it?

@@SFFRN19 the bathesim motto

@Will DeMarco arabic?

@@littlefinger7522 If u mean what the comment said then yes it was in Arabic if you are asking what he meant by the Syrian Arab Republic then ya it is Arab as its in the Arabia area

@Will DeMarco Inshallah they will live as a strong and peaceful country

Pretty accurate assessment, but I would like to say that a unified Arab world was the main aspiration of all Arabs at that time. That is why Arab nationalist group propped up everywhere in the Arab world. Alas we grew further away from those ideals and we became one people with different cultures and identities. I still hope we can create a union of sorts like the EU, but I don't have hope in our courrpt and weak Arab "leaders".

SilverAbsol Actually in west asia the good way to divide countries for less conflicts is to have an assyrian state in northern iraq, kurdistan, alawite state in syria and unified israel and palestine. “Unified arab world" would only cause more conflicts...

Babylonian Mapping/Gaming Yes like there is no such thing as iraq or syria ...These are borders drawen randomly by colonialists without taking into consideration ethnic or religious differences, just divide and conquer.

Babylonian Mapping/Gaming Mesopotamia is gone pal calm down their gone

Mesopotamia and Iraq, however, are the same thing. A different name doesn't necessarily mean anything will change. It would be like calling Lebanon Phoenicia or Jordan Nabataea.