Help us combat aggressive evangelization in Israel: outreachjudaism.org/partners/

Rabbi was so patient listening to that nonsense 🙏😭

Why is it when I listen to this girl, the phrase, “Stupid people don’t know they’re stupid” comes to mind.

I love how Rabbi Singer is always calm and kind. ❤

Many Christian’s think like this girl I’m glad I left 4 yrs ago thank you rabbi singer I’m 27 yrs old I’m a Noah hide

I’m not a Christian or Jew, but I have a deep reverence for the Jewish historical tradition of extreme discipline, self-scrutiny, and study. It’s inspiring.

The young lady is upset and is not prepared to debate or even challenge this rabbi. She was talking a lot but saying nothing . She wasn’t even able to articulate what exactly she has a problem with, she’s just upset that the rabbi know his and her faith better than she or any of her pastors .

I'm a Hindu woman 64 years old from India but living in abroad over two decades. I'm studying Koran but came across this wonderful learned eloquent Rabbi Tovia. And I'm interested to read Torah as well now.

8 minutes in and this Christian woman has made 0 arguments. She hasn't said anything except for "Tovia misunderstood the passages". Not to mention calling Rabbi Singer a liar over and over (without reason). What a waste of time.

She didn't give us any counter points she just spent all of her time talking about how wicked Tovia is rather than actually telling us how exactly Tovia is lying.

The best argument against Christianity is the Bible itself

A Christian calling ANYBODY a liar is a stretch.

Thank you Rabbi for saving me from paganism

Me as a Muslim pray to The Almighty and ask Him to protect and bless my cousin in faith Rabbi Tovia Singer.

She says she can counter him and then she proves his points

Sad to see some people claiming Rabbi Tovia a liar

Poor girl, she realized her pastors are lying to her. She realizes this wrong but just throws guilty to the truth telling people. Btw, obviously she can’t make a point. Good Christian.

She is beginning to wake up. When people are mad it’s because she is coming to realization

I suspect whenever a young Christian declares they can out argue a rabbi, it is never going to go well for them.

Rabbi I love you for your patience and sticking to the truth. May the God of Israel be praised

This woman not only shows her ignorance by suggesting that Rabbi Singer lies, she has the audacity to say she is informed about Judaism. If she knew even a modicum about Judaism she would realise that not only is he not lying, he does not need to lie because he knows his subject better than his opponents.

As a Muslim I have huge respect for rabbi singer .. amazing intellect

I'm from Dominican republic, I have a lot of respect for Rabbi Tovia Singer. Man" He opened my mind about the bible. Tovia doesn't lie to anybody, He doesn't deceive anyone, because He always gives you the quote for you to look out for yourself. Love Israel from Dominican republic.

I am a muslim. Girl calling Rabbi a liar is just a projection. Rabbi Singer has all my love and respect.

The woman gets too emotional to make a valid arguement with out it devolving.

I sent more than 50 questions to that angry lady... She didn't answer them... But also she became SILENT...no more videos published by her...

When you logically deconstruct someone's argument and shatter their faith, they will lash out.

Thank you, Rabbi.

I’m amazed when a gentile thinks that they know the Bible better than the Jews. That’s like telling Elon musk you know more about electric cars than him.

There’s no factual argument for Christianity. Rabbi Singer is courageous for speaking about this and attacking

My favourite words of Tovia Singer. "Trinity is a self-inflicted wound from which Christianity has never recovered.."

Even as a skeptic regarding all religious 'supernatural' claims, I have *mad respect for Rabbi Singer ;-)* I've been watching him for a long time.

As a Muslim man I have huge respect for Rabbi Tovia and Jews for being true beliievers of one and only God . Land and political matters have nothing to do with the fact that Jews only pray one and only God .

I am so glad Rabbi Tovia Singer is here!! He addresses this attack so well !! Such a great teaching!! Baruch HaShem!!

First OF ALL, I AM NOT A JEW NOR CHRISTIAN. AFTER LISTENING TO THIS LADY, PEOPLE SHOULD RUN AS FAST AS THEY CAN FROM CHRISTIANITY.

She is not educated. But she is convinced she is.

This girl thinks that to beat a Rabbi, she has to be as good as Rabbi. And then she exhibits her expertise by calling the Rabbi a liar. If that's her strategy to overpower her enemy, she's lost her ground

This little girl is so confused. If you can’t explain a point plainly you don’t quite understand it yourself.

The Rabbi speaks the truth... and the truth is hurting Christians

If anyone is a liar it's that girl, Rabbi Singer has ALWAYS given the listeners the book, chapter and verse of every scripture he has ever quoted and urged the listeners to look it up for themselves, he has literally begged listeners to read it for themselves!

She just admitted that the whole Christian thing is a lie. 😂

As a former Christian I urge this lady to open her mind and not be stuck in the Christian teachings. I thank Rabbi Tovia for providing clarity in the original texts. I have learnt a lot from his teachings.

She lied that "Christians are told to not take things out of context.". Then if so, what are their pastures, oh, sorry, pastors hiding?

One day, each of us will know the truth, for better or worse.

Tovia’s reaction poker face is priceless.

Tipical answer of a christian when being confronted with the truth(your lying,your lying!) I should know,as for me and my house rab Singer we thank Hashem for the work your doing and will keep with anything we can bringing the children of Israel back to Torah,Baruch Hashem!

I never would have found my ancestor "Rabbi Benjamin Papermaster" without you Rabbi Tovia. I start conversion early next year, thank you from the bottom of my heart.

A Christian calling a Jew a liar about Jewish Hebrew bible history is one of the most mentally insane things I ever seen in 2023. Smh

The audacity of this girl blows my mind, Rabbi, I really admire your calm actitud.

Thank you for you kindness. I get really frustrated when adults make fun of children who are struggling to figure it all out.

i am Christian I loved listen Rabbi Tovia Singer, It make me understand Bible, from Other side Point Of View, It Make Faith strong to The LORD Jesus Christ, Toda Raba Rabbi Tovia Singer.

She really embarrassed herself.

My only criticism of Rabbi SInger has been that he never uses medrash, chassidus, kabbalah... not even gemora! And this was the first time I heard him quote Rashi z"l... Now I understand why!

Stages of grief: denial anger bargaining depression acceptance right now she's angry.

Ignore these idiots. Rabbi. Love your work Rabbi.

When I was a young kid at catholic school i asked questions. I was told to not read the bible and accept what the church taught. That started me on a lifelong search. Went through many churches. Now I am in what could be called Messianic. Not that I want to convert anyone except out of the world system. Guess it is that I want to follow God since he has been ao food to me in the past 68 years. Always leading .e closer to him.

Thanks Rabbi for NOT being defensive... BUT rather informative & clear mind factual based spoken Keep up your good work _/)

"With regard to everything that I have told you, be watchful to keep, and the name of any foreign god, do not even utter, it shouldn't be heard on your lips" Exodus 23:13.

The big question is WHY would 'Matthew' (or whoever wrote that 'gospel') cite a passage like Hosea 11, pretending it was about God calling Baby Jesus out of Egypt back into Judea after the death of Herod (etc.), knowing that ANYBODY who has read Hosea KNOWS it's about how God called the 12-tribed nation of ISRAEL out of Egypt -- even going on to chastise them for having "sacrificed unto Baalim, and burnt incense to graven images" (verse 2). WHY would 'Matthew' do something so patently ridiculous, so laughably bogus? It is plain to me, having read Joseph Atwill's book "CAESAR'S MESSIAH," that the true authors of the New Testament were propagandists working on behalf of the Flavian emperors in the immediate aftermath of the Jewish War which THEY had won against what had then been "mainstream Judaism" -- the popular form of it that had instigated the War in 66 CE. These Jews HATED Rome, and had come to believe that a Zeal for the Law on their part would be rewarded by YHWH by His helping them to conquer their pagan enemies, the same way young David was able to kill Goliath, despite him being a scary-looking giant. The winners of the War -- the Flavians who began a new dynasty ruling over the Roman Empire -- studied the writings of their enemies: the zealots, the messianic Jews, the ones who saw themselves as the Sons of Light in a conflict in which they supposedly COULDN'T LOSE, because YHWH was on their side -- obligated by the promises He had made to their forefathers to fight on their behalf IF they returned to His ways. Anybody who has read the Dead Sea Scrolls knows that they were punctilious in their strict observance of the Torah. But the writers of those sectarian scrolls did ONE thing in particular that their enemies in Rome must have found absolutely bonkers: they scoured through the sacred texts and deliberately PRETENDED that certain non-prophetic passages in books like Habakkuk and Nahum (for example) ACTUALLY WERE prophetic. They believed that their own current events -- the unfolding history centered around their spiritual/political drama involving their Teacher of Righteousness versus the 'Liar' and/or the 'Wicked Priest' HAD to have been foretold by the Prophets of old. So they went out of their way to take verses out-of-context and interpret them AS IF those passages were foretelling events in their own day. These are the so-called "pesher" texts found at Qumran. When the Romans, having captured alive many of the fanatical Zealots and their sacred and sectarian literature, interrogated them and found out about this goofy way of 'interpreting' old books written centuries before, what were those Romans supposed to think of the mental gymnastics that those pesher-writers went through, to see THEMSELVES described in obscure passages from Habakkuk (etc.), a method of interpretation that helped to justify their own politically-motivated rebellious actions against Roman hegemony? The Romans undoubtedly thought their enemies were off-their-rockers. Willing to twist their own sacred scriptures into meaning something that the original writers surely never intended. Thus, when it came to concocting a 'New' testament -- a new pseudo-judaic 'scripture -- so as to promulgate a bogus 'messiah' who would prove to be PRO-Roman and ANTI-Jew, the Roman propagandists working on behalf of the Flavians SPOOFED what the pesher-writers from the Zealot community had done. THAT is why 'Matthew' takes a passage like Hosea 11:1 ridiculously out-of-context, pretends it's a divine 'fulfillment' of prophetic scripture, yet knowing full well that only an idiot or a fool wouldn't see it for being an illegitimate and bogus way of dealing with a supposedly sacred text. Those Flavian propagandists were only emulating the pesher-text writers, those 'interpreters' who weren't above twisting passages in the TaNaK to serve their own agenda. What was good for the Jewish goose is good enough for the Roman gander, one might say. This bogus way of trying to use 'scripture' to interpret current events has never gone away, by the way. Anybody who thinks that the crisis in Ukraine is a prelude to Armageddon is guilty of the same unhinged prophecy-mongering that those poor oppressed folks in Judea resorted to, a kind of pattern-seeking that led to their brave yet doomed stand against Roman oppression. Every time the U.S.A. gets a new President, some evangelical minister tries to see if the new President's name can add up to 666 with gematria. The Romans viewed the Jews -- i.e. those non-hellenized Jews who would never compromise on their religious principles -- as seditious fanatics. The war was costly for Rome, and it was a war they couldn't risk losing, no matter what. If the Jews were to successfully overthrow Roman rule from their province, then all the other conquered provinces would follow suit. Rome HAD to win, no matter at what cost. They put down the rebellion with the utmost cruelty. And then . . . to punish the Jews for having DARED to take on Rome's might, the Flavians invented a religion that BASTARDIZED their sacred writings, purporting to present as an actual personage in history a parody of messianic expectations -- the 'christ' named Jesus. This fictional 'messiah' was placed in Judean history exactly 40 years before the events Josephus chronicled in his JEWISH WAR. Because the outcome of that war had already happened, the fiction set 40 years before it could present this 'Jesus' character ACCURATELY 'PROPHESYING' THAT FUTURE. The entire New Testament was written by Rome, by propagandists working for Vespasian, Titus, and Domitian. The calamity visited upon the Jewish people trapped in Jerusalem during that horrific siege was seconded by the even greater calamity that would dog the steps of Jewry ever after, the institutionalized antisemitism brought about by the new religion which was designed to stoke hatred of Jews in the hearts of non-Jews. The central theme of this 'new' testament was that the God of Israel had ABANDONED those whom He had adopted as His "Chosen People" since the time of Abraham -- that the Jews had FORFEITED their status as God's Chosen People by their rebellion against Rome. Christianity was a ghastly parody of Messianic Judaism (i.e. the version of Judaism that the Zealots favored, as opposed to the Pharisaic Judaism and the Sadducean Judaism practiced by Jews who were subservient to Rome) -- designed to be anti-Jewish, to portray gentiles as more righteous than Jews, to portray a Jewish Messiah who was friendly with TAX-COLLECTORS, because it's all about the MONEY, folks, the economic exploitation of the conquered provinces. Those tax-collectors -- themselves Jewish -- were like the Vichy in France after Nazi Germany conquered them, Frenchmen who aided the Nazis to carry out their agenda. No self-respecting Frenchman would ever consider a fellow countryman to be a Patriot if that man were aiding and abetting the depredations committed by their enemies. Any would-be 'messiah' who was seen befriending tax-collectors during the Roman occupation of Judea would be DESPISED by the Jewish masses, and rightly so. Virtually everything about the 'Jesus' of the gospels is an upside-down spoof of what the Jews had every reason to expect a 'messiah' to be. Joseph Atwill's "CAESAR'S MESSIAH" provides the corrective lens that enables us to see the New Testament for what it really is: a spoof of Judaic religion intended to heap unending suffering upon the Jews throughout posterity. Religion was a tool to be used to further the agenda of Rome. Rome laughed at the sufferings of the Jews, as the 'sacrament' of the Eucharist shows, it being a commemoration of the CANNIBALISM described in Josephus' JEWISH WAR, when a woman named 'Mary' killed and cooked her own unnamed infant, describing their hopeless situation as a 'calamity'. Christianity was Rome's revenge against the popular Zealot version of Judaism that inspired the uprising in 66 CE.

I listened to her speak for five minutes but it was just words. Good job bringing a discussion out of it.

Yet another, Tovia Singer, "hold my beer", moment.

She didn't give one single example to support her argument, just a broad general accusation. I've never heard Tovia explain anything in a manner that changes the plain meaning of the text. His explanations always bolster the meaning of the text, and he always uses specific examples. And he always encourages you to look it up for yourself.

Your so patience monsieur rabbi shalom for YOU thanks for your wisdom

She goes "don't put the passages out of context". But the context, smarty, was placed by the church.

This girl is terrified, which is why she's resorting to the 'what about' argument, basically trying to say 'Jews do it too!' and use that to justify the fact that she was lied to. Her anger is a defense mechanism because she's starting to wake up. I appreciate the Rabbi's calm, measured response and hope she keeps studying and gets past her emotional denial. It's hard to give up everything you've been taught. :( Compassion in the face of anger is the best response, as Rabbi Singer exemplified.

""You are My witnesses," says Hashem, "and My servant whom I chose," in order that you know and believe Me, and understand that I am He; before Me no god was formed and after Me none shall be. I, I am Hashem, and besides Me there is no Savior." Isaiah 43:10,11.

She says “i will tell you in a minute “ all the time, but sill said nothing 😂😂 Instead continued her baseless accusations without proving him wrong 😂

Yeah… she is not well-studied. But the poor dear thinks she is.

Christians hold the patent to cognitive dissonance.

Tovi? No ma’am. It’s Rabbi Singer. Respect.

All I got from this was "No way Hosea". ❤ From Israel 🇮🇱

Also, the Talmud literally says that drash can't replace the p'shat of a passage.

Rabbi Tovia, looking at the comments section, I don't know how you keep your sanity with so many crazy folks. Thank you for all you do.

This girl is a perfect example of someone who is not “well studied”, referring to herself as “well studied”. She belongs at a college freshman beer circle.

also disrespectful and angry while the rabbi is not angry and calm and well composed

Amazing response Rabbi Singer!! 100% spot on

Barach Hashem for Rabbi Singer being a loud speaker for a voice in the wilderness

Just a little laugh at the privilege behind her confidently stating Jews are reappropriating their own bible.

In my 20,s I had a girlfriend who had a minister for a dad ,I now look toward Judaism for truth of scripture and my old girlfriend is now a Mormon and I love Rabbi Singers joke about Christians seeing how Jews feel I am still thinking scientifically thinking and love Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks teaching on evolution when confronting Richard Dawkins on his book The God Delusion. Thank you Rabbi Singer for your teaching and Love of scripture you are wonderful!

Jeyzus H......"I know my imaginery friend better than you do!!!!" What an utter waste of a life.

I don’t care to watch any blockbuster movies anymore! Rabbi Tovia singer is the real super hero! ✨

😑 "he takes new testament out of context" sheesh the entire new testament is a literal collection of "taken out of context" in fact I've got a new name for the nt...... "Taken out of Context" this is insane lol

Did she take the video down, can’t find it

Wow that's disrespectful. I couldn't ever question the Rabbi.

Yeah, ran into her video when it first came out and responded, she had nothing but baseless accusations and no facts. Thanks Rabbi Singer and the Outreach Judaism team.

Thank god...we have you rabbi...keep up

סרטון נהדר, תשובות מעולות, תודה רבה!

The Christians are famous for taking verses out of context. The most famous one is 'I and the father are one'.

This will soon be over for good. Figure it out, people.

Bible : this is a circle Christians : no it's a triangle without corners

That girl is so disrespectful. Rabbi Singer is very well versed in theology. Facts not feeling, missy.

I grew up Christian but am no longer religious. I would never have made a video like hers because Rabbi Singer isn't trying to convert Christians. He's talking to Jews that Christians are trying to convert. So, there's no need for her to take it personally.

She should be a politician, she's mastered the art of talking without actually saying anything. LOL

"This entire matter that I am commanding you, it is that that you shall observe to perform, do not add onto it and do not subtract from it" Deuteronomy 13:1.

Thanks from Indonesia

Does anybody know where to find the original video of the girl in the car? I can't seem to find it on youtube.

If there was a Jesus, according to Jesus himself he never was sent to the gentiles or knew christianity or christians or any new covenant

I feel sorry for the well-meaning protestant types, they are genuine and sincere, but they are wrong.

I am a Hindu...I was almost taken in Jesus Conspiracy by so called Pastors, Priest & Exorcist..untill God Almighty intervened and guided me to him via Rabbi Tovia... Listening to him is like catching a lifeline and feels like What Born Again truly means ( It is coming back to God Again) ...Thank you Rabbi..I pray that HaShem bless you abundantly..Love & Respect to you Rabbi 🙏

Shalom Rabbi Singer