Angular Contact vs Radial Bearings (Cup and Cone vs Cartridge): Engineering Analysis

  Рет қаралды 68,530

Hambini

Hambini

Күн бұрын

This video will explain the difference between Radial Deep Groove ball bearings (6000 series) and Angular Contact bearings (Cup and Cone / 7000 series).
It covers the basic geometry, an explanation of bearing related terms, a visual of the running speeds, a cut up and then an Engineering Analysis.
Maths has been kept to a minimum.
This is mainly bicycle-oriented.
My Website www.hambini.com
Click me on twitter / hambinieng

Пікірлер: 377
@jomgelborn
@jomgelborn 4 жыл бұрын
Free information from a killer engineer. I love KZfaq.
@Quarterblad
@Quarterblad 4 жыл бұрын
Finally good engineering stuff without marketing shit
@ja60123
@ja60123 2 жыл бұрын
(applause)
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
I really enjoyed this video! I looked forward to it for a week and I learned a bit as well. Thanks for all your efforts! . Heres a little practical info (my opinions and experiences) Ive learned just playing around with bicycles, vehicles and machinery for a few years. Traditionally, bicycle hubs,headsets and bottom brackets were all cup and cone, loose ball type angular contact bearings. They have been proven, tried and true over many decades. The fact that Shimano, Campy and Chris King and just a few others still use angular contact tells you something. These are the only brands Ive seen and experienced consistently true high quality in, along with Phil Wood(cartridges). The FACT that mostly all other brands, even high end blingy stuff, uses cheap radial contact cartridge bearings tells us something else. Most radial contact bearings used in bicycle parts are in actuality designed for electric motors which spin at thousands of rpm. These are even specced with a lesser amount of grease for thermal expansion. Not exactly ideal for a bicycle application!! (Phil Wood specs his own fully greased bearings) I have to totally disagree with Hambini about the difficulty of servicing cup and cone bearings. I serviced them as a child!! I can service a cup and cone component in 20 minutes or less! They require simple inexpensive tools such as cone wrenches. Loose balls are available in any hardware store! Sure they’re messier. Getting adjustment perfect DOES require practice and PATIENCE! But you CAN make them perfect! They CAN be adjusted for preload AND WEAR!! Have we become this lazy, impatient and or mechanically inept? (Job security for me, HAHA) Are we so pressed for time, were willing to sacrifice perfection? Especially those who seek high performance, longevity and low friction!!!Our bicycles roll on bearings! If you want them to perform at their best, they require extra love and care. Radial cartridge bearings, on the other hand, CANNOT be adjusted for preload or wear. Good operation is solely dependent upon QUALITY manufacturing!! Once they are used they wear, (even the high quality ones) they get looser, you must tolerate wear until its bad enough to need replacement! That looseness, that we must tolerate, leads to faster wear and potential damage. Furthermore, a cartridge bearing depends solely on a EXTREMELY precise fitment into the hole in which its pressed and the components they mate with. . If that hole or components are not machined to a VERY EXACT TOLERANCE, even the very best cartridges available will wear out prematurely and or perform in less than an optimum manner. Cup and cone/ angular contact does not suffer these issues!! Press fitting bearings into their housings require tolerances in tenths of thousandths of an inch! As set forth in a machinery handbook, a common engineering and machinist’s reference. We see all the problems with press fit BB bearings!! What would make anyone believe quality is any less shoddy on all the other aspects of primarily Asian made bicycles? Ive messed around with bicycles, autos and machinery for 50 years. Im not an engineer. I cant and wont argue theory. Out of all due respect, Ive had so many young engineers and programmers tell me ‘In theory this should work!’ , LOL!! I have practical, DIRTY, hands on experience to offer. Ive been a machinist and mechanical inspector for many years. Ive machined and installed bearings in aircraft and spacecraft. I build wheels and wrench on bikes in my retirement. I own and love Shimano, Campy and Chris King bearing components. None of this stuff is new at all. I buy quality and MAINTAIN IT FOR LONG LIFE! Im a long distance randonneur and bike packer mostly. Im not concerned with highest performance or lowest rolling resistance.All of my stuff has been ridden hard, abused, on and offroad in all weathers. Ive raced endurance type events. My Chris King stuff is 16-35 years old. ALL on the original bearings they came with!! Some of my Shimano and Campy stuff is even older and still working great! Because its maintained like EVERYTHING ELSE needs to be! Remember,NOTHING lasts forever! My stuff has hundreds of thousands of miles on it! In comparison, someone gave me a set of White Industry track hubs. These require new bearings AT LEAST every other year!! I like them just because they’re shiny and built into beautiful wheels!! I wouldnt say the WI hubs are bad, but for what people pay, they should be much better!! Ive overhauled most ‘high end’ hubs on the market and most use cheap off the shelf Chinese radial contact bearings. They are simply there for the bottom line, not because they are a superior spec, plain and simple!
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
I did not read this post and I read every other comment on this page up to now. You gotta adjust your commenting strategy if you want people to read it.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Josh Gross Why? If you spent 24 minutes watching the video Id think youre interested in hearing more.
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 No one came here for a poorly written essay. Were you commenting on a video or drafting your personal Wikipedia page?
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Josh Gross If you read my comment you’d see Ive never claimed to be an engineer. Im not a writer either. Are you the grammar police? Im just a guy who has ridden bikes a long time and lots of miles. Ive gotten my hands dirty more than most. What is it? Should I be banned? Did I offend you somehow?
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
MJD I like this channel because I'm concerned with safety, quality, reliability and longevity. Efficiency to an extreme degree just doesn't concern me. I don't race much anymore and if I do, it's endurance type rides. I want to ride more than I wrench. I want bearings that roll well and stay that way for a long time. If I was that concerned with efficiency, I'd remove all the seals from my bearings, use oil for lubrication and replace them every race. Or my mechanic would! That's what many track racers used to do with their bearings. My 43 year old Campy Record hubs still roll smooth and fast and they don't have seals. I don't see many if any brand new hubs this smooth and efficient. Ive owned them since new. They're still used on my commuter almost daily, a fixed gear 'cross bike. Now There's efficiency for you! I enjoy this channel for the roasting and the illumination of the generally shit quality standards in the larger bike industry. I don't always agree with what he says, but engineers are usually good at figuring stuff out, but apparently not 'bicycle engineers' and designers!! I think if Hambini converts just a few critical thinking individuals to actually analyze and think twice before spending hard earned money it was all worth it! I rant, bitch and write essays here for the same reasons, to illuminate and state what's obvious to me. I can't help it if people take it personally that they drank the koolaide and wasted their money! Haha. Being a bike mechanic I get a birds eye view of all the BS, all the hassles and all the elitist fools. The ironic thing is I love fixing bikes, so all this overly complex and overpriced junk is job security for me! Being a retired manufacturing 'expert' I have a unique view of very high quality and the procedures used in obtaining it. Being a hardcore rider and racer of almost 50 years I can SEE what's works and lasts.
@jonb77
@jonb77 4 жыл бұрын
Race surfaces are always doomed to fail before the balls due purely to the overall surface area offered up for wear and tear. It must be noted that 'cup and cone' bearings, due to their serviceability, can be maintained to easily last 20-30 years which is a figure that 'cartridge' bearings can only dream of. A 'cone' will fail before a 'cup' due again to the surface area offered up for wear and tear. It must be noted that in this regard Shimano have always offered replacement cones for their hubs which, thus, further contributes to that 20-30 year lifespan.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Shimano, Campy and Chris King all use angular contact bearings. All these have served me well over many hard riding years. I use even my road bikes well outside their intended usage, riding dirt and gravel, even easy singletrack. Cup and cone bearings(AC bearings) are tried, true and proven in all bicycle bearing applications, although IMO roller or needle bearings work in headset better Ive got 42 year old Nuovo Record hubs that were ridden offroad back in the days way before MTBs. They are still nearly as smooth as new and regularly used. I just rode over 100 miles on them yesterday! Ive got older Dura Ace, XT and XTRs that I still ride. I overhaul my hubs frequently and just replace balls. Only on a couple occasions have I needed to replace cones or broken axles. Shimano are the best hubs for a reasonable amount of money. They are the most practical. I have 6 Chris King hubs and 3 headsets. The oldest I bought when Chris King 1st started making hubs back in the 90s. I saw one disassembled and being a machinist and familiar with high reliability manufacturing, I bought them on the spot. Every one of my CK components still roll on the original bearings they came with. I imagine theres over 100000 miles on my CK stuff. As far as Im concerned they are a great investment and well worth the extravagant price, IF you use,maintain and keep stuff for life. I fully expect mine to outlast me. I have a small business building wheels. These are what I recommend.
@dudeonbike800
@dudeonbike800 4 жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 thanks for sharing your experience. Cup & cone are pretty bombproof and simple. But they don't have enough bling for the modern high-zoot consumer!!! I was weighing my options between Chris King and Phil Wood rear tandem hubs. I had "blown up" three Hugi hubs and one LX (big surprise) on our mountain tandem. I happened to talk to Chris at Interbike and we discussed his aluminum ring drives. I expressed concern with the fact that the he used aluminum. Chris felt very confident that his aluminum ring drives would hold up to high off road tandem torque loads. After considerable consideration, I chose Phil Wood. Then I made my second attempt of the Slickrock trail. Shortly into the ride, we split the Phil hub shell in half. Bummer! They replaced it no charge. But I've since cracked subsequent pawls and the pawl housing, so they are still not quite meeting the durability our torque demands. King is my next choice (or perhaps Rohloff with a gates belt). But interestingly, I had noticed some time ago that King switched to stainless steel ring drives! I knew Al wasn't the ideal choice. A while back I ordered a used King hub service tool from someone on Ebay who included a bunch of extra King parts. Cool thing - he included a VERY worn pair of King aluminum ring drivces! So cool to have an actual piece of King history in the shop. Little did this Ebay seller realize I had discussed those very ring drives and their design with Chris so many years ago!
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Dude On Bike Chris King claimed his aluminum ring drive will withstand 800 ft/lbs of torque I think or some other outrageous number. It might even be on their website. That's more than some race cars! Having long experience (almost as long as CK products existed) with King products and the incredible quality, Ill assume he has test data to back up these claims. But I'll still buy the stainless replacements if mine ever fail! Phil's are nice, but not like CK. Phil doesn't make their own bearings either. Nobody besides CK do that Im fairly sure. That's the big selling point for Chris King as far as Im concerned. Breaking a Hugi and a Phil Wood? That's impressive! Is this a motorized tandem?? Haha! Who's your stoker? Fabian Cancellara?
@dudeonbike800
@dudeonbike800 4 жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 Yes, King's bearings (and products in general) are something to behold. As I mentioned elsewhere, I have a damaged R45 that I cut open to expose the internals. Endless amusement. Ha! No, just a couple who love climbing the steep and challenging stuff. But thanks. We even did a few laps on Whiskeydrunk's Whiskeydrome on it. Fun stuff! PS My Dad's partner was Phil Wood's doctor back in the day, before I was old enough to know what Phil was. Bummed I missed that possible connection. Also, I had a Phil BB in the 80's (before I even knew about the above) I needed help with. So I rode my bike down to their address and simply couldn't find them. Looking for a shiny, impressive corporate building, I poked my head into some grungy old shop and asked, "You know where Phil Wood is?" "You found us!" Ha!
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Dude On Bike Are you in SJ? I'm in South SJ! My sister in law had an art studio next to Phil's shop years ago. I still use a couple Phil square taper BBs. Ive replaced the bearings once in each since the '90s so I can't complain. Every once in awhile I'm tempted to apply for a job at Phil Wood, but I'm pretty burned out machining stuff. Did it for 30 some years. I'm moving to Colorado soon and will build up a complete fab shop for my bikes and rock crawler. I'm gonna buy some big boy toys so I can build up whatever I want. I recently started to dabble in steel frame building with a friend, so the torch is lit!
@Steve-jo3cl
@Steve-jo3cl 4 жыл бұрын
BEST ENGINEER ON KZfaq !
@eddolous
@eddolous 4 жыл бұрын
“The headset bearings will never do 1 revolution in their entire life” Sam Pilgrim has entered the chat
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
Dude and his friend see like fun at the pub.
@chamkintcai9152
@chamkintcai9152 2 жыл бұрын
we can offer the biclylce sprocket and chain ,dear
@EvoRides
@EvoRides 4 жыл бұрын
Stoked to see you putting out so much great content recently Hambini. Looking forward to the new bike reveal.
@lamismavaca
@lamismavaca 4 жыл бұрын
Evo @hambini yes please show up proudly your New *Tifosi* Beast
@skpractical1613
@skpractical1613 3 жыл бұрын
kzfaq.info/get/bejne/g8eVhJmI3ZmucXk.html
@KennyInVegas
@KennyInVegas Жыл бұрын
I love my old Campy Record hubs with 9 ball bearings and a cone. I overhaul them a few times a year....still super smooth...bought new in 1988 on Mavic MA40 rims
@krzysztofsmyczynski7064
@krzysztofsmyczynski7064 4 жыл бұрын
You're the man, simply explained what's it all about.
@WowRixter
@WowRixter 4 жыл бұрын
Your technical terminology is very easy to understand. LOL Another great video
@Stelios.Posantzis
@Stelios.Posantzis 4 жыл бұрын
Great quick overview of bicycle bearings.
@nigelhanson2353
@nigelhanson2353 4 жыл бұрын
Learnt so much about bearings! brilliant detail and explanations, keep it up hambini👍
@seylonpizza9549
@seylonpizza9549 4 жыл бұрын
ඔබගේ පැහැදිලි කිරීමට ස්තුතියි.
@MrRicardoax01
@MrRicardoax01 4 жыл бұрын
This vlog was easy to understand, thanks!
@rzeckner
@rzeckner 4 жыл бұрын
Informative and entertaining as usual. Thank you.
@TheMadMagician87
@TheMadMagician87 2 жыл бұрын
Great info, thanks for the video. Not a cyclist, but still very widely applicable and well presented information. Cheers.
@SuperOCHomes
@SuperOCHomes 4 жыл бұрын
I love when you get two or more bearing books out. Looking forward to this one!
@julesmorrissey
@julesmorrissey Жыл бұрын
Another very helpful and informative video - thanks!
@jffydavy5509
@jffydavy5509 4 жыл бұрын
Thank You for an excellent explanation of ball bearings. You gave a great overview, but as you know it can get very complicated when the bearings are designed for a very specific use. In the last century, pre-2000, cartridge bearings in hubs and bottom bracket had contact seals and you could feel the drag and feel a wobble after extended use. High quality cup and cone bearings when properly adjusted felt lower in friction and with regular service gave great life. Campy used to sell replacement cups, cones and bearings(grade 25). You might want to explain bearing grades and how that affects bearing performance.
@nigelnightmare4160
@nigelnightmare4160 4 жыл бұрын
I used to change the cups & cones on my Campagnolo Record Mk1 hubs and was still using them up until the bike was stolen in 2012. Deep groove cartridge bearings are designed for HIGH SPEED applications (RPM's in the tens of thousands). Most pro riders won't get above 80 mph on alpine descents that equates to somewhere between 700-800 rpm which for a deep grooved cartridge bearing is SLOW! So at bike speeds they never warm up to normal running temp and therefore run slack.
@chrisscott8362
@chrisscott8362 4 жыл бұрын
+1 Jeff Daniels. That is my experience too. Shimano cup and cone bearings, with simple maintenance lasts lifetime. Only trouble I’ve had is CSB cartridge bearings in what was sold as “high end wheels” Maybe Shimano has a point!?
@montewiddison3610
@montewiddison3610 3 жыл бұрын
@@nigelnightmare4160 {
@apollocorbin6279
@apollocorbin6279 2 жыл бұрын
I realize it is kinda off topic but does anyone know of a good site to stream new movies online?
@jamesonjaden9776
@jamesonjaden9776 2 жыл бұрын
@Apollo Corbin flixportal xD
@Alan_Hans__
@Alan_Hans__ 4 жыл бұрын
Best techo description of a bearing that I've heard. I've also used that same techo description. Good informative video that youtube suggested to me and because it was good and well presented I'll have a gander out your other videos and potentially/probably subscribe.
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
Alan H we are awaiting to see if you subscribe or not. After all it is a piece of your soul we are talking about.
@Alan_Hans__
@Alan_Hans__ 4 жыл бұрын
I gave him a piece of my soul after watching another vid :D
@chriswilkinson4605
@chriswilkinson4605 4 жыл бұрын
Technical term it's f#cked !! Hahaha
@marcelschlebos3975
@marcelschlebos3975 4 жыл бұрын
Thanks habini Nice video explaining the difference between the bearings👍🏻
@nigelnightmare4160
@nigelnightmare4160 4 жыл бұрын
Interesting, down to earth and educational. What's not to like? Thank you
@stuartdryer1352
@stuartdryer1352 4 жыл бұрын
Demystified that nicely. Thanks!
@vythinathanduraiswamy3430
@vythinathanduraiswamy3430 Жыл бұрын
Good video for anyone looking to understand basics of deep groove ball besring vs up and one. Cyclists would love this. Tks.
@yannickokpara4861
@yannickokpara4861 4 жыл бұрын
Just gets better and better!
@ianmiller4777
@ianmiller4777 Жыл бұрын
I thought this was really clear. (Very neutral for Hambini too!). I'm sure I am not the only person who runs destroyed cup/cone angular contact bearings with a little bit of excess play (bottom bracket especially) because I don't have a spare bottom bracket spindle. I wish I new better what causes the damage to the cones. It doesn't seem to matter what I do with bearing adjustment, the cones always show pitting first. One of the great things about radial bearings is that there is no preload setting to worry about. So for sure they will wear out, but at least you are unlikely to damage them during the initial installation.
@cgwin3980
@cgwin3980 4 жыл бұрын
I replace the bearings in my Race Face BSA BB with Enduro SS angular contact bearings. I put them in the Race Face cups. Right off they were smoother and after 4 months they are working smoothly. I did pop the crank out to see if there were signs of spinning in the cups as I just pressed them in, and there was non. So a $63 upgrade to a 2 year old BB. I'm happy.
@christophergould4013
@christophergould4013 3 жыл бұрын
Very good explanation of bearing makeup uses
@aliVimtaj
@aliVimtaj 3 жыл бұрын
Awesome, thank you for an excellent explanation. 👌🙏
@skished
@skished Жыл бұрын
Very nice. Thanks you for your knowledge
@SnookiePookums9
@SnookiePookums9 4 жыл бұрын
Hey Sachin! Huge fan from Seattle. Could you please discus lubrication at length? I'd love to know what kind of grease I ought to put in my bearings and how much. Thanks!
@dudeonbike800
@dudeonbike800 4 жыл бұрын
I have a large bearing like that from an old mining town. So much fun to play with. That plus my Chris King R45 with cutouts, I can play with myself all day long!
@smokinjoe909
@smokinjoe909 3 жыл бұрын
Great video thank you for sharing. Would you recommend ceramic bearings in a 1/8 buggy?the stock steel bearings keep going bad in my wheel hubs. They offer aluminum wheel hubs that might help the bearings from flexing around corners which would possibly help save bearings from wearing out. What are your thoughts? 1/8 scale arrma talion truggy 6s running on 4s most of time. Fast eddy bearings or jims bearings offer ceramic kits. I thought about searching each size separately to see cost. Thanks for your time
@lilhavin
@lilhavin 3 жыл бұрын
I know he's speaking English but this sounds like one of those classes I dropped illicitly in high school. lol Na, seriously - this is good stuff! Kudos to you sir and thanks for the valued information!
@ShareeDesigns
@ShareeDesigns 4 жыл бұрын
Thank you for the great video.
@ryanstark2350
@ryanstark2350 Жыл бұрын
I think that cup and cone is easier to maintain and cheaper. Simpler tools to dismantle correctly. The only importent thing is to to tighten the cone just right. For this you need to secure the axle at one end to be able to gently adjust with cone spanners. It's not hard and once set up perfectly I think they perform better because there are less contacting surfaces compared to most cartridge designs and less friction. They clearly perform better in wheels that I have set up. I don't think cartridge bearings on wheels is a techical improvement at all and I think this is why Shimano and Campagnola didn't change to cartridges.
@ryanstark2350
@ryanstark2350 Жыл бұрын
I recently serviced some 30 year old Shimano hubs. New bearings and one cone had to be replaced which was still available. These wheels now perform better than new and better than much newer cartridge bearing wheels which I have.
@androzetga1916
@androzetga1916 Жыл бұрын
great explanation
@RoofRack2
@RoofRack2 3 жыл бұрын
Great presentation
@Kidtricky69
@Kidtricky69 4 жыл бұрын
Looking forward to this.
@somewhatfrog
@somewhatfrog 4 жыл бұрын
Hey Hambini, thanks for another masterclass. What do you think about Coombe pedals? I am currently using Speedplay Zero system, because of walkable cleats and better cornering clearance (riding fixed gear crits) and precise adjustability, tho even under my 59kg their bearings go shite quite fast. I also wonder if Speedplay bearings (I bet quality of those are not far from zipp's lol) can be replaced with something better.
@Antti5
@Antti5 4 жыл бұрын
In practice, my impression is that the guys using Shimano wheels or the more expensive Campagnolo (or Fulcrum) wheels with cup and cone bearings seem to have VERY little trouble with them. The modern ones are very easy to adjust with the wheel in place, and they seem to need very little maintenance. Campagnolo's cup and cone hubs have been the exact same design since the 1999 model Record hub that introduced the aluminium spindle and moved to 5/32" bearing balls, 15 per side, both front and rear. The hub shells are different wheel to wheel, for marketing purposes, but internally the only difference is that some wheels use ceramic balls, and some also ceramic bearing surfaces. These parts are all interchangeable. In 18 years of regular use, I never had any issues with these hubs. I never had to replace any parts. Meanwhile, my buddies seem to be busy getting new sets of cuntish shitbag bearings for their (insert brand here) wheels.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Yup, I still commute on 43 year old Record hubs on my single speed. Almost as smooth as new. I use old Dura Ace XTR XT hubs as well. My loose ball hubs get new balls every overhaul, before winter and after winter or any ride I submerge the cranks a lot, like some creek bed trails I do lots. High quality steel balls are cheap and overhauls take 10 minutes or so. Chris King are the ultimate if you can afford them. They make their own bearings when every other 'blingy' hub manufacturer (even at the highest end) uses bearings from various other sources. Its partly why CK is so. expensive. Theyre surgical quality and angular contact. Lots of expensive hubs use cheap Asian bearings. My Kings are 25 years old, over 100000 miles, original bearings. These are mtb hubs used hard but well maintained.But they are so well sealed, overhauling every other year is excessive! More often I just clean and lube the driver. .
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 3 жыл бұрын
Cjango Freeman Have you been to CK's factory? I wanted to take a tour in Redding CA when he was still there just to see their facility, but I'm curious how you know who they hire. I really don't care for these PC discussions at all, especially on non political channels, but you sound sorta confused or misled. Maybe King haven't been able to find skilled folks of an acceptable 'color' to fill their job REQUIREMENTS. I don't know about Kings hiring policies, who applied for their positions etc, but Portland is a pretty 'woke' city. You couldn't pay me enough to live in a place like that, but I could easily work for Chris King, because I've got skills that some folks (of any color) DONT. Some folks (of any color) have skills I don't possess making them more qualified for a particular job. Color only matters to racists (as far as I'm concerned) if you really want to discuss politics. I will always judge people on their character, words, actions and abilities. Color never comes into question. Racism goes all ways! And I've encountered racists in all sorts of people of different colors. There are wonderful folks of all colors as well as bad people. There are highly educated and skilled folks of all colors as well. We all have a choice to be fair and good or bad and racists. Having a particular skill and being competent at what one does should be the only thing that qualifies ANYone to perform a particular job. Doing said task better and faster is what makes ANYone more hireable or worth higher wages. I would never hire people according to their color. That is truly bigoted and or unfair. Its not common sense from a business and financial standpoint either. People go into business to make money, plain and simple. If you'd like to do something out of your own charity, in your personal business, that is also your choice as well. I hire those who have the skill to do something I need done. I don't care what color they are. Isn't that fair? Surgical quality is basically an engineering, manufacturing and quality process where everything is documented and traceable to its original source. Different cleanliness standards apply as well. Everyone who supplies a material, component or service to a particular device or assembly is accountable for their part. It is pretty much the highest manufacturing standard there is, since human life is in the balance, but these sorts of standards are sometimes applied to other things in varying degrees besides medical equipment. To put it simply, Where quality is concerned, you pay for what you get.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 3 жыл бұрын
Cjango Freeman Shimano hubs are really nice. I have some, quite old and still smooth. My XTRs are nearly silent! In really wet and deep water conditions Shimanos can fail. Ive had to walk out! Kings never do that. The bearings and the driver are ultra well sealed and the design of the driver can't fail pushing you forward. These arent pawls. Pawls (used in Shimsno) work good but they have certain issues when the pawls get contaminated and your hub start freewheeling in both directions! But otherwise Shimano is fine as long as you maintain them. I had Shimano and Campy for years, I saw a disassembled King hub at a shop and bought it right there. That was 23 years ago and I still hammer on that wheel. I'm a machinist. I recognize quality and sound design, I had the cash and I knew about their headsets. It was a no brainer for me. But Shimano hubs are great, they are definately the best value out of all brands. I build wheels as a small business and sell lots of Shimano. The hubs I recommend are Shimano, Campagnolo, DT and King. I was given some White Industties hubs (you'll certainly not buy these, haha!) and they built into fast track wheels! Phill Wood, Paul Components and Hope make pretty nice stuff too. But most of these companies are probably owned by white dudes so there you go!
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 3 жыл бұрын
Cjango Freeman If you ever want to discuss manufacturing, education, how greedy corporations and politicians abandoned them, I may be able to clue you in, but you'd need an open mind and an ability to think for yourself. The fact is, the skilled trades haven't been supported by public education in decades. Its easier and more profitable to buy landfill and garbage from China or hire illegals to do such 'lowly' work. I know plenty of employers who want to hire skilled tradesman, engineers etc. They try to hire QUALIFIED American citizens, REGARDLESS of their color. They can't find qualified workers of any color! Its simple as that! Right now, skilled manufacturing positions are in high demand in the US and the pay is good! Employers I know of often need to import people from overseas. Public education and the MSM have completely brainwashed many and your mindset is a pretty good example!
@stefanush
@stefanush 4 жыл бұрын
Hi there. Great work, keep it up! I have a question. Since I cant upgrade the bearings in the Shimano pressfit bb-s, is there any benefits of upgrading my cheapo bb BB-RS500-PB to SM-BB92-41B?
@bbqreunie984
@bbqreunie984 4 жыл бұрын
Thanks, again learned something.
@F1FanWoodsie28
@F1FanWoodsie28 2 жыл бұрын
Excellent explanation! I'm doing a conversion on a giant drill press that I have to turn it into a light milling machine. The bearings that are in there are deep groove (6204Z and 6201Z), but a drill press mostly has axial load. A mill, though, will mostly have radial. In that case, am I better off replacing these with angular contact bearings (especially if I might still want to drill with it)? Preferably single or double row?
@00jamiejohnson00
@00jamiejohnson00 9 ай бұрын
im here looking for the exact same answer
@markrobinson1458
@markrobinson1458 4 жыл бұрын
Interesting as usual 👍
@CodSlap
@CodSlap 4 жыл бұрын
Looking forward to this: cartridge bearings seem to be the norm on modern higher-end bikes, but I still chose to build mine using both. Going to be a good Saturday. :)
@rodpalm6398
@rodpalm6398 4 жыл бұрын
Cartridge bearings haven't been used since the 90's, WTH are you talking about? Pressed in bearings are not the same as cartridge bearings.
@CodSlap
@CodSlap 4 жыл бұрын
Rod Palm You are, of course, correct: press a loose ball bearing into a banana, and you will have a ”pressed in bearing”, possibly even a crude way of demonstrating what a prince albert is to a tipsy friend or two at the bar without being thrown out, but ultimately something that is not the same thing as a cartridge bearing. Your mileage may vary, of course. I take ’pressfit’ to just describe the way two objects are held together, or the interference fit that’s achieved when two objects of suitable shape and size are pressed together. And yes, neither of these objects have to have anything to do with a cartridge bearing. That having been said, whenever I open up my threaded BB and replace the bearings in the cups, I sure do pressfit new sealed cartridge bearings in there before I thread them back on. Maybe it’s a language thing? For me, a ’cartridge bearing’ simply denotes the metal thingamajig with all the races, bearings and seals contained within a single nifty enclosure, as opposed to e.g. loose cups, ball bearings and cones. The word can, of course, mean something completely different to you, but at least Google Image Search and Park Tool seem to be of the opinion that those pesky little donuts are used in modern bikes as well. If you have a bike with a pressfit bottom bracket that runs without cartridge bearings of any kind - more power to you! (Just as long as you’re not running lemmings in there.) And if you simply mixed up cup & cone bearings with cartridge ones in your comment - check out this small company called... erm, He-man...? Sheman? Shimano! Yeah, that was it, I think. Still producing hubs in 2019. Small little outfit. Cough. Steel bearings rolling on work-hardened steel cups, very little in the way of friction or seal drag when adjusted and lubed correctly, and seem to last well under all kinds of side loads. Easy to take apart, clean and maintain to boot. Old tech? For sure. Trendy? Hell no! But I prefer them in my wheels nonetheless. You might, of course have to lace a fresh hub once every decade or so, but I think it’s a fun exercise too. That’s WTH I’m talking about, thanks for asking politely. :)
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Rod Palm Damn dude!! What are/were you smoking? Can I have some? Do you know what most of the common ‘cartridge bearings’ (yes, most PRESS IN, but not all!) present in high end bike parts are actually designed for? They are radial contact bearings designed for electric motors. Were talking about designs made for thousands of rpm. They even spec less grease in them for thermal expansion. Hardly ideal in a bicycle type environment! They are specced as such because they’re most cost effective(read cheap), easiest to manufacture and most convenient to idiots who cant be bothered with regular maintenance. Most ‘cartridges’ , even in high end components, come from China and theyre crap! Theres a reason Chris King makes their own angular contact ‘cartridge’ bearings,even the balls!(who else does that?) Theres a reason why they cost what they do. They are designed to be serviced not thrown away. My CK stuff is 16-35 years old, ridden well over 100000 miles. ALL ORIGINAL! Ive never replaced one ‘cartridge’! They run even smoother and faster then when new! Theres also a reason why Shimano and Campy still use loose ball, cup and cone, angular contact bearings. They are tried and true over decades! All they need is 15-20 minutes of simple love and care before and after every winter. I own 40 year old Record and Dura Ace hubs, still as smooth as new and used regularly. Please pay a little attention to the upcoming video. Maybe do a little research beforehand so you can understand the terms being used. Please understand what press fit means and the tolerances involved and required. Its all in the machinery handbook, a common source of info for machinists, engineers and designers. You’re bound to learn something! Maybe youre confused with ‘cartridge’ type bottom brackets. Those are still used on less expensive bikes. (I wrench in a shop!) It just means that bearings, cups and sometimes the spindle are integrated into one unit. Some bike companies are pulling their heads out of their asses and returning to common sense threaded designs. Press fit BBs were/are a shit design, once again designed for the bottom line, profits and manufacturability to the cost and frustration of unknowing consumers. Pressfit shit creates far more problems than those it never solved. You cant beat ‘newer’ Shimano outboard bearing BBs! But once again, I have perfectly functional, really old loose ball units. Check out a Sugino 75 Super Lap bb. Probably the smoothest bb on the market, using an old square taper spindle! Once again, an angular contact design!!
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
@@rodpalm6398 yea fuck you rod palm.
@rabishop4684
@rabishop4684 4 жыл бұрын
Excellent explanation. For clarity of younger viewers it would have been useful to show a proper cup-and -cone wheel bearing (say). I don't think any manufacturer still use cup and cone bottom bracket bearings. I think the reason Campagnolo and Shimano still use cup and cone bearings is that they can be adjusted for wear and give minimum friction due to being cage-less. I'm guessing that to accurately machine and grind the cup and cone in bearing quality steel and then assemble and adjust them would be more labor intensive and more expensive than banging in a couple of preparatory ball races in. Some National Time Trail champions I was lucky enough to ride with as a Junior, (in the early 1960's) used to polish their wheel bearings every week. They also polished their chains usually on a Saturday afternoon while watching sport on the BBC's Grandstand. They assembled the bearings dry in order to get the adjustment with just a hint of shake, then lubricate them with 3-in-one light machine oil. And as a keen youngster I did the same. Riding out on a silent Sunday morning you could hear each unloaded ball drop into place. That is if you could hear them above the rasp of your tubulars at 130 psi pressure on the tarmac. Happy days. Only criticism is I don't like the superfluous swearing.
@hodgo1981
@hodgo1981 3 жыл бұрын
with regards to bottom brackets, Wheels manufacturing sell angular contact cartridge bearings as an "upgrade" I've considered buying these, and this hambini video is part of my research.
@NirreFirre
@NirreFirre 4 жыл бұрын
Great one! Perhaps a little extra fact about probably Sweden's largest industrial pride, SKF, could be worth noting: "Assar Gabrielsson, SKF sales manager and Björn Prytz, Managing Director of SKF were the founders of Volvo AB in 1926. In the beginning, the company functioned as a subsidiary automobile company within the SKF group. SKF funded the production run of the first thousand cars, built at Hisingen in Gothenburg, beginning in 1927. SKF used one of the company's trademarked names: AB Volvo, which derives from the Latin "I roll", with its obvious connotations of bearings in motion."
@paulb9769
@paulb9769 Жыл бұрын
I actually enjoy doing my cup and cone hubs. My biggest question is what bearings to get Chrome Steel, Carbon Steel or Stainless Steel or Ceramic Ball Bearings Si3N4 Silicon Nitride vs ZrO2 Zirconium Oxide. I have plenty of Chrome Steel G25 but thinking there is a better option what is your view?
@d095205300
@d095205300 3 жыл бұрын
Good information, thank you. I have a concern with trying to convert a 6304 to a sealed tapered roller bearing. Is this possible? I can't seem to find the correct bearing online if it exists.
@SCWgreg
@SCWgreg 4 жыл бұрын
So factory set up with my 2017 Cannondale CAAD12 has a PF BB30, 4000 miles In the first year, and I’ve had it serviced twice for the dreaded CREAK, needs a third now. I don’t wash the bike, but do wipe it down, so the bearings are rarely subjected to water. Very hilly/mountainous area where we ride. I’m contemplating switching out to a Chris King BB that is angular contact. Reviews are good in terms of solving the creak. Will I notice the friction then in terms of watts? How much more likely then will service and/or replacement be needed? Stick with radial? Go Angular? Better Hambini BB solution?
@tristano1998
@tristano1998 3 жыл бұрын
My big question hasn‘t been answered by this presentation, that is: Is it better to use an angular contact bearing in a Bottom bracket than a radial one? Like Wheels manufacturing is promoting it? When i understood correctly, the AC bearing produces more friction - but can take axial loads better. So more friction is bad in the BB. But what about the axial load? How much axial load gets the BB, or in other words, what are the angles of load applied to the crank spindle and thus the bearings and what is their typical direction? Would have liked those questions to be answered. Strange to me that a „BB specialist“ like you are excluding especially this very important part?
@dezwhip
@dezwhip 4 жыл бұрын
Hi everybody, I have some experience to share with you. I hope in doing so maybe I can help the good and mechanically sound products not to disappear entirely from the market, which currently seems to be the trend. Actually I understand this is a hopeless endeavor but at least I’m doing what I can... Mr Hambini, in the end I have treat for you. :) I was working as a bike messenger in Stockholm Sweden for 7 years (but this was 10 years ago). This job really deals a lot of punishment to the bike, probably much more than most people would think. The first few years I trashed several bikes and especially a lot of wheels. Then I learned what works. This is my experience: Bear in mind, because of my professional history I might be overly focused on reliability, over characteristics needed for competition. However I want my bikes to be as fast as possible, just without sacrificing functionality. What works and is price competitive, is older Shimano LX, XT, XTR or similar quality race standard (105, Ultegra or DA). It has to be quality above Deore and it has to be steel or titanium axle 9/10mm. Unfortunately when Shimano introduced aluminium axles, they made the bearing balls smaller and thus decreased bearing life by more than 90% (I'm not exaggerating!). I could also detect fatigue damage on the aluminium axles, on steel or titanium axles I never saw that. Sadly, almost all of these good solid hubs seem to be discontinued. And for what, saving a few grams? What also works very well is Phil Wood hubs, if you can stand the weight and price. The Phil hub has very long lasting cartridge bearings that can be replaced and the hub itself will last FOREVER! They are absolutely bomb proof. I think in the aftermath of a nuclear war, mutant cockroaches will somehow move around on Phil Wood hubs… To summarize, my tip for long lasting hubs in demanding conditions, is above Shimano for gears and Phil Wood for high end SS/fixed. Beware though, to get good value out of older Shimano you have to have some knowledge about setup and maintenance, this is crucial. Factory build wheels might work for racing but not for messaging. I’ve tried a couple, and they both failed to scraps after only a couple of salty winter months. Carefully hand build wheels with 32 or 36 J bend spokes is the only wheels I trust. Finally for BB, square taper is the most long lasting and generally reliable BB standard. It is also very available and adaptable for chain line or clearance issues. Integrated systems might be stiffer and lighter but for hardwearing all weather workhorse bikes they are just no good. And I would never even try the press fit systems, for me they just scream trouble! So mr Hambini, if you actually red through all of my text. Maybe you with your great mechanical understanding and engineering skills could be inspired to make an in depth analysis on one or two square taper BB’s compared to modern integrated systems. To my knowledge the best cheap square taper BB option would be Shimano UN55 and the best high end option a Phil Wood BB. These BB’s are also very well known in this realm of the bike community. That would certainly be very interesting for the likes of me and I think a lot of touring people and hardcore commuters. Even if you did a three hour video on it I’d be sitting like glued to the computer sucking up knowledge. Maybe you’ll also see the light and then increase your business with some intelligently made square taper BB’s. :) Cheers everyone! /deswhip
@loopie007
@loopie007 4 жыл бұрын
I think this will be intresting for the review of how bearings designed for radial load vs axial load will "stack up" to each other. When and where is a good time to use each, and examples in the real world of larger environments and possibly smaller.
@harmony01ful
@harmony01ful 2 жыл бұрын
Hi Hambini in a roll down test same bike and rider and tyres etc how much faster are one type of bearings over another . Have you got a long hill handy and a stopwatch handy? I have seen tests for tyre pressure done this way to prove a point cheers .
@mikeywikeybikey
@mikeywikeybikey 4 жыл бұрын
If only a manufacturer would sell a bike that addressed all of the factors you discuss. Seems like most bikes do one element well and another terribly. Looking forward to seeing where you spent your money.
@cosinus_square
@cosinus_square 4 жыл бұрын
What do you think about the SKF MTRX bearings? Sounds like the same idea as oilite bushes, lubricant suspended in porous material. What about servicing? Throw away when bad?
@EduardoNakiri
@EduardoNakiri 7 ай бұрын
Great ! That is what I was looking for... Thanks for the explanation ! But one question still remains: orientation to mount angular bearings. I think the right way to mount it is the same orientation like shimano's cup and cone, right ? But I won't risk to "break" the bearing when removing it ? I mean, to remove it, I'll have to push it from the center (in to out). This force won't risk to dismantle the bearing itself ? Thanks !
@wandered_art
@wandered_art 4 жыл бұрын
Quesetion about the cages. For old style cup and cones, I was always taught to replace cages with loose bearings for increased efficiency. What is the issue with contact? Do you recommend cages for nonsealed cup and cone bearings?
@drewcama5481
@drewcama5481 4 жыл бұрын
Thank you, I understood this much better..... So a cup and cone bearings for my headset and bottom bracket and a cartridge bearing for everything else? Only had to play it back once!
@mrkim3257
@mrkim3257 4 жыл бұрын
Not particularly bike related but in pairing up angular contact bearing in say a machine spindle application, these bearings are mounted in various ways, i.e back to back, or face to face or a mixed triple etc. You've explained clearly that an acb is best used to deal with axial load and it does so by transfering forces occurring down the length of a shaft and therefore the bearing's inner race, through preload balls, and into the bearing's outter race and housing.....phew! But I have a drilling machine (think expensive drill press) that was given to me in pieces. It has paired angular contact bearings for the bottom of it's spindle. Now of course in this application, considering that an operator would necessarily be applying a heavy axial load via a lever upon the spindle, axial load is the main focus. But, if you wish to drill a nice 'round' hole, then radial accuracy must run a close second. So my question is, how are these bearings best paired? As I see it, if they are paired back to back in order to counter axial loads both down and up the spindle, the preload shims would need to be placed at opposite ends the paired bearings. But to my mind, the most support is being offered over the shotest length of spindle with a back to back arrangement and I therefore question how this would benefit radial accuracy? On the other hand, mounting the bearings face to face with preload shims between would 'seem', (once again to my mind) to offer a little more radial support by increasing the distance between the outter races? Then of course I could be over thinking because I just don't actually 'know', and perhaps the best option in this application is to ignore axial force up the spindle because load is low withdrawing a drill out of material, and don't worry about radial load....just because, and pair the bearings from the bottom of the spindle, face to back, with preload shims placed between and on top of the upper most bearing, thus both bearings then addressing axial force applied down the spindle only??? Have I even got the concept right? Forgive the pun, but as you can see, the pairing of acb's has me spinning in circles 😮
@justinwbohner
@justinwbohner 4 жыл бұрын
There was a lack of perspective here on the hertzian stress involved. You said the angular have less stress, but does it matter? Bicycle bottom brackets don't see very much load I don't think compared to their rating, so the stress would be relatively low. Radial bearings become angular bearings when preloaded, so the matter to be decided is if it is worth it to endure the lower sealing ability and higher drag vs the lower stress and possibly longer race life, but I'd like to see the numbers. It seems to me that bearings fail in this application because of contamination and/or corrosion so sealing would be a priority.
@HyperbeastXion
@HyperbeastXion 4 жыл бұрын
I know this is an older video, but if i got this right. IF I buy a pair of 7808 bearings and i want to but them in my bottom bracket, are they directional? i mean due to the construction of the bearings there is basically a right and a left one?
@psycsy
@psycsy 4 жыл бұрын
Speaking of Shimano sticking with "old" style bearings. What do you think about some bike companies using threaded bbs instead of press fit? As always great vid
@mrGTD170
@mrGTD170 4 жыл бұрын
Do you actually make BSA bottom brackets? I have read some teams at TDF (i think bora) went back to BSA bottom brackets.
@Snoochies
@Snoochies 3 жыл бұрын
Is there available an angular contact bearing from a reputable manufacturer that would fit in a standard 30mm ID bottom bracket (30x42x7)? I've searched near and far and all I've come up with is the 7806C from NTN but it isn't sealed, and the Enduro offering.
@glennoc8585
@glennoc8585 4 жыл бұрын
I used to have shimano cup and cone and they always spun smoothly and lasted a long time. I adjusted often to keep play at bay. As mentioned often the preload is terrible on cup and cone.
@brotherhood42
@brotherhood42 4 жыл бұрын
I have a guy that rides his mountain bike hard and frequently wears out his rear hubs. I would assume the fact he launches his bike a lot creates bearing issues, but would moving him to an angular contact bearing help with premature failure due to the heavy axial loads being put on a mtn rear hub? Otherwise, is it a 6 of one type situation?
@andrewnelson3276
@andrewnelson3276 4 жыл бұрын
What are your thoughts on the new SKF MTRX bearings? I am mostly interested in bearings that last in wet and muddy conditions.
@Hambini
@Hambini 4 жыл бұрын
These are skf marine bearings in bike sizes. The technology is proven. The issue for road use is the drag
@woduk
@woduk 4 жыл бұрын
What bearings are you using Andrew? Bearings in my hope hubs last ages and I ride mtb in all weathers. Heard hope use INA bearings seem good compared with some I’ve used before
@woduk
@woduk 4 жыл бұрын
Click Bait yes where appropriate I’ve been using a thicker grease Mobil xhp 222 on outside of bearing seals to help waterproof them seems to work so far
@thomaslutro5560
@thomaslutro5560 4 жыл бұрын
​@Click Bait And don't pay perfume prices for a degreaser that will just break down the surface tension between grease and water, turning everything into a rust coloured chili mayonaise-like emulsion....
@dizzolve
@dizzolve 3 жыл бұрын
Nice video. I know a decent amount about bearings ....... and I learned something here. sub'd
@mikeyseibert1406
@mikeyseibert1406 Жыл бұрын
I know this is an older video. But for bmx racing would you recommend a bearing with fewer but bigger balls or more smalller balls?
@hedleykerr3564
@hedleykerr3564 4 жыл бұрын
Great presentation very easy to understand and great analogy's! In the future could you give us your thoughts on lubricants for chains specifically waxing vs. synthetic lubes! Again thank you for your time and explaining things to us!
@bbqreunie984
@bbqreunie984 4 жыл бұрын
Good question. Indeed what kind of lubrication for any application or sort of bearing. Anyway if you mean bearings... Probably you mean the lubrication of chains.....?
@Hambini
@Hambini 4 жыл бұрын
I'll add this to my growing list of requests.
@hedleykerr3564
@hedleykerr3564 4 жыл бұрын
@@bbqreunie984 yes thanks!
@ogden99
@ogden99 4 жыл бұрын
@hambini what do you think to SKF MTRX solid oil bearings?
@trevekneebone369
@trevekneebone369 4 жыл бұрын
I was wondering this too, given the coverage of the Cane Creek bottom brackets at Euro Bike this week.
@patcaballero6513
@patcaballero6513 4 жыл бұрын
hi hambini! great show! what's your take on placing bearing (not just bike cartridges, but any industrial bearing) by hitting it with a metal hammer?
@Hambini
@Hambini 4 жыл бұрын
Bad idea
@fieldlab4
@fieldlab4 4 жыл бұрын
I've always been surprised no one uses a tapered cartridge bearing in a BB. Decades ago, Bullseye had a combination BB that used a needle bearing. There have been tapered needle bearing headsets. Angular contact can potentially be loaded up with more ball bearings, depending on if the radial bearing has a notch for loading. Can you talk about how bearings are assembled, why there is a limit on number of balls, and if notches are used? Cup and cone bearings, *good ones* like old campy bearings can use *much larger* balls and races than cartridge. If cup and cone bearings are made to the same standards and hardness of cartridge bearings, they are every bit as good. The cage also keeps the balls from accumulating all on one side so the *bearing actually comes apart!*
@jonathanpalmer5505
@jonathanpalmer5505 4 жыл бұрын
Thanks for another well thought out and presented tutorial. Can you persuade Shimano to sell full service kits for the axial bearings? I don't understood the point of just replacing the cone, balls and axle (which is what they seem to sell) as the cup always looks as worn as the cone.
@Hambini
@Hambini 4 жыл бұрын
I think I have as much chance of persuading them as pinning diahorrhea to a wall
@Greenjuiceman
@Greenjuiceman 3 жыл бұрын
excellent - thank you
@gurdeepkumar6177
@gurdeepkumar6177 Жыл бұрын
It's too good info video 🙏
@MrDazP1adv3ntures
@MrDazP1adv3ntures 4 жыл бұрын
Nicely explained Hambini. Could you discuss the aircaft spec "stepped bearings" which Whyte mtb bikes use on their suspension frames with the spacer washers in the assembley housing. loving the the techinal nomencalture of what a F#cked bearing is.
@philadams9254
@philadams9254 4 жыл бұрын
Another Saturday night of science! Nerds unite!
@robertkujawa3504
@robertkujawa3504 4 жыл бұрын
Hambini, would you say that bigger balled bearings (angular, cup&cone) have greater longevity than smaller balled bearings? Or is that too broad a statement? Anyway, thank you for quality content, I found it easy to follow and understand!
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
This is interesting because the Ultegra hubs use larger balls than the DuraAce.
@Manetty6
@Manetty6 4 жыл бұрын
3:25 the exception is that most of the cheap bikes comes with the cup and cone stuff. At the lower end, which is the mass of the bikes are cup&cone.
@benrutherford4487
@benrutherford4487 2 жыл бұрын
How can you tell which side is the "face" and which side is the "back" ? - it seems i get a different answer from everyone i ask- is the back the side with the wide inner race lip? Or the wide outer race lip?
@user-cq2lb2gb6f
@user-cq2lb2gb6f 4 жыл бұрын
On 12:26, where you resolving force to axial+radial. Did you mean the force from the spokes, or force, that wheel under different conditions (turning, etc) may produce? Because resting wheel will not put any force on bearings, except the weight of the wheel. For vertically resting wheel this will be only radial force.
@thomasvmanning
@thomasvmanning 3 жыл бұрын
@Hambini, I've asked this before, this time I promise I'll remember. What kind of pencil do you use here?
@Hambini
@Hambini 3 жыл бұрын
Kuru toga
@wammo12345
@wammo12345 4 жыл бұрын
Thanks Hambini, this was great! Over the years I've serviced lots of kids bikes and found that often the wheel cup and cone bearings are poorly set up from new, almost always over tightened. I've often wondered if the bearings are somewhat ruined almost immediately. A clean, re-grease and correct adjustment improves them significantly but I do wonder if the components were actually manufactured well, or whether it is just poor assembly of reasonably good parts.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Geekboy NZ Yes, poor assembly is the main problem, but also cheap Chinese manufacturing using sub par parts and materials and CHEAP LABOR. Much of this junk cant even be repaired and made safe FOR CHILDREN, just like many other Chinese toys and products. YOU (or your loved ones) WILL PAY for what you GET! One way or another! So many people want to cheap out on THEIR CHILDREN’S/significant others bikes! Kind of weird, don’t you think? I wrench in a high end bike shop. But I have to deal with this junk on a daily basis. I can take just about any Asian assembled bike, cheap to highest end and find examples of shoddy, sub par workmanship. It is EXTREMELY RARE to encounter a perfectly assembled bike, like how a trained professional would do so. It is always cause for celebration and a beer break!! We thoroughly assemble, inspect, tune and correct all pre assembled bikes BEFORE they leave my store. We have a 3 step quality process to ensure our customers safety and satisfaction! There MUST be a quality process because there is little to NONE in Asian bike manufacturing. In the larger bike industry, the bottom line is the main concern. NOT in my business! I wouldn’t be able to look myself in the mirror! The FACT is most of these assemblers, in Asia or elsewhere are paid by the unit, NOT the hour. Think about that awhile! Department store bikes are the worst, both quality and assembly wise. Theyre usually assembled by those with little to no training or bike experience. Theyre frequently high school kids who just dont know any better. We sometimes have to turn down working on these bikes for liability reasons! We offer free maintenance classes every week. I want people to learn to take care of their own bikes, be a little more independent and at least avoid walking back or that phone call of shame! EVERY bike Ive owned was immediately taken home, disassembled and resembled properly.Before I ever rode it. That way I know I can trust MY LIFE with my bike! All of my personal bikes now are custom built from frame up. These habits started with my father and my grandfather showing me how to build and fix things. They always bought our bikes in a box, completely disassembled. They also told me if I didnt learn to maintain and repair my bikes, I’d have to walk! Talk about motivation!!
@allthingsTechrelated
@allthingsTechrelated 4 жыл бұрын
RollinRat well said. Halfords assembled my new bike a few years ago. The bike was dangerous, As I quickly found out on the first ride when I held the back brake and the bike almost did a U-turn.
@dudeonbike800
@dudeonbike800 4 жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 we're birds of a feather... The reality of kids bikes is that the additional cost of proper, loving assembly raises the cost beyond "being competitive." The American consumer is so obsessed with saving a dollar, they don't realize "you get what you pay for." And to be honest, it's hard to justify spending more money on something either outgrown quickly, abused, or lost/stolen. The reality is unfortunate. And lower price usually means more kids get to actually own and ride bikes, which is a good thing overall. But trust me, I get it. I just spent 10 hours rebuilding a resident's piss-poorly assembled Schwinn so it was safe and actually enjoyable to ride. Donated a lot of my time, but it was worth it to make it right.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Dude On Bike When I was a kid and even later when I became a hardcore cyclist I never had all these problems of 'modern' bikes. And Im not only referring to cheap bikes. Some high end race bikes are a sad joke too. Hell, one of my Schwinn Varsities was my 1st mountain bike a decade before anybody knew what an mtb was! We pounded the hell out of those bikes! I believe corporate greed and bottom line considerations are the big difference between then and now. When the MTB boom happened, the bicycle industry changed for the worse. I watched as my country gave up our manufacturing power!! This all happened during my career. Slowly as we have allowed other countries to do our 'dirty work', our expectations of quality have surely lowered. Before that, only cheap department store bikes were made in China! Even all the Schwinn Stingrays and Varsities I rode as a kid were made in the US. They weren't fancy, but they were solid and safe. I just can't say that about many 'budget' bikes today, not to mention many much more expensive bicycles. NOW LOOK where our reliance on China has gotten us! I'll never ever forget George Bush's speech on the global economy and how our jobs might need to change! Now skilled machinists and tradesmen are in high demand! Ive been a machinist and mechanical inspector for over 30 years. Ive had a side business building wheels and repairing bikes most of those years. Now in my retirement, I've wrenched in a high end shop for 5 years. Because I love it! I teach our free maintenance class! In my career Ive built insanely expensive high reliability products for spacecraft, aircraft, medical devices and defense hardware. The kind of stuff human lives rely on. I don't consider my customers, friends, family or myself any less important.
@harmony01ful
@harmony01ful 2 жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 Hi I worked for a bike company in the land of Kangaroos I saw frames for childrens bikes literally fall apart on the production line way scary I vowed to never buy that brand if i ever had a child. The frames were stuck together somewhere in asia lugged steel frames with terrible brazing back in the 80,s . I was riveting mudguard with a scary press keep those pinkies clear. Good quality childrens bikes are very much worth while , a rebuild repaint and good for many years of service if second hand . I volunteered at a place that taught people to rpair their own bikes.
@richantonio8766
@richantonio8766 4 жыл бұрын
Would love to see you do a video on Disc vs Rim brakes, from an aero perspective.
@Steve-jo3cl
@Steve-jo3cl 4 жыл бұрын
NOt just a aero persprective but performance perspective as well, Brakes are only as good as the person operating the lever
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
@@Steve-jo3cl Disc brakes have greater stopping power. What needs to be addressed is the effect of disc brakes vs rim brakes on time going up and back down a tour de france climb. It will be the effect of time savings on the way up vs time savings on the way down. With disc brakes you can stay off the brakes for longer and pass opponents on the way down the switchbacks. With each switchback and each hairpin turn you make time up on the descent. Watch the tour de france stage 19 of this year.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
The Rant No shit! I wrench in a shop. I replace far more rear pads and rotors, no matter disc or rim brakes than front pads. It seems 1/2 of riders dont know what the front brake is for or theyre afraid to use it! (theyre mostly roadies!) Learning how to set up your brakes for best performance is another issue. Im still happy with cantis and v brakes on a few of my bikes and I mostly ride with loads offroad. Besides, you go faster when you dont touch them! Peter Sagan could slay us all on a department store bike!! I say learn to use what you have until its ‘slowing you down’. Haha! Just learn how to operate the freaking bike!! Disc brakes may be great stoppers but the average, fair weather everyday rider doesnt REALLY NEED them! Or the complications or expense! Most road mechanical discs are worse than calipers, that is a fact! I work in this industry. This is a marketing gimmick to sell new bikes. Plain and simple.
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 I believe disc brakes have a greater stopping power. Additionally breaking with calipers on carbon rims produces shit stopping force not to mention carbon rims in wet weather. There has not been sufficient investment in brake pad materials for carbon rims. Those blue pads are the best we got.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Josh Gross If you gotta have carbon rims, then yeah. I see failed carbon rims all the time. Just as many as metal. Theres LOTS more metal rims in the world. Think about that awhile. Caliper and disc types, carbon and metal all fail in different ways. Just be warned: I used to machine and inspect carbon satellite components. Ive seen how its laid up and produced properly, safely and responsibly. Inspection, (QC or in our case QUALITY ASSURANCE) was a HUGE part of the process! Its very expensive and time consuming. Ive built and inspected all sorts of high reliability devices in my 33 year career. Things that human lives and multi millions rely on. Are cyclist’s lives any less valuable? I know just a little about engineering, testing and quality manufacturing. I wrench in a high end shop now, for fun and laughs. Ive cut up crashed and damaged carbon stuff to inspect layup and quality. I wont be buying any carbon! Not unless I personally know those who build it! Its very apparent there is little to no QC happening in Asia! Im not the only one making such claims. Maybe my standards are too high, but I believe human life is something to be taken seriously. Ive messed around with bikes for 50 years. In that time Ive seen less than a dozen steel bikes that couldnt be repaired. In just 4 years wrenching in a shop, Ive seen dozens of plastic frames relegated to the dumpster!! If you’re racing, carbon might be worth the risk, but just for race day, otherwise I can’t recommend it.
@thebelly925
@thebelly925 4 жыл бұрын
What wheels use the best bearings from the factory?
@johnparedes5670
@johnparedes5670 Жыл бұрын
Is it true that radial cartridge bearings will also have the tiniest bit of play because the balls need a bit of float in the groove? I have Paul hubs with the enduro 61902 bearings in them and they had tiny play from the start (on the bike) and was told that’s the reason.
@Hambini
@Hambini Жыл бұрын
yes it's the C rating of the bearing
@GeekonaBike
@GeekonaBike 4 жыл бұрын
Is the lack of Roller bearings in bikes also a cost issue or is it more the difficulty of adjusting the correct amount of preload? I'm mainly thing about headsets.
@glennoc8585
@glennoc8585 4 жыл бұрын
Somebody was doing needle roller bearings fir some headsets a few years back.
@thetimkatt819
@thetimkatt819 4 жыл бұрын
Do you think oil filled polymer bearings like SKF MTRX will extend the life of the bearing when used in environments where risk of contamination is high? I'm thinking mountain biking in wet and muddy conditions.
@Hambini
@Hambini 4 жыл бұрын
They came out of the marine industry so it's not a new technology. It has been proven there so I see no issues in it working on a bike.
@WowRixter
@WowRixter 4 жыл бұрын
Besides the ball bearing tolerance of the better bearings, NTN, etc are the cages, races, etc better than a common Enduro bearing?
@Hambini
@Hambini 4 жыл бұрын
Yes. The cages in cheap bearings are usually snap in plastic cages
@milybanily
@milybanily 4 жыл бұрын
Waiting !!!!!
@MechaUsagi
@MechaUsagi Жыл бұрын
At 12:16 you have two blue arrows showing force being applied to the upper part of the vbearings. Shouldn' these arrows be pointing at the lower part of the bearings? When weight (of the bike and rider) is applied from above, it's the lower part of the circle of the bearing that hold the weight up.
@SR-fm1ft
@SR-fm1ft 4 жыл бұрын
What do you think of the Zipp 454 wheels? Maybe a good video topic analyzing the wheels.
@jasonstroden7317
@jasonstroden7317 4 жыл бұрын
He has mentioned them in previous videos. He does not think highly of them, because the humpback shape doesn't improve the aerodynamics. Air doesn't have the density needed to make the system work as it is marketed, you need something with the density of water for it to work. The 454 is slower than a 404, but I think still faster than Flo wheels.
@Hambini
@Hambini 4 жыл бұрын
If you have a look at the engineering masterclass in bike wheels video. They are addressed in there
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
They are fraudulent wheels.
@mtdtechh
@mtdtechh 2 жыл бұрын
Would AC or DG be better for bicycle pivots on a full suspension bike?
@Hambini
@Hambini 2 жыл бұрын
deep groove
@PeakTorque
@PeakTorque 4 жыл бұрын
In my orifice we have a never ending debate about preload for dg bb... SKF guidelines are somewhat arbitrary on the subject and empirical. In bike hubs we often see dg bb just locked on the inner races by tube spacers/shoulders with no preload. I guess this is to satisfy the people that say 'they spin up well' and are baffled by a spinning wheel with no load. I prefer hubs with angular contact or dg bb with some preload function. What's your view? The last set of tune hubs i bought, come with a selection of 100 micron shims to set preload. Nice touch.
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
Tune is garbage. TheDarkInstall will verify that.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Peak Torque What is dg bb? Ive never heard that before.
@joshgross8741
@joshgross8741 4 жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 Deep Groove Ball Bearing. Please try to keep up.
@rollinrat4850
@rollinrat4850 4 жыл бұрын
Josh Gross Sorry. Did my question offend you again? I thought we’re all here to share info. Ive worked with engineers. All the acronyms go over my head. I just kinda tune out. Besides that I love wasting space in these comment sections. But thanks for the answer!
@bobqzzi
@bobqzzi 4 жыл бұрын
Do you think there is an argument for using angular contact bearings on mountain bike wheels given the greater axial loads?
@dudeonbike800
@dudeonbike800 4 жыл бұрын
No, there's a good argument for using angular contact bearings on ALL bikes! Plus, think of a fully rigid road bike with 28c tires at 120 psi bashing into/over/through a concrete or asphalt pothole versus a full suspension mountain bike's 2.3" tires at 15psi hitting much softer soil. The difference in conditions couldn't be larger. That said, it would be interested to measure peak forces endured in each scenario. Either way, all bikes benefit from angular contact bearings because of their larger contact areas and adjustability. Once play develops in a radial cartridge bearing, you pull and replace it. Not so with cup and cone and hubs like Chris King. Adjustability translates to longer life.
@jaladars
@jaladars 4 жыл бұрын
Is it worth to by grade 10 ball bearings for higher end wheels like shimano 105 , ultegra or even for the lower end ? Or stick with weldtite which is grade 1000 clearly rubbish. If the answer is yes where should I buy them ? Stainless or high carbon steel ?
@averagelife5523
@averagelife5523 4 жыл бұрын
Aladar Somogyi i have the same question
@dudeonbike800
@dudeonbike800 4 жыл бұрын
Yes. Absolutely. This is an upgrade I make whenever overhauling a cup and cone bearing. It's a waste of time to go to the trouble of rebuilding it with high quality grease and proper assembly with anything below grade 25. But remember, if the races are really cheap, pitted or not properly oriented, it won't matter. Bearings only last when they're properly mounted in a faced head tube and bottom bracket shell. Or a hub being clamped into a frame with bent dropouts. Or a hub with a bent or damaged axle.
Angular Contact Bearing Preload and Bearing Internal Clearance
17:42
Master Mechanical DESIGN
Рет қаралды 10 М.
Dynamic #gadgets for math genius! #maths
00:29
FLIP FLOP Hacks
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
어른의 힘으로만 할 수 있는 버블티 마시는법
00:15
진영민yeongmin
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
Bearings and Preload Explained #bearings #engineering
20:20
Peak Torque
Рет қаралды 30 М.
The truth about cup and cone bearings
18:58
Fred's Shed
Рет қаралды 19 М.
Bearings 101 Bearing Types and Numbering System
10:28
Emerson Bearing
Рет қаралды 185 М.
DT Swiss get Completely RINSED BY 9Velo Wheels Ratchet Hub
27:14
PROFESSIONAL Bike Tools! That Bike shops Don't have!
17:30
Hambini
Рет қаралды 108 М.
Anti-Friction Bearings
8:22
Laney Machine Tech
Рет қаралды 270 М.
Подшипники скольжения и качения
27:32
Дефектоскопия
Рет қаралды 31 М.
Angular contact ball bearing/ AC bearings/contact bearing
8:07
Gopal Study Studio
Рет қаралды 3,9 М.
Aero Bike Wheel Buyers Guide | By an Engineer
21:32
Hambini
Рет қаралды 168 М.
Самый смешной футбольный матч #shorts
0:37
Медведев сгорел из-за решения судьи #shorts
0:47
100% Disrespectful Moments 😥
0:24
Naples90
Рет қаралды 15 МЛН
When Players Knew They'd Lose 😢
0:23
Flush
Рет қаралды 1,5 МЛН
Street Football Skills
0:24
1 Minute Footy
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
Ronaldo Rare Moments #9
0:20
MaxianFootball
Рет қаралды 1,6 МЛН