CHINA To DISNEY: "I Know My Place! It Is Time You Learned Yours!" Check Out My Review of Mulan 1998 If You Like - kzfaq.info/get/bejne/e52Xfa5exLy7Z30.html

Disney tried to make Mulan more realistic by making it less realistic... ... logic😒

how realistic can it get if there is a shape-shifting witch, a phoenix and someone who has superpowers.

The 1998 animated version is more realistic than the 2020 live action version.

You know what's sad? When the executives behind these live-action movies try and figure out why it failed, they're probably gonna blame it on the streaming platform

Every day, they trip, they stumble, they fall. But blame others for their fall, never realizing they could just tie their shoelace!

I hope they'd stop giving the excuse that its "more realistic". come to think of it, if anything, the original animated movie is more realistic than this live remake.

If they wanted to have qi in this, they should have had her learn about qi from some wizard while she was in the army - not already be proficient in it from birth.

Disney: "so lets make a realistic version of The Ballad of Mulan, an icon in chinese culture, without a single chinese writer, director or anyone chinese except the cast"

Disney: this is realistic version you guys. Also Disney: sets up chi and power levels straight out of dragon ball Z. Also also Disney: adds a magical phoenix. Also also also Disney: adds a witch who has actual magical powers.

Disney will never learn.

*Disney:* we made a film on one of your legends China, hope you love it! *China:* why is this English? *Also China:* these costumes are actually 1000 years difference from Mulan’s time period” 🙊 *Also China:* why is mulan growing up in a ‘土楼’ South Chinese Architecture when Mulan is from North China and during that period north and south China were effectively 2 separate countries”🤭 *Also China:* why did you bastardise the Chinese concept of Qi like it’s something out of Star Wars? We don’t even like Star Wars”😅 *Also China:* How you spend $200m dollars to pander to us but do no research”. 😒

For any idiot that says they were trying to be more "realistic" with this version, I live and work in China, and I've read the original poem. No shapeshifting witches, no chi (qi) and Mulan also NEVER SHOWED THAT SHE WAS A WOMAN!!! In the original poem, she hid her identity the entire time she was in the military. It wasn't until she had left service and gone home when some of the soldiers that had served with her visited her home and she met them dressed as a woman. That was the first time anyone knew that she wasn't a man.

Bottom line: Disney sucks! Disney has become a pale shadow of it's former self--- when Walt Disney ran the show. Walt was creative and he insisted on bringing in the most creative people in the movie industry to create and tell amazing stories. they were made up of real people who were flawed characters, who worked hard to grow and they managed to do amazing amazing things in the process--- just like the rest of us! Those are the kind of characters that people can really relate to, and learn to love. Disney now has become a PC-Toxic environment that churns out lazy, easily forgettable live action adaptions of the treasured cartoon classics (that people actually liked) --- just to keep the Mouse House afloat! Disney can't resist adding in despicable identity politics that taint the original directive and destroy the message of the original beloved films. They twist the characters and turn them into a toxic mess! No one is going to thank Robot Iger for that! But hey, destroying an entire company is a small price to pay for "The ride of a lifetime"! Disney movies used to be classic entertainment for the whole family. Now, they have become fruit of the poison tree! RIP.

This Disney failure is sweeter than sweet potato

Chinese Communist Party: Even though you followed our instructions, it wasn't good enough.

Anyone who says the film was good, most likely is a paid Disney troll.

This is easily the worst Disney live action remake. Hell I would rather watch Mulan 2 by far.

You already know the Disney executives are in their offices right now going "Well, I guess our audience wasn't ready for a realistic gritty movie. They say they want something different, but the numbers don't lie."

- "A more realistic portrayal". - Doing Wu Xia acrobatics. I'm afraid they need to pick one.

Mulan 1998: You haven’t aged a day Mulan 2020: You’ve changed, and not entirely for the better

now the last airbender has a competitor

Wow it even failed in the country it was pandering too!

I’m embarrassed to say I had high hopes for Mulan. Thought they were finally going to make a good live action remake. They won’t fool me again.

Walt Disney would had never approved of these epic failure of remakes. Like Holy shit, they are *ALL* awful 😂😂😂 ....the jungle book remake was actually good tho

I wonder what classic film they're going to ruin next.

I hope the little mermaid flunks as well. Stop ruining my childhood movies!

I've hated the Disney practice since their purchase of Lucasfilm so I'm loving every minute of this. 2020 the best & worst year at the same time

Ending of the ballad og mulan: emperor wants to bang mulan, she commits suicide. There is a 2009 film made in china that actually feature these more realistic scenes....IRONIC

to me it sounds like Disney made Mulan like a standard superhero film: give her magic powers (chi) and then have a villian with magic powers she can fight at the end. Harlan Ellison a former Hollywood writer once complained that every show (in his day) was written like a cop show, even when the show is about doctors xD. i guess today the same thing is true, just with superheroes..

Dishonor on China! Dishonor on Disney!

serves you right disney

Aw man, I've always seen disney as one of the top places to be for animation. I did some studies on disneys history and it was fascinating to me that it inspired me to become an animator. So sad to see this is what has become of them. Who the hell are behind these decisions because there's starting to be a growing number of movies with the worst decisions put to film and it seems it's getting worse. Im starting to see the talk about "cuties" now. It's not just movies, I feel its every kind of entertainment people enjoy today or would categorize as men are toxic because that game or that movie. So they aim to change it by forcing a women into the roles, trash every man or at least over exaggerate how bad they are to the point it makes no sense or the attempt should have never happened. When I say bad I mean they can't compete to women and it's all the men's fault. If they're going to do that, make their own story, movie or game instead of trying to butcher what was all ready great just because they have some dumb fan made solutions that will impact politics. I hate politics or that sort of nonsense because it's got nothing to do with me but they're trying to put it in everything I like to entertainment myself with during downtime. Yeah I'm staying with manga, manwha, anime, weebtoons, novels and jrpg if that is the standard of writing from our western creators.

I have to think that "hubris" is the best word to describe Disney's current approach to audiences. They are so big, have such an iconic history, they can't fail. They can do anything they please to their audience. When a cadre has that kind of approach, and they share a social and political ideology, inevitably they will make acceptance of their ideology the objective of their efforts. In fact, that often succeeds. But not if you have the hubris to believe you can trash the basics. Disney is learning it is not too big to fail, that, indeed, bigness may contribute to failure. They are learning that the good will capital built up by through an iconic history has to some extent aged away and to a greater extent has been squandered. All by ignoring the basics, because they've forgotten what the basics are. It seems to me an open question whether Disney survives much longer, at least in its present form.

Disney: You turned them against me!! China: You have done that yourself.

when you turn your back to your core fans ... it all goes to the crapper...

''this is what happens when you sell out'' - shame on you, Disney (2)

I´m really happy it failed and I´m enjoying every second here.

The Chinese actually loved the original Disney animated film from what I heard. Accented Cinema - a Chinese youtuber - talked about Mulan and the remake in his latest video. I highly recommend it.

China already made their own Live action film in 2009, they don't need Disney's version.

It's a pity that Disney messed this up so many people were excited for this And this could have been a cash 🐄

Whoever coached Yifei's action scenes didn't tell her about "The Eye of the Tiger" or "Killer Instinct" . Her fight scenes are not convincing. She has absolutely no expression. In martial arts, when you spar, if you try and have an emotionless face, you end up getting caught. I don't know if it was the coaches, her lack of acting ability ..

Hey, you stole my thunder, I had a video titled "Disney's Mulan Reboot Failure is Now Complete" Lol

Disney needs to stop with these life action abortions and go back to the basics and make original movies again, also the fact they filmed on a Concentration Camp and thanked one of the guards in the credits is disgusting.

Thank you so much for the warning. I have refused to watch the new movie. Thanks Nomz

the original seen more realistic than this movie

The amount of people that had roasted this movie

At least the animated version got a lukewarm response in China.

They didn't even hire anyone Chinese to write the movie! They love to preach diversity, but they don't actually practice it...smh.

Best channel for covering well, anything and everything. Love hearing what you gotta say, huge fan, keep it comin brotha!

no music ... they had it coming.

"Will she be a Mary Sue"? Have I ever told you the tragedy of the Disney Star Wars sequel trilogy?

Disney failed successfully. They managed to unite the East and West in mutual hatred of one movie.

Noms, you are a Godsend! I absolutely LOVE your Mulan videos and I love laughing in the face of Disney. I don’t know why but it makes me, happy.

I never knew this video was release on my birthday last year.

I'm still mourning the loss of potential for this movie. I mean come on! How can you go wrong with Mulan? The story is bulletproof. The creators were handed a perfect on steak on a golden platter and they were like "can you send this back to the kitchen, cook it well done, extra ketchup and we'll eat it off a styrofoam plate. thx"

I hope this live-action will be a lesson that live-action remakes are a bad idea and they should never make/release anymore after this

Anomaly inc: "a message we all hated." As soon as the message ends commercial: "welcome to gopuff" HaHaHa

thank you for saying this, this needed to be said, i felt exactly the same way, way to destroy a childhood fav of mine.

And that's the issue with Disney live action remakes....they use way too much CGI and try going for this dark/edgy look😂😂😂 its like they use the same game-plan for all of them and don't realize its not working and maybe they should just stop

Does anyone of you remember the scene in GTA San Andreas in which OG Loc tries to rap in the bathroom of a burger shop followed by a costumer leaving the toilet telling Loc he sucks? This is what Disney feels like.

Mulan flopped but at least we got Mando season 2 trailer

Disney's all have to do is to come up with a new songs. From You'll Bring Honor...to A Girl Worth Fighting For. But retaining the essence of each song. New songs, new music in a way will feel the live action adaptation fresh and new. But the really tricky part was of that Mushu & the Cricket.

I'd mention the Aesop about the Shepherd and the wild goats, but Disney didn't even pander to the wild goats properly.

You know something is really bad when even China won’t eat it.

You’re the funniest KZfaqr!! Would love another fast and furious franchise rant.

My Mom Bought Me Back To See It In IMAX 28 Times…

And that's why you should never pander.

While 2050 : Frozen live action movie but no olaf & sven

The most unrealistic part of the movie is that the witch, who can shape shift, magically powerful, and had beaten Mulan half death, ended up transforming to a bird to take an arrow for Mulan...

Your video is pure gold :) I’m so glad this happened. This movie is not faithful to the message of the animated version BUT it’s FAR LESS faithful to the ballad of Mulan. Just look at what they did with the beautiful metaphor of the hares, they completely ruined its message! And it wasn’t that hard to understand! 😡

Lets get real MULAN is a rated R story about a real bad axx women who lived 1700 years ago who has a kill count of 1000 plus.. How in the hell Disney thought they can do a live 🎬 flick about HER ?? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Common Disney tried to make Mulan a Jedi or Wizard or something with a feminist undertone

Once I saw the news, I couldn’t wait for this video lmao

Im glad it failed, because atleast disney will know not to keep remaking movies

You know that Mulan 2020 is a failure when Disney's adaptation of the Lone Ranger (another failure) is a box-office success.

Looks like Disney sees, what it means if you have two polit commissars from different ideologies to please.

So Disney remade, 'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon'?

It does not stay true to the original ballad. It actually goes opposite to the original message. Mulan was an ordinary young girl not someone born with any special ability. it is the ordinariness that inspired generations of people. She had no loyalty to the emperor. She did all these just for her family.

Absolutly insane how much money Disney is burning to make these terrible insulting movies. Kinda money that could feed small countries hell even larger ones!

Disney didn't expect that moviegoers would care about a movie being good, rather than simply buying tickets because it has shameless pandering. And it's great to see that Nolan's Tenet made twice the revenue Mulan did in China.

Considering Trolls World Tour made around $40million from VOD in the opening weekend, I'd say this is a clear fail. Disney really sucks.

that openiong was hilarious

This live action Mulan sucks so much I’m literally writing a fight where she gets murdered by Joseph Joestar from Jojo’s bizarre adventure.

Disney fail spectacularly with this movie.

You bring honor to us all Nomz

It was never a matter of if only of when...

Mulan, but make it Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon.

I can count on one hand how many movies I’ve seen that have made me cry from laughing so hard over how bad they were.

It failed at my house too.

Covering up a major part of the film. Were they plotting with naughty dog?

Accented cinema made a video on it. Never saw him so angry with a film

If they wanted it to be more realistic, they should have made it closer to the poem. In the poem, she was fighting in the war for 10 years and was never discovered. Her soldier friends didn't realize that she was a woman until they visited her at home after the war was over.

Companies need to relearn that it is GOOD Products that make money....

With a little bit of luck this Will be Disney's wake up call to stop making those soulless live action remakes....but then again I doubt that

Shame on you Disney and the actors and directors who made this movie.

There is actually serious mulan Chinese adaptation can be found in KZfaq like 2009 mulan movie

tbh, the live action version of Mulan seems like a skit that Nigahiga would do

The irony is that they really where putting all their eggs in the China basket hoping it would be a hit there. Yet missed the mark so horribly that Chinese audiences where actually offended by it.

They went with the Egyptian/Western Symbology for the phoenix instead of the Chinese Symbology.