"HIGH TREASON! ULTIMATE DISHONOUR!"' UPDATE: Mulan FAILS In China - kzfaq.info/get/bejne/r7t5h7OgnKu7d2g.html

I like the final scene, when she gets asked by an old lady: - What's your name? - Mulan! Mulan Skywalker!

Disney: Mushu is too unrealistic Shows no blood, has people flying around and walking on walls like Spider-Man

Good character development: *Exists* Disney: We don’t do that here

They turned Mulan into an annoying Mary Sue with Kirsten Stewart-levels of emoting abilities, and Mushu into a badly rendered GPS

Disney: A female protagonist being trained by a man?! How ridiculous! No...we want it to be realistic....give her magical powers which she automatically knows how to use!!

“I’m Mulan Sue, daughter of Mary Sue.”

Let's be real: Li Shang was never offensive, Disney just wanted an excuse to write the accidental bi icon out of their film.

The writers didn’t understand that “chi” isn’t a superpower, it is “life force” that flows through the body. Acupuncture is meant to regulate the flow of chi. In some stories there is reference to something like “cultivating” chi but again you’re not born with that you have to work on it. Witches being persecuted for magic wasn’t a thing in China; that is largely a western Christian idea. Some people in those times were seen as having magical powers like shamans but they were generally respected unless they used their “powers” to do harm.

As a little girl, the 'Be a Man' sequence was one of my absolute favourites in Disney! Watching Mulan fail over and over again, question and doubt herself, getting kicked out and then using her ingenuity to retrieve the arrow and prove herself was just so inspiring! It not only showed you that with hard work and determination you can achieve anything (even if you are a bit of a bumbling mess and feel out of place!), but it also showed that you don't have to be the same as the others to excel. Mulan used what she could (she wasn't as strong but she WAS lighter than everyone else) to innovate the method around her unique strengths and skills. She didn't expect an easy ride, nor to be treated any differently to the others because being a soldier is not only a right, but also huge responsibility that requires you to fight and pay a price for inclusion. So she made herself useful and worked at it with her own blood, sweat and tears, using her hopes and dreams for her familial honour as motivation. I love this. It didn't dumb the world down, nor did it change the standards of strength/war/bravery, which require one to 'be a man'! Rather, it shows a woman matching up to those standards in her own ways, without any special treatment, and without the view that it's just a blind right! THAT'S true feminism! This is why 'be a man' was my motivation song as a young girl!! Ladies, instead of waiting around for fucking Chi, you must be swift as the coursing river with all the force of a great typhoon! 💪🏼

Talking Dragon= Not realistic and serious Phoenix and Witch= Realistic and serious *You all right there Disney?*

Hollywood be like: lets eliminate Shang since we can't tolerate seeing an attractive ASIAN man.

Mulan is strong because she is brave. She sacrifices herself for her father. she knowing how to fight from the beginning makes her actually not brave and not strong

Conclusion: Disney stop making live action remakes, just stop.

Animated Mulan: a woman can perform the same feats as a man with courage and wits Mulan remake: a woman can perform the same feats as a man as long as she has superpowers ... Empowering

As a person of Chinese ethnicity, I haven't been this insulted by Hollywood since the Jaden Smith/Jackie Chan version of the Karate Kid (which inexplicably was set in China despite being called the Karate Kid). If they really wanted to make a "realistic" version they should have just done a direct copy of the 2009 Chinese version with Zhao Wei. That was actually a good movie.

Everyone just watch the Chinese live action movie instead: "Hua Mulan: Rise of a Warrior." Unlike the Disney version, it's pretty damn good and keeps Mulan's core character intact while not being anything like either Disney version. It focuses more on the actual war consequences and relationships than just trying to say how women can fight too. Also no supernatural bullshit, AND they sing. Cuz y'know... war songs absolutely exist and are a staple of troop morale.

Artemis Fowl: Finally, a worthy opponent! Our battle will be legendary!

One of the things I loved the most about Animated Mulan is that she is fundamentally a lazy teenager who comes up with ingenious, clever tricks to do the things she needs to do with the least possible effort: she feeds the chicken using the dog to drag their feed around, and in the same way she figures she can climb the pole using the heavy discs as counterweight, and she defeats the Huns causing an avalanche instead of fighting them one by one. She uses her smarts where she can't use strength - but Live Action Mulan doesn't have to, because she's already a superhuman.

Everyone: A wrinkle in time was the worst woke mess Disney could have ever released Mulan 2020: hold my tea

Disney: *takes Mushu away from the Live Action Film* Mushu: "DiShoNor on YOU! DisHonOr on your COOOOWWWWW!"

I’m so tired of these Mary Sue’s being presented a strong female characters. Mary Sue’s are not inspiring and they set up high expectations that will easily fail.

Disney: *Casts Jet Li and Donnie Yen for this movie* Also Disney: *Doesn't let them do cool martial arts moves* “It's treason, then”

Disney: We're gonna make this hyper realistic. No dragons! Everyone: ........ Also Disney: A witch, a phoenix and Super Saiyan powers.

I was very disappointed about the grandma being cut out of the movie

Mushu isn't realistic. Disney: ok we'll just add a Phoenix, super realistic.

"She kicks an arrow to kill the bad guy." WHAT???

“Pander to Chinese market??” “Realistic?” Have you even read a single book about Chinese history? This movie is far from history... First of all there’s no witch... And if you look at the review in China....

2009: I’ll make a man out of you 2020: I’ll make 30$ off of you

So what you're saying is watch the original cartoon and preserve my nostalgia got it

Mulan: *is a feminist icon* Disney: Let's make Mulan a marie sue, let's rob her of all the character development she had and all the struggles she had to overcome as a woman in a men's world and as a giwl feeling she doesn't fit into social expectations for women in her society. That should appease tHe FeMiNiZtZ

Disney made the Worst Movie of 2020: Mulan Netflix: Hold my beer...

Whoever said Beauty and the beast live action was good, lied to you. It wasn't good at all.

So they failed at a concept that they absolutely nailed 20 years ago?... Really?

They turned mulan into a jedi....

it sucks that this could have been good

Mulan in 1998 was a complex and relatable character. She was well rounded and showed that a woman can use her strengths to achieve her goals through hard work and determination. The Mulan character in 2020 was the most flat character I have ever seen. They didn't show her develop at all. They didn't develop her relationship with her comrades or show her working hard or struggle or learn during training. Nothing was earned. She didn't learn anything. Neither did the other characters. When they ended up following her and supporting her it felt hollow because it didn't show they're relationship with her or they're sexist attitudes develop. I agree that they made her a Mary Sue. Mary Sue is a term that gets overused a lot even when it's not true, but they really did make her a Mary Sue in this movie. Plus the supporting characters: fellow soldiers, her sister, etc were extremely underdeveloped. I didn't care about any of the characters. The stakes were much lower because the villains didn't seem as threatening at all. I did like her costume at the end and the visuals, but the script had cringe you lines and flat characters. It should have gone through a major rewrite.

Chi = The Force These writers are such hacks.

disney: _"we will remove all western elements to please china"_ also disney: _everyone speak english_

Disney: We want to be accurate to Chinese culture, so we will scratch the fan favourite comedic dragon character. Also Disney: Mulan has a western phoenix sidekick now.

I wish the movie ended with someone asking her name and she says, “I’m Mulan,” “Mulan Skywalker”

You can't even get any satisfaction from telling people "I told you so". That's how disappointing Disney has become.

When a character starts off the movie with unexplained proficiency in every possible skill and never once faces a real challenge. -Modern Hollywood Scriptwriters

Did you seriously think that "chi" was a concept invented by Akira Toriyama?

To your point about men having more athleticism than women generally: this is true in some respects, but a bit oversimplified. I understand it's not the point of your video, but I'mma make a thing out of it anyway because I think it's interesting and I don't like seeing it boiled down to a black-and-white "men are stronger" statement. All of the things I'm about to mention are statistical averages. They describe overall trends, not individuals. Men tend to have larger bodies than women - which comes with more muscle mass and larger, longer bones. (Fun fact: there's virtually no difference in the strength of muscles between male and female athletes. Male bodies simply tend to have more muscle, not "better" muscles, than female bodies.) Men also have more stable ligaments. So, overall, men's bodies are better equipped for things like throwing, striking, lifting weights, and taking hits. Women have more relaxed ligaments than men, which makes them easier to injure but allows more flexibility. Women have a lower center of gravity and a wider pelvis, granting them superior balance. Athletic female bodies tend to be more energy-efficient than athletic male bodies. This results in superior endurance. Also, women are believed to have a higher pain tolerance than men (which makes sense from an evolutionary perspective, given how painful and important childbirth is). So, while men are stronger in the common ways strength is described (lifting, striking, movement speed, taking hits without serious injury), women have some important athletic advantages over men (pain tolerance, flexibility, balance, endurance). The difference in athletic capabilities of men versus women is far from the point of the movie, though. Disney's 1998 Mulan is roughly equal to all of her fellow soldiers in physical capability once everyone has been training together for a while. Her being female is never a physical obstacle to her. It's a social/cultural one, because if she is discovered to be a woman, she will be executed and her family dishonored (plus, her father might be enlisted in her place, meaning she will have tried to save his life for nothing). And she doesn't succeed because she's the most athletic of the soldiers, either. She succeeds because she is intelligent, resourceful, determined, and resilient. These traits define her, and she uses them to drive the story over and over again. These traits are what make her a strong character for boys and girls alike to look up to. The fact that she also kicks ass is just icing on the cake.

So basically, "I'll Make a Man Out of You" was given the "Be Prepared" treatment? You'd think Disney would have learned not to do... that... to their iconic songs.

The Beauty and The Beast live action adaptation was an abomination

I really liked how mulan took out an ordinary paper fan and just stole the enemys sword from it

Animated Movies are better than Live-Action Movies *CHANGE MY MIND*

Did anyone *actually* think this Mulan was going to be good, especially after the Lion King remake? This is 21st century Disney. Nothing they’ve done recently is worth sailing the high seas for let alone paying $30.

nobody: disney: let's take a crap all over our classic movies

Cats' (2019): Ha! We aren't the worse movie anymore!

'what a strong female character should be' The animated Mulan was already a strong female character, jfc Hollywood.

Women shouldn't be afraid of being themselves, as long as they are already perfect to begin with.

Giving Mulan superpowes undermines her character and the feminist message behind the first movie. Mulan feels trapped in her societies framework for femininity, but thrives in the army because she is able to express it in the way that is natural to her. She builds relationships, she has to think outside the box because she knows she can’t overcome challenges by brute force. While marriage is constricting and opressive in her old life, she is attracted to and (in a Disney way) is able to explore her sexuality even if it is with her CO. She is more equal to him in the soldier/officer dynamic than she would be as a traditional fiancee. She defeats the villain by embracing her womanhood, in a dress and parrying him with the fan. Not by being «more man» and using her magical «chi» muscle power to kick an arrow. All her victories in the original comes from her and her ingenouity, she never needs to be the most physically strong to be valuable.

In the era of post-creativity, this movie can be described in just three words: disappointing, derivative and insulting. Just like the rest of the Disney remakes/reboots.

This is what happen to Disney when their boss died. We need to find a way to bring back the real Disney.

I love that instead of working hard and growing stronger with her comrades while developing powerful bonds with them through mutual struggle, she just has superpowers 😑

*Someone needs to Make a Man out of Modern Disney.*

Car salesman: *slaps Disney* ”This bad boy can ruin a great story so fast"

The leader of Han in the animated movie was way more scary. He lets two of the soldiers free to send a message to the Emperor and shoots one of them in the back cause he suddenly remembers you only need one messenger to send a message. He didnt have to do that but he loves doing it cause it was fun That scene alone makes the live action version look weak

This movie is SOULLESS, as the main actress with 1 face expression, the one on the poster

Disney you were the chosen one it was said you would make great creative movies and not bland copies of old ones. Inspire children and not please some people on tweeter. You were part of my childhood I loved you

With all the wall running you'd think this was Princess of Persia

having no mushu, is like having aladdin without the genie, its just rubbish

Making her already perfect actually conveys a terrible message. Instead of the message being "If you train hard and really push for it, you can become a great warrior", it's now "hey, you too can be as strong as this Mulan, if you are already perfect." Disney in their horrible mindset of pushing their agenda can't recognize that they are sending an insulting message, that doesn't empower your heroine and in their mind of making her more "progressive", it makes her regressive.

It was obvious it was gonna be terrible movie.

From what I can tell Disney removed the "Western" elements of the animated version and put in brand new Western elements. A witch? Not a thing in Chinese culture. "Chi" is not the force of Star Wars. The emperor dueling the antagonist? Would never happen.

Wait, who told you the Beauty and the Beast live action was actually good? That one may have been the worst of them all! It was horrible!

This movie gave me nothing. I felt nothing for anything that was going on nor did I care. There was just nothing about this movie. And that’s the word that perfectly sums up the movie. Nothing

They removed my FAVORITE scene from the movie, which give so much character to Mulan’s father. The scene where he talks about the flower blooming late, but it blooming as the most beautiful of them all

The only live action movie I like is Cinderella, sure it didnt need to happen, and for the longest time I thought they made the movie because someone saw the stunning dress and was like "yep, lets make a movie about that".The movie didnt really add anything new, it was basically the same story as the animated one, but I liked it. All the actors enjoyed their characters so much, that the whole movie just vibrates with positive energy and if im having a bad day I watch it (which is a really good thing) unlike for example Beauty and the beast, Emma is so gloomy and uninterested in anything that I just cant fall in love with that movie. I didnt even want to watch lion king, it looked bland, the trailer just didn't do it for me, the animation is not getting better (I mean technically yes, but visually not) I want to see something I never saw before, Lions on the other hand I saw many times. Good example was Aladin, the movie wasn't perfect but I love what they did with genie, he was definitely highlight of the movie, because Will Smith was genuinely enjoying his role, and it shows, he did it justice. Animation on his part was well done and really added something magical to the movie. However I dont like what Disney is doing to their female leads, how weirdly they are twisting their motives and personalities, the only one that stayed true to herself was cinderella, and I love the message her movie makes "be kind" in this world its very hard. When someone is mean to you, its so easy to be mean back, but what takes courage is to stay positive and be kind, because kindness can change people and make the world better place. Jasmine was one of my favorite because of how lonely she felt, now she has a best friend and I cant relate to her anymore. She wants to rule and that is not a bad thing, I just wish they would show me more of how she truly cares for her people, it could have been shown so much better so we as audience could connect with her and root for the good she could bring to her kingdom. I fear for what they are going to do to Ariel, I mean she gave everything on line for one guy, she risked everything in hopes of true love at land she dreamed about her whole life. She risked loosing everything - father, sisters, her home....in hopes to find what she was missing this whole time. Which happens, sometimes love is the most important thing in our lives. With what disney did to Mulan I think they are going to change Ariels motivation....I dont knwo Im just tired of these remakes, they are not good, they make the story worse and noone is asking for them. I wish disney would go back and try to realize what made their movie so magical and memorable, they used to be making history now I dont even want to talk about them.

When you put the politics before the art, then the art is worse. That's what this movie did

When I found out Mushu isn't in the film, that was a deal breaker for me.

When I saw the poster they straight up copy from the animated movie I knew it was going to be a bad movie. Not because they copied it (although that is never a good sign) but because they missed a key detail. You see in the poster with the sword, in the animated one Mulan is smiling whereas in the live action when she just looks serious. It's a small detail but it shows how the makers fundamentally misunderstood what makes the animated Mulan so likeable; her confidence and charm even in the face of danger.

Gotta watch the First Live Action Mulan, made by China and it's rated R 2009 even has Jackie Chan singing "Be a Man".

Disney: let's not put mushu.. Mushu: ALRIGHT THAT'S IT DISHONOUR DISHONOUR ON YOUR WHOLE FAMILY DISHONOUR OF YOU-

Disney does Lion King: it's exactly like the original. Every scene is the same. The only difference is, there is no emotion, charisma, charm, humor, colour and heart of the original. Every sane human on planet earth: WHAT IS THIS GARBAGE?! Disney: well we've done something wrong... here, let's try again! Disney does Mulan: everything is changed from the original. Every scene is completely different. On top of that, movie loses all of it's emotion, charisma, charm, humor, colour and heart. Every sane human on planet earth: WHAT IS THIS GARBAGE?! Disney: There is just no pleasing you people!

It was completely bland and forgettable. It doesn't have the same energy like the animated film. Either its different but yet forgettable or its the same style of Gus Van Sant's Psycho, a complete waste of time.

Worst Video Game of 2020: The Last of US Part 2 Worst Big Budget Hollywood Movie of 2020: Mulan Worst Mainstream TV Show of 2020: ???

See, I love your interpretation of the Witch and what she should have been, because the Mongols DID have female warriors and it was a more accepted part of the culture. You even see a bit of that in the animated cartoon, when Shan Yu recognized Mulan and said, "The soldier from the mountains..." He never looked surprised that she was a woman or mocked her for it during their fight, because that was an accepted part of his culture. It would have made TOTAL sense to see a female Mongol, sorry Moron, warrior and have that dynamic!

I've seen so many reviews praising this completely. Are the ones who are paid to review this too scared to say the truth?

“I’m Rey” “Rey who?” “Rey Fa Mulan”

"Worst movie of 2020" Cuties:hello there

Anamoly tearing this disgrace of a film to shreds Me: "I'm going to enjoy this"

I know someone who knows someone that worked with horses and Disney wanted to use their horses and when the horses returned they were bruised and horribly treated which is ironic because in tlj they were space horses that were treated badly

I’m very curious as to why Hollywood has developed a disdain for hard work.

"I Will Make A Man Out of You" we owe it to Donnie Osmond the song wouldn't have worked without him.

So Basically they made Mulan Captain Marvel/Rey's Lesbian Love Child....Mamma mia. Edit: Then Put it up for Adoption with an Abusive Father, Artemis Fowl.

They turned Mulan into Rey.

To be able to feel with a character...you have to be afraid of her being harmed or even killed. But her ability of being indestructible doesn't make you feel anything. Result: Booooring!

Can you imagine being a kid that never see the original version and then watching this, thinking that Mulan is this greedy one man show?

I'm not surprised that this sucks.

Is it just me or does the actress playing Mulan have one facial expression and looks like an absolute lifeless plank of wood.

"It doesn't matter that Li Shang was an actual character! He's got abs! And he's a captain! And he's attractive!" 🤣🤣🤣🤣

The acting in this is trash. Everything is rushed and their actions make no sense

I subscribed like a second ago and I'm already treated with a new video wow this channel looks pretty promising

I'll say it again - 2009 Chinese adaptation. Deal with the subtitles, it's a superior film to this!

"Just be yourself and you would win... because you are full of Qi!!!!!!!" That "full of Qi" part must must not sit well with of a lot Eastern audiences. The make up at 6:10 would also add oil to the fire. On the other ends, this movie have many issues with human right. They have pissed off a hell lot of Western audiences. Mulan 2020 has unlocked a new achievement: "Pissing off everyone on both sides".

After watching this video I'm gonna watch the 1998 Mulan just for kicks. I'm Chinese btw. And I loved Mulan when I was a 10 year old.