Watch the full NBF Episode: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/j9V3nZOBv6_Ug2w.html Support Safina Society: www.patreon.com/join/safinasociety

Thank you so much for this video. It cleared up some misconceptions I had, and helped me understand the different views within the realm of Islam. Jazakallah kharain shaykh

This is a crazy question to ask, but even then should be done in a scholarly fashion. If you're arguing in these comments about who's in the fire from the prophet's family, you've got a screw loose and you need to check yourself. It's disrespectful to utter such filth.

i'm so glad you guys are taking up more space online. We need more orthodox Islam to be represented, jazakallahu khairan

Jazakallah khair shaykh, this matter was confusing to me and was cleared in the first 45 seconds of the video

The Qur'an makes it clear that God would never punish a people who have never been shown any devine guidance. The teachings of Ishmael and Ibrahim had long been forgotten by the Arabs. However the Qur'an also raises the question of devine retribution for crimes committed by human beings. A good example is that of the pagan Arabs who used to bury alive their female infants.

That goes to people who didnt get message like the people of Amazon, native Americans, and many indigenous people.

Could we change the title, it seems very gut wrenching. Perhaps “fate of the Prophet’s (ﷺ) Parents” or something which wouldn’t make him ﷺ hurt when seeing it. Jazak Allahu khayran

Both the Blessed Parents of our Prophet Sallalahu Alaihu Wa Salam will be granted Highest Honour in Jannah...

Say, “Is it other than Allah I should desire as a lord while He is the Lord of all things? And every soul earns not except against itself, and no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another. Then to your Lord is your return, and He will inform you concerning that over which you used to differ.” ~ Qur’an 6:164

Thanks for this explanation. I also thought this. Islam was not there in that time. Then why they ended up in Jahannam? Also, I don’t understand why people are so obsessed about whose going Jannat and Jahannam. Man think about your Jannat. You don’t need to think about others. People are too obsessed with others life than theirs.

I love this Cheikh

Jazakum Allah khair

Say, Whoever is in error - let the Most Merciful extend for him an extension until, when they see that which they were promised - either punishment or the Hour - they will come to know who is worst in position and weaker in soldiers. ~ Qur’an 19:75

The trade off is that those who dont receive the message are exposed to more spiritual risks. And they dont have the knowledge on how to positively influence their record of account with Allah. It will be upto Allah to judge individually.

Which quranic verse did he point out regarding hurting the Prophet? Ina zalika kana uzin nabi? Can someone please tell me the number?

MāshāAllāh well explain covered pretty all common areas of the topic

Sheikh, do we do refrain from saying wretched people like Netanyahu are in the hell fire as well?

Jzk Ustaadh

Subhanallah

I cannot fathom the fact that some people insist on persuing this point. What benefit is there on such rabid insistence on something that is clearly a difference of opinion? Pause of a minute. Breathe. Ask yourself why you exert such energy on trying to force people to believe that the parents of the Best of Creation ﷺ are in the fire. What is the benefit?

Say, Indeed, my prayer, my rites of sacrifice, my living and my dying are for Allah, Lord of the worlds. ~ Qur’an 6:162

Masha allah shaikh ❤

أحسنت شيخ فلله الحمد و الشكر لله رب العالمين

Those that don’t receive the message in this world will be tested on day of judgement

Lots of opinions on this topic, good evidence on both sides, but ultimately it's our own self we have to worry about. For everyone else, we have to believe that Allah will treat them with justice in the hereafter.

Mashallah ❤

The parents of the Last and Final Messenger of Allah Sayyiduna Muhammad (ﷺ) are undoubtedly amongst the most excellent of people.

How can you say they in fire when ALLAH swt chose them to be the parents of our prophet pbuh..

Hello wasn't prophet Salih as sent to the people of Arabia?

What about the message of torah and injeel? The message surely reached?

Last hadith he said "i come from pure loins etc" is fabricated its from al hilya by abu naim which is a book about early sufism mostly. We are extremely saddened by it but if RasoolAllah (pbuh) said his parents are in hell now we can't dispute anymore. May Allah guide us all.

2:45 could it be meant for Abu Talib instead? who was like a father and received and rejected the message?

This is a matter in which there is a difference of opinion: Muslim (203) narrated from Anas (may Allah be pleased with him) that a man said: “O Messenger of Allah, where is my father?” He said: “In Hell.” When he turned away he called him back and said: “My father and your father are in Hell.” Al-Nawawi (may Allah have mercy on him) said: This shows that whoever dies in a state of kufr will be in Hell. And being related to one who is close to Allah will not avail him anything. It also shows that whoever died during the fatrah (the interval between the Prophethood of ‘Eesa (peace be upon him) and that of Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him)) and was the follower of the way of the Arabs at that time, which was idol worship, will also be among the people of Hell. There is no excuse for the call not reaching them, because the call of Ibraaheem and other Prophets (peace be upon them) had reached these people.

If Allah (swt) revealed a whole chapter Honouring the mother of isa (as) Maryam , one of the greatest woman mentioned in the quran. Then what about the rank of the woman who bore the best of the creation to ever exist. (Saw)

Where has the etiquette disappeared to? What fuels this obsession with condemning others, as if those doing the condemning are in a position of divine authority, passing judgment onto hell? The Prophet (pbuh) came to guide us away from hell, yet these individuals are recklessly condemning even the Prophet (pbuh) parents to such a fate. I agree with the speaker 100%

The Hadith of testing on yaumul qiyamah I’ve heard from a muhaddith that there is a weakness. Ibn Abdul Barr commented that the akhirah is not a place of testing which (of course) we don’t use to determine how we make Hadith authentic or not but it is just supplementary. Using supplementary evidence like this can be mentioned after establishing the Hadith is weak and not on its own. I’d like to look into it further myself.

Is it true that the prophet saw cried heavily at the grave of his mother and then the sahaba cried also. What ŵas the reason of our proohet crying heavenly? Sorry if i made grammatical mistakes. English is not my mother tongue

Jazakallah kairan shayekh. Its like my brain new window just opened.

قال تعالى "وتقلبك في الساجدين"

This is the best answer I've heard.

What about receiving the message of the prior messengers before Muhammad ﷺ received revelation?

The parents of the Last and Final Messenger of Allah Sayyiduna Muhammad (ﷺ) are infinitely superior to my own parents.

It would be much better to respond to the islamqa article on stream.

Ya, Sheikh, the point about Mushriks are Najis, isn't it talking about spiritual najasa because if I am not wrong there is a hadith saying bani adam is not najis? If I am mistaken, I ask for forgiveness.

Wahhabis trying their best to insult the parents of the Messenger of Allah (salallahu alayhi wa Salam) will never cease to amaze me

We don't know, but let me share with you a more authentic narration. Allah subhana wa taala narrated that the Prophet peace be upon said: “I do not say to you that I possess Allah’s treasuries or know the unseen, nor do I claim to be an angel. I only follow what is revealed to me.” and he afterwards said “Are those blind equal to those who can see? Will you not then reflect?”

I only understand one thing from all this misconception, we must not associate anything with Allah. No one is forgiven on the day of judgment if they do shirk

No one has ensured way into Heaven, that's the truth but Allah is Merciful and He knows for how long one should remain in Hell, its all dependent on our life in this world and how close we are in faith to Him, Allah has made it easy for us on how to go to heaven but we have to work our way to it and prove we are worthy to enter

الصلاة و السلام على سيدي عبدالله و سيدتي آمنة

السلام عليكم What sharia text do we have saying this that people who never heard the message of Islam are in jannah. I thought we just remain silent on such people . This is where how we approach the text becomes extremely important. It is easy to yell we follow Quran and sunnah but how with what method...etc. Allah knows best

Muslim (203) narrated from Anas (may Allah be pleased with him) that a man said: “O Messenger of Allah, where is my father?” He said: “In Hell.” When he turned away he called him back and said: “My father and your father are in Hell.” Al-Nawawi (may Allah have mercy on him) said: This shows that whoever dies in a state of kufr will be in Hell. And being related to one who is close to Allah will not avail him anything. It also shows that whoever died during the fatrah (the interval between the Prophethood of ‘Eesa (peace be upon him) and that of Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him)) and was the follower of the way of the Arabs at that time, which was idol worship, will also be among the people of Hell. There is no excuse for the call not reaching them, because the call of Ibraaheem and other Prophets (peace be upon them) had reached these people.

Can you give a reference? because what you just said is going against the majority of scholars view. So if there is no reference we have any choice that to reject it.

Grandfather of prophet was clearly making dua to Allah to protect the Kaaba from invasion of Abraha. So how can they (his family) be pagans or disbelievers ?

Two points: 1. I’d take the attitude of Imam Ahmad and not talk about things like this. 2. The point about not talking about if we believe in it is a valid point. And Imam Shaaf’ie (rh) out of respect to Muhammad (saw) did not mention the name of His (saw) daughter in the Hadith of Usama (rh) in relation to punishment.

I have understood from this video not to say they are in Jahanam. May Allah forgive me for my past statements on this matter. But I think it is not also accurate to claim they are in Jannah. We just don't know. And it is not important for our theology.

To be honest I struggled with this question but alhamdulilah the shaykh clarified it. I struggled particularly with the Quranic ayah in Surah Isra and the Apparent Hadith of the prophet.

The prophets parent were not alive to learn about the last messenger so therefore that question is irrelevant.

The questioner asked O Messenger of Allah, where is my father (Abi) Prophet ﷺ responded My (Ab) and your (Ab) are in Hell If Ab Is translated as uncle then it will be My uncle and your father are in Hell It doesn’t make any sense use the same differently without making it clear As for pure loins , it means not outside wedlock, of course they were idol worshippers (irrespective of whether accountable or not )

Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger, (ﷺ) as saying: I sought permission to beg forgiveness for my mother, but Allah did not grant it to me. I sought permission from Him to visit her grave, and He granted it (permission) to me. Sahih Muslim

Honestly, this doesn't benefit you 1 bit if they are in heaven or hell Allah knows whats upon us is to gain beneficial knowledge that will benefit our dunia and akhira

How can this even be a question? Think of it logically. The womb that carries Allah swt greatest creation is in hell? What stupidity

But syiekh, my teacher is also an ash'arie,he told me that the parent of our prophet pbuh, already received the message of Islam at that time, because even though they lived in a jahiliya era, but there are still some abraham teaching, so based on the hadith and quran verses, it indicated that they know that is wrong to worship idols,but still chose to follow their ancestor way instead of way of Islam which then completed by our prophet pbuh.

How is it that Muslims quote Prophets of the Old and New Testament about the coming of Muhammad yet accept that the family he is born to has no idea that Muhammad would be born from them? Does that make any sense? How would Allah make it known to so many for thousands of years of who Muhammad is and from where and under what circumstance he would be born and yet the very people from whom he would be born would not only have no idea but would also be pagan? Abraham knew so don't you think that at least one family line descending to Muhammad would also know? Allah favored the houses of Nuh, Ibrahim and Imran above all others for Prophecy which means that He would preserve the line from which Muhammad would be born from disbelief. How is it that we don't question that the families and parents of Abraham, Moses, Jesus were Believers yet for the greatest of all Prophets and God's Mercy to Mankind many Muslims are adamant that Muhammad was born from parents who were unaware, unexpecting idol worshipers. There are other strong sources that say Muhammad's parents were in fact strong Believers all the way back to Adam yet these are utterly rejected by the majority. Why is that?

4:32 Why is it forbidden to say that the Prophet's parents are in hell?

6:13 that could refer to being from loins free of zina

Haven't these Muslims heard of the hunafa? The monotheists that clung to the remains of tawheed left by prophets Ibrahim and Ismail (as)?

Did Maryam accept the true message of her own son Ee'sa once the Injeel/Gospel was revealed upon the whole community, or did Maryam stay utmost firm upon the path of her forefathers and followed the guidance of Taurah/Torah to the teeth 🤔 Was she convinced of her own son's new preachings, or was she firm upon her forefathers old teahings 🤔 **Tbh knowing the answers really W-O-N-T benefit me or you**

We reject and Tawil of every evidence bcz it contradicts with our baseless theological commitments

Wasn't Ikrimah a Khariji?

Muslim (976) narrated that Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “I asked my Lord for permission to pray for forgiveness for my mother, but He did not give me permission. And I asked Him for permission to visit her grave, and He gave me permission.” It says in ‘Awn al-Ma’bood: “But He did not give me permission” means: because she was a kaafirah (disbeliever) and it is not permissible to pray for forgiveness for the kuffaar. Al-Nawawi (may Allah have mercy on him) said: This shows that it is not permitted to pray for forgiveness for the kuffaar.

So the oppressor also goes to jannah bc he is from “ahlul fitrah” ???

Alhamdulillah, what difference it makes when you take knowledge from a scholar and not from books!

To be accurate to the Quran’s wordings, it is not to seek forgiveness for the mushrikeen. In fact this ayah that was quoted in the video from surah tawbah is thorn in this argument ripping it apart. Allah said: “… after it been clarified that they are people of Hell.” Just as a matter of fact, this is a categorical proof that his (saw) mother is for hell. That’s because Allah only forbade seeking forgiveness for the polytheists after it’s clear that they are people of hell. And then authentically we know that he was specifically forbidden from seeking forgiveness for her. This is clear. As for his father, then his statement is categorical! And authentic! What’s left to conjecture!? Then to put this discussion into perspective: What about waraqah bin Nawfal? What about Zayd bin Amr bin Nufail? Are they the same as the other people of their time? No they are not. And Zayd bin Amr is proof that they knew about Ibrahim and his way and they chose to make shirk following their forefathers. It’s clear.

See how the people of sunnah and adab talk comoared to the najdiya wahabhiya insulters that have no idea how to show love and adab for the messenger of Allah peace be immaculate upon him his family and companions.

But isn't shirk unforgiveable? Someone could have a concept of a Creator, but they could associate partners and diminish His glory. How is that person going to jannah?

What? To even ask that question...

That is false interpretation. The Prophet said my farther is in hell fire its very clear cut

That's a bit of leap. Not sure. Did they receive the message? Message of what "Monotheism"? Why not. Hijab valley all the way to Yemen was occupied by numerous Jewish and Christian tribes. They practiced monotheism. 2400 yrs prior, Hajar and Prophet Ismael were left in that area around Mecca. Hajar was accompanied by Prophet Ibrahim and she must have been a strict monotheism. Do the message had already reached Mecca and Hijab. Finally, when the Messenger asked to pray for his mother's redemption, he was denied by Allah. That shouldn't have been prevented otherwise. Allah always knows best.

Refuses ahad hadith but believes khidr is still alive.

But the prophet's parents did receive a message, though اهل الفترة are only those who never at all received anything about a messenger like they lived with the same amount of knowledge about a message as they were born , but even the prophet peace and blessings be upon him himself was aware of the religion of abraham before islam and that was his religion and waraqa ibn nawfal was from ahlul kitab and believed in the prophecies in the injeel about Mohammed . To summarize , there was a message conveyed to the prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him ) parents through the remnants of al haneefiyah (abraham's religion or ملة ابراهيم) , the true monotheistic christians , and other true remnants of people of the book

FINALLY! A video with so many evedences that debunk the disgusting fatwa from saudi fatwa cult

Was Abdul Mutallib Muslim then too?

Subhan Allah!! The proof was established against his parents through the message of Ibrahim! This is how and why Allah did not allow his beloved prophet to ask for forgiveness for his mother. The fact that Allah did not allow the prophet to ask for forgiveness for his mother is a proof that his mother died as a kafir with the proof being established upon her. Because it is known through the Quran and ijma that it is not allowed to ask Allah to forgive the disbelivers. it amazez me how some people can look for any reason they can find in order to justify their desires.

Fatha kallubuka fis shaajidheen...

Anyone said SAW parents will not go to paradise is cursed run a way do your hijra to such a devil he will bring anger of SWT

Bro started speaking like MBS and rejecting ahad Hadith lol

The Arabs and especially quraish are not part of ahlal fatra. Abdullah bin judan prophet mention he is in hell even though his from ahlal fatra

No they not

Then I think Imam Abu Hanifa should be called out, because in his book Fiqh ul Akbar he call the Prophets parents kafir and Mulla Ali Qari wrote a book defending this opinion of his.

Adjust the title please.

I really wish that the prophet (pbuh) meets his parents in Jannah. Also, I want to ask if I can pray for the forgiveness of prophet's mother if I am blessed to visit her grave?

I consider any person that insults the parents of our Prophet Muhammad s.a.w my enemy. I dont care who you are watch what you say around me, wahabis.

Abu Talib said he remained on the religion of Abdul Muttalib, and Abu Talib is in Hell, which would mean the same for Abdul Muttalib, how does that mean the Prophet PBUH's lineage is "pure" in the sense stated?

Subhanallah, i get what this means. But Islam did not originate in the 7th century. So to claim "have you heard about Islam" to mean the major Islamic sects that came after the revelation of the Quran and deem it scripture is simply not true. There are believers among the people, who received the message of Islam, even if they don't know about the Quran or Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. Abraham peace be upon him is the best example of a muslim, he is the leader of mankind as the Quran mentions, he is the role model the prophet Muhammad himself followed as the Quran tells us, and yet he didn't hear of the prophet Muhammad necessarely directly, nor of the Quran, he was the one who make dua for the Prophet to come actually, not the other way around... So anyone who was truly following the Taurat or and the Injeel or the best they got and were in submission to God are muslims by definition and they shall have their reward. And they may have received messengers, just not with the latest revelation, but perhaps with other of the verses of Allah subhana wa taala as i mentioned be it from the Taurat or the Injeel. In any case believers are few, they have always been consistently the minority except in counted occasions... But Allahu 3alam. Salamun alaikum (I might have made the comment before the video, actually i though he was gonna say they are in hellfire, but either way, we don't know, to claim people came there to not be tested and go to paradise no matter what they did makes no sense, if anything they would be judged based on the fitrah, because they did have a moral consciousness inserted by Allah subhana wa taala, so that at least should be binding, unless you believe there are exceptions and some people get recreated on earth, but i see no evidence for that in the Quran, Allahu 3alam, i see the opposite.)

Sir, that is a good question. Also remember the messenger of arabic god was a non-muslim for 1st 40 years of his life an idol worshipper like his quresh tribe of mecca.

Even at the beginning of this video I knew this guy wasn't good. How do you know the Prophet's mother went to jannah or anyone who died that didn't get the message?

How u know she never recived the message lol and why was Abdul Mutallib a Muslim then and why would these Muslims in the religion of Ibrahim marry non belivers lol .

the fact that this would even be a question for consideration makes me want to leave this religion. Still muslim, just about. Just speaking the truth here.

Wrong interpretation of the hadith by you. Please look up at the ulama regarding about the hadith.