Thanks for the suggestion. This was one of our first videos, and the layout/space we used was definitely not ideal. Since then, we've moved to a much bigger gaming table for our videos (it even fits Twilight Imperium...). Having the table match the game would be very cool, but is definitely out of our budget for now.

I've been watching your latest reviews for several months now, and today I got curious and went looking for your first videos. It's great to see how your reviews constantly got better over time - keep up the great work!

Thanks! I cringe a little when I watch the very early ones, but it's a nice reminder of how much we can improve over time. I'm glad you've seen that as well, and hope that we can continue to get better.

3:37 Purple lassie has TOTALLY been hypnotized! :D

I would suggest a metal table, like they use in veterinarians offices, or mortuaries. It would really fit the theme, and frame the game well.

I've watched a couple other reviews of this game, and your's was incredibly informative. The others mostly leveled complaints against length and randomness, and didn't actually cover the structure, or how it was actually played. I was interested in this after playing Elder Sign, and before this review, was largely turned off the game. But thankfully you have given me some more powerful information to make a decision. Subbed.

Good video giving a complex game an overview in only a few minutes. Nice production and the hosts do a great job of talking through the game. What's missing to me is a summary at the end. Not many video reviews talk the downside of games so I like that but then it just ends (on a down note). Add a quick summary of points would be my suggestion

We are in the warehouse and we are next to each other. Just a lighting / focus effect.

Is it just me, or were they wearing Cthulhu dice and Elder Sign necklaces respectively? :D

Nice short and direct review. Great.

Fantastic Review video. I look forward to seeing more reviews and to purchasing some of these games from Starlit Citadel!

It took quite some time to get everything going on in our first game with the group, but once you play it through, you'll see it is not hard. It's just that there are a lot of details that require some explanation. We now play it weekly and always have a blast, it's a phenomenal game!

Great review. Nice and quick, just what I was looking for.

Great video series! Keep up the good work!

It was sort of spooky the way that neither of you said goodbye; you just faded away with the creepy music still playing.

Currently playing Elder Signs, plus love the HP Lovecraft shorts, so this is definitely at the top of my list, along with Zombicide which I am excited to get my hands on.

@ChipmanofAB Good point. I'll look into it for our next series of videos in the new year

This is the shortest review of Arkham Horror I've seen. Bravo!

I thought I noticed it as being a d12 necklace. I could certainly be wrong.

What music is in the background?

Thanks for the review. I've been curious about this game for a long time. :) Cheers

Yes, we're both Canadian

I wanna play games like this but no one around me is into awesome stuff like this... :0(

Wow great vid - I've subscribed and look forward to more!

Great review. Thanks!

I miss there review some of my favourites online

Enjoyed the review. Thanks!

I just bought this. What have I gotten myself into?

@verducci84 Oh, good point! You're absolutely right. From what I've heard about Elder Sign, it sounds like it would be a good intro to the genre for casual game-players. Not having had the chance to try it yet, myself, MoM was the first thing to spring to mind. ;-) I'll have to add it to my to list of "must play in 2012" resolutions. Happy New Year!

being from and living in Massachusetts i feel like i should own it plus it looks awesome

Arkham Horror is the Game that got me back into Boardgaming and without a Doubt is my favourite Game (maybe for all Time). Though the Rules seem complicated, they can be explained quite well and new players seem to get hang of it while the first game runs. The Last Tip You gave for the Mythos phase is quite important, I completely agree with it. One other thing You forgot to mention: The price is extremely great for whats in the box, there are hundreds of parts for 35 bucks... and High Quality!

This is great! Would you please consider reviewing Touch of Evil? I've just bought this one, that one, and Star Trek Catan today, and can't wait to try them all out!

Continued; As for the cards, and they're a lot of them which take up a lot of real estate , don't lay them flat on the tabe. Invest in a few business card racks and use these. This will make the cards easier to see and organize It goes without saying that the token can be organized in one or two plano or bead crafting boxes

me and my friends played this yesterday took us 8 hours from starting to learn the rules till we finished the 1st game lol

I don’t know why I am watching this after the game is already out of print :(

Meethos?! ;-) (Sorry to nitpick, but "mythos" has the same root as myth, mythology, etc., so is pronounced similarly.) Great review/summary though! I liked it very much. (And I'm always glad to see gamer gals represent!) Someone else asked if there's something like this game that's a bit more accessible to new players. I'd highly recommend Mansions of Madness, but with the caveat that at least ONE player needs to know the rules very well. Thanks for the review-- I look forward to more!

Was gifted this game a couple years ago, but have been intimidated by the rules-heaviness of it.

Much like are real life reality!!! YAAAAH

@FuaimCatha04 I would actually suggest Elder Sign as it is very much Arkham Horror Light. It's a great gateway game to "ease" people in to AH. Not that there's anything wrong with MoM. I love it and actually prefer it to Arkham Horror,and I love the hell out of Arkham.

I love this game. Please start season 5, everybody else’s reviews suck.

Nice game, but indeed needs a group with Time and Focus.

Love the D20 necklace. :)

@FuaimCatha04 It's a great game. It's super fun, fast-paced, sets up in 5 minutes and it's quick enough so you can squeeze in a game while Arkham Horror is being put together. Or you can just whip it out when you don't feel like setting up AH. We play it all the time. It's only like $25 on Amazon and they just released a revised edition in December. I highly recommend it.

It's a d12 necklace , i think it's a nod to joanna playing a barbarian in another web series

AH(2E) is the king, even today!

Best boardgame ever.

They are all far removed from the author's short stories. I have not tried Mansions of Madness yet, but it looks like it might be better than the other two. Elder Sign is a quick and easy game with dice rolling which plays well and fine. I have used it to my advantage.

Good video. Make sure you are looking at the right camera ;)

@RODEO32100 Done and done. Elder Sign review is up.

I doubt that Lovecraft would like this game and they continue to make fun of him in the USA. It is only an okay game with good artwork, but Elder Sign has better game play value, although Arkham Horror rules can be modified to correct the pace (which is the main issue). .

It's the ancient ones

saw this today for $60, so sad i didnt have the money

You mean Arkham Horror Lite? : ). Seriosly though, I like Elder Signs as well but there is no way it plays better the Arkham Horror, just easier. Although I do play Elder Signs more often, I enjoy Mansions of Madness and Arkham Horror more. It's all about opinion

Meethos? We don't say that in Liverpool.

These women rock!

I liked your video, it was well produced. Except for the tables youmused

I like the way robot on the right stays in standby until the robot on the left finishes it's dialogue and then enters standby mode so right robot can take over. Good review though.

Are you actually standing in a store, and are you actually standing next to each other? It looks like you are all pasted in. xD Great review though.

I watched your review and based on that I wont buy the game.... To complex for me. Thank you for saving me €60

Are these guys from canada?

Mythos, not meethows

are ya'll Canadian? cause i think I detected an aboot.

ummmm wtf is up with that creepy ass music !

Id play all the games with the blonde......good lord!