His whole dealership needs to be audited to see if he's done this to anyone else in the past. If so, he needs to be sued and needs to be shut down and/or go to jail.

The fact that he scammed them and then thought he could say he had no legal obligation was the cherry on top

All that was missing was his gaudy gold chain. The guy is a scammer and he knows he didn't give the 1,000 to the warranty company. Guarantee you this isn't the first time he's committed fraud while selling a vehicle.

Funny how quiet he got and his face changed when the judge came back out and figured out his whole scam.

Judge Milian was in her bag during this case , FANTASTIC WORK 💯

No wonder the defendant paid for the plaintiffs' dinner - acting like a nice guy when in reality he was a true snake! Judge's intuition was spot on!

The dealership is obviously selling bogus warrantees and pocketing the money. $700 to the shop and $300 to the salesman

It was a scam from the very beginning, hence the reason that they didn’t provide the purchasers with a copy of the warranty documents from “Cars”. They didn’t want them to reach out to that company, only to find out that they had no contract with them whatsoever.

Don't think anyone who watched this case was surprised that the application was never submitted. Looks like this dealership is just scamming people leading them to believe they have a warranty and pocketing the money...

What always gets me is the audacity. He KNOWS he’s a scammer and he still agreed to go on national TV. I’d either just settle or sue me privately so the world doesn’t know I’m a scammer afterwards smh

That "Warranty" sounds like a royal scam. The money flows only one way: Toward the company.

OMGOODNESS the defendant folded, he knew they never paid the 3rd party. He was so slippery I just wanted to take a bath after listening to him. 😢🛀

This judge is the most profound, precise, intelligent, emphatic and good judge I've erver witnessed!! Respect from Amsterdam!!!! ❤

Update: He never submitted the documentation or the $1K‼️‼️

Big surprise that the defendant never submitted the warranty information or the thousand dollars. What a bunch of scam artists purposely collecting money for these bogus warranties that they hope no one will ever try to utilize

He was so confident.... his face at the end was priceless. Scumbag

He knew that it was never submitted. Good Win for the Plaintiffs. 👏🏾👏🏾

*I KNEW IT!!!* I could see that coming from a mile away! I kind of wish the Judge pulled him back in after he gave that answer to Doug and told him she changed her mind and to pay them now because you didn't bring the proof here and I don't believe a word you say... For him to say she "deviated from the case" and he's not liable regardless... Like no dude, that has absolutely EVERYTHING to do with the case because if you never bought the warranty for them, then you just kept their money and you're just a dirty scamming thief.

WOW, what a surprise, he didn't produce the evidence. Of course he didn't!

This is so common that it is like the number one thing that used car dealers get sued for. They charge you for a warranty but never submit the warranty. If you come in with a problem they either fix it on their own dime or submit the warranty and then make a claim. This is why these third party warranty companies are forcing a 30 day waiting period before the warranty is in effect. If you buy a used car and a warranty you should get paperwork for that. Because she had no paperwork it seems likely this dealer was scamming people out of their money and never buying any warranties.

Judge Marilyn is very smart! I like how direct she is & she’s very perceptive & highly knowledgeable of the law.

He enjoys "sounding" smart.

He knew he hadn't bought the warranty, that's why he went "above and beyond" to help her, hoping he wouldn't wind up eating an expensive repair.

The defendant has probably done this more than a few times, and this one time got caught on International TV (Canada / USA) and this will warn people to be really careful before they ever buy a car from this shifty shady sheisty slithery scammy sales lot. I hope this judgment becomes public record so that any other affected customers can exercise their rights.

With all due respect, the defendants company sound like thieves 😂

Me and my husband went through this same deal! Bought a truck at a uses care dealer, warranty was through a third party. Engine blew after four months from the purchase. Warranty was denied. We had no money to hire legal help. So we were sunk. It was our only vehicle at the time, so we had to buy a whole new engine. DONT EVER BUY A CAR WITH A THIRD PARTY WARRANTY.

I just HATE it when somebody, especially a litigant who thinks they're being very attorney-ish, says, "Your Honor, with all due respect ..." How much respect do they really think is due? And ... Judge Milian agrees with me.

Upload times are perfection...audio only gets uploaded right before I drive for the day, theres a fresh one to view in the am while shaving...plus 2-3 cases once im off and chilln..im surely addicted, thank you JM and TPC

I guarantee he didn’t sent that in. It went right in his pocket. Wish we knew what ended up happening.

I'm suprised the defendant's eyebrows haven't flown away😂😂

That plaintiff should file complaints with the BBB, her state Attorney General and the US Attorney General’s Office

Doug is so savage "it's her decision that counts" 🤣

Too funny when the judge called his bluff😂and you could see it all over his face!!!😂😂😂 Yeah, buddy! Your scam was caught and called out on national television!!

Once he said “deviate” I knew he was lying.

His argument at the end makes no sense. He does NOT have a legally binding contract that says he has no liability. That contract was never executed. He never sent the money for the warranty.

The judge deviated from the case 😂 The judge deviated by looking into the warranty, he wasnt expecting that 😂

The second he opened his greasy mouth, i knew he was a crooked scammer

I love this case! JM was excellent in this figuring and unraveling this all out.

i knew he was a scam artist gangster from his hair style! all that’s missing is his gold chains and rings !

That dealership is a scam machine 😒

Went from “suing the wrong person” to “suing the right person” real fast

I took a look at the slick back hair and his eye brows and i knew what time it was

Shocking… the defendant is a scam business operator. His face says mug shot.

worked out good, she not only got her transmission fixed, she got a free lunch as well.

I'd love to hear what happened after that week. And one thing I learned in my Civil Law course was that putting "We're not liable" in a contract does NOT free you from liability. If it did, everyone would put it in.

The defendant knows about the pocketing of the warranty money too bc he lied and said he’s been in contact with the company and they said they deny the warranty because of the age of the car. If he really called they would have told them the same thing they told the judge, “we don’t know wtf you’re talking about”😂😂. Judge should have pointed that out🤔🤔

That wasn’t somebody at his dealership that did that it was all him. Looks like he’s putting a new transmission in the car lol I do love a happy ending.

Lmao! The plaintiff got Doug's big head as*..."so what you ask me for" 🤣🤣

She bought her own lunch cuz that was her money he was using 😂😂

The Car Dealer's name says it all - Just a sleazy character, NO question !!!

Yeah the "warranty" gets "denied" then they do the work at a "discount" so no matter what they get that thousand from you. Scam, absolutely ridiculous

No wonder he felt the judge deviated from the case. Smh. Scammers.

Not shocked. That defendant had enough grease in his hair to do an oil change. Sleaze

What a joke the defendant is... he's not contractually bound if the warranty company denies the claim...they couldn't deny it as it was never given to them nor was it even paid for...bottom line, the defendant is a SCAMMER!

There was a similar case like this once before. JM ripped the defendant a new one. Search the people's court extended warranty. The title is Un-Warranting a Warrant. It's worth a watch.

He absolutely had legal liability up until the money was PAID to the insurance company. WHICH IT NEVER WAS. Typical scammer.

When the defendant walked in that idea entered my head that he never submitted to warranty. It is a common scam. They never gave the the woman a cop of the warranty for her to check into it herself.

This happens all the time with used car dealers lol, people just don't know. The judge used the term "roulette" which is 100% what it is. Here is how it works: The used car dealer sometimes (not every sale obviously) charges a customer for warranty, but never actually purchases the warranty from the 3rd party warranty company (just like this case). They hope the term of the warranty runs out before anything goes wrong with the car, which is how they profit the warranty cost. If something DOES go wrong during the term, they usually just count it up as a lost scam, and pay the money out of the dealerships pocket to fix the problem, and just tell the customer it was covered under the warranty. This is still profitable to them because the amount of scam warranties they sell with no mechanical issues during the term of the warranty outnumber the ones where something actually goes wrong and they have to pay out of pocket to keep it hidden. What's crazy is usually the warranties they play roulette with are not 1 year unlimited miles lmao. Thats way too long, and something (even small) is bound to go wrong on a used car in that time frame. Usually the warranties they scam with are 3 month 3k mile warranties (the most popular ones from used car dealers). This idiot ruined his own scam by playing roulette with a LONG ASS warranty on an old ass car, and ALSO telling them the warranty was denied, instead of just shutting up and going fully into pocket and counting it up as a loss and just not telling the customer. He figured he didn't want to take the loss of 1,800 (2800 for new tranny minus 1000 he already made from the scam). He was banking on them just rolling over and taking it, and instead they went to court. This case just touched the tip of the iceberg of this scam, but its a very real thing. Also, this guy has absolutely done this tons of times before.

We already know there was nothing sent. Can't believe the judge was so easy on this car salesman.

This EXACT same thing happened to me! The warranty cost was $150 but they never sent it in with the paperwork and I ended up a plaintiff in small claims for a transmission against the dealer that sold me my vehicle as well! I think it cost him around $3500 (it was years ago so can’t quite remember)

Defendant is handsome as hell and the lady in purple shirt behind plaintiff is beautiful!

The judge didn't realise she caught him in a lie when he said he had called the insurance company and they told him they were declining the claim, yet when the judge phoned them they said they had never seen that policy, so he lied to the judge, as it is impossible for the company to decline a claim when they didn't even have the policy. He should be in jail for fraud and theft...

Sad that I judged that defendant like second I seen him … but I knew he was shady and swindled this lady .. sometimes u can just see through people

Hence why he called and bought her lunch 😂😂😂😂

Wait up a minute... shouldn't Slick have to return the thousand as well as fix the car, because clearly there was fraud involved, and the customer relied on a promise of a warranty that never existed? Slick shouldn't get to mitigate his losses by pocketing the grand.

JM Is absolutely brilliant….. not trying to compare but JMathis I don’t think would have pulled his card the way she did. Her mind went where mine didn’t consider ….. why was he so overly involved in calling the warranty place. Usually the dealership would hand you the warranty department phone number and info and you’re on your own. Something smelled fishy and she figured it out … great job

These two men need to button their shirts for court. Good grief! Defendant is like so many unscrupulous car salesmen, scams people out of their money. He even looks slick and greasy but thinks he's cool, "with all due respect." 😡😡😡 Of course the defendant didn't submit the evidence the judge wanted because he's a crook. Pocketed that $1000. I hope the plaintiff got her car fixed and that bogus warranty money back.

His speech to Doug at the end convinced me he is the one pocketing the $1000 and probably does it each time, I wonder how many people he has done this too and just accepted him saying 'the insurance company declined your claim'. I hope he goes to jail for fraud...

The judge was so excited. Lol that was a fun verdict. Even my heart was racing.

All that mumbo jumbo and he's just a two bit crook.

Class in session 👏🏽👏🏽

Unfortunately certain businessmen tend to do very shady things

This owner got what`s called "KARMA"!!!...for scamming the couple for an extra thousand dollars. Smh

I could already tell he was a crook. That comment to Doug in the hallway confirmed my suspicions. I hope they're out of business by now. They've been running that scam for years.

anyone who has bought a vehicle from this clown should sue him for repairs and fraud. He was pocketing the $1,000….. himself.

Judges aren’t the only ones who feel that way, “with all due respect”😏

Each time he collected $1k from the customers and since there's a miles/time limit on the warranty, he was counting on the small percentage of customers would use the warranty.

As soon as the defendant said the Judge deviated, we know, they absolutely sued the right person. That's fraud buddy.

Sleazy car salesman “Give me $1000 and I will guarantee you a full coverage warranty for a year! However if the $1000 dollar payment never makes it to the warranty company, I’m not legally responsible.” 😂😂😂😂

Don't buy warranties from Wal-Mart with your purchases. I did once and was given a repair shop to call. They refused to honor the warranty because they said "We don't fix those anymore". The item was six months old.

I am 100% sure he is selling bogus warranty to thee buyer and hoping nothing breaks. If something breaks Oops sorry warranty doesnt cover this. Here is your Refund that u paid for the warranty. Thats his SCAM for sure..

The state needs to investigate this shady car dealer.

There should be a Part 2 with cases like this. I’d love to see the outcome.

It was obvious that the guy scammed them. If he was legit he would have been happy with the judge's ruling because all he would need to do is show that he paid the third party company. Then he can wipe his hands from all the mess. But since he was upset at the judge's ruling, that was a clear sign that he knew he did not have the proof that he needed because he knew he was being dishonest.

If someone is selling you a used car "as-is", but wants to also sell you a warranty is a BIG red flag.

My word. Why are our buttons undone 🤣

Defendant looked like a shady character, these types are good talkers,good convincing power and what's with free meal.

If the defendant had submitted the warranty to the 3rd party, then yeah, it'd be against the 3rd party. But he (or his agent) took her money, never paid for the warranty, and got caught. Given the amount, if she filed a police report, and presuming this his his s.o.p., it could shutter his dealership.

All he was missing was a thick gold chain and a leopard velvet blazer lol😅😅😂😂

Him and that company are in kahoots they splitting the 1000 and turing down people after they get their money it's a scam

One look at the guy and his demeanor is all you need to know!

She said it was a salad 🥗 a very nice salad 🥗 😂

I bet the defendant owns the repair company

owner of the dealership is obviously a liar and a thief. Because he specifically said he called and said that the Insurance company DENIED their claim and didnt really give a reason but maybe it was the age of the car. Then the Judge said they never denied the claim they never had a policy for the plaintiff. So the owner obviously got caught in a lie. He tried to throw the blame on a salesman after and never came back with the proof because he had none!! Sleezeball

I’m shocked that the Judge didn’t nail him to the wall for outright lying to her that he was told by the warranty company that they denied the application, which he knew he was going to lie about before he even stepped in to court because he never submitted it in the first place!!! He didn’t expect the Judge to call the warranty company - I could see it in his eyes - and he knew he screwed up BIG TIME! Another crooked used car salesman tried to strike again and it served him right to have to pay the Plaintiffs.

Plaintiffs husband looks like a heart attack in waiting....🤫

Fun Fact: this scammer ran for PRESIDENT!!!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Lmaooo 😂 what is this the jersey shore the shirt being unbuttoned sent me.

You know they say dont judge a book by its cover but just one look at the defendant and i knew he wasnt shit

The defendant ran for President of the United States in 2016.