That KOTOR quote is actually from KOTOR I, not KOTOR II. Also - One topic that I didn't mention in the video and only touched on through the footage I added: Major Miles. I think Miles had a substantial impact and that should definitely be noted. I didn't tout his importance much here because it wouldn't have added much in terms of contribution to the thesis of the video (a lot of what Miles teaches him is reinforcement for what was already told to him by others), but I should have mentioned his importance as an aside as well, for sure. He was very important to Scar, primarily because he showed Scar what an Ishvallan could do to change things.

Funny thing is, Bradley should've won their final duel, and he even says that he would have if he were 10 years younger. The only reason Scar scored that final critical blow was because a shard of Bradley's shattered sword caught the sun at just the right angle to blind him, given that he'd already lost his Ultimate Eye earlier. It shows how, no matter how skilled you are, no matter how wide or narrow a gap between you and your opponent, victory or defeat can hinge on the most random of circumstances, and you can never be 100% certain of any success.

scar is awesome and all, but look how cool killua's skateboard is

FMA in general is a story that continuously champions perspective. People are as they are, not innately anything. Anger is what it is. It can be good or bad. Science can be good or bad. Everything depends, and that is the truth. It's very insightful and realistic in that sense.

Scar is so great, the fact Envy caused a catastrophic domino effect by killing an ishvallan child, causing the war, forcing Dr Marco in creating the stone, giving it to Kimblee who then murdered Scars brother, resulting in the death of Winrys parents!

not gonna lie, whereas in FMA Scar was a badass anti-hero in my eyes it wasn't until Brotherhood that he became my favorite character, if anything i'd like to add he embodies for me one trait: Redemption, to me Scar symbolizes that no matter what, should you choose to, you have the power to rise above and beyond, that independently of your birth, status, beliefs, knowledge, history nor abilities it is ultimately the choice of wether to harm people or help them that'll ultimately dictate your story, and that acknowledging your past mistakes is not weakness nor justification for your shortcomings, but the first step into carving a better future for you and those around you.

I just wish you had at least mentioned Miles, one of the most important characters in regards to Scar's change. He sees Miles as a role model for how a person who wants to do good should act; a role model for how revenge wouldn't do you any good, while change will. Miles leads Scar into his motivation during the endgame, and it's a shame that he didn't get any credit for that in this video.

It's so cool how Father basically removed the emotions he thought sinfull. But in reality it weren't the emotions that were sinfull but the way you acted upon them. Wrath is okey if you use it to see what you want to change. Greed is okay. It's okay to want things and the same is true with the other homonculy

I love how instead of preaching forgiveness like most anime do (even the greats) FMA talks more about tolerance. I always find it annoying when a character goes through some trauma and then just suddenly forgives the person that caused it

Scar Vs Wrath is one of the best fights out there. When you think about it, this man was consumed by Wrath throughout the series and now his final battle is versus a man who not only in the one responsible for his Wrath but the man who holds the title Wrath itself. One could say that this final battle was both a physical one as well as a spiritual one. His final trial of shedding himself from his Wrath is fighting Wrath itself. The best part is that this is just one of many perspectives of the Scar vs Wrath/King Bradley battle.

Can we all take time to appreciate how big an influence Scar's brother had on the plot, despite being dead throughout the whole story excluding flashbacks? Not to mention that, despite only having a few minutes of scree time, he feels like a real person.

I'm glad this is an FMA video on what makes the series good, not one about why the live-action movie is bad. Breaking the cycle of negative videos.

Great video as usual. I would like to add that Scar’s brother is shown to wear transparent identical glasses to Scar’s dark shades which may be symbolic of his brother’s open minded understanding of the reality of the world of FMAB while Scar seemingly controlled by anger throughout the beginning of his character arc no longer cared to understand anything or see the multitude of reasons why the mass extermination of his people took place hence dark shades.

Scar is one of my favorite characters of anime. I love his character and backstory. Goddamnit I love FMA so much..

the name scar is also symbolic. Its a fresh wound that will heal over time, and in its place, a mark will be placed. When the wound was still fresh, he was hunting for revenge, but as he healed, the wound scabbed, and only a scar was eventually left

Scars character arc is among one of my favorite parts in FMA, and may I say just how god damn beautiful the animation is in his fight against Bradley. This video was a nice treat for me to wake up to, great job as always.

Aww, he's helping :')

Scar changes so much that he literally goes from destroying Al’s body to helping to reassemble him.

"Some would say...wrath" OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH 13:32 LMAO

The fight between Scar and Bradley is so very symbolic. The man driven by hate for so long, fighting the personification of Wrath itself.

To draw a Shonen comparison, Scar is a better-written Sasuke

In the wake of current happenings with senseless violence and treachery, I find this video comforting because it challenges a person to think that anger can be used for good. It can be channeled not to exact revenge or commit public atrocities but instead, become the energy and motivation to pursue change in society, which is sorely needed. That is one timely upload and you are who we need at this time and beyond. Thank you for always sharing. My respect for you bleeds deep.

Aleczandxr, once again, you have created a beautiful video essay on a character that never really gets enough focus as to his actual change. Many people have often touched on why Scar has changed over time, and highlight Winry as the change, but never have I seen anyone mention and highlight that Winry stands for the exact same goals as to what he has been taught and shows that someone with that mindset can be strong. This is honestly one of the reasons I have seen many people have said that Winry is their favorite female character in all of shonen, due to how "weak and powerless" she is as far as a power level of the other characters, yet is probably mentally the strongest out of the main cast, with the chance to look past and realize that hatred never solves anything. Not only this, but drawing attention to the fact that Scar begins to take on this mindset and begin to better himself, look for why his brother died, what he left behind, instead of trying to mindlessly get revenge for the death. He is no longer looking for meaning in what his brother died for. He is looking for meaning in what his brother lived for. I also think it's an interesting idea that by finally using the final step of alchemy towards the end of the show, Scar is metaphorically bringing his mindset full circle. He is now complete. He is being fulfilled. He is "completing" the cycle back to life, no longer breaking it at the death point in the circle of life. He has begun to actually live his life and go beyond just wanting to end other's. Thank you for all you do man. I seriously love each and every one of your videos. No other youtuber besides maybe supereyepatchwolf has even come close to your analyses and made me think about my favorite series in new and interesting ways. I'm pretty sure I say it on almost every video I comment on, but you are honestly amazing and I can't wait to see the next one.

That was an amaizing character break down. Shows how much work you put in this video. Generally eveything is just amaizing. Great work

I really loved that, for even the people who didn't get the deeper themes of FMA brotherhood, it is very obvious and clear that Scar, a once angry man, reaches the climax of the series by going up against the embodiment of what he learned to let go of, wrath and anger.

some would say.... *WRATH*

I think Scar and Guts would get along well.

I love Scar’s character arc. Definitely one of my favorites in the show.

I like Scar character development, from crazy mass murdering villain to anti hero, that's a character that I'll remember,forever!!! U rock Aleczandxr!!!!!!!

There's something about revenge driven characters that I love. Kurapika, Scar, Stain. All so well written.

Scar's redemption arc is one of the best, one of my favourite characters in the anime/manga and seeing him go from villain to hero( perhaps anti-hero cause that's more realistic to me) was an emotional roller-coaster and whilst I'm here KOTOR II: The Sith Lords > KOTOR.

Man, every time you make a video you always manage to outdo yourself. I am extremely envious of the ability to be able to break down the philosphical meaning and themes of a certain character or story. Of all people, you are probably the best I've seen when it comes to this. Anime is a medium that I love so much due to how much it can teach you in ways of ideals and life lessons. And it's people like you who help enhance this aspect. I greatly appreciate it.

Yet again at a loss for words. Truly am inspired by your work my man.

I love the move from selfishness to selflessness for Scar. He was able to see beyond his limited point of view and realize how much more of an impact he could have on more grand events. A far more productive and healthy outlet for his feelings. Great video as usual!

Thank you for analyzing Scar so clearly and not shying away from uncomfortable aspects. You're right in saying this aspect isn't discussed often, and I think it's because we want to avoid real-world parallels, but you spoke calmly and strictly only about the narrative. That lets the audience mull it over ourselves; thank you! Impeccable editing, too!

I'm so happy to see you make a video about my favorite FMA character. Scar's story is truly one of the most well written parts in Fullmetal Alchemist. Hiromu Arakawa's take on Scar's character growth is nothing short of masterful and it's one that never fails to pull me in upon every rewatch of the series I do. Really phenomenal character analysis here! I'm going to share it with my friends since they know how much I like Scar.

Coincedentially, i was binge watching your videos again last night, and the last video I watch was about Bradley. I'm glad to get another FMA video, and its about Scar ^^

Wonderful analysis, what I love about your videos along with character insights and the clear explanation of complicated themes are the lessons behind it, so we can use these insights in our own lives and improve it. You sir have become a wonderful teacher.

Yo Aleczandxr, this wasn't only just a review/analysis about the show, this felt like a whole damn therapy session. I needed this, Thank You.

Dude, you SHOULD make a vide about Envy! I Don't know if you wanna ever do, but it'd be awesome!

This video is absolutely incredible and Scar has one of the best character arcs of all time but also “Aw he’s helping :’)” lives in my mind rent free

Or as I explained to my sister when she walked in mid season: Scar is their Zuko.

Always excited to see a new video from you!

I personally don't hold Scar accountable for killing the Rockbells. He had no idea where he was, he was in massive amounts of pain, he'd just watched all of his people die, and he was in a room with two Amestrians. He wasn't in his right mind. I personally believe it is just a tragic accident.

"Leave it for the Prophets to interpret God's will..." -Scar

This video made me remmember once I shared on Facebook these words from Martin Luther King Jr.: "Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that." And then I friend of mine, trying point a contradiction in that said to me: "I want to see you love someone when he is aiminh a shotgun at your face." But that is not the point. It is not about love the one who hurt you, like you mentioned about Winry. I think that if I repay violence with more violence the cycle will go on and on. But if I choose another route, a positive and constructive one, maybe violence, hatred, wrath can end right there.

It completely flew over my head that scar defeated the literal embodiment of wrath and freed himself

Awesome video. Very insightful and detailed on Scar's character arc. Honestly, I feel like he's the most developed character in the series.

Also, Scars final battle being against "Wrath" is so fucking cool.

Lovely analysis! It definitely cheered me up after being disappointed in the live action movie. Scar's and Winry's shared narrative is one my favourites in storytelling in general, even though its not what one would consider a fun story- it is one of great progress, with a lot of care and thought put in to it for all sides from both from arwakawa and you yourself for this vid! I think the main thing I have to add is how interesting it is that scar and Kimberlee switch places at their last meeting because of Winry. Kim is furious at the end for not managing to exterminate scar, and scar himself kinda just doesn't give a fuck about him anymore. It's both hillarious and astonishing since before meeting winry again at the briggs- Scar was still all in for shredding Kim to bits. But the change is a straight 180- and arguably good for everyone. It also pleased me in that even though Kim was rather interested in meeting winry and was super 'nice' about it, winry still ended up helping scar, the person she had the least reasons to help. Instead she kinda gave Kim the metaphorical middle finger, which is karmaiclly so pleasing. Since Kim himself in someways is the root cause for both Scar's and Winry's conflict. Lastly, I think my fav thing about Scar's Narrative, is that Arwakawa makes it a point that Scar's change is something he earned and had to mentally work through to achieve. As much as I absolutely love the resolution reached through winry and Scar's interactions. It's Scar himself that does the work to bettering his life and others, & at no point is winry held responsible to make that happen. Which is a great change Imo, because a lot of narratives treat a women helping a troubled man like an obligation, or inappropriatly romanticize it, none of which cow sensei enforces. In fact she does the opposite- winry is a hero becuase she does good for others when it is the least of her obligations. And Scar ultimatly changes into a hero because of all the people he met, Marcho, Mei, & Miles as well as doing the personal legwork of reflecting on his own thoughts and that of his master and brother. It's a much more wholistic approach to self actualization and recovery from trauma, and I think I'll always really appreciate that.

Scar vs. Wrath has long been my favorite fight in all of anime. Besides being an epic clash between badass characters, I never could fully explain why I love their battle so much. This video eloquently verbalizes many of those unexplained inner-feelings. All the more reason why Brotherhood is a work of art and also why Aleczanxr is one of my favorite KZfaqrs. Truly powerful stuff. And Chrono Cross music!? You sir are a God among men. I would subscribe to your channel 100 times if I could.

Scar looked like such a complicated character to develop. It is not very common to find a character go from a completelly bidimensional nature to a more complex and deep personality with an organic feel to it. The fact FMA could do it with Scar just shows how good the series is and how well it used a character that could very easily just be frustating. Great read on Scar and his importance tothe series!

I love your video's so much. FMA and FMA Brotherhood are amazing shows and have a lot of stuff to talk about.

*cries in fanboy* I haven't even finished the video yet but it doesn't matter. THANK YOU

While anger is certainly not always a bad emotion, I'd say as a motivation, revenge is only beneficial compared to doing nothing at all. We should punish wrongdoers so they realize they were wrong, and feel remorse, and learn from their mistakes, AND/OR to threaten and prevent others from making the same mistake before they even try it.

You sir are a legend You continue to make quality content also thanks for reigniting my love for fmab I hope you continue to make content and also how about other characters for your analysis from other franchise Scar's journey was truly well done and it shows just how the series is truly a masterpiece

17:55 Chrono Cross' Scars of Time... I see what you did there. Great video, keep up the good work! =D

8:31 "Your face asplodes!"

The beginning section on anger really hit me hard. That was deep man. Genuinely deep. I love it when I read or hear something that makes me actually pause and reflect on myself and the way I choose to behave, and the way I choose to think.

When you realize the true hero of FMA:B is not the Elrics or Hoenheim but Scars’ brother. 😳 mind blown.

This video is extremely well timed considering what's been going on in the world. I never get tired of your Brotherhood videos(or any of your videos for that matter) I can always expect well written well analyzed works by you on our favorite series ~

...This is why I relate myself to this character

This was really nicely put together. Thanks for making this! Off to check out the rest of your channel.

Honestly man your one of the best anime KZfaqr. I always learn something new from your videos. Keep up the great work.

It's a fest whenever I get a notification about one of your videos, even if it's a bad day sometimes it immediately becomes better...welp, time to make some popcorn and some tea.

Great character analyzed. You're the best youtube analyzer for FMA and HxH.

Aleczandxr your videos are so amazing and even when I think I can guess what you thesis is you still end up surprising me with your depth and the tight editing to help illustrate your points. The Winry thing caught me off guard; I never thought about her impact on Scar's life but you hit the nail on the head and it explains his transition from murderer to being an ally for the Elric brothers. Don't ever stop what you're doing, you and SEW are the best analytical creators on this site!

Really glad you got a sponsor. This video really expanded one of the few characters I didn’t care to much about in FMA, and I’m glad to be enlightened! Keep it up man!

I’ve rewatched fmab so many times and every time I feel like I find something new or analyze something I didn’t even notice before truly one of the best anime

I just finished reading FMA recently (today), after putting it off for so long and only just started watching Brotherhood. Scar became a fast favorite and I've got waaaay too many screenshots of him lolol. I feel like he's so underrated and this video made me really happy. Thank you for making this! I think it hit the points as to why his character development is such a powerful message to our spiteful/vengeance driven society

Brilliant writeup! This helped remind me why I loved the writing and characters of this series so much.

You're vids, are absolutely amazing. The amount of work and effort you put into them is really shown not just through the length of the videos, but also through the amount of detail you give to the analysis. Keep up the good work. :)

Your character analysis is on another level.

Very good video, this is among my favourites of yours now.

I love your content, honestly. It's usually deep and well structured, and your ideas are new and thoroughly explained. I'm looking forward to more fma content!

This was an amazing video. Made me really re-watch this show now. Scar is a great character, but it's only a small piece of all the different aspects that make the whole show so amazing. You've more than earned my sub with this one.

I really like the idea in the show of simply not being able to redeem yourself after you've done something horrible & inexcusable, like partaking in genocide. And the fact that the characters themselves know that they have to face the consequences of their actions and don't try to justify them.

I love your videos man. Keep it up I appreciate the content. You help me understand myself, you helped me understand why I love these animes so much. Thank you.

I just finished FMA and I couldn't wait to start watching your content on it. I really enjoyed this video as Scar was one of my favorite characters. It was so interesting to see a man possessed by vengeance consistently show many redeeming qualities, and continue to grow until the very end of the story. You nailed his character arc perfectly. Great job.

Yass! Another FMA video and it was over 20 minutes long thank you thank you thank you! i love character redemption arcs, and i got that feel from Scar...the subtle changes at first in his radical way of thinking, until we get to the point where he fights alongside his former enemies.

Scar is easily one of my favorite villans and antiheros And something you brought up about scar giving up his revenge, I kind of like how he does the opposite in the 2003 series when he transmutes the city of leyore

A SATURDAY upload?! Oh hells yeah!

Your attention to detail is impeccable. I saw aspects of Scar here that I missed during the days watching and reading. The lessons that can be taken seem startlingly simple, but are very deeply complex when explored. Thanks for your hard work.

Great video! Loved that you referenced KOTOR

Scar's Anger is justified.

One of the best revenge plotlines executed in anime. Naruto should've taken a few pointers from FMA ^^

21:55-22:02 Love how you reference the other FMA anime without even mentioning it! Just love it!

I love it. Scar was never one of my favorite characters but I never underestimated his importance in the narrative. I also love how his story arc loops into Roy's by the end with Envy. Great video as always.

I was chastised and punished for exhibiting any rage and anger at all when I was a child. It was my instructors' way of ensuring my subservience and control over me instead of teaching me to utilize and make productive use of my trauma and hatred. Rage does not taint a person. It does not render them impure or unholy. It is the most fundamental human emotion out there. I came to accept that anger and rage will always be present in my mind. Ironically, I found peace by accepting my rage, anger, fury, and need for revenge. It fueled me to help others as a means to reassert dominance over my own life. In my hatred for cruelty and savagery, I did what I could to help people. It was the only thing that made it easier to live with. My rage will never die. My contempt for those who tortured, caged, and shackled me as a child and stole everything from me will never give out. However, I chose my own purpose in the absence of a teacher or mentor. I chose for myself to make use of such pain and fury. I chose well.

Essentially, It's okay to be angry, as long as you use that anger in a positive way.

Yo man I gotta say I just found your channel recently through my recommended videos and damn. Your videos are always fascinating and deep as hell. I've been binge watching every single video that I can find cause the way you present things is very refreshing and nice to see. It's nice to see this kind of perspective on things. Keep up the awesome work and I look forward to seeing what you come out with in the future as I try and watch more of your fascinating content

Amazing video as always!!!!! I'm an oblivious anime watcher and always enjoy someone analyze themes! Thank you! Keep them coming

A: who is ur fav character in FMAB? B: Oh, i love ed B: i love El B: i love scar, and wrath, and greed, and mustang, and izumi, and literally EVERYBODY in FMA

Anger is the feeling of justice when you feel you have been wronged. When you feel you have been wronged by yourself or others. That can be good or bad.

these videos are very refreshing for me, or perhaps all of your viewers. Really speaks to me (or us) somehow in volumes. I am happy that I found this channel through Berserk.

The way you cover up things makes the subject much more fun and appealing to understand. It's really well scripted in a way that covers up the whole topic while still keeping the watcher attentive. Great video, great channel. - Keep on with the good work.

Man I'd love to talk characters with you man. Love your videos

Damn, I just finished watching a perspective of someone justifying the rage of Eli and the innocence of Abby from the Last of Us Part II. Scar relates to these two characters so much that its sad to see the world so gray, where no one will ever be truly right under rage or commitment to violence.

I've had all your FMA videos saved to my watch later playlist until I wat hed the series. After two years, I just finished it and now I can enjoy these videos.

Another beautiful presentation man. Thank you for your hardwork.