So I didn't really know what to call this video since it's not really my favorites but it's definitely not what I think is objectively best, so I split the difference and put one in the title and the other in the thumbnail. Basically to make this ranking I went through every show and picked out my favorite dance numbers in each one. Originally this was going to be top 20 but it ended up as top 45. From there I split the numbers into four different categories: 1) Dances that I think are pretty good and fun to watch, but not anything spectacular. 2) Dances that are really solid and enjoyable, but not the most special. 3) Dances that are particularly memorable for whatever reason. 4) My personal ten. These are some of my favorite dance numbers period, Starkid or otherwise. Then within those groups I tried to rank them as best as I could, mostly on intuition.
What all of this tells me is that this is barely a ranking and that I could probably never make a ranking of every Starkid song (seriously, how do people do that? Although I do know my top and bottom pick)