okay for all those screaming about how they had no chemistry and had "bad teamwork" NOT FIGHTING doesn't always mean good teamwork. Did they understand the assignment? Yes! Did they deliver REGARDLESS of the roadblocks they dealt with? YES! THAT is teamwork! Have y'all ever worked as a group with anyone at all? Being a team is not about being flawless, it's about working together to bring the best possible outcome. Which they did. They slayed the choreo, stage presence, and everything in between and won deservingly. They were being judged based on their performance NOT on their behind-the-scenes argument. As for the "Ice cream" Team while I commend Da Yeon and her talents and skills, she was being relied on for EVERYTHING and that is NOT teamwork when Salute had FIVE people working on the choreography. Stop using this as a reason to act as if Cai Bing is talentless and to hate on the group because Ice Cream Team didn't win. You are being salty and it shows.

I completely agree that most fans look for a villain especially in a show like this. I also thought you made a great point when you pointed out how not only Cai Bing wasn’t only the second “villain” in the show but also that the villains so far happened to be Chinese.

I feel super bad for Cai Bing. She's already too old for debut, so at this point she's just desperate to prove herself that she fits to debut. There's also the language barrier which makes it harder for her to express her feelings. When Cai Bing started crying during the killing part issue, I felt that. People say it's her being manipulative, but if you've ever led a team and everyone is expecting a lot from said team you're bound to cry. It's a human thing, not manipulative. Plus Cai Bing barely had screentime during the performance despite being center. No wonder she wanted to keep the killing part. This felt like PD48 where Lee Sian was center but Jang Wonyoung and Lee Gaeun got more killing parts than she did.

I agree. People were overreacting, although Cai Bing was a bad leader, it doesn't mean she's a bad person. We don't see everything that happens behind the scenes, so why do people think they can judge her over something so trivial?

can i just say... gp999 stans turn so damn fast lmao. changing top picks like socks🤷‍♀️

why don’t people understand that arguing is a normal part of teamwork?? not everyone is going to agree on everything and every team has their ups and downs. i’m so over people cancelling cai bing based on this, she was obviously stressed and overwhelmed

The people who are like 'I always knew something was off about her' are the exact same type of people who swore up and down that Jimin was a bad person thanks to their oh-so incredible 6th sense where they can determine the personality of someone thru their screens. No but seriously, people like them are so annoying. She might not have been a good leader but that doesn't mean she's a horrible murderer or something. She showed some flaws, big deal.

She might not have been the best leader ever but people saying shit like "i knew there was something not clear with her" or "she's showing her true colors" or whatever... Pls save it

I honestly feel so bad for CaiBing. What we saw was probably 5minutes of what would be HOURS of their practice. I honestly would give her the benefit of the doubt that her “attitude” was just her not fully understanding the context and meaning since they were speaking in Korean and a little bit of manipulation of editing. At the end of the day, she gave up most of her parts, she barely had any. They all shined and the performance was GREAT. I really hope this isn’t the end for her coz I know shes talented. People are really quick to turn their backs on you, and that’s so sad.

The Chinese contestants can't get a break like Liang jiao who was sick and had to go to the bathroom from that disease

Sooo... Has NOBODY that's judging Cai Bing ever worked on a group project? More so, have they never been the leader or the team member with the most responsibilities? It's SO hard when you're placed in that position. Groups struggle to organize themselves when everyone in charge is already a part of the group. There's no outside perspective to supervise everyone and everything and make changes where needed. Because of this, communication is key. And if you fail to relay information to the other group members (whether it be forgetting to do so, neglecting to do so, not being able to do so because of a language barrier, etc.), then there are going to be serious repercussions. It basically looks like she was made the leader based on praise and not merit. Being good at something doesn't make you a good leader. Look at my senior year cross country team captains. There were five and it was all a popularity contest (I wasn't one of the five). Three of them skipped half of the practices, one showed up and just sat around most of the time, and only one of them did the job that they were supposed to. It was so bad that the coach asked me to be an honorary captain for the JV runners because the one captain who was doing his job couldn't handle the entire team by himself. They just saw Cai Bing as the one who knew what they were doing the most and figured that they'd be able to guide the team better than the other members. It was clear that she couldn't. She tried. She just wanted what was best for the team. But ultimately, she didn't have the skills necessary to lead them in the most effect way. They still won, which is awesome! But it could have probably been done with less strain on the group. Seriously, a teacher gives you a group project and you get divided into groups via whatever method they choose (pick a number, random selection, based on grades, you pick your own group, I don't care). What's the first thing that everyone does? Nothing. You twiddle your thumbs and look at each other for someone to step up and handle leading the project. And when no one does, everyone finds some way to pick a person who can (usually based on who gets the best grades in the class). Cai Bing was that person doing the best. And unfortunately, it wasn't a position that she was ready to fill. Anyways, great video as always! You never disappoint! Now if y'all will excuse me, I need to write a song about sandwiches and rainbows lol

But what kind of makes me mad about the situation it that everybody got what they wanted at the end. The whole choreography changed from what they had in the beginning. Which means something happened between Cai Bing and her team and Mnet didn’t show how they came together and changed their routine🤦🏾‍♀️

See this is why I hate the kpop community. One wrong move from a public figure and they’re automatically a bad person. Instead of seeing what fully happened people instantly LABEL people this and that. How would you know what fully happened if you weren’t there? Did you consider the fact that there could be evil editing in play? Incorrect translation? Because there’s history about all of those with mnet and survival shows. In saying all of this, Cai Bing’s behaviour did surprise me and I don’t accept it, however, a bad leader doesn’t she’s a bad person. If you got nothing positive to post, I don’t recommend making a 14 min video about someone’s behaviour that occurred once and attack their personality and reputation. I’m sick of kpop attackkng and defending people when they don’t know what really happened or the truth or whatever. Just enjoy the show, vote for the people you want to debut and leave it at that.

People give in to the villain trope so easily because their not used to it. Like you said, we as kpop fans have been conditioned that idol are perfect harmonious people that never argue or fight. So when people actually encounter that, their immediate reaction is to think they’re bad people. That’s why it’s so easy for survival shows like this to create villains. The industry has ingrained that idols make no mistakes and are perfect, but if you stray from that them you’re the bad guy. People want idols to be their authentic self, but truly I don’t think they’re prepared for that.

Bad leader isn't automatically bad person. Not people name calling her over a trivial argument. Anyways she gave up her parts, the team won and guess who Do Ah ran to hug super tight after they won? Yeah Cai Bing. I am sure the girls moved on so we should to...If you don't wanna support her anymore that's fine but stop attacking her over an argument. How many arguments have you had in your life? 🙄

I think what some people don't understand about Mnet evil editing is that it's not just about clips they put together, but also what clips they leave out. Based on the end performance, we can see that Cai Bing let Lou Fei do her part by herself and when they won, Doah hugged her really tightly, so they clearly reconciled and there doesn't seem to be any bad blood... But Mnet didn't show us Cai Bing and her team resolving the problem bc they wanted a villian. A similar thing happened to Wang Yale. She messed up as the leader too this episode, but because we saw her and her team make up, she's receiving very little to no hate. I really hope people lay off Cai Bing and she doesn't lose too much support. This could be her last chance to debut and she shouldn't lose that chance over an overblown squabble. Edit: spelling

People are using this situation as an excuse to call her talentless and to say she only has pretty privilege as if she didn’t deliver on every single performance. Mistakes were made but she’s still one of my top picks.

I like how everyone is acting like they've never said something out of frustration before. 🙃

about the luofei part, theres also the fact that when they decided that she was doing the part alone, cai bing was not there, as we see in the clips, and then both of them decidided alone they would do the part together, so there was miscomunication 2 times, not only one, on absolutetly both parts, not only cai bing being a leader is hard, specially when you're not fluent in korean, and she should have said what she saud, but, in my opinion, if the performance was good and even won the benefit votes, its because they talked and sorted everyting out, but mnet decided to not show that and keep her as the villain

The fact that people were telling to stop voting her on tiktok just because of a something that happened for 2 minutes😭💀

As a chinese person I am deeply offended by mnets actions. Just because you need views doesnt mean you can disrespect certain races as it can come off strongly as racism.

i mean, mnet is showing a pattern for evil editing chinese trainees... they tried to do it with liang jiao, too. they made her seem not focused enough or willing to put effort in her performance, while she was actually feeling sick for how much pressure she felt as she prepared for her rap part. smh. same thing with yale and cai bing - they made them all feel like absolute disasters when, in the end, all their performances turned out to be actually good.

What she has said wasn't even that bad. I understand what she said, as a Chinese. She was just being a strongly opinionated woman. And yeah, people be like supporting strong, confident opinionated women but when women really do that, they get dragged. They have made changes a lot in the perf, that means Cai Bing did listened to the others, resolved the issue within her members and learned from her mistakes but Mnet didn't want to put it on the show because they want to make another Chinese the villain. Cai Bing was a flawed leader but she was trying her best. Do Kpop stans learn nothing about Mnet? Kpop stans need to know, Kpop isn't full of rainbows. It's a career, very stressful. Trainees and idols DO FIGHT behind the scenes.

At some point of the show I was wondering if Cai Bing would just stop being leader. Like honestly, when I was watching the whole scene I was like OK they definitely have some high expectations on Cai Bing 'cause she was in the top 9. They got frustrated after the interim and worried. People forget so easily this is a competition where all of them go one against the other to have a spot in the final 9. It is normal for them to get upset in this kind of situation. So watching the scene as a whole I was like, OK so now Cai Bing's gonna get hate when everybody would have acted the same. Like imagine you are doing some homework from school in teams and you are the one who is organizing the people, who gets who, maybe the direction (as they decided to choose Cai Bing as the killing part 'cause they wanted the sexy aura she brings), and all of a sudden everybody started to complain or to question a lot of things. All of us would have exploded, it doesn't mean we are being mean (neither one or another). People who work together have fights, arguments, they have the ups and downs. It is normal, as well as the fact that not all teams are going to have same dinamics. Like this is quite obvious but people forget... not any of the teams have the same type of teamwork, specially not the dance focus ones. And it is so nice someone pointed out the Chinese thingie... Like I truly thought due to episode 6 that Wang Yale was about to become the next villain. I don't know what it is that Mnet is playing but it should stop editing to make Chinese trainees look so badly and poorly. Fu Yaning, now Cai Bing. I am actually afraid for Shen Xiaoting and Su Ruiqi to be the next target to be honest...

I think the girls chose her as the leader because of her top 9 placement and nothing more. After Cai Bing got the comments about her doing the killing part or giving it to somebody else, the girls started to doubt her (which I understand, they want someone that will help them survive the round) and that what's "failed" their teamwork more than anything else. I think she did the right thing by stepping up and shutting the girls down at the point she did even if that irritated/disappointed them. Being a leader is not about playing nice and I think many viewers probably struggle to understand that. Seeing how talkative Kim Doah (I think I wrote her name wrong, please correct me) is and how ready she was to express herself and suggest change makes me think they should have voted her as team leader.

i saw that quote on facebook saying "these Chinese girls who joined Girls Planet 999 are very happy at the beginning, but they came home depressed." this is true. i hope more C trainees would express their experiences joining the show and reveal everything we should know.

miscommunication is bound to happen in a show like this. language barriers and different levels of training are bound to lead to tension between contestants in a situation like this. it’s so awkward and is honestly not very fun to watch

not to hate nor anything, the main reason ice cream didn't win was dayeon was the main focus, no hate but I could only see Dayeon in that dance, the other members were outshined by Dayeon, meanwhile, in Salute all of them shined, and this is a show where a TEAM/GROUP is made so obviously Salute win was going to win

I can clearly see the pattern on their choosing for the "villain" this time around... For one, the Chinese trainees are (mostly) opinionated women, and they don't seem to share the same "I'm a lady, so I shall not share my concerns out loud for I don't want any type of conflict...That is until I undoubtedly 'play victim' while crying in front of pressure, because 'how come you don't know what I was thinking?'!" mindset that looks to be ingrained on korean and japanese people alike.. Not that the other groups don't have a few members who do speak up, but it's only one or two, and it's not often either. And also, from what I've noticed(and I could be totally off here), koreans seem more "comfortable" with the japanese language than with chinese, so that would make it even easier to spice translations up and change the overall meaning of what was said, and have no one question it, kinda like what they did with Fu Ya Ning...🙃 Anyway, that's just my interpretation on this and sorry for the long 4ss TEDx, if anyone actually read this that is.........🤪

Not gonna lie, sometimes when kpop fans start saying who's a bad person based on the function of their group and teamwork or lack thereof I get a bit weirded out. The reason is because I've seen fans laugh or wanna know about the drama between their favorite groups. They like knowing the struggles their faves went through together and their arguements. For example the NCT haechan and Mark fight that supposedly ended up not even being real??? IDK if what I said makes sense. But, I think fans need to realize that the same thing has prob happened to or with their faves (we just don't see it unless years later idols talk about it or idols poke fun at it for laughs once they're popular). Any who, part of teamwork is getting over humps like this. and then fans usually say "see, working in groups is so hard, but they got over the hurdles UwU" LMFAO

Here's the thing with teams. Most of the time they can't be a democracy. Yes, everyone should be allowed to give their opinions , voice their ideas, and contribute to the project, but in the end you need a leader to say "this is good, this isn't, we're doing this, we're not doing that." A person with a clear vision on the project as a whole instead of individual concerns will always, ALWAYS, produce a better product. One vision is easier for an audience to understand than multiple ones.

Chinese contestants who get negative "edits"/highlights in the latest episode: Bing - MNET used her to uplift every other K members (especially Doah), Luofei & Chiayi dodged the bullets while Hayase & Moka ended up irrelevant with no screen time. She gave them enough material to send half of the writing staff on early break Jiao - illness and language barrier portrayed as laziness/incompetence Xingqiao - she laughed so lets spotlight that and give her nothing else for the rest of the episode Yale - least negative edit because she redeemed herself, smart legend! Contestants who could have gotten the bad edit but dodged: Jiyoon - if she was a foreigner she would be destroyed on that stage for her mistake. BUT NO! let's coddle and praise her FYN - MNET loves Mashiro so FYN could have been the target but FYN was smart to give Mashiro the leader role right away Jiwon - interestingly a K contestant! she got the greedy edit in first challenge but this time she let Mashiro & FYN take the wheels, tactical genius! Ziyin - too nice, MNET can't do anything....yet Zige - literally no highlight whatsoever but MNET does not want to afflict damages on Suyeon & Hikaru At this point I think the only C contestants MNET like are Xiaoting, Ruiqi, Hsin Wei & a bit of Wen Zhe. Next villain edit prediction (for fun): Ziyin - they clearly don't want her but she has lots of votes so...

Mnet just used Chinese trainees for making the show popular

Apparently there is rising anti-chinese beliefs going on in Korea rn to the point where Koreans dislike China more than Japan. It is a bit sus of mnet that both "villans" are Chinese contestants.

TBH as I was watching I was feeling a bit disappointed in her, especially since I've been voting for her. After I had calmed down and thought it through rationally, it does seem like a whole lot of evil editing and a little bit of miscommunication as you've said. Her attitude was still a bit questionable but it's not unforgivable like come on. As for people judging her from a 3 minute clip. It's kinda the same as it was with FYN. Everyone's starting to realize that she's not as bad as people (and mnet) made her out to be. TBH I don't even think she meant to be so bitchy, the way she stopped to think and had that nervous laugh makes me think she didn't expect the judges to ask her to say something to the original singer, and she improvised. Yeah it was bad, she's probably not good at coming up with good disses on the spot, and maybe shouldn't have gone for it at all, but it's not the end of the world, and Caibing's f up is not the end of the world either. If y'all ever feel mad at these girls just try to recall any instance of when you had to perform in front of people, and the feeling you had. Maybe that will help you have some empathy. It's not easy. Ever for experienced idols.

Mnet needs to learn from Youth With You season 2! No villain, no drama, just girls having fun and enjoying their journey in the show but still end up being the best idol survival show so far. I personally really like how ywy2 also allowed the girls to style their own clothes which is really helpful imo to express their self and personality.

These comments here are honestly so well-written, what the heck am I doing here xD

Oh my god. You say one thing that isn't the nicest and suddenly you're a bad person and don't deserve anything at all. Yet people want you to be real, real people aren't perfect 24/7 and are making mistakes, saying things they shouldn't because they're in a stressful situation so stuff like that happens all the time. I'm kinda sick of this mindset, expecting idols to be this and that and when they are, they're getting hate and being cancelled. You made fair points and I'm so glad we can have those kind of conversations here

And we didn't even get to see the whole situation. They changed Luo Fei's part and most likely ended up giving Jia the killing part (which we don't even know for sure because mnet didn't show it). I'm pretty sure the other members talked to Cai Bing or she approached them and sorted this problem out, but of course mnet is not going to air that part because they want to have some type of drama in the show. Even if Cai Bing could've acted better, it's just not fair to judge her when we didn't get to see how they solved this problem.

IKR SHE LITTERALLY GAVE UP HER CENTER POSITON AND PEOPLE ARE OUT HERE TRYING TO CANCEL HER YES SHE DID SAY SOMETHING WRONG BUT THAT DOESNT MEAN SHES "PROBLEMATIC" OR "NOT TALENTED"

tbh i feel that this is the reason why idols or agencies don’t show their practicing process as a video content. becoz that practicing is a serious matter but fans only think about the glitter and the group being great friends

After the Mina-Jimin scandals, at this time I will not point fingers who is good and who is awful even if there is soul proof that these claims and speculations are real.

The only thing I would disagree is that when you say this might not be MNET's fault. At the end of the day, this show is still a business matter. Their production team already knew how the audience would react before the episode even aired or, most probably, they all orchestrated these scenarios and tension way before such events happens. I think we all should know how to dissect and understand why survival/reality shows need to work this way. Unlike regular dramas that would automatically rake in viewers due to several factors like the actors' popularity, the plot, et cetera, reality shows are more focused on pulling or triggering the audience's emotions that would cause buzz because: 1) reality shows are not shows filled with popular stars that would easily generate viewership, 2) watching people do the similar things over and over again would decrease viewership, and most importantly 3) viewers cannot easily gravitate to people that they barely know. Due to these, reality shows need to cloak itself in its concept of being a "reality" show to maximize their viewership and relevance despite them showing only the partial reality or, even worse, a twisted narrative of the reality. Here we will understand why villains, heroes, underdogs, comic reliefs, and other reality show archetypes are important because they would generate viewership. Y'all should realize that even if how much you'd say that you don't care about the drama but only the performance MNET won't change their editing because drama = buzz = relevance = viewership = money. So, although it is obviously our fault as an audience that these trainees are receiving hate, we cannot conceal the fact that MNET and any other reality show producers are the biggest at fault here for needing to paint some contestants in the negative light for the sake of money.

i really want cai bing in the final line up ion care

Period! People are so gullible and easily-manipulated. I swear, most of the people who hated Fu Yaning before are starting to like her, and now the same people turn their backs on Cai Bing.

Mnet made c group villains and j group non existent

Friendly reminder that sana took dahyun to task in sixteen and now they love each other like sisters. Arguments and mistakes happen. This just shows me that idols could breathe wrong and be canceled.

I feel like she was put under so much more pressure and stress than she can handle, and in an attempt to soothe or fix the conflict she went on a rage (kinda) I think it’s kinda childish tho I understand her, she shouldn’t have been the leader tho, like she’s not fit to be one but I don’t think she’s like a horrible person or something, I think she genuinely wanted everyone to do well.

It's anoying that every time a trainee comits an error the fans act like she killed someone, i felt really bad for that girls

Very well said. And during the interim i had a feeling that Cai Bing raised her hand when everyone looked at her, she might have thought that the Masters were asking who is the leader. I might be wrong but that might be the case since Korean is not her first language. But all in all, it’s very unfair to her when a lot of people started to paint her as a villain after several minutes in one episode and some have lost their interest on her. It is really not that deep and it happened to literally everyone at least once in their entire life during a team discussion.

All these languages and you decided to speak with the truth! People are obsessed with villainizing other people just for the sake of having something to throw their hate at. At the end of the day they did resolved their issues and delivered a fantastic performance, which is what was required, that's it and I'm sure at the end all of them celebrated just as much as they would if they hadn't had that misunderstandment

people are calling cai bing a gaslighter when she was crying during the *discussion of changing the killing part* but imagine being in a group setting, okay? having members who doesnt have the same mother tongue and nationality as you... its gonna be quite difficult to *fully* express your opinions and ideas right? wouldn't you cry too? idk.. just my thoughts..

They made cgirls the villains because they're not from an idol factory in which most have fake personality. We can see that they had miscommunication in a team because many of the cgirls knew what they wanted in their performance and willing to expressed it to others and talked it out with their group, and most of kgroup/jgroup were not forthright of their feelings, and the show took this chance to make them the bad guy because they knew that more people are supporting cgirls especially Fu Yaning, Cai Bing, Su Ruiqi and Shen Xiaoting. The show even changed the voting system so that there would be more kgirls in the final group. They also wanted idols who wouldn't give them headaches, I mean look at the final line up. Their villains: Fu Yaning - arrogant villain Cai Bing - selfish villain Su Ruiqi - lazy villain Only Shen Xiaoting survived because she fit their idol requirements

In produce 48 the Japanese trainees were the punching bags and now in gp999 the Chinese trainees are :(

I rlly wish more people had seen this before final voting

Cai bings case is really tragic because she was top 9 and in the end she got no screen time and booted out of the show

I don't think Cai Bing is a bad person by any means. However, like many have noted, her leadership was beyond disappointing. Yes this is a survival show, but team work is vital. And if you think about, the way your team works together and complements one another can especially make or break the performance. She especially should have created her teammates when asked about the choreography. As well, I believe they mainly choose Cai Bing because of her top 9 position. As a team leader Cai Bing shouldn't have told her teammates to stop sharing their opinions. It made things worse for both her and her team mates by telling them to stop their opinions. I just hope all the girls are able to survive the elimination and work well in the future.

Those saying that’s she’s too old to debut are so narrow-minded. Like Into1 debuted this year and the oldest is 28 years old 🤷🏻‍♀️

All team memebers were frustrated planning this performance and righfully so. They just need to choose their roles better! Although Cai Bing is Top 9 and very charasmatic on stage she struggles with the rhythm and her members should've evaluated that before giving her the leader, and killing part position.

Cai Bing isnt a bad person, but a bad leader with no concept of teamwork shown in the clips and people are worried that the show designed to create a group to have someone in the lineup who cant reallt work with others. Shed be great as a soloist

If Cai Bing didn't get evil edited, I'm sure she would have made it into the group

check the latest episodes it's so obvious now with dayeon involved. they wanna make cai bing the evil villain and dayeon the angle savior so bad It's so messed up :(

Whether you like or hate CaiBing's attitude, her team ended up as the winner. And not just that, all of the members stood up. Every single of them. Sunmi herself said that. The Masters didn't know or care what had happened outside of the stage. They were just judging the performance in front of them. When it's succeed, they would assume the leadership was working. As simple as that.

Cai bing is a bad leader yes but judging someone’s personality by their leader ship is just absurd. I bet a lot of yall who hate on cai bing aren’t even near being a good leader. I swear if you’re idol’s real arguments were shown on camera you would bully them out of the industry. This is a competition where in every episode a whole lot of amount of people are getting eliminated so if YOU were going to get a killing part in a 9 member team obviously you would want to have it. And you’ll do your best to keep it. Cai bing also said tht “I would give up the position if majority votes.” Also she was quiet the whole time they were complaining about her. So to people who keep calling her names if someone keeps complaining about you after you make a mistake without giving you second chance won’t you get mad? Think about it rationally it’s normal to get mad when you’re just getting shit on without having a chance. And there were several miscommunication. If you’re working in a team there are going to be roadblocks. People are gonna have different opinions regardless of what they went through they gave an awesome performance and slayed it. Mnet is attacking Chinese trainees specifically and yall are buying it. Ya want drama that’s it.

You know what, am sure y’all’s faves did similar things like this as trainees but y’all aren’t ready for that conversation so I’ll stop

If you were to be put in a situation where you need to lead a team and perform something, you'll probably react in a certain way. If you were to be put in a chill and calm environment, you will also act another way. That's what happens when you were put in different situations, you'll act different but it doesn't mean you are completely like that. Same as Caibing, just because she was a bad leader in one situation doesn't mean she's completely a bad person in other contexts of situations. It's simply a flight-or-fight response but more complex. The whole team is just another case of miscommunication. It's alright that people were skeptical about Caibing now (me too with the way she acted as a leader) but people should realise if you were in Caibing's place, how would YOU act? It's ok that people don't wanna support her anymore but there's so many different perspectives that we should take account into, like the eve team

This is for sure that Cai bing must have apologized as we can see doah hugging her first after the results but I just don't know why mnet didn't show anything about them resolving the situation bts . Tbh I always saw Cai bing kind of nervous everytime .it must be really hard and she must be in a lot of pressure after getting the leader position and being the only top 9 contestant there on her team plus the language barrier. Ppl tend to feel really frustrated when ppl around you don't speak the same language tho when they can't communicate well enough with each other. And girlie literally gave up her killing part to jia ,had less lines and screen time but mnet didn't even show that . I seriously feel so bad for her.

the issue is that yes she was arrogant for those scenes and that wasnt okay but then she gave up some some of her moves and when we saw them perform and win they all hugged her and they looked happy together what the hell happened in the middle?? bc it's obvious they made up why isnt mnet showing us??

it’s not only the villains who are chinese, in ep 1 mnet cut out so many good cgroup performances and focused only on mistakes but made kgroup seem perfect

i noticed that most of the teams here lack teamwork, its like theyre all fighting for one win and it didnt help at all, Regardless, no hate to Cai Bing, but I think the leader position is not for her at all, she couldve consider the other's feelings or they couldve just talk for a second and find the solution to a problem. That is the main *problem* of most people, just because youre the leader doesnt mean youre on the top and have the right to dictate the others. But like I said, nohate to Cai Bing, its normal that maybe she let the emotions thru her and didnt think what she has said anymore, but Kudos to them that Salute still turned out as one of the best performances!

Are you like a defense attorney in real life lol. I love that you're always bringing the rational thinking and facts

In case of miss communication we have to keep in mind that chiayi a Chinese member of the group is fluent in Korean so they have a translator

okay let’s be honest i think what happened is for the better people rly don’t know how hard it is to take on a leadership role.Being a leader isn’t about being nice. people are struggling to digest this situation, the industry has conditioned us that even a simple disagreement could translate to someone being a bad person this rly shows how fast people can take something and run with it without knowing the full context and i’m worried about that cuz it’s becoming more common in the real world people should also rly stop choosing leader just cuz there the most popular in the class/competition.

People are even sending death threats to Cai Bing on twitter😦

also, the part the cc/translations saying “im the leader and i can do whatever i want” was just out of making her look bad. in chinese, she actually said that “i feel like ive said it so lets just go with it” (我觉得我说了就算了）this has happened to her multiple times and this was what led to all the hate she received

they showed 5 mins of a probably 5 hour rehearsal and suddenly everyone is ganging up on her RELAX!

please keep voting cai bing. mnet left out the key parts of their communication : cai bing gave center to jia, luofei danced alone. + SHE WAS TRANSLATED WRONG, she isnt the evil girl mnet just made her look evil.

Cai Bing was a bad leader but that doesn't mean she is a bad person.

Some people are just so hypocratic and insensitive they never think about how they themselves aren't perfect

#JusticeforCaiBing

This is the problem with these survival shows. You see these people acting selfish, immature and competitive because of the desperate situation they are in and it's manipulated and aired for the audience to see. Mnet really wanted CB out, I heard she's one of the older contestants on the show.

Cai bing was my top pick and she still is 😌

Ngl, I really hate how people are quick to judge. Like, don’t you remember this is MNET?? They will evil edit trainees they don’t want, and you literally believe the script/translation? Firstly it was FYN when MANY of you sent hate and later on you just automatically liked her? Same with Cai Bing. You liked her, and later on everyone just started hating on her? There’s obviously a pattern and it’s VISIBLE, aka EVIL EDITING. How did u fall for it? I’m sorry if I sound rude, but pls. Don’t jugde too quick. It really makes me mad

I just know that caibing is crying right now,knowing that everybody hates her😭😭 She is a nice girl i sure

When they asked who did the choreo luofei also pointed at cai bing so I think they misunderstood it as who did the killing part

I wholeheartedly agree and I blame it on Mnet for refusing to hire translators in order to spice up the drama like one of the eliminated girls said on weibo I believe.

2 things, this language barrier thing is hindering any kind of group work that could happen so as much as I love all the trainees idk if that's the best thing for a competitive show like this? Also Cai Bing should not have been chosen as leader lol like this is on the entire team like I think they chose her because she was in top9 and maybe doah or Jia should've been the leader. About the teamwork thing tho, some times it does matter because it's also to see how they would do in the top9, like end of the day you need to be able to work with people But ya this was mainly evil editing. They could've added some scenes where they were all getting along or sumn but noooo

Fu yaning case too (excluding her saying the n word before the show) But I don't see a lot of people defending her And why are people just noticing that on Chinese trainees are being done like this now?? Mnet literally digging the grave for Chinese trainees and painting the Korean trainees as angels 🤦🏿 I won't be surprised if only 1 or 2 slots are left for C-trainees

i will keeping vote for cai bing

Do people honestly except them to sit around a bonfire and sing Kumbaya as they laugh and eat marshmallows with each other? This is a *competition* that these girls are in because they want to achieve their biggest dream, there are going to be arguments here and there. People need to learn to just deal with it.

tysm, this really needed to be voiced! I definitely agree with you, we shouldn't be defining people and their personalities just based on what we solely see from short segments of episodes.

unrelated but it's crazy how we got the same first name, you are very correct tho

The major part of teamwork is fighting until you all agree in what to do

Always glad to receive notification of you posting a new video!

I remember this kinda happen to You Dayeon and she got eliminated although her individual ranking was higher.. so I'm kinda afraid that this episode gonna make Cai Bing eliminated..

Honestly when I was watching this whole thing go down the one that left a bad taste in my mouth was actually Doah... Throughout the entire thing she was honestly kind of acting like a high school mean girl and it would make all the other girls copy her. The bystander effect was quite strong with this one, because no one really seemed to have as big as a problem with it as her, but as soon as Doah did, everyone else was suddenly so upset with Cai Bing. The part with Zhang luo fei and her doing a killing part together and Doah suddenly acting as if someone just slapped her was I think the thing that was most off putting to me... Such a big unnecessary reaction while looking at the other girls to get all of them to think the same was incredibly mean girl-y and reminds me so much of highschool. It was intended to only be a way to alienate Cai Bing after she had just about everyone on her ass since the interim check, and I don't blame her for reacting the way she did... what did they expect? She was hounded by everyone to the point of tears and blamed for it when she did literally nothing wrong, everything she did was nit picked and scrutinised and she had reactions like those from Doah who was basically trying to get everyone to team up against her, which only made it worse. I was actually like genuinely bamboozled when I saw that everyone online was talking shit about CAI BING in that situation... Like what did they expect the girl to do? Honestly...

Felt so bad for her. Mnet editing is evil. Literally. They only show how frustrated the member with cai bing and all bad vibes, and the fact that she wants to be the center etc. but at the of the day there she's listen to the members n master dancing in the corner and barely have part and the fact that she listen to the member by giving jia the killing part..cme on now... I'm not hating the member they did right in some points. Mnet didn't show the fact that she did all of the changes that the member ask for. Mnet is a snake indeed. I'm not trying to be biased but it's normal people do have the bad sight but in this case, she didn't being selfish at the final stage so i assume behind the camera they did manage to sort things out. I'm so mad n disappointed that mnet didn't record or show that. Unfair.literally.

I smell like she will be new punching bag for kpop stan

one thing is for sure, people do be saying cai bing being in top9 is pretty privilege and then voting for kawaguchi yurina. like bro, B R O

Let's vote for cai bing let's save her