She's got the tickets to do the job, you get the experience from doing the job. Communication was what went tits up there. She said it herself, she didn't know what the signals meant, and now she does. That's called experience and no fucker I've ever worked with was born knowing exactly what to do in every situation they've found themselves in.

@@keithpringle3940 You're right. They aren't. Which is why it's best that the experience you do get is under good leadership and when you do gain it, it's done safely, supervised and there is someone there who knows when a person is 100% ready to take on a job/position which literally is responsible and in control of the lives of others. You know, so people don't die at the expense of "Whoops, now you know." She needed experience yes, but it was a bad call to just leave her there by herself. He fucked up. Period.

You know what else puts people in danger? Being intoxicated and assaulting your uber driver.

You are correct... captain's fault and he wasn't man enough to admit it. His ego put his daughter in a terrible situation.

You guys know she is a licensed 3rd mate with a unlimited tonnage license right

@@indeepship____3944Must be 19 yrs old, those licences can be revoked or suspended. Probably most or some of crew have their licence too and more experience. Just because you have a drivers licence it doesn't make you a good driver.

Max Fury i know look how they treat greenhorns she got off easy

They didn't miss it, they purposely edit it to tell a more dramatic story.

Good spot dude

Nice snipe that's actually hilarious. The editing there really gets you to believe a story that probably never took place.

Good spot! The editing is ridiculous I didn’t catch that

Yeah every show ever does this and normally way more exaggerated. Like normally they're acting like they're on a tight time schedule but really they are just pretending.

In my country before you can do anything like deckhand, captain, chief engineer or net stuff you should now how to cook meal.

Finch O'malley that’s not how it works most places. You start on deck work your way to the wheelhouse

Not really, so long as she respects the grunt work they do I don't think it matters especially if she gets taught first hand by her father.

Cameron White unless you can afford to start your own operation. But I can’t stand people that start a business without knowing how to do all the work themselves, I work construction with my step dad and I’m learning the ropes so I can know it all before I start my own. I see guys everyday start without ever working and fail. It’s hard to run a crew of guys when you have no idea what they’re doing and why.

It's not what you do. Its who you know. This proves that saying.

Imagine not having Mike Rowe as the narrator in your country... lol

She turned it off when she sat down

*Next Vid.......Captain's Daughter puts the Crew in Severe Danger, by attempting to make everyone Sammiches.*

@@drowningin you dont know if she turned it off though, sig said he had it off already

@@johnnybravo-ir3ev its on when he leaves you see that in the video, you hear them talking about how they dont want her up there alone and she hears it on the intercom. my guess is she turned it off at that point

Paidinfull agreed

@Hi Altitude When you're the leader you accept responsibility for everything. Otherwise, you're just the boss.

Lesson learned for everyone, nobody got hurt, next!

@RawbVee don't try to put blame on anyone else but him. He should have told her their warnings but he didn't. He admitted to being at fault, you can't think someone with watching experience knows these things.

I agree.

@@Deepwaterjew if she went to captain's school like they claim she should know this. It was 100% her fault she should also ask if she doent know but hey shes a woman so they will just let it go

TheBombDotCom Yeah for sure. Leaving someone with little experience alone with coms off and no instruction as to what to do when the crew gives a warning signal was a stupid move on the captains part.

TheBombDotCom She has a license to be a 3rd member. Yes, it’s her fault.

Once she took the Chair........everything is her fault. Oh No let's change the rules since she's a female. The Sidewalk-Shittin' liberals aka "Those Kind of People" would instantly blame Emperor Trump. The only chair liberals should ride in, is either the Electric Chair or one of the "Chairs of Cheer" that gets pushed out of an 80-Story Window.

MAGGOT VOMIT I said nothing about her being a female, I could care less about that. If you had watched the video you would literally hear captain sig say “ this should always be one, that’s my fault”. Your title proceeds you, because you’re clearly a maggot and nothing but vomit comes out of your mouth..

@@Tkjawa Oh I'm sorry Johnny. I didn't see you standing there.......... You may leave now.

Hahaha

It's ok the chef is Steven Seagal.

Gwildor lmfao! 😂👍🏼❤️

😂😂😂

Caaaaaacccckkkllllee!!!

Exactly! And, I feel like emergency / communication signals should have been literally the first thing he showed her. He shouldnt have left her alone up there. Thank god no one got hurt.

When you're own crew says uh oh that's a bad signal too begin with also

When a captain leaves the wheel house they are walking away from their responsibility. Sometimes this is ok like steaming and letting crew take "watches" so everyone can sleep. When working a boat he should have never left the wheel house with the boat under someone else's control. I am a father too and guilty of chucking my daughter in the deep end for her to build confidence, but he should have stayed in the wheel house and watched over her shoulder. This could of been a lot worse, also the crew arent stupid, they could/should of gone to the opposite side of where they were dropping and waited for a snap(they all knew it was coming) Glad everyone's ok and it's good viewing

Yes and no, she graduaded maritime school which means it’s legal for her to be Captain. She is still in training but she should know how to keep the crew safe. Sig should have been watching though, even if she is a legal Captain.

Eventually you gotta leave them alone. He can't be there to babysit forever.

@Les Brown so you're still ignoring the rookie call made by Sig? Putting his daughter in the Captains Chair without experience on the deck.... This was Sig's fault he almost killed them. Regardless of that happening.

@Les Brown no I'm not. I literally just said he put her in the Captain's chair without experience. READ. I know people don't like fully reading these days, and I wasn't being rude either. My comement literally said whay yours was saying.

@Les Brown I don't know what you're doing or saying in these comments.

@Les Brown yeah but you at least learned the plane first before you tried flying it. Not just brought up by your pilot dad with no experience. His daughter learned nothing of the deck the first time.

@Les Brown so your pilot license comment doesn't hold weight here

it was getting unhooked from the next pot that they were taking down right as they threw the lines from the one that was going over, one of those one in a million type deals

Will Smiff For not being taught what the signals were? Sig is a good captain no doubt. But he needs to school her on everything before she goes solo. Just like truck driving or piloting airplanes. You may know the rules of the air or road but what about times of emergency? Sig didn’t teach her, therefore the blame is to lie on Sig.

@Jeffrey Woods Lmao, you're a special type of stupid, bud. Please, do explain what part of captaining a ship is related to genitals.

@Jeffrey Woods Damn never knew Sig stuck his dick in the Northwestern to steer.

To be fair that's a freak scenario, especially considering it happened in the short time she was there alone. Yeah she should have pulled back the throttle but considering everything it's understandable.

@@beeman4266 You should check out how the main Discovery channel titled their video of this clip. Shows a very different perspective.

I will agree, she did do her best and her explaining everything to Sig, I do appreciate her honesty in that because she was inexperienced and didn't know those particular signals. I am glad Sig was calm in explaining that to her, just like I'm glad no one got hurt in a scenario that could have gotten worse

you dont end up fishing on the deck of a crab boat from having a high IQ.

FATBOIII have another doughnut fat boy. You’re an arrogant little man.

FATBOIII Two things, 1: you’re an idiot and 2: most of these guys make more in 6 months than you make in 2 years.

@@thultimategamer3230 i actually own a lobster license so they prob do make more but i also make all my money in a short period of time, but there is better jobs then fishing and it doesnt take a genius to fish

@@thultimategamer3230 like you said im an idiot and i can do it lmao

Exactly. It's the crews fault

Keep in mind a forward wheel house does not help.

@@reddale6004 No, but it certainly looks a hell of a lot nicer. Lol. And it does protect the guys on deck from the weather a bit better.

Not even that. Fans just understand that even with her graduation training at the academy, Mandy is in NO POSITION to be helming a captain's chair whatsoever. She's way too timid of a person. Needs to do about 3-5 years deckhanding before being handed the wheel. Sig basically said "cool, you graduated. I'm gonna screw over my crew by handing a completely inexperienced kid the controls of my boat and give them a 30 second crash course, and then leave them unattended for a bit" sounds like a recipe for disaster to me

I'm glad somebody else noticed that. You almost kill your team and then you storm off after you get your feelings hurt? Jesus fucking Christ lady, figure it out =/

That's how it is for white people sorry lol I've seen them fuck up so bad many times lol idk they even try working

They're called boobs. Those get you to the top

@@jeffcortez3301 all you see is white people working on theese boats ? Because they acctualy work...

spenser horton yeah and you see how many are replaced so quickly. Cus they really can’t work.

@@JavierGarcia-gx8pt so your saying that no white people are hard workers? Lol..

Dont think there is a thing called hazard pay in their line of work. Beer will do fine

Nice comment . Men wanting to blame her but sign said it himself . He didn't turn radio on . But a lesson learned right ?

@Christian Taylor we all are accepted into a roll to grow into. Every four to eight years a civilian is commander in chief of the greatest war machine on planet earth, the great USA.

Easy to sit back on the keyboard and talk about common sense.

@@Highplainsdrifter44 It should be even easier for a seasoned captain on an Alaskan crab boat with a green trainee at the helm. This is all on Sig and no one else. He was yelling with his hands around his mouth. A radio or hardwired intercom is would be better. His command was "slow down" when it should have been "neutral" and "hard right rudder". Every new employee makes mistakes and requires on the job training (OJT). If the job is inherently dangerous, then that employee should never be left alone, especially without reliable communication with the trainer.

@@Highplainsdrifter44 If you look at 03:59 five men at yelling "hook" while facing the back of the boat. They did not think to ring the bridge until it was too late. This mistake is on every man on that boat and not the Mandy. The correct action would be to call the bridge on the intercom and issue the command of "neutral and full right rudder". Hopefully, people learn a lesson from watching this video and reading these comments.

Yes but it happened and she didn't know to stop it almost killed that guy big mistake by sig he would been sued out the a$$

@@Stopcommentingthesamecomments can't sue. There are waivers the deckhands sign i believe

@@martinverner7390 hahhahahahahahahaggaah dude ppl have broken into ppls houses and sued when they get hurt ur not very smart if u think they wouldn't sue

@@Stopcommentingthesamecomments that’s why you sign paperwork

Jake not his son

Agreed

One of the perks of being captains kid and going straight to captains school is not having to work through being a deckhand

Its his ship and his business, if he wants to mentor his daughter he can.

Capt Phil made his sons work the deck first...... she will never have the respect of her crews once they realize she has never worked a deck

Well... the daddy's spoilt daughter won't break her nails working at the deck

Sig was out there when it happened. Watch again...

Well that's a bit more chauvanist (or "machista") then logical.

@@victoralvarado36 No it's called practical and common sense. My wife cant even handle basic home appliances you think im going to let her in control of an vehicular death machine? Dont be stupid and project your equality bullshit onto us, this is the real world.

@@ryufire12 whatever dude, you're not even worth the time👍

@@victoralvarado36 Considering you were pissy enough to reply in the first place i'd have to concur. I'm sorry if i hurt your feeling, maybe it's your time of the month for that I apologize lol

@@ryufire12 haha, your comments are what's wrong with people like you. You're a chauvanist, plain and simple. Good lick to you👋

well that, and Sig and Edgar are at least portrayed at times on the show to be Fire and Ice

Still would have been unjustified because he left them knowing they were inexperienced and wouldn't know what to do in case of emergency.

To be fair, I don't think doing that would have prevented what happened in this case. Its not like the boat would have stopped immediatly.

Perhaps not, but it remains a fact. Almost any dangerous situation is improved by immediately taking the boat out of gear (m.o.b/collision/wave/etc)

@@samueladams5243 agreed, but we have seen that taking the power off and even reversing has little immediate effect. In this case it seems everyone is trying to lay the blame of their mistakes on the lass because she didn't immediately take the power off. In addition, the lads on deck knew that she was in charge and knew she was inexperienced and as such should have been more vigilant, instead they got sloppy and that is why it happened in the first place.

@@cplcabs Completely irrelevant. "To be fair"? This isn't a trial. Graham is 100% correct, I spent 9 years in the USCG, you always take the boat out of gear when you are unsure of what's going on, period end of story. They damn sure trained us that way. And for what it's worth, this should be common sense, for commercial or recreational vessels.

@@extractedentertainment8213 No shit sherlock? Where did I state taking the boat out of gear was the wrong thing to do? (additional actions could also have been done). So in all your years in the USCG, are you telling me that the instant you took a boat that size (or any size really) that the boat would have instantly come to a stop which would have definitely prevented this incident from occuring?

Glad I'm not the only one thinking that.

didn't see it the first time but thanks

M E I don’t think what happens is fake TV drama. Deckhand made a mistake. There is only two people from Discovery on the ship, and I’d assume Sig would be pissed if he was told to put his crew in a dangerous situation.

Athena C.... care to discuss? I’m not saying you’re wrong, just interested to hear your take on it. Everyone should be able to look at both sides of the argument

@Athena C gender does have a bit to do with how they react in panic situations but 1. It various from person to person And 2. She was inexperienced

Jesus Christ apologies my lord! Your judgement is final 🙏🏻

@Jesus Christ your way or the hellway i guess

Many fishermen believe that having a woman on the boat is very bad luck

Then you wouldn't want to be on the crew of anybody, because the first year of captaining a vessel is always trial and error. You can train and prepare all you want, man or woman, mistakes will happen that first year.

@@derangedtaco3491 clearly she wasn't ready for the test and that's what he was trying to convey or do you think we should put new guys that have never been on a ship in charge.

I thought nepotism too and how that's not the kinda job you can get a foot up in

I mean he has decades in the biz and shes a kid... give her time lol.

tell him that yourself

mandy made the show different

@@rememrald30 I'm paddling my row boat out there as we speak.

odeis5 ah, you’re being too harsh on her. People learn through mistakes, no one is perfect first time out. Especially when there are many eyes on you. She’ll get there.

odeis5 calm down pussy