Kicking someone to stop them from being affectionate is NOT an accident!

There is no universe in which I would give my pet to an animal abuser, no matter what time of day it is or how much of a fuss he is making. I can't even imagine my dog cowering in fear and me dragging her out and giving her to the person who abuses her. I really, really hope she was lying about his treatment of the dog. If not, Daisy is the massive loser in this case. Poor baby.

Damn 22yrs old!! I would've thought 32yrs.

This case was more cringe worthy than nails on a chalkboard. They both need some serious help.

Watching that mom's face turn when the judge said "tell your mom to wait a minute, you're talking". I died.

She just admitted to setting him up to be the bad guy-- he's pacing and she's just sitting on the couch because she knows she's being filmed. She knows to behave herself so she's the victim while she antagonizes him. Not a cute look

She doesn't actually believe he's abusing the dog; otherwise she would've reported him for animal abuse instead of just giving up and complaining that it's not fair that she'll have to get a new dog

love when the plaintiffs evidence supports the defendant. CHECKMATE

That dude (defendant) was ONLY 22???!!! I'm 50 and I look younger than him.

You asked for 500 OR the dog? Yeah, sure, you care about the dog. 🙄

He needs to stop that hard living. He looks no less than 30 yet he's 22.

Not only is she constantly interrupting the judge but this guy abused the dog and you wanted a baby with him??? Hmm

oh she pulled an amber heard with that vidoe lmao

I’ve been binge watching these cases! Who’s with me??

“I just sit innocently, thinking about teaching blind orphans to sing, as he paces and yells at me 😢 “ *video is of her antagonizing him* While I don’t think either are peaches I really dislike how much of a passive victim she plays. She’s clearly a pretty aggressive instigator. And from my personal experience when a person says that everyone always blames them for starting things… more often than not it’s true. The few times it isn’t true they’ve brought it on themselves by always being trashy. Like the boy who cried wolf. At a certain point you get a reputation and people are going to not believe you when it’s actually true. That’s why you shouldn’t start tons of drama. From that clip and the setup I got a lot of insight. He has a short fuse and she knows what buttons to push, and she was pushing. He didn’t like being filmed and she likely already knows that, we start mid argument with her being active. Not passive like she set up (because she wanted to secure a reaction for court). I’m just glad they didn’t have kids. It would’ve been miserable for them to be latched together and drag a poor kid or more into their toxic relationship.

He's 22? Damn. He's not going to age well

If someone came to my house drunk demanding MY dog I would call the cops and tell them to go away.

Many people shouldn't be allowed to even own animals. Sad

She’s 100% narcissist. She pushes and pushes, then wants to record him to make him look like the bad guy. Smh

The judge is so wrong she definitely kicked him in the knee TWICE on purpose

If he kicked her in the knee TWICE and she required surgery to repair the damage, best believe he would be paying for that. It's sick the excuses people make for abusive women.

We had renters a few doors down that did a midnight run on the rent approx 11 years ago. Their mixed breed dog spent more time at our house being fed, she had puppies in our dog house, (We knew only because our son & friend heard noises coming from it) while they still lived here, the mother disliked her greatly. They left her in 90°weather, no food, no water, no shelter. We rescued her. Fast forward four years, and who shows up at our house, smelling of alcohol? The couple that had abandoned the dog! They were hinting around about taking her back. We changed her name upon taking her, she wanted nothing to do with them, clung to my husband, as they made excuses for not taking her with them. I held my tongue as long as I could, and finally told them they would get our Molly when pigs fly! (My husband was not sure if we were on shaky ground because we didn't formally adopt her) They kind of changed their tune slightly when we told them she was spayed, we think their plan was to keep breeding her. I phoned the SPCA the next day, was told they had no legal standing ... period! She is at least 15 years old, currently lying in our livingroom, after having enjoyed a bologna sandwich, one of her favorites! 😁

If someone is coming to your house screaming at 3 AM, then call the police. You dont give up the dog to his abuser. I dont believe it. Also, if you had time to record him coming towards you then you had time to leave and then you wouldnt need to kick his knee….

Dogs and pets are NOT for filling voids. They are responsibilities....

These two would be great for a reality show… the drama, the lies and the dog 😂

I love Judge Milian and I usually agree with her but in this case I think she got it wrong! I dont think that not feeling like being touched or hugged is ANY excuse for kicking someone in the knee hard enough to cause injury! And yes I do agree that the plaintiff seems to be trying to fill a void in her life with a baby or a dog. She needs some counseling and to move on with her life.

The plaintiff is crying victim She's not making sense. If the guy kicked Her for any reason, the judge would have flipped Out! Domestic violence work both ways!

I got Amber Heard vibes from this plaintiff.

I hope that dog is okay and loved 💙

That plaintiff is on the verge of crazy. I think that she wanted to hurt him... the video shows her taunting the guy.

I'd sooner see Daisy go back to the pound than remain with either of these two idiots. Neither really wants the dog. Both want possession of the dog merely to spite the other.

Ex-girlfriend "he is beating the dog" Interview " what are you gonna do now?" Ex-girlfriend “I get another dog and move on” NONE OF THESE TWO IDIOTS SHOULD HVE A DOG

If that exact scenario played out with the genders reversed, he'd be in jail and awarded $. Such BS.

HE's suffered a lot more injury at her hands than the dog suffered at his hands.

Dogs are property. Joint ownership does not defer to the female. So she sacrifices the dog instead of calling police?

WHAT? She sets him up and films it, she 'accidentally' kicks him TWICE and the judge doesn't award him anything, WHY NOT, even with an accident you are still responsible and you don't kick someone TWICE by accident. What is wrong with the judge, she didn't apply the law, she went by her own emotion, which is NOT the law. There's something off about the judge, I'm starting to really dislike her...

Listening to this the second time by accident, the judge said preexisting knee injury,that means she the girlfriend knew she would be able to cause pain and harm to the boy friends knee. So wonderful that they did not have children.and I think the judge was way wrong. I pick up the poop,it's my 🐶 lol

22 yo and still looking at his mom to sort out papers

I had to pause the video and laugh at what the Judge said about kids. I love my kids and she is soooooo rite . Nothing in the world can prepare you for this and they don’t fill a void . They create an entire new space !

Happy Saturday watching from Australia

Two very immature young adults who don't know how to be in a relationship. Hopefully they will learn.

Abuse survivor take - Video looked like reactive abuse. Her voice sounds taunting, not afraid. He sounds triggered. Doesn’t make squaring up on her ok. That said, to act like they aren’t mutually toxic would be ridiculous.

"I didn't wanna ruin his life..." HUH? animal abusers deserve their life ruined.

Sounds like he has a “mommy” problem!

"I'm going to kick you and your little dog too." That was funny. She sounded like the witch from the wizard of oz. 😅😂🤣.

Unpopular opinion they both don’t deserve the dog. She used the word replacement for the lost of her baby with another. Trust me girl nothing replaces the lost of a child. What she needs is to go to therapy and work through the trauma and not try to “replace” one thing with another.

I hate how all of a sudden someone who says something stupid interrupts with multiple ‘I knows’ cause clearly u don’t know just listen and shut up. Some people have the most childish mindsets

She is SO bi-polar... he needs to run and run fast.

22?...Sir, that's a VERY hard 22. 😒

I wonder what would have happened if HE had kicked her TWICE and torn her knee requiring surgery. I doubt the judge would have called it an ACCIDENT, hug involved or not.

Glad judge kept it real about kids. Agree with it all. 🧛🏾‍♀️

I don’t understand the mindset of some woman. Willingly want to procreate in a toxic situation just to have that sob story of being a single mother and we’re supposed to feel sorry for them. How can you possibly think a baby will fit in this equation??

That woman is a nightmare

It's so obvious to me that she had no problem putting her hands on him. She's baiting him so she has ammo to use later. When a woman pulls out her phone to tape u while she's berating you, run as far from her as your knees will carry you. Lol.

if she got the dog for free on craigs list how the hell can she sue for the cost of the dog when it was FREE

I did not like the judge's response toward the defendant about the plaintiff kicking him and punching him. Accident or not she injured him

Very bad relationship... Poor Daisy. Thank goodness they DO NOT have to co-parent a child together.

That’s some harsh looking 23 year olds. Life hasn’t been good.

TOXIC RELATIONSHIP. TOXIC ABSOLUTELY.

A dog case... I'm excited!!!!!

It's so sad when people wanna have kids just to not feel that void. Or they want kids because they think everybody else is having it. These two shouldn't have kids.

How is he 22? Also, if a guy I was scared of started demanding my dog I would call the police regardless of time...that poor dog didn't deserve this

When you ask for the dog or $500, you were never worried about the dog! Money grab for sure.

I think she was antagonizing him or she wouldn't be filming, lol. If she was really concerned about the poor dog, in the hall she'd not be like 'oh well guess I'll get another dog and move on' - wait, what? That concern went away quick.

I hate how much JM sided with the plaintiff. I TOTALLY believe she meant to kick him. She seems like a hot freaking mess.

She seems like the abuser to me...And Since when you kick somebody, and dont mean to hurt them?? AND...since when you get to kick somebody, and it's OK, because she didn't mean to hurt him. BS ...He should have won his case.

If a man had hit a woman on "accident" this judge would not let it slide at all. Totally biased

A restraining order because he was yelling

What an awful decision by the judge. The plaintiff should have to pay for the injury.

That plaintiff is toxic and the defendant needs to grow up.

If he had kicked her he would have been in jail and the judge would have nailed him for it.

Pets are considered property in the eyes of the law. These people need to watch more court shows.

Imagine if a man kicked a woman in the knee because she attempted to hug him.

WHAT? the dog is cowering away and yet she then gives him the dog anyway, thank God she lost the baby with him, because she would be claiming sexual abuse and yet would happily hand over the child. She's exaggerating everything...

The judge is WRONG. Reverse the roles, he is sad, she goes to comfort him and he punches her twice in the face because he didn't want to be hugged, I think he would be in jail for domestic violence, and would be responsible for all hospital bills. I pity her next boyfriend, she will physically abuse him and then when she finally get her baby, she will use it against him and she will end up physically abusing the child too. She is not stable...

Judge ! Shut up let somebody finish they sentence

That Plaintiff LOOKS & SOUNDS nuts.. She's not capable of taking care of a dog or a CHILD, OBVIOUSLY.!!

I think the Dog should have testified. There's probably more details that would be uncovered if the Dog testified.

Both of these adult toddlers have the emotional maturity of a turnip. Thank god they never had kids to use as pawns against each other.

If the plaintiff really cared for the dog then she would have actually sued just for getting the dog back & not for money to get a new dog. When someone genuinely cares for a dog or a pet & is scared for its life then the person would actually be willing to pay any amount in order to get the dog/pet back as opposed to suing for an amount to get a new dog if they can’t get the said dog back.

Probably a good thing that they didn't have a kid together.. they're toxic. Also kicking someone that hard isn't an accident

She’s going to just go get another dog…. Wow…. He’s no prize but she tried to manipulate the judge to see her as a victim

She gives me Amber Heard vibes! Her own recording wasn’t even substantial! And they never record when they are the abuser! Women will antagonize men and then turn the camera on and act innocent! He should have won the 3,000 dollars as well! This is another case of women standing behind women, even knowing that one another is wrong!! 🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️

if she cared for the dog that much ,,why did she ask for the dog back OR $500

Wow. The judge making excuses for the plaintiff.

This is what NOT getting an education gets u. Also bad upbringing from the mommy's

Imagine if it was him who kicked her and your her meniscus. It's just one of those things huh?

Daisy deserves better.

Sadly this judge's feminist views affects some of her decisions. I love watching the Peoples Court but I have seen it quite a few times. She has to leave her personal ideals out of her decisions and just go by law. In this case the counter claim. He was kicked twice. No accident

Prime example of why you shouldn’t get a dog with your boyfriend. If you won’t commit to each other for life, why are you committing to an animal that live 15+ years?

She's a liar !!!!!

I had an Ex like this before and everytime she would raise her voice the dog would run and hide scared! Breaks my heart to see this now

So if he would have kicked her after she tried to hug him, that would be ok and be considered an accident? Pfft.

If the show was on the other foot, would the judge be calling it an accident. The judge is a hypocrite.

Knew she would decide he was at fault for her kicking him. To me she really hates men

I'm a gay dude and I've been with a guy who had her personality. Would intentionally film and taunt and taunt. Ask questions then scream over you until your brain just.snaps. It's pure manipulation and it's so obvious what she's doing. She will forever be a fake victim spreading strife whenever she goes. The fact that she said she wanted a kid to fill a void and she wanted the dog OR MONEY shows what kind of selfish manipulative person she is.

Wow that's wasn't no damn accident she actually wanted to hurt him

Babies can't fill voids. Lol. They take your time energy & empty your pockets!😂🤣 Raising them is even more expensive apparently these days too!

Clearly, something is very off with him. Quite worrisome.

The judge leading the plaintiff.