ESEE 3 vs Fallkniven F1: Companion Knife Comparison

Рет қаралды 35,443

8 жыл бұрын

cedric-ada-store.creator-spri...
Good gravy its bricky on things
Subscribe and hit the bell! Hit like and all that good stuff.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/... - Full steel testing list for my cut test videos, free to all.
/ cedricada - support me on patreon if you like, helps me do the expensive stuff!

Пікірлер: 87

@rtodd279 6 жыл бұрын

Thanks for a good review. Love my F1 but just bought an Esee 3 for my son as I found one going cheapish on eBay. Ive been too scared to get too punishing on my F1 as I am not too confident about sharpening the convex grind.

@haroldclark9794 8 жыл бұрын

Good review. I've had the f1 fir years and use it for field dressing ducks, rabbits etc. and it's always performed well. I've often wondered about the Esee as bush crafters in UK use them a lot, I'm happy with my choice.

@CedricAda 8 жыл бұрын

I really prefer the enclosed handles on the F1, just from a personal comfort point of view

@jasonoconnor9446 6 жыл бұрын

Got both.. love both..

@davezito888 5 жыл бұрын

Yes, need both in every great collection!

@cycloneoutdoors7781 8 жыл бұрын

Its a tough choice but I think I'd go with the F1. On my Schrade SCHF14 I did a similar sheath mod, but instead of the cord like you had I took a dremmel tool to the belt loop and cut it down so that it wouldn't stick out the bottom wearing in horizontal on my left side.

@NorwegianWoods 8 жыл бұрын

That is another good review. I have been eyeballing the Fâllknivens for a while but you made the ESEE look rather tempting as well :) Thanks for sharing - Martin

@rpf1965 8 жыл бұрын

I own an Esee 3 and a S1. The S1 is just a little bit bigger than the F1. I like both knifes, but it turned out, that I take the Esee 3 more often with me for 1 day outdoor activities. The S1 is more often in with me, when I go on longer trips, maybe because it's bigger.

@steveanderson7554 4 жыл бұрын

Can you PLEASE review the esee 3 in s35vn and maybe compare it the the esee 3 in 1095 or to some other knives. . It’s an updated knife and I’ve seen no reviews by reviewers I really trust like you or DBK .

@jdssurf 7 жыл бұрын

Got an esee 3 for edc and love it. More survival self defense all around concealer. Buy both.

@caseysimpson1806 5 жыл бұрын

I have the S1 and the F1. Found an ESSE 3 on sale and I like it. For the purpose of a companion blade, the F1 is always taken in a pack-day pack, back pack, mountain bike pack. I find the Zytel sheath functional and it keeps the whole outfit very light.

@1911acolt1 Жыл бұрын

The esee3 knife only no sheath is 84 bucks.That’s where I live.But amazon also has them at that price.

@joshuagenovese36 4 жыл бұрын

Esee's Warranty is hard to beat!!!

@ozcampnhuntdan7858 8 жыл бұрын

I love my Esee 3 and wouldnt even try another knife because it does everything asked of it. the f1 may be better but I have no complaints on the 3.

@micheletennis87 7 жыл бұрын

Hello, I would like to ask your advice, I want to take a compact knife, robust and reliable to use in nature, are torn between the Lionsteel M4 stainless steel M390 or Esee 3 Carbon Steel 1095, you advise me which of the two? Thanks Michele

@CedricAda 7 жыл бұрын

+Michele Trekkning Lionsteel M4 if you can afford it, out of those two. Looks great and that steel is awesome

@AaronIsaak47 8 жыл бұрын

Lastly, Stainless VG10 over 1095 for food prep anyday of the week.

@unamusedarchitect1646 3 жыл бұрын

Definitely both knives are great. Like the convex better on the F1 plus the stainless means less knife maintenance. But I know the esee is no slouch.

@Luke-sk8ic 4 жыл бұрын

Nice video, thanx! As usual, Americans mostly prefer Esee and Europeans Falkniven. It's ok, probably it depends on different habits and tastes in outdoor activities

@johnnybeanz1296 6 жыл бұрын

Just a word of advice. I intentionally bought a fake f1 from a Chinese web site to compare to my authentic f1 from an authorized dealer. Virtually indistinguishable even when sitting next to each other. Boxes are identical. The only difference was the metal insert for the lanyard hole on the fake was loose and the fake did not show the lamination line on the blade. Get one from an authorized dealer.

@AusTactical 8 жыл бұрын

I've got both, the esee usually rides with me out bush because its been to hell and back, id be happy trusting my life to it in a hardcore situation that said the thin handle can hurt if your using alot of pressure to cut, but i like the feel of the falky more due to the wide handle but find i sort if skips in wood ( user error ) the sheaths on both come from different areas falky is more of an arctic design being a little loose so it doesn't freeze but is nice and narrow, the esee sheath system is awesome and can be carried infinite ways, both of these combined with a scandi edge would be amazing

@JustCantGetRight 2 жыл бұрын

I've always loved the intro of this video. *Channel is named after dogs* "woof woof" Pete: "Don't mind my dog"

@Kolibrichiti 2 ай бұрын

Funny how *justcantgetright* had the right on comment here:)

@numberiv1137 5 жыл бұрын

One for each hip

@ArikGST 8 жыл бұрын

For me definitly the F1, stainless steel is the way to go here where I live.

@ArikGST 8 жыл бұрын

+KillerDeegan ...... it`s in my name..... germany.......

@upbushcraft8882 6 жыл бұрын

And the reason why all as he knows are 1095 is if you forget your fire kit or whatever you can find a really hard rock and headed on the back your knife and it will send Sparks off of it because it's high carbon so that's the reason why they have such a weak Steel there's actually a reason

@justincase4382 5 жыл бұрын

I don’t think that’s the actual reason I mean that could be an after thought reason. I believe that’s when rubbing sticks comes into play. Maybe though I will look into the hitting rock onto knife for sparks sounds like it could be really useful

@AaronIsaak47 8 жыл бұрын

I think the Falkniven would get my vote just slightly over the Esee 3. I always have a Mora of some kind to serve me in this role as a companion knife. lightweight, tough and the scandi edge is better than FFG for woodwork but obviously your knives are stronger survival blades. Theres a Mora coming out with full tang 14c28n but looks a little pricey which kinda defeats the purpose of owning Moras.

@AaronIsaak47 8 жыл бұрын

+KillerDeegan. Nope. Only the classic wooden handle variety but I cannot find a broken clipper or bushcraft model online, there are reports of the blade snapping from over flexing. Im sure it would fail before the Falkniven would but they are sure strong enough for light batoning. Keep in mind Scandi edges will roll and chip easily with mild abuse.

@wizard9403 5 жыл бұрын

I find it hard to believe that the #3 out carved the F1!

@cwrowe 2 жыл бұрын

Good video

@josephmelchor7661 8 жыл бұрын

I feel like after so much use the over molded grip on the fallkniven would start to have play/movement...

@CedricAda 8 жыл бұрын

not so far at all. I would be more inclined to think slab screws would fail first.. but both are 20 year scenarios I would say! The F1 is beastly in its robustness, I promise!

@josephmelchor7661 8 жыл бұрын

+CedricAda Gear and Outdoors With all do respect, the esee performed better in almost all the tasks, and the esee is pretty budget friendly compared to the fallkniven. I would take the esee over it, and unless I'm wrong the fallkniven doesn't come with the sheath???

@josephmelchor7661 8 жыл бұрын

+joseph melchor well here in the us its cheaper

@CedricAda 8 жыл бұрын

+joseph melchor fallkniven comes with the shown zytel sheath. Yeah we pay a lot more for Esee here versus european knives like the F1. If the Esee was like... 120, It would kill the F1, but for the same price? I reckon the F1 is a more flexible knife. Just.

@josephmelchor7661 8 жыл бұрын

+CedricAda Gear and Outdoors the esee 3 in the states ranges from 98 dollars to 130, depending on the colors really. And ok, I'll probably get around to trying out both of these. And your opinion has value just as anyone elses, have a good day and take care from your viewer all the way in Texas. lol

@tigerou812 8 жыл бұрын

If I had the money it would be the F1. Not big on choils and I like enclosed handles. Just think it's a sexier knife :) . But if someone gave me either of them I wouldn't complain I would be happy either way. But I am happy with my Strongarm and my Moras.

@CedricAda 8 жыл бұрын

Nothing wrong with those knives at all, Craig! I would take the strongarm over most other knives in that size limit, without a doubt!

@tigerou812 8 жыл бұрын

+KillerDeegan To be honest I don't use a knife all that much hahaha. But I like the Strongarm and my Mora 106 or 120 it's the shorter blade one. These cover all my needs when I do need a knife. :)

@AaronIsaak47 8 жыл бұрын

Really Im suprised you guys like the Strongarm that much? The design specs are pretty average, 420hc steel etc. It looks like a cheaper version of their LMF which is now one of the only models still produced in the U.S. Ive never used one but Ive always found Gerber to be totally inferior to just about everything else on the market. I would never vouch for it after hearing reports of people getting injured by broken knives and parangs flying out of their handles. All that Bear Grylls stuff is just totally subpar crap mass produced with poor quality steel, sold in blister packs. Maybe Im totally missing something, im sure the strongarm must be a decent knife if you guys all vouch for it that much but over an Esee or Falkniven? To me its like comparing a Toyota hilux to a Great Wall.

@AaronIsaak47 8 жыл бұрын

+KillerDeegan Yeah okay, I didnt realise they were U.S. made, gideons tactical raves about it. Looks like it holds up well as a survival blade by all accounts. It wouldnt replace my BK4 as a survival blade though because these days, anything bigger than a Mora needs to cut, baton and chop well for me to bother carrying it and a 5 inch blade is a little short.

@CedricAda 8 жыл бұрын

+Northern Territory Bushcraft yeah, definitely a mid sized knife for mid size jobs

@dasta7658 7 ай бұрын

Interesting thoughts there. I own the ESEE 3 and the F1Pro., I don't know if the Pro makes a huge difference but there is no way the ESEE even comes close to what the F1 Pro can do with wood tasks. I use primarily Callistemon and Melaleuca (yes same species for those in the know) and the ESEE 3 needs a fair bit of work to get through it. The F1 Pro breezes through it. I will say the same for all the ESEE knives. The S1 Pro, A1 Pro and the F1 Pro don't need me to wear my forearms out the same way the ESEE knives do when working on projects.

@Frdtsl Ай бұрын

Which fallkniven is your favorite?

@dasta7658 Ай бұрын

@@Frdtsl I use the F1 the most because I don't do a lot of chopping or batoning so I guess I would say the F1. I love the A1 it feels so good using it especially removing a lot of wood and whilst it is heavy, it doesn't feel it. Do you have a favourite?

@BigTimberLodge 7 жыл бұрын

I prefer the Esse 3 for EDC and conceal carry for defensive use. If I am going into the brush I will take something else. I like how the Esse has a thin handle which makes conceal carry more comfortable and less noticeable to others. You did a good review.

@CedricAda 7 жыл бұрын

Nicholas Rogers good comment! its a great low profile knife with a good grip, and comfortable to wear against the body

@jdssurf 7 жыл бұрын

Nicholas Rogers spot on correct. This is what everyone should know about these 2. Best comment.

@ce4130 8 жыл бұрын

Hard choice. That lanyard hole position on the Fallkniven shits me severely. Is there any design logic at all behind that? The ESEE warranty means nothing to me, there are no warranty replacements after the apocalypse. I would have a lot of faith in Fallkniven 1/4 inch laminated steel, but wouldn't have much faith in the handle material. Having said that I prefer the covered tang for vibration dampening and see the handle outer being easily replaceable with cord wrap in a worst case scenario. While I prefer the easy care of SS, I would strip and force a patina on the ESEE blade so that it slides through potatoes with some rust resistance. I like the potential for high carbon steel to throw sparks when stuck with hard rock and I really, really like the utility of a hard, sharp edged spine for scraping. But, I prefer the flat pommel of the Fallkniven to the ESEE spike, although I would prefer a flat slab welded on at the base of the Falkniven handle and hardened.

@ce4130 8 жыл бұрын

I'd make a knife with a blade just like the Fallkniven, but with the addition of a rod of hardened 1095 with 1/4 inch square cross section laid down along the spine - if this is possible.

@CedricAda 8 жыл бұрын

+ce4130 would that be for flint and steel purposes?

@CedricAda 8 жыл бұрын

and re that lanyard hole? No, no idea if they mean it to be in a weird spot for a reason! It doesnt really need one but it does ensure I'll never try one either!

@ce4130 8 жыл бұрын

+CedricAda Gear and Outdoors. Yep, glad you could decipher my comment, it's hard trying to compress roaming thoughts into a tiny character limit using a tiny keypad. I just like the idea of flint/steel capability in a knife which could find itself pushed into service as a survival knife, as astronomically unlikely as that is, it is the fantasy, and if for nothing but academic exercise I'm sticking with it! Also, you mentioned the spine of Fallkniven was quite soft, so I picture this high carbon spine being hardened for scraping. Perhaps to maintain lateral ductility and resilience across blade as a whole the softer laminate could be formed in a H or upside down U section with the carbon steel keyed into the top of the H or stuck on top of the upside down U. I don't know if possible to forge these materials together in such an arrangement. It might be easier to incorporate some high carbon steel into a pommel that bolts onto the tang inside the handle... still leaves soft spine issue.

@ce4130 8 жыл бұрын

+ce4130 Actually, maybe a thin layer of high carbon steel could wrap over the spine. I really don't know what I am talking about!

@paulie4x1 8 жыл бұрын

Say Heah Cedric'A, I bet the Fallkniven F-1 is your Fav's atleast that's the one I would pic..I was going to get one since I have the A-1,, But instead I'm going with the H-1 indtead.

@Pointman-LiveWire 6 ай бұрын

I’d take the Esee

@leepierro8398 8 жыл бұрын

f1 definitely better than esee 3, but love them both, but wow in the states I feel bad your paying so much :(

@upbushcraft8882 6 жыл бұрын

You got to think to the esee knives are both left and right-handed to

@johnzane3977 7 жыл бұрын

I apologize for being rude but you can pick either up right around $100. give or take.

@CedricAda 7 жыл бұрын

John nacho Not in australia 😞

@johnzane3977 7 жыл бұрын

CedricAda Gear and Outdoors that sucks.

@LCO213 7 жыл бұрын

John nacho the Ontario Rat 3 is just like the ESEE but a little more affordable. The Fallkniven WM1 is surprisingly affordable, but smaller than the F1.

@johnzane3977 7 жыл бұрын

LCO213 the only difference in the 1095 from esee vs 1095 from Ontario is the heat treat. my understanding is that Rowen industries who produce esee knives has the best 1095 heat treat in the business. I can't say from experience though because I only own esee knives besides a rat 1 folder. seems to me you can't go wrong with either.

@schlooonginator1227 6 жыл бұрын

Esee are great knives but they are overhyped. You basically pay for or subsidize people who are careless. I am pretty sure the Fallkniven is a pricier knife in North America...and it should be, its a better knife. For that size especially, the stainless and just the technology of the F1 is far superior to the 3 then theres the superior convex geometry. For its size class the F1 is tough to beat. Wow, in Canada they are also similar in price...crazy. No way would I spend $175 on either.

@patriceb26 4 жыл бұрын

Bonjour So which one is the best?

@GAUROCH2 2 жыл бұрын

I would not have a F1, I do not know exactly why, but I hate that knife! ...But I am waiting for my ESEE 3 to arrive today or tomorrow! My Isula II had served me well for several years...

@shamitoson 7 жыл бұрын

F1 all day. I have an F1 and an esee 4. Love the F1, hate the esee. The choil is an utter waste of blade. The handles are too thin and blocky. 1095 is a cheap steal and shouldn't cost that much. I also hate coatings and striped it and convexed the blade. I think esee are sooo overrated.

@DutchBushcraftKnives 7 жыл бұрын

100% agreed

@CedricAda 7 жыл бұрын

+Dutch Bushcraft Knives thanks for watching dudes! I just got the Esee 4 with the rounded handle. Thats a closer competitor, but I think I still like the Fallkniven a bit more!

@themando9904 7 жыл бұрын

Ill buy that esee off you.

@grizzlycountry1030 5 жыл бұрын

Sounds like you don't understand the point of the choil.

@_ky5824 Жыл бұрын

It’s quite reasonable to have a choil on knife,but Esee did it in a way that almost everyone could caught up on the edge. I wear S size gloves and still my finger will touch the edge of esee 3 even without a glove.