The composer himself singing this song hits different.. i'm just so proud of this man... Jongdae as well

A silence moment for the people who didn't find this masterpiece yet

NIve... I'll never get tired of saying how much I love this song. The lyrics and the melody are just so beautiful. I don't speak korean, but reading the meaning and listening to it everyday I have learned the lyrics by heart at this point.💙 Thank you, a thousand times, thank you for working with Chen. 💙💙 Support NIve, fellow EXO-Ls!!

Your voice is just so soothing, please do more music with Chen we are anticipating your future work together

Chen and NIve has different style and genre of song but they both sounds frickin beautiful

You made me cry... Thank you for writing such a beautiful song... Thank you for singing this song... Thank you for trusting JD... Thank you...

Anti: Chen out Nive : Chen song singing and Chen cover Nive song. Nive 🤝 Chen Swallow the antics

Uh, I miss you, Chen Exo, I love you, the sweetest person in the whole world. I wish you happiness and success in your life. Go and return to us in peace. I love you.

Both chen and nive are among my fav vocals and this, this really shows how different their colours are and yet, both are so so so beautiful 😭 i am so glad i found both of you..and nive's works are nothing but perfection..

you know the feeling when teh composer sings his own song, and it just feels so surreal... yeah, that is what NIve is making me feel right now... his voice suits this song so much!!

Aww. Chen, our Jongdae's song. Thank you. We EXOLS miss him.

Today, Exol's need this. Thank you 🤍

Thank you so much for writing this song, thank you for letting our Jongdae sing it for us, thank you for supporting him in these difficult times. I look forward to new covers from both, Jongdae and EXO 💕✨ thanks NIve!

thank you for writing this masterpiece for jongdae ❤

Anyone else thinks he look like Jack Frost here? And just wanna say his voice is so beautiful!

Thank you for covering Chen song NIve ♡ You make my day better :D

Covering or should I say singing your work so beautifully. I hope you and Chen make more gems like this.

Ouhhh I'm crying broo hella help me I really miss chen... this song remember me he's memories with his members and also Exo-l...... we know that we miss chen so muchhh lovelots everyone...

you're such a talented vocalist and writer i am so glad jongdae got to work with you💞

shouldn't be named as cover since you're the one who wrote this amazing piece :'D and gosh this sounds beautiful with you singing it!!!!!

Before you even start singing I just know that's gonna be a masterpiece.

Chen, you are in our hearts always go back to us in peace, I love you

Wow, your voice is beautiful, it reminds me of Chen Exo, I love you

After this cover, I realized how much I miss Chen. I can't stop my tears .... Wish he is doing well in military ♡

Thank you for covering Chen Song ♡ I'm crying 😭 I miss Chen. We will wait for him until he comes back 😭

woww.. I miss chen so much and I appreciate your love for chen I am crying 😭 do a collab when he back ❤️

와...눈물이 나네 ㅠㅠ 😭🤭😍

A masterpiece that made Chen debut as solo singer and NIve debut as songwriter.

BEAUTIFUL GOODBYE 💝 BEAUTIFUL VOICE 💕 BEAUTIFUL HEART💟 BEAUTIFUL SOUL💘 BEAUTIFUL MIND💓 BEAUTIFUL MAN❤ BEAUTIFUL HUMAN💞

thank you for covering Chen's song. Give support to Chen and Nive. I will wait for Chen and Nive to collaborate ♥ ️

I swear if you and jongdae will do a duet on this I'm going to cry a river!!!! And oh, thankyou for making me cry again 😭 your voice is sooo lovely 💕 I'll never get tired of thanking you for writing this song and trusting our Jongdae 😭💕 please do more of these......

I want that vinyl!! And thank you for making this song, for making it Chen's solo debut song and for believing, trusting and supporting him. I hope you guys collaborate again when he finish his military service. Please keep on making good music. 💕

Thank You for writing this. It calms me down. Thank you for being with Jongdae. You sang beautifully. Will miss Chen a lil less :'). Much love! #exois9

그저 갓니브ㅠㅠㅠ커버곡 정말 잘 들었어요.팬들에게도 사월이는 정말 애틋하고 고마운 곡이예요 좋은 노래 만들어주시고, 또 꾸준히 언급해주셔서 감사합니다. 나중에도 또 좋은 인연이되어 첸과 함께 작업해주셨음 좋겠어여🥰

I'm glad to you for this beautiful song and glad to you to wrote it for our Chen .... It's a masterpiece.

So freaking beautiful. It has now become one of my greatest wishes, to see NIve, and Chen sing this together. Imagine it.

It's beautiful .. I think I'm going to cry

دفعة متفجرة من المشاعر 😭🤍🤍

Chen would be proud

I will never get tired listening to this song nor shut up on how amazing this song is. Thank you so much for giving us such a masterpiece. I'm looking forward to another NIve x Chen collab once he's out of the military.

I love the lyrics. Goodbye could be beautiful. Breakup could be comforting and well-wishing. Feelings of loss could be healed by not forgetting the love together.

you writing this song was literally the best thing ever, both you and jongdae have beautiful interpretations of this song and I’ll never get enough of each 💗

Love it😍 so sad they don't do a collab together that would be awesome. I hope so much when Chen is back from military. I miss Chen so much ♥️😢

Please create more masterpiece with Chen. I love this song so much.

첸과는 또 다른 느낌으로 좋아요 ㅠㅠㅠ 니브님만의 감성이 느껴지네요ㅠㅠㅠ 사월이 LP 예뻐요!!

I love both versions. Thank you for writing such a beautiful song and trusting Chen to bring it to life.

I love this song so much!

The way NIve and Jongdae sing the song with full of emotions makes every fan cry and I'm not complaining.

Good job, we get another beautiful goodbye with another voice, thanks so much, and another big thank for chennie soldier

I can't stop listening to this..

Thank You 🥺🥺🥺❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

What a meaningful, fascinating interpretation of his voice, calm, peaceful and priceless, like the sky 💙💙

Im so proud of you....... You're motivator in my life...💚💛

I don't why i start crying hearing this .. it always feels like first time

I can't wait for your new song to come out!! Going on a NIve marathon until it comes out!!❤❤❤

not only you have an amazing composing skills but also singing so well. korean music industry need to looking forward to him. Thank you for Beautiful Goodbye *hearts*

Nive nim, keep releasing pretty songs okay. Waiting for your future collab with Chen 💙

I needed this song to be calm down today, perfect timing, thank you~ Let's protect chanyeol on twitter guys..

Your voice fits with the song so well!! Honestly your voice fits with any song beautifully 😅😊

my number one broken heart anthem 😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

im stuned... beautiful jus beautiful

Missing our sunshine way moore ㅠㅠ Thank you for this beautiful song 🙏

와 다 영어 댓글이네 목소리 감미롭고 좋네요👍👍

I used to cry to this song everyday until now along with NCT's My Everything. He composes the best and legendary songs of all time. God Bless you and I hope you never stop writing and composing good songs. I'll be looking forward for your future masterpieces.

히야~ 종대가 부른 사월이도 좋지만 니브님이 부르신것도 색다르고 넘 좋네요^^

an angelic voice indeed.. Jisoo sunbaenim, how could you do that ? singing peacefully, like you are in a bubble, to such high notes.. it's just like your voice creates a magical atmosphere while listening.. I really wish that I could watch your live performance one day.. fighting sunbae! u are fabulous ♡

BREATHTAKING🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹I LOVE THIS SONG EVEN MORE😢😭❤! TK U 😘NIve, you are such a BLESSING, A COOL BREEZE & SHINING LIGHT IN MY SOMETIMES DARK TUNNEL🙏🤗👏

This song, lyrics everything is heavenly for me. Loved the cover. Things every now and then reminding of jongdae.

Thank you for bringing the chen song with your beautiful voice......

Thank you for giving us this song, you and chen both sing it so beautifully ❤

*Its CHEN Beautiful Goodbye!!*

I fell in love with this song the first time I heard it and loved Chen and how he pours his emotion to it. I don't speak Korean but my heart feels the song. I googled the meaning of the song and now I can sing along too. You singing the song made me fall in love a million folds. Thanks to your ingenuity !!! I will enjoy listening to your song even more.. looking forward for more amazing songs.. Take care :)

Thank u for working with chen...i'm cry everytime i listen this song powerful voice but smooth break my heart

BEAUTIFUL GOODBYE IS A BEAUTIFUL SONG

Nive!

CHEN💛

드디어... i get what i want after waiting for more than 1 year... thankyou so much nive... ♡♡♡

Thank you ❤️

I just watched you on I'm Live. I am now a big fan of your's. I will be cheering you on from the USA. FIGHTING

Thanks for Singing this Beautiful Song from EXO Chen :)

I love your voice ♥️♥️♥️

I miss chen,,thank u for this cover :(

It's a beautiful song. And make me cry.

CHEN IS THE BEST MAN

I love this as much as love Chen's one

I am so miss NIve and jongdae rn

i loved this song so much when chen sang and i love it much more now this song suits both of your voices

OH MY GHAD I LOVE THIS SOOOOO MUCH

This is my favourite song from Chen, this was absolutely incredible 😭❤

Nive your voice are so beautiful ❤❤❤ you made me miss jongdae even more :'). I always brag about this song to everyone and ask them listen to this masterpiece. I keep streaming this song since day 1 till now aaaaaaaaa I feel like crying, jongdaeeeeeee ily ❤ thank you Nive

Miss him so much

제가 좋아하는 이별곡 중 하나인데 니브님이 작곡하신거라니 다 이유가 있었더라고요ㅎㅎㅎ 음색 감정 다 너무 좋아요

You didn't a amazing job I love it and I miss Chen

There are no words to describe this ,, your sweet voice reminds me of our dear Jongdae ,, we are one ❤👌🏻

Thank you for bless my ear NIve💕 Can't stop listening...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 캬아...바이브가 심장에 콕콕 박힌다!

UUUUHHH I really like his timbre of voice T.T NIve-nim T.T

Thank you for composing this beautiful song. I still listen to it pretty much every day. Both your versions are beautiful. You and Chen have angelic voices ❤

So amazing! The song in your voice sounds so beautiful. Very powerful and sweet. Please keep on writing these beautiful songs. Hopefully collaborate with Chen again in the future. You have become one of my favorite solo artist.

I recognize that I am a loyal fan of Chen, I love his voice and his music. I also admit that Niven did a nice cover, she has a nice voice, thanks for singing her songs. Thanks for the video, hopefully you can do more covers of Chen and in the future you might even record together. CHEN, my beautiful boy, take good care of yourself, we look forward to your return.

Literally so in love with this man.