When jongdae leave the army we NEED a NIve x Chen collab pleaseeee they both match so much even though their somgs are so different As an EXOL Im just extremely happy hehe

that's why I love NIve. NIve is multitalented. this song is very beautiful tho, it is one of my favorite Chen songs. yup I'm a EXO and NIve fan, I just love people who is multitalented like them. thanks for singing for our Chen NIve. ^^ ♡

I may not understand what is being said, but the LANGUAGE of MUSIC has no BARRIER .....SUCH A BEAUTIFUL SONG🎶🎶💜

I absolutely love the behind the scenes talk about the development of his songs.

Thank you for working with our CHEN and being friends with him!!

Nive nim, we're more thankful to you for produce a really nice song. Thank you for putting your trust in Chen. The song is well loved by everyone. One of the bestest gift ever! Thank you so much!

Thank you NIve for working with Jongdae in this song. It's my favourite ballad, the melody and the lyrics are really beautiful. I like the way I can picture the whole scenario in my head. You're so talented, I hope to hear more of your songs in the future too.👏🏻

So weird. Was literally listening to this song when I got the notification. Such a beautiful song

But I'm just so thankful that ge wrote the song..... Despite it being his first songwriting project, the lyrics are so very well written that despite not knowing the language one will feel the meaning. Not to forget how talented NIve is.... I'm looking forward to more songs by him. And of course songs he writrs for Chen in the future. All my love

Omg thankyou so much for giving this song to EXO CHEN ..... !!!

"There's no competition in music" -Jongdae

His voice is so beautiful that's why I really love him...Chen×nive collab please...make it happen...

I didn't understand ,but music doesn't have barrier . The song is so beautiful. The melody and voces woooo beautiful ,ART. I would like to know what he said about the music and Chen. I really love their voices. Edit:sorry for my english.

I really like the piano melody with the worm voice like CHEN and NIve

Thank you for liking Chen song that much♡

If Chen and NIve, were to sing this song together someday, it would be amazing. They both have such wonderfully beautiful voices.

I want more Nive × Chen collab 😭

I love how he sings a whole different melody using beautiful goodbye chords. Amazing amazing really talented

The song is really sad for me. I always cry when I listen to the song. The emotions that you put on the lyrics and the way Chen sings it is so good.

This song is my fav piece of Nive. It's just so amazing how Nive made this. I will never stop being amazed by this song. Hands down best song he ever produced.

He looks so happy when working!! I'm just glad he enjoys what he does it's absolutely beautiful how he loves what he does and it fits him too!! Love you NIve keep doing what you love that's the most important thing

Thank you Nive, for entrusting your song to Chen. This song is a masterpiece. Good job nive. Hopefully in the future you will continue to invite Chen to collaborate on each of your projects ❤️

Im not crying Your crying 😭

Such a beautiful song!!! I honestly just found out that NIve wrote this song...now everything makes sense.💖💖

I am exo-l and love NIve song, this is just like dreams comes true 😭😭😭

Wow Nlve you are so talented you can sing well,lyric writing , music composing. Thank you giving Chen to sing this masterpiece song.It was so nice to know how was it made.

This song is really a masterpiece. I hope you know that what a beautiful feeling you gave to us by producing it . I really want to wait for more hearts warming songs like this which you and chen work on . It was really interesting to know about the production of beautiful goodbye.

Thank you for breaking down this creative process for non musically inclined fans. Fascinating and fun to see how you bring such a beautiful song to life.

Thank you so much for working with jongdae and creating the masterpiece that is beautiful goodbye!!

Thanks for all. I love the song,and I need a colab with Chen when he returns❤️❤️❤️❤️

When I read the lyrics to that song it really was so struck by how emotional it was I cried thank you for making such an amazing song 🥺💕

omg thank you for creating such a beautiful masterpiece, it was this song that made me realize Chen oppa was my bias and its also the first album ive ever bought because of this song

He has such a beautiful voice When chen is back I really would love to see a collab 😁

I love this song I feel soo thankful you writing that and give uri CHEN Cheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeen my rookie soldier

Thank you NIve for singing chen's song your voice is fabulous

I can't hold back these tears😭

Nive, thank you so much for giving this song to Chen ❤️

i think the more calm notes suit Chen the best. i guess everything really happens for a reason :)) this song is such a masterpiece. thank you because this song exist ♡

I'm now really grateful for your voice crack. It's one of my favourite parts of the song as it shows vulnerability. Anyway, I'm hoping now you'll work out that English version you were singing 😅 It already sounded amazing 😊

Thank you for working with our chenie Hope he will be happy and healthy in the military Serve well jongdae-ah 💕💕

Wao gracias a ti por tu gran trabajo, y por apreciar a CHEN EXO-L te aprecia mucho

Thanks to Chen and this beautiful song I got to know the genius musician NIve

So happy to know nive, that your a part of this wonderful song, im an exol but im also a big fan of yours. Thank you for shring this.

WOAHHH CHEN's song omfghshsf m just so happy to see his name .... miss you jongdae

Im glad with the final result of beautiful goodbye. this song is honestly so soooooo beautiful. Thanks to all the mistake that turn out to be good thing and all hardwork they put in this song. jongdae voice fit perfectly with this song♡ would love if one day they get to do full collab together

So this is how the masterpiece Beautiful goodbye was done. It's so sad I feel broken every time I listen to the song.

Always grateful to you for giving us such a beautiful piece of art. I'll patiently wait for another Chen and NIve collab. Stay happy and safe!

I am today’s old when I knew NIve participated in beautiful goodbye :o

I’m just sweating from my eyes 😭

Such beautiful melody, lyrics. It is one of my favourite song. Exol here.

One of my favorite artist korean artist of all time...I'm thankful to him for making all the songs that I love..I'm also happy he wrote chen's debut song...it's perfect...I'm so happy since I'm an exo-l too...

Thank you for writing this masterpiece.. I wouldn't mind getting hurt if it's gonna be a beautiful goodbye ❤️ I'm looking forward for a collaboration when Chen's came back from military.. 🥰 Keep writing beautiful songs 💛

Thank you NIve

Wowwww Genius NIve!!!!!!! The melody is soooo good thank you NIve....

Thank you so much for this masterpiece ❤️ When this song came out, I instantly loved the song. Chen's voice was so beautifully heartbroken that I felt heartbroke even tho I didn’t experience it. It was nice to see how my fav song was born. I look forward to more Nive X Chen collab in future💖

We promise to listen and love the song always. Thank you NIve.

It is so fascinating to learn about how NIve gave birth to his lovely songs. His smiles and joy are beautiful to watch.

니브님♡♡비하인드 비디오 감사합니다

Nive has an incredible talent for emotional interpretation in music.

Thank you so much for supporting Chen

와 니브님 정말 천재입니다 천재!! 실수해주셔서 감사합니다 ㅎㅎ 사월이 ㅜㅜㅜ 진짜 젤 좋아하는 노래

HUWAAAWW i didnt know making a song would be such a ride!!! from all the accidents and feelings and the whole process in general🤩

Thank you so much I'm so happy to see you sing for our chen ~~~♡

When i was hear demo ver I said "woah that's why chen choose this song" omo i love his song especially "tired,who i'm,Like a fool,how do I and where is the love - ft hanin"

I am so glad to know how the demo was created, with beautiful mistakes that made the song so strong and impactful And I was so surprised about the top liner wow the mood is different Thank you so much!

I love beautiful goodbye. It's a really good song.

omg, I love this song. thank you for working with our chenie.

This is my first favorite ballad of Chen. thank you so much for bringing this song to life!

This song is my fave forever..love the alternate lyrics too

The song is very beautiful. Eventhough it makes my eyes teary everytime, I still listen to it until today. The first few seconds of the music gives impact to me already. Thanks for working hard. It's a great song!

SUCH A BEAUTIFUL SONG

ahhh I didn´t see this yesterday but woooow, I want to cry cuz this is real art, I really like how much he work on this beautiful melody

I love your songs. Getaway , How Do I and Tired are on repeat. Now I suddenly want to hear the full demo version of Beautiful Goodbye.

I really loved Chen’s album and this song especially… I felt comforted by the melody, Chen’s vocals telling the story and overall emotions delivered by the song… now I understand why I felt the healing and comfort from this song is bc it has NIve’s amazing soulful writing and composing. I really envy your talent and I appreciate your love for music it’s so inspiring and thanks for sharing these moments. Can’t wait to hear more of your work!

Thank you so much, it's really a wonderful song. So much love.

Wait so he produced that song?! Omg

Thank you nive

Thankyou for creating this masterpiece. It was such a beautiful song, I hope you and our Chen will get to do a collab in the future 💕💙

Oh my goodness thank you for this 😭😭😭 One of my favorite songs of all time, I love the combination of emotions and feel so so much. Will be patiently waiting for ENG subtitles 😅

1:27 "it feels a little sad" sir you don't know how much I teared up listening to this feeling like I've been through 29 breakups 21 failed engagements and 5 divorces. Seriously I can feel the heaviness in my heart physically. That is how personal this song to me is. It's one of my most played songs on my Spotify Wrapped 2020. I have memorized the lyrics by heart too 😢

FIRST OF ALL I AM A FOOL FOR NOT KNOWING YOU EARLIER!! I MEAN I LOOOOOOVED ‘TIRED’ FOR SO LONG BUT I NEVER THOUGHT TO LOOK UP WHO THE ARTIST WAS. BUT NOW I AM BINGE WATCHING YOUR VIDEOS AND I AM IN AWE AT YOUR UNIQUE AND POWERFUL VOICE, YOUR INNATE FEEL OF THE TIMBRE AND TONE OF SOUNDS, YOUR VARIED DISCOGRAPHY, AND THE FACT THAT YOU JUST WROTE A WHOLE NEW SONG ON THESE CHORDS JUST LIKE THAT!! MY GOODNESS...YOU HAVE EARNED A NEW FAN!! SORRY I’M LATE! :’(

It’s one of the most beautiful songs , thank you so much

*The Art of Ppicksari* 세상에.. 가슴에 콕콕 박히던 그부분! 그대가 멀어진 만큼~ 기억해요~ :') 이런 작업 비하인드 너무 좋아요ㅠㅠ

Thank you so much Exo-L are very thankful ♥️ Greetings from an Germany Exo-L ♥️

Me encanta CHEN lo escuche por primera vez en It's Okay, That's Love " dorama del cual ame, y su cancion era Best Luck es realmete un gran cantante. Igual la mejor voz q he escuchado es la tuya sin lugar a dudas !!!

목소리 자체가 아련해요. 지난날을 추억하며 듣고 싶은 음색이예요! ❤🙏

Please release the English version 😭

It is such a beautiful song. Congratulations! I really appreciate it. Thank you for gifting us with a song you wonderfully made and performed by by Chen

such a masterpiece 🥺

everything is so beautiful. The demo song, the original song before it changed, the outcome song. EVERYTHING. I still can feel the sadness and I'm still crying even from the original song. The song is really a masterpiece and an art

헐 니브님 데모버전도 너무좋아요 ㅠㅠㅜ 따듯하면서도 쌀쌀한거 진짜 너무 딱 4월이네요 봄인데 추운봄이잖아요 ㅠ뭔가 우주의 모든 기운이 모여만들어진곡이네욤!!! 사월이 제 인생 최애곡인데 비하인드들으니까 더 사랑하게되어있어요😍😍앞으로도 좋은곡 많이많이많이 만들어주세여

wow I didn't understand what you said but feels nice that you mention chen's name we want nive and chen collab when he comback

Thank you so much. This song really struck my heart when I first heard it in April last year. It's funny because it somehow makes me feel the pain of breaking up with my non-existent partner hahaha! Kidding aside, I hope you know that as a fan of Chen, I am grateful that the two of you worked together. I wish for future collaborations as well. I admire your passion for music. It's really amazing to watch you discuss how this beautiful masterpiece came to life. More power to you, NIve!

Simply beautiful.

Thank you for making this song

thank you NIve for this song.. this is a perfect 1st single for Chen as a solo artist. still having goosebumps hearing this song.. and still one of my favorite Chen song ever.

종대랑 니브님 조합 너무 좋아요 ㅠㅠ ❤ 앞으로 함께 작업할 곡이 많으면 좋겠어요 맡겨놓은 거 맞습니다(?

I know why Beautiful goodbye is great song. Both Chen and NIve have similarities when it's come to music. They are sincere and detail persons. NIve ask why April ? to himself where as Chen ask why do they keep relationship until April and break up? That shows how much they want to become one with the emotion of song. NIve look so happy when he shows us micro details when create music. And I imagine Chen how he must have work on it. He also feel happiest when he give justice to song. I just hope and pray these little but certain happiness continue in their lives. And we get to hear millions of such story from them.

I came here for jongdae but fell in love with NIve. Wow. Just wow. The musical genius overflowing in this man is so overwhelming,, how is one person so freaking talented??? The voice cracking was a great change, I thought it sounded more like he didn't wanna let her go and its like his voice is cracking coz its forced and hes trying not to cry. This was amazing- wow. I really liked tired too. This man- i have no words for this man- wow

Love you NIve❤️❤️❤️