Absolutely!

group among the People of the Book said ˹to one another˺, “Believe in what has been revealed to the believers in the morning and reject it in the evening, so they may abandon their faith. Surah 3 : ayah 72

JazakAllah Khair ahki Muhammad Ali this was another fantastic video the amount of paitence and cutting edge questioning amazes me every time, watching you go from street dawah to high quality livestream clips with the same quality of conversation is a true blessing of Allah for me and Allah used you as a tool to guide me alhamdulilah, It’s hard to word how grateful I am for your videos but akhi I make dua for your success, May Allah bless you and your family and continue to guide the unguided. JazakAllah Khair

He was a Hindu fake exmuslim. Hindus never talk politely they are satanic demonic in nature. No other religion is truth except Islam. Other religion worship everything except God. They call everything as incarnation and leaves God and leaves humanity and leaves truth and leave brains and leaves water to drink urine like cow urine etc.

I am yet to see any ex muslim come on here or any stream and provide a valid or intellectual basis for them leaving islam...clearly with any sense everyone can see that this clown of a ex muslim couldn't support his claim so he wanted fast exit all emotion no substance he embarrassed himself

Because most dont do their due diligence, this guy says he has talked to sheikhs without explaining what he asked for all we know he also could be lying and just lost faith overtime from my experience most who leave never bother to sincerely try and learn Islam unlike reverts for example which is why the results are the complete opposite one who's ignorant in learning leaves and the one who studied it eventually joins.

The brother asked him to recite surah Al Fatiha but he recited surah Ikhlas. It’s hard to tell who is behind the screen (especially with no face), if they’re Googling, memorized a few basics stuff etc and if they’re actually Muslim. Ahmadiya/Shias/NOI claim to be Muslim so we didn’t get his full belief to see what he had previously believed. I’ve never met a true/practicing Muslim that believed in the Quran and Sunnah leave Islam

Some ex muslims even some muslims they never have any xperiences being living free, follow the trend, socialize and doing thing they wanted to do as the style you lived in before you convert...free western life style...

Ask Allah to maintain you steadfast upon His Straight Path.. Hearts are between Allah's fingers, He turns them as he wills. No one is safe. May Allah guide us and maintain us steadfast upon Haqq until we meet Him. Ameen

Either ignorance or arrogance no third option. That's why there is a penalty for leaving Islam and that's why there is 3 day period where an apostate is debated on their reasons. If all their questions answered and they keep refusing then it's arrogance and the penalty falls on them before a judge by states law following Islamic rulings.

and also desires

Literally that third part is what every Pakistani ex-muslim comes up with, it’s always an Imam or a Muslim scholar offending them which leads them to leave Islam. Indeed Allah can guide someone and take that guidance away from them. They have endless baseless arguments to stay out of Islam once their guidance is taken away

He has a low level of intellect.

😂

I think he's Pakistani bcoz me too and even his accent is familiar like mine.may allah give him hidayat back

yes clearly sounded Indian 😂😂 or may be an immigrant(mahajir)

not south indian. either pak or north indian

Wouldn't be surprised. When i recently talked to a hindu on Twitter he was literally using many arabic words in his argument like they are too much into islam and they might have already learned fathiha and trained to answer how many rakats in fathiha😂

It does sounds like an indian accent ngl lol

This had me on the floor😭😭 what a clown😂

Lmao😂

Lol I cant-

😂

Totally agree with you brother

Definitely it increases our Iman

When people see suffering, hardship and evil some will think god doesn't exist. Some will belive in god becuse Satan exist. There is a creator who created satan in the first place . Allah said he will test people to see who is sincere. He guide and misguide many. He only misguide people those who dont belive in god and don't follow his instructions given in quran. They suffer more later in life. They don't give respect to parents their kids become like them. They do adultery they get sick, face abortion. They drink louse their mind and cause accidents. They take interest, government goes in debt in long run. They allow change gender as freedom , population declines. This are limited fun. Doesn't last long😂

Yes but it has mistakes. Semen doesn't come from between backbone and ribs.

@@redfordkobayashi6936and the Quran doesn’t state that. It’s a lack of your understanding of the Arabic language. I’m just a beginner in learning it and even I can tell you the Quran does not say that. It’s just the translation is not really exact. Arabic is an amazing language. Imagine there is no word equivalent to “a” or “is” the word used in the language will already have it included. Ex. In English we say: she said, he said, they said, we said, I said…..in Arabic there are words used that is one word but it will already contain the meaning of if one man said it, or one woman said it, or two men said it or two women or many men and many women or even many men and women! I love learning Arabic….the richness of it is amazing. I am not a native Arabic speaker but am learning it so that I can read Quran and understand it the way it was revealed. Also I want to add. In Arabic the ending sound will tell you whether the subject is owned or is the owner. Hence why I told you, the Quran does not say the semen comes from that area but is referring to the actual human descending from that area. And as a woman who has had children o can confirm to you that the baby in our wombs do reside in between our ribs and backbone. To such an extent that when it is very near to childbirth we have difficulty breathing sometimes lol. I’m hoping that you read this and that it will broaden your understanding of where we are coming from. Peace :)

Habibi your brother from Tunisia here also ☺️🇹🇳🇹🇳❤️❤️🇲🇦🇲🇦

When he did recite surah al ikhlaas he didn't finish it and this is one of the shortest surah in the Holy Quran !...

@@Abou_Salahedine and it is very easy

He started in the most sarcastic and superficial way ever....disgusting

Who is « they » ? There is only one people talking to Ali in this video

Welcome to Islam sis I in Australia too and a revert for 30 years.Any questions happy to help

Nice one 😂

What? Is that true?

😂😂😂

​@@hnp9007no the ex muslims all of them claim that their are imams

😂

group among the People of the Book said ˹to one another˺, “Believe in what has been revealed to the believers in the morning and reject it in the evening, so they may abandon their faith. Surah 3 : 72

They never a muslim before

When he did recite surah al ikhlaas he didn't finish it and this is one of the shortest surah in the Holy Quran !...

Disagree. There's those that have knowledge and they know 100% that Islam is the truth but they would rather follow their desires, and misguide others out of envy or evil in their hearts from following the footsteps of Shaitan. True kafirs

​@@PhillyPhilly1 Yeah..your comment reminds me of a story about a pious person that finally become a mur*derer of his brothers just because he sliped into an adulterous act..may Allah always give us hidayah and not become that kind of person

Allahumma Ameen

Allahuma ameen

​@@mahaditanugrahani6579 Ameen. Pray for me that I find a good Muslim husband.

majority of pakistan do sound like indians though

​@BrakaInu no, you have got poor judgment ... Indians have got typical azccent ...easy to indentify person is from India

Pakistani are Indian except the Afghans that live there

​@@MohammadAliKhalil Actually they are not many of them are related to the Turks Arabs Persian and as you said Afghan origins few of them are related to the Indian ethnicity. You can clearly see the difference in appearance of Pakistani and Indian individuals apart from some exceptions.

​@@umerkhan1564Pakistanis are not related to Turks whatsoever

Scam Samoon 🥖 😂😂

Don't forget Rob Christian and bob of speakers corner with a new guy who wants fame named "Val ministries"🤣

@@SussyBread1234 don't worry, once he becomes famous, Rob Christian will Rob his channel

​@@PhobeTracker😂

Don’t mention their names . Comments like these just make these fools more known among Muslims. I suggest u to delete this comment

Amin

Ameen

Aameen

​@fhq3 there was no monopoly. Muhammad is right, if everyone goes back and forth on points it's a never-ending loop. That brother needed to put forth his claim, what he believes in and why he left. But he couldn't even do that. His response was "so what it came true"

@@fhq3 there wasn't any claims. The other guy was jumping off topic and expected responses to what he said. Either you are being biased and cannot see how the cinversation went or don't understand.

Alhamdulillah for guiding you brother, and may Allah make you steadfast in the religion

@@zhamed9587 Amin. may Allah do the same for you brother.

For him to comeback to islam is to stop lying😂He was NEVER a muslim.By the way he did not read surat Alahad right..he missed a verse.

@@KodakAllen it's not about being Muslim and non Muslim. It's about being ignorant and arrogant.

@@KodakAllenu don’t know for sure if he was a Muslim or not. I’m 5 min in and he seems kinda genuine. Obviously he’s arrogant in the sense he left Islam

is not The Eyes that Blind but its The Heart that Blind

Polytheist???😂😂😂 wth tell me the story how can someone believe those idols but allah?astagfirullah. Was it because of a boy? I always thought these people are fake 😅 would you mind telling me the story? I can't comprehend it honestly 🥴 im glad she's an ex-friend

The truth is they don't read research that's why they become ex Muslims

And cowards they are ignorant cowards who don’t use there brain they are hearts are hardened there’s nothing we could show people like him he doesn’t want truth

What were you waiting for? To join him based on whatever he would of said? You should wait dajal he will convince you with arguments and miracles. I don’t think you have enough education or theological knowledge to know truth from falsehood you are easily influenced.

maybe something that he catched up that was a wrong information, maybe something he was missing but no he was just another insincere person@@higherfrequency444

His counterargument was that the prophecy about overtaking the two greatest empires of late antiquity by desert nomads with no standing army doesn't impress him much

​@@higherfrequency444 He clearly said : _i have learnt to never expect anything from apostate_ bro I think it will be good for us to know what kind of counter argument they have, so we can learn from it

Brother you never know, maybe Allah will guide him one day. Don't say things like this, but say may Allah guide him.

@@AboodXD maybe the brother forgot to follow up with "if they die on it, knowing"

@@tubera6086 maybe, but in general let's not make personal judgments.

[56:25] Therein they will hear no nonsense, and no accusations [56:26] But only the greeting: “Peace, peace.” In sha Allah ❤☝️

@Friendo65l3 fixed, BarakAllah Feek

I agree 101% 😂

i agree, my father is indian and he tells me about our culture, because in india, it doesnt matter what the facts are, the older you are or if your a hindu debating someone else, you MUST be correct, even if you arent factually, you will get shouted at and they will make you feel like you are in the wrong when you arent.

Ahahahahaha

😂😂😂😂

@@thedrbat9572Eh, thats more out of respect than anything else. No real issue with it

When the so called ex-Muslim did recite Surat al ikhlaas he didn't finish it and this is one of the shortest Surata in the Holy Quran !...Not sure he was an ex Muslim

He probably could very well be a muslim. Bunch of sad muslims who never knew their religion in the first place.

​@@justsaying444sounds like you know him personally? If he's a real Muslim why he wrongly recited the surah? You're not even a Muslim so don't ever talk about something you don't know about. Listen to the whole video. May Allah guide you.

@dreadinside654 it is time for you to come out of your bubble or internet sphere and interact with real people so you can accept the idea that there are many muslims who do not believe in Islam anymore . Yes, i can tell that he is from Pakistan because i am from Pakistan too, and being a social worker, i met people like him who had stayed away from deen far too long to question it, liberal collage education, not good family structure, stuggles in life, trauma, whatever the reason may be. Many do not declare it because of the fear of the families. And as to why he couldn't recite surah ikhlas.. well, a few years ago, a pakistani cabinit minister couldn't recite surah ikhlas as well :) So, you dont use it, and you lose it. The same goes with the quran. If you do not pray and if you learn a quran in your childhood, never to return to it or ever recite it, then you will forget it too. If you have your faith, then be grateful to Allah because He is the one who guides, and He is the one who led stray. Also, do not assume about me that i am not a muslim , it is a slander, and you can get a sin written in your account. So May Allah guide you .

@@justsaying444Yeah he could have been one but never studied his deen which is sad. Probably spent more time doing dunya stuff. Imagine falling into disbelief but never studied it. I hope he stops living in denial and re-learns his deen from scratch otherwise he will regret it in the akhirah. Smh

Actually there is a Hadith which mentions a person who will ask Allah to register his deeds instead of Allahs mercy as a means of entering Jannah. That is a person of confidence, and yet will lose it after Allah shows how useless his deeds are compared to the mercy Allah has given to his eyes.

Very good comment.

@@twofain5719yes the man on the island

@@twofain5719that would be arrogance not confidence

😂😂🙏

lol. That’s the first thing that came to my mind - that’s not a Pakistani English accent.

They literally have the same accent 😂😂

@@bleekwater6176 not at all 😅

​@@bleekwater6176 nope! You are wrong

@@saltahir533indian hindus have a habit of becoming fake ex muslims in order to deceive people,because in india people are leaving hinduism and accepting islam,so in their fear,they started this all nonsense

This dude is a whole circus lol

Alhumdulillah 🥰🥰🥰

Masyaa Allah

Alhamdulillah ❤

What happened 9:18??

Me to bro

Actually he started the discussion with emotional statement that brother Muhammad Ali will be happy because he will be replaced with a better replacement

@@Assyaroni right off the bat that guy was trying to mocked the verse from the Qur'an by saying Muslims are enjoying and happy when someone's going astray because Allahu Ta'Ala will replace them with someone better. And he was being low-key sarcastic about that. But then same verse actually exposed him why Allahu Ta'Ala removed him from Islam.. The guy is arrogant and presumptuous.

​@@Assyaroniwhy is he so butthurt by allah who he believes doesn't exist and replacing him?😂

As a muslim i had doubts as well. I'm trying again again to gain knowledge. Even if i became an ex-muslim (i hope allah won't abandon me as he always guided me with proofs and signs ) i don't think I'll call myself one why? Because i can NEVER stop learning. These so called ex-muslims are fake OR they have no knowledge when it comes to islam.

And may allah guide you and me as well.

​@@icecream-wf5ybeven after seeing the proofs and signs u say u have doubts!!??

Ameen

Aameen

Its like watching a movie and the climax was so terrible that we realize all the build up was for nothing. Lol.

For him to comeback to islam is to stop lying😂He was NEVER a muslim.By the way he did not read surat Alahad right..he missed a verse.

Hey brother i want some help from you can you debunk the 72 hoor deabate

It's like bitter ex that can't get over it. They seem to crave validation because of the low self esteem.

​@@seanou2837 Because deep inside they knew they're ran away from the truth

😂 don’t forget Aqeedah al himaariyah

And the one Shaykh Uthman caught lying "I do istinja during sujood" 😂

And the best one " i told Allah SWT to come down on earth but it was Jesus(pbuh) who came down,Amen🙏🙏"

They now follow the gospel of David Wood.

🤣🤣

In sha Allah 👍🏼 We are here to support you But please make sure what u doing is for the sake of Allah and in the path of the Prophet pbuh, which are authentic. May Allah bless you.

But first you need to seek knowledge 👍🏻

InshaAllah

Try to be like the prophet peace be upon him in sha Allah, Seek knowledge, you will enjoy it once you do in sha Allah

I want to be like him, in Italiano or German languages ❤

Yea I think he is lie. His accent similar with indian, not Pakistani, Pakistani accents is different.

Yup, I recognised it right away. He is not pakistani.

@@NNJ20248there can be many ppl in Pakistan. We need to researched that. This particular person is not Pakistani. This is not how Pakistanis speak accent is Indian mot Pakistani

@@egoiisticprince7977 Jahil. He is pakistani. He has a channel called Desi Neo.

I am pakistani too, focus on his accent guess what it's indian.

@@IVEaLOVE yeahhhh I didn’t focus before.!!! Yeah that is why I couldn’t believe that it was Pakistani tone oh my God.!!!

Edit your comment please, we can't just let them drag our name through mud everywhere including religion.

Ngl, i thought this exmuslim will give us some challenges or new question like breath of fresh air but lol he don't even have question at all

I laugh at the caller arguments 🤣 😂 😆 It contained nothing..😅. He is saying about other people's argument and countered by our bro... so? Where is his arguments? Questions? Nothing.... Actually I was ready for his big big argument statements.. His sentences showed he got a big issues... But then he said about what was said by other peoples...ha ha ha...

Thanks, saved me from hearing the non coherent atheist's nonsense.

Exactly, like he seemed very sincere and then his argument was "(ok the prophecy is true) but what's so great about it" 🤷🏻‍♂️ the very essence of prophecies actually becoming great or impressive is that it comes true, and all the prophecies of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) have come true, only a true messenger of a true God can make true prophecies - what do you mean it's not impressive?

He doesnt understand that it is a big and unecessary Gamble to make for someone to make prophecies which on top of that are unlikely. What if 1 of these Prophecies turned out wrong, which many of them were very likely to turn out wrong, than he would have disproofen his prophethood clearcut.@@SuperheroKaif

He said he's from Pakistan

I'm from Pakistan but the moment I heard him, I knew he was from India. I've also heard many other Indians with similar tactics. Allah (S.W.T) knows best.

These are extremist Hindus who are groomed by RSS to spread fitna under cloak of ''ex muslims''.

Sounds more Indian then Pakistani.

Yes he talks as how he flips the prata.

Exactly! Brother you just said all the things that I noticed through out the video 😂

Orang bodoh menjadi terkenal karna kebodohannya......... Mereka mereka sudah putus asa untuk merusak islam. Jadi apapun dipakai buat senjata

😂 he must be a famous person

Indeed 😂… where is his pork and wine

😂😂😂🎯🎯🎯

Congratulations bro on confirming your place in Jahannum. 😂😂

Claiming to be an ex-muslim is a job nowadays

​@@richarddawkins4607bravo Liar🕺

@@richarddawkins4607welcome to club of rationality

what i've learned about the so called "ex muslims" throughout my life is this : 1- majority of them didn't practice islam much and they follow their desires and hate the idea of certain things being haram. 2-they actively start looking for "shubuhat'' to actively prove to themselves that islam is false just so they can indulge in those haram acts.. 3-they never tasted the sweetness of iman and salat and dhikr and tahajjud and Duaa and loving your muslim brothers and sisters for the sake of Allah they just were born into it and happened to be "muslim" but never actually properly believed in it. 4-they're influenced heavily by the west (like the majority of the confused people among us are) which is why the christians when they try to convert them they don't talk to them from a biblical POV they talk to them from a liberal POV. they pretty much invite them to become liberals with a dab of christinaity. 5-they hide behind silly shubuhat and arguments and "problems'' that are easily solved and as soon as you solve a hundred to them they bring a hundred more cause that's not the actual reason they left..they decided that they're going to leave and happened to then learn those things to make themselves feel right about their decision and convince themselves that it's the right decision. 6- some of them are just broke and sold their religion for a VISA or some money and donations cause they know it's a business now. 7-they learn about islam more after 'leaving' to prove that they didn't leave out of ignorance but ironically that's what makes alot of them come back to islam. but honestly speaking i'd rather them leaving than staying..we don't need weak believers..people that convert are generally strong in their faith so i'd say it's a way better trade and out of these so called ex muslims i only hope for the comeback of the ones that left out of ignorance alone..the others are just useless anyway.

​@@GTari-ob6bj Well said brother Jazakallaahu khairan

He is and never was a Muslim

Exactly ​@@GTari-ob6bj

​@@sumaaami925How do you know that? We don't so it's better we don't make judgment as if we know the unsee. I can understand if you doubt him, it's normal but to make a definite statement about it is wrong because we truly don't know.

Bullseye!! Great observation, brother

I made the same observation. It's funny that he made a claim first and the Question asked is based on the claim he made.

It's always emotional. Hence the verse in the Quran about following their desires. May Allah guide them it's not too late.

True 😂

ameen

Ameen

When the so called ex-Muslim did recite Surat al ikhlaas he didn't finish it and this is one of the shortest Surata in the Holy Quran !...Not sure he was an ex Muslim

Aameen yaa Rabb al'aalameen

Allah give and remove hidayah from whom ever He want

@@AssyaroniHe usually gives hidaya to the sincere people. Recently a career atheist accepted Islam in Kerala, India. He had a minor degree is Islamic scholarship, then became an atheist preacher for 30 years then came back to Islam. Even though he opposed and criticized Islam, he always did it an academic and decent way unlike most of the other atheists and ex-Muslims. He was sincere and Allah showed him light at the end.

Or following their desires

in their period? no wonder they're so agressive lol, just joking . althoug those i've know tend to be agressive

100%...i was one to do it but when i faced myself and reality with honesty i came back to Islam, Alhamdulillah

@@user-lw4gy9yz2b Alhamtulilla, happy to know that Allah swt moved your heart back to islam with realisation of the truth ....and my doa for you gaining knowledge and help those who need guidance ,as deen is getting lesser and lesser to our youngsters understanding, without proper guidance and programmes from Islamic institutions in each country, we will loose our young to care free life of not having islam as guidance and end up with only Islamic names.....May Allah bless us with great leaders to guide the ummah....aameen.

Like a professional waffler

@@homtanks7259 I’m talking about the Indian guy btw

@@abdullahyousef6308 yes I know

It's 'emotional' not immotional

Hermeticism also teaches stritct monotheism, are you saying it is also the truth? Your argument is weak.

@@josephl9931 You don’t understand Tawheed. You have no idea what you are talking about. Tawheed is not just “God is one”. It’s only part of it. Tawheed = Tawheed Ar-Ruboobiyyah, Tawheed Al-Uloohiyyah, Tawheed Al-Asma wa’s-Sifaat. Do your research.

​@@josephl9931bring your evidence, does it reach a good way of life?

​​@@kayjr9795Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God is one Lord:

​@@kayjr9795 you should follow your desires to do what you want in this world...no hell nor paradise waiting in nexlife Jesus save you already

There are 2 rakahs after wudu but not during wudu 😂

@@PhobeTracker ah lol then so before Wudu you do tayyamum? so you can do the 2 rakaat?

​@@irpanfauzi1160 There is a 2 raka'ah sunnah prayer after wudu

Most of them are indians

If you meet a "Pakistani ex muslim" that's Indian. As a Pakistani I have encountered quite few of them.