Diesel and Scruffey's friend dynamic is a great idea!

This time, Duck is the a-hole SERIOUSLY, Diesel was nothing but friendly. And even pretty humble for the most part.

Death toll: Gordon, Oliver, Toad, Toby, Topham, Fred, Percy, Donald, Duck Turns out Scruffy saying a quick prayer could save him and Diesel from dying

Now we've lost Duck and Donald, is it must be absolutely terrible for Douglas to lose his brother. I wonder how much faith and prayer play in this series. Scruffy said a prayer that seemed to save him and Diesel from being taken. Going back to the "Missing 411" episode, Edward said a prayer that seemed to prevent him and his crew from being taken at the old lead mine. I'm curious as to why that is. It also seems that whenever "Lady" possesses one of the engines, her tail lamp appears on them, I suspect it has something to do with how the possessed engines teleport around the way they do. I really hope we learn how in the coming episodes.

5:35 …. Percy is seen on the middle line by the bridge, but disappears a few seconds later … scouting out targets

I just love how many times I saw hidden disappeared/dead engines hidden in the background. It's quite interesting and quite makes the movie feel even more eerie.

Curiouser and curiouser, this episode answers a few questions and brings in so many more. I like the idea of D10's claw being "added" to him when needed, I also like to think his scowl before pulling up Toby was his own frustration of not being able to save another engine from meeting their demise. Nice to see more of D10 as a whole really, he feels like a big centerpiece in this whole mystery. I like that this episode gives us confirmation of the idea Lady is actually possessing/putting the engines she takes in a trance with the conversation between Duck and Diesel, not to mention how his backlamp is suddenly the same as Lady's. Duck's ominous line of "I must be off now, they're.. calling for me, we'll send another.. 'engine' to help you." is a very fascinating hint too, to me it makes it sound like all the engines are still "alive" in a sense, and "help" does indeed come in the form of Oliver trying to kill S.C.Ruffey and Diesel.. so that's really interesting too. I get the feeling S.C.Ruffey was lying to Diesel when he said he didn't see what happened to Donald too, but he's so traumatized and still trying to process the events that he couldn't bring himself to talk about it. I do find it nice that Douglas became a little more caring to the two after what happened to them as well, makes it feel like he's starting to warm up to them a little, though I do feel bad for him about his twin.. This is the second time we see a prayer in action though, with the first being Edward's and it seems to be the only recurring thing that is able to save the engines from whatever trickery Lady is causing, I get the feeling this will eventually tie into the Reverend, being a man of the lord it makes sense now that he will likely be assisting the remaining engines in some way to protect both them and the island. Also wow, 9 years of Oliver missing? That feels like quite the time jump with no one working out what's happening, especially with the soldiers monitoring the place.. perhaps this is because they have no idea when Lady will strike, as she seems to come out every so often to pick the engines off one by one while using the other's to "monitor" the railway for her next target. As a slight side note, I notice it wasn't said where Donald's tender was found which does feel like a crucial piece of information, is it simply implied to have been along the coastline of the Little Western or is that information going to be given in the next installment?

One more thing I wish to say. Given how limited his involvement has been so far, I think James is the next target. I do wonder if this universe’s James will fall to mind games played on him, get tricked, or go down swinging? We haven’t seen Spencer yet either. I do wonder if he will come into play. The Little Western is really down on motive power now. So perhaps we see the arrival of Wilbert?

Gonna say it. Didn't feel bad for Duck at ALL! God, he was more insufferable and pompous than Gordon (R.I.P Big G)

14:38 Check the shadow under the bridge. Lady is first seen. Then a few seconds later, Oliver is seen when Diesel is preparing to leave the shed. I'm sure there are more details like these hidden throughout the episode.

12:01 Percy seen once D10's brakevan moves away 12:53 And again maybe on the left edge of the screen 13:06 Lady behind Diesel 14:38 Lady's shadow on that bridge arch 15:28 Three vans on the right

Every episode has me on the edge of my seat because it just keeps getting more mysterious even when more is revealed to us. Great show lad.

Just noticed a spooky Toby at 4:18, love finding new details

I think toby refused accepting lady to become part of them, and she killed him and dumped his body right there near the buffers.

I find it quite satisfying that Diesel 10 is helping to stop Lady.

We are getting angry Douglas from now on I bet. The Scottish Twins seem to use rage to deal with loss. The question is, will Douglas be a greater danger to himself or to the evil?

This episode was something. Nice to see Diesel and S.C.ruffy have a role in this. The ending was something. I'm wondering what will happen next? You keep up the great work. Keep up the great work.

I guess I never realized how much of an asshole Duck can be. But it's probably the combination of stress, being overworked, and losing close friends.

I'm starting to notice how inefficient D10 and the "MoD's" attempts at curbing these anomalies is. Every time they manage to find a corpse of an engine, they fail to ensure that's its completely disposed of. Neither Gordon nor Toby were actualy scrapped. The only thing he's got going for him seem to be that the entities seem afraid of him, though that's questionable and could be attributed to prayer from another nearby character. D10's gonna have to step up his game if he wants to resolve this.

I absolutely love this series and the atmosphere it brings. Its simple in execution, but holy HELL does it ever execute that simplicity. It builds up anxiety and tensions so well just by telling its story, and showing a few silhoulettes in the dark here and there. Top class Thomas horror.

I love this series its started as a small thingsnd escalated to a full grown panic around the railroad and the military is getting involved

I hope we get someone who become a hero and find a spirit who can rescue everyone that is missing. Thomas and Diesel 10 teaming up and tell Lady that lashing out at others will not bring peace. She must let go and move on.

This is a really good horror Thomas series I can’t wait to see where it’s going.

20:50 anyone else notice that silhouette in the back?

Stuff you might have missed: 0:26 An engine in the background? 12:00 Percy 4:15 Toby 14:37 Lady shadow under the bridge 15:14 Percy under the bridge 16:20 Something out at sea? (probably just a rock) 17:13 Shadow behind Diesel? 19:18 Oliver? 22:58 ???

These guys are dropping faster then the cast of Glee

Finally got around to (trying to) keep myself up to date on the Forest series here. I love the use of Diesel 10 in this episode with the feature on how Pinchy can be assembled and disassembled. A very military thing to do, actually. I hope we get to see more of the alliance between Diesel and Scruffy which I haven't seem since the TCC's Night of the Diesels and Sodor's Finest. It was funny on how neither Duck or Douglas wanted to go out to fetch Donald so they over looked at Diesel and volunteered him. And the more I think about it, I realize that the taken Oliver and Duck are implied to have the intent of trying to kill those they have a history with, this being Scruffy and Diesel. Because the Taken Duck told Diesel to check the pier where Scruffy was and Taken Oliver then tried to kill both of them. But if that is a theme and when you wonder why Taken Oliver took Toad, then maybe the taken engines also go after those they were close too as well so that means Thomas and Douglas could be the next big targets.

This series has really kept my attention . What a genius take on the source material! Can’t wait to see how this continues to unfold.

Well, well well, it's almost Halloween, and after spending a day with some real trains, I look forward to seeing the continuation of this amazing series!

I’m sorry, but ducks “ great western way or the wrong way” is getting a bid

Man, the more i think about it, all the members of the little western are real jerks to sc ruffy and diesel. At least they were put in their place in this story.

Douglas is not going to be able to stay calm down and he would want real revenge

Glad that diesel and S.C.Ruffy are still alive.

This has got to be the most unique and interesting take on the Magic Railroad that I've seen in a while. Not only did you make Lady the villain, but she's also got what's basically the SCP foundation coming after her. Looking forward to seeing what happens next.

I wonder if Douglas will be one of the engines spared from ladies wrath. Because he would recognize that Donald wouldn't be acting as Donald if Lady tried to use him against him. At first he would be fooled, yeah. But I think he'd realize something isn't right with his brother. Here's hoping it isn't too late.

I truly love Ten being a somewhat hero in this. And i would love to learn why Oliver is scared of him.

I think its interesting how you've made Lady a "villian" in this series and Diesel 10 somewhat of a hero. The way Scrap Oliver fled when Diesel 10 came to the scene was intriguing! Now my questions are, Why is Lady doing what she's doing? How many chapters remain in this series?! And finally, how will it conclude?! The suspense is too much!

Goodness, there's quite a bit to talk about here. Needless to say, upon first viewing this I did keep my eyes open for any... cameos by *certain* engines presumed deceased, and I was not disappointed. Oliver, Gordon, all the others... to we, the audience, they're not missing by any means. *They're always watching.* On a rather lighter note, I like the character pairing of Diesel and Scruffy. This series so far has had some interesting and unexpected (in a good way) character pairings. You'd probably never imagine Duncan and Stanley from the Mid-Sodor Railway ever meeting and becoming friends, let alone them becoming friends with Lapis, who is from a different series altogether, but it happened. Even in the very first episode, the animosity between Henry and D261 is a scenario you've probably never imagined before, considering we've never really seen the two interact in official media. Same with Diesel and Scruffy, they do have much in common, but it's a pairing you aren't likely to see often. As for some Easter eggs, I liked seeing some of the war memorials along the Little Western. Sealion Beach is an interesting concept. If I had to venture a guess, perhaps in this universe, there was a failed German invasion on Sudrian soil during the Second World War? Project Sealion was, of course, the planned Nazi invasion of Britain. Just a thought however, I don't know how realistic such a scenario would be. I also liked the HMS King Godred I Battleship Park. Battleships are amazing vessels, I've toured a couple former US Navy battleships from WW2 myself. I really like the idea of Royal Navy vessels bearing names related to Sudrian history within the Thomas universe. As far as I'm aware, we haven't yet seen HMS King Godred I on-screen, so I wonder what era vessel she is. A WW1-era dreadnought, perhaps? Overall, I enjoyed this as usual. I hope you'll make a community post like you've done with previous episodes, allowing us to ask questions about it. Hopefully in the next episode, we can see the mystery start to unravel and, in good time, progress to a climactic showdown with the demon herself.

8:42, Look in the background on the left.

every background easter egg ive spotted atm, because there are a TON this episode: 4:18 - Toby 5:28 - Oliver (inside the shed) 5:35 - P e r c y 8:06, 8:45 - Oliver (inside the shed) 11:41- Oliver (inside the shed, again) 12:02 - Percy 13:06 - Lady 13:19 - Oliver 14:38 - Lady's shadow 15:12 - Oliver's shadow 20:50 - Oliver

Whoa!!! That was crazy! Cant wait to see the next episode!! As always, keep up the awesome work! Im really hooked onto this series! 👍😊

I really hope there’s a happy ending to all of this :(

You are genuinally building a new branch of the thomas fandom and its great

Okay so there was a lot in this episode to like! Diesel and S.C.Ruffey’s friendship, but the fact that you included some of the disappeared engines in the background, and so on. So, new theory: While I do think that Lady is the leader of whatever is happening, I think that Gordon was Lady’s assistant. If Lady was the puppet master, then Gordon helped moving strings around. However, when Gordon was found with Toad, I suspect that Oliver became Lady’s assistant. However, is not as strong as Gordon, so he gets more engines to make up for this like Percy. And while I’m not sure of this, I believe that Oliver got Duck on their side. Maybe since Diesel joined the branchline, as when Duck tells Diesel to prepare the coastline, you can see Lady’s and Oliver’s shadow on the side of the bridge. Of course, this is a theory, but you never know…

Your work just amazes me. Keep up my friend!

I knew we were getting something for Halloween!!! Daylight please tell me how i cam support you in this cause my man! I am super excited everytime one for the videos for Henry's forest comes out! if there is anything i can do to help please please let me know bro! This is truly amazing work my friend!

Outstanding Performance with the mystery which is just getting deeper and deeper but I would love to have some more lore behind lady’s desire 😃👍

I believe diesel could’ve saved duck if he had coupled up and dragged him back to the sheds. I also feel really bad for Douglas, he’s lost his twin and his two best friends at this point, it’s extremely sad. I hope Douglas will somehow bring his missing friends back

This series has me on edge! Hoping to see more in due course. :)

This was great! I can't wait to see more!

This series is crazy, first Gordon, Oliver, Toby, And Percy, and now Duck And Donald. Whose gonna go missing next Henry?!

This is a nice surprise!

I'm always left with questions after each installation, which I then forget about after being fed a new concept. It's fun yet annoying and I love it

WEll damn. An encounter that does not end with vanishing. how strange... Keeping me on my toes!

I’m guessing Donald is gonna be the ghost engine looking for his whistle at the smelters in Edward’s story. Donald is my favorite engine, shame he didn’t make it

I want to see more of this and the ending cuz this is pretty damn good content 💙

Man, i wish you had more views. These series is such a masterpiece! Or dare i say, you're basically has the same creativity like dajara521 back in the old days.

This series is amazing keep up the good work

After watching this latest episode, I have decided to have a go at a theory. It’s a complicated mess, but here’s a take on it all. This is all just one big inside joke. I have heard people say that Lady was created as Britt Alcroft’s self insert OC, and out of all the engines missing so far due to coming in contact with her are all Awdry engines. Is this a jab at her creative direction that led to the show’s downfall. Who knows? And yes, I know Henry is still around after coming in contact with the light, and the Skarloey engines are still untouched (plus, they are a different gauge entirely), however who is to say future installments won’t expand on this. Who knows? I just think it’s a hilarious take on the whole thing.

That actually is creepy it's like he or she is stalking him.

I knew duck would be next. Sad that Donald is gone too.😿

I can only imagine how pissed fans will be if duck is killed💀

BRO THIS SERIES MAKES ME WANNA CRY BECAUSE WE HAVE LOST GORDON, OLIVER, TOBY, PERCY, DONALD, DUCK AND SIR TOPHAM HATT

another good one and makes sense its oliver too kinda crual to try and make diesel fall onto scruffy to kill him lol

The moving of rusty parts is chilling really

And that Bert is why you question everything

Well daylight you made my worst fear come true and that was what if the twins lost one another but i still enjoyed this regardless

Nicely done. [claps] Man, reminds me of Sodor: Dark Times.

@daylight question my guy. So i am curious on when we actually get to see the dark engine herself face to face? Maybe in 5-8 episodes later after this? Really amped up about this whole thing! I am also going to put a theory here and honestly i think lady just straight up kills the engines and other objects she meets or goes into contact with. After she does this she reanimates them into mind-controling slaves to help cacth more victims such as using toby to lure Percy and Gordon and oliver luring Edward towards the old lead mine. Thats just my theroy towards this. Honestly cant wait to see who confronts lady first? Diesel 10 or maybe thomas? kinda a call back to the magic railroad here. but one thing i do hope is that lady in the ends gets annihilated by 10

I like how lady is evil and d10 is just normal

Not gonna lie I get that all the vines are being killed off but man I’m ready for closure on what happens next. Every time I watch this we’re left with questions. Daylight 3, I’m ready for closure you’re killing me with the suspense.

Quite an ironic twist for Diesel/Bruce and Scruffy to be the heroes of the story in this case, as well as go through their own friendship and redemption starting here especially when scruffy is downright Praying for a safety, that's I can respect. Fitting since there's Stranger Things happening whether alien, supernatural, or Artificial threats by the SCP- I mean rogue military agenda. ( definitely loved the of spludger and Lapis Lazuli Friendship ,even though it's not cannon, it's a nice storyshift of the first Steven Universe x Thomas and friends crossover)

I seen Percy, Oliver, and lady in the background in different scenes. I think I might have saw Fred as well. I just can’t wait till we find out what is happening.

I think I speak for all of us that your series are one of the most original and expiring of the fandom , I can't wait for the next episode . Maybe Douglas revange ? Also a note What happend to stanley aftes his episode ?and lapiz?

Love this so much, hopefully the next one wont be long 😊

Man, duck and donald too? How depressing can this get?

So many unanswered questions that I anticipate will come in the follow up. I can’t wait

Another one bites the dust.

If you look behind diesel when he goes to scruffy u can see the shape of lady or Oliver in the fog behind him.

8:28 looks like Oliver is in the shed watching his next victim

2:53 I slowed the video down all the way and I saw Toby's face being as if he got his face smashed in by something, what the hell happened to him? 😢😨

toby in the backgronud.... holy shit.

i wonder how scruffy knew to say prayer

Making a great sequel to the missing 4/11 is nice and R.I.P Gordon,Oliver,and Donald also scruffy just can't catch a break with these missing engines.

Another great episode! I loved Diesel and S.C.Ruffeys dynamic NOOOOOOO NOT DONALD AND DUCK TOO

Donald nooooooooooo rip number 9

I really wanna see more involving the taken or possessed engines, it’d be really cool to see where they go and if one was able to escape the clutches of whoever’s doing this, perhaps Oliver or Percy due to them being the most unwilling to give up, personally I’m leaning towards Oliver being that one though, it’d be really cool also to have seen Duck have seen the taken Oliver

8:19 Well well clever place to hide oliver in the shed and is lady speeding up her plans a lot of engines were taken this time.

I have a question. So in the scene where Duck and Diesel are talking at the shed. You can see a shadow of Lady in the background, and then at one point you can see Oliver peaking out by the bridge, and then by the shed. But Duck was clearly facing the bridge. So is it basically that engines and people can’t see Lady or the taken engines, and only we the viewer can. Or is it like engines that are facing away from them could see the taken engines, and Lady, but they just don’t know they’re behind them.

You really need to watch the backgrounds in these videos, Like toby at 4:17 The engine in the shed at 8:07 that moves at 8:43 Percy at 12:00 The engine (that looks like oliver) behind the shed at 15:11 And the engine in the fog at 20:52 and 21:06 I feel like I probably missed some as well but I love the little details In this series

dudde i can’t stop thinking about this i love it tooooo much 😅

the statements really make it sound like a catalog like scp and its terrifying

Gordon - presumed dead Oliver - presumed dead Toad - presumed dead Toby - dead Duck - dead Donald - dead

oh god bro i wish i had a time travel machine to see your future videos

What im getting so far is that every engine that gets taken/disappears by lady gets given a task to forfill, if they agree and forfill it then they suvive and get made a minion of lady or whatever entity is controling her, if they fail or refuse whatever task they get given then will end up dead abd remains found, perhaps olivers task was to bring toad to lady and thats why hes not dead yet?

im checking your channel every single day i can’t wait for a new video!!!!!!!!

hen are you making another one i’m waiting soo long i love them take your time lol

And entity "L-A-D-Y" strikes again...

For the first time Betting Duck and Diesel. Diesel got the Last laught.

Anyone else beginning to notice a common theme. Lady is going after the original reverend awdry characters and is most likely going after thomas and proteus or thomas and Stanley