Gamble? More like a near-certainty you would hit an object and destroy the vessel. Without Spice Prescience space-travel would be impossible.

@@Shamino1 probably not true really, space is actually pretty empty - two whole galaxy's can merge together without a single star colliding

@@Shamino1 Not a near certainty for a single trip. Each trip was a 1 in 10 chance of being destroyed in the books. But of course this is unacceptable odds for travel and cargo hauling, imagine 1 out of 10 passenger planes crashing daily. Each Heighliner ship could carry massive amounts of cargo, multiple Great Houses worth. 1 ship lost would be devastating.

@@Shamino1 I wouldn't say impossible but very highly improbable.

Good to know because I was wondering how spice folded space but that makes way more sense

Very true. But whatever its flaws I love this movie

BradiKal61 yeah but no one could have done better at the time. With that technology

I remember watching it for the first time, I was about 10 and I was completely baffled, after watching it again I was still a bit confused, but having read the book it was easier.

@@nopenope8249 Except for Spielberg, Lucas & Industrial Light & Magic for Star Wars nearly 10 years previously

Simon Errock we are talking about Dune you ass clown

TRUESEPH Keepin’ it fancy! I mean these people are Royalty of not just one kingdom but the entire Universe! They gotta flaunt it!

The production design was awesome.

Oh yass... this is a strangebeauty kind of thing ... The whole movie is like this way

I _adore_ that detail.

Details like this give parts of the Movie a very Warhammer 40k-kind of feel.

Warhammer 40,000 makes you go through hell

​@@fludbludAlso you may end up traveling through time.

Babylon 5 give you Subspace, which guarantees nothing, except some trouble sometimes.

I’ll believe that you can fold space once I see someone folding water and folding air in half. Good luck! L O L

@@StalkerX86 B5's subspace is the closest thing other universes have to showing "calm Warpspace".. its a dimension "behind" our own, thats psychoactive(makes telepath stronger) & so vast, no one really knows how large it is, or where the eddys will take you, exept for charted courses!

Not an ounce of makeup needed.

😆 he’s mutated into a space worm

😂😂😂

Riiight? Glad he's still getting roles playing himself.

I lol'd!

And really not driving at all- just getting back out and being next door, except in a totally different country

Yep, traveling always require a perfect balance. Not too long not to short, for enjoy the trip.

Nope, its more amazing than that. Imagine if you are sitting in your bed and it suddenly becomes sand and your bedroom wall becomes ocean waves, congrats you just folded space. You remain station but your location appears around you.

@@myballsitchsomethingfierce6319 That happens every weekend - when I smoke the good stuff!

@@mandolinic Spice melange is similar to drugs, lol.

The visuals are all over the place. Some look actually pretty good I think like the first shot of the ships in lines moving to the highliner and others are wildly bad. The scene after this with the highliner appearing in Dune orbit looks like a cell shaded cartoon cutout overlaying the dune/starfield image. The movie in general is all over the place in music, visuals, pacing...

And the Villeneuve movie misses the mark. The visuals are drab, monochrome, boring whereas Lynch's movie is balls-out weird.

@@plaxusvendant2983 Compared to Stanley Kubrick’s 2001 a space odyssey some of the optical effects are weak, but still memorable. Not one scene in the remake is memorable IMO. He really did feminize the film as intended. Black women on Arakkis.

@@rancosteel i know you wanna clap their cheeks

@@UC4AQUgrQ9EwVIGoF0w7xHXg who cheeks?

That's my feelings exactly. Thank you, I feel less alone now!

pspboy7 it's a could have been film.

The colour range and tone of the new Dune is like staring at a bowl of porridge, compared to Lynch's Dune. I will always love this film without guilt.

Me too! Especially this entire scene, with the score. Makes me wish I had seen it in a theater, but I was too young when it came out.

@@reginal.898 Yes I love that Navigator; it's so cute.

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Yes!!! Finally! Someone understands it!!! It's been a pet peeve of mine. I can now free my pet. Thank you!!!

the movie version makes this all so rediculous, one of the reasons it failed

Warhammer 40k: ship is piloted trough literal hell by a three eyed mutant

FTL travel in: Stargate - did someone drop a giant magic hula hoop?

[violent agreement]

And even given how big the door is, it’s not even visible on the Heighliner in the distance shots. That’s how HUGE Heighliners are.

@@philsmith2444 ikr!

This movie is actually infamous for Lynch wanting to be removed as the official director due to so many changes being made to the movie and him not liking the final result.

Just re-read the novel... it was far more faithful to the book than I realized.

@@Rodshark75 that happens when you refuse to add computers into your futuristic universe. However how ships, harvesters and machines operate is kinda a mystery it must be the spice...

FWIW Herbert himself liked Lynch's movie, despite the departures from the novel

Going to be flawed no matter what, there is no way to capture the universe of the novel in a 2 hour movie.

More like a spice joint

For a navigator, wouldn’t it be...”Anyway, where will I be...”

hahaha

@@Chunkboi "Where I will have been..."

Yea 😂😂😂

You bet it, Brian Eno and Toto

That is just brilliant, isn't it? There is a lot here that is astonishingly good, and yet...

You don’t really see the new ones as they’re in suits.

Yeah, I thought it was cool that Lynch spent some time on the Highliners and the Guildsmen. Villeneuve completely ignores it, but he's being true to the book. There's very little mention of it in the first book.

I like the new movie

To be fair, the first book doesn't talk about any of this, so in that respect the new movie is being faithful to the book. If there are more Dune movies for the later books, I expect we'll see the Guild Navigators there.

@@augustday9483 Yeah, but they for some reason missed Thufir, Piter and Yueh among other things despite having twice as much space as Lynch had and replaced it with what: visions of Zendaya and action scenes.

@@augustday9483 No, the new movie turned the heighliner into a sort of wormhole tunnel where you go in one side, come out on the other in another system. It completely changed the whole purpose of the spice and Navigators.

Yes!

Well said!

I don't dig the Baron...but overall this is the best Dune you can see on screen to date, period.

The new Dune is far better, but this comes close.

@@crazybabuskaman3923 Nope, it needs part 2 to confirm that it's better. For now it's just a nice movie with very nice visuals that ends abruptly.

@@avae5343 Acid. Lots and lots of acid

Talk about taking the spice... Maybe this movie is an allegory about drug trips , like 'Puff the magic dragon' was in the 60s

@@obo7707 You sound like you aren't familiar with David Lynch's movies. The craziness in Dune is par for the course in his filmography. It just doesn't work in the Dune movie because it's based on someone else's work.

You have a few types. People who read the book and dislike how different this is. That is fair, I watch this as a David Lynch movie more than as an adaptation of a Frank Herbert novel. Then you have people that just have no imagination and want things to be normal and explained to them simply. Being that this is Lynch you just have too much surrealism for them. And then you have people that can just accept it as an individual piece of art, with all its flaws but still be in awe of how beautiful it is as a whole. Like us, I presume.

I appreciate this film when I look at stills of it. I hate it when I’m watching the actual film.

I know what you mean, Frank. Kind of like how two different Puerto Ricans can....hang on....oh shit, cops just kicked my door in.

I mean,the books by Frank Herbert are chuckfull with weird shit. People snorting sandworm-poo LSD and getting strange powers,turning into half human/sandworm hybrid "gods" and what not... David Lynch just added some of his own weirdness to it.

A lot of balls, no marbles.

Me too 🤯 thanks!

Can you explain how it's a reference?

@@MegaDRKSTR well there's def a chance that the MIB writers/producers had never seen Dune and happened upon the pug idea totally novelly, but that would just be an unlikely coincidence, while the case of it being shoutout or reference or trope or whatever you want to call it would be a more likely and is a common thing to do in movies, especially movies of the same genre, and especially MIB which utilizes a lot of other sci-fi elements that they didn't come up with all on their own. Influence and inspiration are powerful and crop up everywhere. I honestly think that people who care a lot about considering their ideas as novel are on the wrong path. There is use in it, like if you want to make the most money for yourself and guard and maximize your own interests, but I think it's more useful to consider yourself as part of a larger whole, even if it forfeits some profit you could have gotten ensuring copyrights and the like. Even if you were the first person to come up with a chord or to deem a plot of land yours, emphasizing how your piece is just part of systems greater than yourself is the better reference frame than the self-centered one where you don't emphasize the larger systems and instead focus on your own ownership.

Holy shit, I agree ! Too bad MIB didn't have a whole litter of talking Pugs !

me too! and I've watched both multiple times!

Cheap models. Bad special effects.

I love all the whispering

That's because when you watch it on mushrooms, the movie is six hours long.

I watched DUNE in a theater in the 1980s and 75% confused, 10% lost because I couldn't follow it, 15% pissed off because it cost a lot for the tickets and I wasted three hours and felt I had been had.

It didn't make any sense for you then either, you're just trying to sound cool

I'm still lost on the fish pooping out spice haha

Its great to watch high. Highly recommended.

@Cataclysmic Dildoser I thought / hoped so regarding him and BladeRunner 2049. But his 2049 score was pretty forgettable.

The music when they arrive is.. i cannot find the words but, heyy, we are in the far future, traveling the space, and just arrived to this planet, than you have sand and sand and this beautyful epic music this is art

Haunting, mesmerizing…

@@mysticmarble94 they should have used El-P

@@mysticmarble94 Hans Zimmer did the score for 2049, not Vangelis. I like the 2049 score, but to each their own.

The books are awesome aswell

Meh. I've read some of the dialog of DV's version. "Let's have the Emperor be sad that he blowed up House Atreides. blegh.

I think it follows the book much more than it's given credit for.

The Lynch movie has this baroque style you see here. I'm no longer certain what happened first, reading the novel or watching the movie... They influenced each other profoundly. A fantastic music track as well. I prefer telling the story by Villeneuve but I prefer the old movie's music and visual style. I wonder what would have been the infuence on scifi movies if Jodorowsky's Dune 1970s movie were made. We'll never know now...

It makes a lot of sense actually.

@@georgsgrants9925 Explain?

The imperium of man would like to know your location.

Imagine bringing someone from 20000 years ago into our time...everything would be 'whhaaa!' for them too.

LMAO

Yeah its briefly mentioned in the beginning and a massive cylindrical engine ship is shown, but then completely ignored... the whole reason for spice production is this exact sequence, to space travel faster, and to extend life but with a cost of mutation. All this is missing from new movie, I think modern audience are not smart enough to grasp deeper concepts like this.

@@artmaknev3738 The spice importance and the importance of the guild navigators. Also... was I the only one disappointed by the worms in the new dune2?

​@@ClarkeIllmaticalwhy?

@@abraxasee8946 It wasn't impressive. I felt Lynch did more with the worms. DUNE 2 worms, focus on Spice was really bad. DUNE 2 looks good, but if part 3 is not GREAT - Lynch's film will age better.

@@ClarkeIllmaticali'm sorry but you have fucking clinical brain death if you think Lynch's dune will AGE BETTER than the new one 😭😭

Lynch didn't like it and wanted his name removed from the credits. Maybe he changed his mind now that it has a cult following?

Totally agree man - it’s kind of transcendental

It's really good! Kinda reminds me of Radiohead.

@@warpartyattheoutpost4987 Decks Dark (on the heighliner)

"The guild demands belly rubs"

T-rex arms.

Thanks for the time stamp! I went back and watched it again. Good representation of the Sheild Wall and seitches.

true, hard to see nowadays

Same, i get that with 2001 Space Odyssey too.

people these days hate these sequernces sadly

And now for the bravery test. Let's a put happy tree just here, and give it a little friend just here. You know me, everybody needs a friend. Albert! That's the fourth matte painting you've ruined with those f-ing trees!!

It's eerily beautiful, isn't it?

Snore

It's the windows.

That's because it was shot on location, evidently without your permission.

GW stripmined dune to make 40k

Heretic, Find them 🔨

Yes. He Does.

@@LOLHAMMER45678 GW made an epic dune

Death to the false Emperor!

Dune is steamp.. cyberpunk itself

Yes, machines with any sort of internal memory or computation ability were outlawed and the technology banned and destroyed. Leaving only simple machines with human computers to do all the calculations.

Don't let that ruin the experience ;)

Takes a lot of brass to say that.

It's like its inspired by all those UFO sightings that people witnessed.

You nailed it

@@PatousMcGillicuddy Thanks mate! And now, thanks to Villeneuve, we got an awesome book adaptation besides this little pearl of weirdness. 😉

med.c

hahahaha, alien pug.

duh he wrote the book

Slow roasting, apparently.

I think Denis Villeneuve have his very own style. He try to make something new but resonable for the Audiences who not really read the novel before can enjoy. My opinion, both David Lynch and Dennis Villeneuve did very good at space visual. Dennis of course with advance CGI can open many door never be open before But Lynch movie did very good at music, creative background and character building

@@BELIVE114 yes but now my friend who never watched the old dune movie, thinks that spice gives you psychic powers... like jedi in starwars. He thinks that navigators are those women dressed in black...arghhh, missing the Space Guild explanation was kind of a mistake in Part 1, hope it will be explained better in Part 2.

I’d say he surpassed it by a country mile.

@@VulKus117 Villeneuve went for something completely different, ie a story that follows the book closely and in visual style feels more like a traditional historical epic set in the future, and largely succeeded on those premises

​@@TsothaVilleneuve's Dune is just a poor copy of Lynch's Dune, the chronology and most of the scenes are the same, he can claim it's a new adaptation it is a remake 😑

@@senzosanjuro1769 Totally agree. While he is an excellent director, he did not manage to instill the Space Goth elements in the first movie (and I guess also in the upcoming second). DUNE is a Universe where intelligent machines are fobidden, thus we need to have a kind of retro-futuristic/gothic cultural background.

why?

@@enzog8245 Because modern filming uses a non-realistic myopic style. The everyday realistic style long shots used in Dune would be frowned upon as too old fashioned. And modern cameras have multiple focus meaning it wouldn't even be physically possible unless you turned off a lot of its automatic features, which would relegate the shots to an "art style" that would be criticised as being amateur.

I wish we had movies with today’s special effects with 80s sets and storytelling. I feel like movie sets and backgrounds are all just boring black and gray. And they rely too much on explosions and fights

They took book about war between Jihadists in Caucasus and Russian Empire, consumed some heavy "melange" - and "Dune" was the result.

Its such a shame some of the styles didnt cross over into future sci fi movies

Absolutely, it would have added a ton more of lore exposition. We can hope for a Director's Cut or more exposition scenes in Part 2 hopefully

@@afterburner94 Denis said no other cuts. No directors cut and such.

@@-.-.11 there is a 5 hour cut

@@HamguyBacon You don’t know what we’re talking about, do you?

@@-.-.11 why wouldn't i know? what do you know oh right nothing.

It's straight "Eraserhead"

Least, or most?

That Pug was the Atriedes' chief strategist.

@Master of Sinanju Master of Sinanju Well at 1:18 it could be the pug's internal monologue.

With enough spice, the dog itself could one day one become a Navigator. Those are the dictates of evolution and if you throw your Aces and Eights hand in with that bullshit doctrine of racist propaganda, I have some oceanfront timeshares in Laughlin, NV that I want you to buy into on the Platinum Shit-for-Brains Plan.

Its that dog breeds still look the same after 10,000 years is bullshit

That's where it killed it for me, the cult type of environment. Movies that have weird folk enforcing their will because "beliefs" just irritates me. I'm a dude who likes to see advanced tech, not weird organisms laser puking planets. It's been years since I've seen this movie and I didn't remember much of it due to lack of interest. Doesn't mean it's a bad movie, clearly you enjoyed it as well as many others and it's getting a remake! I'm just picky myself

@@sacr3 A cult following is a small but passionate fanbase. That has nothing to do with what's in the movie itself. Have you even read the book? It's entirely about cults controlling the universe with remnants of belief systems like Monarchism, Islam and Christianity. Lynch didn't change any of that, and if this version follows the book, it won't either. So if that's the cult type environment you're referring to, you should probably be looking elsewhere for your entertainment. The entire series of books is about a civilization without advanced technology: no computers, no robots, both of which were banned by royal decree. That's why they have the Space Guild, the Mentats, the Bene Gesserit, etc.: people with mystical powers or savant level intelligence to fill the void left by the absence of advanced technology. There is very little advanced technology in the Dune universe; only global socialist monarchies directing the building of vast infrastructure to support a spacefaring empire. That may seem highly advanced, but that has little to do with technological advance. In fact, most of it relies on the unifying power of religion, mysticism, and paranormal activity. Herbert himself was making a point about our own civilization's advancements, which are more sociological wonders than technological. Aside from space travel, genetic engineering that is a stage beyond our own capacities and a few other minor things, there is little in the Dune universe that can't be replicated with modern technology. In fact, it depicts a ruthless and barbaric authoritarian civilization that has technologically advanced very little in 10,000 years. The glory of Dune is perverse glory, not righteous glory. That's how Herbert intended it. It was a warning against Monarchism, Imperialism, Socialism, state religions, resource mongering and dependency infrastructures, social engineering, cults of personality, rigidly defined classes, caste systems, insane racial and ethnic divisions, eugenics, the guidance of civilization by gurus seeking to fulfill prophecies, etc., etc. The intention is for the audience to look past the depictions of superficial glory and see the perversity and savagery of all of that as it really exists. Lynch tried to portray that in keeping with Herbert's vision, but most people missed the point. I think the same thing will happen with this film. All art is an artists' rendition. I suspect this film will be no different, regardless of how much it might stick to the books. I'm just hoping that it won't be the typical socialist propaganda that we're seeing in today's films and TV shows. If so, then it will be a huge artistic failure, because the story itself is a condemnation of all that.

@@BatEatsMoth Jesus bud, listen there are millions if not a couple billion that dislike this movie for their own reasons. This movie gave me too much of a cult/religious taste in my mouth and I'm no fan. Therefore I didn't like this movie and how they portrayed things like, well, this FTL travel. My preference is with advanced technologies, but show me a flying space fetus shooting energy from its mouth and you'll lose me right away. May as well just make it a giraffe that shits out universal locations if we're going to make no sense.

@@sacr3 Hey that's fine with me, but you're barking up the wrong tree with the new one because it's still just a film adaptation of Herbert's novel, which is 100% about the sort of things you don't like to see in a sci fi movie.

@@BatEatsMoth fair enough chief! It's a well known film and my old man adores it. So who knows, I may go visit the old man and watch it with him. Maybe it'll surprise me. Either way I show some form of support even if I walk out upset.

He who controls the spice controls the universe...

Not to be nitpicking, but the movie takes place closer to 20.000 years in the future. Which actually makes it even weirder that they still have pugs. The spice must flow

@@SnackboiSlim Considering the Tleilaxu exist with their genetic manipulation and synthesis talents, it seems a trifle to imagine pugs still existing. Long live the fighters!

@@mnomadvfx Sure. But is it reasonable to assume they still remember what a pug looks like? They barely even remember where earth is

@@SnackboiSlim Earth is nothing but a mith in Dune Saga so you have a valid point. There is little chance that humanity would remember anything resembling dogs so far in to the future so far away from Earth.

Villeneuve lacks vision. He tries to pass off minimalism as some form of individual style when its clear he lacks any

Nazeem Oh, that was his nose? It seemed like it came out the other end

Nothing to see here. Move along...

They hired the director of Eraserhead to make this. It kind of goes without saying there will be weird shit like this all over the movie.

And the Oscar for "Best cinematic use of a Turkey's ass" goes to....

I thought it looked like a giant huhu grub or whitchity grub and agreed it was hooting what ever out of its bum, somehow it did not quiet fit the bill, a sort of mutated Jubba The Hutt

Yeah, that (gigantic) bit of Baroque design was an interesting touch. My favorite moment in the film.

The spiceddiver cut ?

I watched this movie recently. After the first half, almost everything had a rushed feel... as if the DeLaurentis company told David Lynch that the budget is running out & they won't pour any more money into the project. It didn't help that the Harkonnen baddies were so cliched & looked like Fat Evil John Belushi and Sting on 'Shrooms (yes, it is Sting).

I heard rumors that there is no such scene in the 2021 movie but I'm not sure 😭😭

@@mysticmarble94 Well?

@@dubuyajay9964 Yeah, he was right.

It actually made no sense, for all I care that thing could have been a recycled monster from another aborted movie.

👍