Here's a massive compliment : I suffer from insomnia and I always listen to your videos to fall asleep as your voice is really calm, it really helps! (I just have to re-watch your video in the morning to remember the recipe haha!) thank you!

IMHO this is the best bread making channel on planet KZfaq. Thank you John☘

I’ve been making sourdough loaves for a couple of years, with varying rates of success, but have just tried your method out for the first time and the result was in another league - rise, crumb and crust all vastly better. Your videos are a joy to watch, too. Thank you!

I was looking at sourdough recipes last night and today... John blesses me!

I bake sourdough every week and decided to try your recipe. Very simple and easy to understand. The dough seemed a little wet during the machine kneading so I sprinkled a little more flour in and kneaded about 25 minutes. (I live in Florida, so the atmosphere is quite different) after the 3 hour proofing the dough was still a little sticky but I was able to shape and stitch without any problems. When I took it out of the proofing basket to bake, it was perfect!! And the baked loaf was absolutely beautiful!! (I wish I could post a picture!) Since I use my bread for sandwiches, this less open crumb is perfect for sandwiches!! Thank you for this wonderful recipe!!

Thank you Chef. Appreciate all the little tips from how-to-roll-fold-and-tuck to reminding us that time is a guideline and actually looking at the dough is what really counts.

Nearly 500k subs, and 38 million views - amazing. Many thanks for the channel.

Never have I felt I might be able to do this! So grateful for this brilliant clear tutorial. Thank you very much.

Thank you for sharing your easy to follow recipe! Beautifully looking tasty bread!

Hello John, first of all I want to say that my husband and I really enjoy your videos. Thank you for sharing your wisdom and experience. I am new to sourdough. Today I baked my 5th loaf. It is the first time I have used your recipe and it turned out so well, by far the best! This will be my go-to recipe from now on! Next, I'm going to try my hand with your sourdough dinner rolls. Thank you again for all your wonderful videos!!😊

My wife loves your rolls!

I've never cared for sourdough bread... but I think this is a recipe I would enjoy, and it looks gorgeous. I love how you never omit steps that beginners might not know to do. This makes it so easy to follow without making novice mistakes. Now I'm wondering how to adapt it to baking in a dutch oven over hot coals. I have a bread droid to do the hard work of kneading. :)

Your voice is very soothing, making it easy to listen to your instructions while learning to make your fantastic recipes.

I loves this videos pure vintage and enjoy the cooking book Mr. Kirkwood.

Well my first loaf came out beautiful and tasty, baking another one today!!! I am so happy I found you. God Bless and be well.

You make it look so easy, thank you for showing us how to make an easy sourdough loaf.

I smiled seeing your well organized empty fridge shelf as you put in your 2 bannetons to proof the dough overnight. My fridge is so crowded that it's always a scramble to find space for one loaf let alone two. It looks like a lovely recipe.

Thank you Mr. Kirkwood for another fine bread video! I have tried most of your recipes over the last 2 years. I stayed away from the meat pies though since my pastry dough never seem to come out right.

I’ve made this recipe at least 10 times if not more. It comes out perfect every time. Thank you 🙏🏼

Hi John, I hope you are well! I have tried making sour dough before without success. The recipe was very complicated. I am going to try your recipe as I know it will be a success like all of your other bread recipes ( I have your bread book) and your super easy Yorkshire pudding recipe. THANK YOU SO MUCH. Linda from Australia. 🥰🇦🇺

I’ll need to try this! I’m actually making your hamburger buns today for my husband’s birthday dinner tomorrow! The best!

As I’ve never made sourdough before then it’s gotta be a “must” for trying….TY for showing us “how” John. Hope you are all well. 😊

I made this today using your sourdough starter and recipe and it turned out perfectly! I’ve never made sourdough before so I’m blown away! I wish I could add a picture here because it’s really beautiful and tastes delicious. Thank you so much for your easy to follow instructions, you make cooking a joy 🤩

Absolutely scrumptious 🍞

Sourdough Pancakes are so good!! I would love a recipe for this!!❤💙

John watching you make bread is always mesmerising! Thank you

As ever john, you are the master of bread. I have a problem with digesting supermarket bread but no problem with this sourdough recipe. A BIG THANKS!!!

This was great, I can't wait to try it. Thank you for your efforts. I'll report once I make it...

Thank You! This will be fun! I’m working on collecting German Wasser Brötchen Recipe’s

Thank you! I've been trying sour dough for a long while, and while it's turned out okay, I haven't managed to get that beautiful ear you have on yours. I didn't realise that was related to the tightness of the skin.

Looks beautiful. I got some artisan Sourdough bread from the local bakery a few weeks ago and it really was the best bread I ever tasted. It was Sourdough mixed with some white potato and rosemary... couldn't stop eating it. Gonna have to learn to make this myself. Thanks.

Hello John I've started with the sourdough wish I've many times tried, must try again now Thank you so much for your recipe.

Where’s all the comments!? Another amazing looking loaf John!

I love the sound of lots of loaves cooling after they've been taken out of the oven. I was bowled over (no pun intended) the first time I heard it. The popping and crackling sounds were amazing.and the smell of fresh bread. There's nothing else quite like it. We had to make our own sourdough starter, but it always seemed a chore and took days. . So, now that I know you have it for sale, I will surely buy it to use. Thank you for showing so many lovely videos John.

I literally can smell the bread! Thank you for your videos, I learned a lot.

Thank you so much for this video. After too many failures you’ve saved Sauron, my starter, from the bin! I’ve just made this amazing loaf and it turned out perfectly! 🥳

From Toronto Ontario Canada and l love your website it's awesome. Made the beef stew and dumplings it was excellent. I figured it would last me and my wife a week. Lasted two days absolutely awesome. I'm just starting my sour dough bread adventure , as l only have all purpose flour I added 4 grams of wheat gluten per 100 grams of flour and it's much easier to work with thanks. I am having a beer but enjoy your tea thanks again have a great day

Made this again. Started this last night, bake off this morning. To hot to cut right now but it smells amazing. Thanks for a great & easy recipe. It’s a keeper.

Perfect as always. Simplest instruction out there, results guaranteed.

I followed your instruction carefully but using 1/3 rye 2/3 white flour. Came out perfect and very tasty. Fermentation took about 5 hours though. I think I'll continue using this method over the traditional stretch & fold method. Thanks for your video!

Best sour dough recipie on youtube. Sour dough for dummies. Relie on your trusty wooden spoon!

That is a beautiful loaf of sourdough bread!

I just made your other recipe and it came out beautifully …and so I need to take some to a friend tomorrow …and I’m going to try this recipe so I can bake it in the morning and take it to her warm. All of your recipes have been exceptional and I’m sure this one will be as well. Thank you for what you do.

Another great recipe John. Your Sourdough Starter is fantastic. Mine is out of the fridge warming up a bit to be fed. Thanks for the shout out, pleased to help.

thanks for this ! never knew about the baking cloche, you've taught me a number of things

Hiya John, just an update on my first ever sourdough baking! I mentioned that I had to add another 4 heaped dessert spoons of flour to my mix as it was like cake batter! anyway I went through the process of getting into the oven! It had risen quite well , so I turned it over on to my home made table tennis bat, to dust of the excess flour, and all looked pretty good,but after a few seconds it started to collapse so I quickly got into the pre heated large bowl and placed it straight into the hot oven but it continued to collapse slowly and almost looked like a thick pizza base, lol. I had to cook for an extra 15 mins and then turned it over for another 10 mins to cook the bottom! It had a lovely crispy crust, was still a little doughy inside with a light grey sort of colour, but when it cooled my wife and I had a couple of slices each with lashings of butter and it wasn’t too bad! Room for improvement comes to mind! So I’m thinking what went wrong ? Should I have stirred the sourdough starter before using it? All my weights and rises were perfect! I’ve now ordered some Alison’s very strong flour 14 protein, and will try again this weekend! So any ideas John would be very helpful to a better Loaf this Sunday! Kind regards David.👍👍

Excellent, Thanks John.

This video is great John. I can’t wait to make it. Thanks so much.

A bit different method than how I make mine but I think I'll try yours with my next one. Thanks for your great instruction!

You make a very good job of explaining how to make your recipes, very enjoyable to watch, thank you. Good luck from Spain!!

Good Morning John, This is GrahamDavid Hobbs from Malaysia and a very Big Fan of Sourdough Bread Baking I shall definelty try out your Sourdough recipe from this video. I am sure it will work for me here as My average Kitchen temp is 29+ C and humidity is always around 60%. i will get back to you and let you know how it turns out

Just what I needed been trying sourdough lately

I learn so much from your videos. I’ll be trying this recipe soon. I made your sandwich baguettes, and they lived up to your hype.

that is a nice SD loaf you have there and a decent shithe of bread, will be giving this one a go, just waiting on my starter to mature....

Fantastic, John, I have made your French baguettes several times. I find it relaxing. I will make this recipe soon. PS: I’m going to recommend your channel to others.

This channel is now a go to for my morning routine. Keep it up! Thank you. 🙏

Lovely, thank you John

You are a true first class baker!

That is beautiful bread. The term "sour" comes from the technique of using already fermented flour to start your batch. Your stater is the sourdough in your sourdough bread. It's the same from sourmash whiskey. You are using the ferment from a previous batch.

Thanks for this video it's so clear & easy to follow. I have been wanting to try sourdough but many of the other recipes I've seen are all too complicated. Such a great channel 👏

Hello John, I would like to thank you for your easy to follow step by step recipes. I have made a few of your bread and roll recipes and they always turn out great. Just a note to everyone reading this, my store was out of my usual flour so I bought another brand. After seeing this video I looked at my “bread flour”label and turns out it is 3g of protein per 30g serving. That’s only 10% protein. I guess I should read the labels before I buy now. Oh, and great voice! Very calming indeed.

thanks so much my dear friend 😀 it is really great bread

Looks amazing ! I’m just imagining the smell x

Hi John, another great video! I've found myself missing a lot of your videos and I'm ashamed as your recipes are really good. I've rung the little bell and hope KZfaq works with me. I'll be sure to binge watch all I've missed Take care and stay well, Greetings from a small village just south of Amsterdam

Thank you John - you got me in to baking bread and through lockdown 👍

That looks beautiful. I don't like all the air holes in the bread, so this recipe is ideal for me. Many thanks. 💛

What a great presentation John. Thanks so much for sharing. Cheers from AKL, NZL.

Thanks so much for the recipe and video instructions. I have had a few sourdough failures, but I tried again this time with your beginner recipe. Started it yesterday and baked it this morning. Success! Lovely rise, crispy crust and great taste. So then I thought why not try the regular high hydration recipe you also have. It was so easy with just the folding and no kneading, I couldn’t resist. Such a soft dough though, and I had planned to bake it in a cloche instead of Dutch oven. It spread a bit when I put it on the cloche so I was thinking I might not have a well shaped loaf…..John, it came out amazing. Too hot to taste right now but wow it looks fantastic. Nice rise. You really are the best with your combo of recipes and clear instructions! Thanks so much again! Oh, and you know since my mum was from Great Britain, I love seeing some of the foods she made for us here in Canada, but left no recipes for! Thanks again! 🇨🇦

Hello again Mr. Kirkwood, I want to thank you so much for the fantastic videos you put out for us to learn and enjoy, please keep up the great work you do believe me it is much appreciated, take care hope to speak with you one day.

My favourite bread, so I have to try this out. Cheers John!

GREAT 👍 APSOLUTELY DELICIOUS AS ALWAYS. HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY . AND OF COURSE HUNDREDS AND HUNDREDS . THUMBS UP FOR YOU💯💯💯👍👍👍

Yay . A new John video 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

Going to be making mine soon John! And I can’t wait to taste this bread 👍

Finally, two real sourdough loaves, John. Gorgeous. So proud;

Thawadah for your recipe, this was my first attempt at sourdough bread and I am hooked....

Maybe I'll try this before stepping into the higher hydration kind, thanks for the wonderful recipe as always!

Hello John! Thank you so much for this recipe! My sourdough bread turned out perfect! Have a lovely day!

Nice job Mr John .

Hello John your loaf looks delicious, I do like homemade bread especially when it’s still warm and the butter melts into it.... yum!! tfs Jax 🥰x

Your starter is great

Oh my gosh! I'm salivating❣️

Hello John. We love this bread at home, so I asked an English lady friend of ours for the recipe. I did everything according to her recipe but unfortunately didn't succeed. Hers turn out beautifully!🤣 However, I'm going to follow your recipe as the result looks absolutely fantastic. Thanks very much for sharing this.

Okay John, I have been too intimidated to make sourdough, but since every other bread recipe of yours that I have tried has worked, I guess this will be my next one to have a go at!

Perfect 😋!!!👍👍👍 Delicious !!!❣️

Just baked off the bread this morning and it turned out quite nicely. As some other commenters have reported, the dough was stickier than it appeared in your video. I didn't add any extra flour to compensate but just went with it. ;)

Another winner loaf/bread recipe 👍🏼❤️

A fantasic bread John. Cheers.

The best sour dough I ever had was made into sour dough pop-overs. Hollow muffins of sour dough bread that when broken apart hold gobs of melted butter or sour cream. 6 to a basket and me and my friend polished off four baskets of them together on top of the meal. no neeed for dessert they were so tastey.

The legend returns

Love your tutorials - hope to one day try them, thank you - love your accent

This is stunning 😍

I will try this recipe, I have my own starter in the fridge but I only use 100g and I have to say the rise isn’t as much as yours. I’ll feed him Monday morning and get going in the afternoon thank you for for this recipe.

Got here as Fast As I could. can't imagine how good this'd be if I had the Kitchen space for it x-x

Oohhhh... have not made sourdough in years.... this is now on the list! Thank you for this!

brilliant as usual!

Great recipe for beginners! The overnight proofing does so much for flavour. I made a Lithuanian scalded rye loaf last weekend. Super delicious and much better than the supermarket versions as I didn't add any sweetener. Isn't knowing all the ingredients great?.

Looks delicious!!!

I can’t wait to try this! I have the same shape banneton too!

Thank you sir 🙏

I’ve tried this! Absolutely delicious!