And then they ask why minors being debuted is such an issue to the public💀

It's giving Fifty Fifty

You hit the nail when you brought it back to the girl's age. Them siding with min heejin is foolish because contrary to what fans think, producers get replaced and changed all the time in the entertainment industry. New Jeans can still exist without her. They can’t exist without the company. Their naivety about corporate politics allowed them and their parents to be manipulated by Min Heejin who has been problematic and toxic from day one. This was situation was inevitable.

Idk why people r so surprised, i mean min heejin has a history of being like this. Still, those texts were so painfull to read😭 imagine what new jeans must be feelin rn. I dont even think they r as close to min heejin as it is shown tbh, theyre probably just brain washed by her or just bound by their contract. New jeans deserve better

So messy they should have kept quiet and it's crazy and bunnies need to keep low and not spread more hate just to protect min heejin just because new jeans are supporting her And it's crazy how min heejin said all those horrible comments about the girls I found it interesting how people were on min heejin the moment she spread the "crush aespa" message And the fans are too much

The parents shouldn’t have gotten involved at all, especially going public about it. The girls are done for and the parents who didn’t protect them are to blame

From the way MHJ talks about them, it makes me believe that they and their parents are being manipulated into taking a public side. I really believe that MHJ is promising them things even for a future where she loses the legal battle. To me, it's clear as day that in a future where MHJ leaves HYBE (and it's not 'if', but 'when'), NewJeans will ask to terminate their contract to go with MHJ to whatever hole she thinks of restarting her own company. It's a shame, this next comeback of theirs will be the last one for a long time.

Smh, that petition was such a bad move. I feel sorry for girls. If MHJ doesnt win, it'll be bad for them

GREAT MOTHER MIN HEEJIN told those language used in chats are her NORMAL JOKING WAY OF TALKING☠️☠️ and that eveb after chat got out, Newjeans members called her & consolidated her & it was full of LOVE😬 Calling someone f@t, whiny, lazy, brain ded, and a bsh is JOKING😊 and that 5 girls dont even have self respect or wht🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

They're done for. Now I wonder wtf were their parents thinking? Why didn't they consult all of this with a lawyer that is not related to MHJ? cause sure as hell she might have been the one who suggested which lawyer should take their case. As an adult you should know that you can't trust someone 100%, even less if money is involved. It's like their parents have no common sense at all! Not even the adult members! Fifty-fifty was the perfect example of what NOT to do, and they still chose to go down that way. This isn't gonna end well, sadly, cause consequences are inevitable.

I don’t understand how the NewJeans girls and fans still support her after all the things she said about them. She did a number on those girls to make them so loyal to her. It’s a really sad situation.

I dont trust her since the beginning and newjeans needs to wake up and not be on her side

I am happy I was proven wrong about minors debuting in the industry and that ceo's don't care about their artist they only care about the money the artist bring to the company. This whole saga is literally proof that minors debuting in the industry is a bad thing and how people should support their favorite groups instead of the ceo or the company .

Thank you for your words. Agree with you. The only question I will always have: why did Hybe hire her in the first place??? it's nearly impossible for them to not know, what kind of person she is. Before hiring her. I bet, the people inside of the industry have way more information about her. But even we, usual people, could it see, how potentially problematic she may become. So why? It's either two ways: they saw, but didn't care. Or they didn't try to get more info about her. And I don't know what is worse.

Yet she releases hybes "stepping" on aespa text and says "I don't want to step on anyone" while fake crying ....she even replied to the text with a laughing response yet people were getting on her side just cause of that text .....like ur telling me no one in these comment section hasn't written a mildly mean text as a joke (honestly I don't even think it was mean hybe is a company ofc they wanna find a way to get their idols on top)

It’s nice to form bonds with your idols to a certain extent but idk.. MHJ is just creepy around minors, and the fact that everyone seemed to have forgotten that her inspo is literally underage X overage😭 (I think you can look it up where she said that was her inspiration, I don’t remember the full post but it’s online somewhere) and the fact that she uses their sympathy as more leverage to get her point across and then it turns out she’s talking bad about them- yup.. some mother figure she is🙄

This is soo frustrating! I hope some evidence surfaces against MHJ and her true colors are revealed & noticed by South Korean law. Its time they take debuting/training minors and their sexualisation seriously.

NJ just made the biggest mistake in their life!! They should have just watch and learn..!! But i guess they have no choice but to follow the instructions of their greedy & selfish CEO who is willing to take NJ to her grave + more groups if possible including BTS!! 😂😂

That’s what I said from the start. Also their parents. They needed good advice and didn’t get it. They were USED by MHJ to provide that document to the court. Thanks for this video.

hope they managed to save/invest their 5 mill - cause i think they're done

I think that it would be a good idea for a video to talk about debuting minors in Kpop and in the west, because I believe that many people will understand how awful it is especially in the future, when the idols/celebs grow up. For example, Justin Bieber, Britney Spiers, Justin Timburlake, Usher - how all of these artists have done awful things because of the pressure of debuting under the age of 18

Dude, not just min hee jin. All of them are guilty except for the kids💀

Wtf did the girls and their parents have to get involved?!

I don’t like HYBE but they’re winning this case. Not only is MHJ screwing herself over, but also NJ and their parents.

Petition was their parents idea and the parents are manipulated but MHJ. I hope the girls come out of this with some kind of career.

I see that texts all over the place. I can't imagine how the girls feel now.

Hybe's like the mafia, they NEVER should've taken sides.

I guess all that's happening is karma to all toxic tokkis out there lol

Well said 👏🏻 my guess for these emotional manipulation of public from min hee jin is to make sure she has a safe landing in her next job. Like she already knows she is going to get fired and who would want to hire someone who has such a bad reputation. So I think she is trying to get public sympathy so that if someone decides to hire her, they don't need to fear about backlash. That's just my opinion 😅

the NJ members are NOT innocent bystanders in this situation. They choose MHJ and now they must face the consequences. they deserve everything coming to them .. if their careers are done , so be it. they should have learn from the 5050 situation

MHJ is using them. She should never have brought them into the conflict. It’s a conflict between MHJ and Hybe , and should have stayed that way. It’s a sign of desperation on MHJ’s part that she has had to get NJ to publicly support her. If MHJ really had a good case , she wouldn’t need NHJ to publicly support her.

LMAO I love how this video roasted NJ and Bunnies hard but it's all facts and the material are all given by MHJ. 9 minutes of nonstop roasting lol.

MHJ is the puppet master indeed…

Min Heejin's been giving Lila Rossi vibes.

When you voice this then you automatically hate new jeans

What a great "mother" she is to them.... 😅 putting her minor "daughters" in the line of fire, expecting them to shield her.

The public opinion is one heck of a mood swing. Before this i saw HYBE stans defending the company by dragging other party totally unrelated "Well Company X is trash, they blahblah", then there was "Oh look at her she's so pitiful crying like that, how can one woman go against a big company", then go back against their words when MHJ drop other artists name, then go back again "Well HYBE is shady", then back again on and on...

You're spitting facts girl ✨

You know she is such a total b when she throws young artists like illit under the bus, claim ownership of what new jeans has done, and claim everyone plagiarizes her, when she has no right to these things.

btw, it would be interesting if you displayed the names of the groups on screen during the clips you use as background

Keep in mind, during her press conference, she said one of her girls (I forgot the name) used to be so pretty when she was a little girl. This is weird. It is implying she dont find the girl pretty anymore bc she is older now. Unless that was translated wrong to us. Feel free to confirm this

Wow, I didn't know you, very good, you are a firework!

I didn't like the upbeat spooky vibe on New Jeans videos and background instrumental. Their songs were too simple sounding. It's off topic but I do hope their concept will change slightly if they survive.

And to think people called "just haters" to the people that didn't want to stan Nwjs because of their age/because of Min Heejin.

This whole thing is such a big mess! Even MHJ not denying the chat records, other than saying HYBE invaded her privacy kinda shows it might be the real thing. I do believe that New Jeans members and their parents should've stayed out of this battle. Whatever the case, the victims here is NJ. It is looking like NJ will have some problems in whatever decision the Court decides. Wishing the best for them.

Absolutely right,

I honestly don't believe in "their innocence" because they are past the age of high school, and we all know in high school, kids are not innocent. What kids haven't developed are high moral/ethical values and integrity. But in terms of losing their innocence, learning how to gossip, backstab, etc., teenagers are ruthless experts (some even smarter than Min Hee Jin at it). MHJ and staff said New Jeans were strutting around like hotshots on the top floor of HYBE, and it's 99.99% that the girls are talking and planning their their parents and MHJ. They chose to sign the petition and stab BSH in the back, so now all I see are 5 little Min Hee Jins whenever I see New Jeans talking with baby slur acting innocent. I feel sick when I see them now tbh. We know they don't act like how they act on camera irl.

This whole mess is annoying af.

NewJeans are not only minors but are also inexperienced with the way the kpop world works. It's easier to isolate and manipulate them since they are young and impressionable. Just give young people gifts and a there's a big chance that you will win them over. She really groomed these poor girls. I don't even like or stan NewJeans but their situation is really sad and scary. While it may seem pathetic that NewJeans members are supporting MHJ, they should not be hated because they are groomed to believe that they owe everything to MHJ. Groomed people have a hard time seeing that their groomer is abusing and gaslighting them.

Min Hee-jin probably gonna have another case after this for market manipulation or something of the matter. 😅

Petcion total stupid move .. End pls not liesss ..pls ....you sound like some " payola" bot.. Dis msg has not bin acept on court ...bicos der fabricate !!! ..no reciver of dat msg . End aka wen dat not past .., KAKAO ..share dat msg on internet media... Bro dis laydi is FK...UP...bat Hybe go on court with fabricate evedance is messt up.. Meehhh

MHJ IS FUQED !!!

HYBE will pay the way ❤ Illit

PREEEEEAAACH!

Hybe already hate them. If they stayed Neutral Hybe will end their career, so there really isnt any rational choice.

But is the girls' dormitory inside the Hybe skyscraper? I wonder if they shouldn't send them somewhere else.

In the end the innocent party in all of this is NJ. Hope and wish them the best.

Yall making assumptions we honestly don't know how if they decided themselves and always base it on age and stuff like stop with these videos and let the court decide and mhj always said she was a blunt person so we don't know how she interacts with newjeans so just stop with the videos of assumptions and accusing her with no valid evidence of her showing harm to newjeans

뭐고

Do you think MHJ has a drinking problem? You know how constant consumers of tons of wine get crazy and don’t temper their outbursts? Just saying, she behaves like a text book heavy drinker. No matter how expensive the vino!

One more time... 1. Physical activities that require strength, coordination, and memorization often start training people at a very early age. Baseball, football, soccer, gymnastics, and others all start drawing from elementry schools through afterschool practice and workouts. People competing in college-level sports did not start in college. 2. Everyone makes it sound like the NJ members were orphaned kittens scooped up by awful MHJ. Several of the members were already showbiz vets having worked in musis, television, and dance. They and their parents, who had to be involved as their legal guardians, had been dealing with business personalities and legalities for many years. Is is possible that MHJ has completely fooled all of them? Maybe, but you're telling me they've been around all the other semi-crooks in showbiz and can't pick up the signals after repeated exposure? I don't think MHJ browbeat the girls into signing the petition, but whether she did or didn't, don't you think everyone asked their lawyers about the ramifications of it? It's pretty clear that after years of dealing with Hybe's people and MHJ, that they've thrown in with her despite her eccentricities. You're telling me that the parents are as stupid and easily swayed as the kids? 3. I'll be curious what MHJ says about the texts. Are they pretty harsh? Yeah, but you watch enough Kentertainment and you soon discover that if you piss off a Korean, you're likely to get a torrent of insults that you're fat, stupid, lazy, and unapppreciating. It would be interesting to get early texts from trainers of other groups. Since Koreans tend to be publically reserved, the flame wars over there probably makes us look tame. This is all spin. Hybe releases something bad. MHJ releases something bad. These guys are plinking at each other trying to shape public opinion while the legal battle goes on behind the scenes. No One Knows the Full Story Yet. So take a breath. There's a long way to go through hazy territory...

I’m on MHJ side !!

I don't support Hybe, I don't support Min Heejin, I support new jeans, it is given off Fifty Fifty buys but you do have to admit that Hybe is very shady and it's clear that the CEO does not like newjeans only because they are part of another company that he has to split profits with, Hybe don't like that they are not company that created NewJeans, even if new jeans concept is not 100% original stealing this concept from one group and give it to new rookie group is really shady and shameless and because of the stunts Hybe pulled ILLIT is getting so much hate and shade for all the things this company is doing who clearly supposed to be adults but acting very childish in both groups are getting dragged into this turf war, You Hybe says that they have bad luck with girl groups that they create but they don't want to represent other girl groups from other companies that they sign with so they practically threw them in the basement pretty much waiting till their contracts expire to be done with them just like they did Gfriend, they didn't even know that they were disbanding it was completely a surprise for the entire group cuz they was supposed to be doing more promotions and they just found out all of the sudden found out that their group was being disbanded, and the fact that it's clear that Hybe is trying to replicate the formula from NewJeans and passing it on to ILLIT, I'm not passing blame onto any of these girl groups because they are all victims here, in the worst thing is if hives wins this case NewJeans is going to be shoved to the basement, by the same time I understand that these girls want to stand up and I said cuz they don't appreciate their concept is being replicated onto another group from their company, is already bad enough when companies still concepts from other companies but stealing from group members from your own company is a bit weird, especially that too many people are already have admitted that the CEO ignores them every time he sees them he doesn't promote them he doesn't take pictures with them he doesn't show his support for them so in the end of the day I hope that they can just leave this company and probably be able to explore their career elsewhere, Fifty Fifty definitely was manipulated and taking advantage of and I believe Men Heejin is taking advantage of new jeans as well but it is quite clear that this company plans on banishing this group to the basement if they win this lawsuit, everybody has to admit that Hyde is really shady and cares too much about profits and he don't like the fact when they can't get the for-profit for themselves when they're cooperating with other companies, very loud clear that Hybe CEO don't like to split the profits between other companies, they definitely want a benefit more for themselves.

I am tired of this mess. I don’t think I will watching any more about this drama. I wait until the case is finished. MHJ and Hybe is the best couple. They should be together and marry because they both are pure evil. NewJeans could be hiatus or disband whatever. I just want MHJ reveal more dark sides of Hybe and both hold hand going down the hole.

I dont care!! I only want NJ to be save and secure!!! Keep your hate to yourself have you lost millions during there drama FR

I like New Jeans but I can't stand Hybe and jealous, greedy and treacherous Bang. Min Hee Jin has flaws but let's remember those messages were denied in court for lack of evidence and were said to be blurry and likely spliced together after three years of forensic auditing of communication. Secondly, much of it was faked by a youtuber known to be a staunch Hybe supporter. Secondly, Bang has made no effort to greet, welcome or congratulate New Jeans members and after New Jeans has earned ten times Hybe's initial investment Hybe's "reward" is for Bang to copy their concept, use payola to inflate the group he totally controls over New jeans and then threaten New Jeans with a one and a half year hiatus after beginning a paid for witchhunt of Min Hee Jin and undermining New jeans comeback. It is also condescending to claim that the parents have been manipulated and hoodwinked by Min Hee Jin given the poor treatment and toxic jealousy of Bang instead of realizing that they just prefer to work with her since she care more about developing their success. Hybe has a long history of discriminating against their best female groups and idols" first GFriend, then Garam, and is currently letting fromis 9 rot in a dungeon. Currently, Hybe's preferred girl groups with weaker vocals consist of mixed Japanese members that are under his total dictatorial control since the Dahn World cult which Bang, Hybe and BTS belong to glorifies Japan, so Hybe female groups without Japanese members are discriminated against even as Hybe does massive censorship of comments mentioning their involvement in the cult which they never deny. By the way this is coming from someone whose favorite girl group is the Japanese group Nogizaka 46 so I have no bias since am fond of Japanese music. Consistent with their Dahn World affiliation, Hybe also acts out occultic rituals like the Walpugis Night with GFriend which was their last release before they were sacrificed and cancelled on April 30 which is a witchburning and sacrifice ceremony in occultic folklore. Three years later, again on April 30, Hybe wanted to try to vote Min Hee Jin out and gain dictatorial control of New Jeans. Also Hybe did a mock sacrifice of Garam when she fell from a great height onto a car. Furthermore, Hybe didn't let Garam release the official school disciplinary report which she had prepared on April 15 three weeks before debut proving she defended a friend who pleaded for help from a rich jealous bully who posted nearly nude photos of her friend online and stole a facebook account to frame an innocent child for the crime. Hybe also refused to let Garam make a personal statement as she requested even though opinion quickly turned in her favor after she was able to release this information once she had been freed from Hybe's cruel bondage of silence and inability to defend herself, though they dumped her in the process. Furthermore, Hybe hoodwinked those who testified on Garam's behalf by telling them it would be used to defend Garam likely in court but then they buried it and it never saw the light of day and there was no court case. What the witchhunt for Min Hee Jin is really about is Bang's extreme jealousy and lust to destroy SM entertainment which he tried to acquire several months ago with his comments about crushing Aespa and luring Min Hee Jin who worked at SM to work for Hybe so he could gain clout from her reputation. Yet when he realized New Jeans was more impressive than LeSSerafim his jealousy caused him to take their concept and create his own group he totally controlled and then seek to get rid of Min Hee Jin and undermine New Jeans and elevate his groups above them using payola and massive press manipulation, .create a scandal to destroy the SM created group by Min Hee Jin and then if possible throw New Jeans in a dungeon for a year and a half after the Japanese tour which messages from New Jeans parents indicate. This is likely what Bang's design was for Aespa as well but fortunately He failed in his take over attempt. Take a look at what I believe to be highly manipulated brand rating for idols this month and one will notice that most if not all Illit members are above all members of Aespa and New Jeans. This is why so many are saying that Hybe is destroying kpop not only because Bang stated he wants to take the K out of it. This isn't to insult the other groups which have talent, but the objective difference to the ears is clear. Consistent with this, it is striking that Hybe's move to destroy Min Hee Jin and undermine New Jeans began immediately after the harsh criticism of what so many viewed as Le SSerafim's poor vocal performance at Coachella after New Jeans had been praised for its performances at Coachella the previous year and after Illit and LeSserafim had both been criticized for their encore performances on Music Shows. Bang wants the great cultural legacy he feels SM entertainment offers, but he knows he doesn't have it so he wants to destroy it and Min Hee Jin is a symbol of this since she was responsible for working closely in concepts with many of the greatest girl groups like Girl's Generation, f(x) and Red Velvet. I think MHJ has some flaws but I think she cares about New Jeans the most and I believe Hybe is a far worse alternative besides it is obvious the parents and New Jeans have sided with Min Hee Jin. Let's see the huge amount of dirt that will be uncovered if Hybe has to go a forensic audit without payola to clean their name.

What??? 🥴🥴🥴🥱🥱🥱